Of course we do feel and understand Soo Chul's anger and pain and Anna's actions is really unforgivable but it doesn't give him a right to instigate violence especially to a woman who is recovering from an operation though it should not be tolerated to any gender. Please writer nim don't make SC a violent angry man don't glorify and justify violence as this is in all kinds are wrong.
He has never been this angry at his wife wrongdoings and now he vent decades of rage towards anna!? Very much agree with all the comments, violence is never ok no matter how much you hate anyone
Gosh I never imagine he could be violent; I could understand his anger but to trash her like that while knowing she is sick (from taking her to the hospital), is wrong.
This is glorifying violence. I’m sorry but the slap scene and this scene was horrible and NOT OK! A slap was ok fine she deserved it but this is violence
I think she made a huge mistake when she left and he also has the right to be angry or not to forgive her but he hasn't the right to abuse her!! He can ignore her but not this violence!!
VIOLENCE against women, never , ever . We can't accept it . You can be furious even feel hate with someone but never violent . You can't make "your justice " using your own hands , you become worst than the one who has hurt you . Say everything you want and then choose another path . After saying some words you can't erase them. Forgive is a noble feeling that God gave us , we know that forgive doesn't mean forget . That is ok not to be ok with that , but NO TO VIOLENCE in a very violent world where women are treated like trash everywhere in the globe , it is not a good example to follow, do not agree wit it . I read some comments and I am shocked wit some WOMEN saying it is ok , NO, IT IS NOT OK. Just sit down as a human being and TALK, life is about respect , all lives are precious and all lives matter . It doesn't matter WHO made the mistake , what matters is : sit down and say everything you want and then live forever , it is normal and ok, do not look back and do not come back . When you hate someone, you live in prison, believe me .
Taking off from the responsibilities to our children only ends up to unbearable resentments in the latter days of our lives. No matter how difficult the situation may be, put in mind that God never forsake parents struggling to have better lives for their children. 🙏❤️
Mr. park scares me. Yup Anna did something terrible both as a mother and a wife, but he can't ignore the fact she's still Dandan's birth mother. Anyway Dandan has the right to know the truth and she has the right to accept Anna as her mother or not. It's obvious DD and Daebum are different in current Mrs. Park's eyes(I mean the way she treat DD).
Does Sa Ra scare you when she attacked Guk Hee, a couple at a restaurant, she hit Se Chan multiple times one day, she pulled Dan Dan's hair and slapped her. Is this OK? Does she scare you?
@@layla_2250 the fight with guk hee and dan dan was a petty one really.. Just pulling hairs (in which both of them were involved) and she didn't hurt sechan that hard (again not saying that she did right by hitting him for no reason) but this violence is totally on an another level ... Trying to almost kill someone by choking that too a very weak woman (who had just almost recovered from cancer) and pushing her down is by no means acceptable no matter if it is a man or woman who is doing it
I understand the hate and pain of Soo Chul's character, I am okay with the slap even it has blood, but i think its too much to push a woman like that. Anna Kim's character dont deserve to be treated like that. Arggghh Thats absurd!
Now this is sick that this scene even is ok after that slap. Why does Korea accept abuse and getting drunk but kisses are super restricted!!! It's crazy and upside down. Have they never studied about the effects of what's beeing displayed and normalized in live animation causes societal influence??? Crazy! First the children was locked in a dark room - tutor doesn't report to father. How many things is going to be accepted and restricted?
The violence is painful to watch but this isn't a fantasy show, I don't think it's about normalising anything, the reality is there really are men who would react like this.
@@mimi11011 It's what's beeing displayed and in what manner vs. what's beeing restricted. I agree violence exist, don't get me wrong. I feel there is an imbalance and that it's disturbing.
@@anditapritasari4988 This show is yellow labelled: "Film intended for audiences 15 and over. Underage audiences accompanied by a parent or guardian are allowed."
@@mimi11011 To me having an age restriction during prime time is like having a speed limit in a desolated area. But, affecting minds doesn't only happen to underage. That's just lazy authoritarian behaviour.
