I wasn't assuming their gender in my head when I wrote the comment so no. And even if I did, I would've called it a guy anyway since I call everyone a guy even if they're female. And no, I'm not editing my comment.
CandyDream their "now" Animation was mostly tweening but the two seconds of animation at the end is cool. The tweening looks nice too, but I never concidered it animation. Doesn't mean it doesn't look good👌
PaintedBleu - I've seen you somewhere before... Or was it fake.. Oh yea! I've seen you at Marie's remix of "your reality" from DOKI DOKI literature club Edit: yep I've see you there, you said you would animate it ;-; I am still looking forward to it now xDD
I honestly think Stariaat was way better back then,probably because she put alot more effort into what she was making. Now her animations just seem lazy.
doggzed I agree and the past video looks so smoother I would have probably pay more attention to her if she did more of that stuff I was a fan of her a long time ago a while before she got popular and I kinda like the stuff
Purple Pika But you can see the difference. The older animation was smooth, the newer animation had good art but the animation isn’t like the older version. Sure, they’re both good but I would like to see her make more smooth videos like her old ones.
you wanna know how? she was so smart in the past but now... stariaat and the bunny are like starfire and raven from teen titans go. and stariaat uses sub bots.
No offense, but Starriat didn't really improve She even became worse. Anatomy is inconsistent, animation isn't the smoothest, etc It really makes me wonder how come she has so many subs and views for making these badly animated videos. Seriously And please don't attack me on my opinion thanks!! UWU
Stale Bananas it’s almost as if they’ve just went down a level, the tweening, although I don’t like tweening, looked really good but in the second one it was just a bunch of flipped drawings.
I can’t believe Scyrina is here. They had indeed improved over years. Though, for the content they make, they shouldn’t be underrated. In the future, I hope they make more content like that :P
Hi! Does anyone want to be in an animators then vs now video? If so, you must have progress on your art, and reply to this. (This is not a joke) hurry, I'm only doing a few people. If I do the video, I will be sure to credit everyone, and it will be on my other channel called ilifoo
okay so, for people who are gonna/already have commented/ about how stariaat didn't improve or how she's worse, take a second to think about how *your* animations would look (if you haven't already tried.) if you have smooth, non choppy animation, gud for you. but animating is hard. (I know this from doing this myself) you're trying to do a tail wag, but you want to make the ends move so it looks realistic. but really it just looks like it's flapping around. while you're drawing each frame of animation, the lines aren't completely the same, so it looks like it's changing size and proportion, but you're either trying to go for perspective or realistic movement. remember, she's only been animating for 1 year. her art has improved to something amazing, but she's still trying her best in animation(I'm talking about Stariaat). and then you might reply to this, "but (ex. GhostFaceNikol) has been animating for only one year and their animations are top-rate!" yeah, well some people are more skilled in animation than they are for others. and I'm not saying and trying to tell you that her animations HAVE improved, I'm stating my opinion. I look down in the comments and there are people telling me that her animations ARE bad. that's your opinion, not mine. if you're one of those people you try to tell others what IS and what ISN'T, then you need to stop. you can't comfirm it for sure. Stariaat's animations may be rapidly improving for me, but it may not to you. try to remember, it's all based off of purely opinion of different people. and don't blame the people who disagree with you on your opinion. But her animations *probably* will get better, so don't rage on her.
I feel like staariat is like, a person that was way way way beautiful before, but then got botched plastic surgery and became ugly. (Not her as a person, I mean like I feel like this as her art and how it’s progressed)
I feel like you didn’t really pick the best clips for some of these animators. I think you should have picked a clip where they truly tried at the animation in both. Stariaat’s new one was legit supposed to be something with bad animation!
Stale Bananas I know, but sometimes there are videos where RUclipsrs don’t try as hard... you should pick the ones where they truly do try because that would be the most true to the RUclipsrs
Flutters and yeagars art styles back then are actually AMAZINNGGGGG Edit: WHAATS WRONG WITH ME SCYRINAS TOO!!!!!!!1111!!!111!!!1!1!1 OMG BUT SERIOUSLY SHES TWEENING MASTERRRRR
meimei stuff animation takes a lot of practice. It’s not something everyone can do in a matter of months. Just. Do as much as you can every opportunity you get and you’ll do great. That’s my advice. Don’t have high expectations, just try your best all the time.
