Pinkie isn’t seen here…it was her, she coughed not Fluttershy. That’s what I’ve always believed when I first listened to the fanfiction all those years ago
OMG YESS, I've always thought so to (BECAUSE OF THIER ELEMENTS)!! But, I couldn't add pinkie pie because of how difficult her voice is to replicate :ccc So I changed it some, im sorryy!!
fluttershy: i couldnt live with myself if any of you died and i could of prevented it. that line right there is the indicator that she sacrficed herself. Edit: heres a thought what if she wasnt lying and infact there were multiple people infected?
I theorize that Fluttershy never coughed, and that it was Rarity. Rarity asked if they could forget about it and looked the most scared. Fluttershy was right next to her and would probably have been able to tell it was her. I think Fluttershy, hoping Rarity wasn't really infected, lied and sacrificed herself since it was clear someone was going to die for it. ❤😢❤ Fluttershy has such a big heart, I can easily see her lying to protect a friend. Edit: I'm sorry I forgot to include, this video is very well made and it spooked the heck out of me. It's great ❤😂
A part 2 was made in 2017 and it said applejack was the one who coughed and lied about not coughing and it makes since sense she was near applebloom when she got infected and it said fluttershy had enough of the virus and lied cause she wanted to died and leave the hurt or should I say stop hurting
@@joeypoland2756 What's part two called? Also that does come off as abit insidious because then she was letting her die so she didn't get killed for being infected. Also thank you for your insight! I wasn't certain if this was directly connected to a specific AU and was trying to go off visual details. :)
Finally- it made more sense for AppleJack to put flutters down- I feel like in the original, it didn’t make sense for Rainbow dash to do it- even with the half-ass explanation AppleJack spent her whole life kicking trees!
“I couldn’t live with myself if any of you died and I could have prevented it” Oh my god this just means she lied and sacrificed herself so she wouldn’t have to deal with the pain Fluttershy NO 😭😭
@@Breathe_Oxygen2Either that, or they took too long and it spread(it's a bit ambiguous as it ends with the cough originally with nothing afterwards) There's also sequel that apparently reveals who coughed and explains more from the original story
For people who don't know, the reason why Rainbow Dash got so mad and started saying "Where are they when you need them the most", she's referring to Celestia and Luna for not helping in THAT whole situation
Think it was Rarity. Applejack being the element of honesty probably wouldn’t lie about it, Twilight panicked when there was a cough, and by the way she said it Fluttershy wasn’t the one who coughed but gave herself up to save others. Leaving Rainbow Dash and Rarity. Possibly RD but she panicked right away as well and it seems Rarity was the most nervous. She was the one to suggest to forget about it rather quickly. Unless Pinkie Pie was hiding
Ah yes. The original mlp infection au. Again, real nostalgia. I'm just so happy this side of the mlp fandom is returning in new forms. So that new generations can be as traumatized as we were as young kids.
Things i did before sleeping: 1) searching Momo the chicken in googol 2) watching mandela catalogue 3) saw a short about a girl covered in blood doing cannibalism 4) watched this video Result: Nightmares, cant sleep, anxiousness, eyes wide open
Imagine if it was an MLP version of the Lacey Fletcher incident. (I'm not trying to joke about her death. It was a very tragic thing. I'd rather not type the story here so go read something about it)
Dammit STARLY! YOU JOINED THE TREND! I thought this was something else, and I had to re-read the channel title over and over. I couldn't laugh one bit during it all. It was so dark and suspensful that I couldn't dare ruin the moment. On the other hand, the last part make me chuckle a bit. MORE! DO IT MORE! First it was Makaryo, and now its you. I can't stop replaying this. Much love ❤ and stay awesome!
this is so good!!?! this is so different from your other videos, and i already love it. I did not expect that end tho😭 (it does not help that i watched the friendship test before this😓😓)
Not as scary as i was expecting but as someone who relates to flutter shy and has a bad coughing problem it did get to me a little bit, i feel really bad for all of them but i will say who ever lied should be ashamed of their self as they put everypony throw that and got flutter shy k*lled because she didn't want anyone else to be hurt.
