The Philippines' Fragile Truce With Its Muslim Separatists: Will Peace Hold? | Insight
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 22 апр 2024
- It has been 10 years since the Filipino government signed a peace deal with the separatist group, the Moro Islamic Liberation Front (MILF). The government promised autonomy and development for the Bangsamoro region. In return, the MILF pledged to decommission their troops.
But recently, the peace agreement is fraying at the edges, with the army and MILF forces clashing in November 2022. The MILF has complained that promised economic reforms and aid have not arrived, while the government says the MILF are slow in disarming.
In one year, the region will elect its own government. As time is running out to complete the terms of the deal, will peace hold? Or will failed promises threaten the fragile truce?
• 00:03 Introduction
• 03:22 The turbulent history of Southern Philippines
• 06:30 The formation of the MNLF and the beginning of conflict
• 08:14 Making peace with the Muslim separatists
• 14:16 A fragile peace
• 17:40 Unfulfilled promises threaten to derail hard won peace
• 24:56 Bangsamoro in the Marcos Jr era.
• 27:50 The destablising effect of clan feuds
• 31:05 Other militant groups remain threats in the region
• 35:50 The scars of violence after decades of war
• 38:48 What will the 2025 elections mean for the Bangsamoro?
• 43:42 What happens next?
===============
ABOUT THE SHOW: Insight investigates and analyses topical issues that impact Asia and the rest of the world.
==========================
#CNAInsider #CNAInsight #Philippines #Bangsamoro
For more, SUBSCRIBE to CNA INSIDER!
cna.asia/insideryoutubesub
Follow CNA INSIDER on:
Instagram: / cnainsider
Facebook: / cnainsider
Website: cna.asia/cnainsider
Truth hurts but the reality is right now, a Muslim in a Christian village can live their life safely, a Christian in a Muslim village cannot.
As long as the Muslim community views and teaches that everyone out of their religion is an outsider it will never end.
What do you expect from that false religion? It had a pure demonic origin and yet it's weird how Jesus is the One who will return in the Judgment Day as the perfect Judge as mentioned in their hadiths.
this is true to the rest of the world. europe, usa, india, name it. only israel knows how to deal with these religion of peace
I know exactly what you mean brother, we have the same situation in India. These people* have problems everywhere with every other community, and when clashes happen they play victim card.
Case in point, ISIS. All driven by lust for women and power.
Ironic they say they are peaceful but wish death upon people who dont want to convert to their beliefs. And those who say they are muslim and have friends with different beleifs, then your just disobeyed muhammads teachings and considered out of islam.
It's not a good time for Muslim and Christian divide within the Philippines because there is currently a much larger and more dangerous threat coming from outside the Philippines...
Bare in your mind: ISIS is greatest threat not China
you got it in reverse, the threat of losing 1/3 of your country is always greater than losing some island. if you lose some uninhabited island so what? if you lose 1/3 of your country, are you still the same country? the reason Duterte is sus of US is when he was mayor, he saw the CIA bribe the police to get a bomb maker out of the country. why is american bomb maker making bombs where the muslim are? if US can use Philippine has a proxy against China, you really think they can't use the muslim as proxy against Philippines?
too many ignorant from ur country
as expected of "m@ va va" "u r !" "I @ h 1"
Malaysia? 😆
We Malaysian always support our brothers and sisters in Southern Philippines
We all from the same roots Tekbir! الله أكبر
no we don't , we don't get involve in foreign wars.
Free Sabah
@@Pets_Wildlifep belah dari Malaysia bukan dia payah 😂😂..sekupang pun tak rugi..
Thank you brother. We the Bangsamoro people are forever grateful to the Malaysian people and its government. Jazakhallahu khairan. Subhanallah, Alhamdulillah, Lailahaillahllah, Allahuakbar.
Soon Mindanao brother will be one of the territory of Malaysia I'm a Muslim in Mindanao no to Philippines but Malaysia ☝️
During my time the muslim students always the nicest and modest. My mother was a public school teacher in mindanao and the muslim parents and students always respectful.
why should christians rule over muslims,,,,,,muslims have their own equal right to rule over their land,,,why should muslims bow down before others
Aren't they terr.....
I'm a Christian Filipino and have muslim relatives in Tawi-Tawi and other parts of Mindanao. I support Bangsamoro Autonomous Region to be ratified during our lifetime. Both sides should trust each other and take into effect the agreements based on the Bangsamoro Organic Law, so as to end the sufferings and anxiety of residents be they Muslim or non-Muslims in the said region. Use our taxes well on these meaningful advocacies for peace and development of everyone. ❤❤❤
Their leaders don't want peace. There is no $$$ in peace for them. All they want is control.
O you who believe! do not take the Jews and the Christians for friends; they are friends of each other; and whoever amongst you takes them for a friend, then surely he is one of them; surely Allah does not guide the unjust people. Quran 5:51
Once you give autonomous status to these extremist ,they will ask for a Islamic country.
Muslim lang nag papagulo sa mindanao
tell them to surrender to our governemnt and stop acting like they own mindanao. They are disrespectful animals who do not respect our soldiers, even wearing the same uniform as if they have done a great service to our country and people.
Christians, Muslims, Moros, and all Filipino people stand with peace in the region of Bangsamoro. We are brothers and let us not take it away from the future generations to come. "We can't talk peace while holding a gun in your hand.." -Kaleidoscope World (Francis Magalona)
Fight those who believe not in Allah nor the Last Day, nor hold forbidden that which hath been forbidden by Allah and His Messenger, nor acknowledge the religion of Truth, (even if they are) of the People of the Book (Jews and Christians), until they pay the Jizyah with willing submission, and feel themselves subdued. Quran 9:29
there will be no peace when that religion teaches violence. They are killing christians, bunch of cowards. Backwards people who do not know how to act
Islam is E V I L
@@moholah3745 Jizya is like the tax implemneted by the Philippine governement. But since Philippine is not a muslim majority state, Jizya has never been implemented there.
@@theinjil3092@MuslimFilipino don't argue with the animal, period.
