Thing that India had boomed in digital is all thanks to JIO. We had to pay RS 298($4-5) per month to get 1 GB internet before 2016. AND AFTER JIO's DISRUPTION IN MARKET RATES IS AROUND RS 399 PER MONTH FOR 60 GB. That had made huge difference.
@@praveenpillay4329 Jio disrupted the entire market & moulded it as per their vision Seems like in this case it was power of Jio only since they were the ones controlling the market & having a pseudo-monopoly for a while
@@praveenpillay4329 you can't take away their credit, jio was the one who started this change otherwise we would have been using that 1gb/month with that 3g speed but jio forced other networks to bring that change and now we are having 2gb/day
@@krystal... that would have been great bcoz after the Jio , everyone is stuck in their phones. Youth is now focusing on gaming and also becoming a youtuber as they think it's easy from hard-core studying.
Also West, please don't paint this wrong picture in your heads that India is the next China. India is a whole different universe. India is India, and me and most of ua as a young generation are going to keep it India. We won't destroy our heritage and culture like the Chinese or the west. We respect ourselves and everyone else.
Lol young generation is slave of western culture mainly American culture. Some years ago they started to hate Holi n Diwali but when white people started to enjoy those festival those westernised people started to enjoy this festivals westernised style
@@sup9023 shirts aren't west or East.. they are a general clothing, and women still do wear kurthas regularly and if u consider Tshirts/jeans to be western tradition, ur wrong. 😃
Instead of being offended with the title, we Indians should be offended with the blatant lies in the video itself, but NOBODY even noticed those lies. Because most of us don't read the newspaper or keep up to date with policy issues in India. And then we go out to vote (or not) without having the basic bloody knowledge required for voting for the right people. The only thing we are good for is writing the kind of low-IQ and emotionally charged comments the kind of which you just wrote.
My family is in manufacturing. It’s not just tax that’s stricter in India , it’s also the payment terms that Chinese companies are willing to give against what India can do. The goods transactions are monitored very strictly out here. Because currently there is anti dumping against china India is attracting manufacturing but since covid the shipping prices have sky rocketed. We used to ship a container to West coast at 2k dollars which is now 13k dollars minimum post covid making the cost of importing From India really high compared to Vietnam and Indonesia etc. Although the growth has happenned it could have bee way better if govt proactively took care of other costs out of India
If you get down the import policies, then surely the domestic manufacturers will see its doom due to dumping into India. Even the taxes, it might be strict in nature but these are what is required for a developing nation to grow!
@@karthikbaliga225 I am not talking about importing. I am talking about exporting when the manufacturing happens in India. The video is about manufacturing in china vs India to markets abroad not the other way around.
@@Wiseenoughtobefoolish what im talking about is the guy who referred the Hair industry, telling the Raw material have to be imported for using them in manufacturing
@@TusharSharma-gc4vs you know right what she is talking about. Noth korea too has it's official name as 'democratic people's republic of korea'. That doesnt make it democratic
Nokia went down because it failed to read the market not because the policies it was working fine before that it was even the biggest mobile company up until the rise of smartphone and touch screens
Exactly! They lost the game and that's it - no need to be so sour about that! They should have made a better model in this fast paced world, if they wanted to stay in market!
I can relate to why Indian Gov is using high import tariffs, the major reason here is Indian MSME's (Micro Small Medium Enterprises) constitute to 30% + of employment and 70% of those who're working in MSME's are from Rural areas. Now this becomes important coz India has more villages than cities, so if tariffs are decreased below a threshold, then India's rural class faces severe employment issues. More employment issues lead to more poverty and ultimately it can branch out in the form of inflation and several other stuff. All these things go out of control for Gov Of India once it initiates the process to decrease import tariffs and these things are costlier for Indian economy to handle. So Gov takes a balanced approach of providing cushions to MSME's by giving them PLI's(Product Linked Incentives) which are incentives given when specific targets are reached. Honestly speaking, India is doing good and striving to be better, considering other impediments which India is fighting against. I'm asserting this positively because in 1947 when we got independence, we were given food aid by the US and fast forward to today, India's annual wheat production is well over 100M Tonnes. So yes! India is not the next china, India is the next big thing. Thank you, if you had the patience to read such a long story!
I hope lndia can be the next Bangladesh. After years of "growth", lndia's per capita GDP is still behind Bangladesh. lndia ranks 101 out of 106 in the World Hunger Index 2021
@@aburetik4866 If percapita index is the only criteria to measure quality of living, then I can quote several other parameters where Bangladesh is nowhere near India. Percapita is higher for Bangladesh just because they have less population compared to India, if you study facts without any basis then you'll probably end up as an half boiled intellectual. Better get straight with facts instead of targeting India just because India has Modi Govt
@@sarcastic_.verse. Bangalesh ranks also higher in world hunger index, human development index etc, than lndia. lndia is one of the p00rest countries in the world.
@@aburetik4866 As I said, Bangladesh ratio of area to population is the major reason for these stats and considering only these can be a sign of your narrow minded thinking 😂 for your "P00r country" remark, Bangladesh GDP is $32k and India's GDP is $2.67L 😂 yeah! India's poor!
@@sarcastic_.verse. lndia has more ppl than Bangladesh, but it also has more arable land. But it still ranks behind Bangladesh in the world hunger index. lndia's GDP looks higher than Bangladesh, but after dividing it by way more ppl, each lndian is p00rer than Bangladesh, and most of them can barely afford food as shown in the hunger index
INDIA 🇮🇳 is a unique country 🏁 We are not rely on one sector ☝️ our diverse country have diverse works 👈 Not a bubble economy like China 🙄 We move slowly & effectively , not blindly grow one sector 🔥 Our government only need to do Right Decesion at present & future 😃 Jai Hind 🇮🇳 Jai Bharat 🇮🇳 Our great 👍 country 😊 India 🇮🇳
You subscribed top dhruv tattee ? Go to sham sharma show, he is true patriot and dont give false information like dhruv gives all the time. Dhruv is basically AAP IT cell worker
The West would certainly want India to become the next China, cuz it stands to gain everything economically from the rise of India, that they did from that of china; but without the risk of India turning rogue. It is easier to do regime change in India than in China because of democracy, so India will always be a more controlled power. No matter how rich, the moment any Indian govt wants to act funny, there are 100s of political parties that the west can exploit. Also causing riots and mayhem is a cake walk in India. So why not? In fact India didn't become what China became in the last decade was by choice. Doors were always open.
It's easier to do regime change in India?? Well only Indians can make that happen now, not any outside force. So it's very wrong to think India is a more controlled power. If people here think that some outside force is trying to control us, then Indians will burn the entire system down. It's not British era anymore. I've even seen school kids discuss geopolitics nowadays.
It's quite scary to see how much turmoil foreign forces managed to create in Hong Kong, constantly adding fuel to the fire. In the same way, you see that Taiwan which has had a decent relationship with China for decades suddenly moved towards a very anti-China stance in the past decade. It is easy for the West to influence public opinion (with the Internet) and political parties (with corruption) in these countries. The US basically own all big social media like Google, Facebook, Twitter, and can easily tweak subtly the algorithms to show more of certain news and influence elections.
India is actively changing the way how it is evolving, honestly speaking this current government has more of a vision compared to previous ones and its paying off dividends. Not only we are growing powerful geopolitically, but also exports are going up but so are imports. There is still scope of creating alot of jobs in textiles while is still a HUGE sector in India and it can be raised 20x times. We've already went over Bangladesh's textile imports in just 2 years of this government's planning and its going to go even further up. Why and how did this happen? Digital revolution! everyone is being spoonfed with digital means to run their commerce and trade, they are literally sending government agents to the poorer sections of society and showing them how to use this as their advantage. The access to market is becoming far more greater than it used to be. India already has a booming service sector, what we need is a strong manufacturing base that can absorb the lower to middle class population we have. With PLI which stands for production linked incentives, which this video failed to mention India already is second best manufacturing destination right behind China. India will take a few years to grow its internal eco-systems and go very strongly into electronics. Mobiles, laptops, PC and alot of these sort of things will shift from China to India very powerfully. This is the first time we have a actually worthy man in power, with all the power he can have in the seat of PM. India is actively planning for future and tapping into all sorts of ways it can to reduce the imports. Which means Ethanol blending, Using hydrogen as fuel, E-Vehicles...all those things which can lower the import of crude oil. India will never be another China. India is India.
Modi is just doing dirty politics to win elections. He always divide the society on ground of religion and also neglecting states like Bihar jharkhand chhattisgarh for their poor maintenance and quality. He is manipulating the minds of people by showing that he is a true nationalist. India will never be a developed country if religion becomes obstacle.
I just read the first lines and bhakt spotted. Screaming on top of your lungs doesn't mean ur better. Manmohan Singh silently flourished India in many sectors. Most of the things today were started in that time period.
@@navzilla1164 but that doesn't mean that Rahul Gandhi (Pappu) is suitable for becoming PM of India 🇮🇳. He is the worst politician i have ever seen. Literally , he can't handle his own party, how is he going to handle country like India 🇮🇳. Some new leader should come who can do it more better and effectively.
