@@Yuukire748 Because it's executed nicely for something that is uncommon in the industry.. If you don't like it, then it's your preference, but no need for the unnecessary hate
@@Yuukire748think how they have Hatsune Miku concerts. It's pretty cool how they get them to show live. Like a hologram. Then again this is assuming you know what vocaloid is or even vtubing.
@@카니카니-u7e 스마트폰도 처음 나왔을때랑 향후 5년~10년사이에 존나 발전하고 변함.. 쟤네도 처음이니까 그렇지 계속 나오다보면 더 발전해서 아이돌을 대체할만하기도 할건데 그냥 왜하는지 이유를 모르겠음 진짜 애니처럼 재미로 보는것도 아니고 그렇다고 실생활에 반드시 필요한것도 아니고 하는거라면 현 아이돌들 빡센스케줄 대체하는거?? 어차피 가상이라 팬싸같은것도 못할건데 아님 영통으로 대체하려나ㅇㅅㅇ
@@imarock8763 maybe they don’t want to be, aren’t seen as fit, or can’t dance (so they may have professional dancers). there are many reasons as to why they may not be there, but they honestly don’t need any. MAVE: seems great already, and it being a group full of ai’s is new and fun.
No one’s actually there apart from the dancers in motion-tracking suits. The whole thing is put together to look like they’re performing on stage in front of an audience but everything is CGI, including the audience members holding the light sticks lol
I just hope that whoever does the vocals for the girls get good treatment by the company financially if they are using actual vocalists/rapper’s it’s only fair. This is also good if those that do the vocals wanted to debut but never got the chance in the past but now they do in a different kind of way
I'm thinking the same way too. I've been watching I Can See Your Voice Korea for years, and I've realized that too many talented singers in Korea need to get the recognition they deserve. Virtual idols are the way they can express their talent without having to show their faces. Maybe what is lacking is people will keep saying they are not real idols
well they don't have to promote in music shows, participate in variety shows and stuff... so that's less work and stress ig... and they seem to have gotten attention lately. at least they could use their talent in some way, so don't worry. i think the singers would say something if they actually do not like the idea for these virtual idols to take over the stage or not even take the job in the first place. planning will always be the first step in developing something, so the singers already know what they're getting themselves into before these virtual idols debuted
@@calvinlee9252 good point, that could be the case as well. If it is just hopefully everyone who is involved are compensated for whatever/however they agreed upon.
@@calvinlee9252 for vocal as good as this, its not possible. Even Japanese producers that has been using their own vocal as sample for vocaloid doesn't sounds this good
I do think they're real, just don't know if we'll ever get to a ppint that they'll put on real people after them on shows because their concept is AI so that's very unlikely to happen. They might reveal who the singers are but not to make them idols. These are just my speculstions
Of course there is someone behind the voices, but what if they'll do units like NCT. Sometimes we'll get the AI version and sometimes the real ones. It will resemble aespa but they rarely use the AI version..
Must say, the mocab is really good everywhere except the eyes. Giving soulless a tiny bit but overall really impressive. Good job to whoever is behind this and the dancers. Also, it’s the way that this A.I. group lets the vocalist stand off to the side and belt while so many groups don’t even do that- Edit: I obviously know there are groups who do that and of course they don’t have to be to the side, I was just making a joke.
uhm, it is a thing. It’s not just to the side, the main vocal can also stand at the center belting and having a moment. Some idols even parody it if they’re covering another song and the high note comes up
@@Isaisbackyeah Yuju was the first idol to come to my mind when I saw op’s comment. She makes sure she’s having her moment when she’s hitting them notes 😂
Honestly I don't see animated/Ai/whatever groups as real groups & I can't bring myself to equate them with real people; however, if I have to see this from the digital side, it's just amazing and truly well done. Whoever designed everything for them and whoever did the animation and voice over etc indeed did a great job. I love it not as a kpop group, but as an art & animation & music lover. They can't be compared to real people but the job people behind this have done is well appreciated. Seriously it's unbelievable how far technology has come today!
I feel this is the wave of AI youtubers and Idols that has been so popular in Japan, washing over Korea as well. It's still begs for that discussion whether they should be considered real or not, an animated person. So you're not alone, I myself find it quite hard to believe anyone would sit in the Music show and watch and cheer for their performance. Not because the group Is bad or anything but because they are not really there. To those of us, watching from our mobile devices, it makes no difference since we are watching from a screen, but to someone who makes themselves present ay a show, how do they watch them?
It's gonna be a new experience honestly. As I said they can't be compared to real people but watching them perform as a new technology is so fun in my opinion. It shows how the new technology works and how real people worked so hard to make it happen. I would've watched them perform too; but as I said earlier again, not as kpop idols but as someone who loves this side of technology, animation & in general art & digital art. It depends from which side you look at it.
Это конечно всё очень круто, голограммы были со времен майкла джексона, но то что они сделали более качественно меня радует. Также хочу сказать что в один момент голограммы заглючали(не в клипе) это не очень хорошо. Но а так всё вроде не плохо
This group is so good they have a perfect debut song and even promoted!!! I hope we will knew who are behind there voices because they need praises for there talent.
The entire point of AI is to have no real people behind them. They don’t have to credit them, pay them for their talent, they won’t have any leverage for their fame, they won’t ever get sick, they won’t ever gain weight, they won’t “need” plastic surgery, they won’t age, they’ll always be perfect and perfectly exploitable. Pure profit once they get the tech down.
@@lilaccrystalbunnyd3331 My understanding is that there are no girls behind the voices. The voices are computer generated from samples, so they aren’t doing this to protect anyone. They’re doing this because it gives them the upmost control and ability to profit.
Not only the dance moves look so naturally also that Siu had a break from dancing when she did the high note and the ending fairy! This is so cool that they tried to make it so naturally!
what I'm thinking is maybe those persons behind their voices are former or still tainees that didn't have the opportunity to debut. I'm with you, I hope they will be recognized someday
I'm pretty sure the vocals are a result of dozens of voices blended together through AI. So that the company takes all the credit. Since 1 AI's voice here is the result of 20 real life girls, it's like the voice no longer belongs to any of them.