Their goal is still to eventually have the entire island of Mindanao be their own independent country. As an example, in my city, they migrate here to build families and increase their population so that they can call for a referendum in the future. Now that they feel empowered they try to destroy the local culture that has thrived for many decades and bend it to their will. In their eyes we Chavacanos will always be in the wrong. We get loud stares from them when we publicly speak our own language and yet when we call them out for the most minor of wrongs they will cry Islamophobia. They want all business establishments to cater to only them and if businesses dont comply these businesses would be publicly reprimanded for being Islamophobic. It's hard to compromise with a group of people that's beset on their ways. They use the "multiculturalism" card only for their benefit and not for all people.
Same thing in india
The book is inspired from a Warlord. It's is no wonder why Extremist always end up as Terrorist because they want conquest and create an islamic country of their own, they want to be sheikhs or sultan as the spoils of war.
E hundung na kaw boy kakilahan ta kaw, ayaw na kaw mag pasaplag sin artificial Zamboanga Nationalism mu di’!
You’re just a weirdo who watched too much American far right-wing youtube videos and think as if the Muslim migrants in the US and here are the same. Well to correct your pagka pendejo, the Muslims in Zamboanga are Natives who had lived their for one thousand years now, and Zamboanga used to be a part of the Sultanate of Sulu, still even with the occupation of the Spanish the Muslim here remained especially the Sama Banguingui and the Bangsa Sug. You Chavacanos are the immigrants here, we already existed as a distinct culture and nation while you are still in the balls of your stockholmed Indio Forefathers. Anyway, you are losing the demographic area that us why you people start to embrace nonsense just like this, sooner your people will be just like the Indians in the US who are stuck in their reservations or you will be like the Chavacanos of Tondo, Ermita, Davao, and Cotabato whom all are extinct hahahahahaha conose yo con bo boy, ansina gale de bos ideology sigue lang. Pacha yo de bos kara si puede yo mira con bo aqui na Zamboanga especialmente around na Tetuan o Pasonanca. Kambya ya bos de bos custumbre, ganiyan talaga nangyayare kapag sumasama ka sa mga nonsense na fringe far right larper groups sa facebook no? Hahahahahaha quidao boy
Absolutely correct! 90% of them are hypocrites!
Thats what they did to Historic City of Cotabato. Christian City no more due to migration of Moro people
GOOD LUCK MUSLIM Philippines
Please raise your voice for Christians in Manipur, India. They are persecuted for so long and the Western media pays little attention.
Nothing to do with Christianity its a tribal conflict. Stop spreading misleading info
Manipur belongs to meteis, whether they are hindu or Christians..
Just think, if u give your home to someone for shelter and at last they want to replace u .
Kuki are continuously enjoying special rights there even after joining Christianity and leaving tribalism, they have their own kuki valley but are buying lands in imphal Valley too
No body in meteis want to end up like rohingyas as when u are weak, nobody helps u.
Meteis can't be bhuddha anymore.
Looks like you are from bhikaristaan.
Im a Christian from Northeast India and i can confirm that theres no religious conflict in Manipur.
Those who disbelieve among the People of the Scripture (Jews and Christians), and the Polytheists, will be in the Fire of Hell, where they will abide forever. These are the worst of creatures. Quran 98:6
Giving one million each is a big amount, there are many Filipinos who just work for a living
.
It's not all cash. According to the video, only 100,000 is given as cash. That's barely enough for a family's survival for a year in the provinces. The rest are in things like livelihood, housing and educational assistance. The government is having trouble with housing because of multiple claimants in some properties. That support seems reasonable especially if people follow the agreements.. These people cannot transition without such support.
giving bulk of money end up on buying arms you need to fix the sociopolitical first traditional leaders will not easy let go on his grip
The worst thing about these people they dont work
im filipino catholic and my muslim filipinos are my brothers! hatred has no space in our filipino culture
They r not ur brothers wake up to urself
See if they treat the Christian fellows in Indonesia or Malaysia ?
You should see how Muslims treat Christians in Musllim majority countries. Christians can't even build their churches.
@@jamesboth3785 Indonesian Christians are oppressed kindly but they never asked for independence and establish a rebel group
Foreigners commenting here without knowing why there is a conflict anyway. It's not about Mohammad or Jesus, it's about ethnicity, the land, and history. Sure, religion can play a role, and there are islamic terrorists (e.g. Maute group), but it's not central to the root of the conflict. It would still exist if the Moros were, say, Hindu
I agree. These Muslim tribes are even fighting against each other. Even family members have a tough time co-existing for peace. The government is serious about ending this war but it’s the tribes having issues with each other trying to get more from the government. One more issue is a foreign country is supplying weapons and ammo to these rebels to fight the Philippine government. These foreign journalists have no clue about the deep-rooted insurgency in the Philippines.
Parang
isis
hesbolah
hamas lng yan
IDIOLOGY na
nsa kuran nila pag hindi sumunod sa islam PATAYIN ang JEWS AT CHRISTIAN sahil walang tiwala kahit Kapatid nila sa muslim damay
Pag hindi Sumang ayun...sabi islam is religion of PEACE pero nanawagan ng jihad ...Ilan dekada na ang Alita nila kanya kanyang tribu
Philippines is not a natural country, it is land carved by colonialist. however we in ASEAN has agree and accepted that the post WWII border should be maintained. of course all independence movement is about land and control. however there is a proxy war being played here. the CIA support the infighting to keep Philippine dependent on their military assistance, if Philippines is united and strong, they would not need the american anymore.
Its islam ☪️ which is problem
It is the religion thats the base of the conflict. Stop sugarcoating
Muslim Insurgency is no longer a credible threat in Mindanao. This is current news.
While there's abject poverty in Mindanao the public pulse in the region is strongly pro-government.
ha? akala mo lang un. pag naka tira ka sa lugar ng kamusliman hindi ka safe lalo na kung hindi ka muslim.. simula pa nung bata aq until now patayan ay nan jan, konting alitan lng patayin agad, posisyon sa work patayin agad lalo na kung hindi ka muslim.
@@Neronero41 Im talking about the secession. The desire of muslim south to fight for independence is no longer a credible threat.
@@Neronero41
tinutukoy nya na mas align parin sa government yung mindanao ngayon, hinde yung patayan ng mga muslim.
malabo na humiwalay yung mindanao sa main government dahil mas modernized na yung mga major city sa mindanao,
proven to nung marawi, wasak narin yung natitirang abu sayaff.
mas marami na nagiging pro-government dahil umuunlad na paonti-onti yung mga city sa mindanao.
meron parin mga hinde dahil sa kahirapan sa mga mas malayo na lugar (sulu, zamboanga).
sobrang onti narin yung mga balita ng kidnapping ng abu sayaff ngayon di tulad nung 2012.