Instead of being offended with the title, we Indians should be offended with the blatant lies in the video itself, but NOBODY even noticed those lies. Because most of us don't read the newspaper or keep up to date with policy issues in India. And then we go out to vote (or not) without having the basic bloody knowledge required for voting for the right people. The only thing we are good for is writing the kind of low-IQ and emotionally charged comments the kind of which you just wrote.
Bangladesh has an advantage over India, that it is a far more homogeneous society than India - in terms of language, religion, landscape and even challenges. Therefore, India has to overcome a lot of barriers to deal with its diversity.
Bangladesh has for more disadvantages bcz it's population is less and has very less labour than india and hence labour cost is more in Bangladesh and also and also it just has 2 developed ports wheras india has more than 10 and also it's main maritime routes r through bay of bengal and the distance also increases greatly to export to n USA or even Europe
@@saiprasadbharadwajpemmaraj7186 No Sir, they have higher population density. Also, the country is not very big so transportation costs are less. Just imagine India's most populous state has no direct access to any port, so no big manufacturing companies are there. Once India's infrastructure improves and transportation time and charges get reduced, India will also progress much faster.
Well it is Bangladesh,we all know how idiotic their country can be ,don't expect them to even touch India in a long run. As a neighbor we would like to see a stable bangladesh for sure ,so all the best to them for that
We all need to stop making excuses as to why bangladesh is doing better than India and instead start figuring out how we can be much better. Bangladesh did what most developing countries do which is focus on low skilled manufacturing. India needs to make better policies that willl attract low end goods manufacturing. We can't jist rely on IT as that employs a very small percentage of the workforce.
All those companies were evading taxes, idk why people just read headlines, I mean these companies were working in the country, not following laws, I think govt. Did right thing, its not about getting investment, its about getting regulated investment....
It is very hard to delineate every growth prospects in comments but I want to say I am very optimistic for India,if for a sec I assume make for India instead of make in India then it is not a problem also because of our domestic consumption. Again many things to explain but It is very hard to explain in the comment section , India will grow exponentially in the coming decades
Tittle of the original video:- Is india the next china? Me:- How about no! Fact:- India is india and will always remain that , both literally and Metaphorically. And we LOVE IT 😍 the way it is
Instead of being offended with the title, we Indians should be offended with the blatant lies in the video itself, but NOBODY even noticed those lies. Because most of us don't read the newspaper or keep up to date with policy issues in India. And then we go out to vote (or not) without having the basic bloody knowledge required for voting for the right people. The only thing we are good for is writing the kind of low-IQ and emotionally charged comments the kind of which you just wrote.
Hmm let me share my thoughts. If automation is implemented in certain places in India where workers need to take health precautions like 1) Working in coal deposits, trust me I've trained at thermal units for 6 months and the workers had respiratory problems unless they check up and they need to highly paid. 2) Working in factories where pollution is high. 3) Implementing a good Traffic system, with a proper signaling system where there is no necessity of a traffic police. etc.. Automation is good and must be implemented where human can't able to do the work effectively at long run but not to replace human. In other words I'd like to see India as 30% automated to beat a completely automated country China.
I hope lndia can be the next Bangladesh. After years of "growth", lndia's per capita GDP is still behind Bangladesh. lndia ranks 101 out of 106 in the World Hunger Index 2021
@@aburetik4866 India Lacking Behind Bangladesh's GDP Per Capita Is No Miracle, We've Such A Huge Population & The Underlying Issue Of Prioritising The High Skill Market Led To This Stage, We Need A Huge Progress In Low Skill Manufacturing Industries & Goverment Should Burden Themselves With Import Taxes For A While To Achive The Progress We Strive.
@THΣ HΔCҜΣR 01 lndia is 6th, not 5th. And lndia's got 1.4 billion p00r ppl. Most of its GDP is spent on food for such a large population. lndia ranks 101 out of 106 in the Word Hunger Index 2021
the government has placed high import taxes due to the dumping practices of china and various countries. countries like china usually dump large amounts of goods/raw materials subsidized by the Chinese government. Due to the cheap rates, the factories/ consumer starts buying those cheap goods, affecting whatever small amount is produced in India. these import duties are usually only on selective products and Bloomberg is usually pessimistic about India they will never show the growth or anything, they just highlight the negative, although that is also important, they should show the positives too
Anti dumping duty is charged separately on goods that are sold below fair market value. It cannot be applied on every import lol. Import taxes has always been high in india to promote Indian manufacturers. This practice worked during 1990's and early 2000's but its only going to harm india in today's world.
Jabs knew.. the topic is so critically sensitive to the targeted audience that none is going to bother him for his shirt 😂 he thought this vdo to be safe to wear something new😂
I am an employee in a MNC and we do use RPA (robotics) and automation to reduce the effort rate and cut the labor cost. But by doing that we should have someone to run that automation. It's just that population has to be more educated and should have advanced skills in order to have a job which will be easier for the upper middle class and rich class but the lower middle class and poor class has to continue to struggle unless there is something government taking initiative for them.
@@DS_Gaurav No it isn't. You dont need a MBA or Mtech to sit and manufacture toys. Nearly 50% of India’s domestic toy demand is fulfilled with imports from China. Its just incompetence from our side.
Look always India is a world's teacher ( ViswaGuru). In education, culture , medical field or in any other field. China has a rich culture too but Indians love to our own cultures & traditions. Next decade will be India's decade....
These people wont understand that india culturally dominated the whole of south asian countries and even china and japan. A chinese scholar has himself said it . India has always been a net exporter of relegion and culture .
While India is aiming to become a 5 trillion dollar economy, the most populous state of Uttar Pradesh has its own goal of 1 trillion dollar economy! If every other state sets similar goals according to their capability, India could go beyond $5 trillion!
sometimes we feel DEMOCRACY is disaster for India but at the end we have our rights it is what a human want so democracy is not bad but local politics is so bad
The United States and Europe experienced the great depression and serious overproduction and class solidification in the 1970s! In those years, only China's infrastructure and education population had the strength to accept these low-end manufacturing industries!! The United States, Europe and China are just trying to get what they need!
Bro but we should do it for necessary material which are not even available in India, its affecting many unique businesses and resulting in bankruptcy. And then we need to buy imported products which are expensive
India is like the ancient elephant in the room of modern civilization defined by recent political ideologies. They try to ignore or denigrate India, but the elephant is learning its own strength and will again reclaim its central place on the planet. Jai Ganesha! :- Dr David Frawley
I don't think it's because of ego but India is fundamentally different from any other country for that matter. If we take any aspect that involves India i.e national or international it takes a while to understand the complexity and uniqueness of India's approach. Ex. Indian Space Program India's Non Alignment Movement Developing IT vs cheap manufacturing Rupay and UPI I think Indians are wired differently, if you know what I mean 😅😅😅
I hope lndia can be the next Bangladesh. After years of "growth", lndia's per capita GDP is still behind Bangladesh. lndia ranks 101 out of 106 in the World Hunger Index 2021
@@aburetik4866 We definitely have many issues to address, there's no denying that fact. But we can't compare India to any other country just because there's exists no country with the level of complexities and diversities. Thats exactly why we need to look inwards and be innovative.
One of the major reasons India does not want to completely surrender it's market to the West is because the West cannot be trusted. The West is very nosy and will start interfering and even controlling the internal affairs of India. So what India is doing is very good.
The only problem is if we open the doors and companies like Tesla, apple and others come in with no challenge, there is no way Indian company can grow and compete with them. So we need to be protected to a certain limit before slowly opening up tax free imports
Just to point out that even though the context behind is obviously true, the comparison with Bangladesh is always going to a bit skewed. 40% of Bangladesh's population (~167mil) is about 67mil, while 20% of India's population is almost 320mil. The economy of scale is always going to be a challenge for India if numbers are going to be compared tbh
according to IMF gdp per capita of india 2022 nominal = 2515$ gdp per capita of bangladesh 2022 nominal = 2362$ and gdp ppp india 2022=8358usd bangladesh ppp =6633usd
Mumbai alone is richer than whole of Bangladesh, really. They are just talking of equal wealth distribution which is indeed a huge issue that we're underestimating. That'll cause more problems going forward but we have covered that aspect with welfare schemes so we're not that worse off as long as next government doesn't just cut them off. People do not understand what people at the lower levels getting their monthly amount means...you are increasing purchasing power of the lowest rung of society. Bangladesh has done it with old school methods, The world hasn't caught upto what India has done and they don't understand what Modi has been upto. Modi's method is truly new school, not old school and best of all it doesn't have leakages. It'll take about 10 years for them to understand what happened here exactly.
@@vyzxyz6477 the problem isn't india doesn't have high per capita income the problem is the states that have low per capita income compared to other ones drag down the per capita income of whole country
Note that GDP of Bangladesh is higher than India in terms of 'Per Capita' because India has a much much higher population then Bangladesh but the nominal GDP of India is much much higher in Bangladesh, India is 4th of 5th in the world right now after US,China, Russia or somewhere on the same spot with UK
Actually automation wins only when the cost of labor increases which is due to lack of labour in an industry. It's all interconnected. If workforce is available, and its competitive robotics will not be attractive for the companies. Declining population will push companies into automation to keep things affordable for the population as well.
Instead of being offended with the title, we Indians should be offended with the blatant lies in the video itself, but NOBODY even noticed those lies. Because most of us don't read the newspaper or keep up to date with policy issues in India. And then we go out to vote (or not) without having the basic bloody knowledge required for voting for the right people. The only thing we are good for is writing the kind of low-IQ and emotionally charged comments the kind of which you just wrote.
