Evolution into Whales
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 2 окт 2024
- Here is a link to the whole playlist:
• History of Whale Paleo
Join this channel to get access to perks:
/ @aronra
If you like what I do, please consider supporting my efforts.
PATREON► / aronra
PAYPAL► www.paypal.me/... 
Развлечения
I like the analogy of "Take a picture of a person every day from the day they are born. Define the exact day that person became a toddler, adolescent, adult and senior."
Any chance of octopus evolution next. A) I find octopi super interesting b) I know bugger all about their evolution
Good idea!
@AronRa cool, I did start looking at it recently, I think our nearest common ancestor is actually precambrian. I don't have the time to really dig into it though, I'm not being super lazy!
@@JDODify The nearest common ancestor between Protostomes (like Octopods) and Deuterostomes (like us) would indeed be pre-Cambrian.
@@AronRa they’re probably not big fans of fossilising either, so it must be so difficult to work out their lineage in any detail.
Just looked it up. Nephrazoans include both Protostomes and Deuterostomes... before we were even "just an asshole" 540Mya
Balderdash! You can find sea fossils on mountains because that’s where the flood dropped them. My family’s preacher’s imaginary friend told him so…
No no no! They're clearly there to test your faiþ
Everybody can learn more from these 42 minutes than from thousands of hours of bible studies.
But where else can I learn that to get stripped offspring, the mother has to look a stripped plants during 'The Deed'?
@@alanhilder1883 Have a kindergartner make up a story about where babies come from or why things look the way they do and you'll probably end up with something equal if not better than what the Bible says.
And the 2,000 hours it takes to unlearn the babble.
seeing the only thing you'll learn from bible studies is bible story details, yes.
Don't get me wrong learning about whale evolution is awesome but the idea that you can't learn anything from the Bible shows an inability to grasp poetry, allegory, linguistic development and the way those tie tied to history.
Like the Torah is is a text chock full of glimpses into the way people thought and lived. It's an ethnography and code of laws that got turned into a religious text and that's fascinating.
I really appreciate the effort that goes into researching, scripting and creating these phylogeny videos, they are simply superb.
They remain my favorite Aron Ra content. Which is saying something, because all of his content is good.
@@KianaWolf Good? It's so dumb. Feet? Toes? Just weird
@@maffimukshukran9369
Why are you so afraid?
Mesonychids are cool; a perfect example of how evolution 'tries everything and see what sticks'
Also showing no intelligence involved, no creator.
Aron Ra! Everytime I hope for more, you do one!👍💙💙💙🥰✌
Virgin "atheist channel morphs into a right-wing conspiracy or TERF channel" versus chad "atheist channel morphs into science education channel"
Keep winning, aron
Just finished, and it's a keeper.
It's fascinating as all of these are.
Thank you, Aron Ra.
Imma need a cetacean for your claims.
Why did I laugh at that? ;-)
Excellent.
I'd never considered how much of a "living transitional species" manatees are. I didn't know that they still essentially have fingernails in their flippers.
I once overheard someone at dinner say the Manatee "disproves evolution". Smh. We were on a cruise so I did not engage.
@@seamusmcfadden994 I don't blame you, but I'm mischievous enough to have feigned complete ignorance and asked them "Oh? How so?" just to watch them display their lack of knowledge. 😉
@@George89999 I love that!
@@seamusmcfadden994 Thanks but I can't claim too much credit for it. Socrates supposedly used a similar technique to get people to question their beliefs.
My farts make mire sense
I'm gonna say, we need more of these videos.
Do a series on most well known animals, so people will have something to show the religious liars who claim evolution isn't real...
Seriously, if these videos were everywhere, instead of churches, we'd be space travelers by now..😂
I took my super religious MIL to a mammoth archaeological dig museum not realizing she teeters on the creationism crazy fence. She wanted to come on vacation with me and my husband, and I was the entertainment guide 😂 a stanch atheist teetering on the antithesis fence.
@@agiraffe3673 nice
18:30 Unfortunatley pig-footed bandicoots became extinct in the middle of the 20th century due to habitat loss and predation from feral cats and foxes. _Please_ keep your cats inside, because they can do a lot of damage to native wildlife.
right,
coffee..chk
smoke...chk
Let the learning commence.🤓
Nothing like a taxonomy lesson from Aron in the morning. Thanks for all that you do.
thx for what? were you concerned about your toes? this video was so dumb.
