@@theoneeditor399 close your eyes and listen to it. He is clearly saying bear every time. You hearing other words is the point of the video. Your eyes are tricking you.
That's why when babies learn new words, they focus on mouth movements. If you have kids, try and notice whenever you say a word they've never heard before, they don't bring their ears closer, but their gaze focuses on the lips. For some reason, babies have this intuition about mouth movements.
This must have been insane during covid, babies learning to speak and everyone with face masks! Wonder if that cohort had difficulties or were late speakers because of that?
Mouth starts closed in the first clip. Mouth closed in second clip. If you don't watch the video, only listen, it sounds the same. Super cool, really interesting! TY
4 дня назад+1
Nope. In the second clip the teeth touch the lower lip, that's how we produce the 'f' sound in 'fair'.
I'm not a native English speaker so maybe that's why, but I can swear I hear "there" not "fair" as well. Maybe in my non-English brain I don't hear "fair" as often as "there".
I also heard "vare/vair" instead of "fair" in the second clip. I think that may be our brains' attempt at compromising the audio input ("bear") and the visual input ("fair") since /v/ is phonetically quite similar to both /b/ and /f/
This is a good illustration of how communication is not limited to a single sensory organ. And this provides a clue as to why comments such as this section, and forums where the written word alone is used. That not only can and do miscommunications happen, but we are also missing the emotional context of what is being said. As such there can be only limited, or even no emotional empathy happening between conversing parties. So toxicity can flourish since our innate affective empathy isn't triggered the same way as it would be in person.
@@itoibo4208 Exactly. One thing many people are unaware of is that there are in fact three types of empathy, cognitive, affective(emotional), and somatic. Most people who I've spoken with, only think of the cognitive version, being able to put yourself in another person's perspective.
Yeah, for the 2nd clip, I heard there & vair (not a word, but for some reason I got the v sound probably from lip-reading the f as a v). Edit: I'm not deaf, but I can read lips a little.
@@girlofanimation I wondered what a deaf person would think because of 'forcing', where an idea is put into your head (which is what I thought the clip would be about...)
I don't see why would you be curious what a lip reader would think, because it's not like he's saying the same thing but with different mouth movements- he's saying different things, but the same audio is playing for both. A deaf person would have no idea of that. They would see that he's saying different things so say that he's saying different things. (the fact that different audio is playing is totally irrelevant)
@MsHojat Do you lip read? Do you rely exclusively on lip reading to communicate? Perhaps it means 'nothing', that is, without context, the lip patterns are ambiguous or garbled. That is, imagine talking on a VERY bad phone line. You can 'fill in the gaps'. Tl;dr - context matters.
Exactly. And if you notice, they're not the same clip. The second one his bottom lip touches his upper teeth where the first one, his lips touch. I call bs.
I often feel much more grounded when calling because I'm in my own space. But in general I experience nuances more in tone than in visual info. My brain's visual ability is kinda crap 😅
@brucedabetta I loved it while everyone hated it 🙈 It was really nice to me that facial expressions couldn't conflict with the truth you can see in the eyes anymore. And it felt comfortable to feel less exposed in public. (Yeah social anxieties)
I hate the drag of going into an office but I begrudgingly admit that it makes meetings and working sessions a *bit* easier due to seeing body language along with spoken word. I also hate having to turn cameras on during work calls but when I do, I also admit I can follow the discussion slightly more quickly because I can see mouth movements and facial expressions. The benefit to me isn’t enough to justify forcing everyone to return to an office full time or mandating cameras on, but I can see the usefulness from time to time.
I saw the circles bouncing off each other before the sound was introduced. I didn't even consider the idea of them passing through each other until you mentioned it...
This is a great independent example of why people who are losing their hearing struggle to hear conversations if they can’t see who’s speaking to them. And that habit, or tool, kind of becomes heavily relied upon before the individual even realizes they’re suffering from any hearing loss. For instance if you’re having a phone conversation, you can’t see the speaker, and get frustrated speaking on the phone so begin avoiding answering and replying by text. Or if you’re speaking with someone, but maybe don’t have your glasses on and suddenly are very confused while having the conversation because you took your glasses off, how is that effecting your hearing? Another reason why it’s important to notice these kinds of things in our friends, family and acquaintances- because they may not even see the correlation. They may just begin getting frustrated and start withdrawing rather than asking “huh” all the time (especially if they were heavily reinforced to not say “huh”!) or trying to interpret the muffled conversation.
or worse when you are working with your second language and you feel responsible when people in meeting turn off video and you think oh my good my listening skill is so bad but if they just turn on the video you are able to understand!
@@jrxsayyIts not wasted time if the comment is helpful or informative, I really enjoyed this comment because I relate to what he is talking about, so now I understand a bit more about myself and this struggle of hearing others correctly!
Then, close your eyes and you'll hear the same sound. It's called phonetics. If you're only 15 years old, perhaps you need more pronunciation practice.
Same. In one of his recent videos it started with some tones and that one didn’t fool me either. The ball bouncing one in this clip does work for me though.