@@Neronero41bakit safe ba sa christian? 😅😂 Oo patayan sa Amin kayo mga baboy. Kanina lang oh inaanak ni rape😅
*Istighfar opens the door of sustenance. Saying “Astaghfirullah” (I seek forgiveness of Allah). Prophet Muhammad (SallAllahu Alayhi Wa Sallam) recited this at least 100 times a day.*
May GOD always protect & give peace to our brothers sisters in Filipina.
Greeting Indonesia🇮🇩🙏.
Much peace for all SEA regions & all over the world. Aamiin
trouble with muslims here too?
Everywhere
It's been peaceful these past years. Our Muslims are nicer. A lot of them are peaceful and reasonable. I've met some of them who do not practice strictly. Some of them in the big cities report extremists hiding within their ranks. They do not kill apostates. They allow children, including girls, to get proper education. It gets bad when the extremists get support from outside Muslim extremists. Hopefully, things continue to improve.
@@daxdizon4591that's what they want you to think.... they become friendly to you and the non christian community once their population settle in here and multiply then they will become stronger and start threatening people
☪️ANCER
always
Still believe that we have a common heart, a Filipino heart whether a Muslim or a Christian. Our Filipino heart is our distinct identity to the world. Whatever conflict needs to fix will be fixed.
I'm a Christian and I don't see any division between us and the Muslim brothers, we are one Philippines.
As a Filipino, the President of the Philippines should be careful what to say, especially associated with religion.
wise words.
Marcos is so bangag, he failed the people who nominated him. Escalating the tension in south china sea. Might as well the reason of the division of philippine region
Where ever these peaceful religion people goes they create terrorism
Is that a threat coming from Muslim? Cause we are willing to fight you cult!! You're idelogy threaten the Philippine freedom. Watch youre mouth muslim.
yes trigger happy muslims bka magalit no???
1 incident to question the gains made under the peace agreement? There are various armed organizations there and we only have 1 incident in almost a decade of signing. This is way better than the previous situation. Basilan was a hotspot for kidnapping, extortion and murder. Various criminals and terrorists roamed freely there. 1 incident is a blessing. MNLF was given authority to manage the ARMM decades back. The leader treated it like its fiefdom. There was no improvement in the lives of the Moro citizens. The leader, like other Muslim separatist leaders worldwide, had a huge entourage and stayed in five star hotels. He hobnobbed with the rich and famous. Moros remained one of the poorest demographics in the Philippines despite autonomy. Muslims who went to peaceful areas in Luzon and Visayas were able to lead peaceful, comfortable lives. I see them everywhere. The BARMM was the most peaceful I've seen it in decades. It is also true that some Moro communties hide criminals and terrorists among themselves. These criminals hide among relatives and friends. The Philippine Army knows that once it seeks permission from MILF commanders in those areas, the criminals will be tipped off. That was the basis for the covert operation launched against Marwan. It wouldn't have achieved the objective if it was coursed through MILF commanders. The Muslim community there and MILF members were complicit in hiding him. That's the reason why he was able to remain hidden for years. That's also the reason why the Maute terrorists were able to take Marawi. Local Muslim leaders helped them. These various liberation fronts used to fight among themselves. It does not really seem to be for Moro liberation but a way for the warlords to keep control of these areas and their citizens. Mindanao is also the last frontier for the communist New People's Army. The economic developments of Luzon and Visayas has rendered it obsolete. It is only in Mindanao that it can continue to brainwash ignorant, vulnerable people. Some interest groups have vested interests in making ARMM the way it is. The BARMM has a huge potential for development. Once development sets in, warlords and traditional dynasties will lose influence and power. Ordinary Filipinos will probably visit BARMM areas once they feel its safe to do so. Bulk of Philippine tourism comes from locals. It seems encouraging to see that the decommissioned fighter and the BARMM leader are still optimistic and have already seen personal and community success. Once that former fighter's daughter, who already got her license, finds government work, there is no going back. She will be able to help her sisters finish their own studies and the burden on the father is lessened. Those successes wouldn't have been possible without peace. I am also glad that the BARMM leader graciously credited the various parties including government, MILF, members, NGO and Filipinos for trying to make things work.
Everything would have been alright if you guys gave back the land to the natives instead of colonizing it.
@@safakbehlul8660 okay give back the north borneo then
Is it true that all Mindanaoans wanted to push for Mindanao separation? Do you think it will be best for Mindanao and Muslims? I just came across this video and I'm from Luzon.
@@safakbehlul8660 well, you got it wrong. there were already non-muslims in mindanao before the spaniards came. You need to know that Mindanao is always comprises of three demographics: Christian Bisaya (animistic tatoo bisaya from northern mindanao who got baptized by christian spanish missionaries), Lumad (non-christian natives who refuse to be baptized by spaniards and preserved their indigenious beliefs) and lastly Muslims from Maranao, sulu and Maguindanao who remain independent until the american occupation. Christians and Lumads in Mindanao are also natives of Mindanao and stop spreading false theory that Muslims owns Mindanao. it is just its power and influence of Muslim leaders faded which the Bisaya of Northern Mindanao pays tribute to the Maranaos during precolonial but we see a reversal as those bisaya are becoming the powerful and influential but in Lanao, Maguindanao and sulu is still under the influence of Muslim leaders as it had been before, development on those areas hindered due to local politicians regardless of Religion.
@@rommelmanzon2004 Nope, most Mindanawans wants to live on their own, it is only a politicians pushes for that separation.
The mere fact that the politicians in the Southern Philippines use this armed groups during election is beyond horrific, plus the issue of poverty and discrimination only alleviate the influence of islamic extremism in southern part of the Philippines
As usual the religion of peace plays the victim card again😂😂
If a certain group of minority feel put down then they have the right to secede.
@@user-kg4jv4gr3d LMAO they have problems everywhere with everyone. Have you ever heard off a single positive thing coming from that community.
@@user-kg4jv4gr3d
Shut up habibi. You guys are pathetic.
@@user-kg4jv4gr3d there are a lot of tribes more minor than them though.
