all it takes is one look to the attributes tab to know this is a pointless comparison because each set has different atk and crit stats so if by straight to the point you mean there is no info to get from this then sure, it did so very efficiently
@@hachira True, but the similarity in stats and the similar damage output for all of them results in the conclusion that all these sets are good, just pick the one you have with the best substats. Also, although shimenawa does the most normal atk dmg, take into account the lack of burst uptime which is a buffer and increased damage for Ayato. Honestly all these sets are basically the same outputting damage if you view it that way. I wish Genshin added some kind of character simulator mode (Like the beta stage but in game) where you can select a character and place the exact same stats on an artifact, optimal for testing artifact sets.
@@chongers7967 that would be ideal for the average player, but for people that go out of their way to look up game info everything is out there tbh. It's up to you whether to take those calculations as credible or not
In summary: They give very similar results. Shimenawa has the most significant increase but it uses energy & can be detrimental to Ayato's high burst cost. Nice comparison btw
You are right, and it pains me to see people wasting days and weeks worth of resin and time to farm a 4pc set which will be only 5k damage per whole E better, and not even consistently. While everyone has good Gladiator pieces just passively accumulated from bosses
Halzion yep, as the other person said, I meant the new set (Echoes and Vermillion domain), not the Shim ^^” Momiji domain is op and the best to farm, on the contrary, and I fully support that.
yoimiya's damage will be less with echoes. her NA has multiple hits, and each one of them have very different scaling with the last hit being nearly double of her first hit. so if her echoes buff procs on low scaling hits, it will do less dmg. ayato's each slash has very similar scaling with the third hit being only 20% higher. This allows him to do pretty much same dmg no matter when the echoes buff procs.
Shimenawa is the strongest but reduce energy, the new artefact looks the best but... Gladiator and HoD are more consistent, I think HoD is the strongest for burst
@@TartagliaThe_11th_McDsEmployee not really, Blizzard is also a meta artifact useful for many other units… and at this point most players already have a decent ser for Childe, Mona or Xingqiu
In terms of consistency I'd rather say the new EoO set is better than HoD set. It's because most of time you deal more damage during E with that set. In the long run EoO set is always better than HoD and that's what video shows. In fact I can even give you some numbers because I wrote a simple program that "performs" a really high number of E attack sequences so I can compare average damage dealt with EoO set to the other sets. Of course, differences in damage depend on different factors, like, for instance: elemental DMG bonuses, atk% substats, from other sources and other (than from EoO) flat DMG bonuses. Not going much into details, when using Ayato's signature weapon and with average stats from artifacts, you deal about 13-14% more DMG during E with EoO in relation to HoD. When using Amenoma Kageuchi it's only about 3-4%. With good amount of other flat DMG bonuses, like from Yun Jin burst, this advantage drastically drops and HoD can deal more. This is because other flat DMG bonuses kinda understate the value of flat DMG bonus from EoO set. It'll be even up to 10% more with signature and 3% more with AK sword. I assume you have Yun Jin with 13 lvl Burst and some good DEF% artifacts on her. Edit: I corrected damage formula and values changed. Checked some other weapons. Now with some nice Flat Damage bonus from other source, damage with HoD can exceed that with EoO. Just like when using Shimenawa set but Shimenawa gets even few % better.
@@georgesr8979 oh you wouldn't wanna know how many Def and HP artifact i have gotten from both Blizzard and HoD been grinding those artifacts for weeks now and all i have gotten was a decent flower
lucky me i farmed hod beforehand so i got some good pieces. But some upgrades went to energy recharge which is still not bad for ayato. I was so surprised how i found those my childe still has some flat pieces.
I never actually noticed that the title of the pyro regisvine is sometimes different until this video. Well I'll go beat up the other bosses several times to see if it's the same for them.
Fantastic! Thats what I wanted to see. No unnecessary talk. Straight to the Numbers. Thank you and keep it up! Subscribed I would be intrerested in a comparison WITH his Q DMG included.
Idk what version of genshin you playing but Glad is not easy to farm. (update) fuck sake, yea I get it, I completely forgot strongbox was a thing because I rarely use it . I also just wanted to say that you aren't always going to be guaranteed a glad piece on boss drops for those who say you are . So please stop @ing me the same thing over and over again, I get it.
If only echoes is not rng it will be so good, shimenawa is meh for me because that minus 15 energy, 1,5+year playing still not have any good 4 set gladi, so best set for me is hod :''))
Remember guys the difference is very small and it’s based a lot on your substats and weapon, so choose what is best for you, don’t limit yourself to the shimenawa set if you have better or similar HoD, gladiator or echoes sets.
@@frimeldacruz4649 Xiao mains are like Keqing mains in that they are so overdosed with copium waiting for their BiS artifact set that when it finally arrives, they are willing to waste all of their fragile resins on it... (also, Keqing BiS artifact set when)
@@lordpaulphilippfernandez9904 I can Imagine wasting all resin and restocking with primogem just to farm the new Artifact. I Farm artifact only If I have 2 character that can Benefit from it Example Momiji-Dyed Court I farm both Shimenewa and Emblem of fate before because of Raiden Shogun and Yoimiya.
