One Piece is just so grand and you will really appreciate how Oda still manage to create interesting characters and still able to do something about it unlike Bleach. The protagonists and antagonists are all so good. The world building is true though, it kind of became repetitive....with HxH though. Man that's just different. So good and so damn unpredictable.
@@laquilanda4751 there are good arcs in op like prison escape, marineford, skypia and dressrosa was also pretty good, also the comedy is first 200 chapters was top notch. hxh is great but if we compare length and the fact that hxh is incomplete, then for me one piece is better. If hxh completes the manga with 150 more chapters then hxh definitely will be greatest shonen ever.
The feeling that every arc is the same by the straw hats only going around and saving kingdoms is caused by not understanding the plot correctly. In Alabasta, it was the main plot of saving the kingdom. The point of Law's and Luffy's alliance was to overthrow Kaido. They went to Dressrosa with the goal to stop doflamingo and his smile fruit production (he only claimed that he was the true leader of Dressrosa so dethroning him was just a side accomplishment). And the same in Wano. Kaido only used Wano as his base of operations, using the people there for labor, so it only felt like that the straw hats saved wano by killing Kaido.
Ultimately, almost every major arc still has the same repetitive outline. While the environments and characters of course change, the archetypes don't and it just becomes a cycle of flavorless plot points. Nearly every major storyline can be summed up as; 1. Strawhats visit a new island 2. They meet the princess of the island who warns them about the island's evil ruler 3. Sad backstory 4. Strawhats break island's taboo 5. Luffy fights the big bad guy while his crewmates go after the other minor threats (Zoro vs. whoever's second in command, Nami vs. the resident female villian, etc.)
@@russianbot570 If you over-simplify every anime you get the same result. Romance anime is basically boy meets girl and they fall in love, shonen anime is basically MC travels and solves problems.
@@zxcvb3772 One Piece's stagnant format is still a problem, and, while I did oversimplify it, these arcs still lack lots of nuance and instead choose to recycle the same 1-dimensional plot lines and characters. Your examples lack weight as you're referring to entire stories that follow these archetypes, not just singular arcs. It would be fine if Oda only used them once or twice, but instead he relies on the aforementioned outline for at least half the total story.
@@russianbot570 It is not so much a "stagnant format" and more so a "framework" that works. Why do you think shonen MC most of the time start out as an underdog? Because it's a concept that works. The arcs do not lack any nuances and definitely do not have 1 dimensional plot lines and characters. People these days throw around buzz words like that without understanding what they mean smh.
@@zxcvb3772 What I meant with my comment on the plots and characters being boring/the same is that they rarely do anything out of the ordinary or unexpected for a character in their role. We see next to no development among either protagonists or antagonists (Usopp is still just as cowardly as he was in Arlong Park and every major villain is evil just for the sake of it). When's the last time a character posed an actual moral dilemma or had quasi-decent motives for doing bad things? The characters remain static, always having unchanging and unwavering motivations As for the story arcs' lack of depth, at the end of the day, the good guys win and, at worst, maybe lose a filler character introduced in that arc. I also want to state that I wouldn't consider One Piece a bad series by any means, I just feel like it has some pretty noticeable flaws that fans refuse to address
What a great video you should get way kore views. This video is so well edited and well made. Personally i love hxh its my favourite. But i am watching one piece currently and yet is still think hxh is better.
I think the problem is that the anime just drags the story through the mud. It gets the general idea across but if it was paced appropriately it would be 100x better / tolerable. I feel like the new anime remake will really help people see how in reality/ in the manga, the story doesnt drag or you only interact with certain side characters an appropriate amount of time.
