@@samiman5606Tamazight are not semetic languages. We are speaking about the semetic, the Arabic speakers. Darija is the maghrebi family of Arabic, with just influences from the Tamazight.
As a North African i can only say that This map is terrible we in Mauritania speak Hassaniya which is much closer to peninsular Arabic than to Moroccan or Algerian and i really don’t understand why Mauritania and the rest of the Maghreb are just labeled “Darija” which just means dialect whille the rest of the Arab world is labeled “Arabic” is if we speak a different language like Aramaic.. this map is just bad
@@empirehistoria6598 i am a native speaker to Hassaniya and on this map we are labeled as Darija and we have complete mutual intelligibility with eastern Arabic dialects (even closer to them than to neighboring Moroccan or Algerian) and we can also understand Moroccan and Algerian with a little exposure as do most Arabs
@@abdelkarimalkashi6452 Yes, same with how they list all the languages as "canaanite" when Hebrew and Moabite and Edomite were fully distinct by that time as different languages. If they were to consider Darija different, why not list Hebrew and all the others as well?
There are many inconsistencies. For example, why keep Hebrew, Edomite, Moabite, Phoenician, Punic etc. as Canaanite and Maltese, Levantine, Masri, Sudani, etc. as Arabic, but separate Moroccan, Libyan, Tunisian, etc as different from Arabic (marked as Darija)? Maltese is actually generally accepted as a different language from Arabic and is more closely related to the Western dialect continuum than to the Eastern dialects
Canaanite dialects are shown as one because they were mutually inteligible while Arabic dialects are not. Maltese was meant to be shown as Darija, it was an editing mistake.
If anything, Maltese is closer to Darija than Arabian Arabic. There seem to be quite a few innacuracies in this video. They also left out Sicilian and Cypriot Arabic which used to exist. Also Aramaic and Assyrian still exist in pockets of Syria and Lebanon
The maps shown for the Middle Ages are highly misleading. In the 1000s, Arabic was widely spoken in Spain, from Zaragoza to Algeciras, not just in the south. However, there were no Arabic speakers in what is now Morocco and Algeria during that period. In fact, at the court of Abd al-Rahman III, the Idrisid envoy from Fez required a translator to convert Berber into Arabic so that Hispano-Muslims could understand him. Referring to Darija during this time is inaccurate, as Arabic only began to spread across North Africa gradually after the Banu Hilal invasions in the 12th and 13th centuries. In Tunisia, Arabic was spoken in specific towns like Kairouan, while in Egypt, most of the population still spoke Coptic, with Arabic use largely confined to places like Alexandria, Fustat, and possibly some desert areas. The map needs a thorough revision to reflect these realities.
@@leonardo_fratila Even though up-to-date research has been supporting the idea of the israelites decending directly from the cannanites, nevertheless, the israelites did not consider themsleves as cannanites. This can be easily seen in the bible, a book written by those very israelites/judeans, where they seperate themselves from the cannanite population over and over again.
5:39 did you just casually made the south semitic distribution map in thr state of Amhara? That state is linguistically diverse with several cushitic languages occupying large areas. You can add silte and harari languages
كلام غير صحيح أول من تكلم اللغة العربية الفصحى هو النبي إسماعيل بن إبراهيم عليهما السلام . قبل ٣٨٨٠ سنة قبل الميلاد و اللغة العربية القديمة كان يتحدث بها أقوام سابقون مثل قبيلة جرهم و قبيلة ثمود في منطقة العلا في السعودية وغيرهم من القبائل العربية في شبه الجزيرة العربية .
