Why there are so many Singapore car travel to Johor even weekday? It will cause lot delay to businessman who travel to Johor for business. Propose for visitors should come only in weekend
@@joeyl9435 not really. Those in front me holding Singapore passport when they are at custom. Seldom saw Malaysia pr. Can different the car whether they are Singaporean or pr if you are always traveling. Even if govt should consider to release tourist in batches. You know yesterday 19 Dec it took me 2 hours plus to reach Singapore. I reach 1.15am. Lot Singapore car uses third lane or lorry lane to go Singapore. Really very bad attutide to use third lane to travel. Singapore govt should set up control too
RTS is intended to reduced the heavy human traffic flow at the Causeway. I am very certain motorcyclists from JB coming into SG will switch to this mode. The ERP for motorcyclists entering will increase for sure to discourage them. Then, TEL will be well used. In this way, cut down on noise and air pollution.
If the causeway no jam.. sg government will start worry..because many sg will buy house at jb and come forth and back.. it benefit sg government if the causeway jam..to make sure you rent here and buy house here and stay here..
If there's no Jam and daily smooth and clear traffic and everything is efficient on both customs , Singapore is doomed , everyone will move over to JB as cost is lower. Earn SG dollar and spend MYR .....
That person entered Singapore through second link. Why is this video talking about causeway? RTS has nothing to do with second link, and it won't solve the jams there. Don't expect second link users to take RTS. RTS is too far away and very hard to reach. Besides, it is a well known fact that on mornings of working days, the jams are all caused by Singapore. Not due to the speed of immigration clearance of bus passengers on either side. The bus passengers have already cleared Malaysian immigration, but they cannot reach Singapore immigration. Just keep 1 lane for public buses. And stop all public buses from going through immigration. After dropping off passengers, they have to turn back to the origin country immediately. If the CIQ has to be rebuilt to achieve this, then rebuild it now. If you have seen the structures of both Woodlands and JB CIQs, you know it is not a big construction project. Why is everybody avoiding mentioning this rebuild? It is much cheaper than RTS. And much cheaper that whatever colocation. Factory buses have to be given another lane. Trucks should be banned during peak hours, in both directions, so that there can be 1 lane for public buses and 1 lane for factory buses. This is basically the design concept of RTS, doable at a significantly lower cost and in considerably less time. Another option is build an overhead pedestrian walkway linking both CIQs. Equip it with travelators. This was raised by the public at the very early stage of RTS discussions, but why did the authorities avoid it? They knew it is much cheaper than RTS, didn't they? And they knew it works 24 hours a day, while RTS most likely won't, right? What are people who travel at 02:00 in the morning supposed to do? No RTS, so wait 1 hour for a shuttle bus? Because the daily commuters won't use it? I was one of those commuters for a few years. Trust me, get it built, and 99% of them will thank you. The commuters are tougher than the decision makers. If there are trucks that must travel during peak hours, put them on barges, so that they don't block anyone.
The causeway was designed as a land bridge between two countries. Not intended as a commute line for everyone who wants to earn in SG and spend in MY. When the disparity stops, the jam will stop. Want a quick fix? Reduce wp quota to Malaysians and increase duties for Singaporeans who wants to spend in JB.
SG should reduce the rely on malaysian workers and start employing other countries foreign workers in case one day both SG and MY have some conflict in future. To us singaporean, it is a ''want'' to not going over JB, but to malaysian, it is a ''need'' for them thus it is an advantage to us already. Its really time to stop hiring so many malaysians before its too late.
It’s not a “need” for Malaysian to come over to SG either. It’s demand & supply. If there’s no need for SG to rely on Malaysian workers. Please go ahead to restrict or limit their opportunity in SG.
@@aaron911205 not a need? covid lockdown proves otherwise though. did you see how many thousands of them trying extremely hard to get into sg just to get a job and work? even they need to fork out their own money to pay for quarrantine hotel fees, vaccination so on and so forth. you still remember? it also proves that sg is slowly not relying on malaysian workers ONLY anymore. they are the ones that are dying to come over to work, not us depending on them. its different. go and do your homework before you comment. :)
@@aaron911205 and restrict us from supplying goods and foods? no problem, many countries are supplying to us as well, the recent case of restricting supplying of live chickens proves as well. we got it from thailand and in the end? farmers protesting to MY gov and couldnt sell off their chickens. World don't revolve around you.