My wife is a lip reader due to being profoundly deaf in her left ear. The words and mouths not being in sync on the TV makes her absolutely crazy. She can tell when they’ve changed what someone is saying in editing every time. It is her super power.
@@Apollo-ComputersI can’t watch foreign films or tv that have been dubbed for the same reason. Makes it feel cheap and nasty, ruins the immersion. Subtitles are better. My wife disagrees. We don’t watch much foreign stuff now!
I anaylized the "two" soundclips, and they are indeed congruent. And I was ABSOUTELY sure, that I heard "there" while watching. Wow, what an amazing vid!! 1000 thumbs up.
@@jvc776 Yes, they are homophones (pronounced the same way). I heard "there" and can't hear "fair". "F" is a voiceless consonant and I can clearly hear that the word he is pronouncing starts with a voiced consonant.
Ventriloquists commonly substitute consonants to avoid mouth movement. For example, "N" is frequently substituted for "M". Also, "D" is substituted for "B".
However, turn sound off and look at it and you wonder if the veneers are too white, watch it a second time you’ll begin to wonder if you should invest in some veneers
This is the crazier thing. We all saw the same thing, but you and I saw something different. How many times does this happen every single day and we don't know it?
The craziest thing is the content creator is not giving any response to the balls bouncing thing, even though he cherry picked it out of a long form video to include in a short.
Because in reality you only have one sense, all of your senses are just your brain interpreting signals sent from the organ responsible for that sense So it's only natural that 1 sense would effect others since it's your brain interpreting both at the same time
@@mariusg8824I would say the exact opposite actually. Our senses our extremely powerful and sensitive which is why you hear a different word in the clip justbased on the look of his lips.
@@strangeclouds7 But that's not your senses, it's your brain. The brain can't figure out what the ears tell it, so switches its interpretation depending on what the eyes tell it. It wouldn't do that if the ears would deliver precise information.
I closed my eyes and just listened. I heard the narrator alternating between "bear" and "there". This was true for all the different presentations of the sounds within the one video.
@@parasnipermore There's definitely a difference is what's being said. No doubt that what you hear with eyes open depends on action of the mouth, but the complete video definitely has a hidden trick in it, making it invalid to some extent.
I have often wondered how big a component this is in learning a new language. Even when you know the language relatively well it's still often difficult to differentiate certain sounds from native speakers. And I have always wondered if thats because we can't map the visual queues as well as we can in our nother language. This may be part of why immersion works so well.
Wow, that's really cool. Goes to show that "hearing" is not just "hearing", but how we also rely on visual information. Probably another reason (together with the lower sound quality, of course) why it's harder to make out what someone's saying over the telephone.
I can focus on two distinct things with separate senses, so I could read his mouth movements while he mouthed "fair" and knew he was saying that, but could also still recognize without hesitation that the audio didn't match up and he was still *speaking* the word "bear"
As soon as you asked, “What am I saying in this clip?” I immediately closed my eyes so I could focus on the audio alone. XD You’ll have to get up earlier in the morning to bamboozle ME! Your measly attempt at trickery has been thwarted! Muah ha ha ha haaa!
No, you weren't calling the bluff, you didn't follow the instructions he gave. He asked "What am I saying in THIS CLIP", that's the important keyword which he is implying a video for you to watch. He didn't say "What do you hear?", instead he put that on the title on top of his head as it requires us to read(while we are watching). The point is to be able to hear the same word on both CLIP without getting tricked by your own vision. He didn't trick anybody, it was a test to see how our brain accepts and reacts to the perception coming from multiple sensory organs. Since you only receive an auditory perception, you're not testing your brain capabilities, and even so, you have already failed at it(listening to the very first instruction) 😂 Muah haha haa
@@naz6james570 Yeah, I know. I communicated what I actually did, but then I exaggerated my own reaction to what happened, thinking everyone would obviously know the video wasn’t trying to trick me, and I was laughing at myself for “failing” at such a simple thing. But thanks for explaining.
For me it's the opposite with the yellow balls, I saw them bouncing off from the beginning and never saw them going through each other 😅 An with the first one I got "there" instead of "fair". It's so fascinating how it differs. Makes me wonder how often we humans perceive reality differently in everyday-life 😅
Context is a very important facet of communication. Remove the ability to see someone's face when talking for instance, and we lose a lot of that. This is more or less the same idea, and how I assume a lot of illusions function.
Covid masks were so terrible! I speak with a lot of seniors and we all read lips along with listening. Couldn't converse at all 😷 glad to be past that🙏
I only heard bear and only saw the circles pass through each other. sure, the sound plays, but you can still clearly see them overlapping which wouldn't happen if they were bouncing off each other.
Oh, wow. You revealed my blindspot, most of the time I am subconsciously looking at the lips (or moustache) of people when they are talking to me. While Body language experts say look above the neck to forehead. The CIA says look at the triangle formed between eyes and lips. my spouse often complains and says you don't look in my eyes and talk, now I know why?
