One Direction - Made In The A.M. Vocal Range: F#2 - C#5 - G5

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 17 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 273

  • @aries158
    @aries158 8 лет назад +128

    liam's head voice deserves so much better

  • @gisellefendi5793
    @gisellefendi5793 9 лет назад +220

    After Zayn's departure they've been giving the notes to Harry. Its a good thing actually cause he finally explored his chest/mixed register in the 5th octave. I'm pretty sure if Zayn was still in the band he would've taken those C5s and C#5s. For four albums he has only reached up to a B4 and now he's shown he can hit higher than the 4th octave. Louis' belts are so good in this album. The G#4 & B4 he sustained was amazing. And his high harmonies on Hey Angel were perfection. Not surprised Liam got all the falsettos/ head notes. His belts were normal but his low register was just amazing. The F#2 was so strong and supported. I wish Niall would've gotten more solos to show off his chest/mixed register and belts but his low range was quite showcased too similar to Liam.

    • @brubarurno
      @brubarurno 9 лет назад +8

      +Bey Xtina Minaj Not only Harry though, Liam has had to give a little more work to his head-chest mix (The Bb4s in History). Thing we haven't seen him do in full voice scince the song Another World, in which he does C5s and Bb4s.
      Also, Harry and Liam head voice G5s in the ';Come On' line of Never Enough.

    • @MarthaRose92
      @MarthaRose92 9 лет назад +14

      +Bey Xtina Minaj Agreed when the reality is Liam would've done those notes better. I saw them live in August and each time Liam took over a solo that was once a Zayn solo, it was one of the higher/falsetto ones and he did it with ease without copying Zayn's sound. Not that Harry copies Zayn, but Liam does that kind of solo with more ease

    • @brubarurno
      @brubarurno 9 лет назад +11

      Martha Redfield Liam is pretty bad belting over G4, falsetto is a much different matter.

    • @MarthaRose92
      @MarthaRose92 9 лет назад +1

      Bryce Flint Good point, good point

    • @ramondennis7604
      @ramondennis7604 9 лет назад +5

      +Martha Redfield it's obvious who is the best singer in the best and that's zayn, but he left so their quality has downgraded

  • @happily2480
    @happily2480 8 лет назад +179

    Louis's Range in Album: A2-B4
    Liam Range In Album: F#2-G5
    Niall Range In Album: F#2-Bb4
    Harry Range In Album: Bb2-C#5
    Niall did really improved! (2 octaves 2 notes 1 semi note)
    Liam did AMAZING on this album (3 octaves 1 note 1 semi note)
    Harry Did AWESOME on this album (2 octaves 1 note 2 semi notes)
    Louis did VERY WELL ON THIS ALBUM!
    (2 octaves 1 note)
    Impressive from the boys, keep the work!

    • @MultiKamil97
      @MultiKamil97 8 лет назад +9

      Happily Wow, I've got the same vocal range as Liam, I'm proud of myself :D

    • @happily2480
      @happily2480 8 лет назад +7

      Reply to +Nekros97
      That's impressive.
      Not many people can go up to 3 octaves.
      👏👏👏👏👏

    • @maia9557
      @maia9557 7 лет назад +1

      Happily 👏👏👏

    • @MultiKamil97
      @MultiKamil97 7 лет назад +4

      Happily Well, actually now I got to 4 octaves because I was working lately on whistle register and the highest I reached so far is A#6 :)

    • @ult7511
      @ult7511 6 лет назад +6

      Liam is a really great singer he knows his voice

  • @thegirlfromtv7050
    @thegirlfromtv7050 9 лет назад +102

    I was impressed with the Niall and Liam in Olivia and Louis' and Harry's high notes omg this album really shows how amazing their ranges are (even without Zayn)

  • @DannyMurilloHU
    @DannyMurilloHU 9 лет назад +80

    Liam was always good but he had to work x2 harder since Zayn left and it was worth it since his voice improved so much

    • @underratedartistes7730
      @underratedartistes7730 2 года назад +5

      Yes!!! His was voice always able to do that, he was just never given the chance. He was able hit notes and belt but was never given the part in 1D. 😔 You can see getting more opportuines singing in xfactor, before xfactor, live during 1d tours and his solo however, which is great!