I feel like it’s a bit disingenuous to say one piece is representative in arcs when only Arong park, alabasta, skypia, fishman, dressosa, wano. That’s really it. Everything else has rich and interesting background and everything ends up connecting with each other one way or another. I’m not here to convince u one piece is better I just felt like one piece does a great job at connecting arcs together to paint the overall picture
I encourage everyone to think about their own Nen-Ability: But the question is if you can cheat the System (to a reasonable extend :) Wouldnt even want anything more) so i ask your thoughts on this: What about a catalyst-ability whose sole purpose it to be Useless and even HIGHLY Restrictive and then multiple more Abilities that all have the teeny tiny Restriction 'Can only be used while the useless Ability is active'. I can think of countles ways how this will not work but a few where it would actually work: You just gotta have 3+ Ability-Slots but more importantly have Restrictions that 'act on you' as long as its activated or even outright all-the-time. Kurapika, i think, gave me the idea cause i wondered if Emperors Time extreme Cost only helps Emperor Time or them all - and f this is exploitabe! So what i say is throwing Money into a Campfire can be of Benefit for more Abilities than actually have the Activation-Requirement 'Burn Money' IF you pull it off
All was good, but story to one piece in my opinion. You missed out a lot of arcs which dont liberate a country or which are not about saving countries and defeating final villains eg-Loguetown, Reverse Mountain, Whiskey Peak, Little Garden, Drum Island(wapol was not that serious of a problem but drum island focuses more on the past of chopper and stuff), Jaya, Long Ring Long Land, Water 7, Enies Lobby, Sabaody, Amazon Lily, Impell Down, Marineford, Post war arc, Return to sabaody, Zou, Whole Cake Island, and currently egghead. Someone would be crazy to think that all arcs are luffy becoming stronger to defeat final villain and liberate countries.
One piece's formulaic strutcure is a lot less noticeable than people make it out to be. It only really appears in 6 arcs, and each time their is a lot of nuance in how it's done
Guys listen! One piece is an amazing anime but I would be surprised if an anime with 1000+ episode is a bad anime. Now Naruto and Jjk took inspiration from Hunter X Hunter but not many knows about it because of popularity. Hunter X Hunter got only 146 episodes and it's not even close to finish, that alone tells you the insane potential HxH has. Now why people may not like the anime? Because it's more for mature audience. The power system is the best and characters are insanely well written. So good that many doesn't understand how Complex some characters actually are and ends up disliking. I am not saying Op is childish but I think today's audience mostly prefers insane Animations fightings and huge boobies, add these 2 and an anime gets insanely popular. Op got those 2 plus insane characters and everything. If it wasn't for hiatus HxH would have been beside Op or greater
Ok the amount of respect this guy gave to Hunter X Hunter is just Insane!! Thank you!. You deserve my sub. HxH may not better than op, but just in 146 episodes its a masterpiece, now imagine HxH at it's full potential. HxH hiatus is a canon event lol, it would been at the top
@@ausheshCan't handle the truth? Naruto took some inspiration from Hunter X Hunter. Hunter x hunter never got the recognition it deserved. If it wasn't for hiatus it would have been beside One piece or greater
@JellyNightSquid69 That and also Togashi was already a highly respected mangaka where rookies looked up to him in fact there's a letter that Oda wrote to Togashi where he used the honorific "sensei" Oda himself said "Togashi sensei" and on the same letter he said he is grateful since Togashi sensei judged his work for rookie of the year. That in itself is insane Togashi is legendary, HxH without hiatuses would definitely be without a doubt very well known and liked across the globe and would outshine everything else like you said, this actually crazy to think about it.
you know I cut it up like that to remove the breaths but I'm not really sure If I should leave in more gaps when listening to it back it sounds weird with the gaps but I may be overthinkin it
@premtelangi657 what makes one piece good other than the characters, devil fruits and haki? I've seen 500 episodes and stop watching cause it's not good
@premtelangi657 too be honest one piece is alright but if you actually think it's better than Hunter x Hunter when it comes to writing then you're either mentally disabled or biased
Hunter X Hunter is above One Piece in quality for sure, it's genuinely not fair you need stuff like Full Metal and JoJo to pin against Hunter...but OP has crazy longevity so gotta respect when it's due
@@wesker6908what does HxH have over OnePiece? All the power ups in HXH are ass pulls like Gon and Killua learnt nen so fast. Luffy is far better than Gon, Zoro is better than Killua. The only real character developments happen for Killua, Gon, and Kurapika.