All of these animations look cleaner, and sync up to the music. Some have actually improved, but nothing about this says animation improvement (unless people actually want to get better at animation). Some of these were really good! The one with the cow was really good! A bunch of this stuff was so repeated that I just ended up despising it.
*_Don't put new/young animators in cringe comps! Some kids can't handle it like most adults! And new ones will improve over time, if it enjoys animating, and doesn't let cringe comps get to it. But if it does let it get to it... It may stop animating because it doesn't believe in itself :(_*
I love Flutter’s style from back then and now. It’s so cute. Also the now animation is the cover of You Spin Me Round (Like a Record) by Ninja Sex Party. I love them so much. Especially Danny Sexbang and Ninja Brian.
Only thing I dont like about nikol and rossali is how little movement their characters make sometimes. Like of course they move, but ever so slightly and sometimes they just look and feel kinda restricted in terms of movement. Idk that's just me.
To be completely honest I like the old starriat alot more than how she is now. Her old animation was so smooth but now it's not smooth at all and kinda looks like crap. Sorry I'm not trying to disrespect her or anyone that likes her animations I'm just trying to say that her animations have decreased in quality and that she needs to improve Sorry again
![James Fridman Photoshop Trolls [2020]](/img/1.gif)
Stariaat
Objective: *SURVIVE*
Dat One Squid named Squidy ohhh hi
Hi?
Glenn Starguard I think they mean star is only producing animations in a quantity over quality sorta manner so that she can maintain her popularity.
DanTDM got Popular Fast. Nobody can stop him
plus she needs to chill
Yeagar never changed except for the fact that her fursona got thiccer. Poor guy..
Carma lmaO
Puberty
t h i c c
Carma
Pun
I wasn't assuming their gender in my head when I wrote the comment so no.
And even if I did, I would've called it a guy anyway since I call everyone a guy even if they're female.
And no, I'm not editing my comment.
Scyrina GO GIRL ON DEM SKILLS
Shayla Mosley lol
Shayla Mosley AMEN
Shayla Mosley yeaaah. Scyrina da best
Preachhh!
Wonderful ending to the video
*zooms in on pewdiepies face*
MOST LIKES IVE EVER GOTTEN AHHDBCJCJCJD
Scyrina is the god of animation
CandyDream yup
CandyDream their "now" Animation was mostly tweening but the two seconds of animation at the end is cool. The tweening looks nice too, but I never concidered it animation. Doesn't mean it doesn't look good👌
spicylemons that's exActly what I think but you put it a lot more elegantly than I would have :'^)
spicylemons tbh I think it's more puppet animation then anything else, but the frame-by-frame is to die for also ;w;
IKR
I love flutters style rn :) she has improved so much I am so proud of her lol
PaintedBleu - I've seen you somewhere before... Or was it fake.. Oh yea! I've seen you at Marie's remix of "your reality" from DOKI DOKI literature club
Edit: yep I've see you there, you said you would animate it ;-; I am still looking forward to it now xDD
PaintedBleu 😂
Yeagar was always good. ♥
SCYRINA THO OMG
My reaction:?????????????
tbh i prefer past staariat.
Same!
Ravioli, ravioli, don't lewd the hat loli
xXThe Kawaii Cute Nekø Girl! Lewd Rper!Xx
Same
me too!
So do i
I personally think Stariaat was a lot better back then. Her animations now seem lazier, but they aren’t too bad. Just the past animation was better.
okay so this is my actual reaction of scyrina’s improvement.
then: oh, that’s kinda cool. i wonder what it’ll be like now?
now: HOLY SHIT.
kalii hello i am offering you an invite to my channel
what
I think we all know ho improved the most..
I think ghostfacenikol and scyrina
I honestly think Stariaat was way better back then,probably because she put alot more effort into what she was making. Now her animations just seem lazy.
doggzed I agree and the past video looks so smoother I would have probably pay more attention to her if she did more of that stuff I was a fan of her a long time ago a while before she got popular and I kinda like the stuff
Tahlia Nguyen Well yeah,her art obviously got better,but the animation not so much.
shading and color don't matter as long as the animations are smooth and actually have good quality
doggzed lazy? Have you ever animated in your whole live....