@@shanlieart Oh damn. I didn't even think about that. Yeah, sounds like something a greedy company would do. Here's me thinking "oh this is a chance for idols who's groups didn't work out for one reason or another to have a second shot". Nope. You're probably right
They’re just the voice though, to advocate for their recognition over the “idols” doesn’t make sense, if they wanted that kind of recognition they would just be regular idols/singers. It’s important to give credit to everyone involved in the project obviously, but it seems like a lot of people want to treat the singers behind mave as some kind of secondary idols in the group when they are just another part of the huge group of people working behind mave.
@@ilymeans_iloveyangjeongin ya'll conclusively deciding what's happening behind the scenes when these voices may also be contented cause they don't want to be exposed to the public and at the same time still want to fulfill their dream and make a career out of passion for singing.
Si muy genial, pero el punto es ser un grupo virtual, donde no habrá sobre explotacion de personas,ni críticas innecesarias sobre el físico de los demás, en el grupo perfecto.
Very interesting how they did this though it’s still cool to see regardless of any mixed feelings some of us may have for this group it’s still interesting seeing how this company promotes them and how shows will accommodate them
the only group u can't accuse of plastic surgery and going on extreme diets 🤣 they were perfect from the get go. but, man, they can do better with the dancing
@@jovitasor9965 To be honest, they're plastic anyway. They will never have surgery because they are not real. I don't like the fact that there are more and more idols and groups in the form of AI. If it continues like this, the labels will stop debuting normal idols, living people. Only AI that we will not be able to get to know like another human being, because everything will be a script. People who will hide behind them will also be unreachable for us. People with talents will be pushed aside and replaced by something that doesn't exist and have no feelings. I don't like it anymore. Labels strive for complete excellence in their idols. Now they do plastic surgery and train them. AI will actually be drawn, changed and created to match the highest standards of beauty. We will stan their beauty without knowing who gave them the movements and the voice. No idol will stand a chance with them, and society will have too high standards. Such a phenomenon is already in Japan, where men prefer AI women, mannequins and other strange things instead of a real human and real relationship
@@betxengi5388 blah blah blah, kpopers nowadays are hypocrites They hates AI idols but in the same time they bash real idols without any reason, so your comment are invalid
Realistic? It’s pretty easy to tell that they’re not human, but for sure CGI has gotten better these days (still not 100% there bc the dances do look a bit “robotic” and stiff at points)
팬들이랑 어떻게 소통할까.. 팬싸같은거 열리면 어떻게 진행될까.. 예능 등은 어떻게 출연할까.. 궁금하네 가끔 실수하고 인간미도 보여주고 팬들 진심으로 챙겨주는 게 팬들이 좋아하는 요소가 아닌가..ㅠㅠ 너무 완벽한 건 장점일까 단점일까.. 앞으로 활동 너무 기대되는 그룹임..
They look so real I can't get over this. The animation is soo smooth its insane. I love that they are promoting like a regular kpop girl group. I'm addicted to Mave already
@@jonc8561 so they really performed? I thought it was just a hologram performing just like hatsune miku's concerts in Japan? She performs on stage and she's not real
@@nejii._. i'm pretty sure their bodies are real and some dancers are doing the choreo, look at the clothes moving during the choreo and compare with Hatsune Miku or KDA, this are clearly real people which dance, they just replaced their faces post production
As a student of computer animation I can say that all of this is really well done. I dont even know if the “main” stage is real or just very clever camerawork and compositing 🤯
Hsta ending fairy hicieron, no lo puedo creer. Les tenía CERO fe, la verdad pero me sorprendieron muchísimo. El MV es bueno pero verlas "en vivo" en un music show, simplemente me dejó anonadada. Impresionante.
@@Whoamiare ES VERDAD ,todo por q son japonesas ,la xenofobia del público me esta enojando mucho ,quiero decir a gente q ni existe la reciben bien pero a gente q se esfuerza no
if the people behind these ai would actually show their face and debut in their own group it would actually be so amazing because their voices are amazing 🤩🤩 like k/da
@@nesofadivnn I also had a hard time distinguishing who is who the first time I saw them. I thought they all looked the same lol. But here are some characteristics that I noticed that helped me familiarize them: SIU: her voice and face are angelic, calm, dresses elegantly, main vocalist, has the most high notes ZENA: the girl with bangs, the coolesttttt, gives vibes of an assassin that I read on books 😆 TYRA: The girl whose hair is tied in pigtail. THE RAPPER. MARTY: Chubby cheeks/round face (I don't know but it's really her cheeks and shape of face I find the most distinguishing part of her body). Or you might as well see their concept photos, that will help you more.
They literally played an AR video...nobody is going to complain they're not singing live right? 😅 I really like the song. The vocal talent is definitely there but I'm curious about the real people behind the voices. Would they make a real life debut at some stage in their career?
I am hoping that the singers are singing live at the backstage or somewhere in the studio since they're not even showing themselves so the least thing they could do is sing live for these AIs, but yeah, this is still cool.
i'm not worried about the singing live part, I'm more of wondering what these girls really look like, or they just made up by the company and uses some random girls as their singers. I mean, like are the girls so unattractive that they dont want to really show they real face?
인간에 비해 휴식시간도 필요없고 사생활 논란 전혀 없고 빡센 춤에 고음의 노래 안정적 가능 이런 장점이 많지만 팬덤 형성은 힘들듯.. 사실 가수에게 정을 붙이는게 완벽해 보이는 무대 속 저 사람도 인간이기 때문에 나오는 실수들, 때때로 나오는 열애설 그런 인간적인 모습들이 접점이 없는 우리가 정을 붙일 수 있는 이유가 아닐까 싶다. 그런 의미에서 나는 실력이 떨어지는 아이돌일지라도 그냥 같은 인간으로서 '저사람도 잘 하고 싶을텐데' 누군가의 노력에 응원한번 해줄 생각 없는 사람들이 완벽한 모습만을 보이길 요구하는게 안타까울때가 있다.
![[HOT] MAVE: (메이브) - PANDORA | Show! MusicCore | MBC230218방송](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/IDFQdA2uroM/mqdefault.jpg)
YALL I DIDNT THINK THAT THEY WOULD PROMOTE ON A MUSIC SHOW 😭😭😭 THIS IS SO COOL
@@Yuukire748 it's something never shown in kpop before
@@Yuukire748 u don't have anything more interesting to do with ur life
Metaverse ent slayed with this group
@@Yuukire748 Because it's executed nicely for something that is uncommon in the industry.. If you don't like it, then it's your preference, but no need for the unnecessary hate
@@Yuukire748think how they have Hatsune Miku concerts. It's pretty cool how they get them to show live. Like a hologram. Then again this is assuming you know what vocaloid is or even vtubing.