@@AlexiRoussos nah One Piece just feels repetitive, and the characters mainly just get stronger. The nen system is so much better in HxH where the battles feel like wits instead of strength like in OP. Also besides Doffy, the villains aren't all that interesting in OP.
@@someonesomething1657 the fights in OnePiece are 10x more emotional. Even when Kurapika fights against Phantom troupe members he doesn’t act like a scarred individual it’s weird. And I don’t think hxh villains are interesting either. Hisoka is a psychopath and has no motives, chrollo has absolutely 0 end goal in mind as he just does the stuff he does for the thrill. The only well written villain in hxh is meruem.
In the intro I literally call it one of the 2 greatest Shonen of all time, so if putting it in greatest of all time category is shitting on it ig your right. Also the JJK vs One Piece video is just comparing the 2 in 2023, and I was a One Piece exclusive channel the first 6 months of this channels life and literally made over 100 videos on one piece.
@@itskish204hypocrite In your jjk vs one piece video jjk was winner Aot vs one piece video Aot was winner Jjk vs Naruto video Naruto was winner That is clearly 4 shonen you said better than one piece.Now you saying one piece is top 2💀.where is logic in this.
Greed Island no you're not cooking that's the whole point of gon learning his power his nen ability it's more dragon quest the hunter exam ark is the bottom tier because plus this is a game made for gon from his dad is it interesting storytelling throughout until Chimera ant Arc
Greed Island is top three I don't know what you're missing I don't like fantasies boys getting a lot of girls type anime but this is not it you are something's wrong with you Greed Island is great 👍
How can I Improve My Content? Did you Enjoy the video? JJK vs Naruto is next!
you can add timestamps bro
Dragon Ball vs One Piece.
I like both and it’s close but I like hxh more
quality vs. quantity
true
So you’re saying OnePiece doesn’t have quality? Please 😂 the world, plot, story, and characters are all better than hunter hunter
One Piece is just so grand and you will really appreciate how Oda still manage to create interesting characters and still able to do something about it unlike Bleach. The protagonists and antagonists are all so good. The world building is true though, it kind of became repetitive....with HxH though. Man that's just different. So good and so damn unpredictable.
Don’t forget that bungee gum has the properties of rubber and gum ⭐️🥴💧
Hahahahahhahaha still hxh better
Hunter hunter far better
Hunter hunter still the best i finish watching one piece 1100 and ill say some of arcs are good but not close as hunter hunter
@@laquilanda4751 which arc?
@@OPGOAT1500 like the water 7 idk who the hell write that arc but its definitely good
@@laquilanda4751 there are good arcs in op like prison escape, marineford, skypia and dressrosa was also pretty good, also the comedy is first 200 chapters was top notch. hxh is great but if we compare length and the fact that hxh is incomplete, then for me one piece is better. If hxh completes the manga with 150 more chapters then hxh definitely will be greatest shonen ever.
@@laquilanda4751 how have you caught up with one piece and not know who the creator is?
The feeling that every arc is the same by the straw hats only going around and saving kingdoms is caused by not understanding the plot correctly. In Alabasta, it was the main plot of saving the kingdom. The point of Law's and Luffy's alliance was to overthrow Kaido. They went to Dressrosa with the goal to stop doflamingo and his smile fruit production (he only claimed that he was the true leader of Dressrosa so dethroning him was just a side accomplishment). And the same in Wano. Kaido only used Wano as his base of operations, using the people there for labor, so it only felt like that the straw hats saved wano by killing Kaido.