Wait wait-when flutter shy said she coughed I think when rarity said “flutter-shy!” I think she was trynna to talk to her…and when she was talking to twilight she was like “we’re not gonna actually..” I think she didn’t want flutter shy to die because of her?
Wow, that was a interesting and shocking video (as the same level it was from the original fic). Well done, #StarlyCookie, hope we can see more very soon. 👍🏽👍🏽
Honestly this is my opinion why fluttershy blamed herself: because she didn't want to deal with this shit and Want to go to a place where she can be happy😭😭😭
I’ve never seen MLP content before and well I have no idea what the story is even if this is fanfic, also I only clicked on this because it’s got the funniest horror title ever. Chest infection.
This was great! Just letting you know that the creepypasta link in the desc is potentially dangerous since people keep editing shady links into the wiki
Everyone thinks its Rarity, but i think its Applejack since when she was checking on Apple Bloom u can hear her say “hey apple bloom?” AND COUGHED AFTER ASKING IF SHES ALRIGHT 0:53
Oh my goodness, i look for this for so many years, i remember to hear that story when i was 10 and forgot what was the name of this, so many traumatized memories come back now.
Pinkie isn’t seen here…it was her, she coughed not Fluttershy. That’s what I’ve always believed when I first listened to the fanfiction all those years ago
OMG YESS, I've always thought so to (BECAUSE OF THIER ELEMENTS)!! But, I couldn't add pinkie pie because of how difficult her voice is to replicate :ccc
So I changed it some, im sorryy!!
It's alright maybe you can make a alternate ending to it @@starlycookie
But Pinkie actually appears on the OG fanfiction, right?
Actually in the sequel it was Applejack, though Pinkie would have made more sense
Bro I....
I loved it this should become a series!
this is gonna be somebody’s childhood
YEAAA FRRR
It sure is mine.
nah deadass
I'm a child..
@@onmyojiy12342 me too
The first mlp infection AU, we never forget
IKR!???
The Cough is what started this trend
YESSSSS
fr
This and something sweet to bite.
twilights ”FUCK” got me ascending 💀
LMAO SAME😭
SAME
FRL.
Lol😂
TRUE
fluttershy: i couldnt live with myself if any of you died and i could of prevented it.
that line right there is the indicator that she sacrficed herself.
Edit: heres a thought what if she wasnt lying and infact there were multiple people infected?
it rarity I think
I believe it was applejack like you can tell the difference in their voices. I thought it was clear as day that it was applejack.
@@Cosmicallygaming but thats a bit unlogical, since applejack wouldn't have lied cuz shes literalky the embodiment of honesty
someone said there was a part two of this story posted in 2017(?) and that applejack was the one who coughed @@justliz206
I also believed that there was more than one pony infected
i love how twilight keeps forgetting shes an alicorn, like her wings are lite3rally dissapearing
I theorize that Fluttershy never coughed, and that it was Rarity. Rarity asked if they could forget about it and looked the most scared. Fluttershy was right next to her and would probably have been able to tell it was her. I think Fluttershy, hoping Rarity wasn't really infected, lied and sacrificed herself since it was clear someone was going to die for it.
❤😢❤
Fluttershy has such a big heart, I can easily see her lying to protect a friend.
Edit: I'm sorry I forgot to include, this video is very well made and it spooked the heck out of me. It's great ❤😂
A part 2 was made in 2017 and it said applejack was the one who coughed and lied about not coughing and it makes since sense she was near applebloom when she got infected and it said fluttershy had enough of the virus and lied cause she wanted to died and leave the hurt or should I say stop hurting
Wait where is part two?
@@joeypoland2756 What's part two called? Also that does come off as abit insidious because then she was letting her die so she didn't get killed for being infected.
Also thank you for your insight! I wasn't certain if this was directly connected to a specific AU and was trying to go off visual details. :)
@@Borg231you can go on google to this website called fandom and both parts are on there. I’ve read almost every mlp horror story on that thing😭
honestly what i though as well
"WHO JUST COUGHED?!" gave me a slight jumpscare for 00.1milsecond
and twilight’s *”FUCK”*
Finally- it made more sense for AppleJack to put flutters down- I feel like in the original, it didn’t make sense for Rainbow dash to do it- even with the half-ass explanation AppleJack spent her whole life kicking trees!
