CPM 15V VS Maxamet&CPM REX121

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 7 янв 2025

Комментарии •

  • @robertbarker5802
    @robertbarker5802 День назад +12

    It's going to be tough getting a Seki City K390 from my pocket for anything else. It doesn't seem to chip, for it not being stainless it's not prone to rusting with only minimal upkeep, and it strops back with leather. It's not even a pain to sharpen and it keeps an edge long enough you don't need to do much but keep it clean. And being an ongoing production and not a sprint run I'm not worried about using it up and not being able to replace it. I'd be excited about 10V or 15V but being sprint only just sucks out the joy.

    • @ericasedc
      @ericasedc  День назад +2

      @@robertbarker5802 I totally feel that!

    • @MB-jg4tr
      @MB-jg4tr День назад +1

      I don't see 15v going away anytime soon. And the current "sprint run" isn't a true sprint limited to 1200-1400, they're making more of them than usual

    • @mrmouse-ol9pw
      @mrmouse-ol9pw День назад +2

      I agree. Seen the secondary prices of the manix 2 or shaman in 15v? Crazy. Would be prohibitive to replace as a user

    • @ericasedc
      @ericasedc  День назад

      @ at least I bet they’ll keep making it

    • @ericasedc
      @ericasedc  День назад +1

      @@MB-jg4trand they’ll keep making them. They are raking in so much bank on these. There’s no way they’re letting go of that😂

  • @ShawnL61189
    @ShawnL61189 День назад +5

    Been watching the channel for years. Keep it up Erica!

    • @ericasedc
      @ericasedc  День назад +1

      I appreciate you!!!🎉🎉🎉

  • @dw8143
    @dw8143 День назад +6

    Peak knife nerd. Loving every second. ❤

    • @ericasedc
      @ericasedc  День назад +1

      Yay!!! Glad you enjoy!

  • @Edcreviewer
    @Edcreviewer День назад +3

    I've never had rex121 micro chip on 400 super vitrified and so long as it wasn't maxamet from the first couple runs I've never had it micro chip on the stones neither. That goes for f100 and up resin diamond or CBN bonded stones as well. Now on diamond plates you can definitely get micro chipping on larger particle plates but I do not use my diamond or CBN plates for steels like rex121, maxamet, z max etc and that cuts down on the potential to micro chip at lower grits levels.
    Excellent video E, mine will be going up tonight!

    • @ericasedc
      @ericasedc  День назад

      Cheers mate!!🎉🎉🎉

  • @Knife_guy
    @Knife_guy День назад +3

    I can’t wait to see how 15V compares. Especially with the custom heat treat protocol.

    • @ericasedc
      @ericasedc  День назад

      Sooo exciting thanks to YOU!🎉🎉❤❤

  • @robthompson8285
    @robthompson8285 День назад +4

    I just got that 15V para 3 LW and I've never felt a toothier edge on a factory edge in my life. So many carbides.

    • @ericasedc
      @ericasedc  День назад

      It’s AWESOME🎉🎉

    • @robthompson8285
      @robthompson8285 День назад +2

      @ericasedc Yeah, I'm excited to see your final review of the steel. I know you won't hold nothin back.

    • @ericasedc
      @ericasedc  День назад +2

      @ you know me!

    • @jimmys249
      @jimmys249 День назад +2

      I don't know if it's the carbides or if they're just excited to make them awesome, but mine is the same!

    • @2Bstrifeless
      @2Bstrifeless День назад +1

      ​@@jimmys249I had a similar thought, maybe Sean is helping to improve QC on more than the heat treat. Whatever the reason I'll take it. I'm having fun putting it through increasingly demanding use.

  • @singingtoad
    @singingtoad День назад +2

    Thanks for giving us your take on these 3 steels, I always enjoy hearing your opinions on the knives you test. 👍 Happy (belated) New Year! 🥳🎉

    • @ericasedc
      @ericasedc  День назад +1

      Happy New Year ST!!!!

