India’s Mega Naval Op Projects Power, Sends Out Strong Message
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 10 сен 2024
- NEW DELHI: Last week, the Indian Navy showcased its maritime capabilities in the Arabian Sea, one that involved two carrier battle groups in the first such operation in over a decade. Two aircraft carriers-INS Vikramaditya and INS Vikrant-operated in the exercise that had the coordinated deployment of more than 30 combat aircraft. A carrier battle group projects power and sends out a strong message to the adversary as well, says Vice Admiral Shekhar Sinha (Retd), former Commander-in-Chief of the Western Naval Command. He was speaking to StratNews Global Editor-in-Chief Nitin A. Gokhale on ‘The Gist’.
Since many of our well-wishers requested a UPI payment id to contribute and support us, here’s the link, which gives us 100% of what you choose: stratnewsgloba...
You can also click and buy a RUclips Super Thanks(the heart icon where you liked this video), which directly supports StratNewsGlobal, with 70% of your chosen amount.
Leave your comments, questions and feedback. Like and share our videos.
Subscribe to our RUclips channel. Click on the 🔔icon to get notified of our latest uploads.
To get instant updates join our telegram circle - t.me/stratnews...
Your programs are always insightful on defence matters Nitin Gokhale Sir... You are doing great service to Mother India ...!! 👏👏🙏🏻🙏🏻💗💗
Very rightly said Vice Admiral Shekhar Sinha sir, that we need 3 aircraft carriers.
But we shouldn't stop at defense.
4th, 5th, and 6th will make the enemy shiver and give us more control on Indian ocean.
Thank you Nitin and Thank you VA Sinha sir🙏🙏
Great to see and listen to Admiral a good friend and senior, who has exchanged many notes of peace and development in our NER and periphery. Thank you stratsnews global. JAI HIND
Superb analysis and discussion!!! Thank you very much to both Nitin and Vice Admiral Sinha
India needs 4 aircraft carriers for deployment of 3 CBGs because when one is under repair/refit, the standby aircraft carrier can be used to replace the same.
Mr. Sinha is well spoken, no Wishy Washy, straight to the point...Excellent insight, like to see him more here
We need fixed wing airborne early warning aircrafts to take off from aircraft carrier... And for that we need bigger aircraft carrier... Hope govt approves for building new Aircraft carrier with higher displacement in the very near future. We need to take off P-8 aircrafts from aircraft carrier
Thanks for the information which were new to me❤
Nitin this was an amazing eye opener on Navy ops
When it's required and at appropriate timing, India's capability to destroy targeted satellites in space should also be displayed. Just to assure the Chinese of disproportionate damage in the event of a full blown war
Great to hear from someone with experience
Enlightening. Thankyou
Very Good Information sir,
Thanks to Both.
Jai Hind 🇮🇳 🇮🇳 🇮🇳
Undoubtedly the best reporting,analysis ,strategic ,factual , pleaseing presentation audio video n delivery . No hype or anxiety in interviews n has GUTS
WITH A ZEE. .
Thank you Nitin I have seen very few better .
Gets me thinking.
Admiral Sinha Sahab ne bakhubi Indian naval strategic value ko samjhaya aap donon ka dhanyvad
Thank you Nitin. Very insightful.
India should conduct massive naval ecercises at the mouuh of malacca straits to send strong message to china.
Thank you for a riveting episode as also for inviting Vice Admiral Sinha to the discussion 🙏
Very interesting.. Thanks
Thanks to Nitin Gokhale for a very good overview from V Adm Sinha regarding the practicalities of two aircraft carriers and their impact on the naval capabilities of the country. Some of India's naval bases in the IOR, such as on the Andaman islands and other bases in the Arabian sea area were mentioned in passing. But one understands that India also has an agreement with Oman for the use of a naval base, as well as another airstrip and base under construction on an island belonging to Mauritius. Perhaps in subsequent episodes, it would be interesting to have an overview of India's naval bases in the IOR and how they coordinate with the navies of other nations, particularly the U.S. Navy with its base in Diego Garcia and the French Navy (which is also identified as an important maritime power working closely with India in the IOR), which presumably, has a base in the Reunion Islands. What do joint naval exercises between the Indian Navy and the navies of the U.S. and France, as well as other Quad members, Japan and Australia, achieve in practical terms? Are they mainly goodwill exercises that enhance inter-operability, or are there strategic maritime advantages to India?
