It takes a lot of courage to stand up and say and do what you are doing. I like the way you are opening the eyes of those who are near and dear to you by methodically, and factually breaking things down. Wish you all the best in your journey.
SubhanAllah! Every word spoken is the truth of reality of the 'Cult'. It is an Agakhani cult no doubt about it, and nobody can deny it after knowing the truth of fake Imam./ MayAllahSalaam/peace.
Why don’t you check his lineage do you know what that word means??? When are you so cold or not as a Muslim your not here to judge any one or anything.
Just add one more line , Ismaili Muslims are ethnically, culturally and geographically diverse community. Salim is only talking about his family ( Khoja family). Khoja makes a small portion of this large traditions of ismailis the community. Salim knowledge and understanding is very shallow and mostly based his mistreatment experience in Austrlia seems all on personal reasons or may be for more authorities.
Great Lalani, we can't see your episodes in Canada and UK, Please use alternative social media platform like Reddit...... I believe this Aga Khan is behind all Lalani videos blockage
Ok so this boggles my mind. Ppl pay 12.5% to this 'leader' to avoid going to hell, and no one thinks this is a scam, while Khan is one of the richest ppl in the world? The definition of a scam is paying non stop payments to any individual or party despite your situation. Same as Qadiani fees. May Allah give guidance to all those fooled.
No is a charity aga wealth is by doing business not from member The aga khan foundation has done so much in Afghanistan we don’t pay nothing at all Pluse Ismaili faith are far more richer in any countries specially in Canada I am Shia but I respect the Ismaili Other sect of Islam collect money to creat Islamic extremist group and destroy life While the Ismaili are.very peaceful kind and open mind people Good fore you free to do what ever want to do but try to show the good side of Ismaili people too
@@Uyiiouuoiuiiuyi you should do some research, he doesn’t help anyone it’s a business which is designed by people even worse than AK. Countries they “help” shouldn’t be in poverty and struggling to survive especially when they’re rich with natural resources.
Allah has guided Br Salim away from that evil. Now he needs to make the next step towards sunni Islam. Zakat is approximately 2.5% of disposable income.
4:15 “perception is not reality” May Allah bless you. Brother Salim love to give you a big hug my Brother. It took me 40 years to find the Truth “Islam” too. الحمدلله
Assalamu alaikum be careful of this man in his old youtube Channel he subscribed to channels that insulte Islam and our Noble Prophet, May Allah grant Him Peace and Blessings. He might say things that are true but they remain tainted by what he may still have in his heart...
May Allah bless you. I left the Ismaili system when I was 19 and I am just amazed to watch your videos which I luckily came across only yesterday. Even when we followed the Ismaili system we were never so strict with dasond as back then my father had burdens of rasing his own family and support his parents although he always believed he should pay it.
Our Nabi when through lot still is I am sure your massage will help to decide their future from what been said if you didn’t some would have said more louder very loiter was known about Ismaili religion I am suuni have lot friends who are Ismaili my religion thought us to respect other we never discuss anything just salaam with my Sunni brothers no secret intact we always corrected each other when ever we discuss the topic they way we pray or anything to do with hala or haram and this way we had respect for each other’s may Allah forgive us and guide us all Ameen
15,000,000 deluded followers who need to re-think if they are really Muslim. And who the hell gave him the right to call himself "Prince"? ... Imam? Really?
It takes alot of courage to speak out, the system is so well structured that its pretty much impossible to think out of the box, from being born in an aga khani hospital to get educated in aga khan school to die in a aga khani graveyard, I am so glad that my family stopped following when I was 5, and remember the grief they got from other family members, now most of my extended family are out sadly few are still stuck in system and its just too difficult for them to leave due to various reasons like loosing good friends and support by community and children could get divorced or kicked out of their houses because of the actions by parents.
I will always stand by my Imam, Ale-nabi, Aulad-e-Ali. My imam lives in my heart. He is loving, kind, polite and humble. Always taught me good and never speaks badly of anyone. He is very tolerant and merciful, just like RasollAllah. I love my Mowla just like many other Ismailis and our Mowla loves us even more. Call me blind, brainwashed, but matters of heart and soul can't be described. Accusations you put on my Mowla similar ones were put by Meccans on the final Prophet and even today he is mocked by unbelievers by making caricatures. My Mowla and his family Iam sure are aware of all such organized campaigns like yours on the youtube and other social media platforms, but shows tolerance, and forgiveness and never incites us to retaliate. We wish you peace and harmony in this universe.
Aga Khan didn't appear very tolerant when he published his speech (farman) in 1899 where he said "Arabs are like donkeys". Can you imagine, not only did he get caught saying that, but he actually published it himself. It can be seen close to the bottom of this page - insideismailism.wordpress.com/2015/10/30/truth-about-isma%CA%BFili-ginans/amp/
I always questioned this religion.. relentlessly.. grew up with many of them.. living next to Jamaat Khanaan, I was always curious how secretive they were and none was allowed in their worship place.
Yep, my AK friends never talked about what goes on there. We were not "allowed" to enter their residential compounds. Most of us friends didn't care as we just studied and played together.
Question RELIGION in general and you'll stop worshipping the prophets and "holy books" too. If your conscience is clean, YOU'RE THE RELIGION. You don't need no prophets and messenger to show the right path. You got a brain that functions.
@@samsamani7 Beware of men like this. He just created his own God in his own mind to serve his own desires “We are admonished to ‘trust in the Lord with all thine heart; and lean not unto thine own understanding.’ (Prov. 3:5.) And we are warned: ‘Woe unto them that are wise in their own eyes, and prudent in their own sight!” (Isa. 5:21.)” Who but a fool would make his own god- an idol that cannot help him one bit? (Isaiah 44:10)
You are definitely a man on a mission !! And the way you present your facts with clarity and a calm mind Your words are pure Gold !!! Your reward is the ultimate destination You will be amongst those that Allah will reward abundantly
I like the way you present ..though couldn't get your exact motive behind this ...being a common men I barely care about what my old/dearest friend personal thoughts r , I could have help him instead of stopping him paying dasond that could have make my life more easier , Quick questions 1, any ismaili book in record shows agha khan himself writing himself God? 2, any Ismaili religious book reference that demand dasond by hook or crook un conditional ? 3, being a financial specialist you must have evidence of your own work that evaluate your work n performance for agha in past when you were doing your job and counting mureeds incoming ? This is a healthy discussion first question will help me way find your way of perception vs reality Appreciated
Dear Sabir I wish all my viewers were like you. Wanting to have a healthy discussion. Lets start with my friend. Your suggestion was to help him personally instead of stopping him from paying dasond. Sabir I was only trying to make him financially independent on me or anyone else. If he were to stop paying dasond he would not need help. Regarding other questions you will need to watch the whole series. It will not only answer all your questions but will provide evidence you are looking for. Kind regards Salim
Salim appreciate u consider me , even my own blood relative lets take mother father would have ever come to me for help or tell me or convince me to help on any perspective if they came for n intention that m some one who will help them n once I try to speak a word and they shut the door on me I swear that was the last relation on planet for me, I would have ever turn back on any thing ........look we don't have so called warden to live 100 years today even a freind like taxi driver know what u thinking about practices ...my point is do u carry an idea to move forward instead of doing free marketing for n entity ? Let's meet i don't mind to fly ur place not to convince u but to explore what u got ....hope I convey my point ...
Simple but very insightful questions you raised; but the one that was most resounding to me is: "What gives Aga Khan the right to personally own the religious views when the Prophet did not have that right?" You are an independent thinker and strong willed. You said that you are not interested in any religion, but I want to say to you: "may Allah guide you and shower His blessings on you" - A retired Winnipegger, Canada
Outstanding, non-partial and well documented video. It's easy to see you are very well read and not influenced or brainwashed. Thanks for sharing. I'm a journalist and author of historic based novels based on the Mediterranean and the Near East. I work out of Mexico and write for magazines in Spain and have productions in Colombia. Is there any way I can get ahold of you directly to see if a I can share this information in Latin America and create more awareness of this cult?
As per my experience which is onpaper also, that there is no Humanity in AKDN/Ismailism. Please see in google By type "Hasamukh Vadasariya & Agakhan" Thanks...
"There is no one greater than myself. If you think of God, then it is myself. If you think about Imam, then too, it is me. And your Beloved Master is also me. There is no one except myself" The Aga Khan March 16th 1902 I don't know how much patience I can have with ismailis who see this quote but still don't want to even try to distance themselves from their cult. So disappointing.
Dasond is not mandatory, however is encouraged just like ANY other faith. Whoever taught you this ideology is wrong in doing so, your information is far from the truth! The Ismaili people are one of the kindness communities who want to see real change in quality of life in the east, which is why many families pay Dasond, in order to better their standard of living in developing countries across the world. The word used by the Imam is ‘obligation’ and that words meaning differs to the meaning of the word YOU use in your video which is ‘mandatory’. Our present imam actually states that it is “voluntary”. Paying Dasond is a moral ‘obligation’ and not a ‘mandatory’ task like you have claimed it to be in this video at (24:45) The word ‘Obligation’ means that it is morally a good thing to do (just like you are obligated to look after your parents or your siblings) weather you choose to do this or not is YOUR CHOICE. Never has the present day Aga Khan said that it is ‘mandatory’ to pay this dasond like you have made out to be truth trough claiming he has taught us all to do this, which is just not true at all. Never has the present day imam said this. The word used by the imam is ‘Obligatory’ - therefore you should look up the definition of both words and actually reflect on the meaning before you start to teach others and manipulate those viewers to believe these lies. This information is highly incorrect and manipulative. Each individual chooses to give money through the form of Dasond out of pure generosity. And if you think I am wrong and can prove it please quote me exactly where, when and to what context the imam has stated it is ‘Mandatory’, I have looked and there is no such saying. Stop lying to people! In Islam you give zakat, in Christianity you give Tithe (a percentage of your earning) is the Ismaili faith we give Dasond. My source: CBC interview ‘Man Alive with Bonisteel’ (Canada) 8th October 1986 “It is entirely voluntary” - Aga Khan 1986
@@salimlalani with respect, I’m on episode 7 and I have many many issues with what you are saying as I too have questioned the faith and was in the same place as you, and I too have sat on the pat like you have to lead religion ceremonies, however I can at least tell the truth when stating the facts. Firstly you can’t even give me a proper reply to my first comment, so I ask you why? Is it because I’ve caught you on a lie and you now don’t know what to say back to me? I think this is the case here. And that’s because the imam of the time never used the word you claim he did. The word mandatory is not in any Farman in the last 20 years in the context of dasond. May I remind you that I have put references to prove that it is optional and this indicates you have lied in this first video, and I also have proof you are not telling the truth in multiple other videos or in some cases at least stretching the truth and miss out key facts to shape others into thinking the false information is truth. You say no Ismaili will stand up and talk, but here I am. You ask the question in later videos, where does the money go? I have had first hand experience in attending Global Encounters in Kenya in 2016 and have seen the institutions he has built with this money with my own two eyes. We went into schools, we started work on projects in a sustainable way, we saw the amount of jobs he has created in the east, and above all he has taught us that sustainability is everything. That in itself is a huge blessing. Never has it ever been mandatory in my life time to pay Dasond to the imam and this is the truth. It is only encouraged through an obligation to be a decent human being, not just a Muslim. As for the help in the west, you are a mukhi like you said, for a majlis that you have to pay a lot of money to attend so why didn’t you help your friend with financial difficulties if he was struggling to feed his family? You clearly have money if you were mukhi of that kind of majlis right? I would have thought any decent friend would help his spiritual brother if he is in need. And especially if he has children. I must admit the financial aid is hard to find and far more transparency is needed within our community between the council and the public, however I say this with personal experience that my own family themselves were helped in this country by Ismaili financial aid when they first entered the country. So what you tell people isn’t actually accurate information. The Ismaili community helps eachother. This is how it has always been. But I’d like to discuss this further with you. Let me highlight that I say this with no hatred at all, only frustration in the fact that people can not see eye to eye anymore at a time where is is absolutely vital to stand together. However I can not lie that I’m quite baffled at how you reached these far fetched conclusions about Dasond and social welfare. If it wasn’t for the help my family received through social welfare my family would have starved. There were at that time 6 too 7 people living under one roof in a council house just to paint you the picture.
@@shaazlalani8700 You see by that arguement even Pablo Escobar gave out some charity, and the recipients swear to this day that he was a good man, it is very clever indoctrination. Ask yourself, if you are muslim whom to follow. These people are claiming to be "Imams" and descendants of the prophet PBUH but they are not. They play upon the weakness of the masses, everybody is not knowledgeable or educated in history, so they come up with the idea that Imam so and so in the 9th century did so and so. For true Islam you got to come to the Quran and the Sunnah of the prophet. Islam was not built on Imams or ahel-l-bait, it is built on the Quran and Sunnah thats it. After the death of the prophet, the enemies of Islam were hell bent on distroying Islam and if you research that period there were many wars with the kufars and munafiks. One of their melicious plans was to kill Hussain the prophets grandson. If you take a close look, all this took place in the frontier regions of the expanding muslim empire, not in the Hijaz (Mecca and Medina). Why? Because they didn't dare do that at the center where everybody would recognise them, so they played their dirty games far away in Kuffa, Egypt (the Fatimids). In Egypt they even named their nation after the prophets daughter Fatima....to fool people. The Zakat is 2.5% and most important, is due ANNUALLY. Dasond is on every paycheck and is 12.5%. Big difference, as we say "Asman aur zamin ka farak". It is shirk to worship a human. Read the Quran, follow the Sunnah and study Islamic history. Also, study Greek, Roman, Mesopotamian history and see how those people were pagan.