1:54 음중 카메라 무빙중 역대급 혁신
혁신ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
혁신ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
케이콘 코로나 때 무관중으로 했을 때 확 발전한 듯
이런게 더 발전해서 사람들이 열광하는 시대가 온다고 생각하면 소름 돋는다..
Same! I’ve lost hope in humanity
나중에 진짜 ai그룹 더 자연스러워져서 더 많아지는거 아냐..?
진짜 잘만 만드면 그런 시대 올거 같은데 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 이미 지금도 애니 캐릭터 빠는 사람들 많잖아
이미 버튜버들 이세돌에 환장하는애들이 많음
당연한 수순이긴 함
쟤네들은 연습이나 타고난 외모도 필요없고 쉬지 않고 일할 수 있으니 아이돌 회사 입장에선 사회적인 인식 바뀌고 기술력 따라주면 무조건 나올 수 밖에
이거 직접 사람들이 댄스커버 하는거 보면.. 안무 퀄리티가 진짜 높더라 ㅈㄴ 멋있음.. 아마 댄서들의 모션캡쳐로 만든 안무일텐데 진짜 멋있어
조나인이 만들었네요 오홍
하이라이트 안무 진짜 개멋있더라 ㅋㅋㅋ
프마가 다 만든건데.. 프마는 왜 스우파 안나온거지 인지도 바닥
@@jae-m4l 예 프마가 거의다 만듬요
@@jae-m4l ㄹㅇ 조나인은 그 나이에 대단한 듯..
무대에서 작은 실수하는 디테일도 넣어주세요
옹 여기계시네요!!
머야 왜 댓이없엉
ㄷㄷ
안녕하세용
no
the fact that they each have their own way of dancing makes it even better
Of course its motion captured LMAO💀
Real dancers are dancing😂
I thought I was the only one to notice or loosing my mind 😂
@@Hnz_000 im aware, but im glad they didn’t just make them all in sync as if it had to be perfect
포니테일한 친구 부츠 장식 흔들리는 디테일이 미쳤네요... 저걸 어떻게 하셨지
헐 다시 보니 그랗네
2:24 👀
옷 정식인 체인도 흔들림 ㄷ ㄷ
솔직히 처음에는 거부감 들었는데 노래가 너무 좋아서 계속 듣게 됨 소형 기획사에서 이 노래 나왔어도 찾아서 들었을 듯...
시우(SIU:), 제나(ZENA:), 타이라(TYRA:), 마티(MARTY:)
메이브가 대세야💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙
진지하게 진짜 사람으로 된 아이돌이었으면 입덕했다.. 노래 퀄 좋고 안무도 포인트있고 좋은데 AI라서 부자연스러운 동작과 무표정한 표정이 너무나 장벽..
하 노래 kda more 표절이에요 판도라~ 할때 부분 거의 빼박으로 비슷하고 다른부분들도 거의 똑같아요
@개인계정 상관 ㅈㄹ 크다. 일반인은 표절이 뭔지 몰라서 비슷하면 죄다 표절 타령 하니까 의미 없을 뿐.
@@Xfhhbnh그 정도 가지고 표절이라 그러면 님이 여태껏 듣던 음악 대부분 다 걸린다 요즘은 박자나 리듬 단어 몇부분 비슷하다고 표절 그러드만
전 이미 입덕함
Agreed. Also, the voices behind those Als are amazing😭 they could've been the ones to debut😭
딴건 몰라도 진짜 기술력이 이제는 대박이다...
ㄹㅇ진짜 경이로움
이젠 아이돌 이란 직업을 뺏네 곧있으면 모든 직업을 뺏겠다
@@카니카니-u7e 혹시 모르는 거지. 씹덕 요소 같은 거 더해지면 하츠네미쿠 이런 거 처럼 남팬들 많아져서 시장 활성화 될 수도 있음
@@카니카니-u7e 스마트폰도 처음 나왔을때랑 향후 5년~10년사이에 존나 발전하고 변함.. 쟤네도 처음이니까 그렇지 계속 나오다보면 더 발전해서 아이돌을 대체할만하기도 할건데 그냥 왜하는지 이유를 모르겠음 진짜 애니처럼 재미로 보는것도 아니고 그렇다고 실생활에 반드시 필요한것도 아니고 하는거라면 현 아이돌들 빡센스케줄 대체하는거??
어차피 가상이라 팬싸같은것도 못할건데 아님 영통으로 대체하려나ㅇㅅㅇ
진짜 좀 신기하다 난 이세계아이돌? 걔네도 좋아하는게 이해가 안가던데
이렇게 데뷔하고 사실은 진짜 아이돌이였습니다~하고 실물공개되면 진짜 갓연출 인정합니다 ㅋㅋ
나도 이 생각함 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 😂
이러면 레전드겠다ㅋㅌㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅌㅌㅋㅋ
왠지 그럴것같애 진짜로..
이런 이유가 아니었던 이상 지금 왜 저러는지 모를 정도임..;;;
ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ이러면 난리남
안무랑 노래도 틀릴 수 없는 그룹......
ㅇㅈ
Tampoco se cansan🤣
시우(SIU:), 제나(ZENA:), 타이라(TYRA:), 마티(MARTY:)
대세는 메이브💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙
Ещё нет упрёков типа "толстая,некрасивая, ленивая," ещё SP на высоте
Это компьютерная графика
U guys keep in mind that there's actual singers & rappers behind these AI's. Very talented people!!
Exactly! ...so why arent they on stage😂
@@imarock8763they are I believe they are wearing movement tracking suits
@@imarock8763 maybe they don’t want to be, aren’t seen as fit, or can’t dance (so they may have professional dancers). there are many reasons as to why they may not be there, but they honestly don’t need any. MAVE: seems great already, and it being a group full of ai’s is new and fun.
@@imarock8763 probably because more production will be more expensive so they used ai’s to make it more cheaper
@@seungshiney exactly !!
I'm just imagining the audience looking at an empty stage 💀 but girlies slayed woooo
No one’s actually there apart from the dancers in motion-tracking suits. The whole thing is put together to look like they’re performing on stage in front of an audience but everything is CGI, including the audience members holding the light sticks lol
They were real on stage but edited as an A.i like sim or avatar
@@9ives65 I think the entire thing is animated. The idols, the stage, and the audience.
