I have used the SRT7 (original) as a dedicated tactical duty light for over 6 years as a law enforcement officer. My favorite key features were: high-lumen output, good throw distance, balanced beam, replaceable (18650) batteries, and the ability to 'pre-select' the lumen/mode output. This made it a good searchlight, with abilities to signal, and as a self-defense tool. I always carried a spare 18650 and a small charger with me in my bag. It has served me very well up until the light began to show a bit too much wear, such as a slightly loose selector ring.
i saw looking at the one and the p23i. wanted a new light with more throw and tail stand capable. however the p23i is tippy tail standing. ive had the edc35 for like a month now and dont really have any complaints however the p23i i think performs better at the 3000 lumens. it last several mins for 10 sec on the edc35
Funny what a concern port covers are when ive carried a RovyVon for years on a key chain daily with its super tiny port cover and its in perfect shape still. Pretty simple to set the light down when charging and unplug and put the cover back in place. As far as proprietary batteries i get the argument but its moot in my opinion. Built in a bit less so if you run hard and long and need the light to swap a battery, otherwise its like a cell phone that no one complains about. The depreciation of a 1500 dollar cell phone to becoming worth little to no money in 5-7 years seems fine with most people as they upgrade. Do the same on a 85 dollar built in battery light. In the scheme of things its free in comparison. I have a crate of old flashlights out of date tech, all with replaceable batteries that never get used. It would not have mattered if they were proprietary or not, or even built in.
Tech question, will the SRT7i tail cap operate on the P20ix? I have an SRT and it’s my all time favorite tactical light and i started out with an original surefire P9, im old. lol Features of SRT7i 5/5. Can tail stand, stepless output, and ultra low moonlight mode.
Hi, the P20iX arrived yesterday. I really like the uniformity of the light beam. However, I am very interested in the EDC35. I understand that you penalized the EDC35 a lot for the lack of the strobe, personally I don't use the strobe and I find it annoying when it happens to me by mistake so for me the absence is an advantage, not a flaw :-)
Amazing for self-defense! Already paranoid to the point where I attached a swimming goggles bungee cord to its modified tail cap so I can easily retain it in my hand!
I like a simple „one button“ UI in the tail cap, protected by a bezel against unwanted switching and to provide tail stand ability. That is what my older Flashlights from JetBeam and Fenix provide. But over time they were beaten in luminance and brightness by modern keyring flashlights. So I‘m searching for modern flashlights for EDC and searchlight. I recognize that different people have different wantings. In customer ratings and professional reviews I can read that much people want a sidebutton, some as mainswitch and some as modeswitch. I don’t. The Nightcore EDC33 and EDC35 are two of my favourites because their maximum luminance output as flood light, relative good throw performance as beam light and the single tailbutton. Only the momentary flood and beam mode makes me a bit unhappy but it is acceptable because longer use in that modes causes overheating. I‘m only worried about the build-in battery. The other Nitecores on my wishlist are the P23i and SRT7i about their roughness, relative good lightperformance and tailcap UI. Unhappy that they don‘t work with standarized batteries. The lightperformance of the MH25 Pro is quite more my favourite, but the less robustness and the UI with one tailbutton and one sidebutton don‘t satisfy me and so I closed it out of my wishlist.
edc35 works much easier stripped of bells n whistles that might confuse you to failure in very stressful situations. Hard to fail function is invaluable compared to lots of features or technical optimization.
Still love my P23i, although, I'm very tempted to try a new LumaSheild flashlight. EDIT: I wish Nitecore lights with the strobe function started out with the slow-strobe first then ramping up to the fast strobe and then cycle over again.
What's your definition of "tactical?" While I do agree with the reviewer that the P20iX's "white wall" effect lends tremendous situational awareness at closer distances -i.e. it will cast a bright "flat" light across even a good-sized room- it simply completely lacks throw. Given that most "big box" discount stores, supermarkets, and even schools have at least one long isle/hall that can easily be between 50 to 100 yards/meters long, we can also see (no pun intended) where "throw" is very necessary. Similarly, you need throw to be able to punch-through photonic barriers. Even in fog, it's arguably better to have a more powerful light that has a more concentrated beam (which you can then direct to illuminate your area of interest in an oblique/indirect manner), versus a more diffuse light, which just back-scatters all the more. They're all "tactical" in that each tool is designed to meet a specific end goal. But the real question is what your goal(s) happen(s) to be: like the other person above who asked what light would be best for hunting.....
I have used the SRT7 (original) as a dedicated tactical duty light for over 6 years as a law enforcement officer. My favorite key features were: high-lumen output, good throw distance, balanced beam, replaceable (18650) batteries, and the ability to 'pre-select' the lumen/mode output. This made it a good searchlight, with abilities to signal, and as a self-defense tool. I always carried a spare 18650 and a small charger with me in my bag. It has served me very well up until the light began to show a bit too much wear, such as a slightly loose selector ring.