Ultimately, almost every major arc still has the same repetitive outline. While the environments and characters of course change, the archetypes don't and it just becomes a cycle of flavorless plot points. Nearly every major storyline can be summed up as;
1. Strawhats visit a new island
2. They meet the princess of the island who warns them about the island's evil ruler
3. Sad backstory
4. Strawhats break island's taboo
5. Luffy fights the big bad guy while his crewmates go after the other minor threats (Zoro vs. whoever's second in command, Nami vs. the resident female villian, etc.)
@@russianbot570 If you over-simplify every anime you get the same result. Romance anime is basically boy meets girl and they fall in love, shonen anime is basically MC travels and solves problems.
@@zxcvb3772 One Piece's stagnant format is still a problem, and, while I did oversimplify it, these arcs still lack lots of nuance and instead choose to recycle the same 1-dimensional plot lines and characters.
Your examples lack weight as you're referring to entire stories that follow these archetypes, not just singular arcs. It would be fine if Oda only used them once or twice, but instead he relies on the aforementioned outline for at least half the total story.
@@russianbot570 It is not so much a "stagnant format" and more so a "framework" that works. Why do you think shonen MC most of the time start out as an underdog? Because it's a concept that works. The arcs do not lack any nuances and definitely do not have 1 dimensional plot lines and characters. People these days throw around buzz words like that without understanding what they mean smh.
@@zxcvb3772 What I meant with my comment on the plots and characters being boring/the same is that they rarely do anything out of the ordinary or unexpected for a character in their role. We see next to no development among either protagonists or antagonists (Usopp is still just as cowardly as he was in Arlong Park and every major villain is evil just for the sake of it). When's the last time a character posed an actual moral dilemma or had quasi-decent motives for doing bad things? The characters remain static, always having unchanging and unwavering motivations
As for the story arcs' lack of depth, at the end of the day, the good guys win and, at worst, maybe lose a filler character introduced in that arc.
I also want to state that I wouldn't consider One Piece a bad series by any means, I just feel like it has some pretty noticeable flaws that fans refuse to address
This is a pretty good take. I like the analysis
Nice video man! keep it up
Thank you I really appreciate it!
What a great video you should get way kore views. This video is so well edited and well made.
Personally i love hxh its my favourite.
But i am watching one piece currently and yet is still think hxh is better.
Love how you absolutely glazed every minute detail of both animes while stating facts
I think the problem is that the anime just drags the story through the mud. It gets the general idea across but if it was paced appropriately it would be 100x better / tolerable. I feel like the new anime remake will really help people see how in reality/ in the manga, the story doesnt drag or you only interact with certain side characters an appropriate amount of time.
Netero didn’t fail lmao
It’s like saying the Marines lost against Whitebeard Pirates in Marineford War
I feel like it’s a bit disingenuous
to say one piece is representative in arcs when only Arong park, alabasta, skypia, fishman, dressosa, wano. That’s really it. Everything else has rich and interesting background and everything ends up connecting with each other one way or another. I’m not here to convince u one piece is better I just felt like one piece does a great job at connecting arcs together to paint the overall picture
That makes it a good world building and overall storytelling. Arc quality is a different thing altogether
I never liked one piece. Art style with oversized mouth makes me think its animated muppets. HxH is among my top favorites with FMAB and Frieren
Now instead of animation let's talk about manga style...
I like you comparison man. The deep you go. You are so underrated
thank you!
lol netero didn’t fail
I encourage everyone to think about their own
Nen-Ability:
But the question is if you can cheat the System (to a reasonable extend :) Wouldnt even want anything more) so i ask your thoughts on this: What about a catalyst-ability whose sole purpose it to be Useless and even HIGHLY Restrictive and then multiple more Abilities that all have the teeny tiny Restriction 'Can only be used while the useless Ability is active'. I can think of countles ways how this will not work but a few where it would actually work: You just gotta have 3+ Ability-Slots but more importantly have Restrictions that 'act on you' as long as its activated or even outright all-the-time. Kurapika, i think, gave me the idea cause i wondered if Emperors Time extreme Cost only helps Emperor Time or them all - and f this is exploitabe!