I always thought the same thing!
2:04 "FUCK" twilight said calmly.
2:14
“NO”
harry potter reference!
@@Shanaayelololindeed
On how much I don't understand those mlp virus au's, I love animations and arts that come from those, and this is one of them
Hey, I watched your videos
This is based from a really old creepypasta from nearly a decade ago
My favorite is the black tree virus to be honest
@@Akira-MonomiOriginaleverfree is pretty great tbh
@@ghostlyboos6864 is it now? I’ll have to check
“I couldn’t live with myself if any of you died and I could have prevented it” Oh my god this just means she lied and sacrificed herself so she wouldn’t have to deal with the pain Fluttershy NO 😭😭
3:20 NO DONT DO THIS PLS TELL ME SHE TOLD THE TRUTH BC IF IT WASNT HER HAS TO BE RARITY
Bro they killed flutter shy for no reason that is sad
@@Breathe_Oxygen2Either that, or they took too long and it spread(it's a bit ambiguous as it ends with the cough originally with nothing afterwards)
There's also sequel that apparently reveals who coughed and explains more from the original story
Or rather she lied, thus leading to the remaining four getting infected … she literally killed them with kindness 😓😓😓
Y’all know goddamn well that we need more of this
w t f 4:04
wtf 5:23
MURDER DRONE PFP
WE DOOO
For people who don't know, the reason why Rainbow Dash got so mad and started saying "Where are they when you need them the most", she's referring to Celestia and Luna for not helping in THAT whole situation
this one is actually better than the original where you can easily tell who cough first
What is it called?
@@floppymioThe Cough
I think I know who it was, but could you tell me so I can be sure?
Think it was Rarity. Applejack being the element of honesty probably wouldn’t lie about it, Twilight panicked when there was a cough, and by the way she said it Fluttershy wasn’t the one who coughed but gave herself up to save others. Leaving Rainbow Dash and Rarity. Possibly RD but she panicked right away as well and it seems Rarity was the most nervous. She was the one to suggest to forget about it rather quickly.
Unless Pinkie Pie was hiding
@@montelt7103 People in this video comment section are saying it was applejack
not me actually feeling sad when rarity had to tell twilight to stop at 5:31
The way twilight said "FUCK" was perfect 🤣
That caught me off guard 😭😭😭
1:44 1:44 1:44 😢
Ah yes. The original mlp infection au. Again, real nostalgia. I'm just so happy this side of the mlp fandom is returning in new forms. So that new generations can be as traumatized as we were as young kids.
... The fact it was poor fluttershy... Shes my baby😭💛
Im so sad..
'But in the darkness. Someone coughed...'
Frr I thought it was rainbow dash but guess I was wrong😭
It was pinkie pie since she ain’t here
In the real story, at the end it says "in the darkness, somepony coughed" so it wasn't Flutter
Did you know that pinkie is actually the strongest in the group?
She has rainbow dash speed.
Twilight intelligence.
Applejack taste.
She’s awesome!
LMAOOO PINKIE PIE ISS SO OVERPOWERD
And happiness (10000000Infinty power)
no applejack is stronger
Nah pinkie pie @@kayleeehunter
and the first SMILE in HD ever
5:30 Twilight : JUST FINISH IT!!!!!!!!!
Rarity : STOP!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Rairty crying is so heartbreaking):
SORRY FOR THE RANDOM SWITCH IN CONTENT 🍪
If we ever do more horror animations, what horror stories would you guys like to see animated? :3
Can you do the black tree infection please?
can you please put boyfriend there in another episode of my little pony
Apple sleep experiment?
How about "Cupcakes" or "Butterflies" fics of this series too? I really enjoyed both of them before. 👍🏽👍🏽
@@compahearts5546Agreed with you. 👍🏽
Things i did before sleeping:
1) searching Momo the chicken in googol
2) watching mandela catalogue
3) saw a short about a girl covered in blood doing cannibalism
4) watched this video
Result: Nightmares, cant sleep, anxiousness, eyes wide open
seems about right tbh
You okay?
“doing cannibalism”
I READ THE TITLE AS ‘The couch’ IM CRYING-
SAME
Imagine if it was an MLP version of the Lacey Fletcher incident.