Well she told him why she left for America but she should not have stick by his side like that when he has moved on and have a new family. All that time spent with her now he has come to like her... it's really not good.
Are you justifying the violence towards her? That's messed up. He can be mad and furious but violence is not the key especially to a defenseless weak person.
@Altagracia Vasquez of course it's the writers are the ones who come up with the plot which included the violent scene by the comment above is justifying that violence just because the character made mistakes. It's one thing to acknowledge the faults and flaws by the character and one thing to criticize their actions as well as those who support their actions. You need to improve on your comprehension.
we know lying is a big mistake but the pushing is not the right way to do...she was hit so hard the fact Ana is sick, it is too much...you can confronted her, shout at her, slap her...in every mistakes you should listen first what's the reason....if its not acceptable funish the person but not hitting them.
She explained that after she left them, she almost died and she had many surgeries. Then she said, she didn’t mean to crowd into their life, but because CS didn’t recognize her, it turned out like this. Then in the end, she said she can give him everything. And he said, if she really cared about them or if she has any sense of guilt, she would treat them like this.
Mr Park is right because she lied to him many times at the hospital where her father lied to him and used him many times when he told him the truth early.
Ok I know daebums mum is a bit of a money hungry person, but when you've lived ur life the way they did, wouldn't you be??!? Taking every opportunity that is given to you. She just a wants to live a life that she and her family have never had before, so I sympathise with her !!
Not taking up for him, but look at all he has endured as a result of Anna leaving….that second wife, that money hungry family, losing 2houses…man been thru a lot. Now go and lose your temper with that second wife.
@@robertaward8479 He can be mad but not violent and strangle her. If you think losing temper is an excuse, try that in court and you'll be charged with assault and abuse.
@@_WhiteW0lf_ I’m not condoning what he did, but I understand how his feelings are all over the place. Look what she has done to him. Now she is back again, not being truthful, but expecting to take what she wants. Telling the truth would have stopped his reaction a hundred fold.
The violence was really inappropriate can’t lie. At least the truth is out now but he has no right too separate mother and daughter now. It’s not fair to DD, which is what she was saying yesterday.
The writer is trash for making Soo Chul’s character violent he could have been written in a way of how people should react in a situation where they feel deceived and angry without hitting or throwing someone around. I hate how the writer pushes the boundaries for some these characters like Sa Ra and it’s not okay.
Was she trashed when Sa Ra hit Se Chan multiple times or when she slapped Dan Dan? Dramas have sword fights. Some dras mas with queens have court maids who get slapped all the time.
@@layla_2250 historical dramas are different there were no rights given to children when it came to abuse and employees when they were hit in the work place. Such things were overlooked but the writer is suppose to show positive change such as hitting children and women is bas. Viewers on other platforms have discussed the abuse shown by Sa Ra and how the writer kept putting scenes in and nothing was being done about it until now. But SC being violent towards Anna Kim is creating a negative narrative that if someone betrays you that hitting them hard is justifiable.