So what i say is throwing Money into a Campfire can be of Benefit for more Abilities
than actually have the Activation-Requirement 'Burn Money' IF you pull it off
Heavens arena was too fast paced for me. There wasnt enough payoff when Gon landed his hit against Hisoka
Peak x peak
How is your channel not blowing up Your content is the best!
Thanks! This means a lot!
He is actually hypocrite.
All was good, but story to one piece in my opinion. You missed out a lot of arcs which dont liberate a country or which are not about saving countries and defeating final villains eg-Loguetown, Reverse Mountain, Whiskey Peak, Little Garden, Drum Island(wapol was not that serious of a problem but drum island focuses more on the past of chopper and stuff), Jaya, Long Ring Long Land, Water 7, Enies Lobby, Sabaody, Amazon Lily, Impell Down, Marineford, Post war arc, Return to sabaody, Zou, Whole Cake Island, and currently egghead. Someone would be crazy to think that all arcs are luffy becoming stronger to defeat final villain and liberate countries.
To be fair as far as demon slayer goes, Kokoshibou is well written character. That you can’t take away from Demon Slayer.
One piece's formulaic strutcure is a lot less noticeable than people make it out to be. It only really appears in 6 arcs, and each time their is a lot of nuance in how it's done
HxH is Legendary !! This is the best anime indeed.. the story the power system are on top tier above all
HxH hands down
Guys listen! One piece is an amazing anime but I would be surprised if an anime with 1000+ episode is a bad anime. Now Naruto and Jjk took inspiration from Hunter X Hunter but not many knows about it because of popularity.
Hunter X Hunter got only 146 episodes and it's not even close to finish, that alone tells you the insane potential HxH has. Now why people may not like the anime? Because it's more for mature audience. The power system is the best and characters are insanely well written. So good that many doesn't understand how Complex some characters actually are and ends up disliking. I am not saying Op is childish but I think today's audience mostly prefers insane Animations fightings and huge boobies, add these 2 and an anime gets insanely popular. Op got those 2 plus insane characters and everything. If it wasn't for hiatus HxH would have been beside Op or greater
My dude likes peak
Hunting for your dream!
Naruto vs AOT please
How does this make any sense, those two are not compareable, if you wann compare Naruto with something, compare it to another battle shounen
Ok the amount of respect this guy gave to Hunter X Hunter is just Insane!! Thank you!. You deserve my sub. HxH may not better than op, but just in 146 episodes its a masterpiece, now imagine HxH at it's full potential. HxH hiatus is a canon event lol, it would been at the top
@JellyNightSquid94 Nope
@@ausheshCan't handle the truth? Naruto took some inspiration from Hunter X Hunter. Hunter x hunter never got the recognition it deserved. If it wasn't for hiatus it would have been beside One piece or greater
@@anishchoudhury8537 Delulu
@JellyNightSquid69 That and also Togashi was already a highly respected mangaka where rookies looked up to him in fact there's a letter that Oda wrote to Togashi where he used the honorific "sensei" Oda himself said "Togashi sensei" and on the same letter he said he is grateful since Togashi sensei judged his work for rookie of the year.
That in itself is insane Togashi is legendary, HxH without hiatuses would definitely be without a doubt very well known and liked across the globe and would outshine everything else like you said, this actually crazy to think about it.
I really hope the remake fixes the pacing issue that even One Piece Fans hate and then we can really see how One Piece is better overall.
hxh is the best manga i've ever read, the manga feels like a totally different story than the anime
Why he talk like doesn’t stop to breathe
you know I cut it up like that to remove the breaths but I'm not really sure If I should leave in more gaps when listening to it back it sounds weird with the gaps but I may be overthinkin it
@@itskish204 you is ovathinking it tho it sounds unnatural
Hunter> one piss
Bro's neck shape changed
One piece. Hxh is good but it's not in one piece level
Naah, HxH is goated and way better than one piece
@@wesker6908if you say hunter hunter is “way better” than one piece you’re genuinely insane
Its not even close Hunter X Hunter is better than one piece 😂
Pov: you never seen one piece.
