NT Wright & Tom Holland • How St Paul changed the world (Full Show)
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 19 июл 2018
- For updates, further episodes & bonus content sign up for the Unbelievable? newsletter www.premier.org.uk/unbelievabl...
Justin Brierley is joined by leading New Testament scholar NT (Tom) Wright and popular historical writer Tom Holland to discuss how the apostle Paul changed the world as described in Wright’s recent book Paul: A Biography.
An agnostic in terms of his religious commitments, Tom Holland has nevertheless described the way that the birth of Christianity has shaped much of what we value in Western society in terms of human rights, culture and rule of law. He engages with NT Wright on the way that Paul and the early Christian movement stood in stark contrast to the prevailing Roman culture of its day.
Subscribe to the Unbelievable? podcast for weekly dialogue and debate www.premierchristianradio.com/...
For updates, more debates and bonus content sign up at www.premier.org.uk/unbelievablenewsletter
Mark Matthew Pace
That is rather PRESUMPTUOUS of you, wouldn’t you agree, Slave?
Presumption is evil because when one is PRESUMPTUOUS one makes a judgement about a matter even though one has insufficient facts to support one’s position.
@Mark Matthew Pace Mate you claims are just words with no evidence to support them. Read and take some history lesson..
Mark Matthew Pace
I regret to inform you, Slave, that your response is INCORRECT. 👎
The CORRECT answer is “Yes, Master”. ✅
Bless You Always, TYPICAL Arrogant Westerner!
@Mark Matthew Pace so I can see that you think Jesus's story was made up and what is the froof to that?? Not from the bible definitely
In portuguese?
It's such a delight watching Tom Wright reacting to all that Holland is saying - he's clearly just so happy to be able to converse with someone who has the same deep appreciation for the proper study of history that he does, not to mention someone who really understands the revolutionary impact that Paul's writings had on the world. His reaction at 13:55 to Holland calling Paul a depth charge is probably my favourite response!
I was having the same thought😄🤗
@@Carol-Vaiphei Isn't written iron sharpeneth iron!
I agree!
No sure about history accuracy, as he seems to get a very basic fact about Paul so very wrong. See Paul as a scribe, not apostle, and second his writing, for the most part, was dealing with local Congregational problems. He was the central figure of early Christianity.
As an American born raised and served as a missionary of holiness, sanctification sector of Evangicalism I appreciation this much more intelligent, scolarly reasonable point of view. Having left Christianity because of the abuse and cruelty of my youth, this discussion opens a door that has been slowly opening as I hear these broader, more reasonable perspective of Christianity.
where is the cruelty and abuse
"......simultaneously, all his life is fulfilled, and all his life is shattered......"
Wow. 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
I enjoyed this discussion for many reasons, but especially because of the kind respectfulness of all 3 men.
I could listen to these guys for another 10 hours. Excellent discussion.
@Matthew Pace who hurt you?
Except that Tom Holland can't speak without stuttering.
@Mark Matthew Pace Nobody cares where you live or how many kids you have. How is that pertinent? And "truth" and "lies" aren't capitalized words.
What was the big take away for you 😏
@@tbillyjoeroth haha
These are profoundly interesting conversations to me as someone newly interested in Christianity after being raised secular. Thank you so much.
Same here. I've read a few books by Tom Holland and Dominion in particular was incredibly eye-opening. I doubt I will ever consider myself a 'believer' in the traditional sense, but recongnising that my atheist humanist values are essential a rebranding of the latest Christian reformation has been utterly fascinating.
I suggest reading philosophy and getting acquainted with history of thinking, philosophy, mythology and storytelling.. also history of archaeology to understand that Christianity and the Bible are in no way first to have done anything really.. there’s been all types of philosophies and mythologies and religions before Christianity and a lot of what has gone into Christianity has been borrowed and carefully collated not only in 1st century, but also all the way throughout the last 2000 years of engineering and refining Christianity (probably less so in the last 200 or so years though.. where things have become much more ‘set in stone’ and less ‘fluid’).. I really do recommend getting to know more about the Sumerian culture, Babylonian culture, Egypt, Ancient Greece and Rome.. and only then do you have any chance to understand the context and the true origin and source and what is and what is not actually ‘Christian’.. I also recommend listening to Bart Erhman.