Bangladesh used some pretty risky and intense methods to grow it's economy as they didn't wanted to end up like pakistan and sri-lanka which are screwed as they took heavy chinese loans for their fragile economies.
@@autumn5905 Yeah that mindset only helps those that doesn't have corrupt elites controlling all the loaned money a country gets and filling their vault sized bellies with it, and the people pay the price back. Even India took a loan once, but today it's the 3rd largest economy by purchase power parity and 5th largest nominal, Because it had the will power to rise so the loan helped and didn't worsen the already fragile economy like Pakistan and srilanka, grasp the meaning in my opinion, or simply don't bother tp read and then give a stupid reply 🙂
Bangladesh is soon gonna meet the fate as Sri Lanka and Pakistan... Although Bangladesh is Bengali people so China's gonna hava a hard time to achieve that. LOL
Bangladesh crossed India in GDP per capita But real economy is measured in term GDP ppp and gdp nominal in which india has surpassed even European countries
@@sanjithrithvik3548 bro dont know about imf but our recent govt data says our gdp per capita is 2800+usd as foe fyscal year 22.......... Its obvious that both Bangladesh and india will rise cause we are meant ro be
@@mihrimaainunferdaus388 No. Its not that obvious. The measure of whether a country's economy will continue to rise is the "Economic Complexity Ranking". In this India is ranked 42 while Bangladesh is ranked 108. Moreover, India is quickly climbing these ranks, meanwhile Bangladesh is falling. This is because Bangladesh economy is a one-trick pony that relies on low-tech textile sector alone. Even in High-tech textiles, Bangladesh is not much. Its obvious that you won't grow forever if you don't have a diverse economy. Its basic economics. And therefore, India will continue to grow, while Bangladesh might not.
Instead of being offended with the title, we Indians should be offended with the blatant lies in the video itself, but NOBODY even noticed those lies. Because most of us don't read the newspaper or keep up to date with policy issues in India. And then we go out to vote (or not) without having the basic bloody knowledge required for voting for the right people. The only thing we are good for is writing the kind of low-IQ and emotionally charged comments the kind of which you just wrote.
@@death_parade bro people like you always try to find the hole in everything..this comment is not on government policy or patriotism. Everyone has their unique way to achieve success and we don't need to copy anyone. Socio-economic and political background of india and china are totally different. So you just be happy with your high IQ. I don't have any problem.
Instead of being offended with the title, we Indians should be offended with the blatant lies in the video itself, but NOBODY even noticed those lies. Because most of us don't read the newspaper or keep up to date with policy issues in India. And then we go out to vote (or not) without having the basic bloody knowledge required for voting for the right people. The only thing we are good for is writing the kind of low-IQ and emotionally charged comments the kind of which you just wrote.
according to IMF gdp per capita of india 2022 nominal = 2515$ gdp per capita of bangladesh 2022 nominal = 2362$ and gdp ppp india 2022=8358usd bangladesh ppp =6633usd
The measure of whether a country's economy will continue to rise is the "Economic Complexity Ranking". In this India is ranked 42 while Bangladesh is ranked 108. Moreover, India is quickly climbing these ranks, meanwhile Bangladesh is falling. This is because Bangladesh economy is a one-trick pony that relies on low-tech textile sector alone. Even in High-tech textiles, Bangladesh is not much. Its obvious that you won't grow forever if you don't have a diverse economy. Its basic economics. And therefore, India will continue to grow, while Bangladesh might not.
People praising Jio should remember. Jio was possible because Of Modi ji , He forgive so much tax for jio for Ambani that is how it was possible. Same with GST many people criticized it first but now all intellectuals are saying this is good, Modi ji is a visionary leader don't doubt him
@@karankapoor2701 When did i say that i love the chinese rise. But understand this US also wont allow india to grow beyond a certain threshold . They believe that india too wont tow their line if india too grows to be overpowered , Like they did with china. US throughout history has someway or other hindered indian stability if you would know history.
18:10 Misleading. Bangladesh falls under United Nation's category of Least Developed Countries (LDC) and hence enjoys certain benefits in global trade, tax relaxations and financial benefits.
do not underestimate the power of people who do not want this to happen.....they are very powerful and will do anything to make this journey a rough one
With the horrible governance from our current government, the Indian GDP isn't going to increase to even $3 Trillion Dollars, let alone $5 Trillion by 2025. The government had been ruining the economy, they have imposed huge redundant taxes, and have forced many companies out of India. Because of this, many people have been pushed into poverty and currently 280 Million people are living in Poverty in India. I just hope that the government gets changed soon, or they understand their makes and reform the issues without just talking, but with action.
You can also think like..if the politicians think like if we did good in our period of time given by our people then people will accept us for the next years as well.
@@craz7644 But the policies always take 3-4 years to implement. If good results are there from the policies and if the party who implemented it will not be in power the credit will be taken by next government. Ex - 1999-2004 During atal Bihari Vajpayee many reformed policy were implemented but the results of that was credited by UPA government after 2004.
India is not next china or usa or russia... india is india...india is bharat...for now for the last thousands of years and gor the future tooo...india is unique ..
according to IMF gdp per capita of india 2022 nominal = 2515$ gdp per capita of bangladesh 2022 nominal = 2362$ and gdp ppp india 2022=8358usd bangladesh ppp =6633usd
Make in India is not something that we only wants to make for ourselves but it's a process in which we are decreasing dependance on foreign materials so that the wealth of our nation won't get exhausted and also to make things to export for world.
India is a democracy with socialist characteristics so yes with correct methods and policies implementation India will surpass China but other major factor is currently disrupting these goals like Foreign trade barriers and diplomatic relations. It's a current situation please don't hesitate to share your thoughts.👍
India too is moving towards automation. It is probably not visible globally but you will see in coming 5 years that India will be a big Automation service provider in the world.
OOf this video, Retrospective taxes was started by previous govt, and required major legislation in both houses to reverse old law. *Fact that retrospective taxes have been abolished couple of years ago now by law, and this documentary still wants to harp on it, makes me wonder on their objective. The problems they have listed in India, do they still exist is the question, if not, then should documentary be about India has overcome past hurdles etc and ready for business - its like they know India will be next China and have to make a documentary about it, but lets take money from china and make it the most negative way possible*
@the illegitimate TY SON can't help. Govt Don't wants to be look bad knowing thy will loose the case. Past govt did Blunders there was an incident were thy made new law overnight to collect more taxs. Even TATA was unable to open their factory in own country how will Foriegn company do that.
@the illegitimate TY SON Not quite, unable to attach link, must be youtube policy - Search article "Govt accepts Cairn's offer on retro tax; company to withdraw cases now, refund to follow" ET Economic times article Nov 18, 20121. Search Article " Govt to settle almost all retro-tax cases this month: Revenue Secy" another ET article Feb 5 2022 then if you research, some Indian assets outside were frozen, they have been released long back, all points to cases been resolved. You my friend are either unresearched or unaware of updates.. If you still dont believe call up any foreign company who was victim of this law and asked them of status, they will confirm either money has been received back by them from Indian govt or another lucrative contract been offered as a offset or standard due process is going on of fund clearance in tranches by the revenue Sect of India.
Exactly. And look at the number of Indians in the comment section lauding this documentary for its "accuracy". Seriously, gora worship is in our blood, seems like. Was wondering if not a single person caught that fact about retrospective taxes, gladly there was at least some one.
Though our aim was to become a 5 trillion dollar economy till 2025 ..IMF has said it will be achieved by 2026 due to pandemic..as india is the fastest growing economy in the world now..
India is now Fastest growing economy with 8.5% and if india will grow more faster like 9.5 then 5 trillion will be more faster and Most important is India is focusing on Manufacturing Hub of all sector. India us developing it's infrastructure to reduce Logistics and increase trade , As china is Communist so they developed fast but india is democratic so u can say there ate many hurdles. Some project also slow bcz of politics ,NGOs. India needs more Reforms and policy. Now India is doing best in foreign policy to attract FDI ( $88 billion recently) and more fdi morr development. But i can say India will definitely grow faster upto 2030( 9-10 trillion) 3rd largest economy and India have much potential to replace China. Modi is one of the best PM of india, who transformed India as new India 🇮🇳. If i explained how then i can't cuz u need one more video for that. India for now need One nation One election to reduce expenditure in election , UCC CAA ( for Internal stability), More industrial city, economic corridor. By 2024 india will have American quality roads and upto 2025 india Infrastructure will be much develop , cuz it's construc. is faster Btw Jaby ur shirt is really nice and vibe is amazing, hope u read this
Comparison is there for a reason ... If we want to be different we have to get into Research and Development which we seriously lack except for two or three sector eg ISRO DRDO, but DRDO needs to do a lot more work it is still behind many other defense organisation of other countries unlike ISRO. else India will be next China you may like it or not.
This myth of "DRDO being behind ISRO" is nonsense spouted by people who don't know anything detailed about these organizations, their efforts and success stories.
China's economy grew because of exports - the focus on their internal markets came later. It's the other way round for India - local market growth early on, consequently build manufacturing base and improve quality for local market as it matures and moves up the value chain - those low prices become a competitive advantage for exports later. There are already several examples of such process and success.
