Well, I bloody love wheel pommels. I think one other thing about the disc shape is that it can be pretty wide - ie in its diameter - without having to be especially thick. So it can be visually very striking, with a wide profile and decent weight but slim enough not to get in the way of anything when it’s moving around. If that makes any sense at all…
I was surprised he didn't say anything about the wheel pommel specifically regarding *edge alignment feel.* When you're grappling or reaching for a sword you can't see, the wheel pommel lets you know as your fingers reach for it how you're going to hold it. The handle does it, too, but the wheel pommel really helps. Also, *if you're carrying it around,* the wheel pommel sits more flatly against your person compared to other shapes.
I think there's probably a happy medium that could be attained between a scent stopper and a wheel that would maybe be vaguely scallop shell shaped. The issue with wheel pommels is that there's a fairly harsh 90 degree angle right at the edge of your pinky finger. Sabers often have a similar problem inherently but get around it by just flaring out the grip a bit right before the transition to the basket ring
I'm reminded by your comments of the similarity to those early horseman's pistols that have those great big spheres on the ends of the handles. Good for pulling from saddle reliably in the thick of a battle.
@@Specter_1125 True, true. Though given the balls - at least for the examples I remember seeing in museums - were typically not made of (or shod with) metal, I suspect that being able to use your pistol as a club is a side-benefit compared to the "not fumbling/dropping your pistol" main benefit.
@@Wastelandman7000 oh, yeah, I wouldn't want to be hit by one of those things! And sure, they can be used llke that in a pinch - like people clubbed muskets/rifles if bayonets weren't an option.I just meant, if that was the _primary_ purpose of the balls, they'd've been made a bit more weapon-like.
@@raydrexler5868 apart from that, he knows precisely how to move the sword around with minimal effort put in. If you wave it around like a baseball bat, no matter how strong you are, you will tire quickly. It's more aboute effectivity than about strength. Notice he turns the sword a lot around its point of balance, rather than truly "waving" with it, and that he uses his entire body to do so as well.
Never had a problem with wheel pommels. Can't imagine why some people don't like 'em. When I was young they were my idea of a stereotypical medieval sword.
@phillipmargrave521 it may have also limited their use in historical battles, but the improved grip may have been decided to just be more important in life and death battles. Just like all designs, it's a balance between many factors to decide the design to use.
I've generally tried to avoid them since slicing my palm on one with particularly crisp corners (my club bought a bunch of new ones and I was trying it out for a session). I think from memory it was from repeatedly doing cleeving cuts as a feed for my training partners and pulling the swing so I barely tap them was forcing the sharp corner into my palm.
Yes and as Matt said, not being able to look down means it needs to be found by tactile means. When touching a circle you immediately know where your hand is in relation to it, and thus where the grip is. It's a very elegant and reliable solution.
Exactly my thought as well. It wont get caught on your other gear or get ripped out of its sheath by opponents withdrawing weapons etc. Also, your opponent countering your strike should glance off your pommel rather than hooking under it and maybe taking out your little finger.
Another advantage of wheel pommels is that they are pretty good for use offensively. Whether striking down with a hammer fist or straight out punch like a blackjack it will give a good bonk.
You mentioned the chaos of combat and for some reason I thought of a smoke-filled cockpit. In an aircraft cockpit they try to have the important switches & levers of different shapes so they can be found and identified by touch. So I wonder if having your sword have a distinctive pommel - the wheel - might be similar? In the heat of combat you're grasping for your sword and you know you've got it when you encounter a wheel.
Yeah, if you feel the rondel it's the dagger, if you feel the wheel pommel it's the sword, if you don't feel either it might be a canteen or a tube holding a letter (if Europeans did that).
@@novembermike512 Not usually during combat. Carrying your supplies on you is more of a modern military thing; Middle Ages armies tended to leave things like water supplies with the baggage trains and supply personnel.
@@NevisYsbryd Sure, but people didn't just carry swords in battle. You have to get there, you spend time just sitting around, etc. Just because you weren't expecting a fight doesn't mean the fight doesn't come to you, and that's when you'd need the daggers and swords.
Though practice we found out that eventhough pear (or mushroom) shaped pommels on longsword are better for work with your left hand, round ones gives you extra feeling for the blade orientation. Also the mushroom shape tends to hit you hard in the groin if the blade gots stucked in the doorframe while turning and it needs more attention while wearing (My experties- I used to show the use of the swords in the museum of Prague. We were spending 12 hours a day training/ walking around the city towers carying our kits)
It also seemed to create a perfect "ball peen hammer" at the bottom of the fist where it protruded out just enough to knock the daylights out of somebody. Fascinating explanation and really quite brilliant in the context you've outlined. Great video. 👍
Haven't watched the video yet, but I'll say that in my experience in hema, rounded pommels are easier to grip and to control the sword with if you are using heavy or bulky gauntlets
I genuinely like the wheel pommel aesthetically. Round shapes are just simply pleasing. Never before now had I thought about the function of them for gauntleted hands or even just drawing the weapon from its sheath/scabbard.