Trying to learn about this dude so my mother can build him well because he's her first 5 star from a character banner The things I do for her, I don't even like him but I'm happy she got a character she wanted and I don't want her building him to be bad so she ends up hating him
thats so cool fr, I wish my family played videogames too lol. Thats why i wanna be the cool dad that can play videogames w my kids in the future Also congrats to her for getting him
@@Justme-jp8ih she collecting them all Everybody except the bow users, she's not a fan of aiming and so she's only levelled up gorou for when aiming is needed and she can't join co-op so I can do it for her
My easiest solution for Shimenawa is two part: - Use Fischl - The rotation starts with Ayato Burst > switch to other characters > back to Ayato and do his Elemental Skill slashes.
Use ayato ult before the rotation and you get the 15 energy by the time you switch back to ayato to activate the shimenawa passive. Plus you can use xinqiu in the team and put him last to the rotation and use E before switching back to ayato so that ayato gets the particles and will have more than enough energy to actuvate ng shimenawa. HoD and glads is for those who cant think. Shimenawa is still the best artifacts for him. Its a matter of strategy. Exactly my point.
@@georgesr8979 The thing is, the burst damage should be better with 18% ATK bonus from EoO and SR set if you use Hydro% goblet. The difference is not big though. Edit: Not true for some weapons and easy to overcome with some ATK% team buffs. Then HoD is better.
@@tomaszhachula4171 nope, attacks stats have higher diminishing returns because they can be obtained by alot of sources (Substats, main stats, sets, buffs, resonance, etc) while elem%dmg only has goblet and kazuha
@@andrewjamez9741 Yh, you right. I totally forgot that crit damage doesn't go in the same bracket with the elem% dmg in the damage formula. Instead it multiplies the whole outgoing damage. Still, I checked, and what I said about burst dmg can be true for some weapons, however it can be easily beat with some team ATK% buffs. Yes, I consider atk% sands of eon, feather, some atk% and atk substats and so on. Mistsplitter Reforged needs some better ATK% party buffs for HoD to be better at burst dmg since it can give even 40% elemental damage. Don't forget that elem% dmg fall within "DMG% bonus" category. So it sums with other DMG% bonuses like from some talents, from 2pc-Noblesse, 4pc-Emblem, 4-pc Shimenawa, 4pc-Glad, weapons like Serpent's Spine (even 40% at R5), The Catch, Lion's Roar, Dragon's Bane, The Alley Flash etc. Basically any bonus that has "DMG" in description and it's value unit is "%".
great video! my personal tip for those with jade cutter is to ideally run HOD, this is because jade cutter already gives you so much atk% the hydro% from the 2 piece would benefit your ayato a lot more compared to atk% from 2 piece glad. jade cutter + 2 piece atk% + substats + potential supports would mean diminishing returns on atk%. otherwise i hope everyone has a great time building ayato!
@@gooeyribs4128 the black sword with 4 piece HOD is perfectly fine, i also don’t suggest farming for echoes if you’re an older player as it’s more likely for you to have better HOD/glad pieces, however if you want the other set for xiao for example then go ahead and farm the echoes domain. otherwise black sword with hod is good!
Nice job on the video, can you test how much damage he's ult does by itself with these artifact sets, aswell as another vid with ayatos ult while attacking with his elemental skill with all four artifact sets. That will be good to see which will be best overall damage. Thanks for the side to side comparisons.
it might look like echoes got a lot of dmg, but keep in mind that the rng is really a pain. He had to do it 10 times to get a consistant number. Gladiator/shin is the easiest to far since you probably already have a good set lying around.
to add a small detail, not only it is rng, but also ping reliant, so if u are playing ayato on a orange/red ping daily basis, that set is bad, better go with HoD/shime/Glad instead
Amazing video. Smoothly and seamlessly compared all 4 sets, showed artifacts with enough time for a human being to pause instead of zipping by at lightning speed, and those freeze frame shots of the numbers was just cleeeean. Ty so much!
This is great. Thanks. It seems that they pretty much put out same damage. It'll boil down to how you prefer to play. I've been thinking of going for HoD instead of the new artifact. Simply because the domain its in also has Blizzard Strayer, which will be useful for Rosaria and Chonyun. 2 birds...1 stone.
Imagine we need gacha for a character, gacha for artifact drops, gacha for substat roll, gacha for spiral abyss buff card, and now even the artifact has gacha for dmg bonus 💀💀💀 This game has insane RNG in everything, only luck people would survive.
well, what else we can do in this game? i think this how they make player to have something to do althought it will be boring in the end end game slowly burn me out so i play another game to cover it
It's pretty much the same. Others sets gives you atk% and it boost your burst too so at the end of the day everything is fine. I run HoD because I have some really nice pieces but that's all.
If you are gonna use shimenawa with your since it buffs ayato. You will need to burst then yunjin skill for particles then back to ayato so you can use the 4pcs set of shime. Because the passive wont proc if you dont have energy.