@@MaruMaruPoyo either real persons or edited
.. cuz they can be real like how idols make the zepetos
Look at hatsume Miku concerts
노래 왜이렇게 좋음 안무 왜이렇게 이쁜거임 ㅠㅋㅋㅋ 아까울정돈데
Follow me please ❤️❤️
에스파한테 줬으면 더 대박났을듯 ㅋㅋ
@@jndjjnx9294 근데 진짜 에스파 느낌
@@jndjjnx9294 오 에스파가 하는 거 보고 싶다
@@jndjjnx9294 진짜 에스파 느낌이 나여
의외로(?) 노래가 존나좋아 ㅋㅋㅋ 안무도 좋음 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
단점은 영상을 일주일째 보고있는데 아직도 얼굴 구분이 안감;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;
메이브 진짜 가상이레요.....구굴에 치면 나와요...데뷔날짜 치면...
@@Arin3483 이분도 모르는 것 같지 않은데요?
I just hope that whoever does the vocals for the girls get good treatment by the company financially if they are using actual vocalists/rapper’s it’s only fair. This is also good if those that do the vocals wanted to debut but never got the chance in the past but now they do in a different kind of way
I'm thinking the same way too. I've been watching I Can See Your Voice Korea for years, and I've realized that too many talented singers in Korea need to get the recognition they deserve. Virtual idols are the way they can express their talent without having to show their faces. Maybe what is lacking is people will keep saying they are not real idols
well they don't have to promote in music shows, participate in variety shows and stuff... so that's less work and stress ig... and they seem to have gotten attention lately. at least they could use their talent in some way, so don't worry. i think the singers would say something if they actually do not like the idea for these virtual idols to take over the stage or not even take the job in the first place. planning will always be the first step in developing something, so the singers already know what they're getting themselves into before these virtual idols debuted
What if the vocal is also ai generated
@@calvinlee9252 good point, that could be the case as well. If it is just hopefully everyone who is involved are compensated for whatever/however they agreed upon.
@@calvinlee9252 for vocal as good as this, its not possible. Even Japanese producers that has been using their own vocal as sample for vocaloid doesn't sounds this good
Im actually impressed especially with the voice and actual song its such a bop
I'm too
Whose voices are in this song ?
@@boho0114 We all don't know
Maybe that’s cuz their voices are actual singers 🤦♀️
Fr, the non human visual caught my eye. But I only click to read comments. Turns out it's actually a bop.
가상 아이돌 그룹이 음악 프로그램에 출연하는 것을 생각하지 못했네요.
맨 처음 단어에 ‘우’가 빠진거같아유
북한인이심?
@@퉰 해외 교포 같음 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
아담.. 태초에 그가..ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
몇년전에도 나왔던..
노래 좋고 안무도 쫀득해서 어이없음ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅠ 노래 구려도 다들 신기하다 이러면서 볼 거 같은데 노래까지 좋아서 맨날 들음
live ar 논란도 없고, 연애 스캔들 걱정도 없고, 24시간 풀노동 뛰어도 절대 안 지치는 완벽한 아이돌 그룹ㄷㄷ
ai의 시대가 도래했다~~~
만드는 사람들이 대신 죽어가요 ㅠ
Mitoma >>>>>>>> Son
Tomiyasu >>>>>>>> Kim
Kagawa >>>>>>>> Park
XG >> BTS. BLACK PINK
@@BanzaiJapanEmpire 뭐야 이건 좀 꺼져 극우정병련아
@@BanzaiJapanEmpire 와 신기한 게 여기 언급된 일본인 중에서 미토마만 이름 좀 들어보고 다 모르겠음ㅋㅋㅋ
It will be crazy if it turns out the girls behind the characters are real and will be revealed at some point. This has so much potential!
I do think they're real, just don't know if we'll ever get to a ppint that they'll put on real people after them on shows because their concept is AI so that's very unlikely to happen. They might reveal who the singers are but not to make them idols. These are just my speculstions
For the dancing parts of the videos they are real persons withe their faces replaced by CGI ones.
Of course there is someone behind the voices, but what if they'll do units like NCT. Sometimes we'll get the AI version and sometimes the real ones. It will resemble aespa but they rarely use the AI version..
@@alejmora let's see, we never know if their face actually real or not
I do think they were real. Movie production level on this CGI.
노래도 춤도 누가 춰서 따고 직접 불렀을테니 컨셉이 확실한 버추얼 아이돌 비스무리한 걸로 보면 되는건가...동작 부분이 은근 자연스러워서 기술이 발전하긴 했구나 감탄함
아니 기술도 미치고 노래가 미친좋네....
와 7번 보는 중 노래,춤 잘 뽑은듯 중독성 강함
1위후보에 올라가서 인간이 아닌 이 친구들이 1위하면 어떤 기분일까…ㄷㄷㄷ 앵콜무대는 어떻게 하는지 궁금하다…
아이돌들 다 현타오걋다 ㅋㅋㅋ..
아마도 가수/성우...
일본은 실제로 그러고 있음..
근데 1위 될까
1위는 안될듯
노래가 좋으면 들을지언정 팬덤형성이 어려울듯
이걸 구현해낸건도 대단한데 자세히보면 군무 파트에 조금씩 박자나 각도? 진짜 사람처럼 디테일이 미세하게 다르게 설정된게 미친거같음;;;
전체적으로 어색하게 움직이는게 똑같은데....
@@user-qq9om1bw8y 예전처럼 데이터 복붙해서 움직임 완전히 똑같은데 외양만 달랐을 때보다는 많이 발전한거죠
이런게 앙스타 프세카 말딸 이런 것들이랑 다른게 뭐냐구요.. 오히려 이걸로 성공하려면 기술력이 진짜 아이돌이랑 차이가 안날정도로 훨신 뛰어나야 할듯..
@@mangseog 그것보다는 kda에 가깝지
모션캡쳐라 그런듯?..
아니 근데 나만 후렴이 존나 좋아..? 릴스에 떠서 처음 봤는데 후렴이 진짜 중독성 개쩔드라..
Must say, the mocab is really good everywhere except the eyes. Giving soulless a tiny bit but overall really impressive. Good job to whoever is behind this and the dancers. Also, it’s the way that this A.I. group lets the vocalist stand off to the side and belt while so many groups don’t even do that-
Edit: I obviously know there are groups who do that and of course they don’t have to be to the side, I was just making a joke.
