Aahh yesss! The "Find an ARMY Anywhere" song! When in a crowd just sing/shout, "So show me"! and if there's an ARMY around, they will trumpet back, "I'll show you!"😂😂
I just love how BTS in this song are basically saying: Army, you have treated and loved us so well, now treat yourselves the same way you have treated us and you‘ll be fine, just love yourself 💜
That's it exactly, and brings such tears to my eyes. They're making us promise to believe in ourselves as much as we believe in them. This song really does save lives 💜
Magic Shop, basically, is a psychodramatic technique that exchanges fear for a positive attitude. The song is based on Dr James Doty's book "Into the Magic Shop " : a type of psychotherapy where a therapist takes on the role of a magic shop owner (it comes from a series of children fantasy novels Magic shop by Bruce Coville) who attempts to barter with “customers” in an attempt to satisfy their needs and wants in a constructive way. When you walk into the magic shop, you may ask for anything or try to sell what you don’t want. Everything comes at a price though. What you come in looking for isn’t always what you leave. A few of the lyrics of Magic Shop talk about how the boys want to replace ARMYs “sadness and pain” for “comfort”, much like the way the psychologist/therapist acts as the shopkeeper to exchange one thing for another. It's the second "offical fan song" after 2!3! , the first JK took a lead in writing and producing, besides RM, Hiss, Adora, J Hope,Suga and others. Song by BTS for Army, to comfort them, and also a promise : BTS will always be there for Army. It's one of my favorite BTS comfort song, (with Serendipity and Zéro o' clock)
Thank you ARMY for explaining to us that the "MV" is fan made and not an official video. This makes SOOO much more sense as our reaction will show our confusion as to what was happening in the video towards the end lol. However, the video was still done well and the clips used were beautiful :) Not to mention - the some is AWESOME, which is what counts.
This song has saved many ARMY lives, including mine and my daughters. It's STILL saving lives. The live performance is my anchor. Thanks for the reaction! BORAHAE 💜 💜
I'm 40 years old but when i need a reset or am feeling a bit down this BTS song and Zero O'clock is one of many other songs I listen to. No matter your age or disposition BTS always know how to provide comfort.
I love how the comfort songs are a little different, too. This one makes us promise to believe in ourselves, to love ourselves. Zero O'Clock is about how each day is a new chance for things to be better. And they're generally like that - not just "cheer up" but things with substance. Mikrokosmos is about how beautiful we all are together, how we can light up any night. For me, that one is a comfort song too - I always think of it paired with Magic Shop. 💜
Magic Shop is a masterpiece written/produced by JK. The beginning of my BTS experience. I didn’t know BTS before it just pop up in my feed and oh boy the start of digging the rabbit hole and I’m stuck since then. You guys are the best love your energy and your warm smile. I feel joy watching you. Borahae 💜💜💜
This is a comfort song for the ARMY and an encouragement too. It's like BTS challenge to all of us " you give me the best of me so you give you the best of you... show me" which ARMY replied I'll show you.
And I'm so thankful for the simplicity of this earworm... True TMI Story: Last month I had a painful & scary medical test with a tube down my throat & I had to keep sipping water at designated times to evaluate my swallowing. I was in a total state of panic, because it hurt & my body wanted to expel the tube that shouldn't be there, so my gag reflex kicked into overdrive & I had to keep myself from throwing up because we needed the test results & if she removed the tube, we had to start all over. My eyes were tearing. I was trying not to throw up. Trying to breathe. Trying to swallow the sips of water on cue, so she could record them. Meanwhile trying to calm my mind & body & I was scrambling frantically mentally trying to sing BTS lyrics in my head, so I could have something familiar & comforting to focus on. Even though I know many lyrics & BTS songs & sing them all the time, the ONLY lyrics that I could grasp in my panicky state were "So show me, I'll show you, so show me, I'll show you." It became my mantra for those terrible moments & helped me settle down enough to complete the test. I' ve never been so grateful for an earworm in my life. 💜
@@s.susanmarandi9080 Thank you. My health is a work in progress, but I'm still here & moving forward albeit at snail's pace. My other BTS mantra (now that I have lyric recall again) is RM's voice in my head saying, "A day may come when we lose, but it is not today. Today we fight!" 💜
@@lavenderbluemama953 I wish you all the best! I haven‘t been in that situation, but I think my mind might black out to ON: „bring the pain on“ Your choice is probably better^^
@@MrEQuecky For real! I love ON too. I used to sing "bring the pain" like I was a bad-ass, but now that I have chronic pain, I don't ask for more, lol. No sense in tempting the universe... 😬
The inspiration for this song came from a book called Into the Magic Shop: A Neurosurgeon's Quest to Discover the Mysteries of the Brain and the Secrets of the Heart. Book by James R. Doty What is the magic shop? The magic shop is explicitly stated as “A psychodramatic technique that exchanges fear for a positive attitude”. Psychodrama is often used in group therapy workshops in mental hospitals or other mental facilities to help patients gain insight into their own lives.
