Our tax is spent on protocols, SUVs, perks and privileges, 2000, 5000 units free, millions of PKR pensions, retired reemployment and destruction...... and above all ghabans .......
The problem is a huge amount of the tax paid by the people go for absolutely unproductive purpose. It does not go to build roads, bridges or airports, instead it goes for super expensive cars, luxury mansions, extremely high security for each of the elite and family, foreign tours and eating expensive meals. The awaam is financing this wasteful expenditure. On top of this, the super elite Establishment has gone ahead and contracted expensive dollar loans with the Chinese, who have supplied super expensive gold plated projects. The power plants now have high tariffs which is unsustainable.
He seems representative of FBR. When it comes to Institutional responsibilities, he says unfortunately and blame all things to common people who are trying to survive in his hell situation. It is common that victims are culprits in Pakistan.
They're only interested in his commission. Making everyone a filer is ridiculous! How are you going to process the people living under the absolute poverty line. This idiot will spend tax dollars on auditing 100 million living in abject poverty.
He's only interested in his commission. Making everyone a filer is ridiculous! How are you going to process the people living under the absolute poverty line. This idiot will spend tax dollars on auditing 100 million living in abject poverty.
I think also charitable expense is reduced income altimately income reduced so tax slap will reduce, while also some charitable institutions over invoicing charitable expense to reduce income altimately tax reduced
Plz pay tax as Beauracracy and rulers have to send it to their foreign bank accounts. They have plans to buy flats and pay fee of their children in college abroad. Plz pay because you can't reject their demand and raise voice BC
Keeping in mind the Pakistan's literacy rate and the education level of most shopkeepers, the employees and the employers, builders etc. they all need a tax consultant to file their returns. FBR is usually copy paste its policies from literate countries so it is true that with the current mindset prevail in FBR, it is not possible that tax net in Pakistan could be increased. FBR has lemons i.e. salaried employees & filers and they will keep squeezing them but for how long?
Its a lie that state is not giving anything: the roads we travel, police, emergency hospitals, public universities - they all come via our taxes. One might say the quality of all these services is bad, but for that we are also responsible - after all we (public) are the one working in these institutions. so, do not promote & celebrate people for not paying taxes
What a healthy conversation,,, But honestly your conversation is meaningless because of corruption in FBR. World is in AI now and these 50+ employee don't even want to use computers and come in system. I wish next project will be with Aashir Azim. For KPT.
This dialogue deeply explores issues surrounding the tax system and tax payments in Pakistan. It highlights that while people pay indirect taxes, there is a lack of direct tax contributions. A significant reason for this situation is the fear among individuals regarding tax payments and a distrust of the FBR (Federal Board of Revenue). It is essential for the government to make the tax system more transparent and reassure people that their taxes are being utilized appropriately. If the government improves services and ensures that citizens benefit from their tax contributions, the willingness to pay taxes may increase. Additionally, it is noted that other countries also have a mix of direct and indirect taxes, but there, governments provide better services, which encourages people to comply with tax payments. The discussion also indicates that increasing taxes on the salaried class negatively impacts their financial situation. Therefore, the government should create plans that benefit the salaried class to provide them relief. Overall, there is a pressing need to seriously consider these issues to strengthen and make the tax system in Pakistan more transparent.
Kindly raftaar please make videos on Islamic economic system taxation in Islam us pe bhi podcast kare Islamic taxation me indirect tax hai hi NAHI GST income sales tax ye NAHI hai
Cut the govt spendings, increase operational efficiency in govt department, improve the public confidence that their tax are effectively spent, do the automations in govt processes
Sabko patha hey spending qarz per interest pay karrahen haen aur govt expenditures protocol perks and privilege and ravishing life of the elite, for which they take more loans to meet their greed.
ek dam se agar ye non filer category khatam kery ge to person to person agreement ki taraf log jaye ge yaha tak ke sab kam apas me karain ke our 90 percent pakistan unbank ho kar apna kam chalata rahe ga
Pakistan is an Islamic republic but no mercy on their own nation ...Please note in the UK / USA not all citizens are supposed to become filers..only salaried person tax is deducted at Pay as you earn ( PAYE) that salaried person doesn't need to be registered as tax filer ....only businessman/companies need to register and return tax assessments...they give almost more then 6 months to files ..... FBR need to revise their policy ....those who are non filer still paying tax direct and in- direct taxes....., and there are hundreds and millions of household women or only bread-earning women .Still in Pakistan ..senior citizens so many citizens are not able to understand this complex tax system ...... forget about spending taxes ....we have a history of corrupt government ...
