red velvet’s vocals aren’t superior, all members of aespa are better than more than half of rv they have wendy who is amazing and seulgi who is average but as a group aespa is better
@@ultraviolet9284 seulgi is average in the vocal ranking, she’s mid a that doesn’t mean she’s bad she’s really amazing, but that’s what the tier is called
@@rubyrosem9693 sure, but my point is wendy is a beast, seulgi is average IN VOCAL TIERS, which doesn’t mean she is the average vocalist, joy is at the level of a below average lead vocalist from 3rd gen, irene and yeri are at the average level of a sub-vocalist while all of aespa is at lead or main vocalist level, so aespa AS A GROUP is better than rv
@@whytwokei she is, although karina & giselle are both on the same vocal tier, giselle is d+/c- whereas karina is d+. giselle’s bb4s are also better than karina’s.
@@viem2402 wayy better lol. all giselle has to do is work on her shallowness and have more b4's to her name then she'll be moving up the tiers like its nothing. she's supported an e5 in hv once, the potential is very much there.
@@JustLynny that's why i can'z stand solo fans. They think their fav is perfect from all sides. In fact i do stan aespa equally and I hope Sm let them show their potential. Sm should change their promotion strategy if not these successful groups wil fall down .
Aespa has a toooon of vocal potential and talent already, they’re gonna be crazy in the future. I’ve always felt that Red Velvet’s greatest strength vocally is how distinctive their voices are and how good they sound together, although Wendy and Seulgi certainly aren’t slacking individually
The gap between members in RV is too big and Wendy mostly carries the group (sometimes Seulgi does too). Aespa is more well balanced group imo. So if i have to make comparison As group = Aespa > RV As solo = Wendy > Ning > Seulgi > Winter
What's the gap? Have you ever seen them sing a cappella? All members of RV sing well, and Wendy is the best vocalist of her generation. They are also known for their amazing harmonization. aespa delulus
*ning > seulgi.* ningning is more well-rounded, hence why we consider her average to above average [c+]. she has better agility than seulgi, her projection in all registers is better than seulgi, her lower register is better than seulgi, her head voice [ though not consistent ] is still better than seulgi's. even small things like vibrato, ning is better than seulgi. so they are not on the same rank at all. seulgi at times has a better mid-register, and her belts sound richer since ningning is light, but that's about it, and based on whether you like lighter voices or not. it's actually seulgi and winter who are interchangeable, both are high average and have similar difficulties as vocalists.
@@selenesaint thank you, i edited that. I separated Ning and Seulgi so i put comma (,). Yes Ning is better in almost all categories : Lows, runs, and upper head registers + round vibrato. Ning sounds light bcs she always feels unsure and hesitant to belt even tho i know she can do it so that's why the composers give belting part to Winter.
1. Wendy mid P 2. Ningning low AA 3. Seulgi high A 4. Winter mid A 5. Karina high W-A 6. Giselle high W-A 7. Joy mid W No support 8. Irene very high U 9. Yeri high U If I includes all sm gg since snsd 1. Luna mid P-G 2. Wendy mid P 3. Taeyeon mid P 4. Ningning low AA 5. Seohyun mid A-AA 6. Jessica mid A-AA 7. Seulgi high A 8. Tiffany mid A 9. Sunny mid A 10. Winter mid A 11. Karina high W-A 12. Giselle high W-A 13. Krystal mid W-A 14. Amber mid W-A 15. Yuri high W 16. Sooyoung high W 17. Joy mid W 18. Irene very high U 19. Sulli very high U 20. Yeri high U 21. Hyoyeon high U 22. Yoona high U 23. Victoria U
@@redloona1085No. Her nasality constantly puts her in rough position when singing. She's not even high average, there's no way. She's just C for now.
Honestly aespa is like package i mean winter and ningning they are good but karina and giselle being rapper they slayed . Like gigi has hidden vocals black mamba . Sm should explore them more !!
Yeah that true, in Red velvet just wendy & seulgi can sing in better way in live vocals 👌🏻, and Aespa have more potential in all member that they can actually 'sing' live performer
I love both groups one of my favs and even though wendy is not my bias in rv shes 3rd (i still lover her ) i have to say that shes very talented an ace That girl has rap vocals dance and visuals
support ≠ singing rankings. you can't rank singing off of ONE element. that's stupid. other than that, music is an art - you need to have style in mind. it's impossible to compare two singers with very different stylistic choices.