Gfriend use to do that with yuju... And dreamcatcher does too
I think I’ve seen Aespa do that, at an awards show 🤔
uhm, it is a thing. It’s not just to the side, the main vocal can also stand at the center belting and having a moment. Some idols even parody it if they’re covering another song and the high note comes up
@@Isaisbackyeah Yuju was the first idol to come to my mind when I saw op’s comment. She makes sure she’s having her moment when she’s hitting them notes 😂
truly whoever the singers are… they’re fantastic
24시간 노동해도 무임금, 늙지도 죽지도 않음, 연예계 최장수 가능, 사생활 논란도 없음, 도덕성 평가에서도 자유로움, 모든 컨셉 소화 가능, 실력 논란이 있을 수가 없음... 무섭다 ㄷㄷ 이젠 우리가 광야에 갈 필요가 없음. 광야에서 현실로 찾아옴.
존나빡센춤춰도 라이브 완벽 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
돈독한 팬층은 얻을 수 없겠죠
저거 사람이 만드는데 24시간 노동하면 임금 오지게 깨지는데;;
@@Saeroi_3839 뮤비에만 130억인가? 그정도 썼다고함
@@Qinrwicu2jtiis 헉... 뮤비에만 130억이라니......
아니.. 근데 데뷔곡이 뭐이리 좋누... 가상아이돌이 음악프로그램에 나온다니... 근데 노래 듣자마자 난 입덕함
ㅇㅈㅇㅈ., ,노래 진짜 고퀄진짜 노래 개좋아ㅜㅜㅜ미치겠다
판도롸~~~~~
중독돼서 틈틈이 보러옴...
@@iloveredvelvet4743 당연히 좋겠지 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ KDA MORE 표절 음악인데 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 컨셉 에스파 + 노래 KDA
@@비닐장갑-x5r 애초에 에스파도 kda 따라하는거냐 그런말 많았음..물론 kda 이전에도 가상아이돌 많긴했지만. 저 판도라는 그냥 kda 판박이같음
They're like KDA . The song is so good and i love watching these girls.
THE FACT THAT THEY AREN'T EVEN SYNCHRONIZED MAKES IT MORE REALISTIC 😭😭
likely it is live or recorded mocap which would not be synched
probably movement captued
@@kevlegendsml9956 yeah its motion capture
the only one they lack is more facial expressions then itll be way more realistic
@@sophiamaemagbag yeah thats where kda takes the cake imo
그냥 볼때마다 기술력이 진짜 많이 발전했구나 밖에 생각안듬...
Yes!
메타버스라길래 기대 별 안했는데 노래 퀄리티랑 생동감도 있고 얼굴도 예뻐서 넘놀람
앞으로 더 업그레이드 된 모습이 기대된다
Most stable live vocals in kpop industry 🙄😫🫶💜
LMAO
😆 🤣
IMAGINE PEOPLE COMING FOR THEIR STAGE PRESENCE
OR THEIR LIVE VOCALS😭😭
hologram concert lets goo
i wanna see their encore
or their visual😂
😂 😂 😂 😂
노래 좋아서 어이가 없음 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ ㅜㅜㅜ
ㅇㅈㅋㅋ
@@xxwwxx8851 follow me please 💕💕
나도 …나지금 스카에서도 듣고있음
노래 진짜 잘 뽑음 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
노래 ㅈㄴ 좋음 진심 ㅋㅋㅋ
립싱크 논란이 있을수 없는 그룹
ㅋㅋㅋㅋ그렇긴하네
1위 하면 어떻게 부를지 궁금하닼ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 감사 멘트 하려나
@@blankets_lover 그니까요 앞으로 어떻게 할지 기대되는 그룹...ㅋㅋㅋ
ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
그 전에 시유 유니 라는 센빠이가 있습니다
노래랑 안무 되게 잘 뽑았다
Honestly I don't see animated/Ai/whatever groups as real groups & I can't bring myself to equate them with real people; however, if I have to see this from the digital side, it's just amazing and truly well done. Whoever designed everything for them and whoever did the animation and voice over etc indeed did a great job. I love it not as a kpop group, but as an art & animation & music lover. They can't be compared to real people but the job people behind this have done is well appreciated. Seriously it's unbelievable how far technology has come today!
I agree totally.
I feel this is the wave of AI youtubers and Idols that has been so popular in Japan, washing over Korea as well. It's still begs for that discussion whether they should be considered real or not, an animated person.
So you're not alone, I myself find it quite hard to believe anyone would sit in the Music show and watch and cheer for their performance. Not because the group Is bad or anything but because they are not really there. To those of us, watching from our mobile devices, it makes no difference since we are watching from a screen, but to someone who makes themselves present ay a show, how do they watch them?
It's gonna be a new experience honestly. As I said they can't be compared to real people but watching them perform as a new technology is so fun in my opinion. It shows how the new technology works and how real people worked so hard to make it happen. I would've watched them perform too; but as I said earlier again, not as kpop idols but as someone who loves this side of technology, animation & in general art & digital art. It depends from which side you look at it.
I mean it’s real as anything else. And not new. They sing dance and can talk.
@@myacole1272 it's called ai for a reason
연애뉴스랑 학폭뉴스 있을수없는그룹??
멤버들로 논란생길일은 없는 그룹이 생겼네 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
ㄹㅇㅋㅋ
성우가 학폭으로 논란생길수도
립싱크 논란
Uma aí teve rumor de namoro com um mano virtual
기술 진짜 발전했구나....
버츄얼 아이돌 하면 이세돌이 제일 많이 생각났어서.....구현하는게 진짜 대단하다...
이제 이세돌도... 음중 출연 가능한거야..?
@@우리강아지궁둥짝 3집 기대컨 개작살
이세돌도 출현 좀
Это конечно всё очень круто, голограммы были со времен майкла джексона, но то что они сделали более качественно меня радует. Также хочу сказать что в один момент голограммы заглючали(не в клипе) это не очень хорошо. Но а так всё вроде не плохо
어릴적 봤었던, 90년대의 센세이션, 아담 어디갔냐구요 ㅋㅋㅋ 기술력 발전에 정말 괜시리 감회가 새로움
2:03 SHE LOOKS REAL
i can't believe they are promoting like all other kpop groups, very good stage and excellent quality
노래 하난 중독성 있게 잘 만든듯.. 진짜 집에서 판도라 모두 숨을 죽여 이 부분 시간 날 때 마다 춤 오지게 추고있음
모션이 기대이상으로 엄청 자연스럽네😮 kda도 진짜 센세이션했는데 몇년만에 훨씬 퀄리티가 높아졌네
목표를 사람과 똑같아 지는 것으로 잡을 거 아니에요
그땐 뭐가 인간이고 가짜인지 몰라서 위험한거임ㅠ
즐길 게 아님 진짜 기괴한거임..