Guest repeadedly asking fbr is not adding people to tax net,and crushing more and more thore who r in tax net , i think the answer lies between itself in the statement, Why would any one willingly come to tax net when he is looking at what happeing to those who r already in tax net, Secondly the host said he has read many eu countries has same tax slab and many has more ,there i raise a question for the host ,what to compare an apple with orange eu countries ki per capita income , currency strength ,gdp ,spending power consider these factors ,secondly the on amount in euro slab compare to same slab in pkr amount and tell me by yr faith 300 000 par 30 % = 90000 remaining 210000 ,or 500 000 par 40 % = 200000 remaining 300000 ,is 210000 rs or 300000 main aik middle class kya ghar chalaye ga 100000 rs tu bijli ka bill a jaye ga, 2 bachon ki fees 60000 to 70000 , dont compare orange with apple , reduce tax slabs this is the only way Or highway
My sim was blocked so I had to file return. I am salaried. My tax is deducted at source. Why should I file? I have to hire an accountant and pay a few thousand ruppees
Brother mje Thora guide kar dain detail Mai .Maine be aik video dekh kar 4 years pehle registration kar li mje notices aye hoye Hain 114 ke 6 but Mai toh family dependent ho .Kiya nuqsan ho skat hai ab
All Govt employee are Giving Direct tax on their Income (salary)! and after that, on uncountable things or articles both domestic, cloth, food, fuel, grocery, medicine and Billllllllllllssssssssss indirect tax is being forcefully deducted by the FBR of Govt! whats this? your Point view is WRONG! Sir!
These podcast are no good for Pakistan. I suggest these people's should be appointed there.... but they have not the competence. Now this is the issue. Zero intellect zero responsibility zero competence. 😂
Our tax is spent on protocols, SUVs, perks and privileges, 2000, 5000 units free, millions of PKR pensions, retired reemployment and destruction...... and above all ghabans .......
Correct
N above all Generals 😂
Also taxes are spent in buying MPAs and MNAs to make and break government by Establishment.
Tax collected is spent wildly on government machinery.
Tax filers are just Sitting Ducks for FBR.
The problem is a huge amount of the tax paid by the people go for absolutely unproductive purpose. It does not go to build roads, bridges or airports, instead it goes for super expensive cars, luxury mansions, extremely high security for each of the elite and family, foreign tours and eating expensive meals. The awaam is financing this wasteful expenditure.
On top of this, the super elite Establishment has gone ahead and contracted expensive dollar loans with the Chinese, who have supplied super expensive gold plated projects. The power plants now have high tariffs which is unsustainable.
گریٹ ورک رفتار
Excellent podcast .. good questions and educated way of style . TV anchors shoild learn from you ..
He seems representative of FBR. When it comes to Institutional responsibilities, he says unfortunately and blame all things to common people who are trying to survive in his hell situation. It is common that victims are culprits in Pakistan.
They're only interested in his commission. Making everyone a filer is ridiculous! How are you going to process the people living under the absolute poverty line. This idiot will spend tax dollars on auditing 100 million living in abject poverty.
Dear pakistan friends
Kindly pay your taxes on time. Your CSS people need new imported high end SUV's
what is SUV,s
@@cartoonandmovieworld1137 double cabin
@@cartoonandmovieworld1137 Pogo dekhen
Mera 🍌
He's only interested in his commission. Making everyone a filer is ridiculous! How are you going to process the people living under the absolute poverty line. This idiot will spend tax dollars on auditing 100 million living in abject poverty.
Well done Sheharyar, very well done. Hope people understand
Start with taxing real estate, retail and corporate agriculture
Excellent outstanding informative podcast
Tax refund bhi rishwat ke baghair nahi milta😂
70 per cent is on the Net after taking out all expenses, not on gross like salary tax.