Right? 😭 i don’t know why they teach them. 😬
We also have Muslim separatist in thailand mostly they get support by Local Malaysian govenment in Kelantan.
Mereka terkena hasut propaganda alam melayu 😂
You invade and suppress people of Sulu sultanate 100 years ago .quit their land
I am 49 years old. And I must admit that for almost all my adult life, I have never entirely understood the difference between the MNLF and the MILF and the history of their conflicts with the Philippine government. This report clarified so much for me. You are doing a great service as the Philippine News Media hardly does this anymore for its local audiences. Thank you for this.
Ethnic and ideological, mostly. Nur Misuari of the MNLF was Tausug. Many of his close people are allegedly ethnic Tausug. Hashim Salamat of MILF was supported by Maguindanaoans. MILF broke away when MNLF accepted semi-autonomy offer from the Philippine government. MNLF ran ARMM initially. MILF only accepted autonomy relatively recently. Both groups were aided and supported by Libyan Muammar Gaddafi.
Christian and Muslim Pilipino must United in Peace.. By Hearing the Voice of each other.. Separating the Philippines making it a Weak Country... Foreign Enemy taking this Opportunity to take there advantage.. United Filipinos make a Stronger Philippines...
Autonomous now, later on they would want an upgrade, then secession! Wolf in sheep's clothing. They're not even hiding the fact the ultimate goal is independent separate country. Malaysia has a big part on it, they supported them even before.
Hats off to Malaysia for that.
@@safakbehlul8660 hypocrisy isn't it?! You have an issue with the sultanate of sulu, to reclaim sabah which ,Malaysia still paying a rent tell now. That's why you (malaysia) indirectly supporting separatist/rebels/terrorists in mindanao. You have your own agenda!
@@safakbehlul8660hats off for supporting terrorist? your people support terrorist?
Ithink british inglish you know in the you know
@@bonwi9746 the philippines do not recognize the sulu sultanate but want the territories owned by the sulu. What hypocrisy is this?
*Istighfar opens the door of sustenance. Saying “Astaghfirullah” (I seek forgiveness of Allah). Prophet Muhammad (SallAllahu Alayhi Wa Sallam) recited this at least 100 times a day.*
God bless the Philippines.
Choose peace people of BARRM.
Wherever peacefull community goes peace follows.
What part of liandu are you?
Lingpujari at it's best . typical lindu
@@renta369..4 atleast they don't behead in the name of religion like cancer religion do
It is so good to see Mohagher Iqbal sharing his views. He is a brave Muslim Filipino leader who is - probably singularly - responsible for peace in Mindanao today. He is clear-minded and is able to focus on peace-making. He is able to isolate MILF as a peace partner. The MILF is a vital partner for eliminating extremist and terrorist groups. As testimonials of this documentary show, Iqbal is able to hold the government to deliver on its commitments, as well as, deliver his peace commitments to the government. Iqbal is a modern Filipino Muslim hero. The title should be On the Road to Peace.
BARMM is a land where people are poor but their political leaders are millionaires driving brandnew SUVs. Di na yan problema ng Philippine Government. Sila lng din sisisihin bakit sila mahirap.
Ketua/wakil ketua Ranting Muhammadiyah mengimami sholat 5 waktu di mesjid ranting Muhammadiyah.*Istighfar opens the door of sustenance. Saying “Astaghfirullah” (I seek forgiveness of Allah). Prophet Muhammad (SallAllahu Alayhi Wa Sallam) recited this at least 100 times a day.*
Prove it. It's easy to talk but where's the evidence. It's nothing but hearsays.
@@Algezon go to Bangsamoro
It's true! During my travels from Dipolog to South Cotabato, I observed that despite receiving substantial funds from the National Government and international donations, particularly from the Middle East, the BARMM has shown no significant improvement or progress. Instead, it appears that only the politicians are getting richer and richer. They tend to encourage their people to blame the national government for the lack of support while they themselves live comfortably inside their mansions.
Becoz of Datu's mga hepokritong Muslim kaya mahirap parin ang Barmm area dahil sila ang mga aligator sa mga community ng mga Moro.
More power to Muslims,
We love you from Pakistan 🇵🇰❤️
War monger😅
They don't want your love beggars. Leave YT and beg for food 😂😂😂. Flat earth theorists 😂😂
Saya dari Indonesia tidak mendukung pemberontakan ... Islam tidak pernah mengajarkan pemberontakan terhadap pemimpin yang sah ... Mereka hanyalah Islam munafik ... Yang hanya menghancurkan Islam dari dalam
It's not about Islam and Christianity. It is just that the majority of the indigenous people of Mindanao are Muslims. Mindanao has always been exploited by the Government, of which are majority Christians.
MUSLIMS WHEN MINORITY: I AM A MUSLIM, PLS. DON'T HATE ME!
1) PRETEND SECULAR
2) PLAY VICTIM CARD
3) BUILD MOSQUES
4) DEMAND SPECIAL RIGHTS
5) IF ISLAM IS A RELIGION OF PEACE, WHY DO I ROUTINELY RECEIVED MESSAGES FROM MUSLIMS TO AGREE WITH ME. BUT WERE AFRAID TO SPEAK FOR FEAR OF BEING KILLED!
4) IF ISLAM IS A RELIGION OF PEACE, WHY THERE IS NO POPULAR MUSLIM PEACE MOVEMENT
3) IF ISLAM IS A RELIGION OF PEACE, WHY THE SIGNIFICANT NUMBER OF MUSLIMS LIVING IN THE WEST SUPPORT SUICIDE BOMBING
2) IF ISLAM IS A RELIGION OF PEACE, WHY THE POLICE KEPT FINDING HUGE CASES OF MILITARY GREAT WEAPON IN MOSQUES ACCROSS EUROPE
because they carried arms they were very demanding and their demands is too much that when granted there will be inequality amongst ordenary community from the very limited government resources for basic services.
Who provided them the guns in the first place?
