Messi vs Ronaldo 😂😂😂 Rob, I really don’t know if I am more eager to expand my musicianship with your clear teaching videos or to experience your latest humourous moment 😅 Please keep up the good work!
It is definitely an interesting approach but at the same time, my mind was constantly questioning why not just write a completely new melody & harmony whilst following the rhythm & vibe.. and it would get you a very similar results but without any calculations involved..
in a strict conversion you should also invert the 'decorations' or 'ornamentations'. So a bending going up to the target note should now go down to the inverted target. Right?
Very good explanation! but I have a question, all your examples only use diatonic chords and notes, what happens when you transform a chord sequence that contains true modal interchange (minor in major or vice versa) or secondary dominants how do you change these?
@@QJamTracks Like the tree analogy, above the surface the main character pursues a goal, a clear objective, while doing so they should discover what they truly need in their life, what was hidden underneath in their subconscious. In order to reach this discovery they need to go through many "Negative" obstacles, potentially leading to greater "Harmony".
9:28 I think you could pick almost any coherent progression and melody, and so long as it arrives back at the tonic, it's going to sound, as you put it, _connected._ That, I think, is more the rhythm than the melody itself. But using inverted harmony just gives an automatic ‘one weird trick’ method. For instance, doubling each interval takes us into atonal territory (although kinder than microtonal harmony), and it still hangs together beautifully with a little trimming up here & there. I just tried it with the same _Still Got the Blues_ phrase. (I started down the path of half intervals but I no longer had the blues, I had a headache.) I'm not by any means taking away from the idea you're presenting. I'm adding that you can "maths" your way to any new harmony and it'll be surprising, but crucially, it'll also be inspiring. And there are plenty of other "one weird trick"s to play besides! Thanks for the video!
According to Shred´s series "if written by Bach" you have melody, inversion, retrograde and retrograde inversion. Fascinating if you can do the same with the harmonic structure..... retrograde harmony.... retrograde inverted harmony...,- does this become retrograde inverted negative harmony...,- or? Anyone?
Shared knowledge like this should be awarded. All your videos are stellar. Gratitude and thanks.
Messi vs Ronaldo 😂😂😂 Rob, I really don’t know if I am more eager to expand my musicianship with your clear teaching videos or to experience your latest humourous moment 😅
Please keep up the good work!
I appreciated the subtle humor interlaced in this video lol. Glad you are tackling this subject, its something I've been curious about.
Love all the diagrams you share and your clarity. Sets your videos apart from the rest. So helpful! Thank you.
Quite literally, I was saying "Messi and Ronaldo" in my head a nanosecond before you lol. Cool vid, my g
:)
Finally I understand this. Thankyou. Your videos are always to the point and outstanding.
It is definitely an interesting approach but at the same time, my mind was constantly questioning why not just write a completely new melody & harmony whilst following the rhythm & vibe.. and it would get you a very similar results but without any calculations involved..
Wonderful explanation!! Thanks
Interesting. So the "contrary motion" my guitar lessons had, were a form of this inversion.
Another great, well explained, easy to understand video.
Thanks Rob!
Very interesting concept to explore 👍
very very nice video
You really made it easy to understand
Very, very good...Gran Master...Guitar
Thank you ❤️
Very interesting!!
Very nice !
in a strict conversion you should also invert the 'decorations' or 'ornamentations'. So a bending going up to the target note should now go down to the inverted target. Right?
contrary motion for the win
Very good explanation! but I have a question, all your examples only use diatonic chords and notes, what happens when you transform a chord sequence that contains true modal interchange (minor in major or vice versa) or secondary dominants how do you change these?
Reminds me of want and need in story theory.
Interesting! In what way?
@@QJamTracks Like the tree analogy, above the surface the main character pursues a goal, a clear objective, while doing so they should discover what they truly need in their life, what was hidden underneath in their subconscious. In order to reach this discovery they need to go through many "Negative" obstacles, potentially leading to greater "Harmony".
9:28 I think you could pick almost any coherent progression and melody, and so long as it arrives back at the tonic, it's going to sound, as you put it, _connected._ That, I think, is more the rhythm than the melody itself. But using inverted harmony just gives an automatic ‘one weird trick’ method.
For instance, doubling each interval takes us into atonal territory (although kinder than microtonal harmony), and it still hangs together beautifully with a little trimming up here & there. I just tried it with the same _Still Got the Blues_ phrase. (I started down the path of half intervals but I no longer had the blues, I had a headache.)
I'm not by any means taking away from the idea you're presenting. I'm adding that you can "maths" your way to any new harmony and it'll be surprising, but crucially, it'll also be inspiring. And there are plenty of other "one weird trick"s to play besides!
Thanks for the video!
According to Shred´s series "if written by Bach" you have melody, inversion, retrograde and retrograde inversion.
Fascinating if you can do the same with the harmonic structure..... retrograde harmony.... retrograde inverted harmony...,- does this become retrograde inverted negative harmony...,- or?
Anyone?
How do you determine the harmony?
Could be open or closed harmony ?
if collier is mozart then i'm hendrix reincarnated
And so on......😉😶🌫️
One more long and detailed video about negative harmony bullshit.