@@thegoodthebadandtheugly579
Actually being an Unlicensed Non-Certified historian (That sounds better than a history nut :-)) I actually have read, studied that. There are differences though between those pagan myths and Christianity. One being the Christian Myth, to paraphrase Tolkien is a myth that actually happened. It takes place in Time & Space. Over and over in the Gospels/Acts the phrases When someone was ruler, and that place was where this happened.
There is a line from CS Lewis's "Surprised By Joy" that has always stuck with me.
"Early in 1926 the hardest boiled of all the atheists I ever knew sat in my room on the other side of the fire and remarked that the evidence for the historicity of the Gospels was really surprisingly good. "Rum thing," he went on. "All that stuff of Frazer's about the Dying God. Rum thing. It almost looks as if it had really happened once.""
Tray Don’t Say - I am afraid this idea that you have to think outside of the box on a subject and stretch your imagination is proving too much for you…! You re the one who needs to read more outside of your comfort zone… You are hoodwinked and brainwashed - and convinced you know something. You clearly know ONE blinkered side and cling to it like a limpet… I hope you can open up - because you are heading in a benighted direction.
I don’t think that Christianity is humanist , Jesus was a racist Rabbi, his racism lead Paul to establish a new religion for non Jews and shifted the Roman world from worshiping a Roman man to worshiping a Jewish man ( via the same Myths ) while humanitarian Jews stand with Palestinians and they are the strongest supporters of Palestinian rights by Contrast evangelical Christianity universally support the oppression of Palestinians and are the strongest supporters of Zionism yet they claim their values are humanist . this example question such claims .
I sat in the library in Victoria BC reading “Paul”. I’ve been reading for the past week very slowly because I want to grasp what I’m reading. I have learned so much. Thank you. Alan
Current culture is almost always choosing one of three Ancient Societies to romanticize, Egypt, Greece, & Rome. What happens when you romanticize something? You air brush out all those things you hated & highlight the best points. It is the opposite of finding the reality of it.
The reality of all of them is barbaric compared to modern times. Paul was dealing with people you & I would constantly be offended by, & he shows such great ethic, given by Christ. In a world where being different would get you stoned, crucified, beheaded, flayed alive, etc., it is all the more impressive.
Great talk.
Absolutely!
Well said
This is an interesting idea. Do you mind explaining for me in what ways these three cultures are idealised respectively today?
Liam Johnson
Media, Philosophy, & Political believes. Stargate, Percy Jackson, & Harry Potter (to a lesser degree) are all media related things. Also, anything related to Atlantis is from all three. It is a well know set of mythologies, that requires little new material to market.
Philosophically speaking stoicism is making a comeback in pop culture. Of course, the Republic is always worth the read. Any number of other names (most of which I have to look up how to spell) show up. Epicurean philosophy is almost always talked about, but not always in vogue. This, of course, is also intertwined within any media or political discourse using these.
Politics is just clear really. The ideas are through out the political sphere, due to the fact your personal philosophical view informs your actions & morals. That blended with whatever media has influenced you, lays out your political views often. Some people go with their gut, but they say these influence them. A large amount of these ideas are not new, but come from the Rome or Greece. The Republic we live in, the democracy everyone thinks it is, etc..
The epic is brought out, but the history is forgotten. We do this to our detriment. Not to say you should not read the originals, but the pop culture usage glosses over things. Things like a stoic killing himself because he told the Emperor he had deaden himself to that beyond his control. Of course, he told it to a madman & that didn't help either. Still, I could not accept stoicism as a way of life, it does have some good points.