아이돌마저 없어진다니..
아니 ㄹㅇ 웬만하면 그냥 음 이런것도 있구나 하면서 넘어갈려 했는데 판도라~ 하는 부분이 머릿속에서 자동재생돼서 자꾸 찾아보게 됨 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ애들 얼굴도 구분되기 시작한다 이러다 진짜 입덕하는거 아냐…??
반묶음 청순녀 외에는 구분이안돼요.......... 살려주세요.........ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
@@litch_o ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 약간 한소희 상
I had the same experience 😂
@@litch_o ㄹㅇ 다 카리나 하위호완처럼 생김
그냥 최근 3년 동안 유행했던 케이팝 그 이상 그이하도 아닌데 곡 스타일이 ㅎㅎ
This group is so good they have a perfect debut song and even promoted!!! I hope we will knew who are behind there voices because they need praises for there talent.
I dont think they will show who is behind the voice and movements
The entire point of AI is to have no real people behind them. They don’t have to credit them, pay them for their talent, they won’t have any leverage for their fame, they won’t ever get sick, they won’t ever gain weight, they won’t “need” plastic surgery, they won’t age, they’ll always be perfect and perfectly exploitable. Pure profit once they get the tech down.
Theyre not real
@@JessieBanana also the private life of the girls giving the voices is protected :)
@@lilaccrystalbunnyd3331 My understanding is that there are no girls behind the voices. The voices are computer generated from samples, so they aren’t doing this to protect anyone. They’re doing this because it gives them the upmost control and ability to profit.
THE HIGH NOTE AND THE VOCALS IS INSANE!!!!
1:00 腕の回し方に個性出ててよい.....
신인인데 긴장감 1도 없는 거 봐. 미쳤다.
역시 AI ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
그니까.. 리허설 하고 본방은 첫 무대일텐데 불안한 기색 하나 없이 하는거 진짜 미쳤다ㅠㅠㅠ 라이브도 진짜 졸라 잘하네 안무 진짜빡쎈데... 뮤비 뒤로 순간이동 하는 퍼포먼스도 누가보면 10년차 아이돌인줄..
Not only the dance moves look so naturally also that Siu had a break from dancing when she did the high note and the ending fairy! This is so cool that they tried to make it so naturally!
Nah some of them lagged and looked awkward at times. But overall it looks decent.
노래 진짜 심각하게 점점 중독괼 정도로 좋은데 실제 사람 멤버들 나오면 진짜 이 그룹 덕질하고 싶음…
나올거면 진작에 나왓지 붕아 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
@@oliversushi88 너 나 아니? 제발 개념좀 챙기고 살자 유튜브 무개념들아… 몬데 사람한테 붕은 몬 붕
그냥 그렇다고 실제 사람이 아니라 덕질하는데도 문제가 있을 거 같고 암튼 입덕하는데도 아쉽다 이런 취지잖냐 멍청한 거 티내냐
카카오톡이 120억투자했다함ㄷㄷ
@gayass6974 갠적으로 후렴전에 나오는 파트가 넘 좋음 그래서 아쉽...
헐 그럼 이 노래 부르는 사람들은 뭐에요...???
아니... 이게 잘만들었다고...? 공은 많이 들인게 보이는데 그래서 얘네 진심으로 좋아할 사람이 얼마나 될까 의문
Hoping the humans behind their voices will be recognized too. They sound sooo good.
what I'm thinking is maybe those persons behind their voices are former or still tainees that didn't have the opportunity to debut. I'm with you, I hope they will be recognized someday
I'm pretty sure the vocals are a result of dozens of voices blended together through AI. So that the company takes all the credit. Since 1 AI's voice here is the result of 20 real life girls, it's like the voice no longer belongs to any of them.
@@shanlieart Oh damn. I didn't even think about that. Yeah, sounds like something a greedy company would do. Here's me thinking "oh this is a chance for idols who's groups didn't work out for one reason or another to have a second shot". Nope. You're probably right
They’re just the voice though, to advocate for their recognition over the “idols” doesn’t make sense, if they wanted that kind of recognition they would just be regular idols/singers. It’s important to give credit to everyone involved in the project obviously, but it seems like a lot of people want to treat the singers behind mave as some kind of secondary idols in the group when they are just another part of the huge group of people working behind mave.
@@ilymeans_iloveyangjeongin ya'll conclusively deciding what's happening behind the scenes when these voices may also be contented cause they don't want to be exposed to the public and at the same time still want to fulfill their dream and make a career out of passion for singing.
비슷하게 생긴 사람들 모아서 진짜 데뷔시키면 대박이겠다
Si muy genial, pero el punto es ser un grupo virtual, donde no habrá sobre explotacion de personas,ni críticas innecesarias sobre el físico de los demás, en el grupo perfecto.
실제는 '미녀는 괴로워' 처럼일수도
all Kpop companies be like;
It's so cool to see a performance!!!
they were very nervous. I heard one of them had a panic attack and nearly glitched
@@jovitasor9965please 😭😭
@@jovitasor9965 You may take your leave now.
@@jovitasor9965 bye-✋😭
AI라고 해서 다 비현실적이게 생긴게 아니라 넷 다 매력있고 개성있게 예쁨
오...기대 안 하고 들어왔는데 노래 진짜 좋다,,자연스럽고,,
MAVE: (메이브) MEMBER 💜
0:01 ZENA (LEAD VOCAL) 💗
0:12 TYRA (MAIN RAP, MAIN DANCER) 💚
0:27 SIU (LEADER, MAIN VOCAL) 💙
0:33 MARTY (SUB RAP, SUB DANCER) 🧡
>> FUN FACTS
Siu's bodyline is really similar with Alice Sohee
OMG ZENA, she is so obnoxious in the game 😭 I love her tho
I thought marty was the main dancer
@@MrDnhlz NOPE , MAVE OFFICIAL WEBSITE MARTY SHE IS MAKNAE, SUB RAP, SUB DANCER BUTTT IF THE WEBSITE UPDATES WHEN I WILL FIX IT!