  • @jacksanders3124
    @jacksanders3124 8 лет назад +100

    Great B4 from Louis. Want to see him go higher

  • @aileenlaude4996
    @aileenlaude4996 7 лет назад +65

    Am I the only one who's pissed that most of these songs were never performed live?

    • @nannymcphee5360
      @nannymcphee5360 5 лет назад +1

      ME TOO 😭😭😭😭

    • @JeffyPlaysRBLX
      @JeffyPlaysRBLX 6 месяцев назад +1

      Wished they could've just extended OTRA for 5 or 6 months so it'll end on January 2026 (almost the same time as their hiatus)

  • @MimiXtinaChelleKRow
    @MimiXtinaChelleKRow 9 лет назад +88

    i love Liam's F#2! that was really good!

  • @jleina6165
    @jleina6165 6 лет назад +67

    I NEED to hear Louis’ head voice

  • @luiggi853
    @luiggi853 9 лет назад +189

    0:44 Niall voice !! Not Liam >.

  • @knaxor
    @knaxor 9 лет назад +40

    No wonder I kept straining so hard and kept coming up flat on the note in Drag Me Down, it's a C5

    • @mirajanestrauss2472
      @mirajanestrauss2472 8 лет назад +5

      dont worry its really hard to hit that even harry is sustaining... i think liam and louis are the ones who's not sustaing when hitting high note

    • @MultiKamil97
      @MultiKamil97 7 лет назад +7

      Mirajane Strauss Harry definitely has a hard time hitting those notes because his head voice is not too good. He belts those notes with strain.

    • @mirajanestrauss2472
      @mirajanestrauss2472 7 лет назад

      Yah yah

    • @BlueberryCreature
      @BlueberryCreature 4 года назад

      @@MultiKamil97 he doesnt have a hard time hitting the drag me down note though but yeah, in the studio, they made his pitch higher

  • @grande1071
    @grande1071 8 лет назад +20

    HARRY'S BELTS!!!¡!!

  • @fosterniid5810
    @fosterniid5810 9 лет назад +57

    Liam voice is Perfect

  • @elizabethwillmore1766
    @elizabethwillmore1766 8 лет назад +49

    I love Louis voice

  • @Pandaxa00
    @Pandaxa00 8 лет назад +68

    Seems like people is freaking out in a bad way after hearing Harry's progress. When his voice still wasn't that developed he couldn't belt that high and now that his voice is deeper and darker he delivers this killer C#5😂 well, that's good! If he was destroying his voice don't you think someone would tell him? I think he was amazing on this album, but I think he can go lower, and Louis can go higher. But I think Louis needs to quit smoking because it's obvious his voice has deteriorated. I remember watching their cd of a concert I have and there Louis' voice is really strong and is actually the one that is heard the most when all of them sing, he needs to go back to that phase.
    Liam, when I listen to Liam all I say is 'wow' he's the one who holds the group because he's always harmonizing. His low notes are amazing, and so it's his falsetto.His belts are good.
    Niall, well they're giving him lots of low notes even though he's a tenor and it's working, I mean those long way down notes!!

    • @rollingapples6579
      @rollingapples6579 8 лет назад +4

      He can't execute the C#5 that well

    • @Pandaxa00
      @Pandaxa00 8 лет назад +3

      +Rolling Apples i know, he's probably never going to do it live but at least he did it on the studio, what kind of annoys me is that the 'fans' are always throwing shade at him, like chill everyone 😂 Is not like all of them have an impressive technique, but they always criticize Harry and praise Liam (cause he's perf), Niall and Louis.

    • @rollingapples6579
      @rollingapples6579 8 лет назад +3

      I don't blame him, I have a hard time getting past A4 😂

    • @Pandaxa00
      @Pandaxa00 8 лет назад +3

      +Rolling Apples yess, like they should be surprised he even hit that note

    • @rollingapples6579
      @rollingapples6579 8 лет назад +3

      Exactly.

