I wonder how someone with so little knowledge has been able to get to a position of interviewing an expert in the field. Having said that, her viewpoint probably reflects the average israeli in the suburbs, so it is interesting to see the professor address those kinds of arguments.
"How can they be in a concentration camp if they have a beach?" Sounds like holocaust revisionists pointing out how Auschwitz had an infirmary, a swimming pool (for the prisoners), an orchestra, etc.
"Why aren't the Arabs helping the Israelis carry out ethnic cleansing by allowing the Israelis to push the Palestinians out of Palestine?" Duh, huh, ****breathes through mouth***** "If the Nazis didn't want the joos, why didn't the Americans and Soviets take them? Wasn't the holocaust actually America's fault!" Duh, hurr, breathes through mouth some more.
This dimbulb woman is going pretty hard for "the jews are bad people but they have the power and the Palestinians should surrender." Some people aren't weak and soft and compliant toward their r@pists like you are, darlin'.
but she is!!,she remind me of a school child forced into a debate about which he parents have already indoctrinated her....she believes the Palestinians are to blame for their fate because they will not emigrate....and give away th land....and she will not shut up when faced with her own stupidity...a stupidity of other bigots as well.
Yes, she can. You'd be surprised how many are willfully ignorant of things just because they don't want to shatter the fragile bubble of whatever concept or belief they want to hold on to. The only explanation for why people can't seem to absorb new information is simply because they are scared to.
Interviewer after commenting that she is 'agnostic' toward what's happening to Gaza and that she doesn't know enough, then goes on to, through her admitted ignorance, denies to Dr. Mearsheimer, who has actually been to Gaza and is a studied expert, that Israel apartheid state, among other stupid statements. If you don't 'understand' then maybe you should do your research before making denials to an expert.
You’re all unwilling to understand that as a German (her) and as a human (myself), stopping the killings is the first priority and America encourages more killings. If Palestinians were Americans, would America watch them die? If they’re not American citizens is then ok in American law that that American bombs fuelled a genocide abroad? These are the real questions where the guy fails to take a personal responsibility for what his country does. How can you expect America to change course while the American agrees of what is wrong and does nothing against?
apartheid is a legal term a technical term referring to what happened in South Africa. What's happening is israel is not like South Africa since Arabs serve in the Supreme Court, Parliament, lower courts etc . Therefore Mearsheimer is wrong.
@stephenglasse2743 I think you're mistaken. You're looking at apartheid from a selective lens and a very restrictive one at that. To your point, the Israeli senate also has people of Palestinian origin, but both things are possible simultaneously. You only need to look at the West Bank, the stark disparity in rights and freedoms afforded to Palestinians compared to the settlers. Who by the way, are just that, illegal settlers. They don't have feee access to travel etc, not to mention the forced evictions of people from their own land. Technically, there are minds better than mine, who would demonstrate that Israel is an apartheid, Jewish supremacist state.
What a great saying! It is so on the spot. It made me laugh so hard. I wrote it down to use. I wish I knew your name so that I would be able to give you credit every time I use it. Thank you so much.
She is using same narrative that Israel has the right to defend itself when in reality Israel is the occupying force and Palestinians are the one who are defending themselves against Isreal
not true. Of the so-called 'occupied territories' israel handed over almost 99% inc Gaza, Sinai, and West Bank. Note that despite handing over Gaza the Palestinians then voted for hamas knowing they'd commit Oct 7 acts of war.
@@johndoe-zz1nr Hi Mr. Johndoe. If you don't mind me saying so, from reading your comment, it appears that you are quite uninformed, or should I say misinformed, about the fundamentals necessary to understand the Israel-Palestine conflict. I have a Ph.D. in political psychology and the Middle East geopolitics and have taught many classes on this subject at two universities in the United States. In the service of concision, my response will be concise and brief. You have missed the fundamental point that Professor Mearsheimer was trying so hard to make the interviewer understand. As a first step toward understanding the underlying reason for the Palestinian-Israeli conflict, your point of departure must be the fact that Palestine, in its totality, has always been the ancestral property of its indigenous inhabitants, the Palestinian people. The British, who in 1948 were the colonial occupiers of Palestine, decided to give part of that country to the Jews from Germany and Eastern Europe who wanted a Jews-only country of their own. I would like to know according to which law, standard of fairness, or the rights of ownership you made the statement that they (i.e., the Israelis) handed over almost 99%, including Gaza, Sinai, and West Bank, and that then the Palestinians "voted for Hamas knowing they'd commit Oct 7 acts of war." Firstly, the Israelis didn't have a legal right of ownership to any part of Palestine in the first place. Therefore, handing some of the lands back to the Palestinians can neither be considered an act of generosity nor of philanthropy. it was the British who decided to give Palestine to the Israelis, which means that Israelis had no right to accept stolen property and claim ownership of it. Secondly, please explain what you mean by " voted for Hamas knowing they'd commit Oct 7 acts of war." How do you know they knew about Oct 7 that far in advance? I seriously doubt that even the Hamas knew that then. I highly recommend that you first study the history behind the creation of Israel and then, and only then, comment on the Palestinian-Israeli conflict. Good luck.