My thoughts have aligned pretty much with yours on the subject. I think the popularity of wheel pommels is due to the blend of functionality and aesthetics. On a single-handed sword, a wide pommel helps keep the hilt locked in your hand. It can also help with edge alignment. There are a number of styles that would function similarly, but the wheel is aesthetically pleasing - symmetry and balance that is eye-pleasing to a large number of people.
I noticed something similar to this whilst participating in a harnischfecthen tournament last summer. I was using my own dagger with a wheel pommel and had a much easier time finding it and drawing it than some of the other competitors who were using rondel daggers, simply because the wheel was bigger than the rondels
Best thing about the wheel pommel is you can take it off, drill through centre& use it a as a spare skateboard wheel, that’s why they made em round, so knights could have dual usage
really interesting video thank you! in the future a video about pommel design, material, and use would be great (unless you have one and ive missed it...)!
Pommels are for function. (okay, form as well cause who doesn't want to look as cool as possible when holding a sword). If you have an arming sword the function is counterbalance and ensure your ONE hand grip stays where you want it to be during use. Hence a wheel is very functional. However for using a longsword with both hands we still have the counterbalance aspect - although functionally speaking if that was all you were using the pommel for you could have lead inserts under the grip - but we also have to allow for the fact you are controlling the sword with both hands. Now your personal style may vary, but when I use a longsword I am less gripping the sword in my hands as gripping with my fingers, and I am gripping my lower hand on the pommel. When I move I am moving my hand around the pommel as required because that allows me better range of movement when compared to gripping 'hard' with my hands on the grip and only flexing through the wrists. I am also rotating around the long axis of the sword and with this style a wheel pommel would be fighting my hand movement. So, longsword? Smooth onion style pommel for me. Other swords? Well I am not going to be holding them with both hands, so... different situation. Not saying this is 'technically' correct, but it is how I want to hold a longsword and none of my instructors have tried to correct me... yet :P
When I trained long sword, many years ago now, I had a training sword by Pavel moc with model name Talhoffer. (Though our club used Fiore,) It has a wheel pommel that felt like it was made for my hand. It just felt really comfortable and secure to hold in any technique that used a two handed grip. Especially in the side cut where you hold the sword close to your chest where you flip your grip on the pommel, it made a manouvre I thought would be hard really easy. The hand just effortlessly slid into place, really comfortably too. However, why don't you like the gaudy colours? I think they are fabulous!
I'm even surprised that this required a separate video. When I first picked up an exact replica of a Scandinavian sword with a fairly large apple and a very small handle, I was amazed at how rigidly the palm was fixed in it. In fact, the palm is securely clamped between the guard and the pommel. It will be difficult to knock such a sword out of your hands.
I prefer scent stopper on my longswords to use for gripping but have found on my arming sword it actually gets in the way of throwing a cut, the added width hits my forearm and throws off the cut whereas a disk pommel slips past without issue. In an extended handshake grip it allows you to hold the pommel in line with the wrist
This came as a bit of a surprise to me; I tend to practice alone so I don't hear a lot of others' opinions on pommels, but I have a couple swords with wheel pommels on them and I love the wheel pommel for how it can secure a grip on the hilt both bare handed and gauntleted.
I do like this idea a lot. Weapons coming free is a big issue IRL and in sparing like in some groups like the SCA. It's harder, and less safe in a fight in some ways, to have a trigger finger hold, or weapon retention strap for a sword as is popular in some groups. Using a pommel as the thing is a good idea. Now as for me I find them to be keen. I tore all my gripping tendons long ago so sword grip size and shape matters a lot to my ability to fence at all. When it comes to wheel pommels; made right, on the right length grip, they're fantastic at helping me hold onto them. especially when canted ever so slightly to the side on single-handers. I did actually break my finger once sparring using the wheel pommel on a longsword as a lever point. I took the other fellas pommel to the pinky by accident. Not fun at all, but till then it worked a peach!
I used to hate wheel pommels on longswords until I made the effort to train with one. Now they are my favorite type. I think people who complain about them ergonomically probably haven't spent much time with them. If you don't like them aesthetically, then fair enough. But do give them a serious try. The offer a really secure grip and aid in edge alignment.
HI Matt, how you doing, man is funny because the other days I was using my cold steel gladius machete that has a big plastic pommels and was most easy to control and cut with that pommel.
I've never really like wheel pommels, but I do have a soft spot for brazil nut pommels which lock in your hand similarly to how you describe the wheel pommel in this vid, in fact a particularly fancy pair of swords made by Heron Armoury were commissioned by me for myself and my little brother, and they fit amazingly in the hand and sing when they hit things/opponents.
