Harrison Butker Of KC CHIEFS Homage To HOMEMAKERS, Riles Up SOCIAL MEDIA: Watch
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 16 май 2024
- Amber Duke and Jessica Burbank react to Kansas City Chiefs player Harrison Butker's comments in his commencement address at Benedictine College. #HarrisonButker #Chiefs
About Rising:
Rising is a weekday morning show with bipartisan hosts that breaks the mold of morning TV by taking viewers inside the halls of Washington power like never before. The show leans into the day's political cycle with cutting edge analysis from DC insiders who can predict what is going to happen. It also sets the day's political agenda by breaking exclusive news with a team of scoop-driven reporters and demanding answers during interviews with the country's most important political newsmakers.
Follow Rising on social media:
Website: Hill.TV
Facebook: HillTVLive/
Instagram: @HillTVLive
Twitter: @HillTVLive
Are we really surprised that modern feminists are offended by this?
Nope.
I am a modern feminist, and I don't feel offended by what he says, as I really really don't care about a male athlete's opinion on womanhood. I hope this doesn't sound to arrogant and you don't get offended 😊😂. However, he is beyond creepy, and his cry made me cringe.
@@Catoo. 😆
@@Catoo. A modern feminist 😂😂. What is a woman? 😂😂😂
@@anthonycortez4569 yeah that’s what I want to know. I think they are anti-family
I'm a bit of a degenerate myself but there ain't nothing wrong with a guy having religious beliefs. More power to him.
Except the abuse, brainwashing and so on
@konstantinkrastev4478 because the non-religious never engage in abuse or indoctrination. Whomp-whomp
@@solarski2004 how can you engange in non abusive religious indoctrination lol
It's so lame how people, typically conservative, will wrap their own PERSONAL beliefs in false dogma. Dude thinks women should be barefoot and pregnant at home so that men can lead full lives. That ain't got nothing to do with what's in the Bible, especially considering that his well-educated, high-earning mother and father worked to put him through private school. THAT is what led to Harrison Butker to his football career, not his wife being a homemaker.
@@konstantinkrastev4478 Are you still talking about religion or woke, or feminism?
What bothers me are people lying about what he said, saying his comments were degrading to women which says lot more about their views of homemakers, wives, & mothers then his
I have a sneaky suspicion that HIS LIFE, started the day he was born. 🙃
@aprilwashington2130 again, you’re taking his words out of context. He said “my wife would say….her life started” it’s a saying that people say to exclaim an important life event that changed the course of their passions. You know that. Why ate you acting like he said women’s lives don’t start until they have a baby. That’s not what he said. He’s saying wife is passionate about her vocation and getting choked up about how much that has helped him. And people like you have to twist and turn it
The media didn’t expect for anybody to actually listen to the speech, so they set the frame. It is there diabolical lies that led to this disaster.
Bingo.
"homemaker"
They are entitled to disagree with him but they aren't entitled to Doxx him and try to get him fired. Butker did this on HIS OWN TIME at a Catholic School...Kaepernick pushed his agenda while he was at work. Big difference Jessica
That’s right, shut up and dribble!
@marshallkobe shut up and dribble while ur at work..when ur not at work say what u want
@@rivernorthhomes He put his teammate in his mouth (no pun intended). That's what did it.
DID you say the same about Dylan Mulvayney and Budlight?
a commencement speech is NOT his own time. nor did he get the gig by being a jabitor-his NFL job got him this
At least he has the courage to say it. Unlike the cowards that will try to cancel him.
Rich coming from the conservative right LOL!!
Not agreeing with somone does not equate to trying cancel somone.
"courage" 😂🤣
Absolutely!! 💯
@@dustinavant2003 No but the calls for him to be fired do.
I'm a Catholic educated homemaker. It's nice to hear something positive about my choice. ❤
C.S. Lewis had a wonderful quote (don't remember the exact words) that basically said that the homemaker is the ultimate career around which all other careers revolve.
