The drummer is fantastic. He appropriately hung back a bit in this "unplugged" type performance, which just shows his versatility. But he can let it rip when he wants to.
@@brianharlan51That’s what’s so good about Garbage. They’re a “super group” of sorts made up by three guys who were established in the recording industry but not artists themselves, just accomplished studio musicians, writers and producers. They wanted to record with a bunch of singers and produce one great album but then found Shirley and said hell with it she’s better than all that. Garbage was born.
![Garbage "Special" and "Keep Breathing" acoustic [Nulle Part Ailleurs, January 1999]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/FKAUQCQhkbc/mqdefault.jpg)
![Garbage "Special" and "Keep Breathing" acoustic [Nulle Part Ailleurs, January 1999]](/img/tr.png)
That “do you have an opinnnnnnion?” is vocal perfection.
Agreed!
@@ChadSantos1138 i miss this type of live performance.
one of my crush in the 90's🥹❤️
She is stunningly beautiful!
My favorite Garbage song!
Yes and yes!
And the video... Omg
Right on both!
Watched this 15 times in a row...just can't get enough!
Wonderful bass playing
Just WOW… Shirley owns this performance. First heard this song on business trip in the Netherlands back in the 90’s and was gobsmacked!
Yes! Great piece of music here! And just a stunning beauty she is! 👍 I still get my heart melted when I hear this!
This is perfect. The vocals, the drums, the bass, the electro-acoustic guitars, the beat. Everything
My absolute favorite Garbage song. They sound awsome
Excellent. Just excellent. Her voice just rips everything in me!! ❤
Damn I just fell in love with her all over again 🫠 glad this was in HD👍🏽
If you looked up “stage presence” in the dictionary there could be a picture of Shirley Manson.
or Freddy, or Madonna, or Prince, or Client Liaison, or Fish or Michael Jackson or Billy Bragg or Earth Wind and Fire or the Village People...
Toni Halliday walked so Shirley could run.
@@charabotte1
Prince and Freddie and Bowie all 1st equal imo.
Is a queen
Yessir
Damn, she sounds Heavenly.
So good is this band
Damn! That bass player has been around with the band since the beginning 😮 amazing bass player here
Always loved this particular video! What a sexy voice!!! She has that charisma! Smoldering venerability in her voice!
Thanks for uploading this is my favorite live performance ever.
My pleasure to share this one. Thank you for being appreciative.
It gives me goosebumps. She represents feminine strength during adolescence.
everything is so beautiful
my favourite song of them
Amazing performance, thanks for posting!
God they are awesome 😎.
Shirley Manson absolutely commands the stage.
The drummer is fantastic. He appropriately hung back a bit in this "unplugged" type performance, which just shows his versatility. But he can let it rip when he wants to.
Butch vig; he’s a producer
Produced nirvana never mind
@@brianharlan51That’s what’s so good about Garbage. They’re a “super group” of sorts made up by three guys who were established in the recording industry but not artists themselves, just accomplished studio musicians, writers and producers. They wanted to record with a bunch of singers and produce one great album but then found Shirley and said hell with it she’s better than all that. Garbage was born.
This is a really good version. Thanks!!
Brilliant performance, thanks for the upload💜🍀
That bass
Found the fisherman!
Magnifique! In love with these amazing artists. Superlative version. 🫢🫡
It sounds like their tribute to the Pretenders ! Wonderful song !
Or to R.E.M.! 🙌🏻
How was this 25 years ago? Time flies
Love the bass here
she has an interesting voice
Wow that was amazing!
beautiful girl, great bass line🤘🏼
2:52 the lyrics changed 👋 textured sounds amazing 💗
Their best song. No bs about it. Heavily Pretenders influenced
i love you Shirley, with all my fucking hearth i love you, the best
Preciosa 💖✨
Oh Shirley we adore you.
Really great voice and song! I'd love to hear MELODY CRISTEA of LILIAC cover this !!!!
Linda canción! Like!
awesome ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Defines the meaning of a classic
This is one of those times that a pre-recorded vocal track would be welcome.
Her background vocals during the middle 8 make this song. Oh well.
Here with Liz in Clearwater Beach, 2024!
Timeless
song written for homeboy in South Austin boy he was a hell of a week
Cool song
Wow.....
Great Pretenders
Como se llama el bajista?
Anyone got a time machine I can borrow...:(
Man, isn't that the truth...
27 here, and I've just discovered Garbage. I wish I'd been into them sooner.
What year?
Hi Greg. Not sure of the year exactly (it's been a long time now) but somewhere between 1997-1999.
@@pascalburger7379 1999, cause in 98, she had her hair different
@@EysenbeissThank you! I will update this in the title. Thank you for contributing.
It’s a bit far from an acoustic performance, but who fucking cares . Just listen to her.
Lily Allen
?