Of course Anna Kim had to leave her family coz the family really poor Her mistake is get consent from her husband Anyway she is sick & probably will die coz of canser Might as well her husband forgive her after scolding her drastically
회개하고 용서...? 박수철이 죽으려고 했던 게 누구 때문인데; 박수철은 애나킴이 애 버리고 떠나서 죽을 만큼 힘들어했지만 어떻게든 살았는데 열심히 애 다 키워놓으니까 찾아와서 몇 달 동안 아닌 척 부녀 속이고 기만하다가 미국 데려가려고 하는 건 도덕적임? 현실이면 진짜 죽이고 싶을 만큼 화날 거 같은데
![＂비슷한 추억이 있었네요＂ 옛날처럼 나란히 앉아 휴게소 우동을 먹는 이일화와 이종원 [신사와 아가씨] | KBS 211205 방송](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/ru7enPOrYSQ/mqdefault.jpg)
![＂비슷한 추억이 있었네요＂ 옛날처럼 나란히 앉아 휴게소 우동을 먹는 이일화와 이종원 [신사와 아가씨] | KBS 211205 방송](/img/tr.png)
![[#신사와아가씨] “얼굴을 바꿔서 우릴 가지고 놀아?!” 이일화의 정체를 알게된 이종원ㅣ KBS방송](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/RUfnIfSRyhA/mqdefault.jpg)
![이일화의 정체를 알고 분노하는 오현경♨ 다 털어놓는 이종원! ＂단단이 엄마라니?＂ [신사와 아가씨] | KBS 220212 방송](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/SYLTkmkOW04/mqdefault.jpg)
![Felix "Unfair" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Oswujxm2Ag0/mqdefault.jpg)
![신사와 아가씨 박하나와 유회승이 부르는 임영웅의 ♬사랑은 늘 도망가|[불후의 명곡] KBS 2022.03.05.](/img/1.gif)
Of course we do feel and understand Soo Chul's anger and pain and Anna's actions is really unforgivable but it doesn't give him a right to instigate violence especially to a woman who is recovering from an operation though it should not be tolerated to any gender. Please writer nim don't make SC a violent angry man don't glorify and justify violence as this is in all kinds are wrong.
I agree.
Agree,,,n besides,he already got married...it's so unfair to d present woman thinking that he still have d feelings to her..
Agree, a good person has a forgiving heart..
He has never been this angry at his wife wrongdoings and now he vent decades of rage towards anna!? Very much agree with all the comments, violence is never ok no matter how much you hate anyone
Miss Anna Kim’s is a great actor.
Lee il hwa
Gosh I never imagine he could be violent; I could understand his anger but to trash her like that while knowing she is sick (from taking her to the hospital), is wrong.
He needs to go to anger management therapy. This was not in any way ok.
He is following the script, blame the writer.
@@layla_2250 oh, I am blaming the writer!
이미늦었습니다 그러게 왜버리고 떠났나요
This is glorifying violence. I’m sorry but the slap scene and this scene was horrible and NOT OK! A slap was ok fine she deserved it but this is violence
But the scene in which Sa Ra slapped Dan Dan was OK?
@@layla_2250 why are we bringing sara here? That was not okey either. All your comments here is trying to justifying his actions and for what???
Sei que o que ela fez foi horrivel, mas sem violencia fisica, ja que ela e uma mulher e ainda esta doente.
Ne
I think she made a huge mistake when she left and he also has the right to be angry or not to forgive her but he hasn't the right to abuse her!! He can ignore her but not this violence!!
사과할 기회를 달라고 강요하는게 버리고 간 사람이 권리마냥 할 수 있는 말은 아니지
VIOLENCE against women, never , ever .
We can't accept it . You can be furious even feel hate with someone but never violent . You can't make "your justice " using your own hands , you become worst than the one who has hurt you .
Say everything you want and then choose another path . After saying some words you can't erase them.
Forgive is a noble feeling that God gave us , we know that forgive doesn't mean forget .
That is ok not to be ok with that , but NO TO VIOLENCE in a very violent world where women are treated like trash everywhere in the globe , it is not a good example to follow, do not agree wit it .
I read some comments and I am shocked wit some WOMEN saying it is ok , NO, IT IS NOT OK.
Just sit down as a human being and TALK, life is about respect , all lives are precious and all lives matter .
It doesn't matter WHO made the mistake , what matters is : sit down and say everything you want and then live forever , it is normal and ok, do not look back and do not come back .
When you hate someone, you live in prison, believe me .
Thank u ! good mind!
잘햇어
I just want to point out that I'm against all violence, no matter what gender you are. I don't like hypocrisy.
Taking off from the responsibilities to our children only ends up to unbearable resentments in the latter days of our lives. No matter how difficult the situation may be, put in mind that God never forsake parents struggling to have better lives for their children. 🙏❤️
That might be, but he still should not have been this violent.