Purple Pika
But you can see the difference. The older animation was smooth, the newer animation had good art but the animation isn’t like the older version. Sure, they’re both good but I would like to see her make more smooth videos like her old ones.
Why did you put a real video of a cow for Scyrinas?
DomiFury
Good one
DomiFury ...
DomiFury wait is this suppose to be a joke?
I mean that's their art not a real cow..
Sorry if it's a joke I'm NOT NEW.
Why don't you do animators that do map parts? They are really good at animation
Silvean óÓÒò good idea
Or just animators in general. Most of these types of videos only do animation memers for some reason
Well most people that did this type of videos only do for meme animators because it gets more attention ahahah
I like old staariat animation. ._.
stariaat in the past was so original but now... stariaat is a little cringy with the new style!
Jennifer Vicentini ehhh I have mix feeling about still she able to do what she wants...
yeah but stariaat became a little dumb.
+Jennifer Vicentini how?
you wanna know how? she was so smart in the past but now... stariaat and the bunny are like starfire and raven from teen titans go. and stariaat uses sub bots.
Jennifer Vicentini how do you know she uses sub bots?
Yeager is still good in the then
scryrina is the tween queen
No offense, but Starriat didn't really improve
She even became worse.
Anatomy is inconsistent, animation isn't the smoothest, etc
It really makes me wonder how come she has so many subs and views for making these badly animated videos.
Seriously
And please don't attack me on my opinion thanks!! UWU
i agree too hard.
Same boi
CattoNugget Agreed.
CattoNugget Yes I know i agree! Im not really a starriat fan I love rosali's animations though. Starriats animations just got a bit lazy honestly
TinyKawaii its an opinion though thats not being rude they are giving critic information and think that she should try harder
Soo... less animation, more tweening.... pretty much their art styles changed for the better.
cool
Tulip cat
Ya know didn’t expect to see someone like you here
thank u for sub x3
And so the legends met
I'm watching this while I'm cold in my room
I HEARD BTS
Kanna Kamui ARMYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY
Kanna Kamui same I need that song
NO NOT TODAYY
IKR
Kanna Kamui hello twin
Their old animations are better than mine :(
when the bts song popped up i was like yeEEEARRRR
YOU KNOW WHAT DIS IS THE ABSOULOTE BEST ANIMATORS THEN AND NOW I'VE EVER SEEN *I'm not joking*😊
Rowan's Animations
Aw thanks
*0:52** wait...thats... Is BTS? OMFG IS BTS AFAGAFADAFS I LOVE IT 🎶❤🌈 🎶❤❤❤*
슈가민윤기 I FEEL YA TOO!!!
Oh god the army is flooding in already
YESSSS BTS IS AMAZING
YOUR PROFILE OF YOONGI IS SO CUTE
슈가민윤기
What song is it? I like the sound of there music.
Welp I'm going to listen to bts now bye
MANGLE Violet XD
Jimin's_ each ...
SAMEEEEEEEEEEEE
LOLOLOL ARMY
MANGLE Violet me
2% Of the comments about Scyrina.. -_-
WHY RN'T PEOPLE NOTICING HER!!! SHE IS THE GOD OF ANIMATIONS. ;-;
Ikr
I just feel that squacy person has kind of... flopped...
Foxtastix
Flopped?
Stale Bananas it’s almost as if they’ve just went down a level, the tweening, although I don’t like tweening, looked really good but in the second one it was just a bunch of flipped drawings.
I can’t believe Scyrina is here. They had indeed improved over years. Though, for the content they make, they shouldn’t be underrated.
In the future, I hope they make more content like that :P
I am cheese 1:04 do you know the meme called?
Hi! Does anyone want to be in an animators then vs now video? If so, you must have progress on your art, and reply to this. (This is not a joke) hurry, I'm only doing a few people. If I do the video, I will be sure to credit everyone, and it will be on my other channel called ilifoo
ugly grandma
Don’t put me in it, but I’ll help you get others!