I think he is almost as stunned by her ignorance as I am. He looks dumbfounded a few times when she displays her complete lack of knowledge of the subject matter.
The female host keeps saying that it is a confusing "black box" that cannot be understood. While simultaneously she keeps evading the male guest's question ... "do you think that Britain had a right to give away Palestine's property to the foreign invading Jewish people?" While simultaneously she evades reading the three human rights reports in order to inform herself about the intensely researched facts and data. While she simultaneously keeps telling her male guest that ..."the Palestinians should just leave and go to some other country ... why don't they just leave their homeland? ... I don't understand why they just don't leave". This lady is making herself appear very silly, immature, and immoral. She seems completely unprepared for this conversation that she is hosting.
This is like talking to my younger sister, who is 'not sure of historical facts' but has the audacity to have an opinion. Plus, 'the jews' do 'have a country': most of them have dual citizenship to other countries in which they or their parents were born.
What FIGHTING have you seen? What CONFLICT have you seen? I seen one group of ppl destroying another innocent group of women and children while pretending to be chasing a terrorist
Genozid ja leider Es ist eine Tatsache das der Zionismus breits ist für jeden Art des Verbrechens um zum Ziel zu kommen und der Ziel ist die totaler Enteignung des Palästinas.
@tonymedeiros5515 quite frankly, she should give up her home and land to an Ashkenazi family as its proper reparations. Why should Palestinians pay the price for Germans.
Leave or die. If we live in a world with rules based order, that’s an unacceptable way to run our world. Does she want a world where someone can come to her family and say leave or die, Just accept with it? I’m sorry but we have too much dignity to give up the land where our family members and our ancestors are buried, not theirs.
The ICJ clarification of July 19, 2024 states: 1 Israel must leave all illegally occupied territories (Gaza, West Bank, East Jerusalem...SYRIAN GOLAN HEIGHTS). 2 Israel and all supporters of the illegal occupation are obliged to pay reparations (USA, UK, Germany...)
First of all, it's an "advisory opinion" by the ICJ. Second, there is no mention in it about any other state's any obligation for reparation to anyone. Which means you are just a liar.
The host questions if there can be apartheid if there are as many Palestinians as Jews. What she doesn't recognize is that apartheid does not depend on polulation but on power and the Jews have the power and use it to limit freedom of movement, association, and access to power. She uses twiter as evidence of "the good life" completely confusing nice geologic or geographic reality for political reality. She asks why other countries don't take Palestinian refugees, she shoudl be asking why Palestinians should be refugees from their own country. She commits a classic straw man fallacy when she states, she doesn't want the Jews to not have a country. There is no issue with the Jews not having a country, there is an issue with treating Palesinians as fourth class citizens in their own country, then with ethnic cleansing, and finally with genocide. Either that host is sorely uniformed (and considering access to information that has to be purposeful) or she is a voice for Israeli propaganda that is acting naive for propaganda purposes.
Absolute rubbish total crap Arabs in Israel vote are represented in the Knesset and in the judiciary this odious has been given voice by skilful propagandists who actually did not have to work very hard because Jew hatred is an incurable disease and no one is trying to find a cure
You want the fighting to stop, by telling the Palestinians to just let the bullies keep bullying you. And you never want to tell the bullies that they're wrong. You'd rather tell the Palestinians that they're wrong
Because it's EASIER to point to the weaker group than tackle the bullies. Because doing what's easiest, while ignoring the danger of the ever-encroaching police state, is part of how we have been conditioned to behave. Like her, in fear of the state - effectively extinguishing morality and the courage to stand up and just do what's right, consequences be damned. Like Yemen.
The Palestinians to submit that wouldn’t be the solution (as the professor paitiently explained): If the Palestinians submit (as they already do I’m the westbank) there still would be an apartheidstate so :… how the professor explained that is the reason for Israel’s process of cleansing … it is as simple as that and those discussions are just wasted time … For over a year the world is discussing as if it would help because that is all we can do to stand the powerlessness
Who is that woman. She keeps saying she understands, she completely understands. Judging by what comes out of her mount she has no understanding of the Palestine/Israel dynamic.