@@kokolawson4794 exactly ! and even within technique, there are lots of factors. you can't just state that someone is a better singer because they support 3 more notes. i feel like kids these days are so formatted in school that they cannot understand the concept of not being able to grade something. for example, joy from red velvet and giselle from aespa have VERY different techniques and styles. joy lifts her soft palate, and shifts the sound to her nasal cavity - in the other hand, giselle has a more airy approach. can you objectively say 'x is better than x'? NO. you can only give your OPINION, since to rank them both, you need to have your own set of standards. someone may think that projection is more important than nasality, and consider x better. another person can consider support more importaant than tone, and consider x better than x. agreed with you.
Yes, these vocal tier rankings are dogshit because they're literally only about breath support. As much as they seem like interesting little tidbits, there's way much more to singing than just this. If you have better support than someone else it doesn't mean you're a better singer than them, you can't take these rankings and run with them. No one with a brain will argue Minnie is a shitty singer because she has F+ support. You can't ignore everything else about her singing.
@@harveyism that's incorrect. the ranking system that kpop stans started using all of a sudden only takes in account support, and not just support.. but 'supported range', a very unusual and weird concept, which, as a flute player and singer, i had never heard of. singing isn't always about supporting notes, someone's objective might be a stylistic approach.. this is POP singing. these rankings don't take in account any other technicalities other than 'support', and even that is quite shaky, with some people who have no music degree or knowledge saying 'oh, that's supported, you can just hear it, you'll eventually know how to distinguish support from non-support！'... by that, i mean : singing is objective, as in, there are things that could make someone a better singer overall, BUT, it's still an art, and therefore subjective, which means different people can look at different singers and consider one 'better', based off their own subjective standards, since it comes a point where two singers have very different techniques, strenghts and flaws, therefore, only subjectivity can deem the better one. support is NOT the most important thing in singing. you cannot make a subjective statement and try to frame it as the truth.
@@healing4052bruh first of all she doesn't even look like rosé🙄 and just because a single person said they look similar doesn't mean they actually look similar 🙄
Me da coraje que comparen a estos dos grupos, porque comparan con un grupo de chicas ya con una buena carrera formada con uno que es principiante por así decirlo
Uh, my opinion, which might be close to facts if I'm not sure, this is not my feeling, it's from what I observed. 9. Yeri 8. Irene 7. Giselle 6. Karina 5. Joy 4. Winter 3. Ningning 2. Seulgi 1. Wendy
Aespa have more powerful and strong voice, Red velvet have more cute and gentle voices💖 Ning ning needs to win. Her vocals are perfect and winter on second!❤
Not true. Aespa seemed “stronger” only bcos of the concept SM gave them. Red velvet is not cute and gentle, they are more versatile and also bcos of the concept SM has given them
literally. seulgi is an underwhelming vocalist when in comparison to wendy. she's not shallow.. but some of her faults are stuff you'd expect in w-a vocalists. forced vibrato, poor agility, nasality in the 4th octave... @@Robalexe
@@dmndmnans1441 what are you talking about? Ningning is stated to be a ^C+, but not actually close to be B-. Haewon is stated to be B-, while Lily is ^B-, and Winter has a gap with Yunjin but their both C, but ig Winter could be ^C, and what even are you talking bout realistic, and what more realistic do u even want my ranking to be??
She literally has one of the prettiest and most distinct vocal tones in kpop. Will never understand the English speaking side of kpop rating Wendy of all singers higher
I saw a lot of people saying Giselle is better than karina because she can support better than karina. But let me tell you both their support range ends in b4. Also about getting more lines i admit Giselle has more freedom in her head voice but it's not like she sings like an opera singer in her head voice. On top of that her mix is not developed enough she sounds shallow. But on the other hand karina's main power is her mix which is fairly developed she doesn't sound shallow. She sound pushy while going up in the 5th octave. But her mix allows her to sing many styles with ease the reason why she gets many lines. And singing is not just about support.
also how is giselle d+/c? you can't be two tiers at once. giselle is still shallow, and therefore d+. she's c- at best, and her shallowness is too consistent to be considered average.