(I'm not trying to joke about her death. It was a very tragic thing. I'd rather not type the story here so go read something about it)
DAWN??? GIRL I DIDN'T EXPECT TO SEE YOU HERE 😭
@@BeeBeeloved OOPS-
GOT RECOGNIZED NOW I GOTTA GO INTO HIDING 😃✋
@@DawnThe_Foxcaught in 4k 😞
This was an amazing animation! I always loved the Grimdark stories the MLP fandom made! It's nice to see this story again! Keep up the awesome work! 😄
seems like horror is reapeering in the fandom everywhere
Honestly this is SO good, if at all possible I'd love for a part two to this. Not very scary but i love this by a large shot. :D
5:22 Discord: I Love you too Fluttershy 🥺🥺🥺 (cries)
Zephyr: Mommy😭
5:48
Somepony that was probably Pinkie Pie: **cough**
Twilight: "Oh my God... Did we just kill Fluttershy for nothing!?"
End: **Freddy boop**
I think it was Apple jack it sounds like her
Wrong choice
Dude this is actually so good. I’m sure you can make a lot of good horror mlp stuff. I personally think you should do more tbh
“I’m not trained in combat magic” meanwhile that one episode where pinkie pie used twilight as a machine gun foreign lasers out of her horn
I mean, yes. But at such rapid fire, it could be a very weak spell that’s not designed to kill.
Fluttershy's death is just so sad😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
I love these aus so much! It’s fun to watch at night before you gotta go to bed alone lol
Dammit STARLY! YOU JOINED THE TREND! I thought this was something else, and I had to re-read the channel title over and over.
I couldn't laugh one bit during it all. It was so dark and suspensful that I couldn't dare ruin the moment.
On the other hand, the last part make me chuckle a bit. MORE! DO IT MORE!
First it was Makaryo, and now its you. I can't stop replaying this. Much love ❤ and stay awesome!
OMG I SAW HIS AND IT WAS SOOOOOO GOOOD, AND TYSMM🍪🍪🍪🍪
Dude, I absolutely love this AI Remake of the Creepypasta Fanfiction dude!
Starly, you've really put in so much effort into this! Well done! ⭐
this is so good Icl. I love how we don’t have to swipe but just watch it all happen like a movie
5:22 TWILIGHT STOP-
I love how twilight’s wings disappeared and reappear 😂
Amazing video
Oh my word I remember listening an audio of this story! Finally someone's animated it 🤝
omg I remember this pasta reading, I think I heard scribbler read this in the past. And this goes great with all the infection au's going around now!
BROO this story is absolutely fantastic ❤ Good with the video Starly, and I can't wait for the next one to come!
this is so good!!?! this is so different from your other videos, and i already love it. I did not expect that end tho😭 (it does not help that i watched the friendship test before this😓😓)
3:54 Rainbows face tho-😂😂😂
Fr
Its kind the horror game to Horror Rune AU & Horror Tale AU 💀🎮
nah axetale
I love how you changed the storyline a bit with only 5 ponies and instead applejack killing fluttershy. The ending was truly a revelation . Good job!!
That was really high quality, great job with this!
the fact I'm trying to force my cough to stop while watching this
LMAO
@@starlycookie JEEZ I JUST LET OUT THE MOST DISEASEOUS SOUNDING COUGH I'M GONNA GET THE PONIES INFECTED ITS ALL MY FAULTTT
This certainly was a change from the usual content, but it was executed very well Starly! Nice job with this very dark story 👍
0:11 friendship is m-æc
✨friendship is Mac n cheese✨
I just can't with poor Apple Jack shaking after killing Fluttershy...
This will definitely be someone childhood 😭💔
The storytelling is so good broo, literally has me guessing which one coughed
This is one the coolest skits I’ve seen in a long time and so well made^^
"Who just coughed?! "
"F***''
Damm this is awesome.
The ai ponies one are correctly are the same as the creepypasta story part.
Great job Starly.
The Silence when fluttershy said "it was me"
Gave me the most goosebumps known to mankind
New guy: wow another infection AU. ME: I remember when the story came out years ago in the early days of the fandom
Not as scary as i was expecting but as someone who relates to flutter shy and has a bad coughing problem it did get to me a little bit, i feel really bad for all of them but i will say who ever lied should be ashamed of their self as they put everypony throw that and got flutter shy k*lled because she didn't want anyone else to be hurt.