Love Magic Shop. How many artists out there have such a truly deep connection with their fans, that they consistently write songs to help ARMY and the members find happiness within themselves. It’s just so sincere, as you can always tell when an artist feels the song that they are singing, esp. live. I always prefer live as well, as even their mistakes are just so endearing. They don’t need to be perfect vocally, although they get upset when they can’t perform as they feel they should. They just make me happy just seeing them. I would love to see you react to the video of Jimins songs Rebirth and Slow Dance. It is really amazing from his new album, and if you get a chance watch the behind the scenes video as well. It’s really beautiful. As always, thank you for your reactions to BTS, as well as other artists.
I really think it's time fir you to make a reaction video to another album from BTS, my recommendation is Wings, this is for many armys the best album of their career so far. 😊
Watching you appreciate their live vocals is so fun - you notice their choices and I don't know if you realize how often you give little nods of approval 😂 This song is really meant to be live, so the audience can play their part. I love it - it's such a beautiful gift of a song. It saves lives, even. Can you imagine the power of, from the middle of a crowd of thousands of people, promising BTS that you'll show them what a beautiful person you can be? Promising to believe in and love yourself, at the top of your lungs, to give something back to these men who have given us so much. It genuinely changes people's lives, that moment. We believe in them, they believe in us, and everyone is their own beautiful galaxy. 💜
You absolutely need to listen to Stigma. Would love to see you react to V's full voice range. Its one song that really highlights his vocal range and vocal abilities. This is the song that made the world and fandom realize just how good his voice really is. He is overlooked as he does not often have the big notes in BTS songs especially in early days. Great reaction as Magic Shop is a favorite. JK knows how to write songs to Army.
What's really awesome with BTS voices is that they all have their own distinct hues and texture vocally and not only the vocal line but the rap line too. Those vocal textures really make them able to experiment with songs and put out incredible sounds. They shared before that they each sing the whole song and then decide which part goes to who based on that -- that's how they determine whose vocal best suits a part and a combination too. Their background vocals are a song in its own too, they take their craft seriously because they all have common love for music.
Magic Shop will always be a legendary and special song for ARMYs. But actually, my non-ARMY friend cried when she heard and read the lyrics of this song. 💜🥹
Example Nr. 7777 that BTS is better experienced live :) Now imagine back when this tour was online we didn't have the paid concert live streams with great quality. So army's in the stadium audience streamed the concerts live for other armys around the world with their phones with a wopping 144p quality. These videos sometimes got more than 100k watchers while they were livestreamed. I was one of the people that will be forever greatful for those streamers because they allowed us to experience these songs and the beautiful mix of army's and BTS' voices even from the other side of the world. I cried so much watching my first concert stream in 144p...could only see them blurry but it was still better than anything else I ever experienced. In the middle of the night right before going to work ;)
Magic Shop---lovely with substance. Guys, thank you for the music theory nerdery. That's what distinguishes your reaction channel. That's why I'm here. 💜
I’m so glad you watched them singing this live so you got to hear the call and response. Jungkook has been known to launch into that when leaving the stage and of course ARMY answer back on cue. The Fifth Muster is based around The Magic Shop and contains a wonderful sketch where a sad Jungkook goes to the Magic Shop to get help and encounters a very flirty shopkeeper played by Jimin who sends him into see each member who each has their own solution to his problems yet none of them work. Eventually finding the shoes he wore in the early days gets him back on track. They sometimes hold a Muster which is a special fan event around the time of their debut anniversary which is also known as Festa. J-Hope has said that they listen to the guide which is usually sung by Jungkook then they decide amongst themselves who will sing which parts. Some fans complain when they think that a member might be being short changed with the amount of lines he has but they decide so it is little to nothing to do with their producers.
Jin really sounds amazing, his low, mid, mix, chest, falsetto are spot on! Known as the reliable vocalist live… many Army who has watched BTS live are actually pleasantly surprised at how amazing Jin’s voice is. And how amazing BTS is when performing LIVE! They are the best💜
This was my first listen to this band. I was very impressed with vocals, music & they certainly are “The Whole Package”. If you like finger picking you should watch Mark, the lead guitarist of Dire Straits. Thank you for an interesting & great reaction.