In Egypt we speak Masri (Egyptian colloquial) not normal Arabic, it's very different from not normal Arabic It's a mix of coptic, Arabic, English, Turkish and French words And its grammar is more close to coptic than normal Arabic
Good video but it contains some wrong things for example: it is not north and south Semitic, it is north and south ancient Arabic. It is not Yemenites, it is Sheba and Hemyarite (ancient Arabic) Why you differentiate between Darija and Arabic? Why you did not mentioned the existence of Semitic Language in Anatolia, South east Persia, Greek and Italy? ^_^
Le marocain / the Moroccan language : DARIJA Le Maroc dispose de deux langues officielles, qui sont l'amazigh et l'arabe, mais le français est aussi parlé et compris par la quasi-totalité des marocains. Désormais, l'anglais tend à surpasser le français. L'espagnol est répandu dans les régions du Nord et du Sud du Maroc. La langue amazighe, dont l'alphabet est le Tifinagh, est le patrimoine commun de tous les Marocains. L’arabe classique ou littéraire est utilisé dans le milieu administratif. La langue utilisée oralement par les marocains est la Darija (le marocain). C’est d’un mélange de l’amazigh, l'arabe, le français et l’espagnol. Morocco has two official languages, which are Arabic and Amazigh, but French is also spoken and understood by almost all Moroccans. Now, English tends to surpass French. Spanish is widespread in the northern and southern regions of Morocco. The Amazigh language, whose alphabet is Tifinagh, is the common heritage of all Moroccans. Classical or literary Arabic is used in the administrative environment. The language used orally by Moroccans is Darija (the Moroccan language). It is a mixture of Amazigh, Arabic, French and Spanish.
Darija is the dialect of the Bedouin Arab tribes (Banu Hilal) and the influence of some Andalusian dialects (interspersed with many French, Turkish, Spanish and Berber words) More than a one hundred million people speak Darija .
you're wrong about your comments, I invite you to dive into this subject without searching nor reading what would reinforce your belief but rather enlarge it to get a global and deeper thought>.
I understand that the levantines language were and are similar to each other but it's not correct to just put them under "canaanite". Aramaic is also sometimes confused with Hebrew and the two languages are very similar but you still marked Aramaic separately.
It could be more correct to put the Maltese into the darija family, than into the more "pure" arabic. Anyway, Maltese is a separate semitic language, but very relative to the Tunisian and western Libyan arabic. The darija family as i said.
In fact there is no such thing as "pure" spoken arabic, all arabs talk a dialect which is not literal arabic, that is why arabic is so hard to learn: nobody speaks "real" arabic, we only write it...
@@abdelkarimalkashi6452 The Asian part of the Middle East speaks mostly the standard Arabic. From Egypt and western more is starting the dialects area.
@@Fallacia_Konstantinos Nope, even Iraqis or Saoudis do not speak standard arabic, it is still a dialect, that is why it is hard to understand them even if you understand literal arabic
Oh. I guess we aren’t going to actually show all the languages, but language clusters? While this video is appreciated, it’s disingenuous to the plethora of languages that came from Eurasia. It’s disingenuous to call some of the most major languages in history under the guise of a “language family.” It also excludes Greek and Latin from the region-which had massive impacts on the further evolution of these Semitic languages and cultures.
لغة لاتينية و لغة يونانية هي لغات حديثة .. و هي لغات نصف مصطلحاتها مأخود من لغات سامية .... لغات سامية هي من ساهمت في وجود لغة يونانية و لاتينية ... = اما لغات سامية هي قديمة و عريقة هي تعتبر اقدم لغات الارض ... و حضارات سامية هي اقدم حضارات عالم
@@empirehistoria6598 as Moroccan you confused me 90% of the words we use are literally arabic, even the grammar are arabic with ofc some rules from Amazigh language,please do better research before spreading such a wrong misinformation... Calling it separate language when the vast majority of words and vocabulary are arabic is wild
@@4y7v10 French vocabulary is almost the same as Spanish and Italian but its pronunciation is completely different which makes it uninteligible and hence a separate language. Same is the case with Darija
@@empirehistoria6598 bad comparison, French Spanish are both languages descended from Latin and both languages made their own vocabulary and grammar rules and continue in their own path and Spanish or French or Italian cannot understand each other without learning their languages Unlike arab dialects where we can understand each other to large extend Darija is just a dialect in arabic it's mostly arabic vocabulary and grammar with some forgein words from different languages By your logic Australian English is independent language American English is independent language Scottish English is independent language The major difference between arab dialects is that each one uses different words for the same thing For example the word boy In Egyptian : الواد (al Wad) In Sudanese: زول (zol) In Gulf accents: ولد (walad) In Darija دري/ولد (dri/weld) Or the word woman In Egyptian ولية wliya In Gulf accents: حرمة horma In Darija: امراة mra
@@4y7v10 French has 80% similar vocabulary as Spanish and Italian. Languages become separate when there is little to no mutual inteligibility in terms of conversation which is the case with Darija.