@W I TYPED ACCORDINGLY MAVE OFFICIAL WEBSITE WHICH IT DID NOT SPECIFY THAT SHE WAS CENTER BUTTT IF THE WEBSITE UPDATES WHEN I WILL FIX IT! 😘
계속 듣다보니 좋네요 다음 활동도 기대돼용🤲
무엇보다 노래랑 안무가 너무 좋아서 계속 보러오는 것 같음 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ... 너무 좋아 ㅠ,,, 안무
Very interesting how they did this though it’s still cool to see regardless of any mixed feelings some of us may have for this group it’s still interesting seeing how this company promotes them and how shows will accommodate them
Yeah I'm bit curious too
One of the members is a character in the game called paragon so they’re made by the same company which i find really cool
the only group u can't accuse of plastic surgery and going on extreme diets 🤣 they were perfect from the get go. but, man, they can do better with the dancing
@@jovitasor9965 To be honest, they're plastic anyway. They will never have surgery because they are not real. I don't like the fact that there are more and more idols and groups in the form of AI. If it continues like this, the labels will stop debuting normal idols, living people. Only AI that we will not be able to get to know like another human being, because everything will be a script. People who will hide behind them will also be unreachable for us. People with talents will be pushed aside and replaced by something that doesn't exist and have no feelings.
I don't like it anymore. Labels strive for complete excellence in their idols. Now they do plastic surgery and train them. AI will actually be drawn, changed and created to match the highest standards of beauty. We will stan their beauty without knowing who gave them the movements and the voice. No idol will stand a chance with them, and society will have too high standards.
Such a phenomenon is already in Japan, where men prefer AI women, mannequins and other strange things instead of a real human and real relationship
@@betxengi5388 blah blah blah, kpopers nowadays are hypocrites
They hates AI idols but in the same time they bash real idols without any reason, so your comment are invalid
no bc how did they do this?? everything looks so realistic, the amount of effort put into this group is amazing
Real people are behind their dance and vocal. And the appearance of the characters, I think, was drawn like cartoons
Realistic? It’s pretty easy to tell that they’re not human, but for sure CGI has gotten better these days (still not 100% there bc the dances do look a bit “robotic” and stiff at points)
@@truefalse934 still better than the æs and the PUBG girlies so there’s that imo
@@galacticcat4584 no, real people arent dancing, the girls themselves arent real. The only real thing is the vocal
@@miguelfranciscosoares6745 theyre stiff sometimes so nope
노래랑 춤 중독성 개쩐다 근데 챌린지 보니까 사람이 추는게 더 매력적이긴함.. 그래도 이런 새로운 시도가 있다는게 👏👏
I thought that they won’t promote in music shows but damn they set another standard for new gen of kpop! Wow so good
True
We don't need humans now
We do bro but MAVE: isn’t doing any crime too
LoL imma stan Ai now
But i wish they design them more unique, they look the same
팬들이랑 어떻게 소통할까.. 팬싸같은거 열리면 어떻게 진행될까.. 예능 등은 어떻게 출연할까.. 궁금하네 가끔 실수하고 인간미도 보여주고 팬들 진심으로 챙겨주는 게 팬들이 좋아하는 요소가 아닌가..ㅠㅠ 너무 완벽한 건 장점일까 단점일까.. 앞으로 활동 너무 기대되는 그룹임..
이세돌이라고 아심?.. 그거랑 비슷한거같은대
There are real people singing.
@K-Jammin ㅋㅋㅋ 아니 이세계 아이돌이요
VR...?
진짜 잘만들었다 앞으로 기술이 더 발전할텐데 기대됩니다.
거짓말 안하고 노래가 너무 좋아서 당황스러움., 내가 AI 아이돌 노래 찾아보러 올 줄이야..
They look so real I can't get over this. The animation is soo smooth its insane. I love that they are promoting like a regular kpop girl group. I'm addicted to Mave already
Those are fake faces over real bodies...
@@jonc8561 so they really performed? I thought it was just a hologram performing just like hatsune miku's concerts in Japan? She performs on stage and she's not real
@@jonc8561 no these are purely animation, they tracked the movements of real life dancers to perform this and used the data for this animation
@@jonc8561 never heard of Miku?
@@nejii._. i'm pretty sure their bodies are real and some dancers are doing the choreo, look at the clothes moving during the choreo and compare with Hatsune Miku or KDA, this are clearly real people which dance, they just replaced their faces post production
1:55 존나 멋있다
ㄹㅈㄷ
even hitting the notes it looks so real 2:46
정말 굉장한 프로그램인 것 같아요 🖤🖤
These girls ate the stage! MAVE is here!
"girls" more like illusion
💀💀
💀💀💀
i love it
😀
노래는 좋은데… 진짜 애들을 데려와서 데뷔시켰음 좋았잖아 ㅠㅠㅠ
인정
ㅈㄹ 진짜 사람으로 나오면 이만큼 화제성 못 끌고 쳐다보지도 않았을거면서
그래도 전 새로운 거 도전하는 거 같아서 좋아욤
기술력도 좋아져서 좀 더 사람같아졌으면 좋겠당♡
이게 장난으로 보임..? AI 데리고도 좋은 노래를 뽑아야 잘되지
It's nice to see that they've also had their own ending fairy just like the other girlgroups even they are AI.
True
The only thing left is for their first win xd
@@squishytan7 yes
노래가 좋아서 자꾸 듣게 되네..
누구도 본적없는 놀라운 라이브 실력에 감탄
ㅅ😊ㅛㅛㅅ😅쇼ㅛㅛ😅ㅛ😮😮😮😮😮
ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
신인이니까 .. 당연히 누구도 본적 없지 않나 ㅋㅋㅋ?
@@sksmsskdu1 그것보다는 그 누구도 이정도의 놀라운 라이브 실력을 어디에서도 이전에 본 적 없다고 읽어야할것같은데..
