Kruglov is certainly poised to follow in the footsteps of the great oktavists like Miller, Wishniakov, and Pasjukov. What a wonderful voice and resonance. Just when you thought he couldn't possibly sing lower than that he pulls out some truely astonishing low notes. Also, the fact that these men can sing these notes in full voice, without a microphone, and at a volume level consistent with the rest of the choir puts them on a level that american folk/gospel singers just can't touch!
not only is he awesome, but his ear is impeccable. it's hard to be that accurate on notes that are that hard to hit, especially with large interval jumps.
This guy makes my throat hurt. My range covers the Verdi Baritone and Dramatic Bass-Baritone and on into the bass range. I feel like I sound a sopranist compared to this guy. Seriously, I wish I had a voice like that. We need more Oktavists.
I think he's got a while to wait yet, until he gets a bit older. The basic instrument is certainly there, and he is training it, but he is still a bit of a growler in the lowest register, while Miller and Pasyukov have/had the real 'boom'. Give it ten years...age and practice will do it
He is doing this in a bit higher key than the average . . . he seems to have the roundness of Miller, but his darker timbre is slightly reminiscent of Pasuikov (as his interpretation of the high point of this piece). Can't wait until his voice ages a little more, and his lower range settles and gains power. It's so nice to know there are more profondos coming to the fore . . .
It's not as much a height thing as it is a neck and chest thing. A long, wide neck provides more room for the vocal cords to grow. Take a guy like me. I'm only 5'8, but I've got an unusually wide and long neck, giving me a rather deeper than average voice. Not an Oktavist or basso profondo voice, but not a tenor, though my comfortable tessitura does include it. Though, to be fair, I'm more of an exception than the rule. Height is not a factor, but an enabler. I'm a bigger guy, to be sure.
its longer thicker vocal chords in men ....usually because they were exposed to more testosterone.....the longer and thicker male chords are the more they will be like this its genetic ...voices sound different country to country ....russians even women have much darker voices ....i dunno if its genetic or because of how they grow up speaking its almost universally true though....
Добрый день. Только две. Эта и "12 разбойников" Запись делала регент Русского собора Нью-Йорка, дочь Вадима Афанасьева. Дирижера концерта. ruclips.net/video/27UP3NEFMKY/видео.html
@HMW Actually stereotipes ARE true - a kind of collective "wisdom"... But on a shallow level. They do not satisfy exceptional cases. They are a simplification of real life.
Михаил поет в церковном хоре уже два десятка лет. Вы точно уверены, что он "не понимает"? Думаю, дело в другом. У вас есть какое-то "идеальное" исполнение чисто для вас, и эта версия ему не соответствует. Что и побудило вас оставить комментарий.
Согласен. Он, кстати на него похож. Но лучше всех Владимир Пасюков. Его голос глубже и нет ни единого намёка на напряжение во время пения. Можно сравнить Это замечательное произведение Чеснокова пели Пасюков, Миллер, Вишняков, Круглов. Очень бесит, когда пишут, что у Пасюкова нижние ноты - штробас. Ересь паршивая. Они потрясающи и полноценны.
Kruglov is certainly poised to follow in the footsteps of the great oktavists like Miller, Wishniakov, and Pasjukov. What a wonderful voice and resonance. Just when you thought he couldn't possibly sing lower than that he pulls out some truely astonishing low notes. Also, the fact that these men can sing these notes in full voice, without a microphone, and at a volume level consistent with the rest of the choir puts them on a level that american folk/gospel singers just can't touch!
He's almost in the same category as Vladimir Pasulkov, Vladimir Miller, and myself. He may get stronger in later years.
Eric!
Духовная музыка русских композиторов - это и душевная музыка. Очень нравится Чесноков, особенно его 140 псалом. Хор знаменитый. Спасибо.
He will age like a fine wine
not only is he awesome, but his ear is impeccable. it's hard to be that accurate on notes that are that hard to hit, especially with large interval jumps.
Wow! Considering the distance of the camera mic his volume must have been very strong!
Vladimir Pasjukov no 1!
Fantastic performance of this piece.
Great performance!
This guy makes my throat hurt. My range covers the Verdi Baritone and Dramatic Bass-Baritone and on into the bass range.
I feel like I sound a sopranist compared to this guy.
Seriously, I wish I had a voice like that.
We need more Oktavists.