15:48 ish : its understandable - because Hobi was only a dancer, he didn't originally know how to rap (I know you guys know this part but I'm just giving a refresher before i get to my point lol), Namjoon & yoongi would be rapping and battling in the dorms. Hobi once said "they were always rapping and I couldn't just stand there I naturally had to join in" or something to that effect. The point is, because he learned from those 2, he incorporates elements of both of their styles when he raps. I've gotten yoongi & Hobi confused before too, mostly in songs I don't listen to daily. So don't feel bad! It makes sense when you really think about it. 😊 💜
Have you listened to Jimin's new songs? He said in an behind the scenes that he was told he was singing in an unhealthy manner and so has changed the way the produces his tone. I definitely hear a difference. It would be interesting to see how you hear what is happening with his voice.
hm, would be interesting, but I think also difficult, because the new album also has a lot of autotune. I‘m not sure if it is possible to here the change?
@@JackInTheBox0294 I can understand you, sometimes, I just wanna here an artists pure voice. But from a production standpoint, sometimes I also love when autotune is used really well. For me, it depends a bit on the song. For Jimin‘s album, I would also have appreciated a little less autotune, but it is his choice and it sets a specific tone for the album. So I will take what I can get :)
@@MrEQuecky yes, me too. Their producers put autotune in songs and make good sound tracks with autotune sometimes. For example: ON, Dionysus, DNA, Outro:Tear, Butter, Dynamite, Black Swan. But at that time their producers made awful sound songs for jimin. They used so much autotune, although it is not needed.
This is my favourite song written and produced by Jungkook along side with *STAY* it’s also an amazing song you should check it 🙌🏼 Jungkook is so talented. - Thx guys
Missed seeing you! I love how you can spell in sign language. Yes, I love Magic Shop as it has helped me and so many. Glad you finally got to react to this live version! ‘So Show Me! I’ll show you!’ 👏👏👏💜💜💜💜💜💜💜🇨🇦🫶🏼
I'll treasure Richard' smile after WWH'S flying kiss from now one. That living in a few seconds feeling multiplied for 7 and multiplied again for every Ot7 song, equals Priceless 😍
Fanmade videos are often spoilers for other content please keep that in mind. Unless the video is from the official Bangtantv or Hybe channels (just click the channel name to see if it is a real official channel) then the song doesn’t have a music video, like magic shop.
No fanmade videos! They’re usually poorly made, have no context to the song, and are very often confusing to the viewer. Just do the live version. It’s beautiful.
@@throgaofficial MVs are only posted on HYBE Labels channel, 1thek or BANGTANTV (but as far as I know, they don't post mvs on bangtantv, only in HYBE 🤔)
Jungkook is a genius singer you can see it in every song he wrote and produced, his lyrics are always so beautiful ✨ Songs he wrote and produced please watch them : - live versions - *Stay & Film out*
Congratulations Richard on recognizing C# ahead of Johnny. I hope you are savoring the moment LOL!!!! Thank you for the awesome reaction to the very much loved Magic Shop. Here's a suggestion for future BTS reacts -- "Life Goes On" by BTS (has official MV) and "Life Goes On" by AgustD (no official MV)... I bet you will find this very interesting if/when you get to see it back to back. AgustD's version is one that he submitted for the BTS version but didn't make the cut. The best live version of LGO by BTS is the one in MTV Unplugged. AgustD's live version was during his D-Day Tour.
I agree with you. I love the live version so much better. Their voices really shine when they’re live. There’s nothing that takes away from the studio recording but live. It just so captures my heart.
I get scenes from a fan made video can fascinate the eyes of a person not deeply immersed in BTS material. However, when virtually all the clips used are intimately connected to well-known landmarks on a BTS journey, much of it for me was "good lord what loosely cobbled together intellectual theft being monetized in the guise of love ". I guess Magic Shop is a fan service track, but as even you picked up, the final scene lifted from Suga's Shadow was so misplaced as to belie the song's messaging. Magic Shop is a beautiful work which fortunately transcends all so hopefully the purity of the ARMY/ BTS relationship seen in the live will be your lasting memory, not the collage of images which are best left as eye candy in the context they were released.
these fan made video's with proper caption are still much appreciated for reactions as long you know theyre fanmade because besides live performances majority of bts songs don't have music videos so itll be difficult using live performances with more risk of block or lyric videos with risk of wrong translations fan made videos are sometimes good visually but mainly good for lyrics being correct. so hope you use this in future videos if you dont see a music video on hybe labels or bangtantv, 1thek, btsworldofficial, universal japan etc those are the main official channels with bts music videos but if its a song without, fan made is a good backup plan as long they have translations for the lyrics. :)
The other thing you don't generally hear on the recording, that you DO hear live, is ARMY.💜 The interactive element of this song is REALLY something special.
