she is good friends with Belle they have been friends for a long time maybe Ning is friends with Natty too. not sure about Natty but I am sure Belle is friends with Ning
after I saw an insta post about Belle doing vlog and she said that Ningning bought her a cute heart shaped mirror... I know they are good friends.. and Belle said ot was two years ago, so they wete really good friends even before.... She even said Ningning unnie😂 fryi Belle is 2004 while Ning is 2002.... Ning is an unnie now❤
@@PriscilliaSihombingNot too sure, I saw a video on POPKORN’s channel of Niel, member of gen2’s group, Teen Top talking to Hanbin, member of “gen5’s group”, The Wind.
@@PriscilliaSihombing Edit: Because others couldn't understand what I trying to say. This is my opinion on what I think it feels like the generations are... Not the actual span of a generation. Now the comment is below '2012-18 3rd gen and I'd also consider 4th gen to be from 19-25 tbh'
@@PriscilliaSihombingno, kiof is considered 5th gen. 4th gen started in 2017 with the boyz until 2022. Kiof started 5th gen with zb1 in mid 2023. I know its hard to believe kiof being 5th gen but they actually are
@@pookjiyoon If I remember correctly, I watched an ep of Jaefriends with Natty & Belle and they were explaining they were called Y2K group or something. Me personally, they do remind me of 2nd Gen Kpop just like what op commented.
Unpopular opinion but kpop actually needs this type of sexy concept. The one where they all look like actual adults and not in a cute child like aesthetic. Kpop needs to separate cute from sexy because cuteness and innocence are for children and should’t in any way be tied to sexy and seductive. The concept of aegyo is actually horrifying.
I talked about that on Twitter, its so creepy of see adult acting like Child for pedo guys,I love twice song but when you see their age its creepy and the fact sexy concept with hight school outfit need to stop too
@@hyungking-namjinsope0t469 same here im very biased when it comes to twice but they all need to start acting like their age. Their eldest is closer to 30 than 20, the aegyo has to stop at least on camera. They can keep doing that in their personal lives if that’s their personality but it has to be stopped on mainstream media, it’s just creepy and inappropriate.
KIOF is like a senior that debut in the junior era and they deserve a bigger stage for their huge talent
Only Natty is the actual senior btw
@@ontheclouds3234Natty never made her official debut did she?
she solo before
ahh ty@@WidhyandariHardadiE
They got same sunbaenim comeback vibes just like mamamoo on their debut. They'll do great in the future ;)
ningselle went home and practiced that dance that night
LMFAO i know thats right
LMAOOOO
Dead 😂
Nobody knows
😭😭😭💀
Ningning said " I know that's fucking right"
Who is that
@@BonBon069main vocalist and maknae of Aespa
I'm the 9.4k like lol
😂😂😂😂 love this
@@mysopeworldI thought winter was the main vocalist and Giselle maknae 😅
Ningning looks so proud of them
she is good friends with Belle they have been friends for a long time maybe Ning is friends with Natty too. not sure about Natty but I am sure Belle is friends with Ning
Thankfully its appropriate for their ages.. 👌😍
@@kali_jls ages? 😂😂
ningning was giggling
Help that rhymes
ningselle was ENJOYING it fr
ningning is good friends with kiof esp belle
Giselle and NingNing seem to quite enjoy it lol
after I saw an insta post about Belle doing vlog and she said that Ningning bought her a cute heart shaped mirror... I know they are good friends.. and Belle said ot was two years ago, so they wete really good friends even before.... She even said Ningning unnie😂 fryi Belle is 2004 while Ning is 2002.... Ning is an unnie now❤
I forget that Belle was a producer and worked in SM haha
yup and she even followed ningning’s soundcloud too
STOPPP BOTH ARE MY BIASES IM LEVITATING RN
this friendship is so sweet ❤❤❤❤
The fact that there’s a “gen5” girgroup that are all older than half the groups in Gen4 shocks me 😭
It still gen 4
@@PriscilliaSihombingNot too sure, I saw a video on POPKORN’s channel of Niel, member of gen2’s group, Teen Top talking to Hanbin, member of “gen5’s group”, The Wind.