@AV "Imams don't need us. We need Imamat." Actually, Aga Khan may need your money if he's going to afford to spend hundreds of millions on mega yachts and big settlements to keep adultery claims out of court.
I was born in Uganda, East Africa and we had there a community of Agha Khanis (also known as Khojas). In childhood in the 1960's early 70's, we used to hear our parents mentioning the Agha Khan and he seemed to be some misterious figure. In late 1972 we left Uganda (due to Idi Amin's expulsion order) and were evacuated to a holding camp in Spain, where we had afew Agha Khani families in our group. At the time as a 13 year old we heard about "Prince Sadrudin Agha Khan" as being the head of the UNHCR in Geneva. A lot was happening in our camp but what we know is that many of the Khojas/Ismaili families chose to apply for Canada as their first choice of settlement. I can only surmise that messages were passed through their underground network. Some in our Spain group including my family ended up in Dubai and Abu Dhabi, UAE, which was not right as this country was not a signatory of the UN Convention on Refugees and we started facing problems there as soon as we landed. It was a fiasco with all the wars, corruption and lack of transperency there. Not satisfied with the UNHCR office in Beirut, I later wrote to the head himself "Prince Sadrudin" in Geneva, and I did get a reply but it was just diplomatic and basically said to help ourselves. I thought of this man as just another human being but there was a mystery around him, the "Prince" title and the way he is recieved by heads of states etc. I am Sunni muslim and to us monotheism is paramount. I knew a little about the Khojas as there is no literature about them, but you have brought a lot out, people need to know in this age of information. This is the difference between us and our forefathers 100, 200 years ago.The prophet SAW did not own fine horses, palaces and lands or gold and silver. "You can fool some of the people all the time, or all the people some of the time, but you cannot fool all the people all the time" . J F Kennedy.
@@nooraliismail1615 I went to the Ismaili website and I was a little disappointed because it didn't say anything about the secretive system of taking large amounts of money from devotees who have been made to believe that an ostentatious billionaire cult leader is God on earth. When Ismaili TV start talking about that, they might get a few more RUclips hits.
As a Muslim you need to study the Holy Qur'an with its authentic commentary. You need to study the biographies of the Holy Prophet Muhammad and his twelve Rightful Successors (peace and blessings of Allah be upon them all). Then you compare your Imam/guide /leader in the mirror of the Book of Allah, the sunnah of the Holy Prophet and his twelve Rightful successors/vicegerents (peace and blessings of Allah be upon them all). Do not be scared to ask questions. Do not be a blind believer. If you are following a wrong guide or a leader without a thorough investigation, you will ruin your hereafter and there is no question for having a second chance either. The best gift Allah has granted us human beings is aql (common sense). Do not be stingy or economical with it.
The Ismailis have helped people outside the community not just the Ismailis. Why don't you non believers spend your time in really helping people like what the Aga Khan does as opposed to trying to convince people in what you believe. The Ismailis are happy and accept the Imam as their Spiritual Leader and Guide to worldly matters. We have all heard what is being said here and doesn't phase our allegiance to the Aga Khan.
While this comment is long, nonetheless, it may be of interest to anyone who has an open mind to facts. Salim Lalani's presentations appear to be respectful to the subject matter. And they also appear to have good intentions behind them. However, his efforts involving his personal subjective interpretations on Aga Khan, have to be interpreted with both an open mind, and also as an act of his personal sincerity to others; if it has to have any educational and positive benefits. As long as Salim Lalani focuses on historical facts including "the historical context" behind them with sincere intentions; he will be doing a "sattvic seva", a personal act of sincerity - which is very consistent with the ancient Indian wisdom. Examples of what I mean by emphasis on historical context behind the facts: 1) Historically; Shia Ismaili Imams, have never self imposed their spiritual leadership authority on their followers. Nor have they imposed the secular guidance on their followers. 2) If "some" of the Shia Ismaili Imams history is very vague, the reason is that Ismailis in general and their Imams in particular, were historically being prosecuted by majority others due to Ismailis emphasis on "esoteric interpretations of faith". This resulted in a practice of "taqqiya", a common sense practice at that time, which forced them to remain in hiding for their protection and welfare of their families. But that "taqqiya" practice also involved leaders of the community of that time being witnesses to the events "whose trust cannot be discounted when they vouched the validity of their Imams". 3) The Shia Ismaili Constitution is the guiding document that makes references not only to the historical circumstances, but also to the Shia Ismaili doctrine of Tawhid (belief in one God none other then Allah) including the traditions with regards to the leadership of Ismaili Imamat. Therefore, the constitution should be read in the full context basis and "not on cherry picked basis". Otherwise, it has "a serious potential to be misunderstood and misconstrued". 4) Historic tradition of the Ismailis, in accepting and following the guidance of their Imams, has benefited the community as being one of the most progressive traditions within the Umma. Other very specific benefits being: open minded in the esoteric interpretation of faith, very respectful and tolerant of other traditions within the Umma and other faiths, emphasis on the use of intellect when interpreting their faith and other daily activities, maintain balance between din and duniya, etc. My suggestion to Salim Lalani is that his videos can potentially have benefits, if he continues focusing on historical facts as well as genuine "historical context" behind them. And for that, I humbly request he be sincere in his intentions.🙏 As a benefit to all the interested readers, a very important message: If any member of the Ismaili tariqa, the tariqa's secondary leadership or any other person who intentionally interprets the Ismaili Muslims faith and it's core beliefs other then as articulated in the guiding document of the Shia Ismaili Muslim's constitution; such a member, the secondary leadership or the person is not only misrepresenting the facts as intended; but is also doing a great dis-service to the Ismaili faith in general and the Shia Ismaili Muslim's Imam in particular. The later also being referred to as the current Aga Khan. A note to the readers: All quotation marks in my comments are simply to emphasize some important points for the benefit of clarity.
Ali bhai, with all due respect I disagree with your arguments in defending the institution of Imamat. Here is my response to your arguments 1. Aga Khan, after he arrived in India did impose authority over Khoja community. There are many historical references and court cases available to review. You may refer and read court proceedings involving Aga Khan during British rule in India. Please refer to Ismaili Dua which was recited in Jamat Khanas before 1957. Imam was called to be Mahesh, Brahma and Vishnu (worshipped in India as gods) and of course Ali Sahi Allah (Ali true god) Aga Khan III even claimed in a Farman made in Zanzibar in 1899 that the current Quran is incomplete and he had the actual copy of Quran. Check the attached farman if you can read Khojki ibb.co/N9pR8N3 But this is irrelevant, what actually matters is even if they did not impose their authority, how does it make them equal to Allah (SWT)? No Ismaili can deny the fact that in JamatKhana Ismailis raise their hand and call out to Aga Khan to forgive their sins, give barakah in earnings (rozi ma barkat) and so on whereas Quran clearly states that our Prophet (PBUH) is Bashir and Nazeer (one who brings goods news and warns). Do you have any example during the time of Prophet Muhammad that Muslims used to raise their hands and ask him to forgive their sins in his absence? Or do you have any verse from Quran supporting such action? 2. For the sake of argument even if I accept your argument #2, how do you explain the absence of Imam Hasan from the list of Ismaili Imams. Ismaili Imamat history establishes that Ismailis and Twelvers Shia (Itha Asharis) were one community until Imam Jaffer Sadiq. According to the Ismaili history the split occurred after the death of Imam Jaffer Sadiq. At what point in history one community decided that Imam Hasan was Imam and other community decided that Imam Hasan was not Imam. 3. No comments, any community can have their own set of rules. 4. There is no denial that Ismailis are successful as a community. But most of the Ismailies are unable to understand the cost they are paying to achieve economic success. If success in life is to be measured by economic success than no doubt Ismailies are successful but there is more to life than economic success. Ali Bhai whatever you believe, it is none of my business but I request you to study Quran and then justify Ismaili beliefs in the light of Quran.
Dear Mr Kassam I welcome your comments and I wish to assure you that my work is about spreading awareness that our faith should not be blind. I Agakhan’s case we need to ask ourselves how can someone be God when it is a known fact he has been caught twice with his pants down Mr Kassam I humbly suggest that you reserve your comments until you have watched the entire series I must admit you come across to me as a very reasonable person Great to read your comments
Amyn Pabani, your comments are very courteous, respectful and appreciated. Thank you kindly. Since you have directly asked me, I am therefore hoping that the following response may offer you some answers: 1) We can always respectfully agree to disagree. After all, that is the beauty of subjective interpretations of our perceptions. 2) Considering that RUclips comments section is not necessarily an appropriate forum to engage into a back and forth discussion; I will therefore, respectfully refrain from doing that. 3) Yet your questions are valid and your point of view has many merits. They surely deserve to be answered. For that, may I refer you to the constitution of the Shia Ismaili Muslims? It may not have specific or all answers to your questions; but very likely, you may find some answers therein. Alternatively, it may lead you to an appropriate authorised channel that can provide you with some specific answers.
@Akbar Lakhani, your response has many interesting and thought provoking merits. They are much appreciated. To all the readers interested in this subject matter, this comment may be long, but surely worth your time. The Shia Ismaili Muslim's tradition has a guiding document refered to as the "Shia Ismaili Muslim's Constitution". The said constitution is approved by the Shia Ismaili Muslim's Imam of the time, and clearly articulates the following: 1) The Ismaili Muslims core doctrine of the Tawhid - which is the belief in one God none other then Allah. 2) The historical and traditional references to the beginning of Imamat institution. 3) The role and the authority of the Imamat evolving not only as the Imam of time, but also implied as the Murshid of his murids. 4) Many other very relevant facts. The traditional function and authority of the Murshid in Ismaili Muslims tariqa is comparable to any other Islamic Sufi tariqas. Meaning, it also involves a spiritual bond between the Murshid and his murids upon satisfying certain requirements such as a bayah. It is therefore imperative, that the Shia Ismaili Muslims doctrine and their faith practices should be understood from the focal point of the Shia Ismaili Muslim's constitution. And it should be read in the full context basis and not on cherry picked basis. Otherwise, it has a serious potential to be misunderstood and misconstrued. Once again; as a benefit to all the interested readers, another very important message: If any member of the Ismaili tariqa, the tariqa's secondary leadership or any other person who intentionally interprets the Ismaili Muslims faith and it's core beliefs other then as articulated in the guiding document of the Shia Ismaili Muslim's constitution; such a member, the secondary leadership or the person is not only misrepresenting the facts as intended; but is also doing a great dis-service to the Ismaili faith in general and the Shia Ismaili Muslim's Imam in particular. The later also being referred to as the current Aga Khan.
@@akbarlakhani6624 it is very interesting to hear someone who is defending Ismailism admitting to the belief that the Aga Khan is God. So you’re really saying that it was all a mistake and that the problem is being rectified? What about the one eighth of personal income that people have paid to the Aga Khan believing that he is God? Will they be offered a refund? Will they be told that they shouldn’t continue to pay him until they are clear that he is not a God?
Ismailis believe in one God just as all muslims do. We look to the imam for guidance. Also, I was brought up Ismaili and was never indoctrinated with regards to Dasond. Infact, there is writing that one should give dasond out of love in your heart, not because you have to.
Thank you Alykhan Any comments on the ginan where Pir says Allah yehi Imam? If possible, also comment on ginans and waezes approved by Agakhan that threaten you about horrible consequences in hell if you dont pay dasond! Hopefully your guidance will lead me to the right path. Salim
Sir the question is he collects dasond whithout receipts which is illegal according to Quran and according to the law of the land. This is sufficient to unfollow him.
Why the secrecy about the collection of monies in jamat khana. The money aspect is very concerning and unsettling, where is the accountability nothing is transparent at all.
Hello, I am an Ismaili and can state the Aga Khan does not consider himself to be a god and neither do I not any of the community. It is such a shame you have taken on a role to spread mis-truth and resentment instead of love, tolerance, understanding and interconnectedness. May you be blessed with good health, happiness and the courage to tell the truth. Please be honest. Thank you.
As per my experience which is onpaper also, that there is no Humanity in AKDN/Ismailism. Please see in google By type "Hasamukh Vadasariya & Agakhan" Thanks...
@@karimallidina6633 , I agree with. There are even many interviews of Hazir imam ( Aga khan) available on you tube where He categorically declaring that He has never consider himself God . This guy Salim ( I feel sorry for him) for the mistreatment He got from his own people has chosen this grudges on you tube and maligning the Imam of the time. His information is propaganda , fake , shallow knowledge. Imam never needs our money and I am an Isma'ili from PAMIR. There is no such compulsion to pay money.