Man I don't know how but WENDY FASCINATES WITH THIS VOCAL! wonderful
One of the best vocalists of third gen gg imo. Her and mamamoo powerhouse.
Red velvet vocal is superior. But aespa is more potential. aespa is a complete vocal package. They need more experiance.
red velvet’s vocals aren’t superior, all members of aespa are better than more than half of rv
they have wendy who is amazing and seulgi who is average but as a group aespa is better
@@miam_k I'm MY and to say Seulgi is average? Omg💀🧐
@@ultraviolet9284 seulgi is average in the vocal ranking, she’s mid a
that doesn’t mean she’s bad she’s really amazing, but that’s what the tier is called
@@miam_k Seulgi could easily be main vocal anywhere else. The sole reason she isn't is because Wendy exists.
@@rubyrosem9693 sure, but my point is wendy is a beast, seulgi is average IN VOCAL TIERS, which doesn’t mean she is the average vocalist, joy is at the level of a below average lead vocalist from 3rd gen, irene and yeri are at the average level of a sub-vocalist
while all of aespa is at lead or main vocalist level, so aespa AS A GROUP is better than rv
At last The mix of ningning and wendy is amazing
Remember that Aespa is the ONLY SM artist that all members have support ranges. It's only them and Nmixx have that capability in 4th Generation.
TVXQ, The grace ,fly to the sky
지랄을 한다
외퀴도 한 막귀하는구나
4thgen @@عمرعلى-و8غ
Red velvet is better
@@EarthUwU yeah
even Giselle aespa main rapper was a part of a choir. And I must say she is a better vocalist than Karina, SM just font give her nore lines
yeah maybe
yep, she is a better vocalist than karina
what??? no
@@whytwokei she is, although karina & giselle are both on the same vocal tier, giselle is d+/c- whereas karina is d+. giselle’s bb4s are also better than karina’s.
@@viem2402 wayy better lol. all giselle has to do is work on her shallowness and have more b4's to her name then she'll be moving up the tiers like its nothing. she's supported an e5 in hv once, the potential is very much there.
I even got goosebumps at Wendy's vocals, queen!!!
Giselle vocals>Karina vocals
In my opinion
Its a fact actually
@@minarisan4777 It really is but honestly, if I say it's a fact then Karina fans will get mad
@@JustLynny that's why i can'z stand solo fans. They think their fav is perfect from all sides. In fact i do stan aespa equally and I hope Sm let them show their potential. Sm should change their promotion strategy if not these successful groups wil fall down .
@@minarisan4777 I completely agree with everything you said 💕 sm really needs to be more considerate and understand their idols more.
right
Wendy is right now the best singer in kpop industry
Aespa has a toooon of vocal potential and talent already, they’re gonna be crazy in the future. I’ve always felt that Red Velvet’s greatest strength vocally is how distinctive their voices are and how good they sound together, although Wendy and Seulgi certainly aren’t slacking individually
Karina Giselle deep voices are boring...joy Irene angelic voices 🤩
Pantes Giselle rap nya high note😅
9- Yeri ( F )
8- Irene ( F+ )
7- Joy ( D- )
6- Karina ( D + )
5- Giselle ( D + )
4- Seulgi ( C )
3- Winter ( C )
2- NingNing ( B )
1- Wendy ( B+/A- )
😂😂😂😂
Irene's clip shows her rapping...which obviously won't sound like good singing because it isn't singing.
She’s still F tho…
Singing or rapping, she doesnt support
@@dmndmnans1441 who tf supports when rapping ? 💀 yall acting as vocal coach after watching two tiktoks about it
@@jinsowlzAre u stupid? They said she doesn't support GENERALLY...and that's true, they didn't mean in just that case...
@@jinsowlzshe will still be last
The gap between members in RV is too big and Wendy mostly carries the group (sometimes Seulgi does too). Aespa is more well balanced group imo.