  • @timtitus2532
    @timtitus2532 День назад +2

    Looking forward to seeing more on this super steel. I've read a little bit on it, it'll be good to hear how it goes in real life use. Thanks Erica

    • @ericasedc
      @ericasedc  День назад +1

      @@timtitus2532 Hey Tim! Love ya!

  • @R.H.bladeNshade
    @R.H.bladeNshade День назад +2

    Love to come home to a new video from ya!!! I always learn something useful from your content and i really appreciate that. My Para 3 also came screaming sharp but most of my Spydercos have to be honest. Take care E you da best!!👊💥

    • @ericasedc
      @ericasedc  День назад

      @@R.H.bladeNshade you are the best!!!! I appreciate you brother!!!

  • @kathrynhorn8095
    @kathrynhorn8095 День назад +2

    Solid video:), excited to hear your results after testing the steel. Just wanted to mention that I am testing Rex 76 right now and lets just say that I have some opinions. Wish you a good day and take care.

    • @ericasedc
      @ericasedc  День назад

      @@kathrynhorn8095 I’m sooo excited to hear your thoughts!

  • @LiquidRetro
    @LiquidRetro День назад +2

    Perfect timing, currently trying to decide between two of these knives and steels.

    • @ericasedc
      @ericasedc  День назад

      @@LiquidRetro the video was made for you I guess!🥰🤣

  • @davidkurle5418
    @davidkurle5418 День назад +2

    You sound like you're feeling better👍This was great info! Cheers, E!

    • @ericasedc
      @ericasedc  День назад +1

      @@davidkurle5418 finally yes!!! Cheers brother!!!

  • @1977NOBODY
    @1977NOBODY День назад +3

    Glad I grabbed the 15v… Can’t wait to see how it goes for you this month when using it🙂👍🏻

  • @Wcquick
    @Wcquick День назад +1

    Fun Spyderco steel review, I appreciate your energy in dealing with blade sharpness and toughness.

    • @ericasedc
      @ericasedc  День назад +1

      @@Wcquick oh this isn’t the review! But I am glad you enjoyed the video!!

    • @Wcquick
      @Wcquick День назад +1

      @@ericasedc cool then, more to come

  • @CIGARURI
    @CIGARURI День назад +3

    You're so knowledgeable my FAVE❤ great show

    • @ericasedc
      @ericasedc  День назад +1

      I’m not - but trying to learn! FAVE!❤❤🎉🎉

  • @michaeljordan8757
    @michaeljordan8757 День назад +2

    I really appreciate your insights -- thanks for sharing your knowledge and experience.

    • @ericasedc
      @ericasedc  День назад

      @@michaeljordan8757 I appreciate you!

  • @LastChanceKnives
    @LastChanceKnives 8 часов назад +1

    This is going to be a very interesting comparison. I really like steels with a high amount of vanadium carbides. For example my favorite stainless for a folder is S90V. It holds a very aggressive toothy working edge forever and doesn't take edge damage as easily as other high edge retention stainless steels. I suspect 15V will come out on top because it will be close in edge retention to the others, but will have a higher toughness. I also expect it to take a little more time on the stones.

    • @ericasedc
      @ericasedc  2 часа назад

      @@LastChanceKnives it will be fun!

  • @tmille10
    @tmille10 День назад +4

    The 15v is much finer edge still retaining that hardness, I carry a maxamet manix 2 lw every day or k 390 stretch and 15v is much closer to k 390 in that regard in edge amd the grit to refine it. Excellent take on that ….👍

    • @ericasedc
      @ericasedc  День назад +1

      I totally agree!!!!🎉

  • @Stans_Cutlery_Universe
    @Stans_Cutlery_Universe День назад +2

    Good interesting and informative video. Thanks for sharing and have a great and blessed week.

    • @ericasedc
      @ericasedc  День назад

      Blessings as always Stan!!