You're doing a great thing for the world and your family. I'm so glad the girl on the show stood up for the faith and cleared up what the Pope said
@@JohnDoe-ne1ni I wish they would speak about what truly happened to Pope Benedict in 2010-2011. How he was forced out, to voluntariy 'retire', becasue he was trying to enforce existing usary laws to ALL Catholica and All Christians around thd world. That would ruin the entire feudal predetory monetary system we have right now. The irony of that is if Butker and his employer practiced the Catholic Usary laws, he would only make about $30 to$40000 per year.
Exactly! The diabolical lie Harrison was talking about is that women are taught today that being a homemaker is lazy, shameful and taking the easy way out. That is certainly a diabolical lie! And modern women DO shame women who decide to be homemakers. If you don’t recognize that, you’re not paying attention.
@@carsi7282didn’t know that’s why he retired early 😮
Love Amber. I went to a catholic grad school and had my early education done at a Catholic school. I found nothing he said offensive at a woman
I’m Catholic as well. I found offense in what he said. His beliefs on how he believes women should be, what they should prioritize pursuing, along with his views of abortion and Biden were completely inappropriate to express during a commencement speech to new grads. None of that had to do with graduation as he was merely projecting his opinions onto the female graduates. In what world should a male who will never know the female experience and be capable of bearing children along with thr associated dangers preach to women about abortion? This was not his sermon and yet he treated it like one
Really? You didn`t find it offensive that he tells women that the most important thing in their life is to be a mother and actually their life doesn`t really start until they are a mother and he didn`t tell the men that being a father is the most important thing in their life and their life doesn`t really start until they are a father , even so he is a man and it would make more sense for him to speak to the men? Nobody would have bat an eye when he would have talked about how being a father is the most important thing for him, but he only told the women that for them being a mother is more important than their professional life and he did that at a college graduation.
@@anthill1510He didn't say it that way. Listen again. He spoke about his wife
@@anthill1510oh please. The truth shouldn’t give you the vapors. Get over yourself
@@SupernaturalLove100It was the most inanely inappropriate speech for the occasion he was called to address. He is a 28 year old jock. Self proclaimed Catholic. (not a theology student, he studied Engineering) Not qualified to give a sermon and a bigoted one at that! Catholic or not its a COLLEGE, that accepts female students and their money. If the college condoned his views (and they don't) they are hypocrites.
Family first? Of course, but a mother doesn't need a football player to explain this. His fake choking up was priceless. I call BS.
Butker was absolutely spot on and the fact that his benign speech is "controversial" shows how degenerate and backwards our society has become
BINGO!!
What are ylthe most "diabolical lies being in told to women" he was speaking on? History next year sentenced he insinuated it was having a achievements outside of the theater hometown being fulfulingu. What is the actual cause of crime and men being out of the the home? Hint it's poverty and incarceration. Which southern states have their hugest crime per captia. He is tried to mix a religious speech with political speech. If you listen to what he he actually sad here sounds dumb. It's every fox news /internet bro who think he's smart. Best honest about what's he said.
Butker (?) is the new Colin Kaepernick.
I don’t understand the outrage here. He is proud of the way his wife and him had a family??? Ok? Having a kid changed my life as a man too, for the better, so I understand what he’s saying. And it’s his beliefs. He never said women shouldn’t work or do anything outside the household.
What if his wife change her mind. Will he be ok with that
@@haroldbrown893 That is not exactly a gotcha question. You enter into a marriage with certain agreements. If one person unilaterally changes one of those agreements then anybody would have a problem with it. If they discuss this change beforehand however it goes, it goes. Remember, he is able to have whatever requirements as he want's for a wife. As is his wife free to set her own requirements.
No matter how that situation goes there is no direct blame on him from this. The objectors just have no leg to stand on.
