Nouman Ali Khan's view on making Islamic movies [with examples from the Quran]

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 27 янв 2025

Комментарии • 40

  • @ahol6129
    @ahol6129 7 лет назад +10

    the muslim community is awesome

  • @maherberain1859
    @maherberain1859 2 года назад +4

    he has some crazy wisdome mashallah.

  • @mirza_saabb193
    @mirza_saabb193 6 лет назад +16

    He is presenting ideas to give dawah to a wider audience, and bring youth closer to islam, and all people are focusing on is his beard...c'mon people.

  • @valeriedhodson3014
    @valeriedhodson3014 5 лет назад +4

    Muslim movies would be awesome. Video games are basically self directed movies these days. Movies would teach the youth and reverts. And it would teach non Muslims too. And for reverts it would help them transition.

  • @ayeshakunni4366
    @ayeshakunni4366 7 лет назад +3

    MashaAllha awesome video

  • @hasan_z
    @hasan_z 6 лет назад +3

    There is a beautiful childrens cartoon which depicts the Seerah of Muhammed (peace be upon him) - without showing him specifically. I had it on an old computer, I will post if I remember more details.

    • @hasan_z
      @hasan_z 6 лет назад

      Turns out easier to find than I thought....
      ruclips.net/video/vGxVWDLO87I/видео.html

  • @TheMuslimBr0ther
    @TheMuslimBr0ther Год назад

    Insha allah I will make a movie or a tv show like that

  • @mohammadehsan9894
    @mohammadehsan9894 8 лет назад +7

    what an Idea

    • @johunter4733
      @johunter4733 7 лет назад

      Just don't collaborate with Jews, and it will be ok. I don't trust Zionists.

    • @sugetsumillenium2112
      @sugetsumillenium2112 7 лет назад

      Jo Hunter the Jews own everything, what are we supposed to do then?

    • @johunter4733
      @johunter4733 7 лет назад

      Watch Imran Hosein's analysis on Gog and Magog. If you cant make a movie independently, then don't. But don't work with the Jews. Uploading a movie on a RUclips channel would make sense, but you cant work with these people. You rather not make a movie.

    • @sugetsumillenium2112
      @sugetsumillenium2112 7 лет назад

      Jo Hunter Why can't we work with them? We need to take over the industry or else they'll keep winning the minds of young Muslims

    • @johunter4733
      @johunter4733 7 лет назад

      I told you to watch the lecture. You will get your answer. They are borderline devil worshippers.

  • @sajinahamed9156
    @sajinahamed9156 8 месяцев назад

    Who is this speaker
    Acting is Haram based on consensus from prominent Muslim scholars.
    And he is making fun of the word fatwa repent to Allah brother
    Have you ever heard any lecture from the kabair ul ulema they don't say jokes they are serious in their talks.What is this a standup comedy show

  • @chamilkaziev235
    @chamilkaziev235 8 лет назад +1

    bothers and sisters looked this men. you think he looks like muslim. ok. did a MUHAMMED S.A.S HE'D A SAME SHORT BEAR and he is emam MASHALAH. way? ask him way he is not faloving a sunna of S.A.S

    • @mohammadehsan9894
      @mohammadehsan9894 8 лет назад +9

      Holy Quran says: produce your proof if you are truthful" so now give you proof: where in Quran or Sahih hadiths says that its haram to wear this kind of cloth? and secondly is it a major sin to have little shorter beard? please stop being such a narrow minded, he is you own brother, because all Muslims are brothers of each other, instead of picking on him, keep supporting him.

  • @Exahax101
    @Exahax101 3 года назад

    Please don't make movies on prophets and their companions. Our religion is pure so keep it pure, don't make it look like other religions by making these movies. Our religion is not entertainment, if you want to learn about islam learn from authentic sources.

  • @lianwest4967
    @lianwest4967 7 лет назад +2

    I have respect for you, but what you just said is pure bullshit. You probably don't know that a producer always changes the script and dialogue of a movie while they are filming it. Because not every script or dialogue fits perfectly in a movie. So to maintain the flow and rhythm, the producers changes the real script.
    Now if they want to make a movie based on a story of Quran, they will also have to bring change in the way those verses are given in Quran. And who do you think has right to change Quran????
    So don't speak nonsense please. And if you or people like you don't like to read a book or written Fotwah, then fine, just leave it. Allah (SWT) doesn't need you. and He won't lose anything if 1000 Noumans like you abandon His commands.
    And by the way, movie itself is Haram, and now you want to use it to spice up Islamic learning. Cool... Just wait until you go in your grave, and you will surely have enough entertainment.

    • @johunter4733
      @johunter4733 7 лет назад +7

      Don't give your opinion disrespectfully. Jewish movies are obviously haram. But a movie as a medium of communication is not haram. Its just an art form. If there are no scantily clad women, music and dancing then how is the medium bad. And what you said about changing verses of the Quran to fit a script, which muslim would do that? Would you? Allah SWT does not need them? How do you know that? Did He tell you? Very brave of you to speak for Him. You will have to answer for it.

    • @lianwest4967
      @lianwest4967 7 лет назад

      Oh c'on, first read my comment and understand it. I said that producers often need to change a script to make movie flowing. So if a movie is to make, then the producer will try to edit the verses, which is prohibited.
      .
      And by the way, who told you that a movie will become halal if there is no half-naked women??? Movie itself is haram. And most importantly, when you make a movie about a prophet, then everytime you hear the name of that prophet, the first picture that will show up in your mind is that actor. You will corrupt the image of a prophet.
      .
      By the way, I don't want to argue with you. If you're so keep to learn Islam through movie and with entertainment, then keep doing it and wait until you go in your grave.

    • @johunter4733
      @johunter4733 7 лет назад +2

      Oh come on, learn to write before your argue about any subject. No muslim will edit a verse of the Qur'an without other muslim finding out. Who do you think we are? Jews? Grow up. Motion pictures are haram. Ok. Prove it. And remember I am talking about motion pictures. Not movies. I am talking about telling a tale using motion pictures. And who told you Brother Nouman was talking about making movies about Nabis. Did you watch the clip? I don't think you did. We are not supposed to make graven images about the Creator and His Rasools and Nabis. That is not what Brother Nouman was talking about. He was talking about something else completely. What is wrong with you? Can you understand English. Because you certainly cant write it. Stop embarrassing yourself. Either prove something is haram or hold your tongue. And grow a full beard before you run your mouth off. Ignorant fool.

    • @lianwest4967
      @lianwest4967 7 лет назад

      Really, you better become mature first. I'm typing from my mobile phone, so typos can happen. It's normal, and if you can't overlook it, you should continue going to elementary school and keep learning Grammar so you can figure out who is tryping and who is correct.
      .
      And about beard. Okay, you now started attacking me just to win the argument!!!! Please leave your childish behaviors in your elementary school before you come up to argue about something.
      And best of luck with your movie and charming way to learn Islam.

    • @haxterk
      @haxterk 6 лет назад +4

      Bro, your comment makes no sense at all. There is a difference between the script of the movie and the verses of quran. Script is the whole movie in the form of words. Verses are divine relation from God. Obviously, the script writer of the movie will be muslim so he knows that he cannot add or subtract anything from verses. The most obvious example of this is the movie "The Message". On several scenes, they have quoted Quran but when they did, it is the exact translation of Quran.