I'm Unable to understand why India wants to attract foreign companies to establish factories here. The Country with huge population is obviously has huge demands which should has to be lead us establishing our own companies, making them bigger by getting in-home profit, exporting the production. The perfect Examples are: Byju's, unacademy (education); Swiggy, Zomato (food delivery); Capillary Technologies (Capillary Technologies is a software product company, which provides cloud-based Omnichannel Customer Engagement, eCommerce platform and related services for retailers and brands). This proves that we doesn't need any foreign support for our economic developments.
A country without being manufacturing hub can never become regional or world power...if u r thinking that homegrown start-ups is alone do good for india then there is funding which is largely invested by foreign players..swiggy,zomato,lenskart etc all have major funding from foreign players like Softbank...china is today so large because of manufacturing that western companies shifted their plant in china...apart from manufacturing china building it's own companies and other things as they get money from manufacturing sector so u can never say that why india want companies to come in india they come they invest dollar take local currency and setting up there plant and cycle goes on... Before 1991 we r like that we don't want foreign companies and u know what happened at that time... We have to industrilize ourselves till we have healthy wealth distribution and per capita GDP...china despite being 2nd largest economy have per capita 10,000$ and india today have 2500$ it's only four times vice -versa to GDP to...
At the end of 2020, China's GDP was US$14.72 trillion, and at the end of 2021 it was US$17.7 trillion. 1 year: 2.98 trillion. 1year=1 india. The part it adds in a year is almost equal to the entire GDP of India. There is really no comparison between the two countries at the moment. Let's be realistic.
@@sunnyboynfs When Bill Gates was young, he was just like you and had no education. Yes, if you work hard, it is possible to be as successful as him. But there are billions of people around the world who have this dream. Most don't end up that well, do they? It's good to have expectations in life, but be realistic.
See we get that import taxes are high , but one may look upto the pages of history the openness will indicate a foreign monopoly once again the strategy used by east india company to capture india and exploit it . Govt of India has been strictly following everything to protect its indigenous trade and business which ofcourse hinders the MNCs and foreign companies. That has both sides. For example (Negative) due to make in india and many tarrif and taxes Tesla isn't still being able to be sold or used in indian streets although Tesla is promising in making cars suitable for the market . But(positive) Tata and many other companies have started using their own research and FDIs to make new Electric concept vehicles which will soon by 2025 be released for indian market and then to the world .
No. That is a stupid idea. We should give incentives to those that add more value in their products within India, but shouldn't outright BAN raw material exports. Take the titanium industry of India, for example. Had we not had a developed Titanium mining sector, we wouldn't have been able to create the Titanium Sponge plant in India and then not have been able to create the Titanium vertical at MIDHANI that today can meet all of India's titanium needs end-end within India. This phenomenal achievement wouldn't have been possible without India starting with Titanium ore export.
I might not like ccp today but deng xioping was one if the most visionary leaders to have ever been lived , he always said bide your time and work harder. Which eventually lead china to rule global econony today. India should follow those steps, to become self sufficient in every field.
we live in a democracy we can't force people to do this or that everyone loves china but when the china bubble will break shockwave of that feel in every part of the world
That's why India have so much corruption, protest, politics, Stereotypes, over population etc... People literally want to live in another country. Padega India tabhi to badega USA, UK, FRANCE, UAE
National Language tho decide hoti nhi fir bolte hai UN m koi Indian languages kyu nhi hai. Indian cinema globally recognised kyu nhi hai. Jb tk Bollywood world level p famous huwa tumhara Tollywood sandalwood Nollywood mollywood lollywood RR suru ho gya
Diving through the comments, I find that the pride of the Indians is not a problem that can be solved easily. From a geopolitical perspective, South Asia has been extremely toxic and confined to their own little bubble that their nation is supposed to be the best. Taking the case of us Indians, we don’t help an ally nation without mentioning it in their faces. For eg, Nepal being so similar ideologically to India has been left alienated after India rubs it in their faces that they are here just because the contribution of India. Same with Bangladesh, who has shifted its allegiance with China. We Indians don’t miss an opportunity to say that Bangladesh is a country just because India helped in 1971. As said by a legend, never mention the good deeds and the world will be yours. Indians need to realise that our pride will be the doom of us.
Thing that India had boomed in digital is all thanks to JIO.
We had to pay RS 298($4-5) per month to get 1 GB internet before 2016.
AND AFTER JIO's DISRUPTION IN MARKET RATES IS AROUND RS 399 PER MONTH FOR 60 GB. That had made huge difference.
yeah when JIO came whole india shifted to 4g from 3g in single night
That is not because of Jio......that's the power of the market
@@praveenpillay4329 Jio disrupted the entire market & moulded it as per their vision
Seems like in this case it was power of Jio only since they were the ones controlling the market & having a pseudo-monopoly for a while
@@praveenpillay4329 you can't take away their credit, jio was the one who started this change otherwise we would have been using that 1gb/month with that 3g speed but jio forced other networks to bring that change and now we are having 2gb/day
@@krystal... that would have been great bcoz after the Jio , everyone is stuck in their phones. Youth is now focusing on gaming and also becoming a youtuber as they think it's easy from hard-core studying.
Also West, please don't paint this wrong picture in your heads that India is the next China. India is a whole different universe. India is India, and me and most of ua as a young generation are going to keep it India. We won't destroy our heritage and culture like the Chinese or the west. We respect ourselves and everyone else.
India already has destroyed their culture. Look at the drugs in bollywood. Where the Jean's come from ?
says the guy wearing clothing from the ‘west’ & ‘china’ , Why don’t you wear a khadi west & dhoti? Isn’t that destroying our culture🤡
Lol young generation is slave of western culture mainly American culture. Some years ago they started to hate Holi n Diwali but when white people started to enjoy those festival those westernised people started to enjoy this festivals westernised style
@@sup9023 shirts aren't west or East.. they are a general clothing, and women still do wear kurthas regularly and if u consider Tshirts/jeans to be western tradition, ur wrong. 😃
Joe biden has acknowledged your comment.
We Want INDIA to become a BETTER INDIA and not the NEXT CHINA
good luck！
@@原来是你-h8e 😁😁😁
Instead of being offended with the title, we Indians should be offended with the blatant lies in the video itself, but NOBODY even noticed those lies. Because most of us don't read the newspaper or keep up to date with policy issues in India. And then we go out to vote (or not) without having the basic bloody knowledge required for voting for the right people. The only thing we are good for is writing the kind of low-IQ and emotionally charged comments the kind of which you just wrote.
Yeah
@@原来是你-h8e ❤️🙃
My family is in manufacturing. It’s not just tax that’s stricter in India , it’s also the payment terms that Chinese companies are willing to give against what India can do. The goods transactions are monitored very strictly out here. Because currently there is anti dumping against china India is attracting manufacturing but since covid the shipping prices have sky rocketed. We used to ship a container to West coast at 2k dollars which is now 13k dollars minimum post covid making the cost of importing From India really high compared to Vietnam and Indonesia etc. Although the growth has happenned it could have bee way better if govt proactively took care of other costs out of India
If you get down the import policies, then surely the domestic manufacturers will see its doom due to dumping into India. Even the taxes, it might be strict in nature but these are what is required for a developing nation to grow!
@@karthikbaliga225 I am not talking about importing. I am talking about exporting when the manufacturing happens in India. The video is about manufacturing in china vs India to markets abroad not the other way around.
@@Wiseenoughtobefoolish what im talking about is the guy who referred the Hair industry, telling the Raw material have to be imported for using them in manufacturing
Do u know how much pride Indians have??? We definitely don't want to be known as next China. It would go so bad to our heads 😅
It's called jingoism
@@karankapoor2701 its called having ideals
Pride of Civil War 😊😊
India has a huge amount of pride. Indians have so much pride that they called themselves Superpower 2020 even before becoming a superpower.
@@Leonardo-lb6rs we are the pharmaceutical hub of the world, UPI which even USA can't beat etc...🥱 Feels like some World Superpower achievements
Well as a democracy vs a socialist country, some differences will always remain. Specially in the way policies are formulated and executed.
Well according to the preamble india is socialist republic
@@TusharSharma-gc4vs you know right what she is talking about. Noth korea too has it's official name as 'democratic people's republic of korea'. That doesnt make it democratic
@@TusharSharma-gc4vs not in the original preamble.
When our india will Islam free then we can develop.
There's a clear difference between Socialism and Communism
Nokia went down because it failed to read the market not because the policies it was working fine before that it was even the biggest mobile company up until the rise of smartphone and touch screens
Then you should see How govt is chasing Xiaomi with Taxes.
Well that case definitely hit Nokia, but it couldn’t survive anywhere whatsoever
@@ms.550 these Chinese companies must be taxed as they are all mostly covered ups
Exactly! They lost the game and that's it - no need to be so sour about that! They should have made a better model in this fast paced world, if they wanted to stay in market!
We don't want to be labelled as the Next China. We were India, we are India & We will be India always ❤🇮🇳
What does that even mean man, you know what they meant, don't have to be so poetic.
you mean always as poor as India?