  • @bboyshr6
    @bboyshr6 День назад +3

    Almost fell out of my chair cause I thought you were doing a table top on an unused para 3 15v 😂. Glad to see you are feeling better

    • @ericasedc
      @ericasedc  День назад +1

      @@bboyshr6 omg I would NEVER!!!!!!

  • @christopheverstappen3193
    @christopheverstappen3193 День назад +3

    cool can't wait. Want to know how it preforms.

  • @snowtiger44
    @snowtiger44 15 часов назад +1

    Thank you for your indepth review my birthday was oke with loving people take care my friend

    • @ericasedc
      @ericasedc  15 часов назад +1

      @@snowtiger44 take care pal!!!

    • @snowtiger44
      @snowtiger44 15 часов назад +1

      @ thank you 🙏🏻 pal

  • @KnivesAndPizza
    @KnivesAndPizza День назад +3

    Awesome video Erica. Have you had any experience with Elmax? Do you like it

    • @ericasedc
      @ericasedc  День назад

      I haven’t used it much!

  • @mrmouse-ol9pw
    @mrmouse-ol9pw День назад +2

    Wish u would have thrown k390 in also as u speak about k390 so highly. Is it true the lightweight model only runs 1 washer on 1 side? Isnt that your second 15v para? Is there a book or person i should look into for a brand new person to sharpening?
    Youre the best knife tuber😊

    • @ericasedc
      @ericasedc  День назад

      Yes it has one washer. I didn’t do K390 because it wasn’t relevant to the video. I have sharpening videos for beginners on my sharpening playlist. Thanks so much for watching. I appreciate you!

  • @Barney_Greenway
    @Barney_Greenway День назад +1

    Hi Erica, I have a Shaman in 15V around here, very interested in your results! It's my only Shaman, so I really can't say if I like it bc of the steel or the model. Have a great day! 🤗

    • @ericasedc
      @ericasedc  День назад +1

      Have a good one man!

  • @CaseySackett
    @CaseySackett День назад +1

    Excited to see how this one does!

  • @just9911
    @just9911 День назад +1

    I REALLY wish they had a 15v option for the Sage 5. I want to like the PM3, but the ergonomics just aren’t great for my XXL glove size hands. The AWT scales help a bit, but it still doesn’t reach the level of comfort as the Sage family of designs.

    • @ericasedc
      @ericasedc  День назад +1

      Let’s hope they run some for the Sage then!!🎉🎉

  • @MB-jg4tr
    @MB-jg4tr День назад +1

    Yerba Santa extract for your lungs, trust me. I used to wild harvest it and have a lot of experience using it as medicine. Its not widely known but is the best I've found for lung health. It will completely cure bronchitis in 1½ weeks, and quickly heal any other lung issues. Its inexpensive.

    • @ericasedc
      @ericasedc  День назад

      That’s awesome!

    • @ericasedc
      @ericasedc  День назад

      Thanks I’ll look into it!

  • @tmille10
    @tmille10 День назад +3

    You need to grab some Aluminum scales from the great Mr. Ripplinger for that Sage 💯 really ups the feel 👍

    • @ericasedc
      @ericasedc  День назад

      No way I love the orange!😂

    • @tmille10
      @tmille10 День назад +1

      @ I love FRN myself but you can get them in orange 🍊 😀

    • @ericasedc
      @ericasedc  День назад

      @ I’m keepin the OG scales hehe

    • @tmille10
      @tmille10 День назад +1

      @ no worries I feel you on that, I put a call out to Work Tuff to send you a Nomad bushcrafter so answer the e mail if it comes if not I’ll send one ☝️ of mine. I live outside in a swamp and Carolina creeks and it’s top notch for everyday work….