@@stalebananas2377 if you want to then that is fine. Also, cool name
maybe me?
qwq
Flutter and yeagar are teh same
yeagar looks the same
okay so, for people who are gonna/already have commented/ about how stariaat didn't improve or how she's worse, take a second to think about how *your* animations would look (if you haven't already tried.) if you have smooth, non choppy animation, gud for you. but animating is hard. (I know this from doing this myself) you're trying to do a tail wag, but you want to make the ends move so it looks realistic. but really it just looks like it's flapping around. while you're drawing each frame of animation, the lines aren't completely the same, so it looks like it's changing size and proportion, but you're either trying to go for perspective or realistic movement. remember, she's only been animating for 1 year. her art has improved to something amazing, but she's still trying her best in animation(I'm talking about Stariaat). and then you might reply to this, "but (ex. GhostFaceNikol) has been animating for only one year and their animations are top-rate!" yeah, well some people are more skilled in animation than they are for others. and I'm not saying and trying to tell you that her animations HAVE improved, I'm stating my opinion. I look down in the comments and there are people telling me that her animations ARE bad. that's your opinion, not mine. if you're one of those people you try to tell others what IS and what ISN'T, then you need to stop. you can't comfirm it for sure. Stariaat's animations may be rapidly improving for me, but it may not to you. try to remember, it's all based off of purely opinion of different people. and don't blame the people who disagree with you on your opinion. But her animations *probably* will get better, so don't rage on her.
Everybody was cringey once in a life time but hey I'm still cringey since 3 years ago
YES THE WEEB MEME for staraait !!!!!!!!!
Bendy & Boris the laziest meme to exist
Sammystar 315 No, the pause meme is way more lazy.
Kamila Martinez Zeledon true, and the 5pm meme
Sammystar 315 true, it makes me a little bit angry...
Kamila Martinez Zeledon ikr? It had like 7 frames
Go check out StaleBannanas other videos! Drop a like!
0:52 me: WHAAAA NOT TODAY
my mom: whats wrong
Me:NOT TODAYYYY
I like squacy’s art back then it just has more animation
Much difference between then and now
You spin me
Meme fan girl Killer right round baby right round.
Yas
The last one is soooo funnyyyy! 😂😂😂😂
41k views!!! Nice job stale!
Yeagar has been real good all time. But definitely improved.
Like flutter's before
I think then and now are still the same
Now Flutter
*is all about her bunnies*
Yeagar didn’t change at all
whyaretheyallbetterthanmethenandnow
2:50
This is the best possible way to end a vid.
I feel like staariat is like, a person that was way way way beautiful before, but then got botched plastic surgery and became ugly. (Not her as a person, I mean like I feel like this as her art and how it’s progressed)
Jaylen Richardson
That was a pretty good analogy
Where's Lauren 👀
Weeb meme!
Meme fan girl Killer
I’ll try
?
1:04 .____________.
I'm so proud bro! 4.9 k views!!
WAIT WHAT ABOUT JELBEARWOLFIE!?
AlliToader -
I check it out
Oh god... my comment is popular
RexiDino FishyBoopkins
‘Tis now
I feel like you didn’t really pick the best clips for some of these animators. I think you should have picked a clip where they truly tried at the animation in both. Stariaat’s new one was legit supposed to be something with bad animation!
Feather Limes
First to last
(To videos date)
Stale Bananas I know, but sometimes there are videos where RUclipsrs don’t try as hard... you should pick the ones where they truly do try because that would be the most true to the RUclipsrs
O R I G I N A L C O N T E N T 101
Yes,
But for some reason it still got 180k
Views
Flutters and yeagars art styles back then are actually AMAZINNGGGGG
Edit: WHAATS WRONG WITH ME SCYRINAS TOO!!!!!!!1111!!!111!!!1!1!1 OMG BUT SERIOUSLY SHES TWEENING MASTERRRRR
WAIT BTS!!?? Saturn cat killed me.
khmer she killed me too
-Squacy’s then is KINDA better than the now-
SarahDaWolf Hickox
I didn’t think so?
Stale Bananas
Sorry if I hurt anyone ;-;
The best one: ghostfacenikol
HEJ HEJ MONIKA HEJ PADIG MONIKA
Sigh. I wish I can have a change in my animating like these guys
meimei stuff just keep at it. Some of these changes were from when they were like. 8 to 16 or older.
