Это видео недоступно.
Сожалеем об этом.
Philippines and U.S. Cooperate on Maritime Law Enforcement | Taiwan Talks EP371
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 15 авг 2024
- The Philippines and U.S. are working to develop cooperative maritime law enforcement procedures as Chinese aggression continues in the South China Sea. In this episode of “Taiwan Talks,” we look at multilateral alliances in the Indo-Pacific region, U.S. policies on Asia, and global diplomatic shifts. Additionally, we examine whether the U.S. will take action to retaliate against China, and how these developments will affect the security of Taiwan.
Our guests are:
Yen Chen-Shen
- National Chengchi University Professor of Political Science
Guermantes Lailari
- Institute for National Defense and Security Research (INDSR) Visiting Scholar
Chapters:
00:00:00 - Introduction
00:00:32 - Significance of Philippines-U.S. Maritime Law Enforcement
00:01:21 - Potential for Multilateral Security Pacts in the Indo-Pacific
00:05:55 - Trump and Biden’s Policies on China, Asia
00:08:35 - ASEAN Opinions on China, U.S.
00:11:33 - India Shifting Away From China, Russia Ties
00:14:59 - Comparing Maritime Law Operation With Existing Defense Treaties
00:19:00 - Concrete Action To Retaliate Against China?
00:21:35 - Is U.S. Bogged Down by Multiple Conflicts?
9 dash line was a grave miscalculation by the PRC. They never anticipated the Philippines MDA with the US could be triggered. Now more build up of American forces in addition to what’s already in Korea and Japan. Good job PRC for excluding that in your analysis. The best part, PRC cannot back down from their 9DL anymore and look weaker. This will give more and more excuses for the EU and US to reinforce and buildup Manila more under the banner of UNCLOS and FONOP on top of the MDA.
MDT Is garbage lol if you think U.S. is going to come” save” you
We can add: one of the major reasons President Trump placed large tariff on China which has now morphed into a total chip sanction, is China’s aggressive claim in the WPS.
Japan has alwaysbeen in the Philippines JICA has been investing in the Phils for the longest time.
The Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA) is a governmental agency that delivers the bulk of Official Development Assistance (ODA) to the government of Japan. It is chartered with assisting economic and social growth in developing countries and promoting international cooperation. JICA is not a military alliance between the Philippines and Japan.
The Philippines and Japanese government agreed to start negotiations for a defense pact called the Reciprocal Access Agreement (RAA), aiming to facilitate the presence of visiting forces and conduct joint military training activities. If formally signed, it would be Japan’s first RAA with a member of the Association of Southeast Asian Nations and Japan’s third overall.
The Japan-Philippines-U.S. trilateral alliance is still on the table... Once, this alliance is finalized then this will be China's headache. This trilateral partnership is built on deep historical ties… and a shared vision for a free and open Indo-Pacific.
@@militarybrat74 yes i agree my point is JICA has always extended help and provided assistance to our country.Not militarily but economically and for that i am grateful.
I'm a Filipino and we will fight for our rights period...
Tama k kabayan we filipinos will fight our rights and we fight till the end
You have to fight against USA to have your rights for USA already took away your rights when U have to listen n obey USA instructions , Philippine have no rights at all .
The US had always had the Defense Pact with the Philippines since the 1950s. This EDCA now actually enhances this. So since the 1950s it always had been an attack on the Philippines has always been like an attack on the US, and any war with the US always got the Philippines involved (Korean, Vietnam Wars, Involvement in the 1990 Iraqi War).
For Indonesia, it's not entirely Pro-US as the Philippines but it still remains in much more favorable towards US in terms of Military Cooperation. It is likely that the Philippines will be supporting Indonesia position to lead ASEAN Political-Security, especially in terms of Territorial Integrity and Maritime Safety of the Waters of it's Members, indirectly supporting the Philippines stance with the ASEAN Framework. Bilaterally, Philippines and Indonesia will consolidate a Maritime Partnership on Governance and Management of the Seas, under the UNCLOS, particularly with given focus on The Archipelagic Doctrine, that is initiated and pushed to be ratified by the Philippines, with support from fellow Archipelagic States like Indonesia, Japan and New Zealand.
With these Philippine-Indonesia Security Partnership will come several trilaterals and quadrilateral groups will be created both within ASEAN and with it's Outside Partners.
First, Japan-Philippines-Indonesia, securing the North-South Maritime Trade Routes that is mostly falls under BIMP-EAGA Development Agenda, which is a potential Trade Alternative when a South China Sea Routes are Disrupted and closed due to possible conflict or war.
There's Philippines-Indonesia-Australia, which will be augmented from the Trilateral between Japan-Philippines-Australia. And expanded to Quadrilateral Groupings with Indonesia added to it, securing the North-South/East-West Trade Routes from Indian Ocean to the Philippine Sea thru Indonesian-Philippine Seas in between.
But beforehand, Indonesia first needed to have Trilaterals with Australia-Japan.