    • @ericasedc
      @ericasedc  День назад

      @ bahahaha I don’t think they’ll wanna work with me since I’m so honest 🤣🤣🤣

  • @geraldkoth654
    @geraldkoth654 День назад +3

    Try 13 degrees per side and finish with at least 1200 grit (mine is Venev so no idea what others are) Then strop with 1 micron and then .5 micron. Scary sharp. That edge has held up for a year and a half with my son using it. He beats it like a rented mule.

    • @ericasedc
      @ericasedc  День назад

      That sounds awesome!

    • @2Bstrifeless
      @2Bstrifeless День назад

      Sounds like a light saber. I'll have to try something similar.

  • @Edcreviewer
    @Edcreviewer День назад +2

    Literally made a video on these 3 steels this morning to upload tonight!

  • @johnmackey3164
    @johnmackey3164 День назад +1

    My 15v para3 was perfect until i took it apart. Now i have lock stick. Cant get rid of it. Perfect bevels and crazy sharp out of box.

    • @ericasedc
      @ericasedc  День назад

      That’s why I’m not taking it apart yet hahah😂

  • @mybrotherscout3661
    @mybrotherscout3661 День назад +3

    Thanks for the video. Take care.

    • @ericasedc
      @ericasedc  День назад

      Thank YOU for watching!🎉

  • @KennyFlagg
    @KennyFlagg День назад +1

    Really hoping to try out 15v - would pull the trigger on a native or even mule just to get my hands on it while money is tight. The real grail (since I am fangirling) will be to test those vitrified diamond stones Shaun has put out.

    • @ericasedc
      @ericasedc  День назад

      @@KennyFlagg bahaha ok that’s awesome 🤣🤣

  • @John..18
    @John..18 День назад +3

    Great video,, 👌,,
    So many super steels these days,, ,
    I really hope the availability, and cost of knives doesn't skyrocket, with the bankruptcy of Crucible,, 😱,, whatever happens with them, it's got to affect knife production in some way,, 🤔
    (We already pay much more for knives over here, than you guys,,
    😱🇬🇧,,,)

    • @ericasedc
      @ericasedc  День назад +1

      Yeah… we shall see!!!

  • @mikehouser7587
    @mikehouser7587 День назад +2

    Go use your shipt….. Priceless! Thanks!

    • @ericasedc
      @ericasedc  День назад

      @@mikehouser7587 thank YOU!!!

  • @silvia2408
    @silvia2408 День назад +2

    Great review ❤

    • @ericasedc
      @ericasedc  День назад

      @@silvia2408 not a review quite yet! Thanks so much for watching!!!

  • @SubUrbanNinja-EDC
    @SubUrbanNinja-EDC День назад +1

    I am convinced that Spyderco can make a knife out of tin and it would be sharp as a razor. Love me some Spyderco.

    • @ericasedc
      @ericasedc  День назад +1

      @@SubUrbanNinja-EDC haha true!!!

  • @davids2629
    @davids2629 День назад +2

    You should check out the spyderco mule teams!

    • @ericasedc
      @ericasedc  День назад

      NO. I have tried them. Not my jam 😂

    • @davids2629
      @davids2629 21 час назад

      @ curious why?

    • @ericasedc
      @ericasedc  21 час назад +1

      @@davids2629 way too large. And odd looking. Totally unnecessary for me.

  • @ADAMGILBRT82
    @ADAMGILBRT82 День назад +1

    Excited for this one 💪🏻

    • @ericasedc
      @ericasedc  День назад

      @@ADAMGILBRT82 that makes me happy to hear!

  • @barboki
    @barboki 15 часов назад +1

    Fun with steel fun with Spydercos!!!!

    • @ericasedc
      @ericasedc  15 часов назад

      @@barboki Spydies are always fun!

  • @andrewdavis146
    @andrewdavis146 День назад +1

    What degree angles are you using?

    • @ericasedc
      @ericasedc  День назад

      @@andrewdavis146 for what?