Never understood the dislike for wheel pommels. They sit in the hand nicely and allow easy alignment of the blade. Also help you to turn the sword thumb the blade. The HEMAShop bastard sword hole is also exactly sized to jam a decorative 20p in too.
Fascinating, I’d never considered how much gauntlet geometry would affect the ergonomics of sword construction. I’d always assumed it to be the other way around, having the armour accommodate the tools. Makes perfect sense that the developments would spread both ways.
Question, has anyone ever modified the fleur-de-lis into a spearhead or polearm? It seems it would be a useful melee weapon. Pleeease answer, you're the most knowledgeable person I know of. Loved your guest show with the samurai mazter. He was pretty laid back 🔙
Hello Matt! Directing Henry IV, Part I and I came across a minstrel song about Henry "Hotspur" Percy that refers to he and Douglas fighting with "swords of fine collayne" . Would like to use poem for the play. Could you tell me what "collayne" is? Can't seem to find any info. Thank you! Love your channel.
I really like medieval color schemes. There’s an excitement quality and a feeling of love of life with those colors. Nowadays everything is either just a shade of grey or full-blown rainbow and glitter
Amateur longsword HEMA practitioner here. I don't have that many experiences with different kinds of pommels, but here goes. I've handled red dragon (rawlings) longswords with and without a wheel pommel. Those particular sparring lonswords don't have totally rounded handles, but rather "elliptical" ones, to help with edge alignment. I've also found out that I can handle them a lot better with a pear shaped pommel , as it does not "dig into" my hands like the wheel shaped one. With sparring gloves, I also find it much harder to wield the sword with a wheel pommer rather than a pear shaped one, especially with circular motions.
Please do a video on the leather gloves they used. As a civilian, without a shield, sturdy gloves allows of gripping a enemy blade more easily, as well as protecting against cuts that would end the fight early.
Ballpark before the answer. Its easier to balance a sword with a large pommel. Especially to fit an individual. They would also be easier to cast as well. So less work. It would also make it easier to index the edge. As it would fit the lower curve of a clenched fist. Allowing you to feel without looking, whether you have the blade correctly held.
I don't know if they did it historically or not, but wheel pommels are also well-suited to mount something like a gem or medallion in the center, or for decoration like knotwork.
I've used a lot of swords in fights, the wheel pommel is really working very well, eg in handling and have a nice feel and balance to it... There is a reason why there are so much of those around...
My suburito {heavy training stick} has a bulb on the endd of the handle. Helps when I'm tired and my grip starts to slacken... it's not meant to be there. But I made the thing myself out of a rail road sleeper.
That's a great insight Matt. My pretty cheap sword collection started c25 yeaars ago & my first sword was a Deepeeka(I hear you, but I'm not rich!) "Archers sword, which is a smaller arming sword with a ball/globe pommel, quite a large one c2 inch diameter. It must be quite hollow as it's not heavy. While I love the sword still, the pommel bugs me , is a little too large to assist sword use(not that I do, these are just all hanging eye candy & historic interest) & I always fancied changing it for a wheel pommel. But what I wondered is if ball-sphere pommel ever were a thing? Is there any actual historical provenance or is it just the invention of a modern Indian sword maker?
In my (admitteldly limited) experience, the flattened shape also helps with maintaining edge alignment. My small finger can tell the orientation of the pommel and thus the blade.
I love wheel pommels, but it might be what I'm used to. I think they feel great in the hand. Most of the replicas I own have wheel pommels. And, yes, they look great! Of course, I'm just a collector/backyard cutter, not a practitioner of medieval martial arts. However, I AM a visual artist, and usually depict non-Viking-era medieval-type swords in my art having wheel pommels. Not ALWAYS, but usually.
No idea if this is supported by any evidence from the time but I find that since wheel pommels stand proud of the hand where as pear pommels sit into the hand far more, its much easier to hit someone with a wheel pommel with a hammer fist compared to a pear pommel.
Does the edge of the wheel pummel rub you hand abrasively? Or would it do so if you were striking and parrying? I can’t really tell if it would from the video, if you used it barehanded.
I always liked the look of scent stopper pommels, wheel pommels look good too. Scent stoppers look less likely to hurt your hand with prolonged use. After this video wheel pommels seem more attractive than I first thought.
It is interesting hearing this juxtaposed to having watched some of the Chinese Dao videos. Is there anything particularly different between the wheel pommels and the dao's common ring causing such a difference in preference?
I can't help but wonder if, from a mass production standpoint, ease of making the simple disc combined with the functional points you covered to make this the preferred choice for stocking in your ducal or royal armories. So this might not be the pommel one would have on their personal or family sword. But could it have been the one handed out to recently conscripted bowman or as a quick replacement for blades damaged or lost in combat?
I like wheel pommels for keeping blade alignment. I feel like it helps. I don't like it on two handed swords though. I prefer having a rounded knob like a plum pommel when I'm using both hands.
