The criticism that Mariah has gotten about her voice is a perfect example of how society and the media craves to see famous/beautiful/talented people fall from grace. People love joining witch hunts and being followers. I’m happy you got to see Mariah’s true vocal evolution throughout the decades.
Thank you! Millions of people over criticize or simply hate on Mariah and they have absolutely NO idea what it take to sing her songs. Not even the 'easy' songs in her catalog are easy. Its so frustrating to see how people treat her. One thing about people they love to see successful & super talented people fall from grace (just to give fake sympathy and tears when they're gone). Good thing she has kept her head above the water for more than 30 years because...whew! She has been pulled down (with blocks attached to her feet) so many times but she broke free. A legacy!
Thy 2013 my all version of Mariah is one of the best imo. That was mature Mariah doing amazing things to an already amazing song and it's just wow! Those runs!
She performed at Live Duet of Hero with Pavarotti where Mariah sang the first verse in her original style then Luciano took the 2nd verse in a latin opera version then sang the bridge together - her most heavenly performance in 1999
So glad to see (and of course it takes a singer to understand what goes behind being able to perform this song live) how you educate people too, not only presenting the videos and your thoughts on those, but also informing. We need to just appreciate what Mariah can deliver, simply just because nobody will do it as she does. Thanks for sharing!
Thank you so much for appreciating my approach! I really try to keep my comments respectful while also making them light and fun for people to watch, because as a performer myself I know what an impact people’s words can have
15:39 she had a duet with him with "Hero"! Although it didn't kind of mesh well (at least for me) because he was singing in a different language and was kind of doing it in his own style. Not saying that it's bad, of course. He's legendary. It's just that it turned out like a remix because they were each doing their own thing. 😂
@@TreMcLeod_ if I'm going to say anything, it's that Hero is more of a live song for me. The studio is amazing, but hearing/watching her performances of it live is an EXPERIENCE. I wasn't that much of a fan of the song at first too. But I grew to love it over time when I watched her live performances for it. ❤
2013-2017 were some of the messiest years for Mariah. Her beef with Nicki, her evil manager, her weight problems, her messy televised performances ... you name it. She also put on a diva-ish behavior as a joke, but people were up in arms to judge her as a bitter, mean, shady, and self-absorbed person. Her interviews were just as messy because these interviewers kept comparing her to other artists, asking her shady questions about the people she had a problem with, and making her look mean and shady. Thankfully, she redeemed herself in 2018. She chose the right interviewers to interview her. She only talked about her artistry and musicality. She shared her struggles dealing with bipolar disorder and her awful family. She wrote one of the best biography books. She's come a long way, and it's our job to give her the respect and the credits that she deserves.
I don’t understand why ignorant people have to comment about her voice when we all know she has nodules. She’s been open about that. Have some grace and compassion for somebody dealing with a health issue. Throat issues are a health issue. Nobody gives Julie Andrews shit. That poor woman lost her voice from having surgery to remove her nodules. So can you blame Mariah for not wanting to go to extremes to deal with her vocal issues? Having health issues does not diminish who a person is and was. People are really cruel and just stupid. She still can sing but you’re used to 90s Mariah who had no competition. She was hands down the best vocalist of the 90s with an astounding range and technique that was unmatched. So yeah that Mariah might not be the same but she still can sing and entertain. Just leave her be and take it for what it is. Life will bring all of us challenges and I pray that some of the haters receive more grace than they give to this woman when they have health issues. 🙏🏻
Yes... Mariah Monday... The longer reaction was much better. I consider Mariah the modern day Amadeus (as far as the fictional movie goes). The power to be trying to put artists in a box when all they want to do is be free to do their artistry.
The Vegas show: "Wait A Minute"...yes Tre, she absolutely started and ended that song off-stage. You absolutely need to write a remix version for her. I was just laughing at your commentary preceding Singapore. Anyways, another great reaction. Have a wonderful weekend!
Thank you so much for this journey ! When it comes to live performances, "My All" is my favorite song to hear. She changes it everytime, expecially towards the end, from the "baby can you feel meeee" that I always wait & she gives a lot of intensity to the words. I loved everything you said about the fact that people are criticizing her without actually really listening to her. The problem with Mariah, is that she's always compared to "what she used to be" and she was SOOOO GOOD at the beginning of her carreer that it can only be less good. Now, if you compare her not to herself but to other singers of today (who don't have nodules to stuggle with), she is still one of the best & smartest singers there is.
She has done amazing with "vision of love" during her Caution Tour in 2019, specially in St. Louis, Detroit and Amsterdam. Also, in 2023 christmas' concerts, the opening in Chicago with "Hark! The Herald Angels sing" is amazing. Please, check it out if you can! ❤
The Pavarotti & Friends performance of My All , is probably my fave 🥰🥰. As others have written, She sang Hero with Luciano. I will add a lil background info on the Rosie performance. It was Live from NYC at 10am. So we know that Mariah is usually in bed 😴😴 by that time. The studios are kept freezing cold so the cameras, lights & other equipment don't overheat. She also was Rosie's guest on the entire episode also performing , Close My Eyes ( an Amazing Interview since Rosie is also, originally from Long Island & had Mariah surprised with some common memories they shared about growing up on L.I. ) Def enjoying this format of various performances of the same song 🥂👏✨✨✨.