I am from Pamir (Tajikistan) born as a Shia Ismaili muslim ,please stop deceiving people . We are not saying he is God . We follow Allah , Muhammad, Ali and all the descendants of the Prophet Muhammad through his cousin Imam Ali. He is Imam the one who makes interpretation of Islam to his followers. Proud to be an Ismaili ❤️ShukranAllah
You accuse me of deceiving when I have given you the evidence that Agakhan has approved ginans depicting him as God. Pls read Allah ek khasam sabuka before you accuse me again.
Aga Khan is referred as Saheebi Zaamani Wal Asara in first part of ismaili Dua' . It means Lord of Time and Age. What Quran says That no person sent by Allah will say to people that I am your lord. Imam is Fraud Wake up. I am ex ismaili now. 79. No person to whom God has given the Scripture, and wisdom, and prophethood would ever say to the people, “Be my worshipers rather than God’s.” Rather, “Be people of the Lord, according to the Scripture you teach, and the teachings you learn.” 80. Nor would he command you to take the angels and the prophets as lords. Would he command you to infidelity after you have submitted?
[72:18] The places of worship are for God. So do not call, besides God, upon anyone else. (49 Imam names are called in Dua and Imam says in farman to worship him : Call names of Imam) [10:106] And do not call, apart from God, on what neither benefits you nor harms you. If you do, you are then one of the wrongdoers.
Salam Eyaan be careful of this man in his old youtube Channel he subscribed to channels that insulte Islam and our Noble Prophet, May Allah grant Him Peace and Blessings. He might say things that are true but they remain tainted by what he may still have in his heart...
@@salimlalani I have spend 30 years living near Agha Khan jammat khana near garden east Karachi... Ismailis call him hazir Imam, segregated well jelled community mostly keeping to themselves. Standard of living has also improved over the years
My perspective First of all being Ismaili, I do not relate not paying dasond with hell or paying dasond with heaven. My thought process is paying dasond is long term investment with thousand fold returns. Do you agree that your forefathers and other people of Ismaili community were poor/farmers back in Indian villages and struggled to make their ends meet, but were still paying Dasond? They paid Dasond and believed in Imam and outcome is that their next generations(not talking about 100 families but the entire community) are well educated or have migrated to USA/Canada/other countries and are no longer in such situations. I have seen how my life has changed when I compare it with my forefathers and I am thankful for them to keep strong hold on pillars of faith, dasond, etc. and it is because of this, I will continue to pay Dasond and follow faith for the better future of my generations. I do not care how Imam uses my Dasond, but I am proud to say if a very small section of my forefather dasond was used to help Ismailis in 1972 Uganda crisis or my current dasond is used to help non ismailiis around the world via AKDN or helping ismailis in poor situations. FYI :- Nice try.... It was fun to watch the above video. Hope you contribute some money to your friend from revenue generated by views or advertisement :P
To be fair, people from Indian ancestry, including Khoja/Gujarati people, who moved to the west normally become economically successful, whether they are Ismaili or not. And it's interesting you say that you don't care how Aga Khan uses your dasond money and you'd be happy if only a small proportion of it goes to good causes. Asking no accountability of him is giving him a higher status than Muslims gave the Prophet Muhammad (peace and blessings upon him). And this is one of many ways that ismailis put the Aga Khan above the Prophet. Anyway I'm glad that you feel some benefit from your community. I personally feel like a freer person now that I don't have a blind loyalty to a man of questionable character who I've never met before.
First some videos disappeared and then the whole channel got deleted. A bit worrying. Hope all is okay, Salim! Please let us know if there's anything more we can do to support.
I hv a question that if Aga Khan takes money from disciples does he give the agakhanis medical facility,education and loan also to start bussiness?? Just curious no intent to hurt anyone's belief..it takes lots of courage to go aginst family members belief..pls keep going..may Allah grant u with funds and resources..
He forgot his ancestors who used to worship the animals and statues. He forgot when Uthmanids empire, Mughals, English people and Mullahs attacked them and converted them by the force of sword, doing sexual assault with their children, their adults, their women and men in the mosques and today they see with their own eyes. He forgot the situation of his ancestors in past decades and centuries and the condition of his people when they were in a big disaster. He forgot who rescued these people from such misery and now he is alive, he has freedom (free oxygen, free environment to use, free everything he needs in his material life. So, these material life has made him blind and brainwashed him. I don’t know which God he has found and has believe in now? I wish him good health and to cure his memory loss soon. 👍🏻
Since assuming his role in 1957, the current Aga Khan has dedicated his efforts to improving the quality of life of the most vulnerable populations in many parts of the world, while emphasising the view of Islam as a thinking, spiritual faith: one that teaches compassion and tolerance and that upholds human dignity. In recognition of his exceptional efforts and contributions, the Aga Khan has received numerous decorations, honorary degrees, and awards from institutions and nations across the world. Your video clearly confuses fact and fiction. What you offer as fact is so skewed/stretched!
Imam Mustansir Bi’llah II, the 32nd Ismaili Imam: “It is obligatory and necessary for the true believer to recognize his Creator who is manifest in this world in the form of a human being, and to see Him here in order to see Him also in the hereafter.” [Imam Mustansir Bi’llah II, Pandiyat-I-Jawanmardi Or Advices of Manliness, trans. W. Ivanow (Leiden, Netherlands: E. J. Brill, 1953), 101-102.]
I am ismalili and I’m 19 grew up in Houston Texas where we have a large population of Ismaili about 40k and during my time we never ever portrayed aga khan as god we consider him a guide or a messenger of Allah and we never felt forced to pay for dasond I mean I do believe in dasond because it’s my me of the fiver pillars of Islam and that hazar Imam utilizes the money for Ismailis all around the world if I have extra money I usually put it towards dasond but I never felt forced I would usually volunteer and give seva because I felt like that was my dasond to Imam and it made me happy
what you have written is based on belief not truth for example, imam is utilizes money for ismailies i have paid him for 5 decades, i can tell you i have rec'd $0 and i can also tell you i have paid him a substantial amount. now i am sure you have gone to school say you give me $100 for spending on ismailies I promise you i will then i pocket $90 and spend $10 for good work i know you will ask me how do i know imam pockets $90 truth is i dont but i did ask imam he refused to answer there is the problem salman when you hide, you are upto no good hope this helps
@@salimlalani Imams don’t need us. We need Imamat. Also, dasondh is a combination of Usher and Zakat. Khums is also clearly mentioned in Quran and it’s to b submitted to the house of Prophet. We can agree to disagree if you insist Hazar Imam is not direct descendant of Prophet. Out Pirs in Ginans have warned us of your type of ppl.
hi kareem bhai, ok if this is not the reason , i would be happy to have a dialogue with you on ismailism, many run away every time i approach them to discuss khoja religion, if you can face me you take up the challenge mujeebzahir@yahoo.com
@S.A.M "Our imam never answers these ignorants because he is real IMAM." Ismailis like to compare Aga Khan to the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him). Did you know that in the time of the Prophet, Muslims were allowed to question him and ask for accountability?
According to Islam, zakat is to be given at 2.5% of the income by every Muslim but I guess the extra 10% is for his lavish lifestyle. Also, in Surah Fatiha, in one of the Ayats, it is clearly stated, “Thee alone we worship and thee alone we seek for help”, then why are Ismailis obligated to use his name in the dua/namaz? His Serena hotels openly serve alcohol at their bars yet he condemns consumption of alcohol? Hypocrisy at its finest Honestly, there needs to be a serious official internal investigation in the funds being given to him and how he uses those funds. There also needs to be a one on one intervention to expose his lies
yes there should be an investigation but money and power has prevented this let us realise our power our solidarity is also powerful let us come together and investigate ourselves
Assalamu alaikum be careful of this man in his old youtube Channel he subscribed to channels that insulte Islam and our Noble Prophet, May Allah grant Him Peace and Blessings. He might say things that are true but they remain tainted by what he may still have in his heart...
Money will never buy place in heaven only good deeds why he is using qurran Muslim world will not accept insults to Qurran he should be bam to visit Muslim countries I am sure soon this will happen
I think this is quite unfair. I am not Agha Khani but I have interacted with many Agha Khani, not once have I heard one say he is God. I have only heard this from non Ismaili Muslims. One could say they are a bit clannish but otherwise they are quite a hardworking and progressive group. Religion can be difficult, the best policy is " live and let live ".
I'm "Ismaili" and my questions have always been suppressed and shut down by my parents. Like I'm supposed to blindly believe and follow like I'm wearing a muzzle. I am happy to see these videos that challenge AK 4. we are awakened.
@@salimlalani I saw your episodes , you are absolutely wrong, you are misguiding people's just because of money, when you didn't belong to your own people's then you can't belong to anyone else,
Wow! Thank you for the courage to speak out..... You've answered so many questions i always had about this system. Can't wait to hear the other episodes......
As per my experience which is onpaper also, that there is no Humanity in AKDN/Ismailism. Please see in google By type "Hasamukh Vadasariya & Agakhan" Thanks...
You’ve hit the nail on the head regarding those who don’t have voices. Many corroborating testimonies make it clear that people who dissent from the Ismaili community are isolated and bullied and coping with their pain in silence. The abusive comments Salim has received in this channel alone show it. Ismailis can’t hide it any more.
The miss perception here is that only Ismaili pay 12 percent No every Muslim family pay 10 percent But Ismaili pay to big organizations like aga khan foundation who does so much around the world The aga foundation budget is near 1 billion A population of 15 million imagines of whole Muslim collect their 10 percent it would be 100 billion that money alone could end hunger in Muslim world As Shia I would say well done to Ismaili you are great example of peace harmony and humanity and opens minded modern Muslims god bless you
I like the way you present your material salim and I’m excited to listen to what you have to say. I don’t feel as vehemently as you do that we’re being duped. I just don’t pay dasond and I’m perfectly happy ... if others want to pay, I’m ok with it. It’s only money
Dear Dawod, I am not scared because I speak the truth. Truth is God and God is Almighty. Pls subscribe and keep sending your comments and feedback on future podcasts. Thanks for your support.
@@salimlalani I am an ex ismaili also from Montreal. I can't thank you enough for your video. I have shared it in my social medias as well. Please continue your work. Regards.
Dawod here is what my thoughts are even though you question was to Mr. Lalani . Me, being 100% Afghan fluent in Dari , BUT born and raised in Pennsylvania / New Jersey . Once you get to a point of realization you can either crawl in a hole OR have this mentality "Fear is the greatest weapon of your biggest enemy " ~. BUT thats me ...LOL Lets allow Mr. Lalani Answer.OOPS i see he did .
@@salimlalani @UCJQPDG6BfBBI-lgth_WH0XQ question what is your ethnicity? My family is Afghan. I my cousins followers literally throw everything they have for them. I walk into a store and made a mistake and complimented a piece of jewelry and the owner took it out and packed it up for me. And I NEVER would do that to anyone . My cousin told me in my ear. Listen you must take it if you don't it would be very insulting to them. This situation happended over and over in London , when he came to the USA , and abroad. The loyality is unreal
@@believeboy5250 please read your own books Imam Mustansir Bi’llah II, the 32nd Ismaili Imam: “It is obligatory and necessary for the true believer to recognize his Creator who is manifest in this world in the form of a human being, and to see Him here in order to see Him also in the hereafter.” [Imam Mustansir Bi’llah II, Pandiyat-I-Jawanmardi Or Advices of Manliness, trans. W. Ivanow (Leiden, Netherlands: E. J. Brill, 1953), 101-102.]
Salim as Financial Advisor did you advice your client other ways in which he could save 12.5% to help? Or were you looking to touch upon the sensitivities of the issue after you choose to part ways from the Ismailis, if you saw your Ismaili friend did not take your suggestions well could you have adivced him differently? Was that the only option ? Your intentions may be good ???? but you know what they say, the road to hell is paved with good intentions. And by hell I speak metaphorically
Ameen there is no need to complicate matters. problem was simple and so was the solution. my friend was giving when he should be receiving from the imam. salim
my family are hindus. my uncle in canada is married to ismaeli muslims koja gujarati speaking. the koja muslims are peaceful and have integrated into society compared to main stream islam wahabi and shiaates. i have seen a picture of aga khan but ive never qusetioned other peoples religion as they may get insulted. we as sanatan dharma believe in al religions. thank you salim brother for your reply.
from uk. my grandad came to uk from uganda so knowing people culture without any direct contact and internet is a good source of comunication without any abusive violence.
Just wonder, how much money is taken out of a country like Pakistan on a annually by the Aga Khan foundations and how much is invested in? Visiting Pakistan, I have seen many religious debates between the Shia and Sunni but I have never seen Agha Khani representation on TV, does anyone know why? Also, I Wonder why the Iranian Mullah dislike Ismailis?