I love wheel pommels, to the point I've added one to my wooden training sword (that, like my training mates from the time, had nothing at the end of the handle)
I just prefer a smooth wheel pommel. Those that have a raised center are rougher. On daggers , I like antenna pommels over rondel or wheel pommels as they lock better than the wheel, but give more maneuverability than the rondels, and may even catch an opponent's blade.
I only have experiences with pear and scent stopper pommels. I'm curios how wheel pommels might effect sparring and cutting? Weight distribution, edge alignment, etc.
It seems they have some wheely compelling benefits. I'm sure people will come 'round to using them. Even if they don't, it's an interesting disc-ussion.
From a purely aesthetic point of view my most favourite sword design is Glamdring, the sword of Gandalf from LOTR. Following in a close second place is Anduril. BTW: I would be interested to know what you think of the pommel that is used on Anduril?
The wheel-pommelled single handed arming sword from about 1400 is, imho, one of the most efficient and handsome "backup weapons" ever made. Finished one in pattern-welded steel last fall and just commissioned to forge another.
Would an egg pommel achieve the same effect of grip assistance? Or not really. Working with a friend to design a sword and wondering which I should go with, like them both equally.
Question for you Matt. I've always been interested in armor like you guys are wearing. A person with a long staff, a very good one, wielded by someone who is martial with it, could they overwhelm the fellow in armor with speed, dexterity, etc? I guess my thought comes from American football which I played alot thru high school and junior college (too small at 185lbs for Div 1. Also, not fast enough). In that game, size and strength matter, but speed wins.
I just figured one of the reasons the wheel pommel is good, is that it passively helps you getting a good handle on your swords' edge alignment without having to look at it. Great when you are using gloves/gauntlets.
Hi Matt, really Silly question here are you and Tod using opposite sides of the same set of doors as your video backdrop ???
LOL, I love the idea of that! But no, sadly... If he was next door then it would make a lot of things easier!
@@scholagladiatoria No it wouldn't, neither of you would get anything done. You'd be too busy theory crafting and gassing the hours away. 😂
@@XploreNorfolkBut they'd do it on camera and we'd watch it.
Well, I bloody love wheel pommels. I think one other thing about the disc shape is that it can be pretty wide - ie in its diameter - without having to be especially thick. So it can be visually very striking, with a wide profile and decent weight but slim enough not to get in the way of anything when it’s moving around. If that makes any sense at all…
I can't find these for sale anywhere...
"Do you have a minute", "I'll keep this brief."
Okay Matt, I'll put on the tea kettle and bake some cookies.
Hey now, 11 minutes is basically a brief overview of the cliff notes for Matt!
I was just coming back upstairs with a hot coffee before I clicked on play haha.
Nothing better to start the day with, than hot coffee and steel!
I was surprised he didn't say anything about the wheel pommel specifically regarding *edge alignment feel.*
When you're grappling or reaching for a sword you can't see, the wheel pommel lets you know as your fingers reach for it how you're going to hold it. The handle does it, too, but the wheel pommel really helps. Also, *if you're carrying it around,* the wheel pommel sits more flatly against your person compared to other shapes.
Agree, I thought knowing your edge alignment without looking would be a main reason to use a wheel pommel.
I agree as well. I moved from a scent stopper to a wheel pommel specifically for indexing while wearing gauntlets.
I think there's probably a happy medium that could be attained between a scent stopper and a wheel that would maybe be vaguely scallop shell shaped. The issue with wheel pommels is that there's a fairly harsh 90 degree angle right at the edge of your pinky finger. Sabers often have a similar problem inherently but get around it by just flaring out the grip a bit right before the transition to the basket ring
I'm reminded by your comments of the similarity to those early horseman's pistols that have those great big spheres on the ends of the handles. Good for pulling from saddle reliably in the thick of a battle.
Also good for whacking if you don’t have time to swap to your sword.
@@Specter_1125 True, true. Though given the balls - at least for the examples I remember seeing in museums - were typically not made of (or shod with) metal, I suspect that being able to use your pistol as a club is a side-benefit compared to the "not fumbling/dropping your pistol" main benefit.
@@pseudomonad in a pinch, blunt force trauma is blunt force trauma
@@Wastelandman7000 oh, yeah, I wouldn't want to be hit by one of those things! And sure, they can be used llke that in a pinch - like people clubbed muskets/rifles if bayonets weren't an option.I just meant, if that was the _primary_ purpose of the balls, they'd've been made a bit more weapon-like.
"and I have limited movement" Waves it around like it's an empty wrapping paper tube.
Haha, thought the same! :D
His sword muscles are well developed.
@@raydrexler5868 apart from that, he knows precisely how to move the sword around with minimal effort put in. If you wave it around like a baseball bat, no matter how strong you are, you will tire quickly. It's more aboute effectivity than about strength. Notice he turns the sword a lot around its point of balance, rather than truly "waving" with it, and that he uses his entire body to do so as well.
