This comment is great. This is a melody that has always stuck in my head from youth, this movement in particular - i dont know why (im not a fan of the classics in general). I learned both guitar and piano, and I am a guitarist firstly, yet i have only ever partially worked this out by ear (i never learned to read sheet music) so its awesome to see the hand positions and TAB too. Weirdly, though i hardly play, its way easier to play on Piano, and i worked out far more by ear.
You won't hear any A minor compositions like this in any casino bit you will hear C major happy songs. What's most amazing is it's the exact same notes, lol.
When Beethoven in his 30s . He wrote this . And it has never been anything close to A or to C natural . Its was written and composed in c# sharpe. This was never intended to sound in minor nor i. Major . This is one of the most complex pieces of all time . And the progression is unmatched until nowadays.
Mister, thank you very much! as for me this sonata is the best music to play! Just the day before yesterday finished to learn last tact! now it will be the years of practicing to make it sound perfectly, because this music deserves to sound perfectly😊
Absolument magnifique! Il faut beaucoup de travail pour réussir à jouer un tel morceau de guitare et vous l'avez fait! Bravo Robert, vous êtes un grand artiste!
"Thank-you so much for Tutoring This Robert, it is one of my most favourite pieces of classical music. The Tab Really, Really helps as I do not read (Stave?) Music. Bit by bit I am gradually getting to grips with it. Just to (eventually) be able to play this properly (Before I reach my 70th) will be like I have climbed a Musical Mountain, so Thank-you so very much, all your effort and time is very much appreciated.
Such a great piece of music. I learned to play it fairly well to bar 24 a couple years ago. There is much to remember. It`s going to take a while to learn the whole piece and play it well. Needs to be practiced every day for at least a few hundred hours. For me anyway. Sounds great Robert. Not an easy tune.
It’s a beautiful song and I hesitated to make this arrangement because it is so difficult to make an arrangement for guitar from piano. It’s a hard song on piano
Is the tempo steady 12/8 ? Or is it changing depending on the guitarist? I try to go with metronome but on some points seems it changes to off beat , or is it on 1 of every 12 counts but sometimes the guitaristbhas a a delay on timing on purpose?
@@RobertLunn Great, i thought also it gives some emotion. Also on 007 007 repeat on video u play as i remember e b g strings as 007 but the second time u play e g b strings if i am not wrong, measure 26. Is it right the notes or what u play. Also i would like to tell u u are my mentor on classical guitar. U are great teacher and player!!
It is right either way because sometimes I will change the fingerings because I find a different way that works for me. That is wonderful to hear and best of luck!
No, because I think with the fingers you actually feel it more and can vary the different tones with the expression you want 😊 But maybe there is someone out there making an electric guitar version 🤔
Esto es absurdo salió hace 8 horas y justo ayer comenzó a buscar para aprenderme esto es el destino muchas gracias maestro
Oh wonderful!
This comment is great.
This is a melody that has always stuck in my head from youth, this movement in particular - i dont know why (im not a fan of the classics in general).
I learned both guitar and piano, and I am a guitarist firstly, yet i have only ever partially worked this out by ear (i never learned to read sheet music) so its awesome to see the hand positions and TAB too.
Weirdly, though i hardly play, its way easier to play on Piano, and i worked out far more by ear.
I'm playing this In a few days for my college showcase performance! Thank you for the transcription
Oh that is wonderful to hear!
how did it go?
what have you done?
Metal enjoyer instant disqualification
Try capo 4th fret . And u will stun them
On behalf of humanity, thank you very much!!
I appreciate that!
Beautiful
Огромное спасибо за публикацию этой прекрасной композиции. Ваши видео отлично подходят для людей, которые хотят научиться играть на гитаре.
I appreciate that!
I too am taking on this beast of a song. It will be the grand finale for my personal set list. Beautiful piece. Beautiful arrangement. Great playing.
Best of luck to you!
Right here with you brother. How’s it going 4 months later lol
@@CamoFlex right here with you brother, how is it a month later?
Fantastic!
Thank you!
You won't hear any A minor compositions like this in any casino bit you will hear C major happy songs. What's most amazing is it's the exact same notes, lol.
well, the are often used together for a reason like in dust in the wind. Cmajor can sound pretty sad too.
@@AcousticOlli Dust in the Wind somehow even makes G sound sad.
there's a G sharp in this though kind of a harmonic minor scale
When Beethoven in his 30s . He wrote this . And it has never been anything close to A or to C natural . Its was written and composed in c# sharpe. This was never intended to sound in minor nor i. Major . This is one of the most complex pieces of all time . And the progression is unmatched until nowadays.
It sounds so beautiful❤
Thank you!
Thank you so much my friend 🎶🎶
Wonderfull😊😊
Mister, thank you very much! as for me this sonata is the best music to play! Just the day before yesterday finished to learn last tact! now it will be the years of practicing to make it sound perfectly, because this music deserves to sound perfectly😊
Best of luck to you!
Absolument magnifique!
Il faut beaucoup de travail pour réussir à jouer un tel morceau de guitare et vous l'avez fait!