_iScarabi_ oh. So its ginna take a few years? :/
meimei stuff animation takes a lot of practice. It’s not something everyone can do in a matter of months. Just. Do as much as you can every opportunity you get and you’ll do great.
That’s my advice. Don’t have high expectations, just try your best all the time.
Only saturncat, squacy and ghostfacenikol got improved...
i heard nsp's cover of you spin me round and was pleasantly surprised
cosmicnestor hello i am offering you an invite to my channel
heylo
All of these animations look cleaner, and sync up to the music. Some have actually improved, but nothing about this says animation improvement (unless people actually want to get better at animation). Some of these were really good! The one with the cow was really good! A bunch of this stuff was so repeated that I just ended up despising it.
What is the meme at 1:03 ?
fluff bunny
ruclips.net/video/aAcQsitzXUs/видео.html
Nym meme
*_Don't put new/young animators in cringe comps! Some kids can't handle it like most adults! And new ones will improve over time, if it enjoys animating, and doesn't let cringe comps get to it. But if it does let it get to it... It may stop animating because it doesn't believe in itself :(_*
Whenever it says ______THEN
And ______ NOW
I feel like someone's screaming (example)
*YEAGAR NOWWWW*
I’m gonna day Yeagar improved so much in a short amount of time. Like I’m not even kidding, just wow
I love Flutter’s style from back then and now. It’s so cute.
Also the now animation is the cover of You Spin Me Round (Like a Record) by Ninja Sex Party. I love them so much. Especially Danny Sexbang and Ninja Brian.
Saturn cat.... Not Today song by BTS.... she started animating last year.
I fangirled at SATURN CAT then just because... BTS SJKAKAKA
0:55 BTS BTS BTS BTS BTS BTS BTS BTS BTS BTS BTS BTS BTS BTS BTS BTS BTS BTS BTS BTS BTS BTS BTS BTS BTS BTS BTS BTS BTS BTS BTS BTS BTS BTS BTS BTS BTS BTS BTS BTS BTS BTS BTS BTS BTS BTS BTS AAAAHHHHHH !
*squacy now.* eats cookie with fork?
Me: WAT THE FFFFFF EHO EATS COOKIES WITH FORKKKSSS
Every furry ever:
Then: kinda not thick
Now: *T H I C K F U R R Y*
How come you choose their *good* then animations? It kinda makes me feel like I'm a horrible animator.
I kind of thought back during early animation (black and white cartoons) vs now (RUclips animators)
This is why cringe comp. Is shamed but they still do it
These animators got better :p
-I saw a few of them in cringe for some reason-
I still wonder why squacys meme doesnt go to the beat..... NO HATE DO
*ends with pewdiepies's face in camera* YASS BIIITCHAS
Guys shut up they all improved
They aren’t going to stay how they used to draw cause that ain’t helping you in art
You used the hey Monika one for ghost face nikol OMG When she posted that i laughed.
Staariat's animations are still choppy though.
0:07 good animator
0:13 furry
0:28 furry
0:43 anime furry
Only thing I dont like about nikol and rossali is how little movement their characters make sometimes. Like of course they move, but ever so slightly and sometimes they just look and feel kinda restricted in terms of movement. Idk that's just me.
Lol y’all hating on these artists for drawing and doing what they want and having fun instead of making their art how you like it
Sycrina was always awesome if I'm being honest
I subbed :3
mmmm gotta love that 3-8 frame limit....
yeah i didnt see a change in animation just art style....are people unable to tell the difference?
They all improved so much!❤️
*narrating voice* but there was ONLY ONE that was truly the `cringeist"
Saturn cat is my new FAVORITE FOR THE BTS MEME
To be completely honest I like the old starriat alot more than how she is now. Her old animation was so smooth but now it's not smooth at all and kinda looks like crap.
Sorry I'm not trying to disrespect her or anyone that likes her animations I'm just trying to say that her animations have decreased in quality and that she needs to improve
Sorry again
To kurami: look, im not 9, i got 12 years :3 how old are u? I didn't See any animations in your channel
I get it... animators are turning to crappy amv's for their ad revenue! It all makes sense now :0