    • @TehEffinWabbajack
      @TehEffinWabbajack День назад

      ​@@ericasedc Your edges, presumably

    • @ericasedc
      @ericasedc  День назад

      @ I usually run 15DPS. Between 15-17

  • @michaelkennedy4444
    @michaelkennedy4444 День назад +1

    So cool , a gal that’s into exotic steel .

    • @ericasedc
      @ericasedc  День назад

      I love all steel but super steel thin and hard is totally my jam!

  • @darynschultz
    @darynschultz 50 минут назад

    Are you still an Emerson fan ?

    • @ericasedc
      @ericasedc  44 минуты назад +1

      @@darynschultz yep!

  • @floydmorrison2025
    @floydmorrison2025 День назад +1

    The Hot Moms don't stop calling just because you're filming a video, E!! 🤣 That knife looks sick!! I love how you prioritize the steel and it's performance over such trivialities as lock stick or centering etc (good centering here I realize)!! I'd never even heard of molybdenum or niobium before! I just tried to pronounce "molybdenum" out loud and sounded like Stephen Hawking on an Epstein Island vodka & midget bender 😆. Your steel knowledge is mind boggling! You should be teaching this stuff at a university, Dr. Slater!!! I look forward to learning more about molybennmadmsskdduumm in the future from these educational videos of yours!!! Also: that olive Seager hoodie looks amazing on you!! OD Green should be renamed ES Green cause it's SO your color!! I absolutely LOVE the Mallard Ducks logo!! 🦆🦆🦆 Stoked to see how the rest of the 15v testing goes!!! Great video, Erica!!! 🧡🧡🧡

    • @ericasedc
      @ericasedc  День назад

      OMG THE STEPHEN HAWKING JOKES ARE BACK! I missed those! And I love you Jesse!

  • @WhatsthePOINT_EDC
    @WhatsthePOINT_EDC 20 часов назад +1

    No fan girling here. Lol.👊🤣🤘

    • @ericasedc
      @ericasedc  20 часов назад +1

      @@WhatsthePOINT_EDC NOT ALLOWED! 🤣🤣🤣

  • @737driver8
    @737driver8 22 часа назад

    Who has good sharpening videos/guidance for these? coming up to 3 years my maxamet PM2 is slowing down. My 15V is still good and the rex 121 is fresh.

    • @dualsportoutdoors
      @dualsportoutdoors 17 часов назад

      If Erica doesn't have videos of sharpening these steels, Neeves Knives probably does

    • @ericasedc
      @ericasedc  17 часов назад +1

      @@dualsportoutdoorsI have sharpening discussion videos on them but not literal sharpening videos. I need to make some!

  • @tylerrohn6938
    @tylerrohn6938 10 часов назад

    Use that 15v hard, see need to know!

    • @ericasedc
      @ericasedc  2 часа назад

      @@tylerrohn6938 I will!!!!

  • @aaronfisher9776
    @aaronfisher9776 День назад

    You didn't mention the cobalt in rex 121

    • @ericasedc
      @ericasedc  День назад

      @@aaronfisher9776 because we weren’t talking about Cobalt. Thanks for watching!

  • @TheArtistGR
    @TheArtistGR День назад +2

    I've the maxamet

    • @ericasedc
      @ericasedc  День назад +1

      It’s great!🎉🎉

  • @aaronfisher9776
    @aaronfisher9776 День назад +1

    Have data sheets ready before your videos

    • @ericasedc
      @ericasedc  День назад +1

      For what? The only thing I couldn’t remember for probably 3 seconds, was Maxamet’s 6% Vanadium content. Find something better to do than picking people apart for no reason. Thanks for watching!

  • @Itrieditathome889
    @Itrieditathome889 День назад +1

    I love Maxamet and 15v (I actually own 3 Maxamet knives), and I have to say Rex 121 is the only steel that I truly hate sharpening.

    • @ericasedc
      @ericasedc  День назад

      @@Itrieditathome889 wow really?! Why?!