Я все конечно понимаю, но душить и применять жестокость к человеку это уже за все границы переходит!ужасно! Он не имеет права её трогать!
Mr. park scares me. Yup Anna did something terrible both as a mother and a wife, but he can't ignore the fact she's still Dandan's birth mother. Anyway Dandan has the right to know the truth and she has the right to accept Anna as her mother or not. It's obvious DD and Daebum are different in current Mrs. Park's eyes(I mean the way she treat DD).
Does Sa Ra scare you when she attacked Guk Hee, a couple at a restaurant, she hit Se Chan multiple times one day, she pulled Dan Dan's hair and slapped her. Is this OK? Does she scare you?
@@layla_2250 the fight with guk hee and dan dan was a petty one really.. Just pulling hairs (in which both of them were involved) and she didn't hurt sechan that hard (again not saying that she did right by hitting him for no reason) but this violence is totally on an another level ... Trying to almost kill someone by choking that too a very weak woman (who had just almost recovered from cancer) and pushing her down is by no means acceptable no matter if it is a man or woman who is doing it
I understand the hate and pain of Soo Chul's character, I am okay with the slap even it has blood, but i think its too much to push a woman like that. Anna Kim's character dont deserve to be treated like that. Arggghh Thats absurd!
Why is this writer making this characters into such horrible ppl!
Have to agree. I can't fully blame Mr. Park for doing so, tho.
Now this is sick that this scene even is ok after that slap. Why does Korea accept abuse and getting drunk but kisses are super restricted!!! It's crazy and upside down. Have they never studied about the effects of what's beeing displayed and normalized in live animation causes societal influence??? Crazy! First the children was locked in a dark room - tutor doesn't report to father. How many things is going to be accepted and restricted?
The violence is painful to watch but this isn't a fantasy show, I don't think it's about normalising anything, the reality is there really are men who would react like this.
@@mimi11011 It's what's beeing displayed and in what manner vs. what's beeing restricted. I agree violence exist, don't get me wrong. I feel there is an imbalance and that it's disturbing.
@@mimi11011 the thing is this drama is currently airing on prime time on national tv station. So extra restriction is actually needed.
@@anditapritasari4988 This show is yellow labelled: "Film intended for audiences 15 and over. Underage audiences accompanied by a parent or guardian are allowed."
@@mimi11011 To me having an age restriction during prime time is like having a speed limit in a desolated area. But, affecting minds doesn't only happen to underage. That's just lazy authoritarian behaviour.
Well she told him why she left for America but she should not have stick by his side like that when he has moved on and have a new family. All that time spent with her now he has come to like her... it's really not good.
He still should not have been this violent. This was way, way too much.
Are you justifying the violence towards her? That's messed up. He can be mad and furious but violence is not the key especially to a defenseless weak person.
@Altagracia Vasquez of course it's the writers are the ones who come up with the plot which included the violent scene by the comment above is justifying that violence just because the character made mistakes. It's one thing to acknowledge the faults and flaws by the character and one thing to criticize their actions as well as those who support their actions. You need to improve on your comprehension.
@@_WhiteW0lf_ In no way my statement justified the violent actions of MR. Park. towards Anna.
@@xzeonalove Not you. This other person Antagracia is justifying it
ㅈㄹ칮ㄴ짅7ㄱㅅ칫짖ㅅㅈ26딧팃팃딛ㅅ딛ㅅ딛ㅅ
Lee Il Hwa 🥺🥺🥺
I can't imagine that Mr Park would be so angry at her
That he'll just push her like that 🤧
They don't talk about domestic violence in KOREA coz the government has a lot of pride
we know lying is a big mistake but the pushing is not the right way to do...she was hit so hard the fact Ana is sick, it is too much...you can confronted her, shout at her, slap her...in every mistakes you should listen first what's the reason....if its not acceptable funish the person but not hitting them.
He's blinded by rage!
Pushing someone is very mean?