I feel that's where the big drop from the new set comes from All other sets are constant, while the new one, you can; Not crit and not proc = Not good Crit and not proc =Not Good Not Crit and proc = Not good Crit and Proc = very good And even when you make them all %100 crit, it still didn't shine over the others
Im currently using gladiator sets for him and my damage is 6k-8k and im already fine with it. I really dont wanna waste my resins to artifacts that has the same results. Lol. So as of the moment im building my other 4s characters
Great video! Unfortunetely I lost my 50/50 so I can't test him out. Could you please made similar video with flat DMG bonus from Yun Jin's burst? I made some calculations that show that Shimenawa's Reminiscence set will outshine the new EoO set if you had nice flat DMG bonus from other sources (like Yun Jin burst). Also I think that the results will be more reliable if the new set was tested out with the same crit substats, without food buff.
Echoes will allow you to use your burst more often which contributes to his atk speed which in turn offers more dmg. Shimenawa will be good if you are more reliant or his e.
@@drogadepc well since Shimenawa will cost you some energy from your burst so it is more reliable when you are only spamming his e skill because you always will want some energy on his burst. Echos on the other hand will offer less dmg then the Shimenawa set but since it doesn’t cost burst energy you will be able to use his burst. Keep in mind that his burst will increase his normal atk speed high will result in some extra dmg. Hope that helped this is my reasoning so it could be disapproved.
His burst dosent give him attack speed it gives him normal attack dmg (20% at lvl 10), it was changed since the beta, currently best way to increase his attack speed are Yun Jin c6 and Jean c4
Overall echoes is still better, just too much rng Shimenawa maybe higher but u will have rotation problem, workable but not recommed since u can carry another dps/sub to get more team damage via reaction and the buff HoD and gladi is a good stable set if u have a great set use it since farming echoes is inefficient
@@bebekoexd7537 Only the holder but ayato's burst give a buff for normal attacks so it's better to use burst before the elemental skill plus you lose 15 energy of your burst and if you don't have 15 energy and above you won't get the effect that's why Glad or Hod are much more stable and Echoes on the other hand is a whole annoying rng itself unless you have xiao and ayato then both of them can benefit in that domain
I use him with gladiator set with stats - 2.3k atk, 22k hp, 142er, crit 72/210%, talent 1/8/8 with jade cutter. I have a good shimenesawa set which gives me 90/230 crit but i loose er and burst dmg. He does 10k-11k per hit average but sometimes he hit 12k-14k. And all of this is just piled up hardwork not money.
Really, thank you very much, I'm very dense with the formulas and this comparison helps me to get an idea how to equip Ayato for when I have him (I have 120 saved rolls to date), as well as understand that all damage bonuses ( as normal attacks / charged / Element / damage inflicted) are added at the same point, so the more buff of this type you have with your teammates, the less efficient the shimenawa would be (and without neglecting how said set consumes a lot of energy pd: sorry for my inglish I'm not native speaker
Actually, that 18% ATK 2 piece bonus from the new set or Shimenawa's should give you a little more burst damage. I wasn't lucky enough to get Ayato but it's easy to calculate. I assume you equip elemental goblet. Edit: true for some weapons, depends one substats, easy for HoD to overtake with a small ATK% buff.
@@tomaszhachula4171 it's easy to get ATK from different sources (Bennett, nobles,pyro resonance.etc) the 15% hydro DMG bonus is really good and hard to get, unless you use kazuha,the hydro DMG bonus is better than ATK%
Very nice video, this is the best artifact comparison video i've seen, even compared to other channels with hundreds of thousands of subs. I'm using shimenawa hyper carry.
Just the video I needed. Straight to the point comparisons. Thank you!! I'll prolly farm the echoes artifact for my ayato and yoi since I really hate the energy drain of SR
This is an excellent comparison. Even if the stats aren't exact mirrors of each other (nearly impossible to do) by the laws of average the damage is quite similar. It seems the Echoes set gives the best results by a small margin. However, if you don't need the other set, it would be more resin efficient to use the other options. Both Hearth of Depth and Shimenawa are farmed in domains where the other set works for more characters, specially the latter with Emblem set. Or if you already have good Gladiator pieces, they work very well too. I will personally go for the HoD set, as I also have Childe and Ganyu, better artifacts for either one while farming for Ayato is the most efficient use of my resin. I don't like that Shimenawa consumes energy due to Ayato's high burst cost.
Because I completely forgot about the new artifacts, I built the shimenawa set with the amenoma sword. If the sword is refined at least once you can counter the energy loss from the set. All you have to do now is make sure your artifacts bring about a good crit rate/dmg ratio and atk% and hp% 😅😭 I have a pretty good set albeit not the best and I was still surprised by how well my ayato does as a sub dps!
I already have a solid glad set with like 68 crit and 210 crit damage if we include the weapon. Its nice to know that you can kinda just passively get him the glad set without really wasting any resin, I thought the HoD would have boosted his damage alot with the extra 15 water damage but I'm glad its a little better to have the 18 percent attack from glad instead. Happy to see how artifact friendly ayato is
Same to me I also got him the glad set instead coz it was easier for me to get and reroll and since I'm unlucky on getting good HoD pcs not even good Blizzard for Ayaka. Lucky enough my Ayato made it to 2k atk 62/220 crit 120 em and I'm happy with it :D
This was helpful. Glad i put him on gladiators. Just the overal best it looks since no energy recharge drawback and the dmg isn’t that dif from shimenawa.