1) No idea how much much but big money is laundered. 2) Agakhan likes to stay away from debates in case his truth comes out 3) Mullahs will dislike anyone who commits shirk
Respected Sir, If anybody have the the contact number of Mr. Salim Lalani, please provide me. I have a urgent request for them and I have some on paper document too. Please. Contact me gogogokool@gmail.com. I m from India. Thanks
You are rare gem of a person You will find joy You will find success and more over You will find satisfaction of that kind that is found by philosophers and great men Brother you are an inspiration and a beacon for the quest by men of all ages for the truth
@@salimlalani i live in India and have friends who are Aga Khanis in college and always admired them however after seeing your videos i feel for them very sorry - yet your videos are gone all of them
@@salimlalani so now you are asking money yeah? Don't you have shame to beg, just think when you were an Ismaili you didn't needed to beg, better a greedy person like you left, you were not worth,
Please prove to me that even Mohammad and Quran are the the real deal either? I don’t wanna follow someone who married a 13 yo when he was in 50s regardless pf whatever reasons. Same with Jesus. If he had the powers, he couldn’t pull out the 3 nails out of his bodies, when he was being crucified? Give me a break. This whole religion is bs. And God...Hmmm where is he or she when millions of kids are being killed. Even I shed tears. Wonder why does God not come for help?
@@samsamani7 U hv mentioned all d bad thibgs happening or happened around d world and questioning Allah's existence. wat abt gd things??? oh all d gd things are because of logic and science. u associate all d bads with religion and gd vd Science and logic. I worship Allah and being a Muslim I follow Isa as well. u r free to believe watever u want but not om d grounds of criticising other ppl believes.
@@zeynabyt3754 Enlighten me with a few good things but before you do that, answer my questions. Bad things need a response too...and WITH PROOF to make them untrue. Just saying that Quran is certified scripture by God is not proof....and that's one example. Another example... Mohammad was sent by GOD and had all the powers but had to fight Gazwaas to prove that ISLAM is the religion to follow? Wow...amazing huh. A powerful man struggling to prove. Smh. Jesus....the guy who had powers to resurrect humans couldn't help himself be survive or return from his own death? You can prove Aga Khan Wrong (and I agree), mostly with modern history (technology and all) but you can't prove Mohammad or Jesus or even other Gods and messengers to be true because there's nothing the HIS-STORY (history) books that were written with people we don't even freakn know. Anyone can glorify their existence. If you read the Quran or any "holy" books, they're all common sense scriptures. You're human....follow your conscience and you won't need any religion, religious personalities, and/or holy scriptures. And finally, you saying that you follow Allah and adding Prophet Mohammad is indirectly criticizing others for what they're doing. Start thinking so you don't contradict yourself and produce bs responses.
What I don't understand is why does it trouble anyone else what the Ismailis do or pay. It doesn't bother them. As matter of fact the Ismailis progressed in every aspect of life even Financially even after paying Dasond. Clearly the Ismailis are doing something right.
aarondaya you say you dont understand to understand there at least three requirements open ears open eyes and a brain a process the info collected you have demonstrated in your comments that all the three did'nt function pls watch again what i have said in the video will be elaborated in following videos salim
As a Hindu I worked for an aga khan university in London. It was like being in another world. I was a vut obsessed readong about them and their duas especially as a Gujarati person. I dare not ask questions but I was getting so much info on RUclips and intense searching online. When aga khan visited in london followers literally wet themselves. I mean... he's just a man! I'm so glad I got out of there.
Well, people cry when they see their icons, that's normal. I see people crying when they meet famous singers, actors, sportsmen, and spiritual leaders @Jyoti Alfino
My family was plucked from horrific discrimination and unimaginable poverty thanks to the Imam. I'm sorry you were taught the way that you were, and glad you've found what works for you, but accusing an ancient interpretation of Islam of being a cult is ignorant by every measure: We don't try to recruit others, we're encouraged to pursue secular education, independent theological thought, and economic independence. It's also wholly irresponsible given the everyday discrimination we face let alone deadly attacks, I know as an Afghan and as a woman.
Thank you for your comments I agree I am ignorant I hardly know anything But one thing I know is Agakhanism is a cult. It is bigotry on your part to pass your judgement before being heard. Have you ever seen a judge in a courtroom passing judgement before giving the accused an opportunity to speak? Ariana please allow me to talk about how this is a cult Allow me the opportunity to talk about help and the amount of money Imam receives If I don’t have right to be heard, if I don’t have a right to present evidence of what I am talking about, then that will be denying a human being’s basic right
@@salimlalani You have every right to be heard, even to attack the Imam, and jamaat, no one is going to call for your murder or even harrass you. I can't speak to your religious education, but it's now standardized by ITREB, and no text books teach people to donate finacially or face hell, and no one is harrassed for financial contributions. By presenting blatently false narratives about us you're actively encouraging the kind of daily, lived, bigotry we experiance, including the genocide my family faced first hand in places like Afghanistan under the Taliban or Daish in Syria. Not everyone lives in a free society.
@@arianakhan6665 Thanks Ariana for allowing me the courtesy of being heard Now do me one more favor and tell me about blatantly false narratives I will correct myself Thanks again for at least not abusing me like few of your community members
@@salimlalani Imamate institutions are the largest employers and investors in Isma'ili regions in Tajikistan and Afghanistan. Have you looked at the infant mortality rate drop, literacy, or employment rates? i'm not clear where you arrived at Isma'ili believe the Imam is God. It's not in a farman i've come across. Did you consult ITREB, a Rai, read text books like _Knowledge and Liberation_ by Khusrow _et al,_ familarize yourself with Islamic history like the Martyrdom of Mansur Al Hallaj and his place in Sufism? You don't deserve abuse, even as you've created a series of videos debasing my community, your family, and former friends. A British Pakistani tv presenter, Saira Khan, simply stated she respected Islam, but wasn't a practicing Muslim, and is now recieving a torrent of death threats, people are being murdered for cartoons in France, global Muslim protests against French free speech, which are real theats to free speech and they don't come from Ismailis.
Brother I atmost agree with you, Aga Khan is a ruthless businessman not humanitarian person. AKF is just eyewash , in the name of AKF he grabbing millions of dollar donation on yearly basis.
I was born an Aga Khani too, but Jesus saved me from the cult and now I'm a desciple of Lord Jesus. My mom and dad too got saved. May I invite you to learn more about the Gospel and come to know Jesus...start with listening to John Macarthur and read Gospel of John
Dear Ambreen Congratulations on being saved. As far as your invitation to Christianity is concerned, I must politely decline. I have been there and decided not to follow any faith based systems Salim
So you believe agha khan is God or ali ???hour imam never pray your imam never perfume huj ...your imam let his daughter to marry yahoodi ... your imam dancing in club what kind of muslim your
This series belittles the faith of so many human beings. Yes we all have the right to think the way we want but trying to persuade others to abandon their faith, by sowing seeds of doubt, under the guise of spreading “truth”, smells of a deeper objective - perhaps one driven by personal grudges. If I try to balance Salim’s views with what the Ismaili Imam has achieved, the latter’s documented track record shines through. That said, to each his own. Follow what gives you happiness, without harming others.
Mr Alibhoy, it doesn't belittle faith. It criticises BLIND faith. Blind faith that is being exploited to make people LOTS of money. Your skilful use of spin makes you look more complicit than naive, but I shouldn't judge because when I was Aga Khani I would have jumped to his defence also.
Mr Alibhoy Your comment about balancing the argument by considering track record of what he has achieved. great point!! now show me a record of how much he receives in dollar terms??? If you or me had received that much, we could have achieved what he has achieved, if not more.
I think that's a lame reply they say there is always a way where there is a will, so thats means that you are just not ready to do to what you talk about and give lame excuse
@@salimlalani sorry to say then i think then every other day someone like you would put a video on social media be it an ismaili Muslim, non or confused one, and he has to meet in person & clarify his position, & everything he does, besides saying on media & private gathering (darbar/ginan/firman, his work etc.) that i am your 49th imam & direct descendent of prophet Mohd pbuh. its absurd.
ALLAH YEHI IMAM IS DIFFERENT THAT IMAM YEHI ALLAH. Has Aga Khan himself proclaimed himself as ALLAH? NO - He says Bismillah hir rehman nir rahim himslf when he starts a lecture. Also every religion has "money" connected to it.
![[#2024MAMA] BIGBANG (빅뱅) - 뱅뱅뱅 (BANG BANG BANG) + FANTASTIC BABY | Mnet 241123 방송](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/EQsYfiPR9uM/mqdefault.jpg)
It takes a lot of courage to stand up and say and do what you are doing. I like the way you are opening the eyes of those who are near and dear to you by methodically, and factually breaking things down. Wish you all the best in your journey.
I appreciate that!
Thank you for spreading the truth
@@salimlalani I also converted to ithna ashri..before 3 yr from ismili
@@sid_9080 thats even more dumb only if analyzed properly
@@jewelrysuppliers see you in the day of. Judgment who is right and who is wrong
SubhanAllah! Every word spoken is the truth of reality of the 'Cult'. It is an Agakhani cult no doubt about it, and nobody can deny it after knowing the truth of fake Imam./ MayAllahSalaam/peace.
Why don’t you check his lineage do you know what that word means??? When are you so cold or not as a Muslim your not here to judge any one or anything.
Just add one more line , Ismaili Muslims are ethnically, culturally and geographically diverse community. Salim is only talking about his family ( Khoja family). Khoja makes a small portion of this large traditions of ismailis the community. Salim knowledge and understanding is very shallow and mostly based his mistreatment experience in Austrlia seems all on personal reasons or may be for more authorities.
All of them worship Agha Khan and clearly not Muslims.
Jinnah was khoja to . Khoja are gujrati
Great Lalani, we can't see your episodes in Canada and UK, Please use alternative social media platform like Reddit...... I believe this Aga Khan is behind all Lalani videos blockage
Has any Ismaili has seen aga khan’s family or extended family coming to jamat khana for prayers? Do aga Khan pray?
He is an athiest🤣🤣🤣, he doesnt believe in god.
He made fool of ismilies 🤣🤣🤣
Ok so this boggles my mind. Ppl pay 12.5% to this 'leader' to avoid going to hell, and no one thinks this is a scam, while Khan is one of the richest ppl in the world? The definition of a scam is paying non stop payments to any individual or party despite your situation. Same as Qadiani fees. May Allah give guidance to all those fooled.
Good comments
No is a charity aga wealth is by doing business not from member
The aga khan foundation has done so much in Afghanistan we don’t pay nothing at all
Pluse Ismaili faith are far more richer in any countries specially in Canada I am Shia but I respect the Ismaili
Other sect of Islam collect money to creat Islamic extremist group and destroy life
While the Ismaili are.very peaceful kind and open mind people
Good fore you free to do what ever want to do but try to show the good side of Ismaili people too
@@Uyiiouuoiuiiuyi you should do some research, he doesn’t help anyone it’s a business which is designed by people even worse than AK. Countries they “help” shouldn’t be in poverty and struggling to survive especially when they’re rich with natural resources.
Allah has guided Br Salim away from that evil. Now he needs to make the next step towards sunni Islam.
Zakat is approximately 2.5% of disposable income.
Ha ha ha Wuhan Allah. Allan is root cause of suffering.
4:15 “perception is not reality” May Allah bless you.
Brother Salim love to give you a big hug my Brother.
It took me 40 years to find the Truth “Islam” too. الحمدلله
A big hug to you as well and thank you for liking my work so far
Assalamu alaikum be careful of this man in his old youtube Channel he subscribed to channels that insulte Islam and our Noble Prophet, May Allah grant Him Peace and Blessings. He might say things that are true but they remain tainted by what he may still have in his heart...
Stay safe brother. Allah with you
May Allah bless you. I left the Ismaili system when I was 19 and I am just amazed to watch your videos which I luckily came across only yesterday. Even when we followed the Ismaili system we were never so strict with dasond as back then my father had burdens of rasing his own family and support his parents although he always believed he should pay it.
thanks for sharing your story
Good you left
U are not missed
@@riazkarim819 thank you for your comments
Our Nabi when through lot still is I am sure your massage will help to decide their future from what been said if you didn’t some would have said more louder very loiter was known about Ismaili religion I am suuni have lot friends who are Ismaili my religion thought us to respect other we never discuss anything just salaam with my Sunni brothers no secret intact we always corrected each other when ever we discuss the topic they way we pray or anything to do with hala or haram and this way we had respect for each other’s may Allah forgive us and guide us all Ameen
I also left Ismailism 19 years ago and embraced Din of Islam.
Does Aga Khan is a part of Freemasonry . does he has a link with Freemasonry . I do study in Freemasonry ?
15,000,000 deluded followers who need to re-think if they are really Muslim. And who the hell gave him the right to call himself "Prince"? ... Imam? Really?
All I heard is HOW BEAUTIFUL this religion is!!! Ton of love and hugs to all the other Monotheistic faiths!!!
looool wtf were you listening too
It takes alot of courage to speak out, the system is so well structured that its pretty much impossible to think out of the box, from being born in an aga khani hospital to get educated in aga khan school to die in a aga khani graveyard, I am so glad that my family stopped following when I was 5, and remember the grief they got from other family members, now most of my extended family are out sadly few are still stuck in system and its just too difficult for them to leave due to various reasons like loosing good friends and support by community and children could get divorced or kicked out of their houses because of the actions by parents.
uncivilised society
@@salimlalani as if you are civilised, you are nothing but just a ehsaan faramosh,
I will always stand by my Imam, Ale-nabi, Aulad-e-Ali. My imam lives in my heart. He is loving, kind, polite and humble. Always taught me good and never speaks badly of anyone.