  • @braedenburgard4329
    @braedenburgard4329 4 года назад +6

    Niall has some high notes on if I could fly. At the final chorus, in the backround, he sang “show you my heart” and “forget who you are”

  • @bismihamsa2054
    @bismihamsa2054 5 лет назад +11

    Louis nailed it in love you goodbye
    [G#4]

    • @adeladvorak04
      @adeladvorak04 3 года назад +3

      Right right he is very talented

  • @narla4356
    @narla4356 9 лет назад +40

    6:40 that's Harry

  • @1DerfulK-popWorld
    @1DerfulK-popWorld 4 года назад +8

    This one literally gave me goose bumps 05:48

  • @LB-ih7hn
    @LB-ih7hn 4 года назад +25

    Some of the notes assigned to Liam are wrong. However, from all the analysis it seems he has the widest range. I feel that he had limited opportunity to belt, but even when he had belting solos, during live performances he favoured his head voice or falsetto instead. Which is actually quite smart, since 1D had so many live tour performances. I think that saved his voice quite a lot. But now in his solo career, he’s shown that he can actually belt. I really think he’s underrated.

    • @AS-yz2iz
      @AS-yz2iz 3 года назад +2

      The If I Could Fly notes were Harry not Liam.

  • @brubarurno
    @brubarurno 9 лет назад +6

    If you listen closely in Drag Me Down, before the chorus breakdown (and Harry's C5s) there's a really buried in the mix clip of Liam singing the melody line an octave down bottoming at C2 "nobody can drag me *DOWN*". You have to keep your hearing as sharp as possible. (2:22 in the YT video)

    • @brubarurno
      @brubarurno 8 лет назад

      +Hussam Seif Al Deen You're free to listen as many times as you want. Go to the timestamp I provided and listen as sharply as you're able to. Buried beneath the main vocal line and the first lower octave unisone (Niall and Liam) lies yet another one on the second octave which tracks down to a C2 (nobody can drag me *down*)

    • @brubarurno
      @brubarurno 8 лет назад +1

      ***** I might try to isolate the channel with the C2 when I have the chance. But yes, it's really hard to pick up.

  • @Brooksicles2.0
    @Brooksicles2.0 6 лет назад +11

    The 'I'm missing half of me' is Harry

    • @AS-yz2iz
      @AS-yz2iz 3 года назад +1

      Yes! He needs the credit for that beautiful falsetto.

  • @natalvarado6319
    @natalvarado6319 7 лет назад +10

    Slays legends ❤

  • @lloyd_joshua
    @lloyd_joshua 4 года назад +5

    i believe Louis can further stretch his range... overall they did well on this album defo my fave from them!

  • @arriannevalderrama4238
    @arriannevalderrama4238 7 лет назад +9

    The A2 in Long Way Down was Niall, not Liam.

  • @CaloiEmrys369
    @CaloiEmrys369 5 лет назад +13

    6:26 sounds like a mix of Liam and Harry at the start

  • @tushh7506
    @tushh7506 4 года назад +3

    They did more belts in this album than four when till four only zayn was the one belting but they Zayn has always been my favourite but they proved they ain't less than him especially harry being a baritone nd belting c5s is not easy as it sounds

  • @natalvarado6319
    @natalvarado6319 7 лет назад +4

    Kings talented

  • @AS-yz2iz
    @AS-yz2iz 3 года назад +6

    That falsetto in If I Could Fly was Harry, not Liam!

  • @cinnamonhes8996
    @cinnamonhes8996 8 лет назад +2

    thank you for making this video it's great.

  • @ScarlettChinchilla23
    @ScarlettChinchilla23 8 лет назад +4

    I love your vocal range videos! especially for 1D and Little Mix. Would you mind making vocal range videos for all the members of 1D, as well as all their albums, and a group vocal range (similar to what you've done for Little Mix). Thank you!