Never had a problem with wheel pommels. Can't imagine why some people don't like 'em. When I was young they were my idea of a stereotypical medieval sword.
I find they restrict my wrist movement and force me to use draw cuts. Maybe I’m not using correct form.
I do like the way they look.
Literally thinking the same thing
@phillipmargrave521 it may have also limited their use in historical battles, but the improved grip may have been decided to just be more important in life and death battles. Just like all designs, it's a balance between many factors to decide the design to use.
I've generally tried to avoid them since slicing my palm on one with particularly crisp corners (my club bought a bunch of new ones and I was trying it out for a session).
I think from memory it was from repeatedly doing cleeving cuts as a feed for my training partners and pulling the swing so I barely tap them was forcing the sharp corner into my palm.
My first medieval sword is a hand and a half sword with a wheel pommel, and I can tell you it is not very useful for longsword techniques.
I think a wheel pommel is the best because it doesn’t get caught in clothing and it’s comfortable to rest your hand on when it’s on your belt.
Yes and as Matt said, not being able to look down means it needs to be found by tactile means. When touching a circle you immediately know where your hand is in relation to it, and thus where the grip is. It's a very elegant and reliable solution.
Same. They have just about all the benefits of a sphere, but removing the sides also allows them to lay flatter and can help with indexing the edges.
@@Seppleberrythey were usually hollow. A lump of steel that big would put the point of balance too far back.
I agree that getting caught on things is an important concern that often gets overlooked.
Exactly my thought as well. It wont get caught on your other gear or get ripped out of its sheath by opponents withdrawing weapons etc. Also, your opponent countering your strike should glance off your pommel rather than hooking under it and maybe taking out your little finger.
Another advantage of wheel pommels is that they are pretty good for use offensively. Whether striking down with a hammer fist or straight out punch like a blackjack it will give a good bonk.
I think most pummel shapes do that fine.
Yes but sticking out a bit more might help slightly more than most for some attacks.
You mentioned the chaos of combat and for some reason I thought of a smoke-filled cockpit. In an aircraft cockpit they try to have the important switches & levers of different shapes so they can be found and identified by touch. So I wonder if having your sword have a distinctive pommel - the wheel - might be similar? In the heat of combat you're grasping for your sword and you know you've got it when you encounter a wheel.
Yeah, if you feel the rondel it's the dagger, if you feel the wheel pommel it's the sword, if you don't feel either it might be a canteen or a tube holding a letter (if Europeans did that).
@@novembermike512 Not usually during combat. Carrying your supplies on you is more of a modern military thing; Middle Ages armies tended to leave things like water supplies with the baggage trains and supply personnel.
@@NevisYsbryd Sure, but people didn't just carry swords in battle. You have to get there, you spend time just sitting around, etc. Just because you weren't expecting a fight doesn't mean the fight doesn't come to you, and that's when you'd need the daggers and swords.
If it makes sense now then it made sense then
Though practice we found out that eventhough pear (or mushroom) shaped pommels on longsword are better for work with your left hand, round ones gives you extra feeling for the blade orientation.
Also the mushroom shape tends to hit you hard in the groin if the blade gots stucked in the doorframe while turning and it needs more attention while wearing
(My experties- I used to show the use of the swords in the museum of Prague. We were spending 12 hours a day training/ walking around the city towers carying our kits)
It also seemed to create a perfect "ball peen hammer" at the bottom of the fist where it protruded out just enough to knock the daylights out of somebody. Fascinating explanation and really quite brilliant in the context you've outlined. Great video. 👍
I've also found wheel pommels to aid in edge alignment with single handed swords, especially in the handshake grip.
Haven't watched the video yet, but I'll say that in my experience in hema, rounded pommels are easier to grip and to control the sword with if you are using heavy or bulky gauntlets
A video dedicated to just breaking down the cultural aesthetics of a place/period to their approach to sword design would be really interesting!
I have always liked wheel pommels. They give a nice feel for edge alignment, and are also great for the second hand on a hand and a half grip.
I absolutely love wheel pommels. They are incredibly helpful with edge alignment.
I agree, using longsword with wheel and pear pommel, the wheel let's me use the palm to improve edge alignment. Also looks way cooler IMHO
Pizza wheel pommel! 😂🤣
@@Ealsur 🙌
@@kristianhartlevjohansen3541 Mmmmm... pizza sword.
@@KunstdesfechtensI raise you a burgher(burger) sword.
I genuinely like the wheel pommel aesthetically. Round shapes are just simply pleasing. Never before now had I thought about the function of them for gauntleted hands or even just drawing the weapon from its sheath/scabbard.