Do you plan to be more active on TikTok ? There are so many talented lambs doing stuff worth reacting it could be interesting to have shorter reactions as well or maybe in RUclips shorts then
The Rosie O’Donnell one w the tan outfit she was having trouble w her voice, she kept losing it and had all the background singers there to fill in incase. It’s a tense performance cause she is stresssssseedd
patti doesnt sound the way she used to... and dolly sounds pretty well but her songs are as demanding as other females artists i mean... if you hear mariah singing her less demaning songs she still sounds the same...
![SahBabii - Viking [Official Music Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/D37cL92JX0I/mqdefault.jpg)
The criticism that Mariah has gotten about her voice is a perfect example of how society and the media craves to see famous/beautiful/talented people fall from grace. People love joining witch hunts and being followers. I’m happy you got to see Mariah’s true vocal evolution throughout the decades.
Meanwhile Mariah just gave us absolutely EVERYTHING throughout years. And still continues to do so.
I'm so used to the "ooooh aaaaah RISKED MY LIFE feel your body feel your body" in every performance 😂
Thank you! Millions of people over criticize or simply hate on Mariah and they have absolutely NO idea what it take to sing her songs. Not even the 'easy' songs in her catalog are easy. Its so frustrating to see how people treat her. One thing about people they love to see successful & super talented people fall from grace (just to give fake sympathy and tears when they're gone).
Good thing she has kept her head above the water for more than 30 years because...whew! She has been pulled down (with blocks attached to her feet) so many times but she broke free. A legacy!
Thy 2013 my all version of Mariah is one of the best imo. That was mature Mariah doing amazing things to an already amazing song and it's just wow! Those runs!
RIGHTT
so true
She performed at Live Duet of Hero with Pavarotti where Mariah sang the first verse in her original style then Luciano took the 2nd verse in a latin opera version then sang the bridge together - her most heavenly performance in 1999
"i dont hear criticism from people who can sing it better." REAL!
If there is one thing Mariah gonna do is walk off stage immediately 😂
I’m learning it’s her thing! 😂😂
😂😂😂
So glad to see (and of course it takes a singer to understand what goes behind being able to perform this song live) how you educate people too, not only presenting the videos and your thoughts on those, but also informing. We need to just appreciate what Mariah can deliver, simply just because nobody will do it as she does. Thanks for sharing!
Thank you so much for appreciating my approach! I really try to keep my comments respectful while also making them light and fun for people to watch, because as a performer myself I know what an impact people’s words can have
@@TreMcLeod_ and we appreciate you so much for that!! Honestly.
15:39 she had a duet with him with "Hero"! Although it didn't kind of mesh well (at least for me) because he was singing in a different language and was kind of doing it in his own style. Not saying that it's bad, of course. He's legendary. It's just that it turned out like a remix because they were each doing their own thing. 😂
"Hero" is not my favorite...but maybe I'll enjoy the "remix" haha
@@TreMcLeod_ if I'm going to say anything, it's that Hero is more of a live song for me. The studio is amazing, but hearing/watching her performances of it live is an EXPERIENCE. I wasn't that much of a fan of the song at first too. But I grew to love it over time when I watched her live performances for it. ❤
2013-2017 were some of the messiest years for Mariah. Her beef with Nicki, her evil manager, her weight problems, her messy televised performances ... you name it. She also put on a diva-ish behavior as a joke, but people were up in arms to judge her as a bitter, mean, shady, and self-absorbed person. Her interviews were just as messy because these interviewers kept comparing her to other artists, asking her shady questions about the people she had a problem with, and making her look mean and shady. Thankfully, she redeemed herself in 2018. She chose the right interviewers to interview her. She only talked about her artistry and musicality. She shared her struggles dealing with bipolar disorder and her awful family. She wrote one of the best biography books. She's come a long way, and it's our job to give her the respect and the credits that she deserves.
I was so happy when Stella left the scene, because I couldn’t stand her. She was bad for Mariah
I love the Milan 2000 version! The ending improvisation was amazing
Regarding divas live, her hair was so big because it’s full of secrets
I don’t understand why ignorant people have to comment about her voice when we all know she has nodules. She’s been open about that. Have some grace and compassion for somebody dealing with a health issue. Throat issues are a health issue. Nobody gives Julie Andrews shit. That poor woman lost her voice from having surgery to remove her nodules. So can you blame Mariah for not wanting to go to extremes to deal with her vocal issues? Having health issues does not diminish who a person is and was. People are really cruel and just stupid. She still can sing but you’re used to 90s Mariah who had no competition. She was hands down the best vocalist of the 90s with an astounding range and technique that was unmatched. So yeah that Mariah might not be the same but she still can sing and entertain. Just leave her be and take it for what it is. Life will bring all of us challenges and I pray that some of the haters receive more grace than they give to this woman when they have health issues. 🙏🏻
Yes... Mariah Monday... The longer reaction was much better. I consider Mariah the modern day Amadeus (as far as the fictional movie goes). The power to be trying to put artists in a box when all they want to do is be free to do their artistry.
