Damn, he was so clearly manipulated. This makes me sad. I feel like he was gaslit and groomed from the time his mom died to believe in a certain kind of reality. I don't see anything wrong with him getting clemency tbh. I'm sure he has a much better grip on reality now and feels terrible about what happened. It wasn't just a matter of being an immigrant imo, but having a whole other narrative of reality spun by his sister that led up to these events.
Agreed! There were a lot of factors that went into the reasoning and actions for everyone, not just Andrew, so I completely agree with your comment here. The gaslighting was definitely key in Andrew's actions.
Just finished class and watched. I feel so terrible for Andrew! So many things and factors around his conception and birth were so hurtful toward him. It’s so painful to see a sibling turn to jealousy , and it hurts the whole family.
I completely agree there was this pressure placed on him since birth just because of the IDEA of him, which is so unfair. Cathy also got the very short end of the stick just for being female. It's all bad.
Hi Brittany, thank you so much for featuring the story of our dear friend, Andrew. We told him about your feature, and he so appreciates you taking the time to learn and share his story with your audience. Much love to you and your viewers! - Advocacy for Andrew Suh
You are so welcome! Thank you so much for taking the time to comment here in our community! This is a great reminder that the cases that we talk about are not just stories to tell. They involve real people and can really help to make an impact. I hope that I told the story well enough as this case has so many different layers to it and is very much a conversation starter and you can tell by the comments. We have even had some viewers sign the petition. Best of luck to Andrew and team!
Feel so sad for Andrew! I saw his docu one day , signed his petition which sky rocketed after vloggers share his story. Then nbc did A story on his sister and featured Andrew “called twisted loyalty” My heart totally breaks for him. He should of been given a reduction of his extremely excessive sentence. He has done almost 30 years already. He is not a threat to society and even with support from the prosecutor and no opposition from the victims brother and his very mitigating circumstances/damaging childhood… the system thinks it’s better to keep him locked up. 😭why do worst criminals get less time and already free? Even ex prisoners have commented on some of Andrews story on RUclips saying he doesn’t deserve to be locked up.
This is such a sad case. I wish Andrew had some friends that he could of shared things with because it is so obvious what the sister did. I for sure will sign and hopefully enough signatures will move a cog of the wheel in his benefit. Thank you for sharing this.
Absolutely! I definitely agree. Unfortunately he had a good number of friends but never felt comfortable to share his personal problems at home with any of them. He definitely needed an outlet and someone in his life that could counteract the negative influence that he had.
I agree that this was completely wrong and he needed to serve time. At the same time, the culture that he was brought up in and the pressure of being the protector of the family is key in this case. I think that he should have a second chance and it sounds like he is completely remorseful. I also think that the sister should rot in jail!! Thank you for your diversity in sharing cases.
The irony of the sister destroying the brother's life because her life was destroyed by her parents neglect due to her brother's birth is not lost on me
The way you explained the culture, really did change my mind about this case. I really think he was manipulated and had his culture used against him by his sister and he should have a lesser sentence because of it. Yes he killed someone, but he was basically brainwashed and thought he was killing a man who murdered his mother, stole from him and beat his sister.
Yes, there is a lot of manipulation at play here along with the culture piece. It's such an unfortunate and tragic story for everyone involved. No one made it out unscathed here, and its' so sad.
Thank you so much! I get so invested into these cases and I am happy that that comes through on the other end. So happy to hear that you have been enjoying the content so far!💕
i was SO relieved to hear there wasn't going to be makeup involved! Just watching all that stuff makes my face itch! i've never been into heavy makeup. just watching makes me very uncomfortable.
I know! I love a natural beat but unfortunately it takes so much makeup to get a look to show well on camera so sometimes you have to pack it on! lol but yes, I always make sure to streamline my videos when we are getting in deep!
I believe culture was the reason for the sister's behavior 100%. Blackmail over the mother's death would explain why she didn't remove Robert from her life and finances. Putting culture aside, any child who has lost both parents of which they were extremely close to, could be easily manipulated in this way. For all of these reasons I feel that he has done his time and hopefully learnt a valuable life lesson. 🙄
New subscriber here. Great job. I think he has served his time. He did a terrible thing but I think the circumstances should have given him a sentence of 20 years or so.
@@BizzieBrittany It is crazy. If this guy doesn't qualify, who does? It is important to recognize culture in this case. It is a rarity and should not obviously be used to exploit bad behavior, but still, his story is severe for sure. I do really like that you are reporting on some more obscure cases. And it isn't like 20 years is a slap on the wrist and he has done nothing but good since he went to prison. Bravo to you Bizzie!