My thoughts have aligned pretty much with yours on the subject. I think the popularity of wheel pommels is due to the blend of functionality and aesthetics. On a single-handed sword, a wide pommel helps keep the hilt locked in your hand. It can also help with edge alignment. There are a number of styles that would function similarly, but the wheel is aesthetically pleasing - symmetry and balance that is eye-pleasing to a large number of people.
Another amazing and informative presentation. Thank you.
Amazing observation and finding! That makes total sense to me. Thank you for sharing this valuable information!!
I love the wheel pommel on my arming sword. It doesn't impede my gauntleted hand in combat at all, yet it's perfectly weighted.
I noticed something similar to this whilst participating in a harnischfecthen tournament last summer. I was using my own dagger with a wheel pommel and had a much easier time finding it and drawing it than some of the other competitors who were using rondel daggers, simply because the wheel was bigger than the rondels
Best thing about the wheel pommel is you can take it off, drill through centre& use it a as a spare skateboard wheel, that’s why they made em round, so knights could have dual usage
really interesting video thank you! in the future a video about pommel design, material, and use would be great (unless you have one and ive missed it...)!
Pommels are for function. (okay, form as well cause who doesn't want to look as cool as possible when holding a sword).
If you have an arming sword the function is counterbalance and ensure your ONE hand grip stays where you want it to be during use. Hence a wheel is very functional.
However for using a longsword with both hands we still have the counterbalance aspect - although functionally speaking if that was all you were using the pommel for you could have lead inserts under the grip - but we also have to allow for the fact you are controlling the sword with both hands.
Now your personal style may vary, but when I use a longsword I am less gripping the sword in my hands as gripping with my fingers, and I am gripping my lower hand on the pommel. When I move I am moving my hand around the pommel as required because that allows me better range of movement when compared to gripping 'hard' with my hands on the grip and only flexing through the wrists. I am also rotating around the long axis of the sword and with this style a wheel pommel would be fighting my hand movement.
So, longsword? Smooth onion style pommel for me.
Other swords? Well I am not going to be holding them with both hands, so... different situation.
Not saying this is 'technically' correct, but it is how I want to hold a longsword and none of my instructors have tried to correct me... yet :P
I love your famous quick videos.
I love how they loook and feel
When I trained long sword, many years ago now, I had a training sword by Pavel moc with model name Talhoffer. (Though our club used Fiore,) It has a wheel pommel that felt like it was made for my hand. It just felt really comfortable and secure to hold in any technique that used a two handed grip. Especially in the side cut where you hold the sword close to your chest where you flip your grip on the pommel, it made a manouvre I thought would be hard really easy. The hand just effortlessly slid into place, really comfortably too.
However, why don't you like the gaudy colours? I think they are fabulous!
I'm even surprised that this required a separate video.
When I first picked up an exact replica of a Scandinavian sword with a fairly large apple and a very small handle, I was amazed at how rigidly the palm was fixed in it. In fact, the palm is securely clamped between the guard and the pommel. It will be difficult to knock such a sword out of your hands.
I prefer scent stopper on my longswords to use for gripping but have found on my arming sword it actually gets in the way of throwing a cut, the added width hits my forearm and throws off the cut whereas a disk pommel slips past without issue. In an extended handshake grip it allows you to hold the pommel in line with the wrist
The effects of a non-rounded shape is what i was wondering about having never handled one. Cool feedback
I find it really nice with longswords or feder for edge alignment
They also look very cool. Never underestimate the popularity of something people like the look of.
especially in medieval Europe.
Perfect circle hand smithed and polished? VERY fancy. Probably a smith's way of showing off their skill and toolkit, too.
Also, easily to bling. What it fancy looking, hammer a coin into the center
@@PJDAltamirus0425 not to mention those sexy Irish ring pommels
Paint it in your team colors. Gild with gold and engraving.
I like wheel pommels on my longswords too. They're comfortable to grip with my off hand, and help index the edge alignment.
This came as a bit of a surprise to me; I tend to practice alone so I don't hear a lot of others' opinions on pommels, but I have a couple swords with wheel pommels on them and I love the wheel pommel for how it can secure a grip on the hilt both bare handed and gauntleted.
I do like this idea a lot. Weapons coming free is a big issue IRL and in sparing like in some groups like the SCA. It's harder, and less safe in a fight in some ways, to have a trigger finger hold, or weapon retention strap for a sword as is popular in some groups. Using a pommel as the thing is a good idea.
Now as for me I find them to be keen. I tore all my gripping tendons long ago so sword grip size and shape matters a lot to my ability to fence at all. When it comes to wheel pommels; made right, on the right length grip, they're fantastic at helping me hold onto them. especially when canted ever so slightly to the side on single-handers.
I did actually break my finger once sparring using the wheel pommel on a longsword as a lever point. I took the other fellas pommel to the pinky by accident. Not fun at all, but till then it worked a peach!