Sana magkaisa ang Pilipino ma pa muslim at kristyano lalo na sa Chinese Communist Na. Unti unti sinasakop ang mga isla ng pilipinas…. Lord sana makamit ng Bansang Pilipinas ang pakakaisa at kapayapaan.. sa makakabasa nito Muslim ka man o Catholic umpisahan natin ang pagkakaisa at kapayapa sa mga pamilya natin… God bless to my Kababayan Filipinos….🙏🙏🙏
Islam is the most tolerant secular and religion of peace 💣
The world doesn't realize that anywhere there's a presence of religion of peace, there's an absence of peace. tsk....tsk...tsk
WTF is this documentary talking about? Is it trying to evoke or stoke another conflict when it is resolved for now? Looking into. Future where something could go wrong?
china's way, para may internal conflict ang pilipinas.
free free mindanao
@@nikmatdunia2708we are already free here in Mindanao. What are you talking about? 🤣🤦🏻
@@nikmatdunia2708 Really? Mindanao is free. You want independence? The most moronic idea ever.
This channel is a chinese propågandā. Obviously, they will stôke conflict since PH is fighting back in the west Philippine sea. This issue is already settled now. This channel just want to reuse the issue to stir trouble within filipinos so dont get foøled by this chinā channl.
The Moros claim of Mindanao as a whole is bogus to the max. They only partially settled the Western Mindanao, while the native Lumads settled on the inland, and Visayans were already native to the island since early middle age on the eastern Mindanao. The Moros also a historically marauding people with piracy as their main income resources even before the Christianization of Philippines. Ancient Tagalog, Visayan Hindus, Buddhists, and Lumad folklores all talk about the muslim Moros (Tausugs, Sulus, Maguindanaoans) as being "villainous" horde due to their many slave raids and aggressive warfares against "infidels". I dont agree whenever Moro independence leaders all are victimizing themselves historically for their so-called cause as they still conduct piracies and clan wars up through present era.
*Istighfar opens the door of sustenance. Saying “Astaghfirullah” (I seek forgiveness of Allah). Prophet Muhammad (SallAllahu Alayhi Wa Sallam) recited this at least 100 times a day.*
You don't know the history and just making problems. Your face is bogus.
Hoax .lol
ISLAM MEANS "SURENDER" OR "CONVERT" OR "DIE"
Muslims live in Peace and prosperity here in Luzon
free mindanao
@@nikmatdunia2708 where's the cash from this time? Iran or China? 😂
We will never surrender the west Philippine sea no matter what. US and our allies are coming to stay around china and Taiwan is an independent country no matter what.
Let us all ban Islam in the Philippines.
@@nikmatdunia2708 from Abject poverty and extremism? Yes; will do
Semoga umat muslim Philipina di lepas kan dari belenggu penindasan, dan mereka bebas menjalankan ibadah agama ,
they are free to practice their religion the govt does not even tax the mosque. the problem is the mindset of being independent we gave them an autonomous region with self-government yet still not enough to have peace we gave them everything to have peace but in return they bombed our churches and several Christian were kidnapped and killed for no absolute reason!!
LOOOOL PHILIPPINES IS A SECULAR COUNTRY UNLIKE THESE ISLAMIC COUNTRIES WHO ARE BACKWARDS.
Amin
Non Filipinoes here in the comments doesnt understand how good Christian and Muslim Filipino's get well together. There will always be some conflict, maybe about some conflicting customs but its never about religion. Nonmuslims like myself will never tolerate "re-education camps" for our Muslim brothers that other intolerant countries do.
There can be only one armed forces of the Phil. not two, three or four.
there could be possible, if law give them the right to exist
Religion of Peace strike again ... FROM INDONESIA CHRISTIAN,,,,,,,
Dunia mencatat bangsa penjajah itu beragama Kristen 😅
@@diansyaputra8848 DAN LAHIRNYA 15L4M5 DI ABAD KE 6 AWAL DARI PENJAJAHAN , PERAMPOKAN, PEMERKOSAAN, PERBUDAKAN , PERZINAHAN DAN PEDOFIL TERHADAP ANAK KECIL USIA 6 TAHUN SPRTI PENYERANGAN DAN PENJAJAHAN DAN GENOSIDA DI KOTA MEKKAH DAN MEDINAH... UNTUK ORANG 15L4M5 PELAJARI SEJARAH AWAL AGAMA MU... SEMUA BERASAL DARI PEDANG DAN PEMBANTAIAN UMAT MANUSIA..... TAKEEBBEERRRRRR...ALOHA SNACKBAARRRRRRR......
@@diansyaputra8848 AND THE BIRTH OF 15L4M5 IN THE 6TH CENTURY THE BEGINNING OF COLONIZATION, ROBBERY, RAPE, SLAVERY, ADULTERY AND PEDOPHILE AGAINST A 6 YEAR OLD CHILD SUCH AS ATTACKS AND COLONITION AND GENOCIDE IN THE CITIES OF Mecca AND MEDINAH... FOR PEOPLE 15L4M5 LEARN THE EARLY HISTORY OF YOUR RELIGION .. EVERYTHING CAME FROM THE SWORD AND THE MASSACRE OF HUMANITY..... TAKEEBBEERRRRRR...ALOHA SNACKBAARRRRRRR......
@@diansyaputra8848 AND THE BIRTH OF 15L4M5 IN THE 6TH CENTURY THE BEGINNING OF COLONIZATION, ROBBERY, RAPE, SLAVERY, ADULTERY AND PEDOPHILE AGAINST A 6 YEAR OLD CHILD SUCH AS ATTACKS AND COLONITION AND GENOCIDE IN THE CITIES OF Mecca AND MEDINAH... FOR PEOPLE 15L4M5 LEARN THE EARLY HISTORY OF YOUR RELIGION .. EVERYTHING CAME FROM THE SWORD AND THE MASSACRE OF HUMANITY..... TAKEEBBEERRRRRR...ALOHA SNACKBAARRRRRRR......
@@diansyaputra8848 AND THE BIRTH OF 15L4M5 IN THE 6TH CENTURY THE BEGINNING OF COLONIZATION, ROBBERY, RAPE, SLAVERY, ADULTERY AND PEDOPHILE AGAINST A 6 YEAR OLD CHILD SUCH AS ATTACKS AND COLONITION AND GENOCIDE IN THE CITIES OF Mecca AND MEDINAH... FOR PEOPLE 15L4M5 LEARN THE EARLY HISTORY OF YOUR RELIGION .. EVERYTHING CAME FROM THE SWORD AND THE MASSACRE OF HUMANITY..... TAKEEBBEERRRRRR...ALOHA SNACKBAARRRRRRR......