@@李荣-n7sNo..as wealthy as India
In terms of culture, bravery and pride
@@李荣-n7s what the f are u saying bruh🤣🤣🤣🤣....MY servant probably earns more money than ur father🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@李荣-n7s Not poor like China
Remembered the days, When Japanese ruled China 😬
I can relate to why Indian Gov is using high import tariffs, the major reason here is Indian MSME's (Micro Small Medium Enterprises) constitute to 30% + of employment and 70% of those who're working in MSME's are from Rural areas. Now this becomes important coz India has more villages than cities, so if tariffs are decreased below a threshold, then India's rural class faces severe employment issues. More employment issues lead to more poverty and ultimately it can branch out in the form of inflation and several other stuff. All these things go out of control for Gov Of India once it initiates the process to decrease import tariffs and these things are costlier for Indian economy to handle. So Gov takes a balanced approach of providing cushions to MSME's by giving them PLI's(Product Linked Incentives) which are incentives given when specific targets are reached. Honestly speaking, India is doing good and striving to be better, considering other impediments which India is fighting against. I'm asserting this positively because in 1947 when we got independence, we were given food aid by the US and fast forward to today, India's annual wheat production is well over 100M Tonnes. So yes! India is not the next china, India is the next big thing. Thank you, if you had the patience to read such a long story!
I hope lndia can be the next Bangladesh. After years of "growth", lndia's per capita GDP is still behind Bangladesh. lndia ranks 101 out of 106 in the World Hunger Index 2021
@@aburetik4866 If percapita index is the only criteria to measure quality of living, then I can quote several other parameters where Bangladesh is nowhere near India. Percapita is higher for Bangladesh just because they have less population compared to India, if you study facts without any basis then you'll probably end up as an half boiled intellectual. Better get straight with facts instead of targeting India just because India has Modi Govt
@@sarcastic_.verse. Bangalesh ranks also higher in world hunger index, human development index etc, than lndia.
lndia is one of the p00rest countries in the world.
@@aburetik4866 As I said, Bangladesh ratio of area to population is the major reason for these stats and considering only these can be a sign of your narrow minded thinking 😂 for your "P00r country" remark, Bangladesh GDP is $32k and India's GDP is $2.67L 😂 yeah! India's poor!
@@sarcastic_.verse. lndia has more ppl than Bangladesh, but it also has more arable land. But it still ranks behind Bangladesh in the world hunger index.
lndia's GDP looks higher than Bangladesh, but after dividing it by way more ppl, each lndian is p00rer than Bangladesh, and most of them can barely afford food as shown in the hunger index
RRR was Amazing 👏 😍
KGF was crap 😏
Pride pride pride!
It's just a comparison. China would wish we were next china. 😏
@@mayurk8697 haha 😄 sounds sarcastic
a better and modern India, not the old poor India
in handling terrorism India will follow China and ISRAEL.
Ultra nationalism, LOL, you wish india was china
INDIA 🇮🇳 is a unique country 🏁
We are not rely on one sector ☝️ our diverse country have diverse works 👈
Not a bubble economy like China 🙄
We move slowly & effectively , not blindly grow one sector 🔥
Our government only need to do Right Decesion at present & future 😃
Jai Hind 🇮🇳
Jai Bharat 🇮🇳
Our great 👍 country 😊 India 🇮🇳
You subscribed top dhruv tattee ? Go to sham sharma show, he is true patriot and dont give false information like dhruv gives all the time. Dhruv is basically AAP IT cell worker
The West would certainly want India to become the next China, cuz it stands to gain everything economically from the rise of India, that they did from that of china; but without the risk of India turning rogue. It is easier to do regime change in India than in China because of democracy, so India will always be a more controlled power. No matter how rich, the moment any Indian govt wants to act funny, there are 100s of political parties that the west can exploit. Also causing riots and mayhem is a cake walk in India. So why not? In fact India didn't become what China became in the last decade was by choice. Doors were always open.
It's easier to do regime change in India?? Well only Indians can make that happen now, not any outside force. So it's very wrong to think India is a more controlled power. If people here think that some outside force is trying to control us, then Indians will burn the entire system down.
It's not British era anymore. I've even seen school kids discuss geopolitics nowadays.
I beg different. China got all manufacturing jobs from the West. Would the West now want India to get all service jobs from the West?
It's quite scary to see how much turmoil foreign forces managed to create in Hong Kong, constantly adding fuel to the fire. In the same way, you see that Taiwan which has had a decent relationship with China for decades suddenly moved towards a very anti-China stance in the past decade. It is easy for the West to influence public opinion (with the Internet) and political parties (with corruption) in these countries. The US basically own all big social media like Google, Facebook, Twitter, and can easily tweak subtly the algorithms to show more of certain news and influence elections.
INDIA has the most financial inclusion till this date.
Our GOVT. Is really working very hard.
India is actively changing the way how it is evolving, honestly speaking this current government has more of a vision compared to previous ones and its paying off dividends. Not only we are growing powerful geopolitically, but also exports are going up but so are imports. There is still scope of creating alot of jobs in textiles while is still a HUGE sector in India and it can be raised 20x times. We've already went over Bangladesh's textile imports in just 2 years of this government's planning and its going to go even further up. Why and how did this happen? Digital revolution! everyone is being spoonfed with digital means to run their commerce and trade, they are literally sending government agents to the poorer sections of society and showing them how to use this as their advantage. The access to market is becoming far more greater than it used to be.
India already has a booming service sector, what we need is a strong manufacturing base that can absorb the lower to middle class population we have. With PLI which stands for production linked incentives, which this video failed to mention India already is second best manufacturing destination right behind China. India will take a few years to grow its internal eco-systems and go very strongly into electronics. Mobiles, laptops, PC and alot of these sort of things will shift from China to India very powerfully.
This is the first time we have a actually worthy man in power, with all the power he can have in the seat of PM. India is actively planning for future and tapping into all sorts of ways it can to reduce the imports. Which means Ethanol blending, Using hydrogen as fuel, E-Vehicles...all those things which can lower the import of crude oil. India will never be another China. India is India.
Respect to your work 👏
Modi is just doing dirty politics to win elections. He always divide the society on ground of religion and also neglecting states like Bihar jharkhand chhattisgarh for their poor maintenance and quality. He is manipulating the minds of people by showing that he is a true nationalist. India will never be a developed country if religion becomes obstacle.
I just read the first lines and bhakt spotted. Screaming on top of your lungs doesn't mean ur better. Manmohan Singh silently flourished India in many sectors. Most of the things today were started in that time period.
@@navzilla1164 💯
@@navzilla1164 but that doesn't mean that Rahul Gandhi (Pappu) is suitable for becoming PM of India 🇮🇳. He is the worst politician i have ever seen. Literally , he can't handle his own party, how is he going to handle country like India 🇮🇳.
Some new leader should come who can do it more better and effectively.
No we don't want to be China. We would love to remain as India only❤❤
We want india become china in terms of economy nothing else.
But far developed 👍👍👍👍👍
We need to extract good things such as business acumen that made them so powerful.
Instead of being offended with the title, we Indians should be offended with the blatant lies in the video itself, but NOBODY even noticed those lies. Because most of us don't read the newspaper or keep up to date with policy issues in India. And then we go out to vote (or not) without having the basic bloody knowledge required for voting for the right people. The only thing we are good for is writing the kind of low-IQ and emotionally charged comments the kind of which you just wrote.
Bangladesh has an advantage over India, that it is a far more homogeneous society than India - in terms of language, religion, landscape and even challenges. Therefore, India has to overcome a lot of barriers to deal with its diversity.
Bangladesh has for more disadvantages bcz it's population is less and has very less labour than india and hence labour cost is more in Bangladesh and also and also it just has 2 developed ports wheras india has more than 10 and also it's main maritime routes r through bay of bengal and the distance also increases greatly to export to n USA or even Europe
@@saiprasadbharadwajpemmaraj7186 No Sir, they have higher population density. Also, the country is not very big so transportation costs are less. Just imagine India's most populous state has no direct access to any port, so no big manufacturing companies are there. Once India's infrastructure improves and transportation time and charges get reduced, India will also progress much faster.
Well it is Bangladesh,we all know how idiotic their country can be ,don't expect them to even touch India in a long run.
As a neighbor we would like to see a stable bangladesh for sure ,so all the best to them for that
Bangladesh is developing because it’s enjoying free roads and transportation from India and also Indian market access too
We all need to stop making excuses as to why bangladesh is doing better than India and instead start figuring out how we can be much better. Bangladesh did what most developing countries do which is focus on low skilled manufacturing. India needs to make better policies that willl attract low end goods manufacturing. We can't jist rely on IT as that employs a very small percentage of the workforce.
All those companies were evading taxes, idk why people just read headlines, I mean these companies were working in the country, not following laws, I think govt. Did right thing, its not about getting investment, its about getting regulated investment....
Or course the narrative is western so they gonna blame the govt.
It is very hard to delineate every growth prospects in comments but I want to say I am very optimistic for India,if for a sec I assume make for India instead of make in India then it is not a problem also because of our domestic consumption.
Again many things to explain but It is very hard to explain in the comment section , India will grow exponentially in the coming decades
Tittle of the original video:- Is india the next china?
Me:- How about no!
Fact:- India is india and will always remain that , both literally and Metaphorically. And we LOVE IT 😍 the way it is
Instead of being offended with the title, we Indians should be offended with the blatant lies in the video itself, but NOBODY even noticed those lies. Because most of us don't read the newspaper or keep up to date with policy issues in India. And then we go out to vote (or not) without having the basic bloody knowledge required for voting for the right people. The only thing we are good for is writing the kind of low-IQ and emotionally charged comments the kind of which you just wrote.