@@4f540 그것도 맞구요 ㅎ
여기 문맹이 있는 것 같은데…ㅋㅋ
솔직히 까놓고 말해서 저 애들 하나하나가 SM에서 엄청엄청 최선다해 공들인 나비스랑 퀄리티가 비슷함..... 캐디분들 대박이네요..... 살아는 계십니까,,,
와... 동작이 많이 자연스러워졌네 조만간 표정도 완벽한 AI아이돌 나올듯
ㄹㅇ 표정만 더 자연스러워지면 퀄리티 훨씬 더 오를듯
피부가 늙지않고 음이탈 없는 그룹
*For new fans MAVE are :*
0:12 TYRA main rapper, dancer
0:27 SIU main vocal, leader
0:34 MARTY sub rapper, dancer
0:42 ZENA lead vocal
It’s not make sense. Watch the video again
you only knew two member
What a brainless person!😂
😟
what😭
노래 너무 좋다ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 아직 버츄얼 캐릭터에 적응은 안되지만 이쁘게 잘 만들었네 그리고 버츄얼이기에 가능한 무대 해버리네ㅋㅋㅋ 무대 바꾸고 마법 쓴다ㄷㄷ ㅋㅋ SM도 ae-에스파 이쁘게 만들어주지 실물 에스파만 겁나 이쁨
노래는 기깔나게 뽑았네요. Sm 이수만이 꿈꿨던게 이렇지 않았을까.
에스파가 그 가상멤버들 데리고 이렇게 공연했어야했는데 ...ㅠ
@@용용이-f3fㅇㅈ
@@용용이-f3f ? 지금 멤버 아니면 에스파 누가함 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
@@구름-c6i6o 진짜 몰라서 묻는거 아니지?ㅋㅋ
As a student of computer animation I can say that all of this is really well done. I dont even know if the “main” stage is real or just very clever camerawork and compositing 🤯
아무리 가상 걸그룹 이라도 노래가 이렇게 좋으면 안 좋아할 수 없잖아..
바이럴 ㄷㄷ
@@omgomgomggg 카카오+객관적으로 그닥 막 좋지도 않은걸 난리발광
Hsta ending fairy hicieron, no lo puedo creer. Les tenía CERO fe, la verdad pero me sorprendieron muchísimo. El MV es bueno pero verlas "en vivo" en un music show, simplemente me dejó anonadada. Impresionante.
Yo tengo una duda ,tienen como actrices de voz o voces hechas completamente por computadora? Por q da mas para la primera opción por como se oye
@@stream-in-bloom hay voces detrás, lo que no se sabe es su serán reveladas y harán algo tipo aespa
@@allysahibari3681 ohhh , gracias
Ya ni a XG le hicieron Ending 😑 estoy emperrada
@@Whoamiare ES VERDAD ,todo por q son japonesas ,la xenofobia del público me esta enojando mucho ,quiero decir a gente q ni existe la reciben bien pero a gente q se esfuerza no
라이브 걱정없는 아이돌
스캔들 걱정없는 아이돌
컨디션 걱정없는 아이돌
ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ논란은 없을듯ㅋㅋㅋ
365일 콘서트쌉가능ㅋㅋ
아진짜요 없는 아이돌
if the people behind these ai would actually show their face and debut in their own group it would actually be so amazing because their voices are amazing 🤩🤩 like k/da
이왕 그래픽인간으로 만드는김에 중간에 큐브깨지는것같은 cg로밖에 구현할수 없는 특수효과나 의상들 입햐주삼 얘네가 인간만큼 인기있을려면 진짜 뒤집어지게 멋있어야됨
와,,, 미쳤다 노래 개고퀄이야
From Tyra's rap and then it transitioned to Siu's part in 1:29 with her angelic voice 😍😍😍 I SO FUCKING LOVE THIS PART.
Excuse me, how do you distinguish between them?
@@nesofadivnn I also had a hard time distinguishing who is who the first time I saw them. I thought they all looked the same lol.
But here are some characteristics that I noticed that helped me familiarize them:
SIU: her voice and face are angelic, calm, dresses elegantly, main vocalist, has the most high notes
ZENA: the girl with bangs, the coolesttttt, gives vibes of an assassin that I read on books 😆
TYRA: The girl whose hair is tied in pigtail. THE RAPPER.
MARTY: Chubby cheeks/round face (I don't know but it's really her cheeks and shape of face I find the most distinguishing part of her body).
Or you might as well see their concept photos, that will help you more.
@@hyunjinshairdeservesafando8235 cute
@@hyunjinshairdeservesafando8235 excuse me what's Hyunjin's hair Fandom name I wanna be one 👁👄👁
aespaに世界観が似てる。
こういうカッコいいコンセプトめっちゃ好きだしバーチャルK-POPアイドルは衝撃を受けたのでこれからの活躍にも期待！
They literally played an AR video...nobody is going to complain they're not singing live right? 😅
I really like the song. The vocal talent is definitely there but I'm curious about the real people behind the voices. Would they make a real life debut at some stage in their career?
Have the same dilemma. Hoping real life talent would be recognized too.
I am hoping that the singers are singing live at the backstage or somewhere in the studio since they're not even showing themselves so the least thing they could do is sing live for these AIs, but yeah, this is still cool.
Idols dont really sing live so its the same
@@Dany-lx1wx Dreamcatcher does, but its true not all idol sing live.
i'm not worried about the singing live part, I'm more of wondering what these girls really look like, or they just made up by the company and uses some random girls as their singers. I mean, like are the girls so unattractive that they dont want to really show they real face?
와..이걸 아무렇지 않게 받아드리는 문화구나 시대가 진짜 빨리 바뀌는구나
너무 멋져요 이렇게 활동할 줄은 몰랐어요
음중까지 출연하노. 진심이네ㅋㅋ
인간에 비해 휴식시간도 필요없고 사생활 논란 전혀 없고 빡센 춤에 고음의 노래 안정적 가능 이런 장점이 많지만 팬덤 형성은 힘들듯..
사실 가수에게 정을 붙이는게 완벽해 보이는 무대 속 저 사람도 인간이기 때문에 나오는 실수들, 때때로 나오는 열애설 그런 인간적인 모습들이 접점이 없는 우리가 정을 붙일 수 있는 이유가 아닐까 싶다. 그런 의미에서 나는 실력이 떨어지는 아이돌일지라도 그냥 같은 인간으로서 '저사람도 잘 하고 싶을텐데' 누군가의 노력에 응원한번 해줄 생각 없는 사람들이 완벽한 모습만을 보이길 요구하는게 안타까울때가 있다.
Tyra’s vocals and rap are really cool