Lmao no🎉
@premtelangi657 Pov you're the average annoying one piece fan who thinks it's the only anime
@premtelangi657 what makes one piece good other than the characters, devil fruits and haki? I've seen 500 episodes and stop watching cause it's not good
@premtelangi657 too be honest one piece is alright but if you actually think it's better than Hunter x Hunter when it comes to writing then you're either mentally disabled or biased
There is very few boring chapter or fight in hxh unlike one piece and characters intract like real people and they develop
Hunter X Hunter is above One Piece in quality for sure, it's genuinely not fair you need stuff like Full Metal and JoJo to pin against Hunter...but OP has crazy longevity so gotta respect when it's due
its not, op is better than all the manga u mentioned
@@xandex69yea
@@xandex69It's not even close to Jjba part 7💀
HxH
Yu yu hakusho better than these two
Two goats of shonen. But one piece is the best.
real
HxH is way better…
It's not even close one piece is so much greater. Don't even try to compare HXH to one piece
In what category does one piece beat HxH in?
HxH is so much better in every way. One piece is paced like shit and has shit animation
@@wesker6908 Bringing in the animation quality is a pretty frail point considering what a lot of Togashi's art looks like for HxH
@@wesker6908what does HxH have over OnePiece? All the power ups in HXH are ass pulls like Gon and Killua learnt nen so fast. Luffy is far better than Gon, Zoro is better than Killua. The only real character developments happen for Killua, Gon, and Kurapika.
@@AlexiRoussos nah One Piece just feels repetitive, and the characters mainly just get stronger. The nen system is so much better in HxH where the battles feel like wits instead of strength like in OP. Also besides Doffy, the villains aren't all that interesting in OP.
@@someonesomething1657 the fights in OnePiece are 10x more emotional. Even when Kurapika fights against Phantom troupe members he doesn’t act like a scarred individual it’s weird. And I don’t think hxh villains are interesting either. Hisoka is a psychopath and has no motives, chrollo has absolutely 0 end goal in mind as he just does the stuff he does for the thrill. The only well written villain in hxh is meruem.
FullMetal Alchemist exist
Thank you. Was looking for this comment.
Jeez is it really that good a 64 episode anime can compete with 1000+? Ofc it can be good but still wow
HxH solos
Let's be real one piece claps jjk hxh and ds
Imma need u to stop acting like u love one piece cause u shit on it everytime u talk about it
In the intro I literally call it one of the 2 greatest Shonen of all time, so if putting it in greatest of all time category is shitting on it ig your right. Also the JJK vs One Piece video is just comparing the 2 in 2023, and I was a One Piece exclusive channel the first 6 months of this channels life and literally made over 100 videos on one piece.
@@itskish204hypocrite
In your jjk vs one piece video jjk was winner
Aot vs one piece video Aot was winner
Jjk vs Naruto video Naruto was winner
That is clearly 4 shonen you said better than one piece.Now you saying one piece is top 2💀.where is logic in this.
@JellyNightSquid94he is so hypocrite . One piece never win against any shonen series even jjk. Now he is saying op is top 2.he obviously lying .
I just can’t enjoy hxh as much knowing I likely won’t get a satisfying conclusion.
Chimera ant
York New City
Greed Island
Hunter's exam
Season 6 besides Ging explaining the dark Continent
Greed Island no you're not cooking that's the whole point of gon learning his power his nen ability it's more dragon quest the hunter exam ark is the bottom tier because plus this is a game made for gon from his dad is it interesting storytelling throughout until Chimera ant Arc
Greed Island is top three I don't know what you're missing I don't like fantasies boys getting a lot of girls type anime but this is not it you are something's wrong with you Greed Island is great 👍