@@aaron911205 yup, thats why i said we should reduce the malaysian workers and stop relying on them even though we are neighbours, who knows one day malaysia will do something to us which i think they will. many times already. hahahaha😂
![[ENG SUB] 新柔长堤一百年：他们与它的跨时代故事 100 years of the Johor-Singapore Causeway](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/R24tGglhBbU/mqdefault.jpg)
![[ENG SUB] 新柔长堤一百年：他们与它的跨时代故事 100 years of the Johor-Singapore Causeway](/img/tr.png)
移民海關辦公室的員工通常會以蝸牛的速度時間慢慢處理旅客。完全自動化檢查站是加速瓶頸缺口的關鍵.
我希望关可以灵活的在假期段和繁忙时间段部署更多的海关官员,开放更多关卡柜台，以便更快清关,这将有助于降低堵塞
The bottleneck is at Malaysian custom!!!
How to not jam when those Abangs deliberately work at turtle speed
You are lucky that they work at turtle speed. You'd cry if they slow down to snail's pace . . .
At least 'Abang' is working, 'Adik' is mainly sitting and standing around at work in Custom office. Lucky you! 😤
人離鄉賤!貨離鄉貴!嗎?小時候的兒歌>教你唱你就唱，現在呢>叫你4点爬你就4点爬嗎?
不错，不错，看完视频觉得有效率的改变(两国一检)，给两国政府一个大大的赞👍!
这个可以参考内地与澳门之间的青茂口岸，就是这样处理的。
主要就是繁忙时段才会有大量人流通过，其他时间关卡通行大多数是很顺畅的。大家错开时间出入境就没有问题。
后来不是说会采用扫描QR code ，不需要护照吗？
如果， 地铁车 里面 着火🔥的话，哪怎么办？ 你人可是 在海上
当RTS开通之后也会有更多马国人想到新加坡打工赚钱。 到那时候还是会一样塞到妈妈都不认识了。
When the flow is smooth, then most Msian will go to SG to work. Then Msia will face labour shortage.
In other way around if flow is smooth more Singaporean will come over and spend their money where create more business activity and job opportunity
@@JohnsonChiw Then, Malaysian businesses will have a shortage of employees, and Singaporean businesses will have a shortage of customers.
Malaysia will take labour from other countries or robot
just don't let so many people coming ok liao 😂
这不只是政府的问题，私人企业有責任来改善，如运输业也要好好的分配时间，个人的通关不是最大的问题，造成阻塞的大多数是大型运输车辆。
货运可曾考虑用船？抱歉小僧愚昧
@@leo290702 如果可以用船马来西亚的货物就不必要用路运到新加坡再用海运到其他国家了，时间分配是最可行，如果运输公会让各别公司不要挤在同一时段出车就可解决问题，就如新加坡的CBD作法就是不要上班族都在同一时间挤入市区一样，重点在于海运的费用远比路运高不符合经济效益。
時間成本
@@leo290702
Why there are so many Singapore car travel to Johor even weekday? It will cause lot delay to businessman who travel to Johor for business. Propose for visitors should come only in weekend
Many Singapore car owners are Malaysian, holding sin PR returning home or go visiting and shopping 😅
@@joeyl9435 not really. Those in front me holding Singapore passport when they are at custom. Seldom saw Malaysia pr. Can different the car whether they are Singaporean or pr if you are always traveling. Even if govt should consider to release tourist in batches. You know yesterday 19 Dec it took me 2 hours plus to reach Singapore. I reach 1.15am. Lot Singapore car uses third lane or lorry lane to go Singapore. Really very bad attutide to use third lane to travel. Singapore govt should set up control too
在台灣管理不會這樣。慢，塞。沒效率。好笑。距離才1公里
我曾經搭巴士塞塞20：00左右
為什麼要搭巴士的不搭專車火車？
或走路過去？
另外驗證通關 新馬人民 ，沒效率驗證 。
现在入境马来西亚人行关口以有电子关卡、方便多了、至于没用电子光卡的人们、也以废除手指印证、也舒缓了很多..堵车堵人的问题通常是在周末、公共假期、放暑假、会比较多人..问题还是人多我覺得、或是排队时、马来西亚这边没管道的真确指示、导致人们插队….如果马方注意这方面..或许会缓冲一下..个人见解😮
RTS is intended to reduced the heavy human traffic flow at the Causeway. I am very certain motorcyclists from JB coming into SG will switch to this mode. The ERP for motorcyclists entering will increase for sure to discourage them. Then, TEL will be well used. In this way, cut down on noise and air pollution.