Jimin's next song has to be: the "Who" music video, Who's live performance on Jimmy Fallon, and the acoustic version of "Who." The music is "Who"! I really want to hear your professional opinion about the acoustic and the evolution of Jimin's vocals. Please! Por favor!제발!
Hey have you guys watched dreamers worldcup fifa song by jungkook. It has official mv and his live performance on opening of fifa worldcup was outstanding too
THANK YOU for watching! If you enjoy this video, please hit LIKE and SUBSCRIBE or buy us a coffee at buymeacoffee.com/throga
Aahh yesss! The "Find an ARMY Anywhere" song! When in a crowd just sing/shout, "So show me"! and if there's an ARMY around, they will trumpet back, "I'll show you!"😂😂
ABSOLUTELY 😄😃💜
It's our version of "Marcooo - Polooo"
💜💜💜💜
best call and response ever!
I also want to try "ApoBangpo!" at the theater, but I'll probably be too shy. 😅
I just love how BTS in this song are basically saying: Army, you have treated and loved us so well, now treat yourselves the same way you have treated us and you‘ll be fine, just love yourself 💜
Love how you explained what the song means! I've heard it many times, but your explanation brought tears to my eyes for some reason. 💜
That part of the song is the most meaningful and beautiful part of it. ("You gave me the best of you, so you'll give you the best of you.")
@@donnasweet3198 Thannk you so much 💜 now I‘m moved by your comment as well 🥲
@@s.susanmarandi9080 I absolutely agree 💜
That's it exactly, and brings such tears to my eyes. They're making us promise to believe in ourselves as much as we believe in them. This song really does save lives 💜
Blue and Gray is also a masterpiece that perfectly weaves their own flavor.
I love Blue and Gray, it's so poignant 💜
Essa é maravilhosa.
Yes, they should react to the PTD concert c😊nation of Blue & Grey plus Black Swan. That was a beautiful performance 💜💜💜💜💜💜💜
Magic Shop, basically, is a psychodramatic technique that exchanges fear for a positive attitude. The song is based on Dr James Doty's book "Into the Magic Shop " : a type of psychotherapy where a therapist takes on the role of a magic shop owner (it comes from a series of children fantasy novels Magic shop by Bruce Coville) who attempts to barter with “customers” in an attempt to satisfy their needs and wants in a constructive way. When you walk into the magic shop, you may ask for anything or try to sell what you don’t want. Everything comes at a price though. What you come in looking for isn’t always what you leave. A few of the lyrics of Magic Shop talk about how the boys want to replace ARMYs “sadness and pain” for “comfort”, much like the way the psychologist/therapist acts as the shopkeeper to exchange one thing for another. It's the second "offical fan song" after 2!3! , the first JK took a lead in writing and producing, besides RM, Hiss, Adora, J Hope,Suga and others. Song by BTS for Army, to comfort them, and also a promise : BTS will always be there for Army. It's one of my favorite BTS comfort song, (with Serendipity and Zéro o' clock)
And DJ Swivel produced "Magic Shope" too(who made "Euphoria", "Heartbeat")😊
great post!
@@LPnerd thank you
And for me SNOOZE Yoongis voice works so well with WOOSUNG
@throga
Thank you ARMY for explaining to us that the "MV" is fan made and not an official video. This makes SOOO much more sense as our reaction will show our confusion as to what was happening in the video towards the end lol. However, the video was still done well and the clips used were beautiful :) Not to mention - the some is AWESOME, which is what counts.
For the future: if MV is not on BANGTANTV or HYBE or BTS JAPAN OFFICIAL channels, then it's not official.
@@xanamo Thank you! We will pay closer attention to this next time :)
Jungkook composed and produced this song. One of my favorites!
This song has saved many ARMY lives, including mine and my daughters. It's STILL saving lives. The live performance is my anchor. Thanks for the reaction! BORAHAE 💜 💜
@@magicinthelandofsushiandsa1322yes and also prod by DJ Swivel
I'm 40 years old but when i need a reset or am feeling a bit down this BTS song and Zero O'clock is one of many other songs I listen to. No matter your age or disposition BTS always know how to provide comfort.