He is very tolerant and merciful, just like RasollAllah. I love my Mowla just like many other Ismailis and our Mowla loves us even more. Call me blind, brainwashed, but matters of heart and soul can't be described.
Accusations you put on my Mowla similar ones were put by Meccans on the final Prophet and even today he is mocked by unbelievers by making caricatures.
My Mowla and his family Iam sure are aware of all such organized campaigns like yours on the youtube and other social media platforms, but shows tolerance, and forgiveness and never incites us to retaliate. We wish you peace and harmony in this universe.
thank you
Aga Khan didn't appear very tolerant when he published his speech (farman) in 1899 where he said "Arabs are like donkeys".
Can you imagine, not only did he get caught saying that, but he actually published it himself.
It can be seen close to the bottom of this page - insideismailism.wordpress.com/2015/10/30/truth-about-isma%CA%BFili-ginans/amp/
@@persolu3680 ours is an esoteric faith that’s all I will say, I will appreciate a no response to this instead you may reflect on that.
I always questioned this religion.. relentlessly.. grew up with many of them.. living next to Jamaat Khanaan, I was always curious how secretive they were and none was allowed in their worship place.
Yep, my AK friends never talked about what goes on there. We were not "allowed" to enter their residential compounds. Most of us friends didn't care as we just studied and played together.
Question RELIGION in general and you'll stop worshipping the prophets and "holy books" too. If your conscience is clean, YOU'RE THE RELIGION. You don't need no prophets and messenger to show the right path. You got a brain that functions.
@@samsamani7 Beware of men like this. He just created his own God in his own mind to serve his own desires
“We are admonished to ‘trust in the Lord with all thine heart; and lean not unto thine own understanding.’ (Prov. 3:5.) And we are warned: ‘Woe unto them that are wise in their own eyes, and prudent in their own sight!” (Isa. 5:21.)”
Who but a fool would make his own god- an idol that cannot help him one bit? (Isaiah 44:10)
You are definitely a man on a mission !!
And the way you present your facts with clarity and a calm mind
Your words are pure Gold !!!
Your reward is the ultimate destination
You will be amongst those that Allah will reward abundantly
Thank you
I appreciate
I like the way you present ..though couldn't get your exact motive behind this ...being a common men I barely care about what my old/dearest friend personal thoughts r , I could have help him instead of stopping him paying dasond that could have make my life more easier ,
Quick questions
1, any ismaili book in record shows agha khan himself writing himself God?
2, any Ismaili religious book reference that demand dasond by hook or crook un conditional ?
3, being a financial specialist you must have evidence of your own work that evaluate your work n performance for agha in past when you were doing your job and counting mureeds incoming ?
This is a healthy discussion first question will help me way find your way of perception vs reality
Appreciated
Dear Sabir
I wish all my viewers were like you. Wanting to have a healthy discussion.
Lets start with my friend.
Your suggestion was to help him personally instead of stopping him from paying dasond.
Sabir I was only trying to make him financially independent on me or anyone else.
If he were to stop paying dasond he would not need help.
Regarding other questions you will need to watch the whole series. It will not only answer all your questions but will provide evidence you are looking for.
Kind regards
Salim
Salim appreciate u consider me , even my own blood relative lets take mother father would have ever come to me for help or tell me or convince me to help on any perspective if they came for n intention that m some one who will help them n once I try to speak a word and they shut the door on me I swear that was the last relation on planet for me, I would have ever turn back on any thing ........look we don't have so called warden to live 100 years today even a freind like taxi driver know what u thinking about practices ...my point is do u carry an idea to move forward instead of doing free marketing for n entity ? Let's meet i don't mind to fly ur place not to convince u but to explore what u got ....hope I convey my point ...
@@Sabirjumani1981 i would love to meet you
i live in australia
@@salimlalani sure , would love to know vision sure your appisode won't show 🙄
Simple but very insightful questions you raised; but the one that was most resounding to me is: "What gives Aga Khan the right to personally own the religious views when the Prophet did not have that right?" You are an independent thinker and strong willed. You said that you are not interested in any religion, but I want to say to you: "may Allah guide you and shower His blessings on you" - A retired Winnipegger, Canada
thank you sir
Great start!!! Cant wait for the whole series!!! Looking forward for more facts and figures with evidences!!!
You will get exactly what you want. thank you for a great feedback
Thank you for bringing light to this issue.
-Former Ismaili
welcome
Outstanding, non-partial and well documented video. It's easy to see you are very well read and not influenced or brainwashed. Thanks for sharing. I'm a journalist and author of historic based novels based on the Mediterranean and the Near East. I work out of Mexico and write for magazines in Spain and have productions in Colombia. Is there any way I can get ahold of you directly to see if a I can share this information in Latin America and create more awareness of this cult?
My email address is s_lalani@hotmail.com
As per my experience which is onpaper also, that there is no Humanity in AKDN/Ismailism.
Please see in google
By type
"Hasamukh Vadasariya & Agakhan"
Thanks...
Reza if you are in Colombia I will meet you to talk, I live there 6 months of the year. Let me know if you are ever in or around Medellin
"There is no one greater than myself. If you think of God, then it is myself. If you think about Imam, then too, it is me. And your Beloved Master is also me. There is no one except myself"
The Aga Khan
March 16th 1902
I don't know how much patience I can have with ismailis who see this quote but still don't want to even try to distance themselves from their cult. So disappointing.
Dasond is not mandatory, however is encouraged just like ANY other faith. Whoever taught you this ideology is wrong in doing so, your information is far from the truth! The Ismaili people are one of the kindness communities who want to see real change in quality of life in the east, which is why many families pay Dasond, in order to better their standard of living in developing countries across the world. The word used by the Imam is ‘obligation’ and that words meaning differs to the meaning of the word YOU use in your video which is ‘mandatory’. Our present imam actually states that it is “voluntary”. Paying Dasond is a moral ‘obligation’ and not a ‘mandatory’ task like you have claimed it to be in this video at (24:45) The word ‘Obligation’ means that it is morally a good thing to do (just like you are obligated to look after your parents or your siblings) weather you choose to do this or not is YOUR CHOICE. Never has the present day Aga Khan said that it is ‘mandatory’ to pay this dasond like you have made out to be truth trough claiming he has taught us all to do this, which is just not true at all. Never has the present day imam said this. The word used by the imam is ‘Obligatory’ - therefore you should look up the definition of both words and actually reflect on the meaning before you start to teach others and manipulate those viewers to believe these lies. This information is highly incorrect and manipulative. Each individual chooses to give money through the form of Dasond out of pure generosity. And if you think I am wrong and can prove it please quote me exactly where, when and to what context the imam has stated it is ‘Mandatory’, I have looked and there is no such saying. Stop lying to people!
In Islam you give zakat, in Christianity you give Tithe (a percentage of your earning) is the Ismaili faith we give Dasond.
My source: CBC interview ‘Man Alive with Bonisteel’ (Canada) 8th October 1986
“It is entirely voluntary” - Aga Khan 1986
I suggest you hold your comments until you watch the series
@@salimlalani with respect, I’m on episode 7 and I have many many issues with what you are saying as I too have questioned the faith and was in the same place as you, and I too have sat on the pat like you have to lead religion ceremonies, however I can at least tell the truth when stating the facts. Firstly you can’t even give me a proper reply to my first comment, so I ask you why? Is it because I’ve caught you on a lie and you now don’t know what to say back to me? I think this is the case here. And that’s because the imam of the time never used the word you claim he did. The word mandatory is not in any Farman in the last 20 years in the context of dasond. May I remind you that I have put references to prove that it is optional and this indicates you have lied in this first video, and I also have proof you are not telling the truth in multiple other videos or in some cases at least stretching the truth and miss out key facts to shape others into thinking the false information is truth. You say no Ismaili will stand up and talk, but here I am. You ask the question in later videos, where does the money go? I have had first hand experience in attending Global Encounters in Kenya in 2016 and have seen the institutions he has built with this money with my own two eyes. We went into schools, we started work on projects in a sustainable way, we saw the amount of jobs he has created in the east, and above all he has taught us that sustainability is everything. That in itself is a huge blessing. Never has it ever been mandatory in my life time to pay Dasond to the imam and this is the truth. It is only encouraged through an obligation to be a decent human being, not just a Muslim. As for the help in the west, you are a mukhi like you said, for a majlis that you have to pay a lot of money to attend so why didn’t you help your friend with financial difficulties if he was struggling to feed his family? You clearly have money if you were mukhi of that kind of majlis right? I would have thought any decent friend would help his spiritual brother if he is in need. And especially if he has children. I must admit the financial aid is hard to find and far more transparency is needed within our community between the council and the public, however I say this with personal experience that my own family themselves were helped in this country by Ismaili financial aid when they first entered the country. So what you tell people isn’t actually accurate information. The Ismaili community helps eachother. This is how it has always been. But I’d like to discuss this further with you. Let me highlight that I say this with no hatred at all, only frustration in the fact that people can not see eye to eye anymore at a time where is is absolutely vital to stand together. However I can not lie that I’m quite baffled at how you reached these far fetched conclusions about Dasond and social welfare. If it wasn’t for the help my family received through social welfare my family would have starved. There were at that time 6 too 7 people living under one roof in a council house just to paint you the picture.
@@shaazlalani8700 You see by that arguement even Pablo Escobar gave out some charity, and the recipients swear to this day that he was a good man, it is very clever indoctrination. Ask yourself, if you are muslim whom to follow. These people are claiming to be "Imams" and descendants of the prophet PBUH but they are not. They play upon the weakness of the masses, everybody is not knowledgeable or educated in history, so they come up with the idea that Imam so and so in the 9th century did so and so. For true Islam you got to come to the Quran and the Sunnah of the prophet. Islam was not built on Imams or ahel-l-bait, it is built on the Quran and Sunnah thats it.
After the death of the prophet, the enemies of Islam were hell bent on distroying Islam and if you research that period there were many wars with the kufars and munafiks. One of their melicious plans was to kill Hussain the prophets grandson. If you take a close look, all this took place in the frontier regions of the expanding muslim empire, not in the Hijaz (Mecca and Medina). Why? Because they didn't dare do that at the center where everybody would recognise them, so they played their dirty games far away in Kuffa, Egypt (the Fatimids). In Egypt they even named their nation after the prophets daughter Fatima....to fool people.
The Zakat is 2.5% and most important, is due ANNUALLY. Dasond is on every paycheck and is 12.5%. Big difference, as we say "Asman aur zamin ka farak".
It is shirk to worship a human. Read the Quran, follow the Sunnah and study Islamic history. Also, study Greek, Roman, Mesopotamian history and see how those people were pagan.
Where have all the videos gone?
Where in the Quran or sunna does it say that if you dont pay aga Khan it would result in a person ending up in jahanum ?
@AV "Imams don't need us. We need Imamat."
Actually, Aga Khan may need your money if he's going to afford to spend hundreds of millions on mega yachts and big settlements to keep adultery claims out of court.
I was born in Uganda, East Africa and we had there a community of Agha Khanis (also known as Khojas). In childhood in the 1960's early 70's, we used to hear our parents mentioning the Agha Khan and he seemed to be some misterious figure. In late 1972 we left Uganda (due to Idi Amin's expulsion order) and were evacuated to a holding camp in Spain, where we had afew Agha Khani families in our group. At the time as a 13 year old we heard about "Prince Sadrudin Agha Khan" as being the head of the UNHCR in Geneva. A lot was happening in our camp but what we know is that many of the Khojas/Ismaili families chose to apply for Canada as their first choice of settlement. I can only surmise that messages were passed through their underground network. Some in our Spain group including my family ended up in Dubai and Abu Dhabi, UAE, which was not right as this country was not a signatory of the UN Convention on Refugees and we started facing problems there as soon as we landed. It was a fiasco with all the wars, corruption and lack of transperency there. Not satisfied with the UNHCR office in Beirut, I later wrote to the head himself "Prince Sadrudin" in Geneva, and I did get a reply but it was just diplomatic and basically said to help ourselves. I thought of this man as just another human being but there was a mystery around him, the "Prince" title and the way he is recieved by heads of states etc. I am Sunni muslim and to us monotheism is paramount. I knew a little about the Khojas as there is no literature about them, but you have brought a lot out, people need to know in this age of information. This is the difference between us and our forefathers 100, 200 years ago.The prophet SAW did not own fine horses, palaces and lands or gold and silver.
"You can fool some of the people all the time, or all the people some of the time, but you cannot fool all the people all the time" . J F Kennedy.
Mohabat
thank you for sharing your experiences and supporting my work
Thanks for sharing. Want to know more about agha khani and Ismaili Muslims. Keep sharing videos.
Regards,
From India.
sure i have just uploaded one
@@salimlalani Thanks will watch tonight.