CIQ空间那么高, 通关只有一层, 当初设计时, 通关层为什么不设二层？容量就增加一倍, 繁忙时开放。
每次在CIQ看到黑压压的人群, 抬头看那高高的空大上的空间。
仿效airport design
CIQ staff very slow now
车辆插队就罚款，并且要严格执行，相信不过一年时间，插队的恶习会得到很大的改善。
0:08很自私的行为，车子佔用车位一整天，尤其是bi一带
他不会做完的
三年啊
骗人的啦
Jam becos many ppl want go work Singapore
If the causeway no jam.. sg government will start worry..because many sg will buy house at jb and come forth and back.. it benefit sg government if the causeway jam..to make sure you rent here and buy house here and stay here..
自己都说了，有人手不够的问题，那里可能会解决过关卡阻塞的问题？ 政府已经换了几次，奇迹是不可能出现的，这不是魔术表演。
想想covid19的时候不能通关，俩地人民都应该好好珍惜🙏
这么好的福气，我希望你每天都有。
All due to the exchange rate‼️📈
不行, 如果不塞马劳甚至很多外国人会移居柔佛, 新加坡屋价会大跌。新加坡政府人民绝对不会允许的
你能代表300万人民的意思？ 那你做总理是不是可以不用涨gst和交公积金？
@@lsg303 用屁股想也知道新加坡政府只是敷衍大家一下，以新加坡政府效率要是能不塞三四十年前早就不塞了。
If there's no Jam and daily smooth and clear traffic and everything is efficient on both customs , Singapore is doomed , everyone will move over to JB as cost is lower. Earn SG dollar and spend MYR .....
Can't really move to Malaysia without having a proper visa. There's limit how many times/ days of stay. Unless you have mm2h
人多的时候马来西亚人那出护照直接过就不会塞了。
Dirty secret is traffic is a feature, not a bug.
进出马来西亚，需要有200台机器，电脑。
Malaysia is many generation backwards…many countries already have automated check points way before covid…lmao
That person entered Singapore through second link. Why is this video talking about causeway? RTS has nothing to do with second link, and it won't solve the jams there. Don't expect second link users to take RTS. RTS is too far away and very hard to reach.
Besides, it is a well known fact that on mornings of working days, the jams are all caused by Singapore. Not due to the speed of immigration clearance of bus passengers on either side. The bus passengers have already cleared Malaysian immigration, but they cannot reach Singapore immigration.
Just keep 1 lane for public buses. And stop all public buses from going through immigration. After dropping off passengers, they have to turn back to the origin country immediately. If the CIQ has to be rebuilt to achieve this, then rebuild it now. If you have seen the structures of both Woodlands and JB CIQs, you know it is not a big construction project. Why is everybody avoiding mentioning this rebuild? It is much cheaper than RTS. And much cheaper that whatever colocation.
Factory buses have to be given another lane. Trucks should be banned during peak hours, in both directions, so that there can be 1 lane for public buses and 1 lane for factory buses. This is basically the design concept of RTS, doable at a significantly lower cost and in considerably less time.
Another option is build an overhead pedestrian walkway linking both CIQs. Equip it with travelators. This was raised by the public at the very early stage of RTS discussions, but why did the authorities avoid it? They knew it is much cheaper than RTS, didn't they? And they knew it works 24 hours a day, while RTS most likely won't, right? What are people who travel at 02:00 in the morning supposed to do? No RTS, so wait 1 hour for a shuttle bus? Because the daily commuters won't use it? I was one of those commuters for a few years. Trust me, get it built, and 99% of them will thank you. The commuters are tougher than the decision makers.