I love your realization at the end. Time changes. Seasons come and go. But she will always be Mariah Carey.
The Vegas show: "Wait A Minute"...yes Tre, she absolutely started and ended that song off-stage. You absolutely need to write a remix version for her. I was just laughing at your commentary preceding Singapore. Anyways, another great reaction. Have a wonderful weekend!
2013 performances will always be my favourite
Thank you so much for this journey ! When it comes to live performances, "My All" is my favorite song to hear. She changes it everytime, expecially towards the end, from the "baby can you feel meeee" that I always wait & she gives a lot of intensity to the words.
I loved everything you said about the fact that people are criticizing her without actually really listening to her. The problem with Mariah, is that she's always compared to "what she used to be" and she was SOOOO GOOD at the beginning of her carreer that it can only be less good. Now, if you compare her not to herself but to other singers of today (who don't have nodules to stuggle with), she is still one of the best & smartest singers there is.
She has done amazing with "vision of love" during her Caution Tour in 2019, specially in St. Louis, Detroit and Amsterdam. Also, in 2023 christmas' concerts, the opening in Chicago with "Hark! The Herald Angels sing" is amazing. Please, check it out if you can! ❤
Is 2023 actually live cause a lot of people said she started lip syncing it last year
I'm kinda mad at some people because they say VOL 2024 is lipped I don't think so I've seen it and it's better than last year's in my opinion
Love the back to back live performances reaction❤ it's "giving me life, and it's everything"
You really really have to have a look at the Grammy’s performance of her singing We belong together and Fly like a bird. It is… SO SO gooddd!!!
Great video❤❤ I really liked the through the years approach!
It’s so fun! And it definitely gave me a lot of perspective
@@TreMcLeod_ Yeah! Are you going to do this type of video for more live performances?
Agree with EVERYTHING you said
It’s the analysis of these arrangements for me. Spot on
You really do have a pretty great voice yourself, very pleasing to the ear
Just watching you watch Mariah is so fun! ❤
That Vegas show definitely has its special meaning I guess... So emotional
I really like this throughout the years performance for videos
Wow multiple performances are greaat!!!!
Okay, now I’m waiting for the “feel ya body” part for me to see you shake yo shoulders Tre!!! 😂😂😂
On the Caution Tour her renditions of My All are so nostalgic sounding they're worth checking even for your own self ❤
The Pavarotti & Friends performance of My All , is probably my fave 🥰🥰.
As others have written, She sang Hero with Luciano.
I will add a lil background info on the Rosie performance. It was Live from NYC at 10am. So we know that Mariah is usually in bed 😴😴 by that time. The studios are kept freezing cold so the cameras, lights & other equipment don't overheat. She also was Rosie's guest on the entire episode also performing , Close My Eyes ( an Amazing Interview since Rosie is also, originally from Long Island & had Mariah surprised with some common memories they shared about growing up on L.I. )
Def enjoying this format of various performances of the same song 🥂👏✨✨✨.
My favourite is actually the Rosie performance! She sounds tired but it’s so emotional and the musical changes are my favourite
Continue with the Multiple Performances of One Song for you to appreciate how Mariah's voice changes every year! ❤❤❤
Try watching her play along the piano at Jimmy Fallon intimately with her fans she was really good at it, i think it was 2014 ish
ruclips.net/video/ZlObJAlSi78/видео.htmlsi=deiWnJ2rwd04Ab0H
2013-riah is my favorite post 90s Mariah
Can you react to her recent live performance this year.😊❤
yess her concert last week !
ruclips.net/video/7r_-JdcgwdA/видео.htmlsi=hS6bYIwXz5d7hzOU
Do you plan to be more active on TikTok ? There are so many talented lambs doing stuff worth reacting it could be interesting to have shorter reactions as well or maybe in RUclips shorts then
That’s a great idea!
Pavarotti and Mariah performed hero on this show …she’s in a pink dress. They sing together.
The Rosie O’Donnell one w the tan outfit she was having trouble w her voice, she kept losing it and had all the background singers there to fill in incase. It’s a tense performance cause she is stresssssseedd
Please react to Mariah The One live too. Thank you 🫶🏼
patti doesnt sound the way she used to... and dolly sounds pretty well but her songs are as demanding as other females artists i mean... if you hear mariah singing her less demaning songs she still sounds the same...
Patti doesn't sound the same because her technique changed every decade😭. She has a solid one for years.
Nothing is more boring in a reaction than watching the same song over and over. Not a great choice