I guess the Israelis are at fault foe reacting to the murder and rape of its citizens I must assume that other countries would be passive in these circumstances Why did the USA invade Iraq genius the ignorance of people is incredible
This interviewer is not brain dead, she is heart dead. She is ignorant, rude and not being sure "of facts" yet she interrupts the Professor repeatedly. Good God.
She does not want to know and does not want to acknowledge what the Israelis have done and continue to do. Call it what it is or you are complicit in this genocidal land theft.
She says the Jews deserve their own country, but expects the Palestinians to abandon their homes and roots and move to Jordan and Egypt. Even the most rabid right wing demagogues in Europe would not make such a profoundly unjust argument
You are very confused In 1947 the Arabs refused partition an unfortunate tragedy a horrible blunder No one is asking the Arabs to move The only thing they have to do is stop killing Jews digging tunnels in order to commit murder etc
Why is she even on the air.? She is the most ignorant host I have seen to date. She knows no history. She knows no current events. Wow. Ignorance at this level is stunning. Sad. Poor Professor. He deserves better.
Why would you be on RUclips commenting on geopolitics if you know so little about an ongoing G-cide - the most documented and obvious G-cide in world history - that you can't even take a confident stance against it?
76 years of Israeli occupation she asking why it's still like that Democracy means Palestinians will be voted to power Israel can't have that this lady playing dumb 🤣🤣🤣
Israel will not come to its senses, without it being forced to. 1) US has for decades supported Israel unequivocally, will it always support Israel? 2) The Arab street has not forgotten the Palestinian cause even if some of the Arab leaders have, will Arab people on the street always support the Palestinian cause? So which will happen, the Arab street stops its support or the USA stops its support? In my opinion, the US will be the one which changes, as the USA has often been fickle, we can already see US public support is changing, as it has in Europe. When US policy changes, Israel will no longer be able to continue as it has, it is very difficult though then to predict what will happen, it would be in Israel’s interest to realise this sooner than later, so that it can remain a state.
She says things and then says thats not what I am saying. "Listen John "she says rudely not listening to him and talking over him. I Imagine hé must be thinking " Thé germans just dont think normally with a serious almost pathological lack of empathy. Thé problem is thé Germans as a nation just can't tune into othe peoples perspectives and are thé worst politiciens in Europe and this woman amply displays this. Germains are great engineers, musiciens, but thé worst when it comes to politics.
WWII germany were the aggressors and had to pay the price with having their borders changed. The Palestinians are the victims here since 1947. The ukrainians will have to accept territorial losses, despite western support, they are also victims of aggression. In the middle east the so called virtuous west is supporting the aggressive invaders (Israel) but really should be forcing them to stop - which it could (ie. look at Serbia and the Balkans conflict)
How utterly ridiculous. So this lady doesn’t research literally anything about the situation in preparation for an interview on the topic with a subject matter expert? Then - life is unfair so deal with it? How about giving Bavaria to the Jews?
The displaced Germans in WW2 can go back to Germany after WW2. But Israel will not allow the displace Palestinians to go back to theirs lands like the previous Nakbas ( 1948, 1967 etc ).🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸
This interviewer doesn’t have a basic understanding of the facts. She said that there are 7 million Palestinians within Israel that are equal citizens 😂
His books are well sourced, and are of academic quality. The reports he mention are from dependable sources. I think what’s more probable is that you have a dog in this crooked fight, and aren’t an honest broker. It’s incredibly dark to observe just how far people have deluded themselves when they have been indoctrinated into a cult.
AI confirmation. 1. Complexity as an excuse • The core of the conflict is clear: It is essentially about land, rights, and self-determination. Palestinians are fighting for their own state and against the occupation of the West Bank and the blockade of Gaza, While Israel claims to defend its security but also increasingly annexes and colonizes more land. These basic issues are not “complex,” but quite clear. Even ChatGPT get’s it!
If I could debate you I would destroy you argument with ease You are either I’ll informed or a Jew hater probably both if you think otherwise read the history instead of blabbering rubbish
This interviewer admits she's ignorant, but still insists on interrupting and arguing with her expert guest to defend genocide. Disgusting
Professor talking to a doorknob
Naziism is still flourishing in the minds of complacent zombies like this idiot.
🤣🙏🤣
lol 😂
🤣
The patience and the look the professor has with this doorknob😂
If you dont know enough about what is happening in gaza then youre choosing not to look
Thank you. It's your fucking responsibility to know what's going on! Ignorance is not an excuse
Literally
This woman is NOT as she professes to be, she's definitely on the Israeli side...
She's a fraud. Opens by washing her hands, why the hell is she interviewing Mearsheimer?