For real, my inner hoarder is so satisfied to finally have a proper use for those amazing double crit Glad pieces I just randomly accumulated from world bosses.
I literally have the perfect shimenawa set and just waiting for his next banner release on wednesday. Also putting blackcliff long sword on him, kinda excited not gonna lie.
I think you also have to consider ayato's burst buff to his slashes. when using shimenawa, you will not be able to proc burst that often than when using the other sets.
Straight to the point, gives me the info I need and no bullshit for 10 mins.. amazing video my friend well done!!
all it takes is one look to the attributes tab to know this is a pointless comparison because each set has different atk and crit stats
so if by straight to the point you mean there is no info to get from this then sure, it did so very efficiently
@@hachira True, but the similarity in stats and the similar damage output for all of them results in the conclusion that all these sets are good, just pick the one you have with the best substats. Also, although shimenawa does the most normal atk dmg, take into account the lack of burst uptime which is a buffer and increased damage for Ayato. Honestly all these sets are basically the same outputting damage if you view it that way.
I wish Genshin added some kind of character simulator mode (Like the beta stage but in game) where you can select a character and place the exact same stats on an artifact, optimal for testing artifact sets.
@@chongers7967 that would be ideal for the average player, but for people that go out of their way to look up game info everything is out there tbh. It's up to you whether to take those calculations as credible or not
Yes This is what im talking about. Very good video
@@hachira exactly we need discalimers
In summary: They give very similar results. Shimenawa has the most significant increase but it uses energy & can be detrimental to Ayato's high burst cost. Nice comparison btw
You are right, and it pains me to see people wasting days and weeks worth of resin and time to farm a 4pc set which will be only 5k damage per whole E better, and not even consistently. While everyone has good Gladiator pieces just passively accumulated from bosses
@@jeremiahsmith916 how can you "waste" resin on shimenawa's domain lmao
@@Halzion_ he's talking about the new set. the echo set. If your already farming emblem and shim, then your fine.
Halzion yep, as the other person said, I meant the new set (Echoes and Vermillion domain), not the Shim ^^” Momiji domain is op and the best to farm, on the contrary, and I fully support that.
@@jeremiahsmith916 my bad I thought you were also talking about shimenawa
Of all comparison videos ive seen, this has to be the most efficient in artifact comparison. Hence, you deserve a like and subscribe.
His builds were poop.
Yes it is. I agree
auto subs for him!!
A well crafted, no nonsense video. Is it possible for you to do a dmg comparison with yoimiya using the echoes vs shimenawa set?
Pls pls pls
+1! Please do it for Yoimiya!
Yes pls do it for yoimiya
please!
yoimiya's damage will be less with echoes.
her NA has multiple hits, and each one of them have very different scaling with the last hit being nearly double of her first hit. so if her echoes buff procs on low scaling hits, it will do less dmg.
ayato's each slash has very similar scaling with the third hit being only 20% higher. This allows him to do pretty much same dmg no matter when the echoes buff procs.
Shimenawa is the strongest but reduce energy, the new artefact looks the best but...
Gladiator and HoD are more consistent, I think HoD is the strongest for burst
HoD is the most painful artifact to grind
@@TartagliaThe_11th_McDsEmployee not really, Blizzard is also a meta artifact useful for many other units… and at this point most players already have a decent ser for Childe, Mona or Xingqiu
In terms of consistency I'd rather say the new EoO set is better than HoD set. It's because most of time you deal more damage during E with that set. In the long run EoO set is always better than HoD and that's what video shows. In fact I can even give you some numbers because I wrote a simple program that "performs" a really high number of E attack sequences so I can compare average damage dealt with EoO set to the other sets. Of course, differences in damage depend on different factors, like, for instance: elemental DMG bonuses, atk% substats, from other sources and other (than from EoO) flat DMG bonuses. Not going much into details, when using Ayato's signature weapon and with average stats from artifacts, you deal about 13-14% more DMG during E with EoO in relation to HoD. When using Amenoma Kageuchi it's only about 3-4%. With good amount of other flat DMG bonuses, like from Yun Jin burst, this advantage drastically drops and HoD can deal more. This is because other flat DMG bonuses kinda understate the value of flat DMG bonus from EoO set. It'll be even up to 10% more with signature and 3% more with AK sword. I assume you have Yun Jin with 13 lvl Burst and some good DEF% artifacts on her.
Edit: I corrected damage formula and values changed. Checked some other weapons. Now with some nice Flat Damage bonus from other source, damage with HoD can exceed that with EoO. Just like when using Shimenawa set but Shimenawa gets even few % better.
@@georgesr8979 oh you wouldn't wanna know how many Def and HP artifact i have gotten from both Blizzard and HoD been grinding those artifacts for weeks now and all i have gotten was a decent flower
lucky me i farmed hod beforehand so i got some good pieces. But some upgrades went to energy recharge which is still not bad for ayato. I was so surprised how i found those my childe still has some flat pieces.
All of your artifacts set is so balance stat. I can't imagine how long do you prepare them? Nice effort!
Thanks for video btw !
They're trash lmao
this is what we need, no talking and straight to the point showing the results next to each other!! Well done
I never actually noticed that the title of the pyro regisvine is sometimes different until this video.