Ikr. kpop industry is just weird sometimes
@@PriscilliaSihombing Edit: Because others couldn't understand what I trying to say. This is my opinion on what I think it feels like the generations are... Not the actual span of a generation. Now the comment is below
'2012-18 3rd gen and I'd also consider 4th gen to be from 19-25 tbh'
@@PriscilliaSihombingno, kiof is considered 5th gen. 4th gen started in 2017 with the boyz until 2022. Kiof started 5th gen with zb1 in mid 2023. I know its hard to believe kiof being 5th gen but they actually are
Kiss of life and aespa are sisters coded, Belle is close friends with Ning and Julie is so Giselle coded
Yea Julie and Giselle both saying the n word is so twin of them🥰
@@hgfdxfghj im not talking about the nword thing💀 they look similiar
@@hgfdxfghjyou r so weird
@@hgfdxfghj Well there's nothing wrong with that 🥰
@@hgfdxfghj r u blind 😂
Giselle be like that's my girls
Ningning and Giselle found their kids
Giselle is always so genuine love herrrr so muchhhh
Ningning face❤
TripleS got shy and had such a cute reaction 😂 and then Ningning 😂😂😂
I’m sure when tripleS went to their dorm they were talking about how kiof is their style lol
They have 2nd Generation K-pop vibes . I miss those days 😭
That’s why they’re called Y2K girl group.
@@nightxlynxs sorry idk much about scenes in K-pop these days basically retired oldie 🥲
@@nightxlynxswhat? When? Says who? Where's the y2k
@@pookjiyoon If I remember correctly, I watched an ep of Jaefriends with Natty & Belle and they were explaining they were called Y2K group or something. Me personally, they do remind me of 2nd Gen Kpop just like what op commented.
@@Ponyo_020 Don’t be sorry & you’re not alone, I took I hiatus from Kpop, unfortunately😢💔.
NingSelle really like it 😂
Ningning mouthing that they are cool 😂
Ningning and Giselle : "Hell yeah i also want that dance move"
KIOF are really talented. It doesn’t feel like they debuted so recently because of how good they already are❤
SEUNGBERRY!
@@Gottagetthegrootback stayyyy
Yooyeon is defo fangirling in her mind, Miss “We’re 24 members at least one of us has to be like that (👩❤️👩)” 😭‼️
LMAOOO
Always wanted nobody knows presentation in front of others artists 😬
Loved the reactions ❤
Giselle was like'Yeah hit that'
yooyeon when she saw pretty girls :
yooyeon got so flustered omg 😭😭
Ningning and Giselle is enjoying it! ❤❤😂
Giselle quase se levantou pra dançar junto
THEY GOT NINGNING GIGGLING AND BLUSHING BYEEEEE (me too girl)
Ning ning and giselle having the time of their lives lol
tripleS my cuties
The sunbaenim aespa enjoy just the show😂😂
Ningning def had this on her playlist. The song suits her vibes so much 😍😍
Ningning felt inspired🤣🤣
Triple S:omg
Aespa :woah
NINGNING ENJOYED IT 😭
Giselle's reaction:"Ooooh...Damn girl!"