God Bless
mackdmara Very interesting, however I would not say many people, especially of my generation, are stoic in their approach to life; Epicurean, yes, but there is no sense in which millennials realise that they are owed very little. Also, there is very little discipline or self control in them. But you may be referring to some other aspect, or to the intelligentsia?
NT Wright is such an absolute teddybear! 🙂
As the atheist German philosopher Habermas put it a couple of decades ago, all our morality derives from the Hebrew prophets and the New Testament. Everything else is postmodern chatter.
Wow that was so incredible listening to!!! I’ve found a new interest in history after growing up quite ignorant of it. And as a Christian I’m finding out how crucial it is to know your history in order to have an appropriate perspective of the Bible and Christianity as a whole.
It amazes me that so many operate on faith and ignorance - devoid of historical and/or doctrinal contextual knowledge.
@@food4thort everyone operates in some level of ignorance. Faith or no faith. It’s just part of people learning to grow up. Not enough people have had to face reality enough to even be aware that they are ignorant. If someone doesn’t teach them, and they don’t think it’s important enough to look and learn on their own? What are you gonna do?
Can’t make a horse drink water but you can salt his oats and make him thirsty.
@@food4thort I think it has to do with our culture and school system being to comfortable and not grounded enough in reality 😕 no one taught me anything about history or shared stories with me growing up. And frankly I didn’t care about learning. Just getting good enough grades to memorize answers to tests to appease my parents who I didn’t even have a relationship with. It’s all messed up for a lot of people.
@@mamajo5867
But that's trickery, isn't it?
every time you drive your vehicle across a bridge or through a tunnel, you are acting on faith that it is a trustworthy structure, because we haven't met the architects or teams of construction workers and evaluated their fitness and capability for creating such strucutres prior to driving across them or through them. We probably haven't certified that the city has properly audited the structure, either. We just use reasonable evidence of other cars before us passing through unscathed, and take a reasoned gamble that we might be able to also have similar success. The Bible asks no one to put their mind in a waste bin, it asks each person to examine the evidence and make reasonable conclusions.
I Jn 1:1-3 That which was from the beginning, which we have heard, which we have seen with our eyes, which we have looked upon, and our hands have handled, concerning the Word of life- the life was manifested, and we have seen, and bear witness, and declare to you that eternal life which was with the Father and was manifested to us- that which we have seen and heard we declare to you, that you also may have fellowship with us; and truly our fellowship is with the Father and with His Son Jesus Christ.
I'd loved NT Wright's posture was not to convert Tom but to join together in a conversation about how awesome Jesus is to work through Paul. He who is not my enemy is my friend. And through these affirming conversations it is the hope Tom falls in love with what Jesus did for him and there is no debate to him personally that Jesus is Lord.
absolutely!
Jesus is MORE awesome for the poor and the downtrodden, and all those who're helped by religious organisations and who find religion to be a source of comfort.
Only in Calvinism, which is one minority stream on the fringes of Christianity. There are other ways of looking at these questions and resolving the paradoxes.
Austin James I agree! When Paul spoke at Mars Hill he drew the Roman citizens in by finding the common beliefs they shared. When we have hearts for justice, God's salvation is close by.
Interesting to find you on this RUclips comment section Austin. I hope you're doing ok in Lubbock. Cheers.
The anchor is so good at his work and knows so much himself !
Well done !
relaxthenrefresh thanks!
Wright is such a prolific writer and is constantly speaking and lecturing and doing things like this program. And yet he finds time to read - and understand - dozens of books concurrent with all that. Such a mind.
Ghost writers
I love the two “Toms” and I love Paul, too. Fascinating intellectual discussion! Understanding Christianity strictly by the human mind - bypassing the Holy Spirit, the Spirit of Truth’s unveiling of the eyes - would probably be an impossible feat. Aren’t the eyes of the world blinded to this type of deep understanding?
I hope Tom Holland will have a true Homecoming one day :)
You have no idea how much of a pun that is for Marvel fans
@@thatguyk.5306 this guy ...
👍
i get the Spider man reference, but does it also mean the historian in the video is not a Christian? Or considers himself only as a cultural Christian?