🇵🇭 I heard "pear" with an unaspirated 'p' in the first clip and "fair" in the second clip but only with a non-emphasized 'f' sound that is somewhere between the 'f' sound and the 'p' sound. By the way, I am a non-native or non-first-language English speaker from the southwestern Philippines, and Chavacano (specifically Chavacano Zamboangueño / Chavacano de Zamboanga / Zamboangueño Chavacano) is my native or first language, aka mother tongue, while Filipino, and/or also consequentially Tagalog to some extent, is my second language together with English, although English could be chronologically my third or fourth language, if Filipino and Tagalog are collectively my second language or independently my second and third languages, respectively, because Filipino and Tagalog are nationally, officially, institutionally, contextually, functionally, usage-wise, academically or educationally, political linguistically and sociolinguistically two languages, ... ... with Filipino as the official or officialized, more but not exclusively official or officialized and more but not exclusively formal or formalized, standardized, codified, linguistically inclusive, linguistically expanded, intentionally or deliberately designed and redesigned, institutional and institutionally developed and redeveloped, systematic and systematized, organized, ever-changing, quickly evolving, linguistic developmentally and evolutionary guided, adaptable, flexible, versatile, urban or urbanized, metropolitan, modern or modernized, global or globalized / international or internationalized, multilingual-based or multi-language-based, academically or educationally and scholarly studied and learned and researched, nationwide, worldwide, nationally and globally or internationally widespread, technically popular, technically mainstream, and intellectualized language and lingua franca or common/link/bridge language than Tagalog, while Tagalog is still Filipino's core or nucleus language, as well as Filipino's de facto, historically and traditionally official, institutional and linguistic or language basis, among all of the other languages of the Philippines and significant, important and influential foreign languages, and on the other hand, ... ... Tagalog is the archaic, ancient, more ethnic-specific or ethnolinguistic-specific, pre-colonial to post-colonial, pre-Westernized to post-Westernized, and more but not exclusively historical, traditional, informal, familiar, casual, common, conversational, colloquial, indigenous or autochthonous, puristic, rural, local, municipal, provincial, and regional language than Filipino, but also archaicly, anciently, historically, socially, politically, linguistically, culturally, literary, administratively, locally, domestically, regionally, nationally and religiously significant and important language, even more than the other languages of the Philippines.
@aurelspecker6740 I know what you mean. I almost thought there was a graphical glitch or something. I heard "bear" but the lips were off. I guess my brain thought it was bad dubbing.
@@theeverythingstuff My focus on his teeth was on a second watch. On first watch it was on what he was actually saying. It's not weird considering the majority of the video is zoomed in on his mouth.
He never said it didn't. He just said that seeing different lips movements can make you hear different sounds so he put the 2 videos side by side to demonstrate it.
Both clips sounded exactly the same to me. Which is probably because, having living my whole life with sight loss, I’ve never been able to read lips, I can’t see facial expressions when looking at people, so I’ve always just listened for the sounds.
Bro said "bear" 🐻 followed by"deer" 🦌, then "dear" 😊, then told us that we heard "fair" ⚖️, then guilt tripped us by saying he said "beer" 🍺 "there"👉 all this time. 🍻 Cheers all! 😂
@@belushipumpkinthe brain automatically replaces words to read faster... for common sentences that is... for example "weird" i interpreted it as "wired" my brain automatically corrects it
The only thing I'm not keen on is how softly you pronounced the B sound. It's funny though, because before knowing what this was about, I closed my eyes when you asked me to listen, because I know it's easier to concentrate on sound with your eyes closed, so instinctively closed mine when asked to listen carefully. I think it's why we (musicians) close our eyes when really getting into a playing a piece/part on an instrument.
When I first watched, I knew the effect was, so I had my eyes closed for the entire "Bear-Fair" segment. I heard "bear" the entire time when I wasn't looking, but did hear "fair" on my second watch during that segment
![Noob To Max With DRAGON REWORK In Blox Fruits [FULL MOVIE]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/LnBMOinoOvA/mqdefault.jpg)
Am I the only one that heard "there" at second clip?
Me too, to me the balls were also already bouncing because of the context of grass given by the background
Nuh-uh
noh
Me too 😅
Same
The second one sounded like the mix of "bear" and "there".
Bear and fair for me
I heard “bvere”. My eyes and ears couldn’t agree and I guess my brain just decided to roll with it
@@theoneeditor399 close your eyes and listen to it. He is clearly saying bear every time. You hearing other words is the point of the video. Your eyes are tricking you.
@@theoneeditor399 close your eyes and listen. It's bear every time.
Bvthere
That's why when babies learn new words, they focus on mouth movements. If you have kids, try and notice whenever you say a word they've never heard before, they don't bring their ears closer, but their gaze focuses on the lips. For some reason, babies have this intuition about mouth movements.
This must have been insane during covid, babies learning to speak and everyone with face masks! Wonder if that cohort had difficulties or were late speakers because of that?