Well I'll go beat up the other bosses several times to see if it's the same for them.
I never actually noticed that the title of the pyro regisvine is sometimes different until I saw your comment LMAO
I knew it was the case for the Primo geovishap, but I thought it was the only one
Fantastic! Thats what I wanted to see. No unnecessary talk. Straight to the Numbers. Thank you and keep it up! Subscribed
I would be intrerested in a comparison WITH his Q DMG included.
We need more straightforward video like this, side by side, thank you so much!
Echoes is very inconsistent, Shimenawa affects your Ult… the best and most consistent imo are Glad or HoD they’re also easier to farm
Idk what version of genshin you playing but Glad is not easy to farm. (update) fuck sake, yea I get it, I completely forgot strongbox was a thing because I rarely use it . I also just wanted to say that you aren't always going to be guaranteed a glad piece on boss drops for those who say you are . So please stop @ing me the same thing over and over again, I get it.
If only echoes is not rng it will be so good, shimenawa is meh for me because that minus 15 energy, 1,5+year playing still not have any good 4 set gladi, so best set for me is hod :''))
@@jensu3653 how is gladiator not easy to farm, you literally get it from every single boss in existence in the game
First of all no artifact set is "easy" to farm and gladiator's is even harder lmao
@@luciots134 not every boss will guaranteed a glad drop and if we're comparing this to a artifact domain than glad is a lot more harder to farm
Remember guys the difference is very small and it’s based a lot on your substats and weapon, so choose what is best for you, don’t limit yourself to the shimenawa set if you have better or similar HoD, gladiator or echoes sets.
Or better yet: stop wasting resins on the new domain.
True go with the better sub stats than wasting resin. Unless farming for both Artifact if the player have Xiao.
@@frimeldacruz4649 Xiao mains are like Keqing mains in that they are so overdosed with copium waiting for their BiS artifact set that when it finally arrives, they are willing to waste all of their fragile resins on it... (also, Keqing BiS artifact set when)
@@lordpaulphilippfernandez9904 I can Imagine wasting all resin and restocking with primogem just to farm the new Artifact. I Farm artifact only If I have 2 character that can Benefit from it Example Momiji-Dyed Court I farm both Shimenewa and Emblem of fate before because of Raiden Shogun and Yoimiya.
yeah. with team buffs the ranking also can change. any of them is really viable.
Trying to learn about this dude so my mother can build him well because he's her first 5 star from a character banner
The things I do for her, I don't even like him but I'm happy she got a character she wanted and I don't want her building him to be bad so she ends up hating him
Thats so sweet!!!
thats so cool fr, I wish my family played videogames too lol. Thats why i wanna be the cool dad that can play videogames w my kids in the future
Also congrats to her for getting him
@@ionutgogosanu4452 I'll tell her you said congrats
She collecting em Husbandos
@@Justme-jp8ih she collecting them all
Everybody except the bow users, she's not a fan of aiming and so she's only levelled up gorou for when aiming is needed and she can't join co-op so I can do it for her
greatest comparison video ive ever seen, no useless talking, straight to the point…nice job bestie
holyyy shit man that effort is so much appreciated!! can't believe someone already got a decent echoes set
My easiest solution for Shimenawa is two part:
- Use Fischl
- The rotation starts with Ayato Burst > switch to other characters > back to Ayato and do his Elemental Skill slashes.
Use ayato ult before the rotation and you get the 15 energy by the time you switch back to ayato to activate the shimenawa passive. Plus you can use xinqiu in the team and put him last to the rotation and use E before switching back to ayato so that ayato gets the particles and will have more than enough energy to actuvate ng shimenawa. HoD and glads is for those who cant think. Shimenawa is still the best artifacts for him. Its a matter of strategy.
Exactly my point.
Thank you for being so precise! It makes it much more easier to see which one is better. Thank you so much.
This is an extremely well-crafted video. keep it up!
The HoD set was just slightly worse in terms of substats than the others. It should perform similar to Gladiator.
Also the Ult dmg should be Better with HoD
@@georgesr8979 The thing is, the burst damage should be better with 18% ATK bonus from EoO and SR set if you use Hydro% goblet. The difference is not big though.
Edit: Not true for some weapons and easy to overcome with some ATK% team buffs. Then HoD is better.
@@tomaszhachula4171 nope, attacks stats have higher diminishing returns because they can be obtained by alot of sources (Substats, main stats, sets, buffs, resonance, etc) while elem%dmg only has goblet and kazuha
@@andrewjamez9741 Yh, you right. I totally forgot that crit damage doesn't go in the same bracket with the elem% dmg in the damage formula. Instead it multiplies the whole outgoing damage. Still, I checked, and what I said about burst dmg can be true for some weapons, however it can be easily beat with some team ATK% buffs. Yes, I consider atk% sands of eon, feather, some atk% and atk substats and so on. Mistsplitter Reforged needs some better ATK% party buffs for HoD to be better at burst dmg since it can give even 40% elemental damage.