Bravo Robert, vous êtes un grand artiste!
Thank you very much!
thank you for this, you sound great.
Thank you 😊
I can feel real moonlight with this music, thank you, thank you so much my friend your guitar sounds very cool and soft like moonlight
I am glad you enjoyed it!
Thank you very much
You are most welcome!
thanks!!!!!!
🙏🙏🙏
by the way I want to say - it is sounding better on guitar then on piano
Its just your preference, to my ears both are excellent, I also like it in harp, beautiful sound indeed.
don't push it
agreed
That part at 2:39 is what made me learn this song
Oh nice!
Thank you! Grazie Mille Maestro!
Thank you!
Best teacher!
I appreciate that!
G-d this is so incredible
😊🙏
Awesome
Thank you!
Hy Maestro, j'm studying your tutorial with rallenty, and now j'm able to play half piece...! ! Thanks!
Wonderful!!
"Thank-you so much for Tutoring This Robert, it is one of my most favourite pieces of classical music. The Tab Really, Really helps as I do not read (Stave?) Music. Bit by bit I am gradually getting to grips with it. Just to (eventually) be able to play this properly (Before I reach my 70th) will be like I have climbed a Musical Mountain, so Thank-you so very much, all your effort and time is very much appreciated.
That is wonderful and best of luck!
Çok güzel çalıyorsunuz elinize sağlık Türkiye'den selamlar ☺️
Thank you and very nice to meet you!
Clean❤
🙏🙏
Very nice 👌
Thank you!
Thank
😊🙏
Thank you🫵😎🍻🙏
You are welcome!
Nice🔥
Thank you!
درود بی پایان به شما پاینده استاد گرامي پاینده و پیروز باشید 🌹🌹🌹👏👏👏
I appreciate that and thank you!
Once again Robert wonderful ... on the list of to dos! This is like the myth of sisyphus! 😅
Wonderful!
Мне понравилось.
Очень чувственно. Спасибо 👏👏👏
Thank you!
Thanks!
You are most welcome!
Sublime
Thank you!
Nice playing 😮
Thank you 🙏
Such a great piece of music. I learned to play it fairly well to
bar 24 a couple years ago. There is much to remember. It`s
going to take a while to learn the whole piece and play it well.
Needs to be practiced every day for at least a few hundred hours.
For me anyway. Sounds great Robert. Not an easy tune.
Such a great piece of music. Best of luck!
Third movement? 😊
I would be AMAZED to hear anyone play that on guitar!
@@MaguireGuitar check out Emre Sabuncuoglu.
@MaguireGuitar you're in luck. LA Guitar Academy has that on youtuge.
Thank you !! This looks very 3:58 playable! Again, thank you for 3:58 doing so much for struggling guitarists!!
I’m glad you enjoyed it!
It is on my list! I hope I live long enough to get to it!!
@@MaguireGuitarit doesnt actually look that hard at all you know
@@MaguireGuitarlearn it it wouldn’t take that long
Thank you for this legend we need lesson for cuban dance please our teacher
The first classical piece I've played on my classical guitar (I have been playing for half a year now), thanks for the great tab!
That’s wonderful!
Please name another best classical most melodious piece, i just need more practice
@@krishnaborah454Spanish romance is always a good one!
@@RobertLunn well thank you for suggesting. You played it beautifuly 👍🏼
@@krishnaborah454Für Elise is great, I learned it as my first. The second was Comptine d'un autre été, l'après-midi by Yann Tiersen.
3:29
Very beautiful musik!👍👏🙂🌞
Beautiful piece!
nice
Thank you
Круто!!!
Thank you!
It looks impossible, but its so satisfying to actually play
I agree!
Thank you for this video. Looks hard as fuck uuugh but I can’t be a cool wise grandpa someday without it
It’s certainly not the easiest piece
😮❤❤❤❤
🙏🙏🙏
🎉❤
Извините пожалуйста, а это полный разбор???
It is the full first movement!
@@RobertLunn можно все части?
This is so hard, I feel very very frustrated but I love this song
It’s a beautiful song and I hesitated to make this arrangement because it is so difficult to make an arrangement for guitar from piano. It’s a hard song on piano
Muito difícil essa música só pra mestre mesmo
Unfortunately it isn’t easy
Is the tempo steady 12/8 ? Or is it changing depending on the guitarist? I try to go with metronome but on some points seems it changes to off beat , or is it on 1 of every 12 counts but sometimes the guitaristbhas a a delay on timing on purpose?
Personally, I like to speed up and slow down
@@RobertLunn Great, i thought also it gives some emotion. Also on 007 007 repeat on video u play as i remember e b g strings as 007 but the second time u play e g b strings if i am not wrong, measure 26. Is it right the notes or what u play. Also i would like to tell u u are my mentor on classical guitar. U are great teacher and player!!
It is right either way because sometimes I will change the fingerings because I find a different way that works for me. That is wonderful to hear and best of luck!
Anyone do this with a pick instead of fingers?
No, because I think with the fingers you actually feel it more and can vary the different tones with the expression you want 😊
But maybe there is someone out there making an electric guitar version 🤔