He sad "you the women, who have had the most diabolical lies in told to you, many of you in the audience are thinking about you the promotions you have will be get etc."........ Heading did our hospital wife's way of life above everyone elses. He at least insinuated women were being lied to for wanting other things. Listen to his words!
Right. So why didn`t he tell his fellow men that the most important job in their life is to be a father and that their life will only really start once they become fathers? He only told the women how important it is to be mothers and that`s the problem.
He is referring to the conservative religious beliefs that the woman belongs in the home and only the home. He didn`t outright say it, but everybody there get`s the message.
Edit: He did outright say it:
He told the women to be "homemakers". That`s a word used to describe a woman in a conservative christian household who gives the right to make decisions over her life to her husband, "the head of the household" and only ever is a housewife and mother.
Women who decide to stay at home whith their kids, but have equal decision making rights in their marriage are called "stay-at-home-mums". They also often work part time or go back to work when the kids are older.
He and everybody in this audiece knows exactly what the term "homemaker" refers to and implies.
Yep, it's Handmaid's Tale stuff.
As has been pointed out, his mother is an eminent scientist. Perhaps, psychologically, therein lies the problem.
Amber is breath of fresh air. Both of these hosts are delightful, but Amber is really awesome.
Especially when she lies. The conservative way.
I went to a state school, and there were some women there who wanted to become professionals and go on and make a lot of money. There were also some women who wanted to marry rich and divorce into a lot of money.
I guess what Jessica is saying is that Men cannot comment on women. If that is the case, then I expect the nagging from women to stop immediately.
Nothing like a woman who keeps her own name, talks about being liberated and a feminist, graduates from college then finds out all she ever really wanted was to have children and determined that the best choice to provide her with this is someone she left so she goes back to him to do so then never ever really goes to work because she finds out that the world is too competitive of a place for her.
How sexist of you.
@@Webbgurl2000 I can’t tell if you’re being serious or joking, or if you’re just offended because you’re a nagging wife.
Yeah women can't comment on him I agree
There's a difference between men "commenting on women" and a man telling women what is they "are most excited about" upon graduation.
Most didn't listen to his entire speech. I keep forgetting we are all supposed to think the same now. How dare him admire his wife.
It’s rich that you are saying most didn’t listen to the speech while you conveniently omit when he said women chasing a career is a diabolical lie told to them. If you agree with him that is fine but don’t pretend he didn’t say what he said
Did u not watch the above segment where the lady said women were lied to because they think they can do this 1st then try to have kids when the biological clock is ticking?
She said feminist fed women this lie. She said what butker said.
Didn’t omit anything
I remember when women were screaming about how being a homemaker was a full time job worthy of the same respect.
What happened?
At a Catholic institution no less. Nothing here, Biden is losing in the polls. Desperation abounds.
@@emmersonzhaime1998 There are those who think the 3rd wave of feminism that say men and women are entirely equal is a diabolical lie. See all the sad women, close to 40 and above crying. Going as far to see the conspiracy of overpopulation presented by the Elitists.
The group who is supposedly one who champions inclusion for all is the most exclusive ever when it's something they disagree with.
The disagreement isn't with a woman wanting to be a wife and mother without working outside the home. It's about saying that wanting to work outside the home is part of a "diabolical lie" girls are told.
I completely agree with him. The most important job I’ve ever done is caring for my home and my family. People don’t have to agree, but trying to get them fired is just ridiculous! 🙄
Right wing lunacy
Anyone who disagrees with you can’t see the forest through the trees. Raising children impacts society in so many ways. There is no more important role than mother and father.
I'm a working dad, and 100% the most important thing to me is my family and children.
aren't you the same "Shut up and dribble" types that don't care what athletes think?
What is clear is that the people who were the targeted audience enjoyed the speech, evidenced by the standing ovation he received at the end of the speech.
That is because, unlike Notre Dame, Boston College, or Georgetown, Benedictine College actually is a Catholic institution and teaches what the Church really believes.