Don't forget that elem% dmg fall within "DMG% bonus" category. So it sums with other DMG% bonuses like from some talents, from 2pc-Noblesse, 4pc-Emblem, 4-pc Shimenawa, 4pc-Glad, weapons like Serpent's Spine (even 40% at R5), The Catch, Lion's Roar, Dragon's Bane, The Alley Flash etc. Basically any bonus that has "DMG" in description and it's value unit is "%".
@@tomaszhachula4171 ahh, i see, i counted elem dmg bonus as a different stat , which means kazuha buffs a little bit less than I expected ...
great video! my personal tip for those with jade cutter is to ideally run HOD, this is because jade cutter already gives you so much atk% the hydro% from the 2 piece would benefit your ayato a lot more compared to atk% from 2 piece glad. jade cutter + 2 piece atk% + substats + potential supports would mean diminishing returns on atk%. otherwise i hope everyone has a great time building ayato!
I have four piece HoD on him with The Black Sword (no refinements), I’m not sure if this is ideal? Should I do Echos instead?
@@gooeyribs4128 the black sword with 4 piece HOD is perfectly fine, i also don’t suggest farming for echoes if you’re an older player as it’s more likely for you to have better HOD/glad pieces, however if you want the other set for xiao for example then go ahead and farm the echoes domain. otherwise black sword with hod is good!
It's pretty much the same in dmg comparison. Just use whichever has the best substat. My 4 glad hits harder then my 4 hod bcuze of substat.
Same argument for echoes tho cuz it scales based on your atk
Maybe one day I will get HOD for him but for now I got 80%crit with, 205crit damage, 70em, and 140% energy recharge. This is with gladiator set.
This is so good!! Thnx for ur effort, now I know which one's best to use on ayato 😭😭
That video is so genius, I even give you a well deserved sub. Thank you so much, you did a great job.
Thank you for this test!!! now I know that Gladiator's Finale is enough for my ayato
tysm!! wish all demo vids are like this, straight to the point
Nice job on the video, can you test how much damage he's ult does by itself with these artifact sets, aswell as another vid with ayatos ult while attacking with his elemental skill with all four artifact sets. That will be good to see which will be best overall damage. Thanks for the side to side comparisons.
it might look like echoes got a lot of dmg, but keep in mind that the rng is really a pain. He had to do it 10 times to get a consistant number.
Gladiator/shin is the easiest to far since you probably already have a good set lying around.
to add a small detail, not only it is rng, but also ping reliant, so if u are playing ayato on a orange/red ping daily basis, that set is bad, better go with HoD/shime/Glad instead
thanks for all the effort. Your videos are always on point and very informative. Love it! Keep going on. You should have much more subscribers
Man, this was so informative and also straight to the point. I'm gladly subscribing. Thank you for the video!
Amazing video. Smoothly and seamlessly compared all 4 sets, showed artifacts with enough time for a human being to pause instead of zipping by at lightning speed, and those freeze frame shots of the numbers was just cleeeean. Ty so much!
This is great. Thanks.
It seems that they pretty much put out same damage. It'll boil down to how you prefer to play.
I've been thinking of going for HoD instead of the new artifact.
Simply because the domain its in also has Blizzard Strayer, which will be useful for Rosaria and Chonyun.
2 birds...1 stone.
Imagine we need gacha for a character, gacha for artifact drops, gacha for substat roll, gacha for spiral abyss buff card, and now even the artifact has gacha for dmg bonus 💀💀💀
This game has insane RNG in everything, only luck people would survive.
I wouldn’t play if I’m being fr 😭
well, what else we can do in this game?
i think this how they make player to have something to do althought it will be boring in the end
end game slowly burn me out so i play another game to cover it
and yelan has a gacha burst too
RNG for prolonged gaming experience
Epic Seven 🤝 Genshin Impact
There is no such thing as “lucky people”. RNG fucks with everyone equally. This is the beauty of maths
Damn man. You got one more subscriber here. The attention to stat for perfect crit and ratio of crit damage is chef kiss
HoD is the best. This set give you a buff in the elemental and in the ultimate. My Ayato has this set and his damage is amazing.
Yeah I'm currently running HoD also. But I think I should replace on of the main values with Hydro Damage bonus I think.
It's pretty much the same.
Others sets gives you atk% and it boost your burst too so at the end of the day everything is fine.
I run HoD because I have some really nice pieces but that's all.
Same,
I used the one I had with Childe and now he has good attack and like 85/200 on crit
@@Sergio0hf WoW!!! I have 70/180 crit. Your set is better 😉
I think above 72% crit rate is unnecessary
thanfully i stumbled on this channel. This channel legit just does what the title says, no BS filler stuff for mor watch time. Liked and subcribed
If you are gonna use shimenawa with your since it buffs ayato. You will need to burst then yunjin skill for particles then back to ayato so you can use the 4pcs set of shime. Because the passive wont proc if you dont have energy.
Superb! Thanks for the fantastic side-by-side comparing. It seems that you were the only one who thought about doing this.
The HoD also increase ulti dmg, because of the 2 set bonus, and is more consistent, I think is the best for ayato
Tysm for saving me so much time that no other channel does as simply and to the point as you do.