These phylogenetic breakdowns are some of my favorite content on the internet. Thank you so much for your continuous efforts.
Just what I needed, an over 40 minute video on whale evolution. Thank you Aron! Whether it's short or long content I'm always excited to see your uploads.
It's no wonder why you are the foremost authority on evolution. and are responsible for the largest database on evolution. with extremely detailed videos like this one and the many many other videos. and the effort, study, and research, there in on evolution.
thank you so much Aron Ra I appreciate it.
I'd really love to see Aron get into the hilarious mess that is terrestrial isopod taxonomy
He's kinda done that already 😂
I found a new one. It was so aware and conscious I thought we were communicating somehow.
Rolly Polly's?
@@thomascanfield8571 Woodlice generally.
@@thomascanfield8571 they are terrestrial crustacean not insects.
Always found Cetacea’s and other marine mammals fascinating since watching Flipper starring Paul Hogan. It’s a shame that they are under attack from hunting, submarine sonar, pollution and ironically entertainment use. Theists also often have referred to them as fish as Ketos means big fish in Greek and some refuse that they evolved from land mammals.
I absolutely love your evolution videos. And cetacean evolution is one of my favourite tools against creationists.
explaining evolution in depth is like the ultimate troll to christians.
A question for creationists. How do you account for the enormous number of now extinct species?
I look forward to reading your answers.
I'll give it a go.
God works in mysterious ways.
Ours is not to question gods choices.
You'll be sorry when Jesus comes back.
Blah blah reasons blah boring blah more reasons!😁
Erm, umm... God created fossils to fool the nonbelievers into embracing Satan!! ✝️🙇♂️🙏
@@herbieshine1312 Jesus isn't coming; he's just breathing hard.
Thank you Aron for this brilliantly clear exposition! 👍🏻😊
No wonder whales breathe air. It all makes so much sense, and all the info adds evidence to the bigger picture. You can tell it's true.
At 21:56, pronghorns are incorrectly shown grouped with bison rather than giraffes.
I feel spoiled that this man gives this information for free
I knew *Bob the fish* was real!! 🤣
This is extremely interesting and highly informative!!
Thank you for another great breakdown! Keep up the good work 🤘
Hell yeah let’s talk whales!
What did you just say about my mother?
@@tabularasa0606🤨
@@tabularasa0606she had a whale of a time
It's spelled 'Welsh'. And it consists of long series of whistles and gutterings that are unintelligible.
@@tabularasa0606i know someone who likes whales don't worry.
Can you do videos like this for children or teen ages, with the same complexity but with easier words, that’d be amazing
Plus it might help break through for at least a few more creationists who are on the edge.
Not to take content away from Aron, but in the meantime you might want to check out Forrest Valkai. His stuff tends to be a bit more understandable for laypeople :)
Feel free to bop me off your channel, but I really think you are at your best doing taxonomy and phylogenetics.
Thank you kindly. The sad thing is that these phylogeny videos take SO much time and work, and then they get fewer views than some of my unscripted rants. This video took me a week just to do the editing!
@AronRa Much respect! Just grateful for any content when the resources are available to release them!
Off-topic, but a small pleasure I got from this was seeing the pangolin walk. I’d heard of them, but I never realized they could balance on their hind legs with such weird delicacy.
A great overview Aron. Thanks for all your effort.
Always love your educational content. I see you've worked hard to improve the audio (but, it's adorable when one of your animals makes a guest appearance😉).
Awesome stuff Aron! I so wish i had the financial means to support your channel, i simply cant right now but as soon as i can i will be joining your patreon.
I said as much in another video that I planned on starting to rewatch your entire science based video series, but with my 2 year, 3 month old granddaughter, a video or three every weekend she stays over with grandma and me. She stays with us every single weekend, from Friday evening until Sunday afternoon. Along with her usual toddler appropriate videos, dancing to 80s heavy metal music. She is already starting to speak several words of Ozzy Osbourne's "Crazy Train" as the song runs. She even emulates Randy Rhoads minus an actual guitar (dad owns one at home). She also helps me in my backyard garden during the growing season, she eats some of the veges we grow right off the vine. She already knows how to count to 20 in English and 10 in Spanish, and knows several sign language movements. I'm glad my granddaughter and all future grandchildren of mine will be spared the dogmas, fanaticism, and fairytales of organized religion. Thank you AronRa for the great work you've done over the years
@AronRa ... I disabled my Twitter well over a year ago, and thus do not have nor care to use Telegram app. Unless of course, it wasn't the real you who replied to me yesterday? I'll be on the lookout for trying to catch you when you're live and shoot you a SuperChat. It would be easy enough to figure out if you legit replied to me. Although, it seems that reply is no longer here. So ...