Other Trilaterals/Quadrilaterals is between:
-Philippines-Indonesia-India
-Philippines-Indonesia-Vietnam/Thailand
-Philippines-Indonesia-Vietnam-Thailand
-JAPHUS-Indonesia
-Philippines-Indonesia-USA
-Philippines-Indonesia-East Timor
-Philippines-Indonesia-Papua New Guinea
-Philippines-Indonesia-South Korea
-Philippines-Indonesia-New Zealand
-Philippines-Indonesia-Australia-New Zealand
Wow! Nice read
Well explained ! We all wish to come out this way for the greater good 👍
Indonesia is non aligned. As a trading nation with China as it's largest trading partner, it doesn't make sense to get involved in this dispute.
Taiwan talks has always been a good , informative and unbiased. Important issues presented are well discussed . Thanks.
The laws of the Sea's, EEZ territory, in the International law must follow in every nation. And the freedom of Navigation must impose.
West Philippines Sea only refers to the Philippines' EEZ, however, Southeast Asian Sea which encompasses the entirety of the South China Sea makes a lot more sense.
Correct. There needs to be a stronger, coordinated, and constant clarification of this point by our government since people both Filipino, and foreign are confused by this, unfortunately. We're in this for our maritime legal entitlements, not to annex a whole sea unlike China.
You're right. The entire South China Sea is like the Philippine Sea that is located in east of Philippines and other countries which stretched up to Guam. Philippine Sea is not entirely owned or have rights to Philippines but only the EEZ, it is only named after Philippines. Same with South China Sea it is only named after them but the greedy chinese govt owning entire of it with the baseless 9/10 dash lines
@@Raygun8888 Yup. The only reason for renaming South China Sea (portions of it) to West Philippine Sea is because Communist China thinks that just because its named South China Sea is that they own everything thats in there. Aside from UNCLOS which they signed the mere distance for the South China Sea to mainland China makes their claims more ridiculous. Their only point for their expansionism is because they are strong economically and militarily (Not for long though).
There's an ongoing Philippine - Taiwan - US - Japan security talk behind the scenes.
Happy ng mga taiwanese puro ph topic nila...kasi Anjan pinas nkabantay sa kanila
The Philippines is working to Protect Taiwan & Keep Democratic Society & Values in Asia. Communist China cannot BE allowed to Expand further anywhere in Asia. Taiwanese should be very Greatful for the Efforts and Peace & Freedom Loving Filipinos as Taiwan was also part of the Ancient Pilipinas- Formosa. 😊
Best discussions and ideas. Kudos Taiwan.
GUERMANTES LAILARI he was right to say that it was a south east asian sea not a china sea
Thank You Taiwan Talks.
Free the Philippines
From
Who?
Yeah, free the Philippine EEZ from Chinese occupation.
Free the hongkong Taiwan,tibet and Uyghur to China😅
Free Bhutan from China, Free Tibet , Free Hong Kong, Free Macao and Free Taiwan from threat , let them all be free and democratic. No to China Communism No to dictatorship.
@@davinxi5926usa
I think it we should just call the area SOUTHEAST ASIAN SEA, basically Sea sea.
If Taiwan wants a 100% support of philippines, honoring the UNCLOS ruling in favor to philippines is one of the greatest decision.
What? Taiwan has no territorial dispute with china? What are you saying about
Taiwan there have many countries at your side. Specially 🇺🇸 🇵🇭.
The interviewer is great
well said, nice analytical geopolitics discussion. keep it up.
We are with you tiawan too
Philippines 🇵🇭 will help Taiwan 🇹🇼 for freedom and Democracy. No to slavery.
The reason the ASEAN nations (Singapore, Indonesia, Malaysia, Thailand, laos, Cambodia, Brunei) are dumbfounded in the issue of the West Philippine sea is because they are sleeping with China. Most of their infrastructures are built under the Chinese belt n Road initiatives. These countries has debt loan from China while the Philippines chooses Japan and tge U.S.
The United States, Japan, South Korea and Australia are trying to prove that the United States in her allies can do better compare to china. They are investing heavily in the Philippine hoping the ASEAN will follow suit.
The United States and her Allies are leaving China. Japan, South korea, united states will bail out their investments from China.The ASEAN should realized that China's economy is hanging in the rope without the U.S., Japan, South Korea.
PH made back dealings with China over islands they didn’t technically own. This political theater is just for show for the embarrassment for getting in the jar red handed for the secret dealing. With Duerte and xi. They’re the same side
The US, South Korea, Japan, and Australia can't and won't do better than China economically for the Southeast Asian region, the market size is not even comparable. The US is also on the other side of the globe. China has been the biggest trading partner for SEA for a long time, it's not just about them building infrastructure. Even for the Philippines, China is still their no.1 trading partner, even more so if you include Hong Kong (they separate China with HK in their reports). China + HK alone comprises around 25% of their trade.
@hitthedeck4115 how about if I tell you without the U.S investments in China, China will be in famine?
What about the combination investments of U.SA, Japan and South Korea?
You know nothing yet.
@@zzzzzsleeping It may or may not. But one thing is very clear since you can just look up at the data freely available, that Southeast Asian's prosperity and development is coupled to China with how trade works.
Taiwan should be part of maritime law enforcement group.