Love from Australia….😫 ❤️💙 hope Andrew can be free soon. He has paid his debt to society…. Mental childhood (orphaned) trauma and Andrews terrible circumstances should count for something.
I agree! The entire goal of jailing someone is to rehabilitate those who can be and keeping those who cannot be rehabilitated off the streets, and he has definitely proven himself to be the former. 💕
I always find it mildly strange when I watch true crime videos and the person talks about criminals walking the streets and being released and such. I thin coming from a country that doesn't have life sentences or death penalty makes it almost alien the concept of criminals not walking the streets. For me it's like, they will serve their time and then they will go on with their life
I really enjoy your videos! I’ve been watching Snapped forever and love the show. I wanted to say thank you for choosing not to cover the ongoing cases of Gabby Petito and Jelani Day because things are changing so quickly. I’ve seen so many videos from other RUclips personalities on Gabby’s case and Jelani’s and they are so confusing and speculative and then a few days later things are exactly the opposite. While I hope that both Gabby and Jelani get justice, it’s going to take a long time, and the speculation only creates more pain for their grieving family members.
Exactly this. It's so hard for me to watch because these families are still actively searching and grieving the loss of their loved ones and so much misinformation is being spread for views and subscribers in a lot of cases. Praying for both of those families to get the healing and answers they deserve. 💜
@@BizzieBrittany absolutely! I totally agree. As for Andrew, I believe he was clearly manipulated by his sister and deserves a second chance. It’s so sad that she shut him out being the only family member left, but hearing what he has done during his time in prison is incredible. He has really turned his life around and deserves the opportunity to enjoy it!
Love from England ❤ Poor Andrew , I really feel that he should be released , his sister used him to do her dirty work knowing about their loyalty to each other 🥺
As an immigrant, I don’t know if it was so much cultural as it was being raised by his sister and her being the last family he had. And again, I’m not sure if my thinking is so much cultural as it is wanting to protect what is my own. As for Andrew, I think he should have been charged with 2nd degree murder just based on the fact that it was his older sister/guardian/parental figure who put him up to it.
I feel sorry for Andrew for having had such a wicked sister. She was a very bad influence. Having said that, he did the crime and therefoe has to do the time.
Andrew is definitely paying for his crime. He took full responsibility and has had nearly thirty years to pay his debt. he now realises how blindly loyal hand evil his sister Is (he broke down in the nbc show recently which was about Catherine). I encourage u to read his clemency letters to the governor. He has tried two or three times already. He also has support from his Korean Catholic Church who will support him with housing and a pathway back to society. Andrew definitely was manipulated and “should have known better” but we weren’t in his shoes. He has been orphaned since 11.
I'm on the fence about this one, yes he murdered someone, but I don't think he is a killer, if not for his sister I think he would have been a productive and successful citizen, and a danger to NO ONE.
This is a hard one. In the letter of the law he should stay put. Personally, I think he should be freed after some exceedingly thorough forensic examining and testing and then really held to the letter on parole. But I think he also needs pretty intense counseling after because he will be doing his duty to carry on the family name and how is he going to do this with a prison record. I think that he needs to be very mentally prepared so he does no harm to himself. So his parole would need to be very restrictive at first until he has shown that he is not an imminent harm to himself.
I couldn't agree more. I think the biggest part about deeming someone rehabilitated is doing the proper checks to ensure that that is actually true. I also think that it is making sure they received the care that they needed in order to be properly rehabilitated. Great points made!
@@BizzieBrittany thanks! True rehabilitation in this manner is the future of the prison system, I think. We have a gigantic state run program for rehabilitation that does not rehabilitate! I do believe that some people can't be rehabilitated, but I also think that some people get stuck in a prison state of mind almost as a cultural right of passage. It's not. People who have been immersed in a life where disregard for the law is the norm aren't going to deviate from that unless they are educated otherwise. Programs have to be of good quality to actually rehabilitate. It takes a lot of work. I think in 30 years it will look very different. And in 100 years I think it won't even be recognizable to us. Thanks for what you do! I'm really enjoying your channel!
@@TangledYarnPrincess Andrew has actually been asking for therapy sessions for the past 8 years but they prefer to medicate the inmates (even Andrew as an exemplary one, who has an optic licence, super clean record and working in fields that help others) than actually help them. If u read up further on Andrew , u will find that Andrew is clearly no threat but rather the opposite. I truely believe he is a good person that made one huge grave mistake. He has paid his debt to society. I can’t help but think of prejudice in the system.. think about It. Asian young teen .. barely an adult.. no parents..white victim. That’s besides the point though. He has definitely done his time.. cmon originally sentenced to life in prison and just spared the death penalty? That is extremely Excessive.!!!