@@BibleLosophR correct. At least, that's what was said in the beginning of the discussion in the video
Thanks, a great conversation
Meeting of two sharp, intellectual minds. A rare treat. Thank you.
Hi, Paul VanderKlay sent me here!
And I must say this was a really interesting conversation.
Same!
Yep. Paul sent me here. Great guy. He’s nonstop content, commentary, and critique.
@@Btn1136 he's still at it!!!!
Tom Holland apparently is not a Christian but seems to understand better than most Christians what the cross actually means.
10camels many people do not truly study and analyse what they believe in. Christianity is a key component to understanding the Roman empire and the Middle East both of which Tom Holland has studied in depth. As such it should not be surprising. The great thing about Tom is that he tries and succeeds not to impose his own narrative on his findings. As such, here he sounds very much a Christian because he does not scoff at the beliefs he is discussing.
10camels , Something something “Not everyone who calls me Lord,” something...
Welcome to the 21st century. Christianity is alive and well but working underground.
I was brought up in a fundamentalist home and never felt a thing from the dogmas I was taught....yet listening to him I was both in awe and almost brought to tears at once!
@@gucker07 Right to the target!
That was a fantastic discussion. Like someone else said, I could listen to them talk for another 10hrs.!
Could listen to these two talk for hours.
thank you for this incredible education
listening 3 years later to two great minds. The entire conversation is powerful. NT wright was awakened and wanted to get in on the conversation. 14:24 - 17 mins is so engaging, exciting, loaded with so much truth.
Thanks. Beautiful message
Brilliant conversation. Learned a lot !
"In almost every way I am Christian." Says the agnostic Tom Holland. Wow!
I don't know what to say other than, Praise God! So many things coming together here, faith, reason, history, apologetics, even healthy skepticism, in short a desire to see truth: the New Testament for what it really is, and its main author for who he really is.
A conversation between Wright and Peterson would be amazing!!
As a former Christian, Wright is probably one of the more reasonable and erudite Christians out there. Both he and Peterson are stuck in pretty rigid thinking though, which constrains their intelligence, that's for sure.
That would be an interesting discussion. Wright represents the Historical-Literal, and Peterson the Psychological-Allegorical interpretation of the Bible texts. It would be an interesting wrestling match between Religious and Scientific analysis of the same stories.
William Oarlock
Let me guess, you are the savior of mankind? When is your book coming out?
D Z
How do you judge if someone is “rigid” in their thinking? Wright has been under fire for his views on the atonement, which is pretty orthodox Protestant theology.
Lol to your comment.
What a lovely conversation! This is the best thing I have heard/watched all year.
Justin 1 hour does an injustice to these topics.
The mediation of the conversation is pretty good. He seems to know their interests so well that he can have the answer each others' questions.
What a great conversation! Fantastic! You need to get Tom and Tom back on the show again as soon as you can!
thank you for this thought-provoking dialogue. Loving the dialectic between colleagues.
One of the few talks I don't get tired of listening to again and again - and like Tom Holland, I was quite fascinated by the Greek gods and the Romans. And like him, the story"Quo Vadis?" which I read in childhood, freaked me out when I realised that the Roman world was definitely not one I would have liked to live in.
It is with a lot of reading and studying that I now see Paul as the moulder of the world that I was born in...we are still enjoying the fruits of the civilisation he helped bring to birth - as long as we try to better understand the words he wrote the better we can catch the fire of his vision.
What a delightful, insightful conversation, thank you to you all 😊👍👏👏👏
Thank you Justin, Tom & Tom for this remarkable conversation!
Fascinating discussion… the time flew by!
If only Paul had known the impact he was going to have! I think he had no idea of the scale! Big respect to the man, having endured all the hardship he did and what he ignited!
Just come across this talk...SO refreshing to hear Intelligent and intellectual conversation with two of my favourite people. Just got Paul a biography, and reading through In the shadow of the sword....these guys are simply the best. Thank you for uploading! Thank you Justin for allowing this dialogue to flow so well, you really have got a great balance!
mind blown! Thank you for putting these two men together in one room and letting them speak!
