Planing, Closed-Position, and Drop Two: Three Ways to Harmonize a Melody
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 29 авг 2024
- ✅ Buy Jeremy's book 📚 at www.jeremysiski...
✅ Buy me a coffee! ☕️ bmc.link/siski...
✅ Schedule a lesson 📆 w/Jeremy. Save $5 w/code RUclips: rb.gy/fatrw
✅ Sign up 📝 for Jeremy's mailing list at eepurl.com/geqUkz
Pianist, author, and mathemagician Jeremy Siskind shares the similarities and differences between planing, closed-position, and drop two voicings, using the lead-in to the bridge of "Misty" by Erroll Garner as an example.
Don't know about the verb for planing, but when I comp and try planing behind a soloist, after the gig he will come right up to me complaining about my comp-planing 😂... Anyways, thanks for the lesson once again Jeremy!
A proof by induction for you to think about:
- The 1st Jeremy Siskind video I watched was the best
- Each Jeremy Siskind video is better than last
I only discovered you a few months ago and already have I purchased your book.
I also can't wait for your open studio course. Thank you for being such an incredible teacher.
Love from Sydney
Great lesson maestro!
Never heard the term planing before, what you described it as is something I did a lot on guitar and just called it harmonizing with a cluster (of intervals). On guitar because of the slide rule aspect of the neck it's actually easy to do. I had some traditional harmony zealots say it is called Parallel harmony, all I know is it's a cool sound especially with an ugly cluster of intervals and the melody on top making it work.
Great teacher always
Thank you,Maestro🌹🌹🌹🌹
Great! The note in the left hand, bar 2, at 6:30? Why F, and not Bflat ?
Looks like a notational mistake; he played it as a Bb at 6:43
You can drop the second voice in rootless voicings as well. This lets you incorporate situations where the melody is a 7th, 9th (2nd) and 13th (6th).
Incidentally, this general type of harmonised voicing is the bread and butter of big band arranging: generally melody doubled drop two for saxes, close position for trumpets and drop three or drop two and four for bones. Drop three and drop two and four are generally too wide to be used standalone though, as with piano comping.
Yes, indeed! Thanks for the great comment!
Amazing harmonic devices. Thank you
:start planing and figure out how to resolve: - that's a strategy I can put my head around :) By the same token, if you know the setlist in advance, you could practice/prep specific planing strategies at key moments (choose to use or not depending on the vibe in the moment). I'm not sure my brain could work backwards from the target voicing in real time.
Nice. Thx
He/She “planes”. I think it checks out Jeremy. 😅👍🏼
"Plane that!"