Extremely well articulated Shehryar sb!
fbr says rental property income (1month income is for us and 11 month is yours)
THANKS, NICE TALK BUT THE CORRUPTION WITH IN THE GOVERNMENT HAS TO END SIMILAR TO MAY BE MALAYSIA , HONGKONG THEY HANG CORRUPT POLITICIANS .
Well done
Excellent! Proud of you Shehryar❤
55% tax pay karne k bawjood return mai quom ko kia milta h. *....
Good job 👍
amenesty scheme, pay 10% and instead deposit 90% in bank or buy real estate, establish manufacturing concern. A better amenesty.
Non filer category finished is the most idiotic idea. Havent you heard of no taxation without representation. Are we adequately represented?
Income minus experiences is taxable income.
I think also charitable expense is reduced income altimately income reduced so tax slap will reduce, while also some charitable institutions over invoicing charitable expense to reduce income altimately tax reduced
Plz pay tax as Beauracracy and rulers have to send it to their foreign bank accounts. They have plans to buy flats and pay fee of their children in college abroad. Plz pay because you can't reject their demand and raise voice BC
Keeping in mind the Pakistan's literacy rate and the education level of most shopkeepers, the employees and the employers, builders etc. they all need a tax consultant to file their returns. FBR is usually copy paste its policies from literate countries so it is true that with the current mindset prevail in FBR, it is not possible that tax net in Pakistan could be increased. FBR has lemons i.e. salaried employees & filers and they will keep squeezing them but for how long?
Its a lie that state is not giving anything: the roads we travel, police, emergency hospitals, public universities - they all come via our taxes. One might say the quality of all these services is bad, but for that we are also responsible - after all we (public) are the one working in these institutions. so, do not promote & celebrate people for not paying taxes
All substandard
If the average person is paying 70% in tax, we should have gold and diamonds in our universities and hospitals not on Maryam and Tarrar.
What a healthy conversation,,,
But honestly your conversation is meaningless because of corruption in FBR.
World is in AI now and these 50+ employee don't even want to use computers and come in system. I wish next project will be with Aashir Azim. For KPT.
Faisal bhai ek podcast BRICS k liya karay
BRiCs currency kab launch hogi and commodities per kitna farm hoga aur Pakistan ko kia relief milayga
This dialogue deeply explores issues surrounding the tax system and tax payments in Pakistan. It highlights that while people pay indirect taxes, there is a lack of direct tax contributions. A significant reason for this situation is the fear among individuals regarding tax payments and a distrust of the FBR (Federal Board of Revenue).
It is essential for the government to make the tax system more transparent and reassure people that their taxes are being utilized appropriately. If the government improves services and ensures that citizens benefit from their tax contributions, the willingness to pay taxes may increase.
Additionally, it is noted that other countries also have a mix of direct and indirect taxes, but there, governments provide better services, which encourages people to comply with tax payments.
The discussion also indicates that increasing taxes on the salaried class negatively impacts their financial situation. Therefore, the government should create plans that benefit the salaried class to provide them relief.
Overall, there is a pressing need to seriously consider these issues to strengthen and make the tax system in Pakistan more transparent.
Ok Chat Gpt
@Syyrax17 😂😂😂
Kindly raftaar please make videos on Islamic economic system taxation in Islam us pe bhi podcast kare Islamic taxation me indirect tax hai hi NAHI GST income sales tax ye NAHI hai
Cut the govt spendings, increase operational efficiency in govt department, improve the public confidence that their tax are effectively spent, do the automations in govt processes
Uske liye foz ke akhrajat kam karne padenge
dont file taxes if you already have asset like house or plot. Best option is to wait when fbr corruption is fixed
2 dins se ek news ye bhi chal rahi hy k jin ki return incorrect hy, intentionally ya unintentionally. FBR un ko heavy fine kary ge.
Sir, can you show all the taxes list as an image plz
Make tax system easy and make tax slab easy only and government provide benefits to public in return
zyada loadshedding 6 ghantay 8 ghantay walay kia karein
Sabko patha hey spending qarz per interest pay karrahen haen aur govt expenditures protocol perks and privilege and ravishing life of the elite, for which they take more loans to meet their greed.
ek dam se agar ye non filer category khatam kery ge to person to person agreement ki taraf log jaye ge yaha tak ke sab kam apas me karain ke our 90 percent pakistan unbank ho kar apna kam chalata rahe ga
100 maslay, 1 wjah. Lumber 1 napak ......