  • @user-wi1od1fp7d
    @user-wi1od1fp7d 9 лет назад +12

    the a4 at 6:38 is for Harry haha

  • @eldonmati
    @eldonmati 9 лет назад +4

    I didn't really want to listen to this album but after this I feel real curious

  • @HOSHTASTIC
    @HOSHTASTIC 8 лет назад +4

    i think a4 in if i could fly sings harry.

  • @Brookiecookie2004
    @Brookiecookie2004 8 лет назад +1

    ...when you hear zayn in home..... im cutting onions...

  • @juanhoffmann4096
    @juanhoffmann4096 4 года назад +6

    Liam’s A4 wasn’t him it was Harry

  • @charlottebridgettes8340
    @charlottebridgettes8340 9 лет назад +49

    in terms of their vocal abilities in this fantastic album:
    1st: liam (grt voice, solid low notes, and nice head voice, but his G5 in head voice is quite strained in my opinion, and he needs to brush up on his belts!!!)
    2nd: harry (he has a very grt voice too but he's low notes and head voice wasnt as good as liam but he has a good belting voice)
    3rd: Louis (i love his voice this time round. belts and low notes are nice but imo, not as vocally strong as both harry and liam)
    4th: niall (WHAT HAPPENED NIALL!!!??? I'm actually disappointed that niall doesn't shine alot in this album. not much of his vocals are showcased :( i hope that he can do more in the next album)
    this is my opinion so don't be angry if I've mentioned something rude or offensive or wrong bcoz im new to this

    • @eldonmati
      @eldonmati 9 лет назад +3

      +Charlotte Bridgettes (ShuHui) Harry's low notes are weak while his belting notes are powerful because he's a natural tenor

    • @brubarurno
      @brubarurno 8 лет назад +3

      Head voice is not falsetto, head voice is connected, falsetto is disconnected.

    • @eldonmati
      @eldonmati 8 лет назад

      Bryce Flint did anybody say they were the same?

    • @brubarurno
      @brubarurno 8 лет назад

      Steven Matthews Harry is a high baritone.

    • @MonicaRubio
      @MonicaRubio 8 лет назад

      +Hussam Seif Al Deen i don't think it's hard for him to belt above G#4, I just don't think he particularly wants to... he loves hitting notes and being precise a lot. but he needs a proper vocal coach to teach to let go a bit. being a baritone isn't exactly why either lol

  • @gabrielmelo844
    @gabrielmelo844 5 лет назад +5

    6:38 this is harry's voice not liam!!

  • @santiagoabell3388
    @santiagoabell3388 4 года назад +1

    Harry is wass wow

  • @sihaamahmed7451
    @sihaamahmed7451 6 лет назад +4

    6:38 Thats harry not liam

  • @brubarurno
    @brubarurno 9 лет назад +1

    The G5s in 'come on' during the song Never Enough and Liam and somebody else

    • @KrystalLovesCupcakes
      @KrystalLovesCupcakes 9 лет назад +6

      the "come on" is just Liam, he said it in an interview

    • @brubarurno
      @brubarurno 9 лет назад +1

      Josselyn Krystal The line is obviously multitracked, it's entirely possible that it's someone else like Niall who tracked the line aswell, i insist its harry and liam. The falsetto doodling is just Liam though

    • @tyska10
      @tyska10 8 лет назад +1

      +Bryce Flint (Terramt) It was by Liam and Julian not Harry :) they said it in one interview i think

    • @brubarurno
      @brubarurno 8 лет назад

      Justyna J. Link?

    • @tyska10
      @tyska10 8 лет назад +1

      I haven't got link, but i check twitter and it's from updates account. And my fault, not Julian, John. "According to Julian Bunetta, the shouts on 'Never Enough' are from Liam and John. "

  • @annabethchase7935
    @annabethchase7935 8 лет назад

    I can sing as low as C3 but higher than G5... I love their voices!!