Thank you for your suggestion, we will keep on bringing such informative pieces, stay tuned.
How come you have only 1.25 lakh subscribers since so many years? Other RUclipsrs have crossed a million mark.
The reason could be that this is a very strategic and intellectual discussion based channel. The ones you are comparing may be more rhetorical and masala style presentation, which always attracts more people. That being said, 1.25 lakh is definitely on the low side. Maybe we all should talk about this channel in our WhatsApp groups. And also Nitin should try to work out some promotions online.
Wonderful & insightful discussion.
this was great! Please make longer discussion videos on defense.. something of a roundtable would be great
Thank you for the suggestion, we are planning to bring different content for your viewers do suggest us if you want us to cover any topic.
We would like to know from the panel , why India doesn't have shore based navel airbases and navel fighter jets and long range bombers to tackle enemy battle ships?
Navy do have shore based naval Air bases
@@sunilrana7114
One or two
It's not enough
One submarine firing a torpedo and your billion dollar ship inside the ocean . U need submarines nuclear submarines . To become a king under the sea . God bless our navy
Two small aircraft carriers may scare Pakistan or some small nations but when you talk of China who plans to have 10 big size aircraft carriers by the end of this decade, how would the Indian navy plan to block the Malacca Strait with such a bad ratio of 10:2 or 10:3 even if you hypothetically claim that the PLAN does not have advanced or good hardware. The Chinese are no fools and probably already planned counter measures to such vulnerabilities. Image a scenario where in they send 4 or 5 of their aircraft carriers well in advance to different parts of the Indian Ocean or Arabian Sea where they have bases; would the Indian navy still have 1 or 2 of its aircraft carrier at Malacca?
Nitin should when can we expect the 3rd aircraft carrier so one carrier in Dock
When a carrier is in Dock we can have two groups at sea permanently
Scary maaann.... Even with transparent cups its hard to follow... Super like 🎉
👍
Insightful and informative
Chennai and Bhubaneswar needs navel airbases on its shores and long range bombers for immediate action , if enemy forces attack Andaman Islands.
It can protect and do surveillance the entire bay of Bangal by deploying P8i s
LCA is a small plane... our aircraft carriers not being 'flat tops' planes spend too much fuel while taking off. This means either less pay load or, less range. We need marine Rafels ... another 36 of them ..or, 54 of them if we are going to have 3 aircraft carriers.
Submarines for a reason are called silent killers . They are not meant for power projection . Image in a war situation if one of your aircraft carrier is down with repairs then what will h do how will u then tackle ur enemies aircraft carrier
high time andaman & nicobar are fully equipped militarily
Not a very bright idea to operate 2 carriers in such close proximity. They become such easy targets. And use the advantage of covering a larger area by using the range of the naval fighters.IACs should be deployed at edges of the operating envelope of the mig 29s .such pics make for good photo ops.but bad strategy.
Mf star radar still missing on Vikrant, any idea how this effects the ships deploybility?
Great debate but should we not observe secrecy
How's Vikramaditya's fire damage?
Thank you. Always insightful this channel is. Rest are superficial and silly narratives.
take malaca
Very informative and Funny ...we live in paradise. When some general of calibre of Mr. manekshawa ..Mr cariappa or Mr. Sunderji ll come and replace this naive people's in defence.