@@MadofaA I think it’s proven 👍🏻 Nobody was listening back then, there were warnings
@@MadofaAyes children in this period were generally delayed in speech for this reason and many warned about it
@@MadofaAYou know you didn't have to wear the mask at home, it was only intended for when you went out among people you didn't live with.
For some reason? Lol
Mouth starts closed in the first clip. Mouth closed in second clip. If you don't watch the video, only listen, it sounds the same. Super cool, really interesting! TY
Nope. In the second clip the teeth touch the lower lip, that's how we produce the 'f' sound in 'fair'.
I'm not a native English speaker so maybe that's why, but I can swear I hear "there" not "fair" as well. Maybe in my non-English brain I don't hear "fair" as often as "there".
same
Same
Same for me, english is my second language and I also heard „there“
I heard "there" and I'm a native English speaker.
same here ("there")
"thaw thaw thaw"
- michael vsauce
W reference
Omg I was thinking that the whole time
That's what I was thinking. 😂
Fish
Love u so much for that reference
I heard “Vare”. This explains why I, when I was very young, thought “volleyball” was “bolleyball”.
Same here, on both accounts
I also heard "vare/vair" instead of "fair" in the second clip. I think that may be our brains' attempt at compromising the audio input ("bear") and the visual input ("fair") since /v/ is phonetically quite similar to both /b/ and /f/
V-b interchange is quite common in language evolution if I recall correctly
It isn't??💀💀
Same!
This channel never ceases to amaze me!
It does cease to amaze me though.
This is how audiophiles get scammed into buying $5000 power cables
LMAO
lmao dude don't expose me like that
Rude, calling us out like that
😂😂😂
I never thought I would see this comment after not being in the headphone space for many years lol.
“What do you hear?”
“Bear”
“What do you hear NOW?”
“…bear”
Me too
Being blind has its upsides😃
I actually heard both😅
I heard vear
Be too
Lol, I heard "vare" in the second clip and now I'm wondering how this would work with different accents.
I HEARD THIS TOO (I’m American, midwest)
I'm east Mid-east coast and heard vare
I was hearing Vare too
"Fair" and "Vare" have practically exactly the same lip movement, so it's all about your ears in this case.
I also heard vare. The f sound is very rare in my language while v is common.
This explains 30 years of miscomms I had with my wife. I never look at her face when she's complaining. 😂
I honestly saw the balls bounching off each other even without the sound the first time
Yea I came here to make sure I wasn’t the only one 😎🤙
Me too
I saw them go through even with the sound lol
Same.
@@tikket10 yep me too, this one didn’t work on me. I don’t suppose you’re autistic?
As a native german speaker I hear „bear“ at both clips
I’m a native czech speaker and I can only hear “bear”, too.
I am Polish and I heard bear, only later I heard there
Same as a Polish native speaker.
Same. German hete too lol@@rejndbo5706
Native spanish speak bear for both
Absolutely not "FAIR" but there!
yeah !
Derek is tripping
I heard "vare" because it looks like he's making a "v" sound with his mouth.
I am starting to really dig this channel. The content also makes me really attracted to this guy. He has smiling eyes.
This is a good illustration of how communication is not limited to a single sensory organ. And this provides a clue as to why comments such as this section, and forums where the written word alone is used. That not only can and do miscommunications happen, but we are also missing the emotional context of what is being said. As such there can be only limited, or even no emotional empathy happening between conversing parties. So toxicity can flourish since our innate affective empathy isn't triggered the same way as it would be in person.
I have fine empathy via text, but I get the point that the senses work together to give an enriched version of communication.
@@itoibo4208
Exactly. One thing many people are unaware of is that there are in fact three types of empathy, cognitive, affective(emotional), and somatic. Most people who I've spoken with, only think of the cognitive version, being able to put yourself in another person's perspective.
Ok but there's no reason to be yelling at me.
Well this trick wont work with complete sentence
I’m hearing impaired so I don’t really know what he was saying.
"Bear" and "there" for me.
I'd be intrigued what a deaf person lip reading thinks...
Yeah, for the 2nd clip, I heard there & vair (not a word, but for some reason I got the v sound probably from lip-reading the f as a v).
Edit: I'm not deaf, but I can read lips a little.
@@girlofanimation
I wondered what a deaf person would think because of 'forcing', where an idea is put into your head (which is what I thought the clip would be about...)
Same
I don't see why would you be curious what a lip reader would think, because it's not like he's saying the same thing but with different mouth movements- he's saying different things, but the same audio is playing for both. A deaf person would have no idea of that. They would see that he's saying different things so say that he's saying different things. (the fact that different audio is playing is totally irrelevant)
@MsHojat
Do you lip read?
Do you rely exclusively on lip reading to communicate?
Perhaps it means 'nothing', that is, without context, the lip patterns are ambiguous or garbled.
That is, imagine talking on a VERY bad phone line. You can 'fill in the gaps'.
Tl;dr - context matters.
First time: Bear
Second time: Bear, There, Vere.
Never fair tho.
I only heard "vare" with the second one myself
@@saltiestsiren thank you... if you look away from the clip and just listen, this is exactly what he says.