  • @craftingmausXd
    @craftingmausXd 2 месяца назад

    I Am Lyric Bass-Baritone Bb1-G3-F#4

  • @EdJeong-p8c
    @EdJeong-p8c Месяц назад

    Louis: Good lows and upper chest notes, but non-existent falsetto or head mix
    Zayn: Good lows and spectacular upper chest and head or falsetto notes, but poor jaw syllable support on mixed register
    Liam: Ok, lows and amazing head and falsetto notes, way too raspy upper chest notes
    Niall: Amazing lows and good upper chest notes, show me his falsetto because I can hear it sometimes but I want to see his falsetto as a solo
    Harry: Good lows and vocal emotion showing, really poor support on upper chest notes and strained jaw tension on high belts

  • @andrecamila4176
    @andrecamila4176 8 лет назад +3

    In 5:17 is it really Louis. I think it is but I looked for the lyrics and they give the credit to Harry

    • @lexis223
      @lexis223 8 лет назад +5

      it's Liam and Louis is singing in the higher voice

    • @CaloiEmrys369
      @CaloiEmrys369 5 лет назад

      Liam does the backing vocal for it to

  • @carolbrito3447
    @carolbrito3447 6 лет назад +2

    6:39 it was Harry not Liam

  • @MelissaNgai
    @MelissaNgai 8 лет назад

    I love your videos. Great job!

  • @lieparom.120
    @lieparom.120 8 лет назад +7

    0:36 that's Niall's!

    • @reboyamamisaka8387
      @reboyamamisaka8387 8 лет назад

      I don't think so. I think Liam harmonize. cuz Niall's voice doesn't sound so warm.

    • @lieparom.120
      @lieparom.120 8 лет назад +2

      I mean.. I'm quite long in this fandom and I know how their voices sound. I know this is Niall. If you don't believe me, check the lyrics where are written who's singing

    • @reboyamamisaka8387
      @reboyamamisaka8387 8 лет назад

      +Liepa Rom. the lyrics doesn't tell you who harmonize.

    • @reboyamamisaka8387
      @reboyamamisaka8387 8 лет назад

      Liam always harmonize other's parts.

    • @lieparom.120
      @lieparom.120 8 лет назад

      I mean I know their voices too good to mix them up, so.. I know that's Niall :)

  • @adrianyu-chenchou8198
    @adrianyu-chenchou8198 4 года назад +2

    One direction songs are quite challenging for male LOL have to be able to hit at least a4...and a4 is not an easy note for guys haha

    • @kylah7637
      @kylah7637 4 года назад

      Adrian Yeah that's facts, i agree with you

    • @kylah7637
      @kylah7637 4 года назад

      Well, i love 1D they will always be the best boyband in the world with a lot of talent and qualities.

    • @adrianyu-chenchou8198
      @adrianyu-chenchou8198 4 года назад

      Turkish Serial yes. Listen to them a lot back when their together. Love to sing theirs songs LOL

  • @charlottebridgettes8340
    @charlottebridgettes8340 9 лет назад +3

    if im not wrong...
    liam : f#2-Bb4-G5
    niall : f#2-Bb4
    harry : Bb2-C#5
    Louis: A2-B4

    • @charlottebridgettes8340
      @charlottebridgettes8340 9 лет назад +3

      but i consider niall's f#2 as a vocal fry bcoz if u compared his to liam's, it sound so different tbh

    • @mirajanestrauss2472
      @mirajanestrauss2472 8 лет назад

      lol louis can hit C5 above without sustaining.

    • @reboyamamisaka8387
      @reboyamamisaka8387 8 лет назад

      You are wrong.

    • @verutorres9946
      @verutorres9946 8 лет назад +5

      +Savannah Banana liam has wilder range harry Is 2 octaves and 3 notes Liam Is 3 octaves and 5 notes ...