It's about time. People are finally pushing back against the ridiculousness of our current society. WE NEED MARRAIGES. WE NEED FAMILIES. AND THERE IS NOTHING MORE IMPORTANT IN THE WORLD THAN BEING A MOTHER AND RAISING A FAMILY!!!!!
Amber is right on this one. The fact that there is such a backlash to someone simply saying that you are *allowed* to value marriage, raise children, and acknowledge the life/world-changing impact of doing so demonstrates the actual issue to a T. Chef's kiss material right there.
Except he said that wanting the job is a diabolical lie told to girls.
The people mad about this really need to get out the house more often.
Did not have "I agree with Whoopi" on my 2024 bingo card.
I don't follow her at all, but we usually only see a bad side of here.
Given his audience, he's largely right.
It's a fair point. Feminism means women can choose whatever they want. And there is nothing wrong with women who want to be a mom/wife. My mom was looked down on by many for leaving her job to raise us while my dad worked. Too many pretend that doesn't happen. Kristen bell even experienced it. And many just told her she was making it all up...
Yes women are always being put down for that. That’s what this controversy is really about. They don’t want to value getting married and raising a family. That’s why they’re mad. They consider it an insult.
What jessica fails to understand and acknowledge. His speech was not meant for people like her.
And his speech was not meant for the women in that audience who didn’t agree. I’m Catholic and found his presumptions and what he went on to say inappropriate
He was trying to make a general societal and political speech. He knows it is public, and he knows he has a platform as one of two men who cannot get hit on a football field.
@SupernaturalLove100 you were not in that audience 😂
@@SupernaturalLove100
You don't have to take thee advice.
Progressives and the inclusion crowd can't let other groups exist in peace. You must be included in THEIR community. You aren't allowed your own.
solid job by Amber.
She likes to hear herself speak.
@@SupernaturalLove100 lol super in this clip she had a legit, informed take. fine if people disagree but substance wise she was on it.
@@kheldaryt Yes, Amber's lying helped her case.
@@UnconventionalReasoning nah
Jessicas future is gonna consist of 10 cats and alone 😂.
Future? She's already living that way
Lol she's said she's bi, but I guarantee you she pretty much only dates guys, and if she gets married, I'm sure it will be with a guy.
And if that guy transitioned to a girl.... She'd divorce.
I went to a catholic university. We didn't have a commencement speaker say anything like this guy back in my day
In that time , it wasn't a jeopardized nuclear family. But cudos all husband who appreciated that in their wife.
@@aliciamcorniel The divorce rate has been around 50% for decades.
Yeah. But you don't use to have people parroting you can have a baby's by yourself be independents you Don't need a man for anything ,and the more new one is not boy or girls is they., and schools changing gender
@@UnconventionalReasoning The attack on the nuclear family has intensified from almost all directions, if you have noticed. That doesn't necessarily have anything to do with the dismal divorce rate.
for some reason youtube didn't notify me of replies. For context, I ain't that old. I graduated in '09. The Catholic identity we celebrated was one of inclusion and loving everyone as our neighbor. My university was founded in 1808. I find it sickening that Amber attempts to define an entire faith based upon her personal view of Catholicism. I grew up Catholic and left the faith for my own reasons but our university proudly welcomed people of various faiths and backgrounds and we had pride celebrations on campus.
Hes right and if you got angry about this then it hit a direct shot.
Explain what is he right about?
@@idlereport explain what he is wrong about?
@@idlereportabsolutely nothing lol
@@idlereporthe’s right that only a few of them will have successful careers, for example. I mean, the economy sucks and bachelor’s degree doesn’t give you much of a boost these days. The reality is most women and perhaps especially most religious women desire a marriage and family more than a job, even a job you really really like. Also, there’s a biological drive we women have so that in many cases, once we have children, we become far more focused on them and desire to work less than we may have expected prior to becoming a mother.