You should go on the ismail.org and you will get the facts and figures not from a person who has tasted sour grapes.
@@nooraliismail1615 I went to the Ismaili website and I was a little disappointed because it didn't say anything about the secretive system of taking large amounts of money from devotees who have been made to believe that an ostentatious billionaire cult leader is God on earth.
When Ismaili TV start talking about that, they might get a few more RUclips hits.
Great ! Finally truth revealed.. I was curious to know about the secret of this Imam... Wish to know more of him....May Allah bless you...
As a Muslim you need to study the Holy Qur'an with its authentic commentary. You need to study the biographies of the Holy Prophet Muhammad and his twelve Rightful Successors (peace and blessings of Allah be upon them all).
Then you compare your Imam/guide /leader in the mirror of the Book of Allah, the sunnah of the Holy Prophet and his twelve Rightful successors/vicegerents (peace and blessings of Allah be upon them all).
Do not be scared to ask questions. Do not be a blind believer. If you are following a wrong guide or a leader without a thorough investigation, you will ruin your hereafter and there is no question for having a second chance either.
The best gift Allah has granted us human beings is aql (common sense). Do not be stingy or economical with it.
thanks for the write up
Shia and sunni also are in the wrong direction according to my years of research.
@@hakimrahnaward2624 I wonder what made you come to this conclusion. If you are praying, how do you pray your namaz, perform your wuzu, etc?
12 succsesor? he's not jesus dude ...
First khalif was father in law of Mohammed bin Abdulla READ BOOK “UNDERSTANDING MOHAMMED” by Ali sinna.available free online
Mr. Lalani , all your episodes of yours is blocked in USA. Can't view any one of the episodes.
The Ismailis have helped people outside the community not just the Ismailis. Why don't you non believers spend your time in really helping people like what the Aga Khan does as opposed to trying to convince people in what you believe. The Ismailis are happy and accept the Imam as their Spiritual Leader and Guide to worldly matters.
We have all heard what is being said here and doesn't phase our allegiance to the Aga Khan.
While this comment is long, nonetheless, it may be of interest to anyone who has an open mind to facts.
Salim Lalani's presentations appear to be respectful to the subject matter. And they also appear to have good intentions behind them.
However, his efforts involving his personal subjective interpretations on Aga Khan, have to be interpreted with both an open mind, and also as an act of his personal sincerity to others; if it has to have any educational and positive benefits.
As long as Salim Lalani focuses on historical facts including "the historical context" behind them with sincere intentions; he will be doing a "sattvic seva", a personal act of sincerity - which is very consistent with the ancient Indian wisdom.
Examples of what I mean by emphasis on historical context behind the facts:
1) Historically; Shia Ismaili Imams, have never self imposed their spiritual leadership authority on their followers. Nor have they imposed the secular guidance on their followers.
2) If "some" of the Shia Ismaili Imams history is very vague, the reason is that Ismailis in general and their Imams in particular, were historically being prosecuted by majority others due to Ismailis emphasis on "esoteric interpretations of faith". This resulted in a practice of "taqqiya", a common sense practice at that time, which forced them to remain in hiding for their protection and welfare of their families. But that "taqqiya" practice also involved leaders of the community of that time being witnesses to the events "whose trust cannot be discounted when they vouched the validity of their Imams".
3) The Shia Ismaili Constitution is the guiding document that makes references not only to the historical circumstances, but also to the Shia Ismaili doctrine of Tawhid (belief in one God none other then Allah) including the traditions with regards to the leadership of Ismaili Imamat. Therefore, the constitution should be read in the full context basis and "not on cherry picked basis". Otherwise, it has "a serious potential to be misunderstood and misconstrued".
4) Historic tradition of the Ismailis, in accepting and following the guidance of their Imams, has benefited the community as being one of the most progressive traditions within the Umma. Other very specific benefits being: open minded in the esoteric interpretation of faith, very respectful and tolerant of other traditions within the Umma and other faiths, emphasis on the use of intellect when interpreting their faith and other daily activities, maintain balance between din and duniya, etc.
My suggestion to Salim Lalani is that his videos can potentially have benefits, if he continues focusing on historical facts as well as genuine "historical context" behind them. And for that, I humbly request he be sincere in his intentions.🙏
As a benefit to all the interested readers, a very important message: If any member of the Ismaili tariqa, the tariqa's secondary leadership or any other person who intentionally interprets the Ismaili Muslims faith and it's core beliefs other then as articulated in the guiding document of the Shia Ismaili Muslim's constitution; such a member, the secondary leadership or the person is not only misrepresenting the facts as intended; but is also doing a great dis-service to the Ismaili faith in general and the Shia Ismaili Muslim's Imam in particular. The later also being referred to as the current Aga Khan.
A note to the readers: All quotation marks in my comments are simply to emphasize some important points for the benefit of clarity.
Ali bhai, with all due respect I disagree with your arguments in defending the institution of Imamat. Here is my response to your arguments
1. Aga Khan, after he arrived in India did impose authority over Khoja community. There are many historical references and court cases available to review. You may refer and read court proceedings involving Aga Khan during British rule in India.
Please refer to Ismaili Dua which was recited in Jamat Khanas before 1957. Imam was called to be Mahesh, Brahma and Vishnu (worshipped in India as gods) and of course Ali Sahi Allah (Ali true god)
Aga Khan III even claimed in a Farman made in Zanzibar in 1899 that the current Quran is incomplete and he had the actual copy of Quran. Check the attached farman if you can read Khojki
ibb.co/N9pR8N3
But this is irrelevant, what actually matters is even if they did not impose their authority, how does it make them equal to Allah (SWT)? No Ismaili can deny the fact that in JamatKhana Ismailis raise their hand and call out to Aga Khan to forgive their sins, give barakah in earnings (rozi ma barkat) and so on whereas Quran clearly states that our Prophet (PBUH) is Bashir and Nazeer (one who brings goods news and warns).
Do you have any example during the time of Prophet Muhammad that Muslims used to raise their hands and ask him to forgive their sins in his absence? Or do you have any verse from Quran supporting such action?
2. For the sake of argument even if I accept your argument #2, how do you explain the absence of Imam Hasan from the list of Ismaili Imams. Ismaili Imamat history establishes that Ismailis and Twelvers Shia (Itha Asharis) were one community until Imam Jaffer Sadiq. According to the Ismaili history the split occurred after the death of Imam Jaffer Sadiq. At what point in history one community decided that Imam Hasan was Imam and other community decided that Imam Hasan was not Imam.
3. No comments, any community can have their own set of rules.
4. There is no denial that Ismailis are successful as a community. But most of the Ismailies are unable to understand the cost they are paying to achieve economic success. If success in life is to be measured by economic success than no doubt Ismailies are successful but there is more to life than economic success.
Ali Bhai whatever you believe, it is none of my business but I request you to study Quran and then justify Ismaili beliefs in the light of Quran.
Dear Mr Kassam
I welcome your comments and I wish to assure you that my work is about spreading awareness that our faith should not be blind.
I Agakhan’s case we need to ask ourselves how can someone be God when it is a known fact he has been caught twice with his pants down
Mr Kassam
I humbly suggest that you reserve your comments until you have watched the entire series
I must admit you come across to me as a very reasonable person
Great to read your comments
Amyn Pabani, your comments are very courteous, respectful and appreciated. Thank you kindly.
Since you have directly asked me, I am therefore hoping that the following response may offer you some answers:
1) We can always respectfully agree to disagree. After all, that is the beauty of subjective interpretations of our perceptions.
2) Considering that RUclips comments section is not necessarily an appropriate forum to engage into a back and forth discussion; I will therefore, respectfully refrain from doing that.
3) Yet your questions are valid and your point of view has many merits. They surely deserve to be answered. For that, may I refer you to the constitution of the Shia Ismaili Muslims? It may not have specific or all answers to your questions; but very likely, you may find some answers therein. Alternatively, it may lead you to an appropriate authorised channel that can provide you with some specific answers.
@Akbar Lakhani, your response has many interesting and thought provoking merits. They are much appreciated.
To all the readers interested in this subject matter, this comment may be long, but surely worth your time.
The Shia Ismaili Muslim's tradition has a guiding document refered to as the "Shia Ismaili Muslim's Constitution". The said constitution is approved by the Shia Ismaili Muslim's Imam of the time, and clearly articulates the following:
1) The Ismaili Muslims core doctrine of the Tawhid - which is the belief in one God none other then Allah.
2) The historical and traditional references to the beginning of Imamat institution.
3) The role and the authority of the Imamat evolving not only as the Imam of time, but also implied as the Murshid of his murids.
4) Many other very relevant facts.
The traditional function and authority of the Murshid in Ismaili Muslims tariqa is comparable to any other Islamic Sufi tariqas. Meaning, it also involves a spiritual bond between the Murshid and his murids upon satisfying certain requirements such as a bayah.
It is therefore imperative, that the Shia Ismaili Muslims doctrine and their faith practices should be understood from the focal point of the Shia Ismaili Muslim's constitution. And it should be read in the full context basis and not on cherry picked basis. Otherwise, it has a serious potential to be misunderstood and misconstrued.
Once again; as a benefit to all the interested readers, another very important message: If any member of the Ismaili tariqa, the tariqa's secondary leadership or any other person who intentionally interprets the Ismaili Muslims faith and it's core beliefs other then as articulated in the guiding document of the Shia Ismaili Muslim's constitution; such a member, the secondary leadership or the person is not only misrepresenting the facts as intended; but is also doing a great dis-service to the Ismaili faith in general and the Shia Ismaili Muslim's Imam in particular. The later also being referred to as the current Aga Khan.
@@akbarlakhani6624 it is very interesting to hear someone who is defending Ismailism admitting to the belief that the Aga Khan is God. So you’re really saying that it was all a mistake and that the problem is being rectified? What about the one eighth of personal income that people have paid to the Aga Khan believing that he is God? Will they be offered a refund? Will they be told that they shouldn’t continue to pay him until they are clear that he is not a God?
Where are you other 19 videos gone ???
Ismailis believe in one God just as all muslims do. We look to the imam for guidance. Also, I was brought up Ismaili and was never indoctrinated with regards to Dasond. Infact, there is writing that one should give dasond out of love in your heart, not because you have to.
Thank you Alykhan
Any comments on the ginan where Pir says Allah yehi Imam?
If possible, also comment on ginans and waezes approved by Agakhan that threaten you about horrible consequences in hell if you dont pay dasond!
Hopefully your guidance will lead me to the right path.
Salim
Sir the question is he collects dasond whithout receipts which is illegal according to Quran and according to the law of the land. This is sufficient to unfollow him.
Why the secrecy about the collection of monies in jamat khana. The money aspect is very concerning and unsettling, where is the accountability nothing is transparent at all.
Omg couldn't believe people think he is God.Thx for sharing May Allah BLESS U & MAY ALLAH GUIDE US ALL THE RIGHT PATH.🤲AMEEN
Thank you
Hello, I am an Ismaili and can state the Aga Khan does not consider himself to be a god and neither do I not any of the community. It is such a shame you have taken on a role to spread mis-truth and resentment instead of love, tolerance, understanding and interconnectedness. May you be blessed with good health, happiness and the courage to tell the truth. Please be honest. Thank you.
@@karimallidina6633 He did research
As per my experience which is onpaper also, that there is no Humanity in AKDN/Ismailism.
Please see in google
By type
"Hasamukh Vadasariya & Agakhan"
Thanks...
@@karimallidina6633 , I agree with. There are even many interviews of Hazir imam ( Aga khan) available on you tube where He categorically declaring that He has never consider himself God . This guy Salim ( I feel sorry for him) for the mistreatment He got from his own people has chosen this grudges on you tube and maligning the Imam of the time. His information is propaganda , fake , shallow knowledge.
Imam never needs our money and I am an Isma'ili from PAMIR. There is no such compulsion to pay money.
You have distorted quite a bit. If that is the explanation of a cult then all religions should be considered a cult.
Islam is NOT a cult!! Get your brains checked. Cult has a leader, who is very secretive like Agakhan. Read definition of a cult!!
Hi Salim
Is everything ok. I see all your videos are gone. Did youtube try to block your channel?
we are back
Great please make more videos thanks
Thank you, I will
Why is this not in hindi or gujarati, so that i can show it to my parents and relatives
hope fully when i have more time
The book you will publish will be true testimony for all, sura iklash says it all no one greater but Allaha talla massage to all humanity
I am from Pamir (Tajikistan) born as a Shia Ismaili muslim ,please stop deceiving people . We are not saying he is God . We follow Allah , Muhammad, Ali and all the descendants of the Prophet Muhammad through his cousin Imam Ali. He is Imam the one who makes interpretation of Islam to his followers. Proud to be an Ismaili ❤️ShukranAllah
You accuse me of deceiving when I have given you the evidence that Agakhan has approved ginans depicting him as God.
Pls read Allah ek khasam sabuka before you accuse me again.
Aga Khan is referred as Saheebi Zaamani Wal Asara in first part of ismaili Dua' . It means Lord of Time and Age. What Quran says That no person sent by Allah will say to people that I am your lord. Imam is Fraud Wake up. I am ex ismaili now.