@CaptFoster5 there were loads of those supposedly from Aron offering Christmas/ new year prizes/ gifts.
They seem to have all gone now.
@@herbieshine1312 as much as I would otherwise believe the real deal AronRa would in fact be cool enough to do something like this on a small scale, I had a sneaking suspicion the offer that was dropped here was fake. Scammers are everywhere and one of the lowest lifeforms among humanity
@@CaptFoster5 it’s a scam that affects most channels. Scammers create accounts using the images of the creator and similar name and try to lure people on telegram with various false promises. Don’t click and report them as spammers. Stay alert.
Happy new year.
You are extremely articulate in your field. Very interesting.
Look out --- some scammer is posting in this thread.
All I can say is, "nuh-uh! That's not what the bibel sez!!"
Checkmate!
This is the content I like the most. I don't really care about the fallacies of religion, I care about biology and taxonomy and Aron is at his best in this kind of videos
That Hooters picture made me chuckle LOL....great work Aron.
Happy New Year, Aron! Thank you for all your wonderful work!
Cheers from Argentina!
Awww.. you left on a cliff hanger!! Seriously fascinating information. I can well appreciate the amount of effort involved in making this. Already waiting for the next one!
Oh shit, i've been looking forward to this one.
Thanks Aron
I've recently been recommended Answers in Genesis videos, which feature this awkward panel discussion of people who mindlessly scoff at this sort of stuff, so I'm glad you're still doing these explainer videos.
take a shot every time aron says "it's not a shrew"
I take it we can expect the Scrotifera episode to drop this Sunday?
Super job. Can’t wait for the next one.
Any day with an Aron drop is. Good day.
At last, more of my favourite material from Aron.
I look forward to the next instalment.😀
Ayo why does Bob The Fish have to be so sexy, damn!
7:39 "by this point in the revolution they finally had nipples as a focal point"
Damn skippy! 😂 Zatheria of the world UNITE!
I see some of them took the Tylopod challenge.
I watch the whole series on the systematic classification of life yearly; this style of delivery is awesome and the subject matter fascinating.
AronRa's _Systematic Classification of Life_ is the best goddamn series on RUclips.
Whippomorpha 2: Epipelagic Boogaloo
Well done especially pointing out transitional fossils you know the ones creationists say we dont have 😂
And we most definitely know they're not fish🐋🐋🐳🐳
But the bible says....🤔😉
Except they are most definitely fish. Just descended from that lineage of lobe-finned fish that climbed out of the water and gave rise to every tetrapod and then every amniote and then every mammal...
@@rianfelis3156 nope 🐳 are mammals.
@@rianfelis3156 "Descended from" does not equate to "are currently." Same way that we are not fish, but we have a common ancestor that was.
@@grapeshot If we are to get technical, "fish" refers to a colloquial polyphyletic group of animals that include all vertebrates excluding stegocephali, and some may also add starfish, jellyfish and the like. Since it isn't scientific, whales and otters are fish depending on the time period.
Sorry, Aron, I just got out of a meeting with management, we're gonna need you to do one of these series on every major extant mammalian group 😄👍
Never gets old hearing you explain these things
Nice of the creatard's gawd to lay down all the transitional fossils into neatly ascending layers of evolving development for us to research. Thank you mister gawd.
I bet creationists hate all of this irrefutable evidence.
They will just evolve their argument and say "it's still a mammal".
Wonderfully informative and yet, somehow entertaining at the same time. Very well done Aron.
One of the most important reasons why I accepted evolution was when I was in college taking a biology class and realized that everything fit neatly into nested hierarchies and there were no separate kinds or clean breaks. That one species nested neatly into a genus which nested into a family which nested into an order, etc. Like family relationships.
I'm not in college, nor do I have a degree. However, now that I've stopped blindly subscribing to Christianity's dogmas, evolution makes so much sense. I'm glad to have my mind open to learning.