@@lovher I hope he is released, and I hope he is able to go on to live a good life- safely- for himself. There's so much transition from what he has known as adult life into the real world. I wish him the best and hope he goes on to live a wonderful, full, life. And I hope that he is able to do it with excellent support.
@@TangledYarnPrincess I wholeheartedly hope for the same and agree!!! poor Andrew. I have written to him via the connect website app after watching his documentary and he is 100 percent a good person. I encourage anyone to write to him - he would love to hear from his supporters or anyone who could give him insight into the world right now. Instructions r noted on his fb page. His birthday is in January and I read xmas and jan is the most saddest time for him,
omg the chain of events the sister probably resented her parents(i mean from the sounds of it rightfully so abusive father mother who didn’t protect her from said abuse) and new little brother i feel like she was definitely either the murderer or indeed got someone to murder the mother and she definitely manipulated her brother smh it’s just all sad but when she became an adult she had no excuse to kill (allegedly) her brother and conspire her brother to kill her husband she definitely deserves her sentencing
I'm very happy to see Mr. Day get more coverage to be fully honest I'm surprised he had gotten any coverage My children are mixed so I know they wouldn't get much if any God forbid they ever need any to begin with. Don't get me wrong Gabbi deserved the coverage she has gotten however it should be the same for ALL people It breaks my heart that if your white a woman ( sometimes pretty for some reasons ) you get all the glory featured on the news stations and just a little blip if your any type of POC 😭😭😭😭😭😭😳😳😳😳😳😠😠😠😠😠. YOU ARE WHY ILOVE AND WATCH YOUR VIDEOS. Iknow water I can come get some straight up facts about missing POC. Hell I don't see much coverage on my local news about POC unless it oh this dude this height age went missing....now back to this lovely Florida weather INFURIATES ME so much MS Holloway white young pretty American. Over sees Look at that coverage SMDH Mr Day was a good kid hell he was trying to become a DOCTOR he had a family has mom is torn up over this an he should get just as much as any white blonde pretty girl gets gabi getting much so much morei hate this ALL ARE SOMEONES SON/DAUGHTER THEY ALL HAVE FAMILY DADS MOMS SIBLINGS GIVE ALL THEM THE EQUAL COVERAGE THAT IS THE LEAST THESE NEW REPORTERS CAN AN SHOULD DO....SORRY I RAN OFF THE RAILS BUT YA GET ME ?
You said everything that needed to be said and I could not agree more! It is so frustrating that even those on our communities that have so much going for them get little to no coverage when something happens, but we will hopefully change that!
I respect how u respect Koren culture here. But shiiiiit lots of ppl, Americans vehemently believe in an after life and love they families more than anything and heavily value that above all else (esp black folks fr prévious gens) lolllll. Like even non immigrant Americans or non recent ones have these values and it ain't an excuse for us/them. I wonder if in Korea his actions wldnt have been a crime. Anywho rant done. It's all love, i just don't know if his cultural background gives me a diff lens here.
From I heard from the comments of the Koreans from a Korean video covering his case, they obviously believe that what he did was wrong and shouldn’t have been done. They obviously empathize with him because of why he did of what he did. Truly believe that he should definitely have gotten a lesser sentenced than what he got. You do the crime you do the time but at the same time he got a cruel sentence for what the special circumstances he had.
He used and manipulative at a vulnerable age he has suffered enough please let him out it was Catherine's twisted plan all along she is where she needs to be after a lifetime of using exploiting and destroying people around her he still has a chance at a better life he deserves.
35:09 This has nothing to do with a cultural clash or culture in general. Andrew was manipulated by his sister to do his crime. You are assuming a lot here. There are many people who immigrate to the U.S. from different cultures and they do not commit murder. 35:38 Family is important in Korean culture, but not to the point of violating any laws. Morality is very important in Korean culture and that is why it has such a low crime rate. Korea does have its own laws just like the U.S. It is really ignorant and offensive for you to blame culture based on this incident, which does not even support your comment. Andrew was law abiding until his sister manipulated him. He was already 19 years old, an adult when he committed murder. He was law abiding and had grown up in the United States for many years before this happened.
Wow... Don't come for me but I do understand how the sister must have felt... she would never be able to please her father no matter what she did nor how hard she tried... Then her younger brother comes on the scene and Dad couldn't be happier...if that doesn't make you feel like a big old loser what will... I agree that she most likely killed her mother... All those stab wounds made it a crime of passion... I think her boyfriend was beating up on her and basically was controlling the money... So she needed him gone... She had no love for Andrew and it showed... If things had gone her way he would spend the rest of his life in jail and she would be free of the boyfriend and she would have all Andrew's money... Question... Why didn't she get any inheritance? Is that part of their culture too... Catherine was raised in the United States pretty much but she was expected to live the culture of her native land... Is that really fair? She was a cold hearted selfish person but what made her like that... Yes she deserves the sentence she received... I also believe Andrew deserves the sentence he got because he was accustomed to the rules of this country... He knew the consequences of his actions... My opinions just thinking things out a different way...