Hmm let me share my thoughts.
If automation is implemented in certain places in India where workers need to take health precautions like
1) Working in coal deposits, trust me I've trained at thermal units for 6 months and the workers had respiratory problems unless they check up and they need to highly paid.
2) Working in factories where pollution is high.
3) Implementing a good Traffic system, with a proper signaling system where there is no necessity of a traffic police.
etc..
Automation is good and must be implemented where human can't able to do the work effectively at long run but not to replace human.
In other words I'd like to see India as 30% automated to beat a completely automated country China.
I hope lndia can be the next Bangladesh. After years of "growth", lndia's per capita GDP is still behind Bangladesh. lndia ranks 101 out of 106 in the World Hunger Index 2021
@@aburetik4866 India Lacking Behind Bangladesh's GDP Per Capita Is No Miracle, We've Such A Huge Population & The Underlying Issue Of Prioritising The High Skill Market Led To This Stage, We Need A Huge Progress In Low Skill Manufacturing Industries & Goverment Should Burden Themselves With Import Taxes For A While To Achive The Progress We Strive.
@@saisurendrapatthigulla4754 Priotising high skill market? What high skill does lndia have?
@THΣ HΔCҜΣR 01 lndia is 6th, not 5th. And lndia's got 1.4 billion p00r ppl. Most of its GDP is spent on food for such a large population. lndia ranks 101 out of 106 in the Word Hunger Index 2021
@@aburetik4866 IT & Software Exports, Construction, Retail, Automobile, Fashion Designing And Textile Industry
the government has placed high import taxes due to the dumping practices of china and various countries. countries like china usually dump large amounts of goods/raw materials subsidized by the Chinese government. Due to the cheap rates, the factories/ consumer starts buying those cheap goods, affecting whatever small amount is produced in India. these import duties are usually only on selective products
and Bloomberg is usually pessimistic about India they will never show the growth or anything, they just highlight the negative, although that is also important, they should show the positives too
Anti dumping duty is charged separately on goods that are sold below fair market value. It cannot be applied on every import lol. Import taxes has always been high in india to promote Indian manufacturers. This practice worked during 1990's and early 2000's but its only going to harm india in today's world.
I never watch western biased media
Jabs knew.. the topic is so critically sensitive to the targeted audience that none is going to bother him for his shirt 😂 he thought this vdo to be safe to wear something new😂
😂
I am an employee in a MNC and we do use RPA (robotics) and automation to reduce the effort rate and cut the labor cost. But by doing that we should have someone to run that automation. It's just that population has to be more educated and should have advanced skills in order to have a job which will be easier for the upper middle class and rich class but the lower middle class and poor class has to continue to struggle unless there is something government taking initiative for them.
We spend absolutely nothing compared to other countries on education. Skill development is on the shoulders of the private sector.
@@momobhai3792 Agree
Price of education is huge
@@DS_Gaurav yes, that's what I meant by the struggle lower middle class and poor class has to face
@@DS_Gaurav No it isn't. You dont need a MBA or Mtech to sit and manufacture toys. Nearly 50% of India’s domestic toy demand is fulfilled with imports from China. Its just incompetence from our side.
Look always India is a world's teacher ( ViswaGuru). In education, culture , medical field or in any other field. China has a rich culture too but Indians love to our own cultures & traditions. Next decade will be India's decade....
🤣🤣
@the illegitimate TY SON get some education bruh...
Yeah I agree
@the illegitimate TY SON Truth is always bitter to someone.... Silence 🤐 is the best answer... It's not a propaganda it's the fact...
These people wont understand that india culturally dominated the whole of south asian countries and even china and japan. A chinese scholar has himself said it . India has always been a net exporter of relegion and culture .
While India is aiming to become a 5 trillion dollar economy, the most populous state of Uttar Pradesh has its own goal of 1 trillion dollar economy! If every other state sets similar goals according to their capability, India could go beyond $5 trillion!
😂😂😂
In India
Highest economy is from Maharashtra
Tamilnadu
Karnataka
Andhra Pradesh
Gujarat only .
How come Uttra pradesh ??
@@MBS_7 it's an aim
@@mayanksingh8714 aim hi rhjayega
Kuch bhi......whole of North is nothing but a parasite for Maharashtra and other Southern states.
sometimes we feel DEMOCRACY is disaster for India but at the end we have our rights it is what a human want so democracy is not bad but local politics is so bad
The United States and Europe experienced the great depression and serious overproduction and class solidification in the 1970s! In those years, only China's infrastructure and education population had the strength to accept these low-end manufacturing industries!! The United States, Europe and China are just trying to get what they need!
That oh reaction by achara when the video said then came the British 👏🏻👏🏻🤣🤣🤣
If we reduce the tax imports then the companies that makes same product in india would be at loss as the imported one would become cheaper
Bro but we should do it for necessary material which are not even available in India, its affecting many unique businesses and resulting in bankruptcy. And then we need to buy imported products which are expensive
@@bilya.k.2638 Do you think government don't know there are smart people sitting there they have something plan which we don't know
@@shubhankmanhas5255 THEY ARE WORKING FOR AMBANI AND ADANI THINK ABOUT IT
@@shubhankmanhas5255 Lol yeah
@@arpit2455 👍
India is like the ancient elephant in the room of modern civilization defined by recent political ideologies. They try to ignore or denigrate India, but the elephant is learning its own strength and will again reclaim its central place on the planet. Jai Ganesha! :- Dr David Frawley
I don't think it's because of ego but India is fundamentally different from any other country for that matter.
If we take any aspect that involves India i.e national or international it takes a while to understand the complexity and uniqueness of India's approach.
Ex. Indian Space Program
India's Non Alignment Movement
Developing IT vs cheap manufacturing
Rupay and UPI
I think Indians are wired differently, if you know what I mean 😅😅😅
I hope lndia can be the next Bangladesh. After years of "growth", lndia's per capita GDP is still behind Bangladesh. lndia ranks 101 out of 106 in the World Hunger Index 2021
@@aburetik4866 We definitely have many issues to address, there's no denying that fact. But we can't compare India to any other country just because there's exists no country with the level of complexities and diversities.
Thats exactly why we need to look inwards and be innovative.
@@imManojKrishnan That's why democracy doesn't work for lndia. Complexity/diversity with democracy only creates chaos
One of the major reasons India does not want to completely surrender it's market to the West is because the West cannot be trusted. The West is very nosy and will start interfering and even controlling the internal affairs of India. So what India is doing is very good.
@Home gardening It is democracy that makes such diversity into chaos
The only problem is if we open the doors and companies like Tesla, apple and others come in with no challenge, there is no way Indian company can grow and compete with them. So we need to be protected to a certain limit before slowly opening up tax free imports
Well recently India achieved highest merchandise export in our history 😊
@@sosoable so what
@@tweentycenturyrock so india 🇮🇳 is a huge failure and respect to china for becoming India's Father.🙏🏻
@@DS_Gaurav you are indian right.why r u Disrespecting you own country.
@@akshitkumar2111 telling the truth is not disrespect. It's the fact , we should accept that
@@DS_Gaurav xi jingping is waiting for you in his COVID camps for showing his next growth model
Just to point out that even though the context behind is obviously true, the comparison with Bangladesh is always going to a bit skewed. 40% of Bangladesh's population (~167mil) is about 67mil, while 20% of India's population is almost 320mil. The economy of scale is always going to be a challenge for India if numbers are going to be compared tbh
according to IMF
gdp per capita of india 2022 nominal = 2515$
gdp per capita of bangladesh 2022 nominal = 2362$
and gdp ppp india 2022=8358usd
bangladesh ppp =6633usd
@@vyzxyz6477 this video was made during COVID times and india GDP is 2560 dollar
Mumbai alone is richer than whole of Bangladesh, really. They are just talking of equal wealth distribution which is indeed a huge issue that we're underestimating. That'll cause more problems going forward but we have covered that aspect with welfare schemes so we're not that worse off as long as next government doesn't just cut them off. People do not understand what people at the lower levels getting their monthly amount means...you are increasing purchasing power of the lowest rung of society. Bangladesh has done it with old school methods, The world hasn't caught upto what India has done and they don't understand what Modi has been upto. Modi's method is truly new school, not old school and best of all it doesn't have leakages. It'll take about 10 years for them to understand what happened here exactly.
@@ravishbhasin7041 👍
@@vyzxyz6477 the problem isn't india doesn't have high per capita income the problem is the states that have low per capita income compared to other ones drag down the per capita income of whole country
"India is the next China" is a broad generalization, "India is the next Manufacturing power after China" is a better title.
INDIA is India..and will find its own way to develop..
India is the next INDIA 🙏
Next nahi first chutiye
Video to dekhle phele
@@Mukularora7754 dekh tha bahut pehle he
Jaby in Goa mood😁
Our past experiences with east india company is biggest issue with our mindset today . Government always thought about people of india
that's very good
Note that GDP of Bangladesh is higher than India in terms of 'Per Capita' because India has a much much higher population then Bangladesh but the nominal GDP of India is much much higher in Bangladesh, India is 4th of 5th in the world right now after US,China, Russia or somewhere on the same spot with UK
Wrong, this happened in covid time but now we are above them in terms of per capita!!
russia doesn't have high economy India is 5th after usa china japan germany uk is 6th
sri lanka also had more GDP per capita see now they are in shambles
@the illegitimate TY SON Percentage of what?