So if i have to make comparison
As group = Aespa > RV
As solo = Wendy > Ning > Seulgi > Winter
Exactly
What's the gap? Have you ever seen them sing a cappella? All members of RV sing well, and Wendy is the best vocalist of her generation. They are also known for their amazing harmonization.
aespa delulus
*ning > seulgi.* ningning is more well-rounded, hence why we consider her average to above average [c+]. she has better agility than seulgi, her projection in all registers is better than seulgi, her lower register is better than seulgi, her head voice [ though not consistent ] is still better than seulgi's. even small things like vibrato, ning is better than seulgi. so they are not on the same rank at all. seulgi at times has a better mid-register, and her belts sound richer since ningning is light, but that's about it, and based on whether you like lighter voices or not. it's actually seulgi and winter who are interchangeable, both are high average and have similar difficulties as vocalists.
@@selenesaint thank you, i edited that. I separated Ning and Seulgi so i put comma (,). Yes Ning is better in almost all categories : Lows, runs, and upper head registers + round vibrato. Ning sounds light bcs she always feels unsure and hesitant to belt even tho i know she can do it so that's why the composers give belting part to Winter.
@@mark4670 ningning is a stylistic singer, she doesn't belt at all. she stopped belting in savage maybe, now it's just riffs and runs.
1. Wendy mid P
2. Ningning low AA
3. Seulgi high A
4. Winter mid A
5. Karina high W-A
6. Giselle high W-A
7. Joy mid W
No support
8. Irene very high U
9. Yeri high U
If I includes all sm gg since snsd
1. Luna mid P-G
2. Wendy mid P
3. Taeyeon mid P
4. Ningning low AA
5. Seohyun mid A-AA
6. Jessica mid A-AA
7. Seulgi high A
8. Tiffany mid A
9. Sunny mid A
10. Winter mid A
11. Karina high W-A
12. Giselle high W-A
13. Krystal mid W-A
14. Amber mid W-A
15. Yuri high W
16. Sooyoung high W
17. Joy mid W
18. Irene very high U
19. Sulli very high U
20. Yeri high U
21. Hyoyeon high U
22. Yoona high U
23. Victoria U
i dont think you can jump from F+ to E, you might be F/F+ or E- but not F+/E
@@billlinghurst oh that’s my fault haha
karina over Giselle??.
And Lina?
@@TheReVeluvFestival A
1 Wendy B+
2 Ningning/Winter C+
3 Seulgi C/C+
4 Karina/Giselle D+/C-
5 Joy D-
6 Irene E+
7 Yeri E-
Bruh Irene and Yeri Cant Support,How Could They Be In E Tier
@@avenging5138 they have improved
Based !!
@@albiateneatrue
1. Wendy B+
2. Ningning C+
3. Seulgi C
4. Winter C
5. Giselle D+/C-
6. Karina D+
7. Joy D-
8. Irene F+
9. Yeri F
Seulgi C+
@@redloona1085 Seulgi es muuuuy inconsistente con los C5 es imposible que sea C+
@@_jpf_01 C/C+
@@redloona1085No. Her nasality constantly puts her in rough position when singing. She's not even high average, there's no way. She's just C for now.
Honestly aespa is like package i mean winter and ningning they are good but karina and giselle being rapper they slayed . Like gigi has hidden vocals black mamba . Sm should explore them more !!
Red velvet vocals: from low to high. They're the whole package indeed
Can we get a vocal ranking for EXO?
Wendy es otro nivel ahí, en Time after time que cantó con NingNing y BoA se nota mucho la diferencia en especial en las grabaciones.
1.wendy(B+)
2.ning ning(^C+)
3.seulgi(C+)
4.winter(^C/C+)
5.giselle(^D+/C-)
6.karina(^D+)
7.joy(D+)
8.irene(^F+)
9.yeri(F+)
Yeah that true, in Red velvet just wendy & seulgi can sing in better way in live vocals 👌🏻, and Aespa have more potential in all member that they can actually 'sing' live performer
Joy must be above karina, her techniques are more way better
I love both groups one of my favs and even though wendy is not my bias in rv shes 3rd (i still lover her ) i have to say that shes very talented an ace
That girl has rap vocals dance and visuals
NEVER A GIRL WOULD BE MOST BEST VOCALIST THEN WENDY !!!!
no but. the two groups have really different styles and concepts. they both have a lot of potential and are great singers.
Wait irene is close to achieving vocal support
Yes, its so close from D- it's amazing
@@holasoyyo1848she’s not even close, she’s not even weak yet
@@holasoyyo1848not even close to E-.