Jessica. I agree it's up to the woman. She can marry a guy like Butker or not. It's up to the woman. Also, the Kaepernick analogy isn't a bad analogy because Butker won't lose his job, no, it's a bad analogy because Kaepernick thought there needed to be changes made to the NFL. Butker isn't speaking about changing the NFL.
But he is touting his opinion as best, and in that way, the analogy works.
No. Butker is telling women what he thinks most of them will want.
What changes did Kaepernick want made to the NFL?
@@UnconventionalReasoning None. It was about "police brutality", morphed into what ever the story needed to be to get maximum exposure for his antics.
He spoke truth!
He spoke truth for himself. Pretending it's a universal truth is part of what frustrates people about what he said, and comments like yours.
@@UnconventionalReasoning We "should" stop pretending. Pretending that bringing life and raising a family isn't one of the most fulfilling accomplishments. There are very few achievements that compare. We should stop pretending a career is a credible substitute (most people do not have careers anyway, they have jobs).
We should also stop pretending that we getting frustrated by what someone says is enough to establish their feelings as interchangeable truth.
@@EricJGonzalez For those who want it, of course raising a family is one of the most fulfilling things. But we should stop pretending that applies to everybody. A career can be a credible substitute if the person puts a low value on them raising children.
The frustration is when people say, "This works for me, therefore it must work for you." Or people thinking they know a social "truth" that applies to everyone.
@@UnconventionalReasoning Very few things apply to 100% of people. People are inherently unique and different. However, there is "human nature". We tend to "want" what we "can't have". Therefore, when you're aging and no longer able to have children of your own, and your career has run it's course, most people (especially women) will start to wonder if the loneliness was worth it.
@@EricJGonzalez Are you also an expert on what most older women want, or feel regret about?
He said that men and women should find their value in the family over career/material gain.
And it's true if you want true fulfillment, over temporary happiness.
Perhaps for you it's true. The problem is telling people that it's true for everyone.
@@UnconventionalReasoninghe said majority, and that is backed by a lot of research.
No, he didn`t. He only said that women should do that, not the man and that is why people are angry.
@@anthill1510 He might as well be quoting 1 TImothy 2:12.
@@UnconventionalReasoning Exactly.
A fabulous speech.
Experience can vary greatly in parenting, but sacrifice what ever is necessary and embrace being a dad, its the best thing ever!
Good discussion w putting his comments back in proper context. MSM and the Twitter sphere foment misunderstanding to make straw person arguments.
I worked my whole life but my most important job is being a mother
As a man, the most meaningful work I do is as a husband and a father. I support him saying that many of the women in that audience will feel the same about their role as future homemakers. Of course , men and women have other noble pursuits in life. But very few will wish they spent more time in the office while on their deathbed.
“very few” according to your all knowing knowledge about what all women desire? right? bc women are a monolith and aren’t miserable in marriage or as mothers, right?
1. Women have no problem telling men how they should be.
2. Capernick was doing his activism on company time.
1.) Maybe no one should tell anyone else "how they should be".
2.) Kaepernick was just sitting during the anthem to himself. White America made it their business. It wasn't even activism until White conservative (mostly) Americans pushed him to it. Had they left him alone, no one would have even noticed Kaepernick sitting.
Kaepernick was performing horribly when he started kneeling.
Patrick Mahomes wouldn't be benched if he started kneeling.
@@SkylarTheWriternobody pushed him into anything. If he, as you say, was just sitting by himself, he could have just kept on doing that and people would have moved on in a minute.
But nope, he wanted the attention because we was performing terribly
and Kaepernick was benched because of his performance was offered to try out for other teams and refused
@@bropitt That’s a warped version of history, but go off.
Butker is based
He also said somethings against abortion. Jessica is wrong, people are trying to get him fired. I'm pro-choice, female, have a master degree, and I went back to work (from home) three days after both of my children were born. I don't believe the man should be fired. I don't think I could ONLY be a homemaker (though few "homemakers" I know are only that. Most have very busy husbands and are more like the manager of his life in every aspect but work-but often for work as well. Or they are remodeling the house they bought on one salary. )
GOOD FOR WHOPPIE.