But she's on Israel's side because Germans have been brainwashed into a very shallow theory.
Yeah, why don't we move the 2 million back to their homes.
Yes
There are so many like her.
I wonder how someone with so little knowledge has been able to get to a position of interviewing an expert in the field. Having said that, her viewpoint probably reflects the average israeli in the suburbs, so it is interesting to see the professor address those kinds of arguments.
Exactly. Very difficult to know what to say to people like this.
SHE IS COOOKED.
This IS UnFreakinREAL some STUPID DISDSY, BIMBO GET’s A JOB LIKE THIS ….CAUSE SHE FUCKIN AN EXECUTIVE
She plays unknowingly fool…
That's called a usefull idiot
WTF is wrong with these people who say israel has a right to defend itself...... THEY ARE NOT DEFENDING THEY ARE ATTACKING
It's bizzaro world dude. Where have you been?
True comment 👍
"How can they be in a concentration camp if they have a beach?" Sounds like holocaust revisionists pointing out how Auschwitz had an infirmary, a swimming pool (for the prisoners), an orchestra, etc.
"Why aren't the Arabs helping the Israelis carry out ethnic cleansing by allowing the Israelis to push the Palestinians out of Palestine?" Duh, huh, ****breathes through mouth***** "If the Nazis didn't want the joos, why didn't the Americans and Soviets take them? Wasn't the holocaust actually America's fault!" Duh, hurr, breathes through mouth some more.
This dimbulb woman is going pretty hard for "the jews are bad people but they have the power and the Palestinians should surrender." Some people aren't weak and soft and compliant toward their r@pists like you are, darlin'.
She can't be this ignorant.
She aint She is a snake. For someone that doesn’t know much, she’s using all the same points.
but she is!!,she remind me of a school child forced into a debate about which he parents have already indoctrinated her....she believes the Palestinians are to blame for their fate because they will not emigrate....and give away th land....and she will not shut up when faced with her own stupidity...a stupidity of other bigots as well.
I don't think any intelligent person would pretend to be so stupid. She is basically making the case for the Nazi party.
Yes, she can. You'd be surprised how many are willfully ignorant of things just because they don't want to shatter the fragile bubble of whatever concept or belief they want to hold on to. The only explanation for why people can't seem to absorb new information is simply because they are scared to.
Playing dumb very Israeli 🤣
Interviewer after commenting that she is 'agnostic' toward what's happening to Gaza and that she doesn't know enough, then goes on to, through her admitted ignorance, denies to Dr. Mearsheimer, who has actually been to Gaza and is a studied expert, that Israel apartheid state, among other stupid statements. If you don't 'understand' then maybe you should do your research before making denials to an expert.
My thoughts exactly exactly. Claiming to be “agnostic” when she gets cornered by John
Well she is german so shes suffering from generations of intense manipulation
You’re all unwilling to understand that as a German (her) and as a human (myself), stopping the killings is the first priority and America encourages more killings. If Palestinians were Americans, would America watch them die? If they’re not American citizens is then ok in American law that that American bombs fuelled a genocide abroad? These are the real questions where the guy fails to take a personal responsibility for what his country does. How can you expect America to change course while the American agrees of what is wrong and does nothing against?
apartheid is a legal term a technical term referring to what happened in South Africa. What's happening is israel is not like South Africa since Arabs serve in the Supreme Court, Parliament, lower courts etc . Therefore Mearsheimer is wrong.
@stephenglasse2743 I think you're mistaken. You're looking at apartheid from a selective lens and a very restrictive one at that. To your point, the Israeli senate also has people of Palestinian origin, but both things are possible simultaneously. You only need to look at the West Bank, the stark disparity in rights and freedoms afforded to Palestinians compared to the settlers. Who by the way, are just that, illegal settlers. They don't have feee access to travel etc, not to mention the forced evictions of people from their own land.
Technically, there are minds better than mine, who would demonstrate that Israel is an apartheid, Jewish supremacist state.
It takes a minute to tell the truth, an hour to dance around it.🤢🤮💯💔🇺🇸🙏
What a great saying! It is so on the spot. It made me laugh so hard. I wrote it down to use. I wish I knew your name so that I would be able to give you credit every time I use it. Thank you so much.
I lost brain cells hearing her talk.
@Absreer1213 But she wore such a pretty little dress, and her hair was nice. I suppose that should add to her credibility.
@@msimons7440 Look I think this she is a crappy interviewer but there is absolutely no reason to be such a misogonist. Grow up.