thank you for the great job, but I think that when you color my land, North Africa (or as we call it in my language : Thamazgha, or the Land of Amazigh) with brown mostly, you mean that in those reagion, Arabic is spoken, not that it is the sole spoken language. The Only regions were ONLY one language is spoken is the Amazighophone islands where Arabic never penetrate. In those regions, it is correct to color them with ONLY one color as ONLY one language is spoken : Amazigh But the brown region, should colored in dashed colors : were people speak Amazigh and North African language (Darja). I think that it will be more correct and objective. If not, you will be participating in arabizing my land by spreading false information and making people think that in the brown there is only natives of Darija. Thank you again
I can inderstand why you put Darijah as a different language than Arabic, but then why Maltese is Arabic when it is more different than Darijah to Arabic.
Its crazy that modern Hebrew is so similar to old semitic languages, such that, a dude from Israel can read and understand text that is over 3500 years old.
No they can’t modern Hebrew is different to old Hebrew. It was made up so white European “Israelis” that invaded and terrorised Semitic Palestine in 1948, can feel like they fit in.
For those who say that Darija is not a language in reality it is considered a modern hybrid language between Arabic Amazigh French and Spanish and it cannot be said that it is an Arabic dialect because it does not follow Arabic rules and is not understood by Arabs
خاصك تفهمي ان الدارجة ماشي سميت لهجة الدارجة مصطلح عربي يعني العامية أو المعيارية ويتكلمو بها الوطن العربي كله من العراق إلى المغرب ماتبقايش تستخدمي شي مصطلح عربي ماعرفاش المعنى ديالو
WRONG! Aramaic has NEVER been the major or only language in Northern Iraq or Syria! NEVER. It was a minor language throughout history. Hurrian was native there followed by Median and Scythian which replaced it and evolved into kurdish.
Darija is a bunch of dialects of Arabic
Not true it's Tamazight native
@@samiman5606Tamazight are not semetic languages. We are speaking about the semetic, the Arabic speakers. Darija is the maghrebi family of Arabic, with just influences from the Tamazight.
@@samiman5606
"Darija" is an Arabic word
الخواجات يحبون يخربون الدنيا في المشرق.. ليتهم يدرون أننا نفهم كعرب ونسمع للشوالي وهو تونسي والأمور واضحة
Yes, it is an Arabic dialect spoken in the Maghreb region, the areas of Morocco, Mauritania and parts of Algeria
As a North African i can only say that This map is terrible we in Mauritania speak Hassaniya which is much closer to peninsular Arabic than to Moroccan or Algerian and i really don’t understand why Mauritania and the rest of the Maghreb are just labeled “Darija” which just means dialect whille the rest of the Arab world is labeled “Arabic” is if we speak a different language like Aramaic.. this map is just bad
Darija languages are considered to be Arabic dialects but most of them are not mutually inteligible with Arabic of the East
@@empirehistoria6598 i am a native speaker to Hassaniya and on this map we are labeled as Darija and we have complete mutual intelligibility with eastern Arabic dialects (even closer to them than to neighboring Moroccan or Algerian) and we can also understand Moroccan and Algerian with a little exposure as do most Arabs
@@almami1599 yes I realize now that was a mistake. Thanks for the info. Hassaniya should be under Arabic
@@empirehistoria6598 all Arabic should be left as Arabic
@@almami1599even if it's quite different from other maghrebi dialects, hassaniya is clearly a western dialect
I thought Darija is a Arabic dialect in the Maghreb not a language
It is a dialect not language, like 90% of it's words are arabic
Darija literally means common language or dialect, this video is unacurate
@@abdelkarimalkashi6452 Yes, same with how they list all the languages as "canaanite" when Hebrew and Moabite and Edomite were fully distinct by that time as different languages. If they were to consider Darija different, why not list Hebrew and all the others as well?