Visuals don’t mean vocals guys.
Irene is same sing debut, F+
@@miam_k she is close
@@velvetcatcher irene is barely high non-vocalist
she’s not even low weak, D- is low w-a
Both are very good groups but Red Velvet is superior (no hate I love Aespa)
snsd, rv and aespa ranking vocal
1. taeyeon A-
2. wendy B+
3. seohyun B-
4. jessica B-
5. ningning C+
6. tiffany C
7. sunny C
8. seulgi C
9. winter C
10. giselle D+/C-
11. karina D+
12. yuri D
13. joy D-
14. sooyoung E+
15. hyoyeon F+
16. Irene F+
17. yoona F+
18. yeri
I thought taeyeon and Wendy were interchangeable as they are the same for a lot and they balance each other out
Both Jessica and seohyun are a C+, they don't have any resonant qualities
dude no
@@gamerxarmymultistanyes
I think it's tayon B because its support limits up to F5
As a group Aespa vocals are superior compared to Red Velvet but if compared as main vocalists Wendy definitely defeat NingNing
support ≠ singing rankings.
you can't rank singing off of ONE element. that's stupid.
other than that, music is an art - you need to have style in mind. it's impossible to compare two singers with very different stylistic choices.
omg ive been saying this! theres so much more to singing like dynamics, agility, musicality etcetc support tiers are just one element
@@kokolawson4794 exactly !
and even within technique, there are lots of factors. you can't just state that someone is a better singer because they support 3 more notes. i feel like kids these days are so formatted in school that they cannot understand the concept of not being able to grade something.
for example, joy from red velvet and giselle from aespa have VERY different techniques and styles. joy lifts her soft palate, and shifts the sound to her nasal cavity - in the other hand, giselle has a more airy approach. can you objectively say 'x is better than x'? NO. you can only give your OPINION, since to rank them both, you need to have your own set of standards. someone may think that projection is more important than nasality, and consider x better. another person can consider support more importaant than tone, and consider x better than x.
agreed with you.
Yes, these vocal tier rankings are dogshit because they're literally only about breath support. As much as they seem like interesting little tidbits, there's way much more to singing than just this. If you have better support than someone else it doesn't mean you're a better singer than them, you can't take these rankings and run with them.
No one with a brain will argue Minnie is a shitty singer because she has F+ support. You can't ignore everything else about her singing.
This is not just about vocal support (however, that's the most important thing), but about singing technique in general.
@@harveyism that's incorrect. the ranking system that kpop stans started using all of a sudden only takes in account support, and not just support.. but 'supported range', a very unusual and weird concept, which, as a flute player and singer, i had never heard of.
singing isn't always about supporting notes, someone's objective might be a stylistic approach.. this is POP singing.
these rankings don't take in account any other technicalities other than 'support', and even that is quite shaky, with some people who have no music degree or knowledge saying 'oh, that's supported, you can just hear it, you'll eventually know how to distinguish support from non-support！'...
by that, i mean : singing is objective, as in, there are things that could make someone a better singer overall, BUT, it's still an art, and therefore subjective, which means different people can look at different singers and consider one 'better', based off their own subjective standards, since it comes a point where two singers have very different techniques, strenghts and flaws, therefore, only subjectivity can deem the better one.
support is NOT the most important thing in singing. you cannot make a subjective statement and try to frame it as the truth.
joy above aerina
In the intro Ning Ning is looking like Rosé
As expected from the wannabes 🥺🤣
@@healing4052bruh first of all she doesn't even look like rosé🙄 and just because a single person said they look similar doesn't mean they actually look similar 🙄
Wendy on top❤
I would rank Joy above Giselle but agree the rest
Me da coraje que comparen a estos dos grupos, porque comparan con un grupo de chicas ya con una buena carrera formada con uno que es principiante por así decirlo
Cuanta razón
Being older does not mean being better
@@bitchesproofbarbie Yeah sometimes
no es una comparación
es un ranking técnico y objetivo
TWICEとITZYのversionやってほしいです！
do a ranking ; SNSD (0T9) vs F(x) (OT5) vs RV vs Aespa please.