  • @ttiagobarbosa2011
    @ttiagobarbosa2011 8 лет назад

    Can you do a Live version from 2015? Please

  • @chloee3105
    @chloee3105 6 лет назад +1

    Liams a2 was niall i think

  • @mirajanestrauss2472
    @mirajanestrauss2472 8 лет назад +56

    This is my list in my opinion: (In this album)
    1.Liam- Im not surprised, his falsetto really helping the band to make a good performance, and those harmony too. I dont need to explain anymore his vocal is really great.
    2.Louis- His voice really improve from the past album. His high-pitched voice is really good to hear(especially in I want to write you a song) His C#5 in love you goodbye.
    3.Niall- He improved too. His vocal range became wide like louis. He does falsetto too to harmonize.
    4.Harry- I put him last because his voice changed.He always sustaining when hitting high note or more like shouting, it might destroyed his vocal. and he can't control his breathing properly not like before...

    • @brubarurno
      @brubarurno 8 лет назад +2

      There's no C#5 in love you goodbye. Highest he goes is G#4 in that song.

    • @mirajanestrauss2472
      @mirajanestrauss2472 8 лет назад +1

      +Bryce Flint (Terramt) G#4? nope i dont think so..his C5 in rock me and A4 in over again and moments :)

    • @brubarurno
      @brubarurno 8 лет назад +3

      Mirajane Strauss And? That doesn't mean anything. Love you goodbye tops G#4. His highest belt in Made In The A.M. is in End of the Day. If I'm not wrong it's a B4. Then there's some really good C5s in Alive.

    • @mirajanestrauss2472
      @mirajanestrauss2472 8 лет назад +1

      +Bryce Flint (Terramt) ikr but still he is underrated😭😭😭😭

    • @brubarurno
      @brubarurno 8 лет назад +3

      Mirajane Strauss He's alright. Pretty good in the studio. I'd just like him to be a little more consistent live.

  • @idkwtfimdoin
    @idkwtfimdoin 8 лет назад +11

    6:37-6:40 Is Harry, not Liam

  • @jessicacall5262
    @jessicacall5262 2 года назад +3

    on another note, harry's timbre tho. incomparable

  • @craftingmausXd
    @craftingmausXd 8 месяцев назад

    4:28 a mix of harry styles and liam payne
    Larriam stayne 😢

  • @valentinriospatino7893
    @valentinriospatino7893 8 лет назад

    in drag me down the high note is b4 not c5

  • @abrahamdeleon1578
    @abrahamdeleon1578 7 лет назад +1

    What's the song at 4:28, that sounds really pleasing to my ear. Thank you

  • @marklacson5968
    @marklacson5968 6 лет назад

    0:39-0:46 its niall

  • @macca1861
    @macca1861 7 лет назад

    A2 on long way down is Niall not Liam

  • @oliverbautista5792
    @oliverbautista5792 7 лет назад +3

    what's the name of that song: 3:40

    • @melody_1111
      @melody_1111 7 лет назад

      Oliver Bautista long way down

  • @kendalljenner4433
    @kendalljenner4433 3 года назад

    i done wrong....nial voice to liam

  • @thunderhartopp5143
    @thunderhartopp5143 4 года назад +3

    6:53 what song

  • @happily2480
    @happily2480 8 лет назад +3

    Is it bad I can hit a C7?

    • @juliana20oneyzacheu67
      @juliana20oneyzacheu67 8 лет назад +2

      one Juilana louis Lima Niállho Harry zayn? ???????Juilana? ??????20????????😘😘😘😘💋💋💋💋💋❤❤❤❤❤💞💞💞💞💘💘

    • @emptytoiletpaperroll9112
      @emptytoiletpaperroll9112 7 лет назад +1

      Happily ~ Yea, It'll damage your voice if you do it alot.

    • @adeladvorak04
      @adeladvorak04 3 года назад

      @@emptytoiletpaperroll9112 and what about singers 😂

    • @emptytoiletpaperroll9112
      @emptytoiletpaperroll9112 3 года назад

      @@adeladvorak04 Well, hello, I got a reply after 3 years.. honestly I forgot I even commented that, so if you'd mind I have to go and.. eat some ice cream

  • @dhy1011timtams
    @dhy1011timtams 8 лет назад +2

    I'm a girl and I can hit A2. Is it normal? Also, my mom can hit the F#2.