I feel that's where the big drop from the new set comes from
All other sets are constant, while the new one, you can;
Not crit and not proc = Not good
Crit and not proc =Not Good
Not Crit and proc = Not good
Crit and Proc = very good
And even when you make them all %100 crit, it still didn't shine over the others
Tyvm Sir this was a lot of effort take this virtual heart ❤️ as a sign of my gratitude
Im currently using gladiator sets for him and my damage is 6k-8k and im already fine with it. I really dont wanna waste my resins to artifacts that has the same results. Lol. So as of the moment im building my other 4s characters
this is what you call comparison video.. nice job man
straight to the point
Great video! Unfortunetely I lost my 50/50 so I can't test him out. Could you please made similar video with flat DMG bonus from Yun Jin's burst? I made some calculations that show that Shimenawa's Reminiscence set will outshine the new EoO set if you had nice flat DMG bonus from other sources (like Yun Jin burst). Also I think that the results will be more reliable if the new set was tested out with the same crit substats, without food buff.
really appreciate the effort to do such detailed comparison, +1 sub
Echoes will allow you to use your burst more often which contributes to his atk speed which in turn offers more dmg. Shimenawa will be good if you are more reliant or his e.
How so?
@@drogadepc well since Shimenawa will cost you some energy from your burst so it is more reliable when you are only spamming his e skill because you always will want some energy on his burst. Echos on the other hand will offer less dmg then the Shimenawa set but since it doesn’t cost burst energy you will be able to use his burst. Keep in mind that his burst will increase his normal atk speed high will result in some extra dmg. Hope that helped this is my reasoning so it could be disapproved.
His burst dosent give him attack speed it gives him normal attack dmg (20% at lvl 10), it was changed since the beta, currently best way to increase his attack speed are Yun Jin c6 and Jean c4
@@QuinSalieri thx good info
Thank you for this! I love a video that's to the point and clear 🙌🙌
This is called quality, hats off
I also watched your previous video which is also a great help for us and now that you made this video you help us again. I should subscribe now.
What about 2 HoD + 2 Noblesse / or 2 Glad + 2 Noblesse / or 2 glad + 2 HoD / for only use 'burst Ayato' (Not a atk normal fan) ?
Quickly becoming one of my go to sources for informative vids alongside iwin2lose and zy0x! Keep up the amazing work
Overall echoes is still better, just too much rng
Shimenawa maybe higher but u will have rotation problem, workable but not recommed since u can carry another dps/sub to get more team damage via reaction and the buff
HoD and gladi is a good stable set if u have a great set use it since farming echoes is inefficient
Why shimenawa affects rotation?
@@chillax1688 is losing energy applicable for the whole party or just the holder?
@@chillax1688 so what set are u using
@@bebekoexd7537 Only the holder but ayato's burst give a buff for normal attacks so it's better to use burst before the elemental skill plus you lose 15 energy of your burst and if you don't have 15 energy and above you won't get the effect that's why Glad or Hod are much more stable and Echoes on the other hand is a whole annoying rng itself unless you have xiao and ayato then both of them can benefit in that domain
@@user-sd2xo8en4t Xiao has the other set that increases atk as he loses hp.
Thank you for putting so much effort into making the video
I have 4 piece Echo on Ayato and my Ratios Are 62% crit chance 210% crit dmg average hit dmg 14k
What weapon do you use?
@@yuelilie prolly missplitter or haram
@@jtarokujo6462 Ahh I have none of those TT
@@yuelilie don't worry, alot of ppl share the same feeling ~_~
@@yuelilie Actually i am Using BP sword but my Artifacts are cracked and I have c1 plus his E crowned.
I use him with gladiator set with stats - 2.3k atk, 22k hp, 142er, crit 72/210%, talent 1/8/8 with jade cutter. I have a good shimenesawa set which gives me 90/230 crit but i loose er and burst dmg. He does 10k-11k per hit average but sometimes he hit 12k-14k. And all of this is just piled up hardwork not money.
Sounds like ur flexing ://
you don't really need to upgrade his normal attacks right?
@@priyotomo203 no need
@@priyotomo203 if you need him as dps sure you want but not for support I guess
@@aflyingdorito208 sure i am if you want to you can too
Really, thank you very much, I'm very dense with the formulas and this comparison helps me to get an idea how to equip Ayato for when I have him (I have 120 saved rolls to date), as well as understand that all damage bonuses ( as normal attacks / charged / Element / damage inflicted) are added at the same point, so the more buff of this type you have with your teammates, the less efficient the shimenawa would be (and without neglecting how said set consumes a lot of energy
pd: sorry for my inglish I'm not native speaker
I think heart of depth stronger, because ultimate deals big damage too
Actually, that 18% ATK 2 piece bonus from the new set or Shimenawa's should give you a little more burst damage. I wasn't lucky enough to get Ayato but it's easy to calculate. I assume you equip elemental goblet.
Edit: true for some weapons, depends one substats, easy for HoD to overtake with a small ATK% buff.
@@tomaszhachula4171 it's easy to get ATK from different sources (Bennett, nobles,pyro resonance.etc) the 15% hydro DMG bonus is really good and hard to get, unless you use kazuha,the hydro DMG bonus is better than ATK%
And if You use a 4 star weapon,the ATK increase won't be much
@@tomaszhachula4171 What about 2 HoD + 2 Noblesse / or 2 Glad + 2 Noblesse / or 2 glad + 2 HoD / for only use 'burst Ayato' (Not a atk normal fan) ?