FBR is corrupted, I'm jobless and still have to fill my filling. I don't want too,show us transparency of govt
Pakistan is an Islamic republic but no mercy on their own nation ...Please note in the UK / USA not all citizens are supposed to become filers..only salaried person tax is deducted at Pay as you earn ( PAYE) that salaried person doesn't need to be registered as tax filer ....only businessman/companies need to register and return tax assessments...they give almost more then 6 months to files .....
FBR need to revise their policy ....those who are non filer still paying tax direct and in- direct taxes....., and there are hundreds and millions of household women or only bread-earning women .Still in Pakistan ..senior citizens so many citizens are not able to understand this complex tax system ......
forget about spending taxes ....we have a history of corrupt government ...
Ayo we got mamoo on raftar before gta 6
Ju tax na de wo Chor ?
or Ju Tax Chori kr k kah rha Hai usko kia bolen?
Poor employee of 50k income be thinking. What happened to me , khaya pia kuch nhi glass tora, 12 aanay.
FBR daakoo
If a poor person want to pay home what he will do? What the option he have ..... If you want to completely remove non filers
Guest repeadedly asking fbr is not adding people to tax net,and crushing more and more thore who r in tax net , i think the answer lies between itself in the statement,
Why would any one willingly come to tax net when he is looking at what happeing to those who r already in tax net,
Secondly the host said he has read many eu countries has same tax slab and many has more ,there i raise a question for the host ,what to compare an apple with orange eu countries ki per capita income , currency strength ,gdp ,spending power consider these factors ,secondly the on amount in euro slab compare to same slab in pkr amount and tell me by yr faith
300 000 par 30 % = 90000 remaining 210000 ,or
500 000 par 40 % = 200000 remaining 300000 ,is 210000 rs or 300000 main aik middle class kya ghar chalaye ga 100000 rs tu bijli ka bill a jaye ga, 2 bachon ki fees 60000 to 70000 , dont compare orange with apple , reduce tax slabs this is the only way
Or highway
There is no many repeated statements.
Repeat statement is because everyone is afraid at pointing the finger at the real culprit.
My sim was blocked so I had to file return. I am salaried. My tax is deducted at source. Why should I file? I have to hire an accountant and pay a few thousand ruppees
I am also salaried and i regret to be a filer.
I am late filer but my sim is not blocked
Aoa sir kia nuqsan hai filer hone se
@@ShanAli-cf7wf ye bhi yaad rajo ge subah kia khaya ta
Brother mje Thora guide kar dain detail Mai .Maine be aik video dekh kar 4 years pehle registration kar li mje notices aye hoye Hain 114 ke 6 but Mai toh family dependent ho .Kiya nuqsan ho skat hai ab
if Pakistan issues tourist visa to Indians then they can earn a lot of money.
apny kharchy kam kary pehly hakomat... visibility aur transparency ho aam awam k liye k unka tax mn dia hoa paisa kahan ja raha ha
Kisi aur naam say sim lo
Also Pakistan tax system is too much complex common man don't understand so need consultant
Thats true its soo complex that people afraid of being a filer
Tax kyon dain? Kya benefit daye rahi hai govt?
Just need English for others
With due respect his tax knowledge and percentages used are prudently incorrect. As political statements it is ok
All Govt employee are Giving Direct tax on their Income (salary)! and after that, on uncountable things or articles both domestic, cloth, food, fuel, grocery, medicine and Billllllllllllssssssssss indirect tax is being forcefully deducted by the FBR of Govt! whats this? your Point view is WRONG! Sir!
FBR = Chor
Bro is saying word Government again and again in podcast....can he define Government in Pakistan
10 mint ki baat ko itna lamba kheecha ek hi sawal 5 dafa puchha with same answer
Total bakwas kuch b krlo hum nhi dringay tax nhi bnegay filer
the dude has no idea how pakistan works ! lol
non filler ke catagory modi ji ke tarah aik din mai khattam kaar dain ! hahahaha
Mera dimagh kharab ha jo nawaz shareef jaisay janwar ko tax du
These podcast are no good for Pakistan. I suggest these people's should be appointed there.... but they have not the competence. Now this is the issue. Zero intellect zero responsibility zero competence. 😂