@@carlostovar8585 I have all three, and I would go with the EDC35 for hunting. Reason: The peak beam intensity of the "Search" function for the EDC45 is spec'ed at 75,700 cd. while that of the SRT7i is 85,500. Yes, the SRT7i will throw farther, but the EDC35 doesn't give up that much, there, and yet has the advantage of the Lumin Shield floodlight mode, which will give you a close-range white-wall effect to help you gain more visibility close-up, in a wider swath, when you need it.
Why are you reporting the P23iX is 4 ounces and the SRT7i is 9 ounces? One is without battery and one is with battery. There is no way the P23iX is 4 ounces. Misleading.
Why do you keep speaking in future tense when describing things that exist *right now* ? The light *isn't going to be* this or that... it *IS* this or that. Who taught you to speak English, a time traveler?
I have used the SRT7 (original) as a dedicated tactical duty light for over 6 years as a law enforcement officer. My favorite key features were: high-lumen output, good throw distance, balanced beam, replaceable (18650) batteries, and the ability to 'pre-select' the lumen/mode output. This made it a good searchlight, with abilities to signal, and as a self-defense tool. I always carried a spare 18650 and a small charger with me in my bag.
It has served me very well up until the light began to show a bit too much wear, such as a slightly loose selector ring.
Wouldn't change my p20ix for anything, absolutely great flashlight.
i saw looking at the one and the p23i. wanted a new light with more throw and tail stand capable. however the p23i is tippy tail standing. ive had the edc35 for like a month now and dont really have any complaints however the p23i i think performs better at the 3000 lumens. it last several mins for 10 sec on the edc35
@@skmfkr2 the p23i is amazing, perfect match with the p20ix. 2 torch set up
@@Studat I also buy the P 20iX because it has two lumens on the lowest setting.
@@krafter22The 4 emitters limit it on how low it can go. Why the SRT7i can do 0.1 lumen moonlight for
Funny what a concern port covers are when ive carried a RovyVon for years on a key chain daily with its super tiny port cover and its in perfect shape still. Pretty simple to set the light down when charging and unplug and put the cover back in place. As far as proprietary batteries i get the argument but its moot in my opinion. Built in a bit less so if you run hard and long and need the light to swap a battery, otherwise its like a cell phone that no one complains about. The depreciation of a 1500 dollar cell phone to becoming worth little to no money in 5-7 years seems fine with most people as they upgrade. Do the same on a 85 dollar built in battery light. In the scheme of things its free in comparison. I have a crate of old flashlights out of date tech, all with replaceable batteries that never get used. It would not have mattered if they were proprietary or not, or even built in.
Some very good points here
P20iX is my favorite! I have it, and for years of use, it is still strong and perfect ❤
Excuse me: does it have a lock out function and can you use primary cr123 batteries if needed? Thanks
No lock out function. Just twist tail cap away from battery to lock out.
I would LOVE to hear how having both terminals on either end of the battery makes it more drop resistant 😂
Springs on either side will do just fine, like older / other Nitecore lights that have already been using this for a long time.
Does the p20ix have a lock out function and can you use primary cr123 batteries if needed? Thanks
I believe the SRT7i is the best out of all 3 lights I have one and it’s excellent in all categories!
Its outstanding, ultra low long runtime is a nice addition the P20ix doesnt have
Tech question, will the SRT7i tail cap operate on the P20ix? I have an SRT and it’s my all time favorite tactical light and i started out with an original surefire P9, im old. lol Features of SRT7i 5/5. Can tail stand, stepless output, and ultra low moonlight mode.
Hi, the P20iX arrived yesterday. I really like the uniformity of the light beam. However, I am very interested in the EDC35. I understand that you penalized the EDC35 a lot for the lack of the strobe, personally I don't use the strobe and I find it annoying when it happens to me by mistake so for me the absence is an advantage, not a flaw :-)
P20iX rocks. Instant strobe when I need it🤙
Amazing for self-defense!
Already paranoid to the point where I attached a swimming goggles bungee cord to its modified tail cap so I can easily retain it in my hand!
Modified how?
@@danielguerrero2426 A U-shaped tail cap with holes for attaching lanyards.
I like a simple „one button“ UI in the tail cap, protected by a bezel against unwanted switching and to provide tail stand ability. That is what my older Flashlights from JetBeam and Fenix provide. But over time they were beaten in luminance and brightness by modern keyring flashlights. So I‘m searching for modern flashlights for EDC and searchlight. I recognize that different people have different wantings. In customer ratings and professional reviews I can read that much people want a sidebutton, some as mainswitch and some as modeswitch. I don’t.