@@alokkumar-lk3bj yes it is
@@alokkumar-lk3bj choking and trying to kill and then pushing a sick person down is very cruel
@@princessjoe834 it is right thing...
Oh how the mighty have fallen 😳
I need the subs please!! I'm angry and shocked but I need to understand what Anna was saying!
She explained that after she left them, she almost died and she had many surgeries. Then she said, she didn’t mean to crowd into their life, but because CS didn’t recognize her, it turned out like this. Then in the end, she said she can give him everything. And he said, if she really cared about them or if she has any sense of guilt, she would treat them like this.
@@jjhartford17 Thank you! I needed to understand. There's still going to be a long way for them
Oo wow ... This is too much I thought. Poor man ... Everyone deserves having a second chance 😡
Poor man?! He was choking her!?!
Don't bag for forgiveness. Please live your life Dan Dan mother.
Mr Park is right because she lied to him many times at the hospital where her father lied to him and used him many times when he told him the truth early.
He didn't have any right to go strangle her!
@@minmcgonagall9190 he has
This is pure revenge what's wrong with it?
@@alokkumar-lk3bj please stop you’re litreally replying to every comment thinking whatever he did was okey..are you out of your mind?
@@alokkumar-lk3bj that's a twisted mindset. Let's not glorify abuse and violence.
Qé hiso esta persona para enojar su marido señor de la casa ?
Eomma 😭😭😭😭
많은 외국인들 격분과 놀람!!
내가 봐도 너무 이상한 수철~ 예전과 너무 다른 !! 이게 뭔지~~ 민망하고 억지스러움~~~
I am shocked, disgusted and can't understand how they can show this violence in a family drama which is supposed to be warm and fun!
@ shut up
@@zio4933 It's ok that he's angry and hurt. i'm not denying that.He has every right to be, That does not excuse him chocking her imo.
Actions that a man should not slap and abuse a woman.. Moreover, she is the mother of your own child.. Be a real man by forgiving her.
What's about the revenge then? Revenge has just begin
@@alokkumar-lk3bj you are out of your mind .. So should he continue to take revenge and finally succeed in strangling her to death?
@@princessjoe834 yes
I hope he never gets back with her.
No one wants a violent man. No one wants a wife who abandoned their child. No one wants a money hungry wife.
Ok I know daebums mum is a bit of a money hungry person, but when you've lived ur life the way they did, wouldn't you be??!? Taking every opportunity that is given to you. She just a wants to live a life that she and her family have never had before, so I sympathise with her !!
Mr Park, you unmasked yourself now as a violent man. Your anger management are bad.
Not taking up for him, but look at all he has endured as a result of Anna leaving….that second wife, that money hungry family, losing 2houses…man been thru a lot. Now go and lose your temper with that second wife.
@@robertaward8479 He can be mad but not violent and strangle her. If you think losing temper is an excuse, try that in court and you'll be charged with assault and abuse.
@@_WhiteW0lf_
I’m not condoning what he did, but I understand how his feelings are all over the place. Look what she has done to him. Now she is back again, not being truthful, but expecting to take what she wants. Telling the truth would have stopped his reaction a hundred fold.
As many people as Sa Ra attacked, including a child, died not brand her as violent?
The violence was really inappropriate can’t lie. At least the truth is out now but he has no right too separate mother and daughter now. It’s not fair to DD, which is what she was saying yesterday.
It bad to hurt people but she got too greedy
She try to go back to them but she see them living together in her flesh back he was wrong in movie with her family he needed more time aggist
This is SICK! I get the slap but THIS oh hell NO!
I'm shaking!
Why he simply pushed her!
@@alokkumar-lk3bj no he didn’t.
@@potatowatermelonsalad5631 slapping is ok but not pushing...
@@alokkumar-lk3bj this man was choking her..pushed her to the tables hard.Lets not think this was okey.
Yes she is in the wrong but mr Park T_T
Yo entiendo lo que ella hizo, pero esa violencia me tomó desprevenida. No me agradó para nada.