Excellent conversation and Justin, you are simply a top-notch host. Always impressed.
Both of them are brilliant! Tom Holland is a top Historian which requires staying objective and not moralizing or giving his personal opinion. No doubt he right that Christinaity has had a huge influence on Western history even it today secular world when many people are no longer Christians.
excellent. Thank you Justin Brierley. I'm reading Wright's book on Paul now. Good discussion; good pair.
These discussions certainly help me get through work.
This is one of those rare and most excellent conversations. I hope to get everyone to listen to it!
Unbelievable batting 1000. Great show, great guest. Must say, the host is brilliant and perfectly suited to moving guests with excellent questions and insight.
Excellent. I have listened to this post the publication of Tom Holland's Dominion which I have just read. He has become one of my heroes but a huge thank you to both Toms for a stimulating conversation and to Unbelievable for hosting it.
Justin, you've got to do more of this!
Great minds. Thank you so much for clarifying my faith for me.
Excellent conversation!! Both so knowledgeable, generous and civil. Please do this again!
What an excellent conversation.
Imagine having this kind of conversation between N.T. Wright and Dr. W. Lane Craig and/or having all three of them at once. Maaan, that would be gloriously tantalizing.
Great conversation as usual.
This was a easy listen. Very nice.
Thanks
This was one of the most educational conversations I've eavesdropped in on. I have been studying the Bible intensely for nearly 2 decades. Paul's epistles have been a nightmare for me in terms of trying to discern an interpretation within the context of the world in which his epistles were written. However, after watching this, I feel a lot of Paul's teachings will be much clearer. Thank you for this Unbelievable?.
Bazton I agree
@@fraukatze3856 The easy way to interpret Pauls writings is to ask the church that has the original interpretation, the Catholic church
@@eamonnmurphy5385 ....but not The Roman Catholic church 😎
@@1969cmp Paul was a member of the original Church which was the only Christian Church in existence. It went on within maybe 50 years to be known as the Catholic(means Universal) So, Paul was a member (in effect) of the Catholic Church! Why would we not rely on that Church for its interpretation of what Paul's writings say in preference to interpretations of individuals over 1500 years later? They knew him, they understood him. He believed in their beliefs! They passed down these understandings!
@@eamonnmurphy5385 Paul was a member of the original church for which the church governing body was based in Jerusalem.
I'm fine to use the term catholic but more accurate is simply Christian.
The Roman Catholic church has a series of mishaps mostly based on power and poor theology as well as historical revisionism. And this was a problem from early on when the church in Rome was an outpost as most Christians were in the east part of the empire, and as mentioned earlier, the governing authority of the church was the Council in Jerusalem, for which Paul was under.
Now THAT is what I call a Big Conversation. Oh, and yes, Justin, it genuinely was fascinating.
Edit: Not Big, just Unbelievable. My bad. But the discussion was truly interesting.
Thank you.
Thank you for an excellent program.
Excellent program. Thank you.
Great discussion. I have learnt a lot. Thank you.
This is a video to listen to multiple times to really absorb it.
just watching this 5 years later. What a fantastic conversation - I wish I had the opportunity to sit and listen to this in person (I would contribute nothing to the conservation however)! I wonder if I see this a bit differently now that I am watching this after the time that Tom Holland has professed to returning to Christianity and is a believer? Even 5 years ago I saw in the notes he was an agnostic but he seems so excited about Christianity in general. Wonderful.
Great! 😍😍 Truly amazing. Thanks, all!
That was such a great conversation. Could have done with another hour of it.
THIS
A mind to mind meeting. How refreshing!
Wonderful to have such a broad understanding of history that connections are made, and parallels are drawn between Christianity, Liberalism, Desmond Tutu, ISIS, Judaism etc etc. with such ease. And no one gets hot under the collar or 'offended'!
A rare treat.