I love how the comfort songs are a little different, too. This one makes us promise to believe in ourselves, to love ourselves. Zero O'Clock is about how each day is a new chance for things to be better. And they're generally like that - not just "cheer up" but things with substance.
Mikrokosmos is about how beautiful we all are together, how we can light up any night. For me, that one is a comfort song too - I always think of it paired with Magic Shop. 💜
Oh... And I'm 46 😁 right there with you
Yes, Zero O'clock is so comforting💜💜💜
@evantesseract737 yes! Mikro too! Matter of fact I have a "BTS hopeful songs" Playlist on my spotify and these 3 are on it.
Same here! I'm 67.
No actual Music Video for Magic Shop. It's fan made clips of other songs put together.
Thank you for telling us! We just updated the description :)
This is a gift from Jungkook to Army 💟
he wrote and produced this masterpiece 🛐
It’s really my comfort song 🥹
Jimin Cherry on Top
Please react to BTS singing THE TRUTH UNTOLD, HOUSE OF CARDS and cover of I`II MISSING YOU. Gratitude here from BRAZIL.
Magic Shop is a masterpiece written/produced by JK. The beginning of my BTS experience. I didn’t know BTS before it just pop up in my feed and oh boy the start of digging the rabbit hole and I’m stuck since then. You guys are the best love your energy and your warm smile. I feel joy watching you. Borahae 💜💜💜
This is a comfort song for the ARMY and an encouragement too. It's like BTS challenge to all of us " you give me the best of me so you give you the best of you... show me" which ARMY replied I'll show you.
🥹🥹🥹💜
Jin in this song voice is just 😍
And I'm so thankful for the simplicity of this earworm...
True TMI Story: Last month I had a painful & scary medical test with a tube down my throat & I had to keep sipping water at designated times to evaluate my swallowing. I was in a total state of panic, because it hurt & my body wanted to expel the tube that shouldn't be there, so my gag reflex kicked into overdrive & I had to keep myself from throwing up because we needed the test results & if she removed the tube, we had to start all over.
My eyes were tearing. I was trying not to throw up. Trying to breathe. Trying to swallow the sips of water on cue, so she could record them. Meanwhile trying to calm my mind & body & I was scrambling frantically mentally trying to sing BTS lyrics in my head, so I could have something familiar & comforting to focus on.
Even though I know many lyrics & BTS songs & sing them all the time, the ONLY lyrics that I could grasp in my panicky state were "So show me, I'll show you, so show me, I'll show you." It became my mantra for those terrible moments & helped me settle down enough to complete the test.
I' ve never been so grateful for an earworm in my life. 💜
I'm glad it helped you get through that painful, scary experience, and I hope you've fully regained your health now.
@@s.susanmarandi9080 Thank you. My health is a work in progress, but I'm still here & moving forward albeit at snail's pace. My other BTS mantra (now that I have lyric recall again) is RM's voice in my head saying, "A day may come when we lose, but it is not today. Today we fight!" 💜
@@lavenderbluemama953 👍❤
@@lavenderbluemama953 I wish you all the best!
I haven‘t been in that situation, but I think my mind might black out to ON: „bring the pain on“ Your choice is probably better^^
@@MrEQuecky For real! I love ON too. I used to sing "bring the pain" like I was a bad-ass, but now that I have chronic pain, I don't ask for more, lol. No sense in tempting the universe... 😬
The inspiration for this song came from a book called Into the Magic Shop: A Neurosurgeon's Quest to Discover the Mysteries of the Brain and the Secrets of the Heart. Book by James R. Doty
What is the magic shop?
The magic shop is explicitly stated as “A psychodramatic technique that exchanges fear for a positive attitude”. Psychodrama is often used in group therapy workshops in mental hospitals or other mental facilities to help patients gain insight into their own lives.
Love the term shimmer for Jimin's voice.
It really does capture the feeling of his textures pretty well!
Love that term for Jimin💜💜💜
20:10 True, Richard. So simple but powerful. Loaded with all the best feelings of the ARMY and BTS. Thanks you for reaction
Oh God this is literally our ARMYs anthem. This song always makes me emotional.
So happy that finally you’re reacting to Magic Shop❤️❤️. It’s always Army’s comfort song.
Our comfort song 🥺. Thank you for taking time in reacting to this song
Am I the only one who noticed that you were often bobbing and moving your heads almost in unison? So fun to watch.
Yeah they usually do! It's fun 😁
Me encanta esta canción, me da ánimos. La voz de Jimin es una locura!