An ASIAN NATO is a must, given the serious threat posed by China
Wow! Mr. Lailari’s analysis are excellent and on point. 👍🏼👏
Why not ask Unclos?
thumbs up
The best international name for that sea is Southeast Asian Sea, Local name in each country should be West Philippine Sea for Philippines waters and Vietnam East Sea for Vietnam waters.
PH should withdraw to Useless ASEAN nation and form Taiwan-Japan-US-Korea Alliance.
And don't forget Australia & India forging an alliance with the group to deter China's expansionist agenda.
Why withdraw? Where in fact it is economic cooperation its main thrust
I like the name Southeast Asian Sea instead of calling it South China Sea.
I remember in time of u.s president George w bush and our former phil.president Gloria macapagal arroyo... Philippines became a non NATO allied so there's a possibility that NATO will be there
USA USA USA💪
The problem with Trump becoming president will be his stance on Ukraine, which has more immediate global ramifications.
Trump and Putin understand each other.
Trump can say, look Putin, sell your oil to the European or to the world. The profit from the oil goes to the reparations of Ukraine including those killed and injured. Withdraw from Ukraine and everything is par.
The Russian boycott will be deleted case per case from THE ALLIES OF THE U.S. AND THE U.S. ITSELF. THERE WILL BE A TIMETABLE OF NEGOTIATIONS.
Putin is in the hole, he doesn't know how to get out of the pit.
He keeps digging his hole. I don't think he wants to prolong his war.
Transfer philippine embassy from Beijing to Taipei 😊
I swear i would have accepted the chinese argument that it is a civil war if only their country was not a bully to other countries like in vietnam or the Philippines. Unfortunately, it is not the case, CHINA IS gonna fall for its greed, and they are not the only one who have taken an interest in the sea that they are trying to claim and expand. We Filipino are not trying to expand but to survive and develop and play fair on the international orders of things, but china dont want to respect our side. If they can't even do that, how do you think people are not gonna expect they'll do the same to other countries in the southeast. In short, if taiwan falls to china, it is not the end. Sooner or later, china will expand to the rest of the southeast Asia, and it will be hard to defend or regain such taken territories if that's the case. So this matter is not only taiwan and china but it invloves most of Southeast Asia, Australia, the USA, Japan, India, South Korea and most of all the Philippines, my country. And i tell you we will fight if there is no choice, no matter what it will cost. At least, that is my opinion of this matter
WPS.. ATIN ITO 🌊 🛳 🇵🇭 🛳️ 🇵🇭
MABUHAY ANG BAWAT PILIPINO 🙏✌️❤️🔥 🇵🇭 💪💙
Simple solution obey international law and theres peace
The chinese analyst are wrong to tell TAIWAN IS SAFER😂😂😂😂 TAIWAN HAS NO TREATY ALLY COMPARE TO PHILIPPINES, if CHINA FIGHT THE PHILIPPINES THE MUTUAL DEFENSE TREATY WILL BECOME ACTIVE AND THE UNITED STATE OF AMERICA IS OBLIGATORY FIGHT BESIDE THE PHILIPPINES.. unlike TAIWAN FIGHT ALONE VS CHINA… so meaning is TIWAN IS NOT SAFER THAN THE PHILIPPINES
The Phil 🇵🇭 has already MDT since with the USA after its independence. Had not the Phil opted to be a republic then it could have been like Guam, a colony of the USA
💕✌️🇵🇭♥️ 🇺🇸 💪♥️🤍💙
The Japan-Philippines-U.S. trilateral alliance is still on the table... Once, this alliance is finalized then this will be China's headache. This trilateral partnership is built on deep historical ties… and a shared vision for a free and open Indo-Pacific.
Taiwan 🇹🇼 part of the Philippines it belongs to Philippines 🇵🇭. China belongs to India.
I SUPPORT TAIWAN AND U.S WITH LOVE..FROM PHILIPPINES.... Chinese????leader. Xi???👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👹👹👹👹👹
DONT FORGET TAIWAN NINE DASH LINE THE ROOT OF THESE CONFLICT, MALAY WATERS FOR THE SECOND TIME NEIGHBOURS FROM THE NORTH IN ADVENTURISM AND EXPANSIONISM
The Philippines and Japanese government agreed to start negotiations for a defense pact called the Reciprocal Access Agreement (RAA), aiming to facilitate the presence of visiting forces and conduct joint military training activities. If formally signed, it would be Japan’s first RAA with a member of the Association of Southeast Asian Nations and Japan’s third overall.
Taiwan lookalike to Pilipino than Chinese.
Taiwan is not Chinese, Taiwan is Taiwanese.
Chinese Execessive Greediness
Sleepy Joe, to little to late !!!
Say no to World policing
Yes, only Ch. na is the police since ancient times
Yes they are Foolish from ancient time Agree😂.
Fight and protect democratic allies, freedom of navigation, freedom of speech, and voting rights. Keep Taiwan Free! Support he DPP.
@@user-ye6gg5nu6q They were killing each other even own siblings
What do think china puting military garison in the middle of south china sea (we) south east asian don't ask for security guard.