There are many inconsistencies. For example, why keep Hebrew, Edomite, Moabite, Phoenician, Punic etc. as Canaanite and Maltese, Levantine, Masri, Sudani, etc. as Arabic, but separate Moroccan, Libyan, Tunisian, etc as different from Arabic (marked as Darija)? Maltese is actually generally accepted as a different language from Arabic and is more closely related to the Western dialect continuum than to the Eastern dialects
Canaanite dialects are shown as one because they were mutually inteligible while Arabic dialects are not. Maltese was meant to be shown as Darija, it was an editing mistake.
Malta speaks Maltese now (semitic language), not Arabic
The population of malta never really spoke arabic. It transitioned from whatever romance language they spoke to the mix that is maltese
Maltese is really close to Tunisian Arabic, they're mutually intelligible
The Maltese language is mostly Arabic. If I went to Malta, I could understand them
@@eduardomelo151no Maltese descends from Siculo Arabic that was spoken in Sicily
If anything, Maltese is closer to Darija than Arabian Arabic. There seem to be quite a few innacuracies in this video. They also left out Sicilian and Cypriot Arabic which used to exist. Also Aramaic and Assyrian still exist in pockets of Syria and Lebanon
The maps shown for the Middle Ages are highly misleading. In the 1000s, Arabic was widely spoken in Spain, from Zaragoza to Algeciras, not just in the south. However, there were no Arabic speakers in what is now Morocco and Algeria during that period. In fact, at the court of Abd al-Rahman III, the Idrisid envoy from Fez required a translator to convert Berber into Arabic so that Hispano-Muslims could understand him. Referring to Darija during this time is inaccurate, as Arabic only began to spread across North Africa gradually after the Banu Hilal invasions in the 12th and 13th centuries. In Tunisia, Arabic was spoken in specific towns like Kairouan, while in Egypt, most of the population still spoke Coptic, with Arabic use largely confined to places like Alexandria, Fustat, and possibly some desert areas. The map needs a thorough revision to reflect these realities.
Why do you not differenicate between Phenocian and Ancient hebrew? Putting them at the same category of "cannanite" is factually wrong.
True
... or are they?
They both called themselves cananites
@@leonardo_fratila Even though up-to-date research has been supporting the idea of the israelites decending directly from the cannanites, nevertheless, the israelites did not consider themsleves as cannanites.
This can be easily seen in the bible, a book written by those very israelites/judeans, where they seperate themselves from the cannanite population over and over again.
It is true, it is of the same Canaanite branch, it did develop in that part of the Levant, initially called Canaan
5:39 did you just casually made the south semitic distribution map in thr state of Amhara? That state is linguistically diverse with several cushitic languages occupying large areas.
You can add silte and harari languages
Nobody:
* East & West semitic being actually North & South *
9:19 Yemen was divided into the Hadrami language, Himyarite language, Sabaean language.
Darija not a language This is a huge mistake in the video darija an Arabic word meaning a dialect
It is de facto a separate language as it is not mutually inteligible with Arabic of the east
@@empirehistoria6598 How is it not mutually intelligible if it's literally an Arabic dialect ?
No, it is an Arab dialect.@@empirehistoria6598
East Semitic being to the west of the West Semitic 👍
North Semitic being to the south of the East Semitic 👍
Assyrian language still exists
The Assyrians speak Modern Aramaic
Assyrian today is a dialect of Aramaic
@@empirehistoria6598 Yes, I know, but ok, so why we don't see Aramaic on the map, if that still exists?