If there are trucks that must travel during peak hours, put them on barges, so that they don't block anyone.
马来西亚官员分配利益的内部问题....
The causeway point is always jammed on Friday & the weekends. 😰
钱💰
塞？是何原因？有何改善的方法？
The causeway was designed as a land bridge between two countries. Not intended as a commute line for everyone who wants to earn in SG and spend in MY. When the disparity stops, the jam will stop. Want a quick fix? Reduce wp quota to Malaysians and increase duties for Singaporeans who wants to spend in JB.
Important Malaysia grovmemt officer don't always show not happy face . 😊
ERP !!
别存有期待 几十年老问题不可能没办法解决而是不想解决
1 太方便 新加坡人就没工作了
2 新加坡外汇损失巨大
3新加坡實体商家大量倒闭
1.不会的 新加坡政府会保护公民的
@@ennnnnnn8608 会保護公民 降薪罗 派礼券
建多第三通道
这些纸上谈兵的事很多，实际上说的是人排队和过长提及人流量的问题，根本没考虑车流量的问题，脱裤放屁，😂😂😂
会不会有漏洞呀！到时他们拿毒品过关。
所有新加坡的毒品案件永远抓不完😂
贪污
干，谁听得懂那个中国博士说的话 ？ 建好后才来检测 ？还可防可控 ？一路坐到荷兰是吗？
这已经是几十年来还没有解决的问题了!
不是建好以后才检测，而是因为，既然可以检测，就可以想办法防止大量过关人员在同一时间出现在同一地点造成堵塞。
他给的例子已经很明确了，分为质和量两部分。你再仔细看看。
👍👍👍
這影片真的是新加坡政府的宣傳
RTS 真正的目的為什麼？
照顧新山居民來往新加坡，上班？
太天真啦，新加坡政府幾時那麼好心？
笑死人
長提塞車問題？
當然呀，一百年前的工程怎能擔任去？
不開車來往新加坡有問題嗎？
應該沒有的
可是雙方ICQ和 巴士沒做好工作
新加坡online arrival 幫很大的，
刷護照過閘，一分鐘搞定
馬來西亞方面比較慢實現
關閘解決後，巴士穿梭不完整
搞好巴士穿梭，沒問題啦
那麼，RTS 的真正目的為什麼？
其實新加坡的外擴土地，
填海慢有貴，
把MRT申入大馬不就可以？
馬來西亞上當了
無奈，柔佛蘇丹要錢.
SG should reduce the rely on malaysian workers and start employing other countries foreign workers in case one day both SG and MY have some conflict in future. To us singaporean, it is a ''want''
to not going over JB, but to malaysian, it is a ''need'' for them thus it is an advantage to us already. Its really time to stop hiring so many malaysians before its too late.
It’s not a “need” for Malaysian to come over to SG either. It’s demand & supply. If there’s no need for SG to rely on Malaysian workers. Please go ahead to restrict or limit their opportunity in SG.
@@aaron911205 not a need? covid lockdown proves otherwise though. did you see how many thousands of them trying extremely hard to get into sg just to get a job and work? even they need to fork out their own money to pay for quarrantine hotel fees, vaccination so on and so forth. you still remember? it also proves that sg is slowly not relying on malaysian workers ONLY anymore. they are the ones that are dying to come over to work, not us depending on them. its different. go and do your homework before you comment. :)
@@aaron911205 and restrict us from supplying goods and foods? no problem, many countries are supplying to us as well, the recent case of restricting supplying of live chickens proves as well. we got it from thailand and in the end? farmers protesting to MY gov and couldnt sell off their chickens. World don't revolve around you.
@@bensontan7409 likewise, world don’t revolve around you too!
@@aaron911205 yup, thats why i said we should reduce the malaysian workers and stop relying on them even though we are neighbours, who knows one day malaysia will do something to us which i think they will. many times already. hahahaha😂