HIS SPEECH SHOULD BE GIVEN AT EVERY CHRISTIAN COLLEGE.
Very good defence of the Catholic Church Amber.
Thank you Amber!!!
The 1st time I've ever agreed with whoopie
Yep, first time for everything!
Jessica is the only reporter giving me what I crave, which is updates on current fashion trends from Des Moines, Iowa's trendiest t-shirt store.
Harrison is right.
Perhaps for his own life, he's right.
He hit it out of the ballpark. ❤
That isn't very useful for a football player. 😂
Why did the NFL even have an official response!? Does it matter whether they, as an organization and his employer, agree or disagree if he actually was doing this on his own.
“I don’t care to hear it”
It’s not directed at you 🤣
These 2 ladies allow each other to express their viewpoints...unlike Briahna bullying and cutting off the limp Robby. Great debate.
More free speech 🗣️💪❣️Glad we are talking on it! VALUE mothers! We birth them all (the real ones), and our entire society is based on next generation (why the T needs stopping). We also want educated moms❤️. We need to all change the outline of corporate society to center what is good for childhood🐣🤗🥰. Elders- trickle down! Help families be possible ❤️❤️
He spoke truth and the only people that found it offensive are the ones who have been deceived by our culture.
Who "have" a different position on the issue. They were not deceived. You get to be you, and they get to be their own selves. "Judge not ..." 😉👌
Pretending he, or you, know the "truth" is the whole issue. You don't know what the truth is for what is best for each person's life. His religious arrogance makes him believe he knows.
@@patriciajump9511 Oh, but you MUST judge. Not condemn. Otherwise how would you know good from evil, lest you judge.
Democrats have no problem with protesters threatening Jewish Students. But when someone has a different opinion than yours they need to be Canceled.
Ain’t that the truth!
@@kennethhalstead5570 Its because despite popular talks we can actually criticise those.. its the feminist agendas we cant criticise.
@Tiasung Do you ever criticize the "feminist agenda?"
Utterly disingenuous nonsense from the right, as usual.
That’s not related to this topic.
anyone know how much a Butker RC card is going for ?? seriously. what a great man.
To all the people who oppose what he said because it differs from their own beliefs: Whatever happened to “Diversity is our strength?” Hummmm?
We need more Speeches like this !
People are annoyed by it because they only watched the clips instead of the whole speech and don't get the actual meaning of it. A 20 second clip that gets clicks doesn't do the whole speech justice.
the idea working for a bank is more important than raising a kid is absolutely insane
Some people do not want to raise a kid.
Right. He should have told that to all the men who were there.
@@UnconventionalReasoning yes they want to work in a bank as this is REWARSDING not very bright are we
@@UnconventionalReasoning
Still, the idea of you thinking having a job is more important than a kid, even if you’re child free is sad and…not normal
@@kant.68 It is your perspective of life that it "is sand and not normal". Requiring that everyone does the same thing, the "normal" thing, is one of the worst mindsets in society.
Great job Amber. I was going to respond to Jessica missing key words of nuance from his speech but you covered it all
IT WAS A NOT A POLITICAL STATEMENT BUT JUST SOME COMMON SENSE FOR A CHANGE.
He referenced "bad leaders" in the first 30 seconds, and referenced Pres Biden less than 2 minutes in. He intended it to be a political speech.
Butker you are a great man!
Thank you for sharing your beliefs and views of being a proud husband of faith.
Women, you can do it all, but not always at the same time… get some work experience because you never wanna be 100% dependent on anyone without options. Just my own opinion, we all have them and he is welcome to his.
Well done Harrison to speak common sense and stand up for basic common values in a world that's gone mad and deliberately being driven into the ground by the Globalists.
Common sense: "I have zero justification for this position. I will assert that everyone should think it, calling it 'common'. Anyone who disagrees is therefore wrong."