Demasiado para este tipo de dramas. LA primera cacherada ya fue más que demasiado. El resto, innecesario. Eso sí, los actores, sublimes.
Now chusul is a hated man in this episode!
야인시대 이영숙 빛과그림자 조명국
I hope these are all imaginations
The writer is trash for making Soo Chul’s character violent he could have been written in a way of how people should react in a situation where they feel deceived and angry without hitting or throwing someone around. I hate how the writer pushes the boundaries for some these characters like Sa Ra and it’s not okay.
Was she trashed when Sa Ra hit Se Chan multiple times or when she slapped Dan Dan? Dramas have sword fights. Some dras mas with queens have court maids who get slapped all the time.
@@layla_2250 historical dramas are different there were no rights given to children when it came to abuse and employees when they were hit in the work place. Such things were overlooked but the writer is suppose to show positive change such as hitting children and women is bas. Viewers on other platforms have discussed the abuse shown by Sa Ra and how the writer kept putting scenes in and nothing was being done about it until now. But SC being violent towards Anna Kim is creating a negative narrative that if someone betrays you that hitting them hard is justifiable.
@@layla_2250 people have discussed about the sechan’s situation why are you trying to excuse it going to every comments justifying his actions?
So v sad, maybe the writer's he is a violent person, cuz the way he make soo chuls character's violence. not good..
Ella abandonó a su hija ahor quiere hacerse la mártir, no me da pena.
No significa que el tenga derecho de golpearla así! Ya suficiente con la cachetada que le dio! Y él no es ningún santo.
@@minmcgonagall9190 en qué minuto sale la cachetada? Ví que la empujó, no ví nungún golpe, jamás apoyaría la violencia.
@@irri700 el segmento anterior a este. Mira si boca. Y acá la agarró del cuello!
연기 짱 이십니다.... 근데 너무 폭력 적 이다...
Of course Anna Kim had to leave her family coz the family really poor
Her mistake is get consent from her husband
Anyway she is sick & probably will die coz of canser
Might as well her husband forgive her after scolding her drastically
She did not have to.
지금은 수철이 애나킴 용서한건가?
I'm not for Anna Kim side but mr.park wasn't perfect father too.He is more under the money face wife & family.he never takes side for dandan
Were you ok for the Dan Dan slap or when she hit a child multiple times one day?
@@layla_2250 why are bringing this up in every comment? Trying to justify it? What Mr park did is wrong now.
죽는 시늉ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
This drama sucks since it has no English subs
1-32 has english subs. I know because I watch them.
이게 어느나라의 도덕기준인가?
맞겨진 아기를 죽이고 본인도 죽으려했던 자가 회개하고 용서하기는커녕 맞기고
도망했던 사랑했던(?) 전아내를 죽일듯 목조르고 죽인다 협박하고......하는 장면을 뭇가족이 남녀노소 같이
시청하고록 하는 작가의
양심을 허용하는것이??
ㄹㅇ
그냥 쳐보셈
회개하고 용서...? 박수철이 죽으려고 했던 게 누구 때문인데; 박수철은 애나킴이 애 버리고 떠나서 죽을 만큼 힘들어했지만 어떻게든 살았는데 열심히 애 다 키워놓으니까 찾아와서 몇 달 동안 아닌 척 부녀 속이고 기만하다가 미국 데려가려고 하는 건 도덕적임? 현실이면 진짜 죽이고 싶을 만큼 화날 거 같은데
@@파란배경 ㅇㅈ
너무 폭력적이라서 좀 과한 것 같아요. 이미 따귀도 피멍들정도로 때렸잖아요.
너무짜증난다 너무 질실끈다
Wtf is that 🤬😰😰😰😡🤬
VIOLENCE. No other way to sugercoat it. that's domestic abuse!
What is abuse? Pushing her?
@@alokkumar-lk3bj yes it is!
@@alokkumar-lk3bj Pushing her, choking her, hitting her. That is abuse.