    • @DJEDJUNIOR
      @DJEDJUNIOR 8 лет назад

      i'm a boy and i can't hit a f#2, only a2

    • @thethinkinlad
      @thethinkinlad 8 лет назад +1

      It's not normal unless it's a vocal fry. And I think it is. Don't do it too much or you'll get a sore throat.

    • @DJEDJUNIOR
      @DJEDJUNIOR 8 лет назад

      +Random Selenator in my case, i have to stop to do the whistle register

    • @artsenal714
      @artsenal714 7 лет назад

      FookinLarrie it's normal. Not many women can access to the second octave but is not impossible. Some of the females singers that can sing in the second octave are Jesy from little mix, Selena Gomez, Miley Cyrus, Lana del Rey, Beyonce and Mariah Carey.

    • @justsomeonedifferent6616
      @justsomeonedifferent6616 6 лет назад

      Depending on your voice type is could be very normal. If you're a Soprano it's a little harder and rarer to get into the second octave. If you're a mezzo, then it's very normal. All the mezzo's I know about can access it. Contralto has a good chance as well. Mariah Carey was hitting Eb2, Beyoncé hitting F2, Selena hitting Bb2, Jesy httinng B2, Miley hitting E2. Really good notes.

  • @emiliairheart
    @emiliairheart 3 года назад

    0:36 - 0:46 is niall, not liam :)

  • @Brooksicles2.0
    @Brooksicles2.0 6 лет назад +1

    A2 isn't Liam it's Niall

  • @MelissaNgai
    @MelissaNgai 8 лет назад +3

    0:37 I always thought that was Niall singing. Welp, I guess I'm not a true Directioner oh dear God....

  • @ubaipre-picture0983
    @ubaipre-picture0983 8 лет назад +1

    Soo who has the least to widest vocal range??

  • @jadepercival2287
    @jadepercival2287 5 лет назад +6

    right so basically, 0:36 was niall, not liam, and 6:37 was harry, not liam ksjdkfksdj

    • @AS-yz2iz
      @AS-yz2iz 3 года назад

      Yup. Give credit where credit it due.

  • @JonasEurich
    @JonasEurich 7 лет назад

    Hahahah long way down those notes weren’t Liam’s HAHAHAHAHAH they were nialls

  • @juanhoffmann4096
    @juanhoffmann4096 4 года назад

    At least put the Bb4 right

  • @mohammedimaz3879
    @mohammedimaz3879 6 лет назад +5

    Harry is a baritone i'm shocked he can belt a C5 .... Liam is also a baritone but his belting limit is only up to G4 he can't even hit an A4 clearly

    • @prefernoto4788
      @prefernoto4788 5 лет назад

      true harry a full lyric or lyrical spinto

    • @LB-ih7hn
      @LB-ih7hn 4 года назад +2

      Harry strained his voice a lot by belting. Liam actually has the widest range and he actually belts in his solo songs. Which leads me to believe that it was a choice to favour his falsetto over belts. It was actually quite smart considering how many live performances they had and also considering he sang the most harmonies and backing. He really preserved his voice that way.

  • @Brooksicles2.0
    @Brooksicles2.0 6 лет назад +1

    Somr of these are the wrong person

  • @redgxms
    @redgxms 3 года назад

    Louis could go waaaay higher. In the documentary he jokingly goes reaaaaly high and I never see anyone talk about that! (around 24 minutes if you want to look it up)

  • @ramondennis7604
    @ramondennis7604 9 лет назад +5

    their high notes have lost quality since Zayn left

    • @littlethirlwall3551
      @littlethirlwall3551 8 лет назад +12

      Liam high note in live for You and I are pretty good

    • @LB-ih7hn
      @LB-ih7hn 4 года назад +2

      Liam’s high notes are of excellent quality. I just think people got use to just hearing Zayn’s high notes.

  • @higorleomota
    @higorleomota 9 лет назад +12

    They are good, but zayn was The voice of the Group