I love Aespa reaction ningselle totally learned the dance😂
The fact Ningning and belle are friends💞🥹
and natty
Giselle said "I like it" Smiling to ningning
Giselle said " i wanna try that 😅"
ningselle like what they see
Julie pointing like Wassup
tripleS literally debuted before KIOF 😂
that smirk on ningning oh damn she liked it
This is what happens when u debut actual adults🔥🔥
when you're in your rookie era but you slayed so much 🔥🔥🔥
Giselle: “That’s hot”
3:35 WHAT IS THIS BEHAVIOUR JUNGWONIE 🥹🩷 HOW CAN SOMEONE BE *THISS* CUTE
sohyn was probably drooling
ningselle cover soon im praying
Gigi was genuiely loving it
You know Giselle (sorry if it's wrong) might be love it so much. I could see her enjoy this, rare to see reaction from idols nowadays
Ningselle was so proud but also wondering if they can show it 😂
Hyerin is adorable
The way that I am a full blown TripleS stan from the very beginning and I forgot there was a Hyerin in TripleS 😂😂 I don't know whyyy
@@yerinbaekscandlelighthaha me too. It’s hard to keep track of the members. (p.s, that is Hyerin, right? It’s too blurry for me to be certain)
@@c1k2.yeah it’s hyerin, then yooyeon and nakyoung
winter and giselle are ENJOYING that performance so much 😭😭😭
NINGNING IS LIKE I WANNA TO DO THAT TOO
Omg
I missed the moment when aespa became seniors
TRIPLE S AND KIOF MY FAV 5TH GENSSSS❤
They would eat Bp up like how Sistar ate AOA XDDD
Ningning enjoyed sm!!😭
Ningning I know what you are 👀
3:36 not him distracting us with the bow that made us think this album was called royal blood 😭
You know what? After watching this video, wanna make me Julie/Natty will be bestfriend with Giselle. I think they give the same vibes yk
julie and giselle defo gives the same vibes!!!
ningselle dont be shy
ningning reaction had me choking shes so cute amd funny, anyways kiof ate
Ningnings reaction is golden asf 😂😂😂😂 She’s like « yeahhhh i wanna do dat too!!!!!! »
Has anybody noticed how much kof's outfits are similar to aespa's in drama era those red and black ones
Kiof to triple.s : This is literally the kiss of life gurzzz 😂
ningselle enjoyed😭😭
I think Giselle and Julie would be good friends
Asepa was like “thats what I am tlking about”
Rookie: inspirational
Sunbaenim: supportive
Giselle queria muitooooo
Ningselle they're so real 😭🤣
Ningning having gay panic! Us nini us😭😭✋✋
i love kiof and ningselle smmm
Ningning I know what you are
Ningning and jiselle liking what they're seeing 👀
They remind me of SISTAR….😊
Ning was like "yaaaas girl get itttt!"😂
Giselle: woahhh!!! yessss!! joaaa!!
Ningning looks so pleased
JULIES VOCALS AND DANCING RAHHH
They give off mamamoo vibes and i'm all for that
i just know yooyeon came back home fangirling
Aespa enjoyed that shit 😭
ناتي ف الفرقة🥺🥺💗💗💗
بعد انفراد و اقصائها قبل سنين رجعت رجعة قوية و ف فرقة كلهم موهوبين و مميزيينن
no surprise with giselles reaction
No when i first seen this on their challenge...i had to rewatch bc i was like 😮 they're killing it!
Unpopular opinion but kpop actually needs this type of sexy concept. The one where they all look like actual adults and not in a cute child like aesthetic. Kpop needs to separate cute from sexy because cuteness and innocence are for children and should’t in any way be tied to sexy and seductive. The concept of aegyo is actually horrifying.
I talked about that on Twitter, its so creepy of see adult acting like Child for pedo guys,I love twice song but when you see their age its creepy and the fact sexy concept with hight school outfit need to stop too
@@hyungking-namjinsope0t469 same here im very biased when it comes to twice but they all need to start acting like their age. Their eldest is closer to 30 than 20, the aegyo has to stop at least on camera. They can keep doing that in their personal lives if that’s their personality but it has to be stopped on mainstream media, it’s just creepy and inappropriate.
@@sun8843 nah fr piss me off, asia need to stop normalized Child concept with adult like wtf
@@sun8843 cute song for Child its OK for me but with Child voice and aegyo its a no for me
I just know ningning gave a show to members at dorm after the performance
ningselle enjoyed it for sure
What a surprise from TripleS and what a surprise from AESPA, the day they watch a Nicki Minaj or Card B performance they will never sleep again 😂
the way tripleS are also sunbaes to kiof, the three members shown debuted in 2022 💀 their reaction is so cute
Ningning knows whats up, a talent recognizes talent
她们绝对会大火😢😢😢 真的很有实力
Not Julie and Belle having a leash on me😭😭🤚🏻
Ning Ning and Giselle🤭
Nothing can surprise sunbaenim anymore.
Our yooyeon is shock 😅😊😊