Tom Holland is wonderful! He sticks to his discipline of history, he sticks to historical explanations, which is fine.
I only wish this was longer. Please do another one!
agree
Great discussion, thanks.
Wow...what an enlightening discussion
One of my favorite interviews by Justin (or ever). I've watched at least 3 times and always surprised how good it is. Excellence from all 3 participants.
Awesome discussion between N T Wright and Tom Holland and Justin Brierley a great host. I have listened to this show 7 times and hung on to every word. Very edifying. Thanks
This conversation is so full of passion and awe. Thank you a million times and more... I really need to read my Bible with dedication again🙌
This hour passed flying. We could hear this two great historians talking for several hours. Please make it happen, and heartfelt thanks for this content.
I clicked because of the name "Tom Holland"....knowing there was a likelihood, it wasnt Spiderman lol
This is an amazing conversation. And Jordan Peterson really really needs to talk with Tom Wright
I've had the same thought. Wouldn't that be an amazing discussion. We can hope.
Nick Vis - Yes Nick, good of you to see this and also mention it. I cringe when I listen to Peterson concerning Christianity. He states early in his "Maps for Meaning" that he just cannot accept the Virgin Birth nor the Resurrection, nor of course understands that a new nature, a new inner creation, a new heart is required and this can only be given by Christ if we see him for what he is!
This comment is now on almost every video. JP is going to have a busy year it seems
....and throw Ravi Zecharias to help JP jump the gap from mythology to history.
@Khalid Ibn Alwaleed I believe he is referring to the content and not the fact that they agree. Not hard to find white Europeans who don't agree with all this though.
Jay Smith mentioned about Tom Holland and his book 'In the Shadow of the Sword'. I ordered right away and reading it now. It is worth and I really admire Tom Holland.
You should buy Holland's "Dominion" as well.
Fantastic discussion, fascinating. Thanks!
Thanks guys!
Really interesting discussion! Thanks for the upload.
I have just finished Wright's SIMPLY CHRISTIAN. It is almost as good as Lewis' Mere christianity. If only he had talked on Satan and his deception , it would have been a great classic.
Thank you, Wright.
We do owe it to Paul ... and to Christianity ... but ultimately to Christ.
This has definitely explained so much of the mindset of the apostle, Paul. A very deep and respective conversation
Awesome conversation. Congratulations. Praise the Lord.
Excellent conversation 👍
"Fruits without the roots." Spot on critique of secular humanism. Once again I am reminded of Chesterton's quote on how Christian virtues have gone mad predicting the "woke" post modern madness we have today. "Love not Hate!" Spits the rebel, or else!
Respectable Agnostic.
This was great! Thank you.
Excellent discussion! Thanks for giving the opportunity to watch such discussions for free!
BEST EPISODE YET! 🙌🏾
Highly intelligent men speaking about a highly intelligent man whose life was changed by his messiah
Great discussion.
That is the true conversation on intelectual level.... it is a hony for my mind and soul....thsnk
This was like Light for me in terms of understanding a lot of things in NT
Unbelievably good. Watched (followed) Tom Holland v AC Grayling on this channel few hours ago. First time I’ve come across this channel.
Totally enjoyed the discussion
Tom is exactly right: the incarnation is a singularity, more than if aliens had landed on the state legislatures of every country, more than the wildest imaginations of people from the dawn of time.
Tom Holland proves Christianity changes societies and makes all more compassionate .Not just devout believers
It is a shame it took 1900 years for the "Compassionate" part to surface.
@@davidfrisken1617 Not sure you have watched the whole video at the time of posting that.
@@davidfrisken1617 yeah... obviously you didnt watch the video.
@@joserangel7346 I stopped at 52:55, so not quite to the end. What did I miss?
@@davidfrisken1617 Acording to your previous post... everything.
What a delight this is.
Very stimulating conversation. Will try and discover more about this Mediaeval meaning of "supernatural". Thank you for posting it.
Facinating conversation...
Love both their work
Justin is a very good interviewer and host.