Joy above Giselle
Giselle is better than karina
Giselle is better vocalist than Karina.now i understand that Giselle is really very underrated...
Imo:
9.Irene
8.Yeri
7.Joy
6.Seulgi
5.Wendy
4.Giselle
3.Karina
2.Winter
1.Ningning
Uh, my opinion, which might be close to facts if I'm not sure, this is not my feeling, it's from what I observed.
9. Yeri
8. Irene
7. Giselle
6. Karina
5. Joy
4. Winter
3. Ningning
2. Seulgi
1. Wendy
Both are good because both are of SM Entertainment ❤❤❤❤❤
Guys, I'm an aespa and red velvet stan, but I think you are being biased towards aespa here and haven't seen all that red velvet offers
Joy is better singer than Giselle would ever be
Mejor cállate
la verdad aunque duela @@Thv-lino
GISELLE IS BETTER THAN KARINA
Que? No lol
De donde sacas eso?? Karina hasta el momento es mejor que ella, que no escuchas sus canciones?
@@itzelayala7323 But I think Giselle is better and no hate to karina i love Both so much
@@itzelayala7323 you're mad like if you're Karina's official lawyer
They're pretty much interchangeable
@@snowflake6421 ones technically better which is giselle
Aespa have more powerful and strong voice, Red velvet have more cute and gentle voices💖
Ning ning needs to win. Her vocals are perfect and winter on second!❤
their both good really
Not true. Aespa seemed “stronger” only bcos of the concept SM gave them. Red velvet is not cute and gentle, they are more versatile and also bcos of the concept SM has given them
@@whatiwanttoseelol even in psycho they sound gentile and sweet ..stop hating Red Velvet angelic voices because you like aespa deep boring voices..
No ..Wendy Seulgi best
@@rossanascarati2720 did I hate on red velvet? U got to be kidding… u need to read.
Red Velvet singing circles around aespa lmaoo
wendy is, but the other 4 girls really aren't.
You mean just Wendy. Seulgi isn't running any circles around Ningning and Winter, and Joy has less vocal support than the Aespa rappers.
literally. seulgi is an underwhelming vocalist when in comparison to wendy. she's not shallow.. but some of her faults are stuff you'd expect in w-a vocalists. forced vibrato, poor agility, nasality in the 4th octave... @@Robalexe
Wendy will always be one of the best vocalist!
Bro you kidding?! Ningning is NOWHERE near b+ or b-
literally. i don't know why people keep spreading misinfo, she's low c+ at best.
the fact that ningning is the youngest idol in sm-
this is so unserious… joy d?? below giselle???
Giselle have a better support
Joy is weak while giselle is weak-average
Sm artists are the real talents of music industry
Wendy :)
they all are vocal queen ❤
I'm a MY
But I admit RV are great
I have no problem with that. Simply enjoy both groups. Wendy is so unreal.
NMIXX vs aespa vs LE SSERAFIM
nmixx wash them easily.
1. lily *high b-*
2. haewon *mid b-*
3. yunjin *mid-low c*
4. sullyoon *high d+*
5. kyujin *mid-high d+*
6. jiwoo *mid d*
7. bae *low d*
8. chaewon *high e*
9. eunchae *f+ with some moments*
10/11. the j-line.*f/f-*
1. Lily (B- / B)
2. Haewon (B-)
3. Ningning (C+)
4. Winter (C)
5. Yunjin (C)
6. Sullyoon (C-)
7. Kyujin/Giselle (^D+ / C-)
8. Karina (D+)
9. Jiwoo/Bae (D)
10. Chaewon (E+ / D-)
11. Eunchae (F+ / E-)
12: Kazuha/Sakura (F)
@@kim_ga-ramNing is better than Haewon and Winter is MILES BETTER than Yunjin PLEASE BE REALISTIC
@@kim_ga-ram girl you can''t be "c-/d+" there's no such thing as being shallow and non shallow at the same time. lily is just high b-
@@dmndmnans1441 what are you talking about? Ningning is stated to be a ^C+, but not actually close to be B-. Haewon is stated to be B-, while Lily is ^B-, and Winter has a gap with Yunjin but their both C, but ig Winter could be ^C, and what even are you talking bout realistic, and what more realistic do u even want my ranking to be??