What about 2 HoD + 2 Noblesse / or 2 Glad + 2 Noblesse / or 2 glad + 2 HoD / for only use 'burst Ayato' (Not a atk normal fan) ?
Very nice video, this is the best artifact comparison video i've seen, even compared to other channels with hundreds of thousands of subs.
I'm using shimenawa hyper carry.
hydro damage bonus or atk is better？
Hydro dmg bonus 👍
Element bonus always better
Good job man. Nice vid and straight to the point
Nice representation. 👍😮
this is the best video for comparison. you did a great job to informed all of us! thank you!
Hoyo really got use doing statistics/probabilities with crit rate and Echoes set.
Sub to this guy, straight forward, no need long talk, just show the main topic, Thank you for the info.
This!
Every content creator should take notes. This is how u do a no bs, straight to the point content.
Thank u dude !✨
Finally. Someone that doesn't rant for 25 minutes and goes straight to the point with comparison sets/weapons. Thanks.
U are a right person with right time with right artifacts with right edit
I NEEDED THIS
THANK YOU SO MUCHH!♥♥
Thanks for your hard work and dedication for making this video. Really helpful 👍
This was really helpful thanks for your time
direct to the point. you saved me from wasting my time looking on other reviews. 👍
alot of work for this good neat overview of intel. great job! SMASHHH LIKE!
Great video! ^^
I wish there was a showcase video of mixed sets as well :o
You sir/ma'am, deserve a sub. Thank you for this video!
Just the video I needed. Straight to the point comparisons. Thank you!! I'll prolly farm the echoes artifact for my ayato and yoi since I really hate the energy drain of SR
one of the best damage comparisons i've ever seen. subscribed
Cuz this dude straight to the point, and this what's I've need, auto like and subs you, cheers mate 🍻
Weed-nim. What weapon that u use for ayato in this video?
much, much appreciated work. thank you!
Thanks for saving me months of effort from grinding the new set, which has honestly been giving me nothing but defense and health rolls.
This is an excellent comparison. Even if the stats aren't exact mirrors of each other (nearly impossible to do) by the laws of average the damage is quite similar.
It seems the Echoes set gives the best results by a small margin. However, if you don't need the other set, it would be more resin efficient to use the other options. Both Hearth of Depth and Shimenawa are farmed in domains where the other set works for more characters, specially the latter with Emblem set. Or if you already have good Gladiator pieces, they work very well too.
I will personally go for the HoD set, as I also have Childe and Ganyu, better artifacts for either one while farming for Ayato is the most efficient use of my resin. I don't like that Shimenawa consumes energy due to Ayato's high burst cost.
its been said but thank you for the dope no bs video. subbed and liked :)
SUBSCRIBED ✅
Your edits to compare the damage is really good
Keep it up ❤️
Because I completely forgot about the new artifacts, I built the shimenawa set with the amenoma sword. If the sword is refined at least once you can counter the energy loss from the set. All you have to do now is make sure your artifacts bring about a good crit rate/dmg ratio and atk% and hp% 😅😭
I have a pretty good set albeit not the best and I was still surprised by how well my ayato does as a sub dps!
Thank you for video. Really helpful!
I already have a solid glad set with like 68 crit and 210 crit damage if we include the weapon. Its nice to know that you can kinda just passively get him the glad set without really wasting any resin, I thought the HoD would have boosted his damage alot with the extra 15 water damage but I'm glad its a little better to have the 18 percent attack from glad instead.
Happy to see how artifact friendly ayato is
Same to me I also got him the glad set instead coz it was easier for me to get and reroll and since I'm unlucky on getting good HoD pcs not even good Blizzard for Ayaka. Lucky enough my Ayato made it to 2k atk 62/220 crit 120 em and I'm happy with it :D
This was helpful. Glad i put him on gladiators. Just the overal best it looks since no energy recharge drawback and the dmg isn’t that dif from shimenawa.
thanks mate!! good comparison with those somehow equally cr cd
Ohh… I might have to do a glad or shim build now for ayato 🤔 this was super helpful!
Never notice Pyro regisvine has different title each time we battle them. They have over 3 different name. The more you notice and know I guess
Finally I can use my Gladiator set that has been sitting in my inventory since AR45
For real, my inner hoarder is so satisfied to finally have a proper use for those amazing double crit Glad pieces I just randomly accumulated from world bosses.
I tried your suggestion but I already farmed Echo set.
Since I don't have his BiS weapon, I used Blacksword with Echo set and the consistency is good.
I literally have the perfect shimenawa set and just waiting for his next banner release on wednesday. Also putting blackcliff long sword on him, kinda excited not gonna lie.
thank you so much for this!!!
What artifact will be the best to get dmg from his skill?
this video is very well made, thank you
This is what I like to see. Subbed!
I think you also have to consider ayato's burst buff to his slashes. when using shimenawa, you will not be able to proc burst that often than when using the other sets.
i thought i was lagging for a sec
11/10 video. Possible for a similar version for the weapon comparison?