Actually automation wins only when the cost of labor increases which is due to lack of labour in an industry. It's all interconnected. If workforce is available, and its competitive robotics will not be attractive for the companies.
Declining population will push companies into automation to keep things affordable for the population as well.
If people don't have jobs then who will buy from automation companies
Yes I agree with your pont
India is only 🇮🇳India
Instead of being offended with the title, we Indians should be offended with the blatant lies in the video itself, but NOBODY even noticed those lies. Because most of us don't read the newspaper or keep up to date with policy issues in India. And then we go out to vote (or not) without having the basic bloody knowledge required for voting for the right people. The only thing we are good for is writing the kind of low-IQ and emotionally charged comments the kind of which you just wrote.
Bangladesh used some pretty risky and intense methods to grow it's economy as they didn't wanted to end up like pakistan and sri-lanka which are screwed as they took heavy chinese loans for their fragile economies.
@@autumn5905 Yeah that mindset only helps those that doesn't have corrupt elites controlling all the loaned money a country gets and filling their vault sized bellies with it, and the people pay the price back. Even India took a loan once, but today it's the 3rd largest economy by purchase power parity and 5th largest nominal, Because it had the will power to rise so the loan helped and didn't worsen the already fragile economy like Pakistan and srilanka, grasp the meaning in my opinion, or simply don't bother tp read and then give a stupid reply 🙂
Bangladesh is soon gonna meet the fate as Sri Lanka and Pakistan... Although Bangladesh is Bengali people so China's gonna hava a hard time to achieve that. LOL
Bangladesh crossed India in GDP per capita
But real economy is measured in term GDP ppp and gdp nominal in which india has surpassed even European countries
This year imf predicts india will cross Bangladesh per capita
@@sanjithrithvik3548 bro dont know about imf but our recent govt data says our gdp per capita is 2800+usd as foe fyscal year 22.......... Its obvious that both Bangladesh and india will rise cause we are meant ro be
Maybe cause India has 20 times the population of the most populous country in Europe? India is a poor dirty country.
@@mihrimaainunferdaus388 No. Its not that obvious. The measure of whether a country's economy will continue to rise is the "Economic Complexity Ranking". In this India is ranked 42 while Bangladesh is ranked 108. Moreover, India is quickly climbing these ranks, meanwhile Bangladesh is falling. This is because Bangladesh economy is a one-trick pony that relies on low-tech textile sector alone. Even in High-tech textiles, Bangladesh is not much. Its obvious that you won't grow forever if you don't have a diverse economy. Its basic economics. And therefore, India will continue to grow, while Bangladesh might not.
Lets eye for the future....
jaby nice discussion gaining so much knowledge because of you ♥
I'm just watching for achara, she's beautiful ❤️
Yaa gora😂
@@akshyadas7867 hahahaha 🤣 Op
The video is very accurate and informative.Thanks jaby for choosing such a video to react.
We have our own identity..We are self sufficient..We are the cosmic chaos..We are unique..❤❤❤
And unemployed
Instead of being offended with the title, we Indians should be offended with the blatant lies in the video itself, but NOBODY even noticed those lies. Because most of us don't read the newspaper or keep up to date with policy issues in India. And then we go out to vote (or not) without having the basic bloody knowledge required for voting for the right people. The only thing we are good for is writing the kind of low-IQ and emotionally charged comments the kind of which you just wrote.
@@death_parade bro people like you always try to find the hole in everything..this comment is not on government policy or patriotism. Everyone has their unique way to achieve success and we don't need to copy anyone. Socio-economic and political background of india and china are totally different. So you just be happy with your high IQ. I don't have any problem.
19:10 - 19:13 that smile 😃 on Achara's face when presenter said "it has broken myth only men required in automobile 🚗 sector".
Who wants to be China
In development definitely but never in other aspects 😃
but in organic development no like there ghost cities and inflated GDP numbers
Why not like Japan in development ?
Instead of being offended with the title, we Indians should be offended with the blatant lies in the video itself, but NOBODY even noticed those lies. Because most of us don't read the newspaper or keep up to date with policy issues in India. And then we go out to vote (or not) without having the basic bloody knowledge required for voting for the right people. The only thing we are good for is writing the kind of low-IQ and emotionally charged comments the kind of which you just wrote.
India always an India ..it's unique
20% women for Indian population is definitely way more than 40% for Bangladesh's population, but it's still sad to see that's what's happening!
according to IMF
gdp per capita of india 2022 nominal = 2515$
gdp per capita of bangladesh 2022 nominal = 2362$
and gdp ppp india 2022=8358usd
bangladesh ppp =6633usd
The measure of whether a country's economy will continue to rise is the "Economic Complexity Ranking". In this India is ranked 42 while Bangladesh is ranked 108. Moreover, India is quickly climbing these ranks, meanwhile Bangladesh is falling. This is because Bangladesh economy is a one-trick pony that relies on low-tech textile sector alone. Even in High-tech textiles, Bangladesh is not much. Its obvious that you won't grow forever if you don't have a diverse economy. Its basic economics. And therefore, India will continue to grow, while Bangladesh might not.
People praising Jio should remember. Jio was possible because Of Modi ji , He forgive so much tax for jio for Ambani that is how it was possible. Same with GST many people criticized it first but now all intellectuals are saying this is good, Modi ji is a visionary leader don't doubt him
India wont be next china US wont allow that to happen like it did with China. India anyday would want a multipolar world .
Pagal haii kyaa , india hates to see china rise , they are messing up our border
We are talking about economy and not geopolitics
@@karankapoor2701 When did i say that i love the chinese rise. But understand this US also wont allow india to grow beyond a certain threshold . They believe that india too wont tow their line if india too grows to be overpowered , Like they did with china. US throughout history has someway or other hindered indian stability if you would know history.
Multipolar world......here the government is hellbent on making a singular majoritarian country. What are you talking about?
Who the F is USA? We are Independent enough to take our own decisions
India isn't the next china ,India is the next World leader
India is India 🙂
UP has the 3rd highest GDP in India now at $230BN. Yogi gov has did great job. In last 5 years per capita income in UP has doubled.
18:10
Misleading. Bangladesh falls under United Nation's category of Least Developed Countries (LDC) and hence enjoys certain benefits in global trade, tax relaxations and financial benefits.
Once, India also enjoyed this benefits.
@@saifulislamakash1049 Never. LDC was started by UN in late 80s with around 50 countries. Do check the list.
do not underestimate the power of people who do not want this to happen.....they are very powerful and will do anything to make this journey a rough one
With the horrible governance from our current government, the Indian GDP isn't going to increase to even $3 Trillion Dollars, let alone $5 Trillion by 2025. The government had been ruining the economy, they have imposed huge redundant taxes, and have forced many companies out of India. Because of this, many people have been pushed into poverty and currently 280 Million people are living in Poverty in India. I just hope that the government gets changed soon, or they understand their makes and reform the issues without just talking, but with action.
What a joker. India's economy already crossed $3 Trillion mark.
Now i know why ola scooters were malfunctioning XDD (not meant to hurt anyone)
How can politicians can think long term if they are not sure that they will remain in power for long?
You can also think like..if the politicians think like if we did good in our period of time given by our people then people will accept us for the next years as well.
@@craz7644 But the policies always take 3-4 years to implement. If good results are there from the policies and if the party who implemented it will not be in power the credit will be taken by next government. Ex - 1999-2004 During atal Bihari Vajpayee many reformed policy were implemented but the results of that was credited by UPA government after 2004.
Bureaucracy and the Political interest of politicians are responsible for holding India back.
Sare Jahan se achha hindustan hamara 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳 Jay Hind
India is not next china or usa or russia... india is india...india is bharat...for now for the last thousands of years and gor the future tooo...india is unique ..
according to IMF
gdp per capita of india 2022 nominal = 2515$
gdp per capita of bangladesh 2022 nominal = 2362$
and gdp ppp india 2022=8358usd
bangladesh ppp =6633usd
Make in India is not something that we only wants to make for ourselves but it's a process in which we are decreasing dependance on foreign materials so that the wealth of our nation won't get exhausted and also to make things to export for world.
India is a democracy with socialist characteristics so yes with correct methods and policies implementation India will surpass China but other major factor is currently disrupting these goals like Foreign trade barriers and diplomatic relations. It's a current situation please don't hesitate to share your thoughts.👍
India is just India.
We don't want to replace any other nation. We are recreating our own space.
Jaby looking good in that shirt😉,🏖️ vibes...
India too is moving towards automation. It is probably not visible globally but you will see in coming 5 years that India will be a big Automation service provider in the world.
OOf this video, Retrospective taxes was started by previous govt, and required major legislation in both houses to reverse old law. *Fact that retrospective taxes have been abolished couple of years ago now by law, and this documentary still wants to harp on it, makes me wonder on their objective. The problems they have listed in India, do they still exist is the question, if not, then should documentary be about India has overcome past hurdles etc and ready for business - its like they know India will be next China and have to make a documentary about it, but lets take money from china and make it the most negative way possible*
@the illegitimate TY SON can't help. Govt Don't wants to be look bad knowing thy will loose the case. Past govt did Blunders there was an incident were thy made new law overnight to collect more taxs.
