Bruce’s Beach Returned to Family Who Government Took It From
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 20 сен 2024
- The LA County Board of Supervisors unanimously approved returning beachfront property to the Bruce family. Bruce’s Beach, now known as Manhattan Beach, was purchased by Charles and Willa Bruce in 1912 as a resort for Black families who were excluded from other beach areas. A legal battle to return the land to the Bruce family has dragged on for years. Bruce’s Beach now enters escrow before officially transferring to the family. The Bruce heirs will receive $413,000 a year in rent from LA County.
Bruce and his family were really good people for letting black families who were excluded from other beaches go onto their beach because most people back then were really racist
Back then?
Thank you for your comment. 🙂
@@kimbernewman6403 TECHNOBLADE DIED LOL LOL SO FUNNY HE IS IN THE UNDERGROUND AND IM EATING HIS REMAINS AND DRINKING HIS BLOOD LOL LOL
@@kimbernewman6403 and thank you ally! 🖤
They were also..... Black People.....so they knew black folks were good people too. 🤫
The Bruce family is black...
Happy for the Bruce family for winning this long overdue battle. A statue of Willa and Charles Bruce, along with a plaque of their story on the base, should be erected and paid for by the city of Los Angeles. That way everyone can know their story and Bruce and Willa can still “watchover” their beach.
I’ve been following this story and am elated for this outcome. LONG OVERDUE.
TECHNOBLADE DIED LOL LOL SO FUNNY HE IS IN THE UNDERGROUND AND IM EATING HIS REMAINS AND DRINKING HIS BLOOD LOL LOL
Yes, Yes, YES 👏
Now we natives want our land back too 🏹
Sorry but this land belong to the Natives first..
@@SUGAR_XYLER ok-lahoma
sorry I had to.
Aside from returning the property to the family of the RIGHTFUL OWNER, The STATE GOVERNMENT SHOULD BE HELD LIABLE FOR THE YEARS OF INJUSTICE AGAINST THE OWNERS AND THEIR FAMILY!
No
Wouldn't the rightful owners be the native Americans?.. or did we just forget about them
I know shouldn’t everything taken from the Native American be returned too? And what about Nevada, California, Texas and Arizona they belong to Mexico and they took that too. The government just want to look good only. They will never return anything
Congratulations to the family that won this case. This is a huge win for all black families around America.
its good that it has been returned back to them
TECHNOBLADE DIED LOL LOL SO FUNNY HE IS IN THE UNDERGROUND AND IM EATING HIS REMAINS AND DRINKING HIS BLOOD LOL LOL
It wasn't stolen or confiscated. The original owners were paid, just like in 1000s of other eminent domain cases.
@@terryjackson9395
Forcing people to give up their property in exchange of money is still theft, even if it was "legal".
Eminent domain being abused by officials isn't anything new either.
Awesome!! They deserve to have it returned to them, leave it to the government to take something that isn’t their’s 🤦🏻♀️
Natives want their lands back.
Well done
Oh hi ray
So theft under the guise of eminent domain
No, it WAS eminent domain. The original owners, the Bruces, were paid "just compensation" for the property, which is the law for eminent domain. Usually It's about 70% of the value at the time. But, no, the property wasn't stolen or confiscated. Although go ahead and talk the victim thang since that's what media wants you to do. I prefer to do things with my life.
@@terryjackson9395 wow you said jealous
@@skyjacksonA1 Nope, not interested in free sh*#, as you seem to be. Real humans prefer to function in society... Not act like helpless little children.
It's good to see this family got to own that beach again many years later.
What about returning the Land that the US sits on back to the natives?
You first.
Then natives can advocate and spread the word. Help them spread the word where it would actually make a difference...
Why? It’s ancient history, that’s just the course of mankind. Take over each other and occupy each other’s territory. I think that the US government should give back land that was under the agreements that were violated like during the trail of tears or during the expansion to the west but not the entire country, that’s just ridiculous
@@jaydee9308 🏹 Exactly we must start in the NC mountains ⛰
that would be the entire country!
Give it back means that it's theirs. The amount of money being offered seems far too little.
Yeah, media and Newsom know nobody knows anything and easily fall for this virtue signal nonsense.
The original owners, the Bruces, were paid "just compensation" for the property, which is the law for eminent domain.
It's usually about 70%-80% of the value. Bruces just sold the property twice because the property wasn't stolen or confiscated.
about time I've been following that story for years I'm happy they got the Beach back
They and their descendants should never pay taxes on that property.
This is a Great, Awsome, Extraordinary, part of history that has finally been discovered. 👏👏👏
$413,000 a year for rent is nothing for a beach in LA. They keepin' on getting scammed
So happy for them.
Extremely good for them!
20 million for beach front prime realestate.... that seems pretty low.... smh...
