This is how I taught my dog how to sit. I would first lightly push down on the dogs backside. If he did not do this action immediately I would spank him in his back side 3 times. I taught my dog to stand by first putting a choke chain on him and then if he did not stand immediately I would kick him in his foot and then ribs so he would stand. After that since he did not obey immediately I would pull him tight with his choke chain and spank him 3 times in the face and 5 in the backside. I never use treats if the puppy is good I say good dog if the dog is at all bad like even whimpering when the dog sees a squirrel is unacceptable and will be reprimanded with a spanking immediately. This is in no way harsh in my opinion because all animals need to respect and obey their owners perfectly. If this does not happen they should be reprimanded with a tight pull on a choke chain or a spanking.
The video says nothing about using negative reinforcement and hitting, kicking your dog. Even though it gives you the results you wanted your dog will associate you with physical harm for even the slightest transgression such as whimpering. Your reasoning for not believing it's harsh does not connect to the outcome you wanted, especially since that outcome can be achieved through positive reinforcement rather than abuse. Negative reinforcement is a lazy training method and instil's negative characteristics into pets. You might not see it this way, but when someone hits a dog in the face and body, and kick them in the ribs. It's abuse.
thats great but ur dog has already been taught the stand so ur video shows nothing but wat ur trained dog is doing. totally useless!
This is how I taught my dog how to sit. I would first lightly push down on the dogs backside. If he did not do this action immediately I would spank him in his back side 3 times. I taught my dog to stand by first putting a choke chain on him and then if he did not stand immediately I would kick him in his foot and then ribs so he would stand. After that since he did not obey immediately I would pull him tight with his choke chain and spank him 3 times in the face and 5 in the backside. I never use treats if the puppy is good I say good dog if the dog is at all bad like even whimpering when the dog sees a squirrel is unacceptable and will be reprimanded with a spanking immediately. This is in no way harsh in my opinion because all animals need to respect and obey their owners perfectly. If this does not happen they should be reprimanded with a tight pull on a choke chain or a spanking.
Kate Sounds bout right
The video says nothing about using negative reinforcement and hitting, kicking your dog. Even though it gives you the results you wanted your dog will associate you with physical harm for even the slightest transgression such as whimpering.
Your reasoning for not believing it's harsh does not connect to the outcome you wanted, especially since that outcome can be achieved through positive reinforcement rather than abuse. Negative reinforcement is a lazy training method and instil's negative characteristics into pets.
You might not see it this way, but when someone hits a dog in the face and body, and kick them in the ribs. It's abuse.
Nope, don't like that.
You don’t have a Malinois then. You would only spank it once and lose your face or epiglottis.