Love Magic Shop. How many artists out there have such a truly deep connection with their fans, that they consistently write songs to help ARMY and the members find happiness within themselves. It’s just so sincere, as you can always tell when an artist feels the song that they are singing, esp. live. I always prefer live as well, as even their mistakes are just so endearing. They don’t need to be perfect vocally, although they get upset when they can’t perform as they feel they should. They just make me happy just seeing them. I would love to see you react to the video of Jimins songs Rebirth and Slow Dance. It is really amazing from his new album, and if you get a chance watch the behind the scenes video as well. It’s really beautiful. As always, thank you for your reactions to BTS, as well as other artists.
They always manage to sound better live than in studio. They are fabulous. This Army song is so beautiful
SO SHOW MEEEEEEE.. 💜
I‘ll show you 💜
Thank you gentlemen, Bert and Ernie,for another good review of BTS. I'll just let others give you suggestions...I appreciate you both! 🤗💜🫡
Blue and gray is a work of art too, please react
Magic Shop is just like a very comfortable warm hug! apobangpo 💜
이노래는 콘서트영상을 봐야 더욱 감동적이랍니다.💕
I really think it's time fir you to make a reaction video to another album from BTS, my recommendation is Wings, this is for many armys the best album of their career so far. 😊
WINGS is not my fave album but it's my fave concept! Such beautiful imagery, the videos are awesome, and BS&T is iconic.
Wings is my favorito album.
Watching you appreciate their live vocals is so fun - you notice their choices and I don't know if you realize how often you give little nods of approval 😂
This song is really meant to be live, so the audience can play their part. I love it - it's such a beautiful gift of a song. It saves lives, even. Can you imagine the power of, from the middle of a crowd of thousands of people, promising BTS that you'll show them what a beautiful person you can be? Promising to believe in and love yourself, at the top of your lungs, to give something back to these men who have given us so much.
It genuinely changes people's lives, that moment. We believe in them, they believe in us, and everyone is their own beautiful galaxy. 💜
You absolutely need to listen to Stigma. Would love to see you react to V's full voice range. Its one song that really highlights his vocal range and vocal abilities. This is the song that made the world and fandom realize just how good his voice really is. He is overlooked as he does not often have the big notes in BTS songs especially in early days.
Great reaction as Magic Shop is a favorite. JK knows how to write songs to Army.
What's really awesome with BTS voices is that they all have their own distinct hues and texture vocally and not only the vocal line but the rap line too. Those vocal textures really make them able to experiment with songs and put out incredible sounds. They shared before that they each sing the whole song and then decide which part goes to who based on that -- that's how they determine whose vocal best suits a part and a combination too. Their background vocals are a song in its own too, they take their craft seriously because they all have common love for music.
I'm glad you watched the live performance. Top 5 for me. Just a beautiful song. I hope they bring it back for the comeback concert.
Magic Shop will always be a legendary and special song for ARMYs. But actually, my non-ARMY friend cried when she heard and read the lyrics of this song. 💜🥹
Example Nr. 7777 that BTS is better experienced live :) Now imagine back when this tour was online we didn't have the paid concert live streams with great quality. So army's in the stadium audience streamed the concerts live for other armys around the world with their phones with a wopping 144p quality. These videos sometimes got more than 100k watchers while they were livestreamed. I was one of the people that will be forever greatful for those streamers because they allowed us to experience these songs and the beautiful mix of army's and BTS' voices even from the other side of the world. I cried so much watching my first concert stream in 144p...could only see them blurry but it was still better than anything else I ever experienced. In the middle of the night right before going to work ;)
Magic Shop---lovely with substance. Guys, thank you for the music theory nerdery. That's what distinguishes your reaction channel. That's why I'm here. 💜
@@bt6248 Yes, I agree 💜
Glad you check the live version. It always gets me, specially with the audience interaction.
I’m so glad you watched them singing this live so you got to hear the call and response. Jungkook has been known to launch into that when leaving the stage and of course ARMY answer back on cue. The Fifth Muster is based around The Magic Shop and contains a wonderful sketch where a sad Jungkook goes to the Magic Shop to get help and encounters a very flirty shopkeeper played by Jimin who sends him into see each member who each has their own solution to his problems yet none of them work. Eventually finding the shoes he wore in the early days gets him back on track. They sometimes hold a Muster which is a special fan event around the time of their debut anniversary which is also known as Festa.
J-Hope has said that they listen to the guide which is usually sung by Jungkook then they decide amongst themselves who will sing which parts. Some fans complain when they think that a member might be being short changed with the amount of lines he has but they decide so it is little to nothing to do with their producers.