I heard bear...I had the phone planted against my ear because I'm in a loud area. So I didn't see the mouth at all 😂😂
Exactly. And if you notice, they're not the same clip. The second one his bottom lip touches his upper teeth where the first one, his lips touch. I call bs.
@@AnthonyWariner I think that was the point bro, he said the only thing that changed was the mouth movement
This has a great affect on learning new languages, especially the mandarin I had much trouble with while living in China. Great illustration, thanks!
And that's why I hate phone calls! It's so helpful to actually see people speak!
Also why I hated masks during Covid
@@brucedabetta Everyone walked around sounding like Kenny from South Park.
I often feel much more grounded when calling because I'm in my own space.
But in general I experience nuances more in tone than in visual info. My brain's visual ability is kinda crap 😅
@brucedabetta I loved it while everyone hated it 🙈
It was really nice to me that facial expressions couldn't conflict with the truth you can see in the eyes anymore.
And it felt comfortable to feel less exposed in public. (Yeah social anxieties)
I hate the drag of going into an office but I begrudgingly admit that it makes meetings and working sessions a *bit* easier due to seeing body language along with spoken word. I also hate having to turn cameras on during work calls but when I do, I also admit I can follow the discussion slightly more quickly because I can see mouth movements and facial expressions. The benefit to me isn’t enough to justify forcing everyone to return to an office full time or mandating cameras on, but I can see the usefulness from time to time.
I saw the circles bouncing off each other before the sound was introduced. I didn't even consider the idea of them passing through each other until you mentioned it...
Same 😢
same here! we are geniuses!
Same I immediately thought they went to the middle and "bounced" off each other. Or rather went in the opposite direction
Me too❤
Its not genius its too many (old 2d) computer games 😅 I had it too
This is a great independent example of why people who are losing their hearing struggle to hear conversations if they can’t see who’s speaking to them. And that habit, or tool, kind of becomes heavily relied upon before the individual even realizes they’re suffering from any hearing loss. For instance if you’re having a phone conversation, you can’t see the speaker, and get frustrated speaking on the phone so begin avoiding answering and replying by text. Or if you’re speaking with someone, but maybe don’t have your glasses on and suddenly are very confused while having the conversation because you took your glasses off, how is that effecting your hearing? Another reason why it’s important to notice these kinds of things in our friends, family and acquaintances- because they may not even see the correlation. They may just begin getting frustrated and start withdrawing rather than asking “huh” all the time (especially if they were heavily reinforced to not say “huh”!) or trying to interpret the muffled conversation.
Did bro actually waste his time writing this 💀 chill
or worse when you are working with your second language and you feel responsible when people in meeting turn off video and you think oh my good my listening skill is so bad but if they just turn on the video you are able to understand!
@@jrxsayy You are a walking red flag dude!
@@jrxsayyIts not wasted time if the comment is helpful or informative, I really enjoyed this comment because I relate to what he is talking about, so now I understand a bit more about myself and this struggle of hearing others correctly!
I looked away before the 2nd clip played, and heard “there”. Was hella confused when you said fair. This was on 1st watch.
As an English teacher of 15 years, and someone who teaches this exact thing - it's great to see a science + incredibly smart guy back up what i teach.
Then, close your eyes and you'll hear the same sound. It's called phonetics. If you're only 15 years old, perhaps you need more pronunciation practice.
@@wly725 uhh i think you replied to the wrong comment there mate
Am I the only one who just hears bear both times?
Same. In one of his recent videos it started with some tones and that one didn’t fool me either. The ball bouncing one in this clip does work for me though.
Ye me too
i did hear bear both times i guess it didn't work
Same
Then all of you guys eyes have gone bad
Now we need Vsauce to remake this short but more unhinged
Vsauce made a very similar video before including the words "faw" and "thaw" using the same trick
He already did
He have before him with fa fa fa and tha tha tha
Did listen without watching and immediately heard you said the same thing ✌️
My wife is a lip reader due to being profoundly deaf in her left ear. The words and mouths not being in sync on the TV makes her absolutely crazy. She can tell when they’ve changed what someone is saying in editing every time. It is her super power.
I'm not hard of hearing, well a little in one ear. But that drives me insane as well. To the point I can't watch it.
@@Apollo-ComputersI can’t watch foreign films or tv that have been dubbed for the same reason. Makes it feel cheap and nasty, ruins the immersion. Subtitles are better. My wife disagrees. We don’t watch much foreign stuff now!
I'd be curious how she interprets this video.
No one asked lil bro
@@TurdBoi666 Beta behaviour
I can't be the only one who saw the two orange balls bouncing against each other even without the sound
Same here ;)
Same
I can't see the bouncing even with the sound ... I watched it 3 times already
Me too
Same
I anaylized the "two" soundclips, and they are indeed congruent. And I was ABSOUTELY sure, that I heard "there" while watching. Wow, what an amazing vid!! 1000 thumbs up.
At the first time, I heard these two words without seeing his lips and then he told about this fact.
I always loved how this works. The brain using audio and visuals to try to decipher what’s happening in the moment or in screen
"what am i saying in this clip?"