They should get paid for the money that they lost also
If the family had requested that, Los Angeles country would NEVER have even considered it. When it comes to things like this, you have to make compromises
Tell that to the Natives
@@mikef2811 I respect that....but I stand by my statement
And they shouldn’t have to pay property taxes for say 100 years.
Finally justice has served, better late than never
Excellent!!
Now. Return Hawaii to the Hawaiian people
one step forward to take like 20 steps back.
It's nothing to clap and celebrate this is why we're so far behind as a race meanwhile people of European decent continue to thrive and have many more advantages then we do such as home ownership , credit and loans this is just a glimpse of it I will NEVER let go of what happened to my ancestor's
@New Life New Rules no need to project. I’m sure they’ve accomplished much more than you have
@@Baller4Life1 TECHNOBLADE DIED LOL LOL SO FUNNY HE IS IN THE UNDERGROUND AND IM EATING HIS REMAINS AND DRINKING HIS BLOOD LOL LOL
They thrive because they help one another. Unlike many black folks. Who rather harm others in their race instead of helping. Yes racism was even worst back then and I feel for those back then. But today is very different for blacks.
@New Life New Rules "colored"
Don't gag on that klan mask hunny
@New Life New Rules I mean they literally bought a beach and the government took it from them. They literally accomplished something and it was literally taken from them.
About time! Happy for the family. 🙏🏽
now imagine how much taxes he has to pay now lol
The injustice is all the money they lost all those years. I sure hope they get a get tax lawyer and someone who can help them generate some real money. When you have that many family members there is bound to be a lot of fighting.
They didn't even want us to swim :(
Native needs our land back too.
"The klu klux Klan was involved in harassing them" right because times then were similar to times now I'm sure the whites back then said "do you mind leaving please" 😆 I love how she just brushes it off like blacks weren't beat and attacked for being on "their beach". Blacks knew not to step foot there or it'll be the last time they saw the ocean 😉 😁
Whatever, you bitter troll 🙄!
Took that long until they no longer wants it
Wait what! How on earth was this ever ok
About damn time...
About time
When will the gov't give land back to the Natives?
As soon as you leave
I hope they don't sell it and make the beach what it was intended to be by their great grandparents
A blacks only beach?
Now if only they can do the same for Hawaii
Yes!!! The only right outcome!!!
Wow okay Bruce yall doing the dam thing
wonderful
This is awesome!
That’s good
well If Bruce's hold onto the beach for min of 49 years That 20 million will be in the Plus for them. But Think LA would be getting the Better deal out of it if they were to pay 20 million for it. if they Develop the land, split it into plots. Talking about if its like the other plots of land around it. about 15 to 20 homes on it. selling for between 2.5 million to 9 million. then LA would have Price of Land, then Taxes on said Land, then Taxes on said House on plot of land. would think less then 49 years LA would recoup the 20 million they offer
Perfect! Generational wealth is a game changer.
"Under the guise of eminent domain"? There's no guise, that's literally just eminent domain.
They bet not sale there beach back to LA county for 21mil, they city/ government made more than 21mil off that land/property
Hasn't the family already come out and said that they're going to sell it as soon as they get it? The family that's not like Manhattan Beach at all at least from the interviews that I have seen.
Its still rightfully theirs to do with what they please.
Nice
Wait I thought I see this like a long time ago back did you make it again
So they're getting paid twice for the beach?
So what about the other families forced out?
Wow! That's really cool
Nice!!
Justice at last.
very happy for them
Heck yeah, now they own a whole beach yo
👍🏿 as they should
I am all for giving people back their land but where do the other people go. My people came from Eastern Europe in the late 1880s. I don't want to go back because I am old now.
They should sell it before the ocean rises and there’s nothing left
I'VE WATCH ALREADY 😢
Thats amazing im glad they returned the landed. But wouldn't that mean we should then returned the land to native Americans 🤔?
Shut up
You realize that means the Bruce family would have to give it up and leave for Africa. Since, you know, they aren't Native American either. If returning the land means all Non Native Americans had to go, then don't think black people would be excused from that. Slavery wouldn't be a valid excuse as black people also participated in stealing Native American land. A region of Oklahoma was reserved for black people after the Civil War, as it was Lincoln's promise to them. Problem was the region giving to them had a tribe driven out: black people didn't care about that. They were so happy to have a region all to themselves and a chance to build up their community they didn't care about who was there before them. There were battalions of black Union soldiers known as the Buffalo Rough Riders. There mission was to drive out the Apache so both white and black people could settle there.
Paid for land
They owe back rent along with psychological damages …..
No
Do not sell it for 20 mill .
Still is unfortunate 413,000 a year is a insult u can’t even purchase a home in that area for less a million dollars.just laughable 😂
Republicans haven't been this upset since CVS moved the good cold medicine behind the counter ✌️🥴
Yet the Democrats started the KKK
🤣
In a 100 years it will STILL be seen as an unfair sale. The Bruce family should give the money to the Chilula Indian tribe whole stole it from the Kumeyaay tribe who took it from the Chumash people.