BTS FOREVER .... ARMY FOREVER ... I’LL SHOW YOU ....
Jin really sounds amazing, his low, mid, mix, chest, falsetto are spot on! Known as the reliable vocalist live… many Army who has watched BTS live are actually pleasantly surprised at how amazing Jin’s voice is. And how amazing BTS is when performing LIVE! They are the best💜
This song is my all time favorite for many reasons...and it will forever give me goosebumps live! It is incredible live!!!!
Thank you so much for this reaction! You guys are so awesome! 💜
My number 1 comfort song 💜
If this was requested 11months ago then that means I stayed with Throga for 1 yr already 🎉
Always love your reaction💜💜💜
This is by far one of my favorite songs ever. Its simplicity and light-feeling just makes me feel so nostalgic and happy.
My favorite comfort song! I can't wait!! 💜💜💜
Oh my goodness, you both ear to ear grinning while nodding your heads to the beat for the last 20 or so seconds of the song was just heartwarming ❤
This was my first listen to this band. I was very impressed with vocals, music & they certainly are “The Whole Package”.
If you like finger picking you should watch Mark, the lead guitarist of Dire Straits. Thank you for an interesting & great reaction.
22:46 You two are hilarious! This was such a Bert and Ernie moment, lol.
I always get emotional every time I hear this song. It reminds me why I love BTS. Thank you for your reaction. 💜💜💜💜💜🫶🏽🫰🏽!!!
15:48 ish : its understandable - because Hobi was only a dancer, he didn't originally know how to rap (I know you guys know this part but I'm just giving a refresher before i get to my point lol), Namjoon & yoongi would be rapping and battling in the dorms. Hobi once said "they were always rapping and I couldn't just stand there I naturally had to join in" or something to that effect. The point is, because he learned from those 2, he incorporates elements of both of their styles when he raps. I've gotten yoongi & Hobi confused before too, mostly in songs I don't listen to daily. So don't feel bad! It makes sense when you really think about it. 😊 💜
Yes I came here to say the same thing, there is no official music video for Magic shop so any video claiming to be the music video is made by fans
Thank you for telling us! We just updated the description :)
Have you listened to Jimin's new songs? He said in an behind the scenes that he was told he was singing in an unhealthy manner and so has changed the way the produces his tone. I definitely hear a difference. It would be interesting to see how you hear what is happening with his voice.
hm, would be interesting, but I think also difficult, because the new album also has a lot of autotune. I‘m not sure if it is possible to here the change?
@@MrEQueckyyes, i dont like songs with very much using autotune.
@@JackInTheBox0294 I can understand you, sometimes, I just wanna here an artists pure voice. But from a production standpoint, sometimes I also love when autotune is used really well. For me, it depends a bit on the song. For Jimin‘s album, I would also have appreciated a little less autotune, but it is his choice and it sets a specific tone for the album. So I will take what I can get :)
@@MrEQuecky yes, me too. Their producers put autotune in songs and make good sound tracks with autotune sometimes. For example: ON, Dionysus, DNA, Outro:Tear, Butter, Dynamite, Black Swan. But at that time their producers made awful sound songs for jimin. They used so much autotune, although it is not needed.
I love this song!!!❤❤❤
I love this song!! And as usual, your analysis is great. Thank you 💜💜💜
So nice to see the live performance ♥️💖♥️
This is my favourite song written and produced by Jungkook along side with *STAY* it’s also an amazing song you should check it 🙌🏼 Jungkook is so talented.
- Thx guys
Hahaha that last part made me laugh Richard. Yes! Kudos to to you ❤
Ahhh one of my favorites!!
Missed seeing you! I love how you can spell in sign language. Yes, I love Magic Shop as it has helped me and so many. Glad you finally got to react to this live version! ‘So Show Me! I’ll show you!’ 👏👏👏💜💜💜💜💜💜💜🇨🇦🫶🏼
i miss them so muuuuuuuuuuuuuuch 💜
I'll treasure Richard' smile after WWH'S flying kiss from now one. That living in a few seconds feeling multiplied for 7 and multiplied again for every Ot7 song, equals Priceless 😍
Fanmade videos are often spoilers for other content please keep that in mind. Unless the video is from the official Bangtantv or Hybe channels (just click the channel name to see if it is a real official channel) then the song doesn’t have a music video, like magic shop.
*BANGTANTV, HYBE LABELS
really love this
No fanmade videos! They’re usually poorly made, have no context to the song, and are very often confusing to the viewer. Just do the live version. It’s beautiful.