My message to fellow Muslim Brothers. We must support our government. Don't listen to other countries. We must support each other no matter what is our religion beacuse after all only us can rely on each other. Just always remember we are one, we live in the same place Philippines. We need to free our self from History destabilization that continues until now. We must be united under our own beliefs before 15th century. At 14th century we are not corrupted. Around 15th century when foreign beliefs reached our land our corrupted mind started. Everything changed when foreign beliefs reached our land. They erased our own beautiful amazing history. We are the Biblical Ophirian. We must come back to Yahuawa.
aloha snackbar > country
Warn the hypocrites that torturous punishment awaits them. The hypocrites take unbelievers as friends rather than believers. Do they look for honor at their hands? Truly all honor belongs to Allah. Quran 4:138-139
They've always had their own separate kingdom in the south they were never colonised by the spanish. .
Doesn't matter cause the Americans beat them anyway.
Almost every part of the Philippines had their own kingdom and sort off, but they are not as divided as mindanao.
Mutual Respect no matter what religion will result to understanding & peace.
We must be united, not devided.
We need to unite to have enough power to resist the external & internal threats brought by evil that tries to bring harm to the people of this world.
I hope you all know what I mean by this.
It's more beneficial to focus on taking good care of our family & our environment & prepare to protect them.
Just sharing my thoughts.
🙏 🤝 ❤ ✌
Live and let live.
Thailand also has the same problem with Muslim in the south, the Deep South 3 provinces
Let not those who disbelieve think they will escape. Indeed, they will not cause failure [to Allah]. And prepare against them whatever you are able of power and of steeds of war by which you may terrify the enemy of Allah and your enemy and others besides them whom you do not know [but] whom Allah knows. And whatever you spend in the cause of Allah will be fully repaid to you, and you will not be wronged. Quran 8:59-60
Free patani
@@sabreemaie5382 move to Malaysia
Free patani@@mirrorocean3852
Mereka terhasut propaganda alam melayu ... Islam tidak pernah mengajarkan pemberontakan terhadap pemimpin yang sah ... Mereka itu hanyalah Islam munafik yang sebenarnya ingin merusak Islam dari dalam
Dapat isa lang ang armed forces. Walang mnlf,milf at biff. Dapat kung gusto nila nang kapayapaan, wala nang ibang armed forces....
Tama kong gusto nilang mag military mag aply sila sa governo dahil kapag may biff,milf, at bff maging violence
Watching from Pakistan. Praying for peace for all the people.
The influence of Malaysia on the Bangsamoro people is a significant factor in the ongoing dispute over the Sabah region. This is why the MILF was created in the first place.
Every where this people are problem
spanish influence is and still is the reason for this divide. dont blame it on us. we've been in mindanao for centuries living our own life. y'all just blame us for ur own actions lmao.
*Istighfar opens the door of sustenance. Saying “Astaghfirullah” (I seek forgiveness of Allah). Prophet Muhammad (SallAllahu Alayhi Wa Sallam) recited this at least 100 times a day.*
Your the problem not even knowing the whole history. Just want to get in the muslim hate bandwagon. Racist.
Sejarah mencatat bahwa bangsa penjajah itu beragama Kristen 😅
@@jife4504 name me 1 place in BARMM where you would raise your family. Just one.
The solution of the Philippine here is contrary to LKY strategy. In SG design, Muslims must not live and converge in one place and therefore they should live side by side with Indians and Chinese families in every community. The logic there is that they could check each others frequently so that one group may not able to devise anything that could harm the other groups that belongs to different ethnicity and the result is peace and harmony. That is brilliant move by former PM LKY. Anyway, I"m a Filipino.
It worked in Singapore coz it's an immigrant country. Satin mga natives tayo dito.
*Istighfar opens the door of sustenance. Saying “Astaghfirullah” (I seek forgiveness of Allah). Prophet Muhammad (SallAllahu Alayhi Wa Sallam) recited this at least 100 times a day.*
It's a beautiful region. So sad all the fighting. I saw the damage in Marawi City and wondered how anyone survived
Full support Bangladesh 🇧🇩
There is no peace where Islam is.
free mindanao
@@nikmatdunia2708 Free Mindanao from Islam. Islam is E V I L
Christianity is colonialism@@theinjil3092
@@nikmatdunia2708 Free Palestine from Hamas
I hope our government bring foriegn investors create job to our muslim brothers & sisters that way to one left behind,our politicians must show respect to them by employment apportunities not only in Manila 😮😢
?
Sa mga morong pinoy... hangad ko ang kapayapaan at kasagaan ng inyong rehiyon kapit lang sa kapayapaan pare pareho naman tayong mahihirap, mapalad parin ang nakatira sa bukid kumpara sa siyudad na walang makain. Ganun pa man di ito sapat upang tayoy magpaka tamad at umusa nalang sa biyaya...dapat matutunan nating mabuhay ng masaya kahit tayo ay mahirap at salat sa buhay.
Salot ang mga rehiyon Hindi mo manlang makita ang dyos mo tapos papatay ka ng tao para sa dyos mong Hindi mo Naman nakikita
Its so sad that some of Muslims in the Southern Philippines does not recognized theirselves as a Filipinos or Muslim Filipinos their recognized themselves as different and not Filipinos and they wanted the whole mindanao to be seperated or much prepared annexed by Malaysia than to govern by the Philippines as autonomy they still wanted their illegal dreams come true and they will wait for the right time to that plan someday maybe if we faced China in a war they will revolt agains on Philippine Government and help invaders to defeat the Philippines thats sounds so very horrific and bloodier in reality, may the Lord God and the Angels protects all of us (Philippine Nation)
People needed to know that there are approximately 28 million people living in mindanao and its islands, and approximately 4 million of the population are muslim. Filipinos outside Mindanao should know this, cos a lot of them thought that the whole mindanaoans are muslims, which made a major concern despite having access information thru online.
also, a lot of people thought that Mindanao had not been conquered by Spain. In reality, most of the places in Mindanao has been conquered by the Spaniard, only some parts of BARMM are the places that weren't fully colonized by the Spaniards, the rest is fully conquered.
Assalaumaikum brother🇮🇩♥️🇵🇭
Thousands of Christian Cotabatenos left Cotabato City due to suppression and aggression of Moro Rebels and Kidnappings that crippled the Christian Majority of the past in Cotabato
Ah, colonizers. Dapat lang bumalik sila sa Visayas.