Not surprised, the family deserves it~ Wilmrbadguy
Now this is nice change from pre-formative activism we need this and more MATERIAL reparations
They finna sell it
Dude they not going to even care, They’re just gonna complain more and more about something else, Watch them complain about Walmart, because they find it offensive, then get The name changed to something else for self pride, to be honest This is annoying
🙏😇 AMAZING 🥂
Movie required 🍿 🎥
Dang that's expensive rent
It's ashamed this country of freedom..but people always judge by the skin color other than white
ikr, its insane and embarrassing.
It’s ashamed people like you even exist because you try to start something then when you get in a fight you pull a weapon out.
Amen
Yeah Amen, Bruce's just sold the property twice. The Bruce's, were paid "just compensation" for the property, which is the law for eminent domain.
It's usually about 70%-80% of the value. But, no, the property wasn't stolen or confiscated.
Finally.
20 million thats like 10 years of rent hell no 👎 better break the bank for it a Billi
Still waiting for them to return it to the rightful owners. Native Americans.
Wow, so you want to send black people to Africa white people to Europe and Asians to Asia. You're quite the r*cist arent ya
That's some nice generational wealth coming there way!
That's less than 9 grand a year per person
Well hel I'd like the oil money and land taken from my native American family year's ago
His great great grandson sounds like squidward
FINALLY
This title gave me an aneurysm.
20 million, B#$%ch please, oceanside property costs more than that! If the county wants to throw a low ball number like that. I'm sure someone can easily double that offer up!
B#$%ch, learn about eminent domain.
The original owners, the Bruces, were paid "just compensation" for the property, which is the law for eminent domain.
It's usually about 70-80%% of the value. But, no, the property wasn't stolen or confiscated.
The Natives got nothing when their lands were taken...so can't complain...its still 20M.
👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
Why don't they mention that Charles Bruce was paid the equivalent of 1/4 million dollars for the beach in 1924? Eminent domain doesn't allow them to take it for free. They were paid at the time.
They didn't WANT to sell it and were forced to. They would have had MILLIONS over generations isstead of a measly 250k. Why do you leave that out?
@@Seek1878 I didn't leave anything out because I didn't write the story. It seems relevant that the land wasn't stolen, it was purchased through eminent domain, which happened, and still does happen to many people. Should we go back and pay the decendants of anyone who lost land by eminent domain? Or just the black people? Also you realize it's just a tiny lot 500 ft from the water. It's not even a beach, it's literally a small block like 200ft x 150ft. This video is terribly misleading because they're giving the impression it's a huge beach.
@@person86422 what part of the fact that they did not want to sell it do you not understand.
@@pookiesis1465 He doesn't want to understand that part.
@@person86422 Forcing someone to sell their property when they don't want to is wrong. Let me ask you, if you had some property that the government told you they'd pay you for but you weren't interested in selling and told them no, so then they just forced you to take the money and go against your will, and years later that property ended up being worth $20 million that would have been yours if you hadn't been forced to sell, you would just be fine and dandy with that?
You're the one being terribly misleading.
I don't see why we shouldn't pay the descendants of those who had their land stolen.
Everyone is gonna be coming out the woodwork to claim they’re a descendant
Take the forever rent!
I second.
Finally 😀
Celebrate while you can.. in 6 months the city will force them to sell for 20 mil.
They already plan on selling it
20 MILLION DOLLARS 1 time OR 413,000 x 50 years = 20,65000 Hhmmm i say take the 413,000 a year as it can go on for 100 years or more which amounts to 40mill for 1 generation.....
Yeah, but with sea levels rising a beach today could potentially be in the ocean tomorrow. I thought about the same thing you said, but beaches aren't safe investments unfortunately.
I hope they sell, if we were in a different world I'd advocate for the same thing you said, but owning anything near a beach is way to scary in our modern era.
@@avarice5071
The beach could be under water by tomorrow? I get that’s an exaggeration but unless there’s been significant land erosion and significant rising water levels on this particular beach it’s safe to say that it is a safe investment especially since it’s in Los Angeles county.
@@henrylivingstone2971 there just being dramatic
yeah that was just about the dumbest thing ever unless they can tax them for it.
soon tourists can ..and will visit....thdy better have insurance or they wont iwn it for long.
Just admit you don't know how this works.
Rest in peace technoblade
*cheeseburger*
*yes*
Ya
yes cheese
Wise words 👍👍👍👍👍
I agree with your wise statement on the internet 🍔
Hi
I could hear the KKK screaming in defeat.
They sold it back. KKK winning.
Grandson isn't that mad at white people his wife is white !! Forgiveness is the key!!
Commander Cody the time has come... *excute order 66*