79. No person to whom God has given the Scripture, and wisdom, and prophethood would ever say to the people, “Be my worshipers rather than God’s.” Rather, “Be people of the Lord, according to the Scripture you teach, and the teachings you learn.”
80. Nor would he command you to take the angels and the prophets as lords. Would he command you to infidelity after you have submitted?
[72:18] The places of worship are for God. So do not call, besides God, upon anyone else. (49 Imam names are called in Dua and Imam says in farman to worship him : Call names of Imam)
[10:106] And do not call, apart from God, on what neither benefits you nor harms you. If you do, you are then one of the wrongdoers.
[25:30] And the Messenger will say, "My Lord, my people have abandoned this Quran." (Why ismailis are never reading Quran ????)
Salim Bhai we appreciate your bold step for speaking truth, u r really a brave man, Allah bless you n may give you rewards of truth
Thank you Eyaan
I hope you will help me spread the word
Salam Eyaan be careful of this man in his old youtube Channel he subscribed to channels that insulte Islam and our Noble Prophet, May Allah grant Him Peace and Blessings. He might say things that are true but they remain tainted by what he may still have in his heart...
super job ....wish you could even research on other sects with similar issues.
Yes but who will put the food on my table?
Allah guide us all Ameen truth has to be revealed
Your episodes are gone again in Canada. Why can't these Ismaili leaders challenge you at an intellectual level rather than intimidation tactics
Why are followers of Agha Khan paying 12.5 percent if they are not getting in return?
because they are programmed to believe that they will go to hell if they dont pay
@@salimlalani I have spend 30 years living near Agha Khan jammat khana near garden east Karachi... Ismailis call him hazir Imam, segregated well jelled community mostly keeping to themselves. Standard of living has also improved over the years
My perspective
First of all being Ismaili, I do not relate not paying dasond with hell or paying dasond with heaven. My thought process is paying dasond is long term investment with thousand fold returns.
Do you agree that your forefathers and other people of Ismaili community were poor/farmers back in Indian villages and struggled to make their ends meet, but were still paying Dasond?
They paid Dasond and believed in Imam and outcome is that their next generations(not talking about 100 families but the entire community) are well educated or have migrated to USA/Canada/other countries and are no longer in such situations.
I have seen how my life has changed when I compare it with my forefathers and I am thankful for them to keep strong hold on pillars of faith, dasond, etc. and it is because of this, I will continue to pay Dasond and follow faith for the better future of my generations.
I do not care how Imam uses my Dasond, but I am proud to say if a very small section of my forefather dasond was used to help Ismailis in 1972 Uganda crisis or my current dasond is used to help non ismailiis around the world via AKDN or helping ismailis in poor situations.
FYI :- Nice try.... It was fun to watch the above video. Hope you contribute some money to your friend from revenue generated by views or advertisement :P
To be fair, people from Indian ancestry, including Khoja/Gujarati people, who moved to the west normally become economically successful, whether they are Ismaili or not.
And it's interesting you say that you don't care how Aga Khan uses your dasond money and you'd be happy if only a small proportion of it goes to good causes. Asking no accountability of him is giving him a higher status than Muslims gave the Prophet Muhammad (peace and blessings upon him). And this is one of many ways that ismailis put the Aga Khan above the Prophet.
Anyway I'm glad that you feel some benefit from your community. I personally feel like a freer person now that I don't have a blind loyalty to a man of questionable character who I've never met before.
Amazing! Excited for more!!!
More to come!
Looking forward to more!
It was not mandatory as you said. Well it was tout, it was advised, it was preached but not mandatory as court warrant.
First some videos disappeared and then the whole channel got deleted. A bit worrying. Hope all is okay, Salim! Please let us know if there's anything more we can do to support.
Thanks for the info....awareness...
I hv a question that if Aga Khan takes money from disciples does he give the agakhanis medical facility,education and loan also to start bussiness?? Just curious no intent to hurt anyone's belief..it takes lots of courage to go aginst family members belief..pls keep going..may Allah grant u with funds and resources..
Because I hv heard of price Aly Khan hospital in mumbai were agakhanis get free treatment
not true
@@salimlalani ok thank u
I have been following your episodes and am captivated despite being a non Ismaili shia.
Thank you Musa
What happened with your rest of the videos??
we are back
He forgot his ancestors who used to worship the animals and statues. He forgot when Uthmanids empire, Mughals, English people and Mullahs attacked them and converted them by the force of sword, doing sexual assault with their children, their adults, their women and men in the mosques and today they see with their own eyes.
He forgot the situation of his ancestors in past decades and centuries and the condition of his people when they were in a big disaster. He forgot who rescued these people from such misery and now he is alive, he has freedom (free oxygen, free environment to use, free everything he needs in his material life. So, these material life has made him blind and brainwashed him.
I don’t know which God he has found and has believe in now?
I wish him good health and to cure his memory loss soon.
👍🏻
Since assuming his role in 1957, the current Aga Khan has dedicated his efforts to improving the quality of life of the most vulnerable populations in many parts of the world, while emphasising the view of Islam as a thinking, spiritual faith: one that teaches compassion and tolerance and that upholds human dignity. In recognition of his exceptional efforts and contributions, the Aga Khan has received numerous decorations, honorary degrees, and awards from institutions and nations across the world. Your video clearly confuses fact and fiction. What you offer as fact is so skewed/stretched!
thank you for your comments
Truth hurts some people.
Aga khan is an athiest and he made fool of ismilies🤣🤣🤣🤣,
He is connected to zio..sm and is..el.
I used to be ismilie myself
Thanks Salim .Always wonder the reason why no one discussed the details of this faith or belief
Thanks
Imam Mustansir Bi’llah II, the 32nd Ismaili Imam:
“It is obligatory and necessary for the true believer to recognize his Creator who is manifest in this world in the form of a human being, and to see Him here in order to see Him also in the hereafter.”
[Imam Mustansir Bi’llah II, Pandiyat-I-Jawanmardi Or Advices of Manliness, trans. W. Ivanow (Leiden, Netherlands: E. J. Brill, 1953), 101-102.]
Thank you
@@salimlalani Np
Well said brother Hanif Ali May Allah bless you .
Aameen.
@@Shiraz354 Aameen and you too brother
@F S god in human form or an "imam" on earth, this is what the ismaili cult leader says
I am ismalili and I’m 19 grew up in Houston Texas where we have a large population of Ismaili about 40k and during my time we never ever portrayed aga khan as god we consider him a guide or a messenger of Allah and we never felt forced to pay for dasond I mean I do believe in dasond because it’s my me of the fiver pillars of Islam and that hazar Imam utilizes the money for Ismailis all around the world if I have extra money I usually put it towards dasond but I never felt forced I would usually volunteer and give seva because I felt like that was my dasond to Imam and it made me happy
Which is the first pillar of Islam according to Ismailism? salman
what you have written is based on belief not truth
for example, imam is utilizes money for ismailies
i have paid him for 5 decades, i can tell you i have rec'd $0
and i can also tell you i have paid him a substantial amount.
now i am sure you have gone to school
say you give me $100 for spending on ismailies
I promise you i will
then i pocket $90 and spend $10 for good work
i know you will ask me how do i know imam pockets $90
truth is i dont
but i did ask imam
he refused to answer
there is the problem salman
when you hide, you are upto no good
hope this helps
@@salimlalani
Imams don’t need us. We need Imamat.
Also, dasondh is a combination of Usher and Zakat.
Khums is also clearly mentioned in Quran and it’s to b submitted to the house of Prophet.
We can agree to disagree if you insist Hazar Imam is not direct descendant of Prophet.
Out Pirs in Ginans have warned us of your type of ppl.
@F S i am a kindergarten kid
Brother you are absolutely right but be careful this people are wealthy..May Allah help you
Thank you Iqbal
Yes they are wealthy
But what will wealth do against truth?
They are wealthy because they work together as groups
Hi Saleem bhai, Do u think money was the main issue u left the ismailism?
He gives an explanation of what pushes him over the edge in a later episode. I think it was episode 5.
hi kareem bhai,
ok if this is not the reason , i would be happy to have a dialogue with you on ismailism, many run away every time i approach them to discuss khoja religion, if you can face me you take up the challenge mujeebzahir@yahoo.com
I also moved not only money is proven
They do not hijab doesn't pray 5 time didn't give zakat didn't fast totally fake mazhab
Absolutely right VERY VERY INTERESTING THANKS FOR SHARING GOD BLESS YOU AMEEN
thanks
your back:-)
yes
Only fear Allah no human being
@S.A.M "Our imam never answers these ignorants because he is real IMAM."
Ismailis like to compare Aga Khan to the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him). Did you know that in the time of the Prophet, Muslims were allowed to question him and ask for accountability?
Taqqiyya . sar tan se juda .TAQLEED? Just follow. No question ask
According to Islam, zakat is to be given at 2.5% of the income by every Muslim but I guess the extra 10% is for his lavish lifestyle.
Also, in Surah Fatiha, in one of the Ayats, it is clearly stated, “Thee alone we worship and thee alone we seek for help”, then why are Ismailis obligated to use his name in the dua/namaz?
His Serena hotels openly serve alcohol at their bars yet he condemns consumption of alcohol? Hypocrisy at its finest
Honestly, there needs to be a serious official internal investigation in the funds being given to him and how he uses those funds. There also needs to be a one on one intervention to expose his lies
yes there should be an investigation
but money and power has prevented this
let us realise our power
our solidarity is also powerful
let us come together and investigate ourselves
Ismaili save you safe from hellfire and our generation listen to brave Salim
Jazak'Allah, brother! May Allah reward you for this noble work!
Assalamu alaikum be careful of this man in his old youtube Channel he subscribed to channels that insulte Islam and our Noble Prophet, May Allah grant Him Peace and Blessings. He might say things that are true but they remain tainted by what he may still have in his heart...
I was an Ismaili n converted to Suni Muslim 8 years ago.
I’m so happy the truth about Ismailis is coming out now!!!
great
May Allah protect you and keep you steadfast upon the truth 🤲
Rosie Bob Same here. I converted to Sunni Islam. May Allah grant you Jannat Al Firdaus.
Where is Salim Lalani now
Listen to him, he already mentioned he is in Australia
Thanks
Money will never buy place in heaven only good deeds why he is using qurran Muslim world will not accept insults to Qurran he should be bam to visit Muslim countries I am sure soon this will happen
I hope you have no ill intension towards him.
Nice 👍. Heard you on Akbar khoja
Thank you Ayesha
May Allah Subhanahu Taala Bless You & safe You & Your Family. Ameen 🕋
I think this is quite unfair. I am not Agha Khani but I have interacted with many Agha Khani, not once have I heard one say he is God. I have only heard this from non Ismaili Muslims. One could say they are a bit clannish but otherwise they are quite a hardworking and progressive group. Religion can be difficult, the best policy is " live and let live ".
It is obvious you have,nt seen all episodes
if you had and understood them, you would'nt be making these comments
I'm "Ismaili" and my questions have always been suppressed and shut down by my parents. Like I'm supposed to blindly believe and follow like I'm wearing a muzzle. I am happy to see these videos that challenge AK 4. we are awakened.
@@ATLTHRASHER76 no you are not awakened this guy is misguiding people's just because of money,
@@salimlalani I saw your episodes , you are absolutely wrong, you are misguiding people's just because of money, when you didn't belong to your own people's then you can't belong to anyone else,
Sotonye chukwu -i challenge, u r an agakhani.
Wow! Thank you for the courage to speak out..... You've answered so many questions i always had about this system. Can't wait to hear the other episodes......
Glad it was helpful!
As per my experience which is onpaper also, that there is no Humanity in AKDN/Ismailism.
Please see in google
By type
"Hasamukh Vadasariya & Agakhan"
Thanks...
Thank you for speaking up. More power to you. I am not one of you but I am impressed that you are voicing for those who don’t have voices. 👍
I appreciate that
You’ve hit the nail on the head regarding those who don’t have voices. Many corroborating testimonies make it clear that people who dissent from the Ismaili community are isolated and bullied and coping with their pain in silence. The abusive comments Salim has received in this channel alone show it. Ismailis can’t hide it any more.
The miss perception here is that only Ismaili pay 12 percent
No every Muslim family pay 10 percent
But Ismaili pay to big organizations like aga khan foundation who does so much around the world
The aga foundation budget is near 1 billion
A population of 15 million imagines of whole Muslim collect their 10 percent it would be 100 billion that money alone could end hunger in Muslim world
As Shia I would say well done to Ismaili you are great example of peace harmony and humanity and opens minded modern Muslims god bless you
watch episode 23 first
Shia Sunni what's wrong with just being a human being and a Muslim. read whatever books you want to read but let's remember to be human first .
I like the way you present your material salim and I’m excited to listen to what you have to say. I don’t feel as vehemently as you do that we’re being duped. I just don’t pay dasond and I’m perfectly happy ... if others want to pay, I’m ok with it. It’s only money
i wish it was only money
it is abuse of poor people that i am fighting against
How dare you tell the truth? You are not scared?