@@ianhomerpura8937 Long live ILAGA
@@TirabintaToktik-hz1lx puta nga yawa.
@@ianhomerpura8937 dah, mindanao is always composed of three demographics: muslims, christians and lumads. and the least heard? the lumads and not the muslims. Christian and muslims natives in Mindanao is always been in rival against one another even before spanish arrival. Northern Mindanao, southern and western mindanao is never been a muslim area. stop spreading false information. Since the precolonial times, u always keep on harassing native mindanawan bisayas, always looting and attacking our villages since the beginning. FYI, Bisaya is always been in mindanao since before islam came. they are natives from sri vijaya migrated to the archipelago, muslims are one of the tribes that got islamized by arab traders but bisaya refuses to be converted since they are following hybrid form of animism, hinduism and buddhism.
@@ianhomerpura8937 anong colonisers pinagsasabi mo ??
Things like this makes me sad as a muslim here in the philippines, we need the Dutertes back into the highest position, the peace between all religion in the philippines is needed and we dont need another president who is being controlled by USA, Marcos should know better, there is no one going to benefit from it but the USA by providing their war.
They should blame China for this, because of Chinese threat in the North and Western Philippine Republic, the government is unable to give much focus on the process in Mindanao.
What a lame excuse, for as long as I can remember, the Catholic North and the Muslim South have been at odds for decades.
If anything, it's probably the US that has more interest in having conflicts in Mindanao to force the PH govt to rely on it on military support and to allow US to have bases there.
@@jasmikkothat's fake news and propaganda. Usa is needed by the philipines due to china.
@@christan286
Right.. These are 2 different threats
@@jasmikkofocused sila sa Ukraine. Wala silang galaw sa issue dito.
WTF We are at peace already here in Mindanao. Seems like this page is trying to incite another useless violence by posting outdated past struggle.
Best comment.
mutual respect, respect for a religion is the key to peace, we in Indonesia🇮🇩 never fight each other, if we have a conflict, we will discuss what is the key to the problem and don't say that Islam is a religion that likes war, it hurts Christianity too, if you look at the history of the evidence, the Dutchand the British in Southeast Asia all used violence to colonize a country🇮🇩🇮🇩peace is answer
Just curious - Why are these groups allowed to carry weapons though?
Salamat CNA for featuring this.
They did it so the investors see all asean neigbour except singapore are trouble places.. what a naive filipino
let them have their own country,they been fighting Spanish Japanese and American for centuries
They should leave Philippines
@@theinjil3092 lol they're Native,what are you talking about 😂
@@jomosama92 Natives can be kicked out especially if they do not want to integrate.
@@theinjil3092 we Malaysia don't want Pinoy Muslim or non muslim
@@theinjil3092what part of India are you from?
When you talked with Iqbal, the story goes more fantasy than factual. Playing tough but when cornered act like a crying child. Pathetic.
Peace be with you
Ethnic groups in Singapore
Chinese 75.9%
Malay 15.1%
Indian 7.4%
Others 1.6%
We all know why Singapore is "PEACEFUL". Wait till that numbers go up to 50%. 🤞
exactly
their religion brand of peace
Well, hopefully they maintain that demographic
Filipinos, Malay and Indonesian are Austronesian. its unfair to call Indonesian and Filipinos as Malay
@@BravoCoy op never said that lol
In every religion there's a dark side. I can clearly say that when Spain brought Christianity to Philippines there are alot of wrongdoings. However our Lord bless us with our brains to think, to differentiate between good and bad.
I can't say anything about Islam because first and foremost I'm not a Muslim and all I can say to our Muslim brothers to widen understanding, there's more to life, living in peace and harmony among communities where children safely can go to school, play around and achieve their dreams. As an adult or a parent it is our responsibility to provide our children with a safe environment.
In Islam they teach to kill non Muslim so how can we have peace with those people?
Too bad, if only such reality exists in most of them. Sadly, their love for hate is stronger than their love for their children.😢
This kind of superior thinking would never get you closer with your Moro brothers and sisters. This is coming from a Catholic Indonesian who already visited Basilan and Mindanao.
@@wenderis Although majority of Filipinos are Christian, I don't think there's superiority in anyone of us. I don't think our religious belief will divide us. That is why now there's a Bangsamoro govt in southern Philippines because we respect tradition, culture and beliefs of our Muslims.
@@greatzaliv993 "However our Lord bless us with our brains to think," before carrying on: "all I can say to our Muslim brothers to widen understanding, there's more to life, living in peace and harmony."
You don't think they want peace? You don't think the Lord doesn't bless them with brain? It's hard for peace to exist without justice. That ain't peace, thats subjugation. If you really genuinely care about your brothers and sisters, listen to them.
edit: but to be fair, your comment is among the least racist comment in the comment section thats why I try to engage.
Personally I don't think trauma can be erase, I just hope it will be learn to live with.
It is well known that MILF combatants want to receive the financial aid (100k pesos or 3,000 SGD) in accordance to the peace agreement but refused to surrender their weapons after receiving the aid. The Philippine government had already spent 10 billion pesos on these financial aids
i think the trust issue about that matter is expected and inevitable, but what important thing there is the actions that both want an effective peace solution and the historic injustices is not a joke that really need to addressed.
Mindanao is not part of the philippines..!!? So how and when did the people of Zamboanga City start speaking spanish?
The people of Zamboanga City don't speak Spanish but they do speak Chavacano, a Spanish creole language
😂😂😂
Are you trying to legitimize the Spaniard rule over Zamboanga or the Philippines?
Mabuti nga. Para ma subukan ang mga bagong Armas. Pwede ba dun nalang din gawin ang training ng balikatan para hindi masayang ang mga missles. Hehe
Sa bahay mo muna.
Try natin sama ka sa balikan para masubukan tapang mo
kung gusto mo ng may kalaban ka? may kalaban ka talaga, pero kung gusto mo ng wala kang kalaban? wala kang kalaban, yan ang mindset na wala ka
Sa bahay mo muna
Sa kapatid mo munang mga NPA
Semoga Bali selalu lestari dengan kebudayaannya
Dapat ihiwalay na yang Barm.
Kung maging successful sila , it is a win2 solution for both of us.