@@konymielony2364 Aramaic is no longer majority spoken language in any area.
@@empirehistoria6598 They spoke Syraic dialect of aramaic which emerged in 2nd century CE.
كلام غير صحيح
أول من تكلم اللغة العربية الفصحى هو النبي إسماعيل بن إبراهيم عليهما السلام .
قبل ٣٨٨٠ سنة قبل الميلاد
و اللغة العربية القديمة كان يتحدث بها أقوام سابقون مثل قبيلة جرهم و قبيلة ثمود في منطقة العلا في السعودية وغيرهم من القبائل العربية في شبه الجزيرة العربية .
Long live Arabic❤
In Egypt we speak Masri (Egyptian colloquial) not normal Arabic, it's very different from not normal Arabic
It's a mix of coptic, Arabic, English, Turkish and French words
And its grammar is more close to coptic than normal Arabic
No one speaks normal arabic, many regions have their own dialect which are closer between them than they qre to classical arabic
that's just Egyptian darija
Also there are still coptic speakers
In Egypt we don't speak MSA Arabic, we speak masri, which is egyptian darija, like th tunisian darija the morrocan the levantine the Sudanese
Darija is an Arabic dialect !
You need to be accurate, darija literally means common Arabic speech. It's not a language on its own!!! ⛔ ⚠️
Good video but it contains some wrong things for example:
it is not north and south Semitic, it is north and south ancient Arabic.
It is not Yemenites, it is Sheba and Hemyarite (ancient Arabic)
Why you differentiate between Darija and Arabic?
Why you did not mentioned the existence of Semitic Language in Anatolia, South east Persia, Greek and Italy?
^_^
Darija is an arabic dialect like the Egyptian the levant , the yemeni dialects . Correct it pls
Tigre is closer to Ge'ez than Tigrinya which means likely older 😂
Punic was spoken until the arrival of the Arabs in North Africa.
Le marocain / the Moroccan language : DARIJA
Le Maroc dispose de deux langues officielles, qui sont l'amazigh et l'arabe, mais le français est aussi parlé et compris par la quasi-totalité des marocains. Désormais, l'anglais tend à surpasser le français.
L'espagnol est répandu dans les régions du Nord et du Sud du Maroc.
La langue amazighe, dont l'alphabet est le Tifinagh, est le patrimoine commun de tous les Marocains.
L’arabe classique ou littéraire est utilisé dans le milieu administratif. La langue utilisée oralement par les marocains est la Darija (le marocain). C’est d’un mélange de l’amazigh, l'arabe, le français et l’espagnol.
Morocco has two official languages, which are Arabic and Amazigh, but French is also spoken and understood by almost all Moroccans. Now, English tends to surpass French. Spanish is widespread in the northern and southern regions of Morocco.
The Amazigh language, whose alphabet is Tifinagh, is the common heritage of all Moroccans.
Classical or literary Arabic is used in the administrative environment. The language used orally by Moroccans is Darija (the Moroccan language). It is a mixture of Amazigh, Arabic, French and Spanish.
الدارجة هم العرب صح؟
نعم اصلا دارجة كلمة عربية
لهجة من لهجات اللغة العربية و التي يتحدث بها شعوب الغرب الاسلامي
الدارجة هي لهجة من اللغة العربية تأثرت باللغة الامازغية في مغرب جزائر تونس....
@@w444rbv اللهجة الجزائرية لايوجد في الا خمس كلمات امازيغية و كل كلمة عندها مرادف بالعربية يستخدم في اللهجة ايضا
@@FgCr-mp5qd لو كان هاذا حقيقي كان عرب في مشرق يفهمون علينا
Darija is the dialect of the Bedouin Arab tribes (Banu Hilal) and the influence of some Andalusian dialects (interspersed with many French, Turkish, Spanish and Berber words)
More than a one hundred million people speak Darija .
you're wrong about your comments, I invite you to dive into this subject without searching nor reading what would reinforce your belief but rather enlarge it to get a global and deeper thought>.