Even TATA was unable to open their factory in own country how will Foriegn company do that.
@the illegitimate TY SON Not quite, unable to attach link, must be youtube policy - Search article "Govt accepts Cairn's offer on retro tax; company to withdraw cases now, refund to follow" ET Economic times article Nov 18, 20121.
Search Article " Govt to settle almost all retro-tax cases this month: Revenue Secy" another ET article Feb 5 2022
then if you research, some Indian assets outside were frozen, they have been released long back, all points to cases been resolved. You my friend are either unresearched or unaware of updates..
If you still dont believe call up any foreign company who was victim of this law and asked them of status, they will confirm either money has been received back by them from Indian govt or another lucrative contract been offered as a offset or standard due process is going on of fund clearance in tranches by the revenue Sect of India.
Exactly. And look at the number of Indians in the comment section lauding this documentary for its "accuracy". Seriously, gora worship is in our blood, seems like. Was wondering if not a single person caught that fact about retrospective taxes, gladly there was at least some one.
I recommend The Ranveer Show Podcast of BeerBiceps with abhijeet Chawda for more geopolitical info of India
the awkwardness of when u hate China but want to become China!!!
Nah want to be more than china
Nobody wants to become china
Well you kinda hate your competitors
Who said we want to be like china?
India is one of the strongest democracies in the world
One of the most important difference between both countries is one is a democracy and other one is dictatorship
That’s what made one country prosper to new heights and one still hanging with religion warfare
For your information the rule of retrospective taxes are dumped by indian government few months back
We can literally be any country other than china😂😂😂
Though our aim was to become a 5 trillion dollar economy till 2025 ..IMF has said it will be achieved by 2026 due to pandemic..as india is the fastest growing economy in the world now..
India wants a multipolar world
We don't want to be second china,we want to be first India🇮🇳
India is now Fastest growing economy with 8.5% and if india will grow more faster like 9.5 then 5 trillion will be more faster and Most important is India is focusing on Manufacturing Hub of all sector. India us developing it's infrastructure to reduce Logistics and increase trade , As china is Communist so they developed fast but india is democratic so u can say there ate many hurdles. Some project also slow bcz of politics ,NGOs. India needs more Reforms and policy.
Now India is doing best in foreign policy to attract FDI ( $88 billion recently) and more fdi morr development. But i can say India will definitely grow faster upto 2030( 9-10 trillion) 3rd largest economy and India have much potential to replace China.
Modi is one of the best PM of india, who transformed India as new India 🇮🇳. If i explained how then i can't cuz u need one more video for that.
India for now need One nation One election to reduce expenditure in election , UCC CAA ( for Internal stability), More industrial city, economic corridor.
By 2024 india will have American quality roads and upto 2025 india Infrastructure will be much develop , cuz it's construc. is faster
Btw Jaby ur shirt is really nice and vibe is amazing, hope u read this
You live in a dream
indian like to make dream
'Make in India for the world' is Modi ji's new mantra! 🇮🇳
Comparison is there for a reason ... If we want to be different we have to get into Research and Development which we seriously lack except for two or three sector eg ISRO DRDO, but DRDO needs to do a lot more work it is still behind many other defense organisation of other countries unlike ISRO. else India will be next China you may like it or not.
This myth of "DRDO being behind ISRO" is nonsense spouted by people who don't know anything detailed about these organizations, their efforts and success stories.
We are not competing with any one we are competing with ourselves
we wont be next china we will be (BHARAT)
China's economy grew because of exports - the focus on their internal markets came later. It's the other way round for India - local market growth early on, consequently build manufacturing base and improve quality for local market as it matures and moves up the value chain - those low prices become a competitive advantage for exports later. There are already several examples of such process and success.
Jaby, the shirt 😍😍
India is thousands years old.. and India remained india.. and will remain India..
Quite a strange and wron comprasion and Bangladesh one funny bcs they are dependent on only textile. Srilanka was also ahead of India
I'm Unable to understand why India wants to attract foreign companies to establish factories here. The Country with huge population is obviously has huge demands which should has to be lead us establishing our own companies, making them bigger by getting in-home profit, exporting the production. The perfect Examples are: Byju's, unacademy (education); Swiggy, Zomato (food delivery); Capillary Technologies (Capillary Technologies is a software product company, which provides cloud-based Omnichannel Customer Engagement, eCommerce platform and related services for retailers and brands). This proves that we doesn't need any foreign support for our economic developments.
A country without being manufacturing hub can never become regional or world power...if u r thinking that homegrown start-ups is alone do good for india then there is funding which is largely invested by foreign players..swiggy,zomato,lenskart etc all have major funding from foreign players like Softbank...china is today so large because of manufacturing that western companies shifted their plant in china...apart from manufacturing china building it's own companies and other things as they get money from manufacturing sector so u can never say that why india want companies to come in india they come they invest dollar take local currency and setting up there plant and cycle goes on... Before 1991 we r like that we don't want foreign companies and u know what happened at that time... We have to industrilize ourselves till we have healthy wealth distribution and per capita GDP...china despite being 2nd largest economy have per capita 10,000$ and india today have 2500$ it's only four times vice -versa to GDP to...
@@vaibhavgupta9934 hmmmm, understood thanks brother
At the end of 2020, China's GDP was US$14.72 trillion, and at the end of 2021 it was US$17.7 trillion. 1 year: 2.98 trillion. 1year=1 india. The part it adds in a year is almost equal to the entire GDP of India. There is really no comparison between the two countries at the moment. Let's be realistic.
I agree
Only because of British, I wish we could f them up so bad like they did to us .....
Yes there is a gap but nothing is impossible. Even China was once poor but they developed.
With all due respect India is now a 3.53 trillion dollar economy and yes we truly have very very long way to go
@@sunnyboynfs When Bill Gates was young, he was just like you and had no education. Yes, if you work hard, it is possible to be as successful as him. But there are billions of people around the world who have this dream. Most don't end up that well, do they? It's good to have expectations in life, but be realistic.
Not just economically, politically we are heading there.
See we get that import taxes are high , but one may look upto the pages of history the openness will indicate a foreign monopoly once again the strategy used by east india company to capture india and exploit it . Govt of India has been strictly following everything to protect its indigenous trade and business which ofcourse hinders the MNCs and foreign companies. That has both sides. For example (Negative) due to make in india and many tarrif and taxes Tesla isn't still being able to be sold or used in indian streets although Tesla is promising in making cars suitable for the market . But(positive) Tata and many other companies have started using their own research and FDIs to make new Electric concept vehicles which will soon by 2025 be released for indian market and then to the world .
Yup
Bangladesh some time earlier had more GDP per capita ..still bangladeshi people wants to come to india ..they are everywhere in india. .. 😂😂
India should avoid exporting raw material, only value added goods should be exported.
No. That is a stupid idea. We should give incentives to those that add more value in their products within India, but shouldn't outright BAN raw material exports.
Take the titanium industry of India, for example. Had we not had a developed Titanium mining sector, we wouldn't have been able to create the Titanium Sponge plant in India and then not have been able to create the Titanium vertical at MIDHANI that today can meet all of India's titanium needs end-end within India. This phenomenal achievement wouldn't have been possible without India starting with Titanium ore export.
Happy Raja to you 🎉❣️❣️❣️🎉🎉🎉
From Odisha, India
I might not like ccp today but deng xioping was one if the most visionary leaders to have ever been lived , he always said bide your time and work harder. Which eventually lead china to rule global econony today. India should follow those steps, to become self sufficient in every field.
we live in a democracy we can't force people to do this or that
everyone loves china but when the china bubble will break shockwave of that feel in every part of the world
@@Ishantyagiofficial Liking a leader does not mean that i love his policies or his decisions. I just like deng xioping for his leadership.
@@shodhitgoyal6539 yup his vision is great for his country but kuch pane ke liye kuch khona padta hai
I think India is only the country which have multi dialects and speak multi languages even in the movies, news etc. I just love it.
That's why India have so much corruption, protest, politics, Stereotypes, over population etc... People literally want to live in another country. Padega India tabhi to badega USA, UK, FRANCE, UAE
National Language tho decide hoti nhi fir bolte hai UN m koi Indian languages kyu nhi hai. Indian cinema globally recognised kyu nhi hai. Jb tk Bollywood world level p famous huwa tumhara Tollywood sandalwood Nollywood mollywood lollywood RR suru ho gya
India has same ability like china has ..&even trained & ability to work anywhere in world
Diving through the comments, I find that the pride of the Indians is not a problem that can be solved easily. From a geopolitical perspective, South Asia has been extremely toxic and confined to their own little bubble that their nation is supposed to be the best.
Taking the case of us Indians, we don’t help an ally nation without mentioning it in their faces. For eg, Nepal being so similar ideologically to India has been left alienated after India rubs it in their faces that they are here just because the contribution of India. Same with Bangladesh, who has shifted its allegiance with China. We Indians don’t miss an opportunity to say that Bangladesh is a country just because India helped in 1971.
As said by a legend, never mention the good deeds and the world will be yours. Indians need to realise that our pride will be the doom of us.