Good for Amber Duke. She actually knows Catholic teaching and how the media lie and/or are ignorant about what Pope Francis has said about homosexual acts.
One correction, though. The Holy Father speaks Italian, not Latin. Latin is for documents, and rarely at that.
Amber is of fire. Awesome love Fridays.
As a 28 year homemaker I applaud this fella. Keep it up sir.
Please come back to this post and update us when you're 40. Please.
This is a great tribute to his wife…
I enjoy hearing both of your perspectives!! Please respect each other talking with interrupting. I find Mon-Thurs unwatchable due to the disrespect and over talking.
The blew this up. It would've just been another speech. Cancel culture is off it's rocker. People are allowed to have their opinions. Doesn't mean people should lose their jobs over it.
He right Woman slaving away for the corporate life get used up and throw away in the end No family no children Only cats and a lonely life
Happy life is a Happy Wife 😉
He did not lie
Yes he did. He knows nothing abt what the majority of women wanr
I absolutely love the lead lady with the monologue. She is incredible and also a beautiful soul!
His speech was about Catholic values given at a Catholic college. If you're not Catholic then why take offence?
Jessica, do you have any idea what Benedictine College is like?
Good for you Amber for exposing Jessica’s ignorance on this topic. She doesn’t know the first thing about Catholic theology and she clearly was not the intended audience for Butker’s speech. She should have declined to comment instead of opening her mouth and weighing in on a controversial subject upon which she is severely misinformed.
1,000 + 👍
Hoping you all have babies soon too🤗
Amber is a breath of fresh air. I wonder if Jessica will have the same attitude at 38.
Not one older person will say , I wish I spent more time on my career and skipped having children. Having a functional family will be your biggest accomplishment, and telling young women any different is misleading! With age comes wisdom. Congratulations on your degree, and your new career, we’re proud of you, but it will NOT be your biggest accomplishment in LIFE!
Tolerance, what a concept!
Well said Amber
With a wife who has a PHD in Science and teaches in a college she says being a mother and wife is the most rewarding thing in her life
The woman on the right is so based.
A room full of CONSERVATIVE CATHOLIC graduates. Yes, overwhelmingly these women will likely choose to leave the workforce to have children and a family. Maybe not at NYC or MIT, but at Benedictine College in Atchison, KS his statement rings true. Where he was speaking is inportant.
I'm an atheist and do not share many of this guys beliefs, but I find it very sad that Jessica is arguing that pursuing a career is a higher calling. There is nothing more valuable in society than a loving mother AND father. Consumerism is warping their perspective. I thought the left advocated for a better life balance. Not that the right has meaningful solutions, but this is such a sham conversation. Motherhood is the most beautiful aspect of humanity, and they're almost disregarding it as a lesser than pursuit. Thay being said, it was weird to address the woman in a graduating crowd that way. They're 22, they're not at that stage yet. Given its a catholic school theyll probably pursue it, but likely 8 to 10 years down the line lol
He was not telling women what to do. Good for the Journalist who is defending him.
What? He did exactly that !
Your children will always be more important than your career. Total respect for all the mamas that do whatever they have to take care of their babies. I also think it’s incredibly honorable to stay home and pour everything you have into your children. This was a Catholic College commencement speech… I feel like that is not understood to the degree it deserves. The catholic faith teaches all of the principles that Butker speaks on. I’m with Whoopi on that one. If you want respect you need to give respect. It is not disrespectful to tell women about the joy of motherhood… because he’s right, society has lied to us.
Amber! Amber! AMBER! Give me an A... I came her expexting a balance perspective & I got a sharp shooter bullseye on nuance, context, & accurately representing His & the churches perspective. Bravo!!!
Well said, Amber!
Why do people look down at the vocation of HOMEMAKER. It's the most important thing someone can do. Loving and raising children, shaping and forming human beings is IMPORTANT.