I used to hate wheel pommels on longswords until I made the effort to train with one. Now they are my favorite type. I think people who complain about them ergonomically probably haven't spent much time with them. If you don't like them aesthetically, then fair enough. But do give them a serious try. The offer a really secure grip and aid in edge alignment.
Yeah but I don't have difficulty with my edge alignment because I use fishtails.
HI Matt, how you doing, man is funny because the other days I was using my cold steel gladius machete that has a big plastic pommels and was most easy to control and cut with that pommel.
I've never really like wheel pommels, but I do have a soft spot for brazil nut pommels which lock in your hand similarly to how you describe the wheel pommel in this vid, in fact a particularly fancy pair of swords made by Heron Armoury were commissioned by me for myself and my little brother, and they fit amazingly in the hand and sing when they hit things/opponents.
Your blued steel armor is so awesome.
I have two swords with wheel pommels. They are very comforting 😊😂
You work with Windlass? That's super cool!!
That's absolutely fascinating! I didn't know that!
Never understood the dislike for wheel pommels. They sit in the hand nicely and allow easy alignment of the blade. Also help you to turn the sword thumb the blade. The HEMAShop bastard sword hole is also exactly sized to jam a decorative 20p in too.
9:39-9:42 I agree. My favourite OC (Original Character) uses a sword with a wheel pommel.
i guess its a a good way to have a good to grip counterweight that is a bit of protection as well ... and a great place to show of fancy decorations
Fascinating, I’d never considered how much gauntlet geometry would affect the ergonomics of sword construction. I’d always assumed it to be the other way around, having the armour accommodate the tools. Makes perfect sense that the developments would spread both ways.
That'll help guide edge alignment too I'd think...
It totally does.
Question, has anyone ever modified the fleur-de-lis into a spearhead or polearm? It seems it would be a useful melee weapon. Pleeease answer, you're the most knowledgeable person I know of.
Loved your guest show with the samurai mazter. He was pretty laid back 🔙
I hope he keeps us up to date on that windlass sword. I really like the look of it
Hello Matt! Directing Henry IV, Part I and I came across a minstrel song about Henry "Hotspur" Percy that refers to he and Douglas fighting with "swords of fine collayne" . Would like to use poem for the play. Could you tell me what "collayne" is? Can't seem to find any info. Thank you! Love your channel.
Good video & keep it up ⚔️
I really like medieval color schemes. There’s an excitement quality and a feeling of love of life with those colors. Nowadays everything is either just a shade of grey or full-blown rainbow and glitter
Thanks, Matt.
Amateur longsword HEMA practitioner here. I don't have that many experiences with different kinds of pommels, but here goes. I've handled red dragon (rawlings) longswords with and without a wheel pommel. Those particular sparring lonswords don't have totally rounded handles, but rather "elliptical" ones, to help with edge alignment. I've also found out that I can handle them a lot better with a pear shaped pommel , as it does not "dig into" my hands like the wheel shaped one. With sparring gloves, I also find it much harder to wield the sword with a wheel pommer rather than a pear shaped one, especially with circular motions.
Please please please! Make the Royal Armory Type A Castillon sword with Windlass
Please do a video on the leather gloves they used. As a civilian, without a shield, sturdy gloves allows of gripping a enemy blade more easily, as well as protecting against cuts that would end the fight early.
I have Albion Crecy War Sword with wheel pommel. I really like the pommel. It feels good in hand.
I always preferred a wheel pomel on my arming sword! The wheel really keeps it in your hand!
Ballpark before the answer. Its easier to balance a sword with a large pommel. Especially to fit an individual. They would also be easier to cast as well. So less work. It would also make it easier to index the edge. As it would fit the lower curve of a clenched fist. Allowing you to feel without looking, whether you have the blade correctly held.
I don't know if they did it historically or not, but wheel pommels are also well-suited to mount something like a gem or medallion in the center, or for decoration like knotwork.
I've used a lot of swords in fights, the wheel pommel is really working very well, eg in handling and have a nice feel and balance to it... There is a reason why there are so much of those around...
My suburito {heavy training stick} has a bulb on the endd of the handle. Helps when I'm tired and my grip starts to slacken... it's not meant to be there. But I made the thing myself out of a rail road sleeper.
Informative video.
That's a great insight Matt.
My pretty cheap sword collection started c25 yeaars ago & my first sword was a Deepeeka(I hear you, but I'm not rich!) "Archers sword, which is a smaller arming sword with a ball/globe pommel, quite a large one c2 inch diameter. It must be quite hollow as it's not heavy. While I love the sword still, the pommel bugs me , is a little too large to assist sword use(not that I do, these are just all hanging eye candy & historic interest) & I always fancied changing it for a wheel pommel. But what I wondered is if ball-sphere pommel ever were a thing? Is there any actual historical provenance or is it just the invention of a modern Indian sword maker?
Can't wait to buy that sword!