I think he's got a while to wait yet, until he gets a bit older. The basic instrument is certainly there, and he is training it, but he is still a bit of a growler in the lowest register, while Miller and Pasyukov have/had the real 'boom'. Give it ten years...age and practice will do it
Incrível, voz poderosa.
Conheci esse cantor hj, já estou fazendo campanha pra ele colocar legendas nos videos.
Com legenda, fica mais fácil divulgar esse talento.
Beebeltä terverveisiä:ihanaa pyhäpäivän musiikkia.
+MATTI MELA Fantastista.
He is doing this in a bit higher key than the average . . . he seems to have the roundness of Miller, but his darker timbre is slightly reminiscent of Pasuikov (as his interpretation of the high point of this piece). Can't wait until his voice ages a little more, and his lower range settles and gains power.
It's so nice to know there are more profondos coming to the fore . . .
@RAAMerisima I am American Basso Profundo Eric H Hollaway Sr.
Nothing like kargyraa is at work here--this is plain, straightforward singing.
I prefer Kruglov's voice to Miller's. No disrespect to him though. Great performance.
Indeed. It is the size of your instrument that matters (vocal chords).
Дирижор дёрганный. Солист достойный.
Нормальный дирижер
It's not as much a height thing as it is a neck and chest thing. A long, wide neck provides more room for the vocal cords to grow. Take a guy like me. I'm only 5'8, but I've got an unusually wide and long neck, giving me a rather deeper than average voice. Not an Oktavist or basso profondo voice, but not a tenor, though my comfortable tessitura does include it. Though, to be fair, I'm more of an exception than the rule. Height is not a factor, but an enabler. I'm a bigger guy, to be sure.
its longer thicker vocal chords in men ....usually because they were exposed to more testosterone.....the longer and thicker male chords are the more they will be like this its genetic ...voices sound different country to country ....russians even women have much darker voices ....i dunno if its genetic or because of how they grow up speaking its almost universally true though....
can anyone say how closely this technique is related to kargyraa style of singing?
those other guys sound liek girls compare to the basso profondo guy
@OlDoinyo Me neither :(... Sniff!
Хрипатый тоже голос. Звук, принудительным. Он нуждается для отдыха и позволить голосу могут вибрировать тканей.
@babydrane Thanks! I love youtube!
Eu achava que era baixo.Estava iludido kkkkk
Is that a G1 you sing at 4:32? I can't quite make it out, as it is kind of pianissimo.
That’s C2, the G1 come a little bit after on the sheet, he doesn’t go to G1 in the recording unfortunately
Добрый день. А у Вас, случайно, нет ещё записей этого концерта?
Добрый день. Только две. Эта и "12 разбойников" Запись делала регент Русского собора Нью-Йорка, дочь Вадима Афанасьева. Дирижера концерта. ruclips.net/video/27UP3NEFMKY/видео.html
@thepoetician And who are you? If I might ask?
Peter Steele if he were oktavist!
No.
Peter Steele=Bass-baritone.
@@kleberrobertodossantos6825I said..."If he were..."
Words..mean..things...
@HMW
Actually stereotipes ARE true - a kind of collective "wisdom"... But on a shallow level. They do not satisfy exceptional cases. They are a simplification of real life.
Mike Tyson, enough said
Не понимает, о чём поёт. Совсем. Поёт. Молодец. Музыка гениальная. Дирижёр тоже тонкости происходящего в музыке не осознаёт.
Михаил поет в церковном хоре уже два десятка лет. Вы точно уверены, что он "не понимает"? Думаю, дело в другом. У вас есть какое-то "идеальное" исполнение чисто для вас, и эта версия ему не соответствует. Что и побудило вас оставить комментарий.
С микрофон пел он?
В духе Миллера, но с Пасюковым не сравнить
ruclips.net/video/5drXD_6UVus/видео.html
Качество записи отвратительное
Vladimir Miller is better...:D....but this guy is good too O_O....
Согласен.
Он, кстати на него похож.
Но лучше всех Владимир Пасюков.
Его голос глубже и нет ни единого намёка на напряжение во время пения.
Можно сравнить
Это замечательное произведение Чеснокова пели
Пасюков, Миллер, Вишняков, Круглов.
Очень бесит, когда пишут, что у Пасюкова
нижние ноты - штробас. Ересь паршивая.
Они потрясающи и полноценны.