"bear"
"what now?"
"there"
😭
SAME😂
Are you British? If so, you're pronouncing th the same as v and f.
I hear "bear" at both clips and the sound doesn't change the ball passing through each other for me.
Your so cool
Wooo o wish i was as cool as you
@@antmydude236 i know
@@ROUGE28 one day
You have severe brain damage
Wow, cheers. Just when I thought I couldn't trust my brain any less.
I heard "their" in the second 😢 but after you said it was "fair" i can't unhear it
Please… It was clear he said ‘there’
@@destroytheboxes their and there have exactly the same sound for me.
@@jvc776 Yes, they are homophones (pronounced the same way). I heard "there" and can't hear "fair". "F" is a voiceless consonant and I can clearly hear that the word he is pronouncing starts with a voiced consonant.
I can't hear fair 😢
me too! lol
This is the reason we sometimes close our eyes to hear better.
Ventriloquists commonly substitute consonants to avoid mouth movement. For example, "N" is frequently substituted for "M". Also, "D" is substituted for "B".
Okay, now i want everyone listen to champion league soundtrack with your own lyrics
Heard "bear" in both clips because I'm an introverted dumbass and can't read faces.
Same
Same 😭
Yeh me too
Same
same
The balls bounced off each other before you played the clack sound.
That's what I saw too. I saw them bouncing off each other without the sound and before he mentioned it
Yeah same. I can't see them any other way even after a few times of trying
That's what I saw with no sound.
maybe because you just assumed there is a sound (did the same i guess)
Your audio equipment has some delay, are you using bluetooth?
Just close your eyes and listen it both are just same.... Fantastic man
However, turn sound off and look at it and you wonder if the veneers are too white, watch it a second time you’ll begin to wonder if you should invest in some veneers
A lot of times when people talk to me I wear my glasses to hear better, I always thought this was weird, glad to know there is actually a difference.
I heard “bear” on both of them
i bet you arent native
@@drcookie5492 i am not, but i fall for that too lol. Brain is silly.
Same bear
it only affect english spoken person.
if english is not your native language.
both of them will be heared same = "BEAR"
Guys there are a lot of people in this comment section who are native and said they only heard “bear”
This was very confusing at first because I wasn't looking at my phone. Then you said 'mouth movements' and that made me chuckle.
It works if you watch too, because it's bear both times.
People who hear different things based on unrelated video have a massive problem.
@SMthegamer1
I mean, it was confusing because I heard bear both times, and he hadn’t explained it was based on mouth movements first.
@@SMthegamer1 It's two different clips. In one his lips are touching, in the other his teeth and bottom lip are touching
@@theflamingeagle572 Yes, but the same audio was used for both.
They literally tell you this in the video.
I saw the balls bouncing off each other before he played the sound
Same sbh I didn't think they'd phase through
This is the crazier thing. We all saw the same thing, but you and I saw something different.
How many times does this happen every single day and we don't know it?
Same
And then they passed theough each other when he played the sound to me
The craziest thing is the content creator is not giving any response to the balls bouncing thing, even though he cherry picked it out of a long form video to include in a short.
It both sounded like bear.
This has always seemed quite peculiar to me how our body heavily relies on sight to interpret other senses
Because all our senses are crap, and the brain requires to merge all available information to make any sense of the environment.
Cool
Because in reality you only have one sense, all of your senses are just your brain interpreting signals sent from the organ responsible for that sense
So it's only natural that 1 sense would effect others since it's your brain interpreting both at the same time
@@mariusg8824I would say the exact opposite actually. Our senses our extremely powerful and sensitive which is why you hear a different word in the clip justbased on the look of his lips.
@@strangeclouds7 But that's not your senses, it's your brain. The brain can't figure out what the ears tell it, so switches its interpretation depending on what the eyes tell it. It wouldn't do that if the ears would deliver precise information.
• I heard "there" in the second sample.
• The balls bounced without sound in my perception.
I closed my eyes and just listened. I heard the narrator alternating between "bear" and "there". This was true for all the different presentations of the sounds within the one video.
Yeah I wasn’t watching either and I heard bear and there 😂 but while English is my native language I’m not American so maybe it’s his pronunciation 😁
@@parasnipermore There's definitely a difference is what's being said. No doubt that what you hear with eyes open depends on action of the mouth, but the complete video definitely has a hidden trick in it, making it invalid to some extent.
Don't hear that
Not for me. I heard bear both times with my eyes closed. As soon as I saw his lips form the fffff it changes to fair
It's bear both times with your eyes closed, it's the same sound clip lol
"bear,bear,bear"
"fair,fair,fair"
"fair,bear,fair,bear,fair, bear"
"What You See Is What You Get" just gained a whole new different meaning...
I closed my eyes and still heard 'there" in both the second clips.
✅
I heard "bear" both times, but I didn't watch the mouth 😂
I said bear but with the footage on reverse ahah
sticking my ear to the speaker
I have often wondered how big a component this is in learning a new language. Even when you know the language relatively well it's still often difficult to differentiate certain sounds from native speakers. And I have always wondered if thats because we can't map the visual queues as well as we can in our nother language. This may be part of why immersion works so well.