Love your comment! I would never come for you for sharing your view on the case!!! These are the conversations that I wanted this video to drive. I definitely agree with you about Cathy. She was never given the tools or love needed in life to be a productive human being in any way. The hate that developed within her due to the lack of all of that really came through in every action and decision that she made in her life. She also didn't get the love that she was necessarily looking for in her relationships either. All of that fueled the results that we have here today and I feel for her in that way too. From my understanding, the son was the sole heir or the money because he was the son (culture) and because Cathy showed no interest in her family whatsoever. And I love your question on is it fair to ask the children of immigrants to live by the rules of their native lands when they were not raised there. I think that is a tough question to ask because (speaking from experience) it is very important to carry on the culture and customs from your native land as you grow and have your own families or it dies with you. BUT I think there is a difference in carrying on the customs and such and living/making life decisions as if the new culture you have been immersed into has no bearings on your life. I don't think it is fair to shun your children if they don't make every decision based on your culture because they should also be raised to understand the culture that they are living in and be taught to live a life blending both and making just decisions that way. I think in this case, it gets a bit difficult with the culture and customs that you are trying to carry on cross into the legal space of your adopted land. I also notice this a lot with other Asian cultures and the honor killing cases that take in the US and people wouldn't bat an eye anywhere else. It is not right or acceptable by our standards but it is elsewhere.
@@BizzieBrittany thank you for taking the time to respond to my post... I completely understand and agree with what you're saying... It is important to keep cultural traditions alive but like you stated once the children are grown they should be able to freely make there own decisions without the fear of losing their family's love... I feel the same way about religious beliefs... Please keep these interesting cases coming...
![Diggy Graves - Red Vineyard [Official Lyric Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/8Ro085T0mnQ/mqdefault.jpg)
He deserves another chance. He was basically a teenager & trusted his sister to guide him in right direction as any child would. He’s paid his debt.
Yeah, I tend to lean this way as well!
Update: He finally got released from prison as in 01/26/2024.
It's great to hear that.
omg so happy for him
Damn, he was so clearly manipulated. This makes me sad. I feel like he was gaslit and groomed from the time his mom died to believe in a certain kind of reality. I don't see anything wrong with him getting clemency tbh. I'm sure he has a much better grip on reality now and feels terrible about what happened. It wasn't just a matter of being an immigrant imo, but having a whole other narrative of reality spun by his sister that led up to these events.
Agreed! There were a lot of factors that went into the reasoning and actions for everyone, not just Andrew, so I completely agree with your comment here. The gaslighting was definitely key in Andrew's actions.
Just finished class and watched. I feel so terrible for Andrew! So many things and factors around his conception and birth were so hurtful toward him. It’s so painful to see a sibling turn to jealousy , and it hurts the whole family.
I completely agree there was this pressure placed on him since birth just because of the IDEA of him, which is so unfair. Cathy also got the very short end of the stick just for being female. It's all bad.
You did such a great job with this story! Much compassion, and insight! I think Andrew deserves a second chance!
Thank you so much, Una! I think a lot of people would agree with you!
Hi Brittany, thank you so much for featuring the story of our dear friend, Andrew. We told him about your feature, and he so appreciates you taking the time to learn and share his story with your audience. Much love to you and your viewers! - Advocacy for Andrew Suh
You are so welcome! Thank you so much for taking the time to comment here in our community! This is a great reminder that the cases that we talk about are not just stories to tell. They involve real people and can really help to make an impact. I hope that I told the story well enough as this case has so many different layers to it and is very much a conversation starter and you can tell by the comments. We have even had some viewers sign the petition. Best of luck to Andrew and team!
Feel so sad for Andrew! I saw his docu one day , signed his petition which sky rocketed after vloggers share his story. Then nbc did A story on his sister and featured Andrew “called twisted loyalty” My heart totally breaks for him. He should of been given a reduction of his extremely excessive sentence. He has done almost 30 years already. He is not a threat to society and even with support from the prosecutor and no opposition from the victims brother and his very mitigating circumstances/damaging childhood… the system thinks it’s better to keep him locked up. 😭why do worst criminals get less time and already free? Even ex prisoners have commented on some of Andrews story on RUclips saying he doesn’t deserve to be locked up.
This is such a sad case. I wish Andrew had some friends that he could of shared things with because it is so obvious what the sister did. I for sure will sign and hopefully enough signatures will move a cog of the wheel in his benefit. Thank you for sharing this.