Imagine if Yahweh actually had a cloaca. 😂
I'm still trying to figure out why "he" had an appendix (if "he" existed before us and we were made in "his" image)?
@@AndrewJens clearly “he” had some big ole testicles. 😂 And an anus to poop outside the camp.
That was brilliant Aron. Thank you. 👍
I’ll keep it simple so anyone can understand it.
Literally speaks at a college level 😹
He is not speaking at a "college level"
You can pause the video any time you like to look up any word or concept you are struggling with.
another great video. I would love to see a video on why things keep evolving into crabs
Will start watching in a few minutes.
I'm hoping you remember to mention how men can really, honestly, definitely get swallowed by one of these fishes and live inside them😉🤔😂
Excellent stuff. Educational and entertaining....as all education should be. Cant wait for the next one. Really cant wait....so I'll be delving (diving ?) into the literature on whale evolution for myself before it comes out. Thanks for stimulating my interest. Keep 'em coming !!
I love now the greensvreen and not just sitting with a webcam. Keep it up.
Yes. Style and quality is in continuous progress
✌️☮️🖤
@@kaudsiz like I love where he showed how wrong john and jane are.
rock on
I apppreciate that one Zatherium you show here.
Huge! Love the content Aron. Keep it up!
GREAT video. Complexity theory, assembly theory help establish the rock solid science of evolutionary biology on a more mathematical basis.
Okay now this was what I was waiting for and it is proves to be as surprisingly diverse as I have come to expect from watching Aron's work on classification.
Thank you for the amazing effort, your educational videos are an invaluable resource
I’m someone who’s already interested in paleontology, taxonomy and phylogeny as a whole, so it wasn’t a learning experience for me. But goodness gracious, your ability to speak and educate clearly and effectively is incredible. Great video, Mr. Ra.
About 26 minutes in, the hippo having a feed and the crocodile backing off very fast. The second hippo is looking closely at that crocodile, thinking about a snack.
26:10 We really zoom in on where the whales should fit in.
I am such a child, most of the time i was thinking about bollock jokes 😀
Absolutely fascinating. Thank you for the depth of understanding given here.
Boy, it woulda sounded weird if Jim Morrison said, "I am the Basilosaurus, I can do anything."
I'll just... I'll show myself out now.
Love it! Best explanation ever - but did Jesus have a pet dinosaur 🦕?
Your videos certainly have an unique style, bit strange but very informative and entertaining. :D
Aron, while this is extremely informative, just about every technical term you have used is way beyond the understanding of every creationist and most other theists. Einstein suggested explain it like you are talking to a child. Because children are who you are trying to educate, the rest of us are already walking along side you.
My 7 year old brother knew all the names of the dinosaurs, and which came in which epoch. Kids aren't scared by big words unless adults implicitly tell them to be.
Yah but your brother is an atheist.
Brilliantly put together and described. Just about to watch again…
"forget to mention", I always thought they did that on purpose because wikipedia is run by jerks. It is also on my shopping list of things I wish I could tell wikipedia, that is if they listened to criticism, that and why is everything listed alphabetically. Both of which drives me cray-cray.
Fantastic work, you're a natural teacher. bravo 👏
sup aron
This is fantastic. So interesting and informative. Very well done Sir.
Thank you sincerely.
Doesn't modification is your answer ?
What kinda err you believe in ?
How can fish modify by adding what is not there ?
How can fish modify feet if feet is not created ?
@AronRa you say descent modification
How can you modify feet if the descent never had feet
@@Wholetruth2024 can you please get a school child's education in basic science before embarrassing yourself publicly again?
@DataJack very well done,,BWAHAHAHAHA,,hilarious
Brilliant! Thank you Aron Ra.
This video is so good I pushed the like button 8 times!
Keep up the phylogenetic/cladistics videos Aron. Thanks for all the wonderful work and education.
wow, this is a great topic
thanks!
Amazing stuff. Thankyou, @AronRa.
it's a damn shame these videos don't get nearly as large a viewing as the debunking/defenestration content
Whales returning to the sea: "THE BOY ARE BACK IN TOWN AGAIN!"
Dude your are so amazing! I feel like I'm learning some secret information that humanity has always tried to hide! Thankyou so much for this❤❤
An hour of Aron, beats a lifetime of biblical slavery!
I love this stuff. Keep it up.
I love you Aron! You're a goddamned rock star of education and rationality!!! I appreciate the work you do so much!!