He is in fact saying "Vair" in both examples.
Maybe if you are a native Spanish speaker. Sounds clearly "bear" to me with my eyes closed.
Same here. I wonder if our brains just automatically think of them as physical objects, and thus expect them to collides and recoil.
Whats funny is i was looking away anyway when you said the second one and just heard 'bear' twice 😂
"Perception is reality"
He is slowly awakening his inner Vsauce now 😯
Gotta name the McGurk Effect when you share it
Thank god someone said it. I was digging through the comments for it
@@qiai5447same here
Absolutely one of my favourite channels 🎸😊
The sound of the ball is EXACTLY the sound I imagined it would be
Wow, that's really cool. Goes to show that "hearing" is not just "hearing", but how we also rely on visual information. Probably another reason (together with the lower sound quality, of course) why it's harder to make out what someone's saying over the telephone.
That just proved that nothing is real. Reality depends on perception, change your perspective , you change reality.
I can focus on two distinct things with separate senses, so I could read his mouth movements while he mouthed "fair" and knew he was saying that, but could also still recognize without hesitation that the audio didn't match up and he was still *speaking* the word "bear"
As a non native English speaker, this clip actually makes me proud on myself 😊
I find it interesting, hearing "bear" both times, as non native speaker. I don't have that mouth patterns recognition
Me trying to outsmart the system got outsmarted myself 🤦
As soon as you asked, “What am I saying in this clip?” I immediately closed my eyes so I could focus on the audio alone. XD
You’ll have to get up earlier in the morning to bamboozle ME! Your measly attempt at trickery has been thwarted! Muah ha ha ha haaa!
No, you weren't calling the bluff, you didn't follow the instructions he gave. He asked "What am I saying in THIS CLIP", that's the important keyword which he is implying a video for you to watch. He didn't say "What do you hear?", instead he put that on the title on top of his head as it requires us to read(while we are watching).
The point is to be able to hear the same word on both CLIP without getting tricked by your own vision. He didn't trick anybody, it was a test to see how our brain accepts and reacts to the perception coming from multiple sensory organs. Since you only receive an auditory perception, you're not testing your brain capabilities, and even so, you have already failed at it(listening to the very first instruction) 😂 Muah haha haa
Bro this isn’t a trick it’s an experiment
@@naz6james570 Yeah, I know.
I communicated what I actually did, but then I exaggerated my own reaction to what happened, thinking everyone would obviously know the video wasn’t trying to trick me, and I was laughing at myself for “failing” at such a simple thing.
But thanks for explaining.
@BebPlays See above.
Closed my eyes both times because I knew you were trying to trick me.
The first one was crazy but the second one didn't work. They always seemed to go through each other. A bounce would look *completely* different
this
For me it's the opposite with the yellow balls, I saw them bouncing off from the beginning and never saw them going through each other 😅
An with the first one I got "there" instead of "fair".
It's so fascinating how it differs. Makes me wonder how often we humans perceive reality differently in everyday-life 😅
Veritasium : Successful human experiment
Vsauce : gone wrong
Me knowing it’s gonna be one of those “What do you hear?” Vids with a twist so I just looked away from the screen
I actually thought the balls collided when there wasn’t any sound!
Context is a very important facet of communication. Remove the ability to see someone's face when talking for instance, and we lose a lot of that. This is more or less the same idea, and how I assume a lot of illusions function.
Covid masks were so terrible! I speak with a lot of seniors and we all read lips along with listening. Couldn't converse at all 😷 glad to be past that🙏
I only heard bear and only saw the circles pass through each other. sure, the sound plays, but you can still clearly see them overlapping which wouldn't happen if they were bouncing off each other.
They don't overlap. In fact, I only saw them bouncing.
I just heard
"Waxed lightly weathered cut copper stair"
I heard the one that Phoenix SC made
"A waterlogged waxed slightly weathered chiseled grated bulbed trapdoor" or something just watch the video
@@MortisGod_FS Yeah I watched that one
(26 Likes no way)
Oh, wow. You revealed my blindspot, most of the time I am subconsciously looking at the lips (or moustache) of people when they are talking to me. While Body language experts say look above the neck to forehead. The CIA says look at the triangle formed between eyes and lips. my spouse often complains and says you don't look in my eyes and talk, now I know why?
🇵🇭 I heard "pear" with an unaspirated 'p' in the first clip and "fair" in the second clip but only with a non-emphasized 'f' sound that is somewhere between the 'f' sound and the 'p' sound.
By the way, I am a non-native or non-first-language English speaker from the southwestern Philippines, and Chavacano (specifically Chavacano Zamboangueño / Chavacano de Zamboanga / Zamboangueño Chavacano) is my native or first language, aka mother tongue, while Filipino, and/or also consequentially Tagalog to some extent, is my second language together with English, although English could be chronologically my third or fourth language, if Filipino and Tagalog are collectively my second language or independently my second and third languages, respectively, because Filipino and Tagalog are nationally, officially, institutionally, contextually, functionally, usage-wise, academically or educationally, political linguistically and sociolinguistically two languages, ...