Absolutely! I definitely agree. Unfortunately he had a good number of friends but never felt comfortable to share his personal problems at home with any of them. He definitely needed an outlet and someone in his life that could counteract the negative influence that he had.
Love from Scotland 🏴
Thank you, Lisa!💕
I agree that this was completely wrong and he needed to serve time. At the same time, the culture that he was brought up in and the pressure of being the protector of the family is key in this case. I think that he should have a second chance and it sounds like he is completely remorseful. I also think that the sister should rot in jail!! Thank you for your diversity in sharing cases.
Thank you for sharing your point of view here! I agree that there were a lot of things at play here and Andrew deserves a second chance at life.
The irony of the sister destroying the brother's life because her life was destroyed by her parents neglect due to her brother's birth is not lost on me
I feel like he deserves a chance to have a life outside of his sister and her influence on him. He paid the price.
The way you explained the culture, really did change my mind about this case. I really think he was manipulated and had his culture used against him by his sister and he should have a lesser sentence because of it. Yes he killed someone, but he was basically brainwashed and thought he was killing a man who murdered his mother, stole from him and beat his sister.
Yes, there is a lot of manipulation at play here along with the culture piece. It's such an unfortunate and tragic story for everyone involved. No one made it out unscathed here, and its' so sad.
You do such a greay job. You are so easy for me to follow and you keep me interested and listening. I love that you are so genuine in what you do
Thank you so much! I get so invested into these cases and I am happy that that comes through on the other end. So happy to hear that you have been enjoying the content so far!💕
On other hand though I think the way Kathy was treat as a child definitely impacted her and shaped how she turned out xx
Yep! I couldn't agree more. I think that family dynamic destroyed her. She was never brought up in a way to be a good person by any means.
"I will mot butcher that baby's name", bless you.
😂😂😂 I just couldn't!!
My God this family was marked for tragedy 😢 what a curse not one member had a good outcome.
I said the exact same thing, no one made it out of this situation okay.
This was a great video! And I love the fact that you do cases that other people haven't. How can I give a case suggestion?
Thank you! you and leave them here in the comments or you can email me at momsbestblog@gmail.com!💕
@@BizzieBrittany ok thank you! I emailed you
Hello from Croatia! I just found your channel and am enjoying the content you create! Thank you 😊
Thank you so much! Welcome to our little community, Simone!
The girl life was tragic too.
i was SO relieved to hear there wasn't going to be makeup involved! Just watching all that stuff makes my face itch! i've never been into heavy makeup. just watching makes me very uncomfortable.
I know! I love a natural beat but unfortunately it takes so much makeup to get a look to show well on camera so sometimes you have to pack it on! lol but yes, I always make sure to streamline my videos when we are getting in deep!
This is my first time seeing your content and I subscribed!!!!
Yay! Thank you! Welcome to our little community 💜
@@BizzieBrittany thank you ♥️♥️♥️
Dmn this story was so wild!!!!!!
I believe culture was the reason for the sister's behavior 100%. Blackmail over the mother's death would explain why she didn't remove Robert from her life and finances.
Putting culture aside, any child who has lost both parents of which they were extremely close to, could be easily manipulated in this way.
For all of these reasons I feel that he has done his time and hopefully learnt a valuable life lesson. 🙄
I am right there with you. The world was against both these kids unfortunately!
@@BizzieBrittany We can only hope that with the retelling of their stories that others may learn what not to do..
🤞
@@mareekeay8670 exactly!
I signed the petition thanks for posting it 💚💙💛🧡💖
You are so welcome
New subscriber here. Great job. I think he has served his time. He did a terrible thing but I think the circumstances should have given him a sentence of 20 years or so.
Thank you so much and welcome! I couldn't agree with your comment more!
@@BizzieBrittany It is crazy. If this guy doesn't qualify, who does? It is important to recognize culture in this case. It is a rarity and should not obviously be used to exploit bad behavior, but still, his story is severe for sure. I do really like that you are reporting on some more obscure cases. And it isn't like 20 years is a slap on the wrist and he has done nothing but good since he went to prison. Bravo to you Bizzie!
My husband is first time American he knows and speak/ enunciate words better than I do lol
😂😂😂
Love from Australia….😫 ❤️💙 hope Andrew can be free soon. He has paid his debt to society…. Mental childhood (orphaned) trauma and Andrews terrible circumstances should count for something.
I agree! The entire goal of jailing someone is to rehabilitate those who can be and keeping those who cannot be rehabilitated off the streets, and he has definitely proven himself to be the former. 💕
@@BizzieBrittany he was just released ! Amazing ❤ and by gods grace !