Does it really take a tactical nuclear anti ship missile to destroy a 100,000 tonne aircraft carrier? Can the biggest Chinese aircraft carrier survive a number of anti ship missile hits? Apparently, the Soviet Union used to talk about destroying the Nimitz Class aircraft carriers with nuclear missiles.
Do we need to sail into the Indian Ocean with our carrier battle groups to engage the enemy there? If an enemy naval group exits the Strait of Malacca and enters the Indian Ocean, it will not be able to turn far and go opposite to peninsular India, in order to avoid naval bombings. Perhaps, I am mistaken. Won't P-8 Orions be able to detect enemy shipping even before they cross the Malacca Strait?
Carrier Battle Groups can also be sitting ducks as was the case when the Prince of Wales and Repulse were sunk by Japan's kamikaze pilots during WWII; would have liked to know what are the modern measures that can be deployed to protect the CBGs during a conflict
Does anyone fear our Mig-29s?
India needs 4 Aircraft carrier battle groups to protect its marine boundaries from east to west asia with 2 nuclear submarine & 4 conventional submarines.... It will be a mighty indian navy
With respect to Pakistan with nuclear weapons first use option they hav ..what aircraft carrier group of India can do ..by reaching within range of Pakistan nuclear tipped cruise missile which can sank ..our CBGs.. china can sank American carriers groups...with powerful cruise missiles. We think Pakistan won't get it eventually.
Admiral - does China can be aggressive around Andaman so far away from their home land.
Sir what is your thoughts about this government mentality towards navy? They must lack the understanding about navy. For the past 9 year no new aircraft carrier, no new helicopter carrier, no new submarines, no new nuclear submarines, no new destroyer type is sanctioned by this government. All the ships that joined are approved by previous government. After this batches next 7/8 years we will have very little capital ships addition. I would like to say this is navy's lost decades. They always put naval projects on hold due to fund shortage. Even we got only 36 Rafael for airforce. With LCA we can't win against Chinese. They have invested money on special forces and average infantry. They are now very well equipped but where we need long term pans and capital this government seems to lacking. What is your thoughts on this matter? Do you think next 6/7 years will be navy's lost time?
1 Multiple destroyers and frigates are in line for the next decade, don't know where you heard that
2. the issue with conventional submarines is that the Navy wants indigenous AIP installed in the new submarines which it is finding very difficult to get a partner for
3 The airforce has been running. The MMCRA program for almost 18 years now and it is still confused on what it wants. Multiple governments over the last 12 years have asked them to take a call on it but for some reason they're super hesitant 🤷♂️
@@amithabv1060 multiple destroyer? All visakapatnam class destroyer are near complete and p18 is in concepts stage. Actual drawing and fund allocation after that start of production in country like india will take minimum 10 year. That is gap of 1 decades. I know multiple frigates are coming out that's why i never mentioned frigates. I mentioned aircraft carrier, destroyer, submarines, LPD which will have gap of 7 to 12 years.
Good defence minister always seat with services and short out matters. Just like late parekar who forced airforce to buy 36 Rafael, LCA mk1A, tarbo prop training aircraft. Other than parekar for last 10 years we didn't had any dynamic visionary defence minister that's why this capability gap created via Chinese.
@@ranadeepjash1150 1 at no time does the planning and the funding take place over 10yrs
,2 over 50k crore was provided for project 17, and 20k cr for the destroyers
3 there is a debate within the Navy itself on the future of aircraft carriers. With the coming in of hypersonic weapons the entire scenario has changed ( Go watch the confirmation heading of the last US naval commander)
@@ranadeepjash1150 4 first there has to be a vision document by the Navy on its role. Can't Just randomly go around buying ships that it likes. The entire inventory has to be mission specific. Whether it's area deniability or capability projection
I won't call a ship without catapult a real carrier
India needs everything, but the most urgent thing should be public toilets.
Tera Kia hoga Kalia love u china
Lol bhikari
🤦🏻♂️🤣
Give me a break! Aircraft carrier without aircraft is just a piece of junk!
It could be useful as another hotel