this list is satisfying
Could u pls rank them based on their belting too? Tyyy
Even ningning will look like a lead vocal in front of wendy
Yeri - F
Sulgi - C+
Ning2 - C+
Joy - D
Karina D+/C-
Me urge que estos 2 grupos hagan colaboración con Apink, Gfriend, Nmixx y Mamamoo
its not base on voice, this ranking is base on the vocal range. Irene does have a stable and great voice
Please do VVUP vocal rank🙏🏻
Irene is now E/E- tho . And yeri has improved as well .
joy d- is CRAZY
Can u pls do gidle and blackpink
If Yeri and Irene are F what are the rest of the world? I must be a Z!
F is the last tier.
@@luvielam Its a joke
That’s totally fine with me😂
Joy should have been above Karina
Team aespa
GISELLE AND KARINA OVER JOY?
duh
yes
yes obviously
Yes?!
I'm sure SM is in an uproar over this!
giselle is better than karina now!!
Bro wendy...
NING NING ARRIBA DE SEULGI KAKDKGDKDKAKSKSJSJSKS en tus sueños quizás
which song joy is singing
Red velvet - birthday
Rv on 🔝
#Reveluvs ❤
Wendy❤
i don't think seulgi is better than winter. her voice is too nasal
????
@@everyonesmileeeeeis what i hear bro
She literally has one of the prettiest and most distinct vocal tones in kpop. Will never understand the English speaking side of kpop rating Wendy of all singers higher
Wendy B+, who do you expect to be A? Whitney Houston? 😂
Whitney is S with Sohyang and other vocal trinity
luna chen jonghyun eukwang taeyeon and wendy are similar but taeyeon has the edge on her
An A includes Carrie Underwood, Ariana Grande, Jessie and Charice.
You guys just don't know joy's potential
Girls Beautiful 😍
Giselle C-, wendy B+/A-
ning 2 is so gorgeous
aespa очень хороши в вокале когда я посмотрела это видео потому что в к-поп они только 3 года а другая группа вроде довольна старая
New sm group Aesvelvet 💀
I saw a lot of people saying Giselle is better than karina because she can support better than karina. But let me tell you both their support range ends in b4. Also about getting more lines i admit Giselle has more freedom in her head voice but it's not like she sings like an opera singer in her head voice. On top of that her mix is not developed enough she sounds shallow. But on the other hand karina's main power is her mix which is fairly developed she doesn't sound shallow. She sound pushy while going up in the 5th octave. But her mix allows her to sing many styles with ease the reason why she gets many lines. And singing is not just about support.
wait so whos better at singing? is it a matter of opinion orr
Queens vocals red velvet and aespa
1- Wendy(B+) (RED VELVET)
2- Ningning(C+) (AESPA)
3- Winter(^C) (AESPA)
4- Seulgi(C) (RED VELVET)
5- Giselle(^D+/C-) (AESPA)
6- Karina(^D+) (AESPA)
7- Joy(D-) (RED VELVET)
8- Irene(F+) (RED VELVET)
9- Yeri(^F/F+) (RED VELVET)
seulgi and winter are interchangeable. and joy is e+
also how is giselle d+/c? you can't be two tiers at once. giselle is still shallow, and therefore d+. she's c- at best, and her shallowness is too consistent to be considered average.
Not yeri and Irene f, they are like e/e+ , joy es higher than Karina /Giselle , seulgi is c+
Wendy the vocal queen
Winter is a good singer
I would switch Seulgi and Winter , In fact vocal range of Winter is wilder than Seulgi
Not rlly seulgi can sing bery high and very low this wasnt even her best tbh i like winters vocals aswell but seulgi has more of a variety imo
If Yeri and Irenes are Fs what the fvck am I 😭😭😭😭😭
I think they are actually e+ xd
lmao biased af
the real ranking:
1. Wendy
2. Seulgi
3. Ning ning
4. Joy
5. Winter
other
This is about vocal support. You can't be biased about who has vocal support, it's a fact, no room for interpretation. You're just in denial.
Lmao
Red Velvet❤❤❤❤❤❤
Wendy is A tier
not the vocal rankings💀💀
Joy > Giselle and Karina
Yeri and Irene vocals are good for blendings
Giselle > Karina > Joy