Commenting for the algorithm 💙💙💙
Thanks luv!
I went to church with them and Cathy was really manipulative and bad. Andrew had no chance to turn her down she always got what she wanted.
Tell us more.
Tell us more.
Tell us more.
Tell us more.
Tell us more.
I always find it mildly strange when I watch true crime videos and the person talks about criminals walking the streets and being released and such. I thin coming from a country that doesn't have life sentences or death penalty makes it almost alien the concept of criminals not walking the streets. For me it's like, they will serve their time and then they will go on with their life
🌟 🐝 Great case
Thanks Moon!
Also I think he deserves a second chance. Poor guy.
I definitely agree. I am hoping for more updates on this case soon!
@@BizzieBrittany this might not be new but he’s constantly getting his parole date reduced because of the job program he’s in. It recently changed.
@@reynai3843 thank you for that update! I will check out the update and pin it in a comment if needed!
Poor guy... lived in a dark long enough. He deserves a second chance
I really enjoy your videos! I’ve been watching Snapped forever and love the show. I wanted to say thank you for choosing not to cover the ongoing cases of Gabby Petito and Jelani Day because things are changing so quickly. I’ve seen so many videos from other RUclips personalities on Gabby’s case and Jelani’s and they are so confusing and speculative and then a few days later things are exactly the opposite. While I hope that both Gabby and Jelani get justice, it’s going to take a long time, and the speculation only creates more pain for their grieving family members.
Exactly this. It's so hard for me to watch because these families are still actively searching and grieving the loss of their loved ones and so much misinformation is being spread for views and subscribers in a lot of cases. Praying for both of those families to get the healing and answers they deserve. 💜
@@BizzieBrittany absolutely! I totally agree. As for Andrew, I believe he was clearly manipulated by his sister and deserves a second chance. It’s so sad that she shut him out being the only family member left, but hearing what he has done during his time in prison is incredible. He has really turned his life around and deserves the opportunity to enjoy it!
Love from South Africa🇿🇦🇿🇦🇿🇦
Thank you!!!
Oh I feel so sad for Andrew. I believe he was very manipulated. It’s such a hard one but I do think he should get clemency
I feel he deserves a second chance.
Agreed!
Love from England ❤
Poor Andrew , I really feel that he should be released , his sister used him to do her dirty work knowing about their loyalty to each other 🥺
Completely agree! I love the international love, too!
He just got released from prison last Friday.
As an immigrant, I don’t know if it was so much cultural as it was being raised by his sister and her being the last family he had. And again, I’m not sure if my thinking is so much cultural as it is wanting to protect what is my own. As for Andrew, I think he should have been charged with 2nd degree murder just based on the fact that it was his older sister/guardian/parental figure who put him up to it.
I seen this on ID Channel..this was crazy frfr
Live from Ireland 🇮🇪
Thanks so much, Paul!💜
I feel sorry for Andrew for having had such a wicked sister. She was a very bad influence. Having said that, he did the crime and therefoe has to do the time.
I kind of feel bad for Andrew but at the same time he was an adult and could have made better decisions.
Yep! This is why it was so difficult for me to choose one side or the other so definitively!
Andrew is definitely paying for his crime. He took full responsibility and has had nearly thirty years to pay his debt. he now realises how blindly loyal hand evil his sister Is (he broke down in the nbc show recently which was about Catherine). I encourage u to read his clemency letters to the governor. He has tried two or three times already. He also has support from his Korean Catholic Church who will support him with housing and a pathway back to society. Andrew definitely was manipulated and “should have known better” but we weren’t in his shoes. He has been orphaned since 11.
Love from the Philippines 😍
Thanks, Kelly! Loving all of the international love!
I'm on the fence about this one, yes he murdered someone, but I don't think he is a killer, if not for his sister I think he would have been a productive and successful citizen, and a danger to NO ONE.
I agree. I can definitely see him being a normal, productive, member of society had he not been continuously gaslit and pressured.
I heard of this case before but I think the sister and her boyfriend killed the mother. She wanted the money her brother was going to receive.
Yep, same. I feel like this sister was so tired of being treated as nothing, that she was just determined to take what she felt was owed to her.
Hey girl ❤️
💕💜💕
I think Andrew definitely deserves a second chance ❤️
I think he does, as well. I can't be the judge to decide how soon, but I think that he deserves a second chance at life.
Oooooo I've never heard of this one xx
This is a hard one. In the letter of the law he should stay put. Personally, I think he should be freed after some exceedingly thorough forensic examining and testing and then really held to the letter on parole. But I think he also needs pretty intense counseling after because he will be doing his duty to carry on the family name and how is he going to do this with a prison record. I think that he needs to be very mentally prepared so he does no harm to himself. So his parole would need to be very restrictive at first until he has shown that he is not an imminent harm to himself.