THIS WAS SO GOOD STARLY! I hope you make more of these.
Wait wait-when flutter shy said she coughed I think when rarity said “flutter-shy!” I think she was trynna to talk to her…and when she was talking to twilight she was like “we’re not gonna actually..” I think she didn’t want flutter shy to die because of her?
Wow, that was a interesting and shocking video (as the same level it was from the original fic). Well done, #StarlyCookie, hope we can see more very soon. 👍🏽👍🏽
I was so focused watching this, it’s like a movie or it should be in the show. Amazing job!
WE NEED A PART 2 OF THIS. THIS IS AMAZING 😻😻😻
The duality of Twi yelling to end her suffering and Rarity begging her to stop is chilling
HER DEATH WAS TOO MUCH.
This mlp au is like the movie the thing a big group of survivors and finding whoever is infected good horror video.
Thank you for putting a long, verbal warning in the beginning of the video unlike Smile and Cupcakes 🙃
Honestly this is my opinion why fluttershy blamed herself: because she didn't want to deal with this shit and Want to go to a place where she can be happy😭😭😭
2:04 bro twighs "FUCK" sounded like rainbow😭
My fav horror MLP au in Tiktok is the Crystal curse but this is amazing too!
BTW IM 9 AND I STILL ENJOYED THIS.
Awesome job! Yeah, I'm sure everyone in the room would be horrified to find out too late that Fluttershy wasn't the one that coughed.
I’ve never seen MLP content before and well I have no idea what the story is even if this is fanfic, also I only clicked on this because it’s got the funniest horror title ever.
Chest infection.
POV: you're turning 13 next month, so u still watch it
I haven’t gotten into the video yet but props on that warning-
literally the best trend atm i love it definitely gonna hop onto this
5:13 this part is so sad😢
I LOVE THIS OH MY GOD!!!! EVERY SINGLE PART IS PERFECT! I LOVE THIS FANFIC, AND THIS WAS A REALLY COOL TURN
5:22 this part made me cry-
Nahh I'm all for MLP horror fandoms, Imagine having a cough and seeing this though like 💀
OUR COOKIE QUEEEN POSTED AGAIN OMG HI HI HI HI (NO FLUTTERSHY!!!!!!!!!😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭)
This is so good at first i saw it at tiktok its so well made
This was great! Just letting you know that the creepypasta link in the desc is potentially dangerous since people keep editing shady links into the wiki
5:33 My little rainbow dash is so scared 😢
1:17 chat, why can’t rarity illuminate the place when twilights horn went out😅
Perhaps her horn went out too?
I don’t really think that Rarity does magic as much as Twilight
I kid you not I was about to type the exact same thing when I saw this comment😭
I was not expecting the little honk at the end😂
4:59 wheres her wing tho-
They took pictures form the show to make them move and change expressions and stuff, that one must have been from before she had wings
It has to be rarity cuz she felt guilty when they were killing flutter shy knowing she was the one that cough
Skip to 0:28 if you don't wanna read the warnings
BTW, the creator recommends this for 13+
Thanks!!!!
3:54 Rainbow’s face got me rolling 💀
NOT FLUTTER SHY 3:59!
Covid 19 when you coughed back then 2:00
Everyone thinks its Rarity, but i think its Applejack since when she was checking on Apple Bloom u can hear her say “hey apple bloom?” AND COUGHED AFTER ASKING IF SHES ALRIGHT 0:53
OH MY-
I think that was a flashback and it was applebloom coughing
Yessss this is so much better than when i first listened to the cough years ago!
Two things:
1. Congrats on 20K subs
2. What happened to Spike and Pinkie Pie?
They probably got infected
Not me watching this while I have a cough
Wait- it wasn't Fluttershy 😭
Who was it then
Or maybe it spread to one of them, idk
The first MLP infection AU
3:53 RAINBOW DASHS FACE😢
.
Oh my goodness, i look for this for so many years, i remember to hear that story when i was 10 and forgot what was the name of this, so many traumatized memories come back now.