It adds balance to swords and became a good look
I use a wheel pommeled feder since hema gauntlents are similar to plate gauntlets, and I can feel my edge alignment through it.
In my (admitteldly limited) experience, the flattened shape also helps with maintaining edge alignment. My small finger can tell the orientation of the pommel and thus the blade.
great point!
I love wheel pommels, but it might be what I'm used to. I think they feel great in the hand. Most of the replicas I own have wheel pommels. And, yes, they look great! Of course, I'm just a collector/backyard cutter, not a practitioner of medieval martial arts. However, I AM a visual artist, and usually depict non-Viking-era medieval-type swords in my art having wheel pommels. Not ALWAYS, but usually.
No idea if this is supported by any evidence from the time but I find that since wheel pommels stand proud of the hand where as pear pommels sit into the hand far more, its much easier to hit someone with a wheel pommel with a hammer fist compared to a pear pommel.
they’re aerodynamically shaped for easier throwing… to end them rightly
Came to find this comment and was not disappointed!
Here for the meme 🫡
I was getting concerned. I was looking for it. It is now officially required.
hay do you have advice on closing the distance with someone who makes big fast sweeping motions with their sword.
Can wheel pommels be unscrewed and rightly thrown?
y e s
I use a S&W 40 pommel. Good stuff always learn sumtang here
Does the edge of the wheel pummel rub you hand abrasively? Or would it do so if you were striking and parrying? I can’t really tell if it would from the video, if you used it barehanded.
I always liked the look of scent stopper pommels, wheel pommels look good too.
Scent stoppers look less likely to hurt your hand with prolonged use.
After this video wheel pommels seem more attractive than I first thought.
It is interesting hearing this juxtaposed to having watched some of the Chinese Dao videos.
Is there anything particularly different between the wheel pommels and the dao's common ring causing such a difference in preference?
Because they're wheely good, of course! I'll get my coat.
BOOOOO!
Your coat of plates!
That's a wheely good joke!
Yep
I haven't tried wielding one, but I simply like the look of the wheel pommel.
I can't help but wonder if, from a mass production standpoint, ease of making the simple disc combined with the functional points you covered to make this the preferred choice for stocking in your ducal or royal armories. So this might not be the pommel one would have on their personal or family sword. But could it have been the one handed out to recently conscripted bowman or as a quick replacement for blades damaged or lost in combat?
I like wheel pommels for keeping blade alignment. I feel like it helps. I don't like it on two handed swords though. I prefer having a rounded knob like a plum pommel when I'm using both hands.
I love wheel pommels, to the point I've added one to my wooden training sword (that, like my training mates from the time, had nothing at the end of the handle)
I just prefer a smooth wheel pommel. Those that have a raised center are rougher. On daggers , I like antenna pommels over rondel or wheel pommels as they lock better than the wheel, but give more maneuverability than the rondels, and may even catch an opponent's blade.
What sword is that? I love it! It's gorgeous!
I only have experiences with pear and scent stopper pommels. I'm curios how wheel pommels might effect sparring and cutting? Weight distribution, edge alignment, etc.
It seems they have some wheely compelling benefits. I'm sure people will come 'round to using them. Even if they don't, it's an interesting disc-ussion.
From a purely aesthetic point of view my most favourite sword design is Glamdring, the sword of Gandalf from LOTR. Following in a close second place is Anduril. BTW: I would be interested to know what you think of the pommel that is used on Anduril?
I would love to own one of these.
The wheel-pommelled single handed arming sword from about 1400 is, imho, one of the most efficient and handsome "backup weapons" ever made. Finished one in pattern-welded steel last fall and just commissioned to forge another.
A square pomel may have been more likely to catch on fabric - clothing, straps, etc. A round pomel doesn't have pointy bits to catch.
Do I have a minute? For you Matt I have as much time as you need. 👍👍
Would an egg pommel achieve the same effect of grip assistance? Or not really. Working with a friend to design a sword and wondering which I should go with, like them both equally.
Question for you Matt. I've always been interested in armor like you guys are wearing. A person with a long staff, a very good one, wielded by someone who is martial with it, could they overwhelm the fellow in armor with speed, dexterity, etc? I guess my thought comes from American football which I played alot thru high school and junior college (too small at 185lbs for Div 1. Also, not fast enough). In that game, size and strength matter, but speed wins.
A question on the wheel pommels, are they usually hollow or solid,
the Irish had hollowed out wheel pommels to lighten the weight of the hilt making the sword better at chopping
They did! I need to do a video on Irish swords soon...
I absolutely love round and ring pommels!
Did you ever go back and explain the longsword?
guess he forgot to turn the camera on for that take
I feel like he meant in a different video maybe.
Now I’d never wondered about this but once I saw the sentence I had to find out
I just figured one of the reasons the wheel pommel is good, is that it passively helps you getting a good handle on your swords' edge alignment without having to look at it. Great when you are using gloves/gauntlets.