@@beyoursman hhh I live in North Africa I don’t need to search and I have PHD ( Art and History )
I understand that the levantines language were and are similar to each other but it's not correct to just put them under "canaanite". Aramaic is also sometimes confused with Hebrew and the two languages are very similar but you still marked Aramaic separately.
The canaanite languages were all mutually inteligible while aramaic wasn't
Were Natufians proto-semitic speakers ?
Natufians probably spoke Proto Afro-Asiatic language…proto-Semitic probably was spoken by the mixture of Natufians and Zagros Neolithic populations
Thank you
Do you know wich culture could be seen as the first one speaking a semetic language ? (PPNA A, PPNA B, Halaf, Hassuna-Samarra ?)
Darija is a Arabic dialect
I didn't know Amharic is also a Semitic language.
Also learned about Hassania from the comments here
Definitely is. I speak Amharic and I recognize lots of Arabic and Hebrew words
It could be more correct to put the Maltese into the darija family, than into the more "pure" arabic.
Anyway, Maltese is a separate semitic language, but very relative to the Tunisian and western Libyan arabic. The darija family as i said.
Yes that was a mistake
In fact there is no such thing as "pure" spoken arabic, all arabs talk a dialect which is not literal arabic, that is why arabic is so hard to learn: nobody speaks "real" arabic, we only write it...
@@abdelkarimalkashi6452 The Asian part of the Middle East speaks mostly the standard Arabic. From Egypt and western more is starting the dialects area.
@@Fallacia_Konstantinos Nope, even Iraqis or Saoudis do not speak standard arabic, it is still a dialect, that is why it is hard to understand them even if you understand literal arabic
Awsome!
Oh. I guess we aren’t going to actually show all the languages, but language clusters?
While this video is appreciated, it’s disingenuous to the plethora of languages that came from Eurasia. It’s disingenuous to call some of the most major languages in history under the guise of a “language family.”
It also excludes Greek and Latin from the region-which had massive impacts on the further evolution of these Semitic languages and cultures.
Read the title, there is a reason Greek and latin aren't included
لغة لاتينية و لغة يونانية هي لغات حديثة .. و هي لغات نصف مصطلحاتها مأخود من لغات سامية .... لغات سامية هي من ساهمت في وجود لغة يونانية و لاتينية ...
= اما لغات سامية هي قديمة و عريقة هي تعتبر اقدم لغات الارض ... و حضارات سامية هي اقدم حضارات عالم
Vídeo Interessante
Elamites ????
Arab tribes lived in north of Iraq before Islam
Mousel , Harran and Edessa are Arabic
At the end it’s good video ❤❤❤
The language family of the Elamites is currently unknown and is most likely a language isolate unrelated to any others.
Most of the Arabs who lived in Iraq spoke Aramaic
@@strangehermitman7898Likewise the Sumerians
@@irajkaviyan9504
The khorasani Arabs speak Persian but Arabs of Mousel , Harran and Edessa still speak Arabic
The Sumerians and Elamites had nothing to do with Semitic languages; they were different people.
Darija is literally arabic dialect
It is not mutually inteligible. It is de facto a separate language even though officially recognized as a dialect
@@empirehistoria6598 as Moroccan you confused me 90% of the words we use are literally arabic, even the grammar are arabic with ofc some rules from Amazigh language,please do better research before spreading such a wrong misinformation... Calling it separate language when the vast majority of words and vocabulary are arabic is wild
@@4y7v10 French vocabulary is almost the same as Spanish and Italian but its pronunciation is completely different which makes it uninteligible and hence a separate language. Same is the case with Darija
@@empirehistoria6598 bad comparison, French Spanish are both languages descended from Latin and both languages made their own vocabulary and grammar rules and continue in their own path and Spanish or French or Italian cannot understand each other without learning their languages
Unlike arab dialects where we can understand each other to large extend
Darija is just a dialect in arabic it's mostly arabic vocabulary and grammar with some forgein words from different languages
By your logic Australian English is independent language
American English is independent language
Scottish English is independent language
The major difference between arab dialects is that each one uses different words for the same thing
For example the word boy
In Egyptian : الواد (al Wad)
In Sudanese: زول (zol)
In Gulf accents: ولد (walad)
In Darija دري/ولد (dri/weld)
Or the word woman
In Egyptian ولية wliya
In Gulf accents: حرمة horma
In Darija: امراة mra
@@4y7v10 French has 80% similar vocabulary as Spanish and Italian. Languages become separate when there is little to no mutual inteligibility in terms of conversation which is the case with Darija.