I couldn't agree more. I think the biggest part about deeming someone rehabilitated is doing the proper checks to ensure that that is actually true. I also think that it is making sure they received the care that they needed in order to be properly rehabilitated. Great points made!
@@BizzieBrittany thanks! True rehabilitation in this manner is the future of the prison system, I think. We have a gigantic state run program for rehabilitation that does not rehabilitate! I do believe that some people can't be rehabilitated, but I also think that some people get stuck in a prison state of mind almost as a cultural right of passage. It's not. People who have been immersed in a life where disregard for the law is the norm aren't going to deviate from that unless they are educated otherwise. Programs have to be of good quality to actually rehabilitate. It takes a lot of work. I think in 30 years it will look very different. And in 100 years I think it won't even be recognizable to us.
Thanks for what you do! I'm really enjoying your channel!
@@TangledYarnPrincess Andrew has actually been asking for therapy sessions for the past 8 years but they prefer to medicate the inmates (even Andrew as an exemplary one, who has an optic licence, super clean record and working in fields that help others) than actually help them. If u read up further on Andrew , u will find that Andrew is clearly no threat but rather the opposite. I truely believe he is a good person that made one huge grave mistake. He has paid his debt to society. I can’t help but think of prejudice in the system.. think about It. Asian young teen .. barely an adult.. no parents..white victim. That’s besides the point though. He has definitely done his time.. cmon originally sentenced to life in prison and just spared the death penalty? That is extremely Excessive.!!!
@@lovher I hope he is released, and I hope he is able to go on to live a good life- safely- for himself. There's so much transition from what he has known as adult life into the real world. I wish him the best and hope he goes on to live a wonderful, full, life. And I hope that he is able to do it with excellent support.
@@TangledYarnPrincess I wholeheartedly hope for the same and agree!!! poor Andrew. I have written to him via the connect website app after watching his documentary and he is 100 percent a good person. I encourage anyone to write to him - he would love to hear from his supporters or anyone who could give him insight into the world right now. Instructions r noted on his fb page. His birthday is in January and I read xmas and jan is the most saddest time for him,
omg the chain of events the sister probably resented her parents(i mean from the sounds of it rightfully so abusive father mother who didn’t protect her from said abuse) and new little brother i feel like she was definitely either the murderer or indeed got someone to murder the mother and she definitely manipulated her brother smh it’s just all sad but when she became an adult she had no excuse to kill (allegedly) her brother and conspire her brother to kill her husband she definitely deserves her sentencing
I'm very happy to see Mr. Day get more coverage to be fully honest I'm surprised he had gotten any coverage My children are mixed so I know they wouldn't get much if any God forbid they ever need any to begin with. Don't get me wrong Gabbi deserved the coverage she has gotten however it should be the same for ALL people It breaks my heart that if your white a woman ( sometimes pretty for some reasons ) you get all the glory featured on the news stations and just a little blip if your any type of POC 😭😭😭😭😭😭😳😳😳😳😳😠😠😠😠😠. YOU ARE WHY ILOVE AND WATCH YOUR VIDEOS. Iknow water I can come get some straight up facts about missing POC. Hell I don't see much coverage on my local news about POC unless it oh this dude this height age went missing....now back to this lovely Florida weather INFURIATES ME so much MS Holloway white young pretty American. Over sees Look at that coverage SMDH Mr Day was a good kid hell he was trying to become a DOCTOR he had a family has mom is torn up over this an he should get just as much as any white blonde pretty girl gets gabi getting much so much morei hate this ALL ARE SOMEONES SON/DAUGHTER THEY ALL HAVE FAMILY DADS MOMS SIBLINGS GIVE ALL THEM THE EQUAL COVERAGE THAT IS THE LEAST THESE NEW REPORTERS CAN AN SHOULD DO....SORRY I RAN OFF THE RAILS BUT YA GET ME ?
You said everything that needed to be said and I could not agree more! It is so frustrating that even those on our communities that have so much going for them get little to no coverage when something happens, but we will hopefully change that!
Have you covered the Phoenix coldon.??
That case is weird.,,, Mystery and sadness mixed
It is on my list now!
I respect how u respect Koren culture here. But shiiiiit lots of ppl, Americans vehemently believe in an after life and love they families more than anything and heavily value that above all else (esp black folks fr prévious gens) lolllll. Like even non immigrant Americans or non recent ones have these values and it ain't an excuse for us/them.
I wonder if in Korea his actions wldnt have been a crime.
Anywho rant done. It's all love, i just don't know if his cultural background gives me a diff lens here.