... with Filipino as the official or officialized, more but not exclusively official or officialized and more but not exclusively formal or formalized, standardized, codified, linguistically inclusive, linguistically expanded, intentionally or deliberately designed and redesigned, institutional and institutionally developed and redeveloped, systematic and systematized, organized, ever-changing, quickly evolving, linguistic developmentally and evolutionary guided, adaptable, flexible, versatile, urban or urbanized, metropolitan, modern or modernized, global or globalized / international or internationalized, multilingual-based or multi-language-based, academically or educationally and scholarly studied and learned and researched, nationwide, worldwide, nationally and globally or internationally widespread, technically popular, technically mainstream, and intellectualized language and lingua franca or common/link/bridge language than Tagalog, while Tagalog is still Filipino's core or nucleus language, as well as Filipino's de facto, historically and traditionally official, institutional and linguistic or language basis, among all of the other languages of the Philippines and significant, important and influential foreign languages, and on the other hand, ...
... Tagalog is the archaic, ancient, more ethnic-specific or ethnolinguistic-specific, pre-colonial to post-colonial, pre-Westernized to post-Westernized, and more but not exclusively historical, traditional, informal, familiar, casual, common, conversational, colloquial, indigenous or autochthonous, puristic, rural, local, municipal, provincial, and regional language than Filipino, but also archaicly, anciently, historically, socially, politically, linguistically, culturally, literary, administratively, locally, domestically, regionally, nationally and religiously significant and important language, even more than the other languages of the Philippines.
Bear and their
“There” more like it
It's clearly "They're"
Pair and dear
@@WanderingExistence nuh-uh, it's clearly there're
Bare and fare?
I always hear bear for some reason
yea
me too. However, in the second clip, the mouth looked kinda off. Like in a bad synchronized movie. (Americans might not know how that looks)
@aurelspecker6740 I know what you mean. I almost thought there was a graphical glitch or something. I heard "bear" but the lips were off.
I guess my brain thought it was bad dubbing.
I’d say probably autism.
That’s weird how? Ur brain ain’t working boy
I heard bear both times but when you mentioned the possible difference I could hear the “vare.”
The audio sounded like "there" and the balls passed through each other regardless.
As a not native English speaker I can say, there is no difference
His teeth are so white!
really? that's what you focus on?
actually yeah tho
@@theeverythingstuff My focus on his teeth was on a second watch. On first watch it was on what he was actually saying.
It's not weird considering the majority of the video is zoomed in on his mouth.
Uh…yeah, very white (except for the big chunk of black sh*t.)
Thank God for his truth! ❤🎉
Even side by side your mouth is making different movements
Thank you. This guy is pretending lingistics doesnt exist
Thank you I thought I was an idiot I said how can you pronouce the same sound with your lips touching in one clip but not the other.
He never said it didn't. He just said that seeing different lips movements can make you hear different sounds so he put the 2 videos side by side to demonstrate it.
The mouth making different movements side by side was the entire point of the demonstration.
The audio is entirely uncorrelated with the visuals @@allankokkonen5722
The way our mind deceives us is criminal.
Both clips sounded exactly the same to me. Which is probably because, having living my whole life with sight loss, I’ve never been able to read lips, I can’t see facial expressions when looking at people, so I’ve always just listened for the sounds.
I thought the balls hit even before the sound was added lol
Bro said "bear" 🐻 followed by"deer" 🦌, then "dear" 😊, then told us that we heard "fair" ⚖️, then guilt tripped us by saying he said "beer" 🍺 "there"👉 all this time. 🍻 Cheers all! 😂
RUclips kids exist and that where you should be.
The second one sounded like "there" not "fair".
Either way. Point stands
it sounded like he was saying bear no matter what, and the balls didn't look like they bounced off of each other. I'm broken I guess.
Same
@@udrek-b6x Lol we're all weird differently. Or, did I mean 'wired,'? lol
Yeah it means your senses aren’t working properly/fully
@@belushipumpkinthe brain automatically replaces words to read faster... for common sentences that is... for example "weird" i interpreted it as "wired" my brain automatically corrects it
What if I told you Telepathy is real.
i heard "bear" in the second clip but i was like "haha i know this trick so im gonna say fair"
The only thing I'm not keen on is how softly you pronounced the B sound. It's funny though, because before knowing what this was about, I closed my eyes when you asked me to listen, because I know it's easier to concentrate on sound with your eyes closed, so instinctively closed mine when asked to listen carefully. I think it's why we (musicians) close our eyes when really getting into a playing a piece/part on an instrument.
When I first watched, I knew the effect was, so I had my eyes closed for the entire "Bear-Fair" segment. I heard "bear" the entire time when I wasn't looking, but did hear "fair" on my second watch during that segment
The second i saw what type of content this was, i closed my eyes to prove him wrong :)