We learned this after the fact, now we know to look out for this scenario!
@@throgaofficial MVs are only posted on HYBE Labels channel, 1thek or BANGTANTV (but as far as I know, they don't post mvs on bangtantv, only in HYBE 🤔)
@@boramiii there is some solo stuff like winter bear and festa songs
@@blue5lady oh! right, right! thank you 😊
I think I've seen one or two good fan made videos, but this definitely wasn't it🤔 Interlude: Shadow at the end, seriously???
tank you so much im korea amry .
Can you react to the truth untold , house of cards, serendipity,stay gold
Moreee BTS reactions to their group and solo works!
Jungkook is a genius singer you can see it in every song he wrote and produced, his lyrics are always so beautiful ✨
Songs he wrote and produced please watch them :
- live versions -
*Stay & Film out*
Yes😊
Also "your eyes tell", "my time", "begin" and "my you"
A great call and response song with ARMY
BTS are best for live performance, They are the best
Love this song 💜
Thank you guys .
Congratulations Richard on recognizing C# ahead of Johnny. I hope you are savoring the moment LOL!!!!
Thank you for the awesome reaction to the very much loved Magic Shop. Here's a suggestion for future BTS reacts -- "Life Goes On" by BTS (has official MV) and "Life Goes On" by AgustD (no official MV)... I bet you will find this very interesting if/when you get to see it back to back. AgustD's version is one that he submitted for the BTS version but didn't make the cut. The best live version of LGO by BTS is the one in MTV Unplugged. AgustD's live version was during his D-Day Tour.
Love this song! 💜💜💜💜💜💜💜
Taehyung deep voice something else ❤
I agree with you. I love the live version so much better. Their voices really shine when they’re live. There’s nothing that takes away from the studio recording but live. It just so captures my heart.
If I sing this song thinking about the meaning, I cry. This song has saved lives! Thank you for your reaction and analysis, guys.
I get scenes from a fan made video can fascinate the eyes of a person not deeply immersed in BTS material. However, when virtually all the clips used are intimately connected to well-known landmarks on a BTS journey, much of it for me was "good lord what loosely cobbled together intellectual theft being monetized in the guise of love ". I guess Magic Shop is a fan service track, but as even you picked up, the final scene lifted from Suga's Shadow was so misplaced as to belie the song's messaging. Magic Shop is a beautiful work which fortunately transcends all so hopefully the purity of the ARMY/ BTS relationship seen in the live will be your lasting memory, not the collage of images which are best left as eye candy in the context they were released.
Please react to BTS Pied Piper, Let Go, Love myself. I am from Indonesia
I am always impressed that their live vocals are so good, I feel many songs they over process their voices.
I can’t remember if you guys have listened to BTS’s Answer: Love Myself, but I highly recommend if not! Jin’s voice is incredible!💜
Thanks!
You’re very welcome! Thank you for the super thanks :)
Thanks guys! Magic shop has our hearts. As always you were amazing... Lov U ❤❤❤❤
My comfort song
My favourite song. Thanks💜💜💜💜
In love of Magic Shop💜
thank you guys, i love BTS, I am ARMY from Brasil 💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜
Thank you for your reaction to this song , the live video is very special . Forever BTS 💜💜
these fan made video's with proper caption are still much appreciated for reactions as long you know theyre fanmade because besides live performances majority of bts songs don't have music videos so itll be difficult using live performances with more risk of block or lyric videos with risk of wrong translations fan made videos are sometimes good visually but mainly good for lyrics being correct. so hope you use this in future videos if you dont see a music video on hybe labels or bangtantv, 1thek, btsworldofficial, universal japan etc those are the main official channels with bts music videos but if its a song without, fan made is a good backup plan as long they have translations for the lyrics. :)
Magic Shop makes more sense to army, because of the lyrics, the song in itself it is simple but very effective.
Thanks handsome guys..
The other thing you don't generally hear on the recording, that you DO hear live, is ARMY.💜 The interactive element of this song is REALLY something special.
Jimin's next song has to be: the "Who" music video, Who's live performance on Jimmy Fallon, and the acoustic version of "Who." The music is "Who"! I really want to hear your professional opinion about the acoustic and the evolution of Jimin's vocals. Please! Por favor!제발!
Jinnnnnnnn 👏👏👏👏👏💜💜💜💜💜
thank you
Hey have you guys watched dreamers worldcup fifa song by jungkook. It has official mv and his live performance on opening of fifa worldcup was outstanding too
*sips her butterfly-pea tea*