From I heard from the comments of the Koreans from a Korean video covering his case, they obviously believe that what he did was wrong and shouldn’t have been done. They obviously empathize with him because of why he did of what he did. Truly believe that he should definitely have gotten a lesser sentenced than what he got. You do the crime you do the time but at the same time he got a cruel sentence for what the special circumstances he had.
👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼
I'm here for you whether your doing make up or not!
Thanks for always supporting, luv!
Catherine stole from her brother Andrew
Nice healthy hair ima trim my hair asap
LOL girl thank you! I have been keeping it protected for a while because my hair does not like a ton of manipulation at all.
Love ur videos beautiful 💜💙💛❤️🌸🌺🌻
Thank you so much!!
I wonder if u can incorporate what u do with your hair or something while u discuss cases I’m not sure how but that would be cool
That is a good idea! It could be much more of a GRWM but it could work!
Love the videos without the make up. Respectfully said.
Hi! Can you please talk about Amanda black?
Hi! Thanks for the suggestion! I will definitely look into the case!
He used and manipulative at a vulnerable age he has suffered enough please let him out it was Catherine's twisted plan all along she is where she needs to be after a lifetime of using exploiting and destroying people around her he still has a chance at a better life he deserves.
(B yUng ( think B yawwwwn g ) and ( Chul. CH rule ) minus the R the U he said like a hard UUU
Hope that helps
Thank you! I did not want to disrespect that baby!
35:09 This has nothing to do with a cultural clash or culture in general. Andrew was manipulated by his sister to do his crime. You are assuming a lot here. There are many people who immigrate to the U.S. from different cultures and they do not commit murder.
35:38 Family is important in Korean culture, but not to the point of violating any laws. Morality is very important in Korean culture and that is why it has such a low crime rate. Korea does have its own laws just like the U.S. It is really ignorant and offensive for you to blame culture based on this incident, which does not even support your comment. Andrew was law abiding until his sister manipulated him. He was already 19 years old, an adult when he committed murder. He was law abiding and had grown up in the United States for many years before this happened.
You’re a 🌟👏🏻🙌🙏🐶💐💟🇬🇧
Oh my goodness, thank you so much!
Wow... Don't come for me but I do understand how the sister must have felt... she would never be able to please her father no matter what she did nor how hard she tried... Then her younger brother comes on the scene and Dad couldn't be happier...if that doesn't make you feel like a big old loser what will... I agree that she most likely killed her mother... All those stab wounds made it a crime of passion... I think her boyfriend was beating up on her and basically was controlling the money... So she needed him gone... She had no love for Andrew and it showed... If things had gone her way he would spend the rest of his life in jail and she would be free of the boyfriend and she would have all Andrew's money... Question... Why didn't she get any inheritance? Is that part of their culture too...
Catherine was raised in the United States pretty much but she was expected to live the culture of her native land... Is that really fair? She was a cold hearted selfish person but what made her like that... Yes she deserves the sentence she received... I also believe Andrew deserves the sentence he got because he was accustomed to the rules of this country... He knew the consequences of his actions... My opinions just thinking things out a different way...
Love your comment! I would never come for you for sharing your view on the case!!! These are the conversations that I wanted this video to drive.
I definitely agree with you about Cathy. She was never given the tools or love needed in life to be a productive human being in any way. The hate that developed within her due to the lack of all of that really came through in every action and decision that she made in her life. She also didn't get the love that she was necessarily looking for in her relationships either. All of that fueled the results that we have here today and I feel for her in that way too.
From my understanding, the son was the sole heir or the money because he was the son (culture) and because Cathy showed no interest in her family whatsoever. And I love your question on is it fair to ask the children of immigrants to live by the rules of their native lands when they were not raised there. I think that is a tough question to ask because (speaking from experience) it is very important to carry on the culture and customs from your native land as you grow and have your own families or it dies with you. BUT I think there is a difference in carrying on the customs and such and living/making life decisions as if the new culture you have been immersed into has no bearings on your life. I don't think it is fair to shun your children if they don't make every decision based on your culture because they should also be raised to understand the culture that they are living in and be taught to live a life blending both and making just decisions that way.
I think in this case, it gets a bit difficult with the culture and customs that you are trying to carry on cross into the legal space of your adopted land. I also notice this a lot with other Asian cultures and the honor killing cases that take in the US and people wouldn't bat an eye anywhere else. It is not right or acceptable by our standards but it is elsewhere.
@@BizzieBrittany thank you for taking the time to respond to my post... I completely understand and agree with what you're saying... It is important to keep cultural traditions alive but like you stated once the children are grown they should be able to freely make there own decisions without the fear of losing their family's love... I feel the same way about religious beliefs...
Please keep these interesting cases coming...