@0:54 🙄
crazy thing is ... idk why can't christians live with muslims in peace but muslims can live with christians in peace
How can their be peace when Muslims are not allowed to have christians as friends?? Quran 5:51
lol, did you even watch the documentary?
May Allah strengthen their faith
Imagine the world without Islam.
That day will come when your bones have long turned to dust. Yes we Muslims recognize that such day will come. If you think we are so obsessed with this world and anything in it. You are absolutely mistaken.
@@johnsword8954 religion of peace.. Hahaha😂😂 my foot..
@@IskhaWotsa-if9so Like it or not we are here to stay, and there is not a single thing you can do about it. I suggest you to talk to the one creator above who is not represented by any man made graven images to guide you to the straight path and help you open your eyes to the truth.
Islam is E V I L
The world is not without Islam
The Philippine Government did everything for them. Given them the autonomy in governance. But their leaders are for so long very corrupt. We didn't see good roads, street lightings eventhough the Filipino government gave them budget. While the leaders children are studying in exclusive schools here and abroad, living in Mansions in Manila or Cebu.
so if you think they are the problem, why you force them to become the part of philipine. just give them freedom
@@NOOBAnimation243 their ancestors
sa totoo lng napaka yaman at malakas ang pilipinas sadyang may mga makapangyarihang tao lng na nagbu2kod sa mga diwa natin ukol sa kapayapaan at pag uunawa sa pagkakaiba natin ...
Such a peaceful religion.
Muslim religion is actually a peaceful community so other religions are jealous of Muslim community
change word from "Peaceful" to "Violent"
change word from "Jealous" to "Cautious"
Nobody are jelous to muslims
As per usual the islamic is at it again
they want to take over the mindanao region,once they take over it,they will then take other region
Muslim separatist finance by Malaysia 😂
Yes, and their hypocrisy is off the chart! Terrorist loving , terrorist sponsor state. It's a fact
Malaysia does not care about your country and hates the Filipino pirates who are always terrorizing the country's borders
As usual,incompetence government in Manila looking for scapegoat 🐐🐐🐐 (P .S ; Thai Govt also speak same tone as Manila says 💁♀️💁)
@@94snapazzurri keep fooling yourself crackhead! Scapegoat?! Nope it's an open secret, the separatist leaders admited it, one Malaysian intelligence agent before was killed, acted as financiers. A boat from Malaysia with a contraband of firearms was intercepted in the sulu sea area. What now? Terrorists!
@@94snapazzurri correct.. now ilang part plng ng mindanao, sa sunod whole mindanao na ang kukunin.
They should guard the waters against the Chinese and tell them about Islam rather than fight their believing brothers to the north.
Peacefuls ✌️ never live peacefully in everywhere
I don’t see the need of Indians spreading hate in the comment section.
The conflict is more than divide in their beliefs. As stated earlier in the documentary, Mindanao was the last to be added in greater Philippines, prior to that they considered themselves completely independent of Luzon and Visayas.
Naturally some may still hold some sort of resentment against so-called “annexation”, but such sentiment makes only small number of total population. At the end of the day, Mindanao is and will remain part of the Philippines. Muslims of southern-Philippines are as much Filipino as Catholics are.
So when you see a supposedly Islamophobic comment it's from an Indian huh.
@@DarrylGonzales you can't deny their presence in youtube comments. Indian always use the term "peaceful community" as derogatory. may be indian muslims brand themselves as such, but internationally people already knew islam means submission not salaam which means peace. western islamophobes mostly use the term P3dophile followers, but indians would overlook the aspect since they still practice child marriage like muslims.
Mga ka bayan this is not the time to be divided, Mga Filipino tayo lahat! may mas matindi tayong kakaharapin dapat united tayo.
pre punta ka dito sa barrm halos lahat sila gusto nila maging independent minsan nga may naikita pa akong sunog na ph flag
Religion of Peace strike again 🤣🤣🤣
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
when u cant think of another unique and creative insult for islam 💀💀💀💀
💣 💣 💣🤣🤣🤣
Pag may peace and order ang lugar susunod na diyan ang development ng probinsya.. Papasok na ang ibat ibang negosyo na makapagbibigay ng maraming trabaho sa mga moro..
Pero kung ang mentality ng mga moro ay mag aarmas lagi pag hindi naibigay agaf ang mga hiling, talagang wala na namang katapusan na bakbakan at dadanak na naman ang dugo..
Not when the Muslims are crazy.
To be fair, na-maintan yung peace sa halos isang dekada maliban sa dalawang insidente. Hinihintay pa rin nila yung ipinangako ng gobyerno. Naiintidihan ko din kung bakit ayaw pa bumitaw ng armas ng iba. Hindi pa sila kasama sa batch ng returnees. Proteksyon din nila yung armas laban sa mga personal na kaaway, kalabang political at iba pa. May sagupaan ang MNLF at MILF dati. Tapos andyan pa Maute at Abu Sayyaf. At least walang nanggugulo ngayon. Kailangan lang budgetan at tutukan.
@@daxdizon4591 wala nang Abu Sayyaf ubos na sila, BIFF at Dawlah Islamiya (dating Maute) na lang natitira.
@@DarrylGonzales Sabi nga daw kaso madali lang rin naman magpalit ng grupo yung mga dating miyembro. May ties sila kaya puwede lumipat.
Lahat naman Muslim mga Yan.. tapos sasabihin nyo religion of peace kayo
1 million peso for civilian life. Wow.
I love how everyone on the interview, including the narrator, were careful not to pronounce the acronym _MILF._
ONCE AGAIN , WITHOUT LIE ISLAM IS DIE
(with lies, islam rises. and it's a fact)
When Hypocrites can't find anything they blame Islam ..they will first start violence with Muslims and when Muslims retaliate then Muslims are at fault....Islam is peace but if you want War Muslims will give you war.
@@jife4504 🤦♂️😆😆
@@thanerahmed2660the first hypocrite who started it all is Muhammad.
12:25 what language he speak??
local language or what?
its contain few Indonesia word like " bulan, kami, sampai, balik, tapilih" and the accent doesn't sounds like Tagalog
Local Language, the Philippines has thousands of local languages, most dominant being Tagalog or Cebuano
CNA bringing this topic on a crucial time where china and the Philippines are on a dispute. Is CNA are just trying to educate us or there is another reason?
There is no peace in ISLAM thats it 🤷🤷