It’s the fact that he told “majority” of them would want that. Are you okay?
@@SupernaturalLove100 I don't know what you're saying?
@SupernaturalLove100 but if you're saying that you don't like the fact that he told the majority of women, they would want that, then I say "too bad" for you. He's free to express his belief, and I happen to agree with him. Women in general, were created to have babies and raise them. They're blessed.
Great / honest man sharing positive values
“According to a 2019 Pew Research Center study, the United States has the highest rate of children living in single-parent households in the world, with 23% of children under 18 living with one parent and no other adults.” In the African American community 7 out of 10 families are single-parent. As an African American this topic is relevant for me and should be for every American. This discussion needs to start in middle school and be further discussed in college. American families are in a crisis and don’t let the deceptive media fool you. What they did is diabolical because he never said women should stay at home. Listen to the speech and don’t let the media frame it for you.
What does you being Black have to do with anything? The same people you are defending would tell you to stop race baiting.
God bless you for that rant at the end, Amber. I am also very sick and tired of people who don't understand anything about the Church and its teachings commenting on things they don't begin to understand.
my guess is that when Amber has kids we will never hear from her again.
Jessic shut up! Glad Amber's wisdom prevailed in this conversation.
I dont see the outrage here
Amber is a straight BEAST! Replace Robbie 😂
Family is everything
Yes, and family is the basic unit of every society.
If you want your family to be everything, it can be everything for you. Others are allowed to feel differently. That's what makes his speech frustrating to many, he's asserting that his position should be shared by everyone.
@@UnconventionalReasoning , Mr. Butker was stating facts, not mere assertions. Facts backed up by data. Or, did you not hear Amber rattle off the polling data & statistics that proved what he said?
@@NickFromDetroit Pretending any of this is "facts", that "statistics" prove anything about facts, is weak analytical thinking.
@@UnconventionalReasoning , Why Are liberals such science deniers?
By all means, throw out empirical data for your feelings. It’s worked so well, so far.
But remember, facts do not care about your feelings.
Lady on the left - 👎🏻
Lady on the right -👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻
Wow. Get your burkas ready ladies 😳
Jessica was trolling the other girl.
More like Amber was trolling by even distorting what the Pope said
@@SupernaturalLove100 Amber was distorting what Butker said.
This has been blown out of proportion, not surprising though anything that goes against popular culture gets scrutinized.
It seems a bit disingenuous when it’s only Christianity that gets criticized.
This may be a matter of perspective. Children change the trajectory of a married couple's life. I don't look at Butker here as "Catholic Kicker," but as a father. That's the genesis of this in my opinion. It's reflected in this conversation above, narry a mention of children. The focus is instead on "what he said about women." This is the fundamental issue - Children are game changers. Your whole outlook on what life is changes. He's speaking from that perspective primarily, in my opinion.
Yes, and many people prefer to not have children. But according to Butker, I probably stated a "diabolical lie".
No, he is not speaking from that perspective. If so he would have said "Being a father is the most important thing in my life and I feel like my life only really started when I became a father." Instead he told women that`s how they should see their life and he told this only to the women.
And he used the word "homemaker" which is used in very specific contexts where women are told that their place is only to be "a homemaker" and dedicate her life to her children and be in service and under the authority of her husband.
Women who simply decide to stay home with their children when they are little are called stay-at-home-mums and don`t live under an ideology where they have to give the authority over their life over to their husbands.
He deliberately was talking about the concept of "homemakers", he mentioned all the other talking points of people with this mindset, too.
@@anthill1510 He is definitely leaning into his inner Paul: men are the head of the household, women must submit to their husbands. Of course, they must have husbands to do this.
@@UnconventionalReasoning Yep, exactly that. I listened to the rest of his speech and there is even worse things in there, it`s shocking because the audience clapped at the end.
@@anthill1510 Everything he said can be found in various parts of the Bible. That doesn't make what he said right, it makes the book wrong.
Life is tough get a helmet.