The Nightcore EDC33 and EDC35 are two of my favourites because their maximum luminance output as flood light, relative good throw performance as beam light and the single tailbutton. Only the momentary flood and beam mode makes me a bit unhappy but it is acceptable because longer use in that modes causes overheating. I‘m only worried about the build-in battery.
The other Nitecores on my wishlist are the P23i and SRT7i about their roughness, relative good lightperformance and tailcap UI. Unhappy that they don‘t work with standarized batteries. The lightperformance of the MH25 Pro is quite more my favourite, but the less robustness and the UI with one tailbutton and one sidebutton don‘t satisfy me and so I closed it out of my wishlist.
edc35 works much easier stripped of bells n whistles that might confuse you to failure in very stressful situations. Hard to fail function is invaluable compared to lots of features or technical optimization.
Comparisons means you have to tested outdoo4 at night not just talking, we can read the manuals book 😅
Wait… He didn’t go outside? Just started the video.
What a clown…
@tertozer3543 you have to respect the guy! Dont call him clown. He still tries his best to provide others with some important information.
this video is well. knowing some type, bateries replicement etc.
how rude you are @tertozer3543
clown could be yeling clown to other.
Still love my P23i, although, I'm very tempted to try a new LumaSheild flashlight. EDIT: I wish Nitecore lights with the strobe function started out with the slow-strobe first then ramping up to the fast strobe and then cycle over again.
That would be cool!
So when the battery dies in the edc35 that means the light is done for? Not good
Typically a lithium battery can be recharged 500+ times.
just make a new p20ix just with the new ui led and dont change anything else no limitations on run time do it exactly as it
P20x, p23i or srt7 for tactical applications?
I like the P20iX because I just love a flood light, but the SRT7i is a close second for sure!
What's your definition of "tactical?"
While I do agree with the reviewer that the P20iX's "white wall" effect lends tremendous situational awareness at closer distances -i.e. it will cast a bright "flat" light across even a good-sized room- it simply completely lacks throw. Given that most "big box" discount stores, supermarkets, and even schools have at least one long isle/hall that can easily be between 50 to 100 yards/meters long, we can also see (no pun intended) where "throw" is very necessary.
Similarly, you need throw to be able to punch-through photonic barriers. Even in fog, it's arguably better to have a more powerful light that has a more concentrated beam (which you can then direct to illuminate your area of interest in an oblique/indirect manner), versus a more diffuse light, which just back-scatters all the more.
They're all "tactical" in that each tool is designed to meet a specific end goal.
But the real question is what your goal(s) happen(s) to be: like the other person above who asked what light would be best for hunting.....
I have used the SRT7 (original) as a dedicated tactical duty light for over 6 years as a law enforcement officer. My favorite key features were: high-lumen output, good throw distance, balanced beam, replaceable (18650) batteries, and the ability to 'pre-select' the lumen/mode output. This made it a good searchlight, with abilities to signal, and as a self-defense tool. I always carried a spare 18650 and a small charger with me in my bag.
It has served me very well up until the light began to show a bit too much wear, such as a slightly loose selector ring.
Also these three lights each have vastly different applications. Ones a tactical. For military n police. One is a hiking hunting. N the other is EDC.
I guess the edc35 is for edc, .. what about the other two? Which one for hunting?
@@carlostovar8585I think he mean the biggest will be policemen, and the P20iX for outdoor and hunting.
@@carlostovar8585 I have all three, and I would go with the EDC35 for hunting.
Reason: The peak beam intensity of the "Search" function for the EDC45 is spec'ed at 75,700 cd. while that of the SRT7i is 85,500. Yes, the SRT7i will throw farther, but the EDC35 doesn't give up that much, there, and yet has the advantage of the Lumin Shield floodlight mode, which will give you a close-range white-wall effect to help you gain more visibility close-up, in a wider swath, when you need it.
@@chiehlee7982One nice plus of the SR is the ultra low mode. Such a long run time.
Why are you reporting the P23iX is 4 ounces and the SRT7i is 9 ounces? One is without battery and one is with battery. There is no way the P23iX is 4 ounces. Misleading.
edc35 would be, for my job and preferences, the perfect flashlight...if not for the non swappable battery. what *xy decided that this was a good idea
I have the MH12 Pro.
EDC 35 is looking nice. I just wish the EDC27 had similar specs and interface to the them.
Agreed!
Have the p10ix cominimg to me in the post. Main purpose will be tactical edc.
Shouldn't the title be "Triple treat" and not "Threat"? :O
Refueling? It's a flashlight. Nothing more. Stop with your nonsense.
Lose the tunes ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ
Hahahaha i got them all
Replaceable battery for the EDC35.
Why do you keep speaking in future tense when describing things that exist *right now* ?
The light *isn't going to be* this or that... it *IS* this or that. Who taught you to speak English, a time traveler?