Dear Dawod, I am not scared because I speak the truth. Truth is God and God is Almighty. Pls subscribe and keep sending your comments and feedback on future podcasts. Thanks for your support.
@@salimlalani I am an ex ismaili also from Montreal. I can't thank you enough for your video. I have shared it in my social medias as well. Please continue your work. Regards.
@@thebacheafghan really appreciate
Dawod here is what my thoughts are even though you question was to Mr. Lalani . Me, being 100% Afghan fluent in Dari , BUT born and raised in Pennsylvania / New Jersey . Once you get to a point of realization you can either crawl in a hole OR have this mentality "Fear is the greatest weapon of your biggest enemy " ~. BUT thats me ...LOL Lets allow Mr. Lalani Answer.OOPS i see he did .
@@salimlalani @UCJQPDG6BfBBI-lgth_WH0XQ
question what is your ethnicity? My family is Afghan. I my cousins followers literally throw everything they have for them. I walk into a store and made a mistake and complimented a piece of jewelry and the owner took it out and packed it up for me. And I NEVER would do that to anyone . My cousin told me in my ear. Listen you must take it if you don't it would be very insulting to them. This situation happended over and over in London , when he came to the USA , and abroad. The loyality is unreal
In Ismaili system, Is agha Khan an god Or an Imam? Is there a difference between the two?
what do you think?
@@salimlalani I don't know really. I'm an ex-Shia Muslim 12 imami.
@@salimlalani I watch your 4th episode and I got what u mean
@@believeboy5250 please read your own books
Imam Mustansir Bi’llah II, the 32nd Ismaili Imam:
“It is obligatory and necessary for the true believer to recognize his Creator who is manifest in this world in the form of a human being, and to see Him here in order to see Him also in the hereafter.”
[Imam Mustansir Bi’llah II, Pandiyat-I-Jawanmardi Or Advices of Manliness, trans. W. Ivanow (Leiden, Netherlands: E. J. Brill, 1953), 101-102.]
Extraordinary becon of light in darkness world needs people like you
Thank you ishtiaq
Salim as Financial Advisor did you advice your client other ways in which he could save 12.5% to help? Or were you looking to touch upon the sensitivities of the issue after you choose to part ways from the Ismailis, if you saw your Ismaili friend did not take your suggestions well could you have adivced him differently? Was that the only option ? Your intentions may be good ???? but you know what they say, the road to hell is paved with good intentions. And by hell I speak metaphorically
Ameen
there is no need to complicate matters.
problem was simple and so was the solution.
my friend was giving when he should be receiving from the imam.
salim
Very useful insight into Aga Khanism. Very courageous of Salim. God guide you to HIs right path.
Hello Salim Sir
Your videos are all gone
Absolutely true....he is not imam he is only a man like us
who are kojas. they believe in aga khan. sorry if im wrong just keen to know
Hindus were converted in medieval times into followers of Nizari Imams. Today the Nizari Imam is Agakhan. Hope that explains.
my family are hindus. my uncle in canada is married to ismaeli muslims koja gujarati speaking. the koja muslims are peaceful and have integrated into society compared to main stream islam wahabi and shiaates. i have seen a picture of aga khan but ive never qusetioned other peoples religion as they may get insulted. we as sanatan dharma believe in al religions. thank you salim brother for your reply.
from uk. my grandad came to uk from uganda so knowing people culture without any direct contact and internet is a good source of comunication without any abusive violence.
Just wonder, how much money is taken out of a country like Pakistan on a annually by the Aga Khan foundations and how much is invested in?
Visiting Pakistan, I have seen many religious debates between the Shia and Sunni but I have never seen Agha Khani representation on TV, does anyone know why?
Also, I Wonder why the Iranian Mullah dislike Ismailis?
1) No idea how much much but big money is laundered.
2) Agakhan likes to stay away from debates in case his truth comes out
3) Mullahs will dislike anyone who commits shirk
Very interesting informations!
Glad it was helpful!
Respected Sir,
If anybody have the the contact number of Mr. Salim Lalani, please provide me.
I have a urgent request for them and I have some on paper document too. Please. Contact me gogogokool@gmail.com. I m from India.
Thanks
You are rare gem of a person
You will find joy
You will find success and more over
You will find satisfaction of that kind that is found by philosophers and great men
Brother you are an inspiration and a beacon for the quest by men of all ages for the truth
thank you but are you willing to help me?
@@salimlalani i live in India and have friends who are Aga Khanis in college and always admired them however after seeing your videos i feel for them very sorry - yet your videos are gone all of them
He is a liar, a betrayer,
@@salimlalani so now you are asking money yeah? Don't you have shame to beg, just think when you were an Ismaili you didn't needed to beg, better a greedy person like you left, you were not worth,
BRAVO my Friend BRAVO..!!!
Worship only Allah. Follow Prophet Mohammed and Love Ahley Bait.
Please prove to me that even Mohammad and Quran are the the real deal either? I don’t wanna follow someone who married a 13 yo when he was in 50s regardless pf whatever reasons. Same with Jesus. If he had the powers, he couldn’t pull out the 3 nails out of his bodies, when he was being crucified? Give me a break. This whole religion is bs. And God...Hmmm where is he or she when millions of kids are being killed. Even I shed tears. Wonder why does God not come for help?
@@samsamani7 U hv mentioned all d bad thibgs happening or happened around d world and questioning Allah's existence.
wat abt gd things??? oh all d gd things are because of logic and science. u associate all d bads with religion and gd vd Science and logic.
I worship Allah and being a Muslim I follow Isa as well. u r free to believe watever u want but not om d grounds of criticising other ppl believes.
@@zeynabyt3754 Enlighten me with a few good things but before you do that, answer my questions. Bad things need a response too...and WITH PROOF to make them untrue. Just saying that Quran is certified scripture by God is not proof....and that's one example. Another example... Mohammad was sent by GOD and had all the powers but had to fight Gazwaas to prove that ISLAM is the religion to follow? Wow...amazing huh. A powerful man struggling to prove. Smh. Jesus....the guy who had powers to resurrect humans couldn't help himself be survive or return from his own death? You can prove Aga Khan Wrong (and I agree), mostly with modern history (technology and all) but you can't prove Mohammad or Jesus or even other Gods and messengers to be true because there's nothing the HIS-STORY (history) books that were written with people we don't even freakn know. Anyone can glorify their existence. If you read the Quran or any "holy" books, they're all common sense scriptures. You're human....follow your conscience and you won't need any religion, religious personalities, and/or holy scriptures. And finally, you saying that you follow Allah and adding Prophet Mohammad is indirectly criticizing others for what they're doing. Start thinking so you don't contradict yourself and produce bs responses.
@@zeynabyt3754 sister I was ismili now I am mukallid of agha sistani
@@samsamani7 are you ismili ?
What I don't understand is why does it trouble anyone else what the Ismailis do or pay. It doesn't bother them. As matter of fact the Ismailis progressed in every aspect of life even Financially even after paying Dasond. Clearly the Ismailis are doing something right.
aarondaya
you say you dont understand
to understand there at least three requirements
open ears open eyes and a brain a process the info collected
you have demonstrated in your comments that all the three did'nt function
pls watch again
what i have said in the video will be elaborated in following videos
salim
Your videos are enlightening
As a Hindu I worked for an aga khan university in London. It was like being in another world. I was a vut obsessed readong about them and their duas especially as a Gujarati person. I dare not ask questions but I was getting so much info on RUclips and intense searching online. When aga khan visited in london followers literally wet themselves. I mean... he's just a man! I'm so glad I got out of there.
👍
Can u work in Makkah as hindo?
Well, people cry when they see their icons, that's normal. I see people crying when they meet famous singers, actors, sportsmen, and spiritual leaders @Jyoti Alfino
My family was plucked from horrific discrimination and unimaginable poverty thanks to the Imam. I'm sorry you were taught the way that you were, and glad you've found what works for you, but accusing an ancient interpretation of Islam of being a cult is ignorant by every measure: We don't try to recruit others, we're encouraged to pursue secular education, independent theological thought, and economic independence. It's also wholly irresponsible given the everyday discrimination we face let alone deadly attacks, I know as an Afghan and as a woman.
Thank you for your comments
I agree I am ignorant
I hardly know anything
But one thing I know is Agakhanism is a cult.
It is bigotry on your part to pass your judgement before being heard. Have you ever seen a judge in a courtroom passing judgement before giving the accused an opportunity to speak?
Ariana please allow me to talk about how this is a cult
Allow me the opportunity to talk about help and the amount of money Imam receives
If I don’t have right to be heard, if I don’t have a right to present evidence of what I am talking about, then that will be denying a human being’s basic right
You screwed up Dasond is a pillar but if one doesn't nobody throws him out
@@salimlalani You have every right to be heard, even to attack the Imam, and jamaat, no one is going to call for your murder or even harrass you.
I can't speak to your religious education, but it's now standardized by ITREB, and no text books teach people to donate finacially or face hell, and no one is harrassed for financial contributions. By presenting blatently false narratives about us you're actively encouraging the kind of daily, lived, bigotry we experiance, including the genocide my family faced first hand in places like Afghanistan under the Taliban or Daish in Syria. Not everyone lives in a free society.
@@arianakhan6665 Thanks Ariana for allowing me the courtesy of being heard
Now do me one more favor and tell me about blatantly false narratives
I will correct myself
Thanks again for at least not abusing me like few of your community members
@@salimlalani Imamate institutions are the largest employers and investors in Isma'ili regions in Tajikistan and Afghanistan. Have you looked at the infant mortality rate drop, literacy, or employment rates?
i'm not clear where you arrived at Isma'ili believe the Imam is God. It's not in a farman i've come across. Did you consult ITREB, a Rai, read text books like _Knowledge and Liberation_ by Khusrow _et al,_ familarize yourself with Islamic history like the Martyrdom of Mansur Al Hallaj and his place in Sufism?
You don't deserve abuse, even as you've created a series of videos debasing my community, your family, and former friends. A British Pakistani tv presenter, Saira Khan, simply stated she respected Islam, but wasn't a practicing Muslim, and is now recieving a torrent of death threats, people are being murdered for cartoons in France, global Muslim protests against French free speech, which are real theats to free speech and they don't come from Ismailis.
Brother I atmost agree with you, Aga Khan is a ruthless businessman not humanitarian person. AKF is just eyewash , in the name of AKF he grabbing millions of dollar donation on yearly basis.
Thanks for watching and keep your comments coming
I was born an Aga Khani too, but Jesus saved me from the cult and now I'm a desciple of Lord Jesus. My mom and dad too got saved. May I invite you to learn more about the Gospel and come to know Jesus...start with listening to John Macarthur and read Gospel of John
Dear Ambreen
Congratulations on being saved.
As far as your invitation to Christianity is concerned, I must politely decline.
I have been there and decided not to follow any faith based systems
Salim
Shukar Alhamdulellah I am ismaili muslim agakhan is our 49th imam we are true muslim thanks Allah 🤲🤲
So you believe agha khan is God or ali ???hour imam never pray your imam never perfume huj ...your imam let his daughter to marry yahoodi ... your imam dancing in club what kind of muslim your
It's all a lie. Have you seen it with your own eyes? And agakhan is our 49th imam only
This series belittles the faith of so many human beings.
Yes we all have the right to think the way we want but trying to persuade others to abandon their faith, by sowing seeds of doubt, under the guise of spreading “truth”, smells of a deeper objective - perhaps one driven by personal grudges.
If I try to balance Salim’s views with what the Ismaili Imam has achieved, the latter’s documented track record shines through.
That said, to each his own. Follow what gives you happiness, without harming others.
thank you for your comments
Mr Alibhoy, it doesn't belittle faith. It criticises BLIND faith.
Blind faith that is being exploited to make people LOTS of money. Your skilful use of spin makes you look more complicit than naive, but I shouldn't judge because when I was Aga Khani I would have jumped to his defence also.
Mr Alibhoy
Your comment about balancing the argument by considering track record of what he has achieved.
great point!!
now show me a record of how much he receives in dollar terms???
If you or me had received that much, we could have achieved what he has achieved, if not more.
Bless you may Allah Protect you and family
thank you
When I said he considered him as God plz listen to Shamshoud Doha comment.👏
If what you say is true that why don't you confront him face to face instead of saying behind his back?
i would love to do that
i did everything to invite him for a face to face
i got ignored
if you can help me i will be grateful
I think that's a lame reply they say there is always a way where there is a will, so thats means that you are just not ready to do to what you talk about and give lame excuse
@@salimlalani sorry to say then i think then every other day someone like you would put a video on social media be it an ismaili Muslim, non or confused one, and he has to meet in person & clarify his position, & everything he does, besides saying on media & private gathering (darbar/ginan/firman, his work etc.) that i am your 49th imam & direct descendent of prophet Mohd pbuh. its absurd.
ALLAH YEHI IMAM IS DIFFERENT THAT IMAM YEHI ALLAH. Has Aga Khan himself proclaimed himself as ALLAH? NO - He says Bismillah hir rehman nir rahim himslf when he starts a lecture. Also every religion has "money" connected to it.