Aramaic is still spoken in the Middle East
Great
Source: A boycotted branch of mcdonalds
Darija didnt appear until the french came over and Fd up the arabic over there.
Where is jidish?
thank you for the great job, but I think that when you color my land, North Africa (or as we call it in my language : Thamazgha, or the Land of Amazigh) with brown mostly, you mean that in those reagion, Arabic is spoken, not that it is the sole spoken language.
The Only regions were ONLY one language is spoken is the Amazighophone islands where Arabic never penetrate. In those regions, it is correct to color them with ONLY one color as ONLY one language is spoken : Amazigh
But the brown region, should colored in dashed colors : were people speak Amazigh and North African language (Darja). I think that it will be more correct and objective.
If not, you will be participating in arabizing my land by spreading false information and making people think that in the brown there is only natives of Darija.
Thank you again
I can inderstand why you put Darijah as a different language than Arabic, but then why Maltese is Arabic when it is more different than Darijah to Arabic.
Yes that was an editing mistake
Tamazight ?
All afro asiatic languages started in Africa
All Afro-Asiatic African were born in Africa, except the so-called Semitic languages, that originated from "Out of Africa" humanity’s migration.
Such an inaccurate map I have never seen before
Great Video ❤
اليمن هو أصل العرب كيف هذا؟
العلم تاريخ اثري قول كلام ثاني اما قصة جدي يقول يقول كلام ثاني انت من مصدق
كذبه تاريخيه ونفاها العلم
Where is Egyptian?
@@darthparallax5207 Egyptian is not a semitic language
Darija is not a semitic language
Darija is mix of amazigh and Spanish and arabic
Darija is a dialect not a language
So Hebrew is a new language? 😂🤣
In what language the Bible was written then?
Western sahara and Mauritania and south Morocco and south Algeria speak Hassania
Algeria speak tamazight
@@ledamsoo8228 I talking about some place in Algeria like twarg and azawan they are speaking Hassania
The languages of the ancient Kingdom in the territory of the Republic of Yemen were spoken in Central Semitic languages
I didn’t see syriac
False map
wrong
But there ks arabic spoken in malian sahara
Where is Somali
Somali is Cushitic not Semitic
Tunisia no Arabic.
Its crazy that modern Hebrew is so similar to old semitic languages, such that, a dude from Israel can read and understand text that is over 3500 years old.
it's reconstructed.. it was dead then brought back
No they can’t modern Hebrew is different to old Hebrew. It was made up so white European “Israelis” that invaded and terrorised Semitic Palestine in 1948, can feel like they fit in.
Fake
For those who say that Darija is not a language in reality it is considered a modern hybrid language between Arabic Amazigh French and Spanish and it cannot be said that it is an Arabic dialect because it does not follow Arabic rules and is not understood by Arabs
خاصك تفهمي ان الدارجة ماشي سميت لهجة الدارجة مصطلح عربي يعني العامية أو المعيارية ويتكلمو بها الوطن العربي كله من العراق إلى المغرب ماتبقايش تستخدمي شي مصطلح عربي ماعرفاش المعنى ديالو
WRONG! Aramaic has NEVER been the major or only language in Northern Iraq or Syria! NEVER. It was a minor language throughout history. Hurrian was native there followed by Median and Scythian which replaced it and evolved into kurdish.
The South Semitic classification is outdated.