@@msimons7440😂
She is using same narrative that Israel has the right to defend itself when in reality Israel is the occupying force and Palestinians are the one who are defending themselves against Isreal
not true. Of the so-called 'occupied territories' israel handed over almost 99% inc Gaza, Sinai, and West Bank. Note that despite handing over Gaza the Palestinians then voted for hamas knowing they'd commit Oct 7 acts of war.
@ you forgot to mention that Gazans had freedom from air land and sea and freedom to travel inside inside Israel and any country in the world
@@johndoe-zz1nr Hi Mr. Johndoe. If you don't mind me saying so, from reading your comment, it appears that you are quite uninformed, or should I say misinformed, about the fundamentals necessary to understand the Israel-Palestine conflict. I have a Ph.D. in political psychology and the Middle East geopolitics and have taught many classes on this subject at two universities in the United States. In the service of concision, my response will be concise and brief. You have missed the fundamental point that Professor Mearsheimer was trying so hard to make the interviewer understand. As a first step toward understanding the underlying reason for the Palestinian-Israeli conflict, your point of departure must be the fact that Palestine, in its totality, has always been the ancestral property of its indigenous inhabitants, the Palestinian people. The British, who in 1948 were the colonial occupiers of Palestine, decided to give part of that country to the Jews from Germany and Eastern Europe who wanted a Jews-only country of their own. I would like to know according to which law, standard of fairness, or the rights of ownership you made the statement that they (i.e., the Israelis) handed over almost 99%, including Gaza, Sinai, and West Bank, and that then the Palestinians "voted for Hamas knowing they'd commit Oct 7 acts of war." Firstly, the Israelis didn't have a legal right of ownership to any part of Palestine in the first place. Therefore, handing some of the lands back to the Palestinians can neither be considered an act of generosity nor of philanthropy. it was the British who decided to give Palestine to the Israelis, which means that Israelis had no right to accept stolen property and claim ownership of it. Secondly, please explain what you mean by " voted for Hamas knowing they'd commit Oct 7 acts of war." How do you know they knew about Oct 7 that far in advance? I seriously doubt that even the Hamas knew that then.
I highly recommend that you first study the history behind the creation of Israel and then, and only then, comment on the Palestinian-Israeli conflict. Good luck.
That man has so much patience, she is acting like she is an idiot but yet under the thumb of💰💰💰Israel.
He sucks
I think he is almost as stunned by her ignorance as I am. He looks dumbfounded a few times when she displays her complete lack of knowledge of the subject matter.
She is an idiot. She's not acting. jews have uploaded into her her understanding of why jews are superior and am entitled to whatever they wish.
Exactly. People are saying she's ignorant. She's not. She is a hasbarist.
I don't understand her reasoning "oh there are cute pictures, how can it be an open air prision"
This is a rare occasion where the interviewer who doesn’t know anything about the subject interviewing a well known professor. Isn’t that questionable
The female host keeps saying that it is a confusing "black box" that cannot be understood.
While simultaneously she keeps evading the male guest's question ... "do you think that Britain had a right to give away Palestine's property to the foreign invading Jewish people?"
While simultaneously she evades reading the three human rights reports in order to inform herself about the intensely researched facts and data.
While she simultaneously keeps telling her male guest that ..."the Palestinians should just leave and go to some other country ... why don't they just leave their homeland? ... I don't understand why they just don't leave".
This lady is making herself appear very silly, immature, and immoral. She seems completely unprepared for this conversation that she is hosting.
She isn't d*mb she knows she just doesn't want to anger the german authorities. Germany is practically a fascist state. Not that it excuses her.
Absolutely.....
This is like talking to my younger sister, who is 'not sure of historical facts' but has the audacity to have an opinion. Plus, 'the jews' do 'have a country': most of them have dual citizenship to other countries in which they or their parents were born.
What FIGHTING have you seen? What CONFLICT have you seen? I seen one group of ppl destroying another innocent group of women and children while pretending to be chasing a terrorist
Her ignorance is breathtaking.
5,000,000 -50,000=4,950,000
Israel is bad at Genocide
She's not actually ignorant. She is playing a fool in order to get her hasbara heard.
She does not strike me as an intelligent type at all, she is neither informed on the matter nor does she grasp what he is telling her
Genozid ja leider
Es ist eine Tatsache das der Zionismus breits ist für jeden Art des Verbrechens um zum Ziel zu kommen und der Ziel ist die totaler Enteignung des Palästinas.
I wonder how she would feel if someone took over her home
@tonymedeiros5515 quite frankly, she should give up her home and land to an Ashkenazi family as its proper reparations. Why should Palestinians pay the price for Germans.
She says she knows nothing and is agnostic, then with immense arrogance lectures him.
Professor is too nice to a person with limited knowledge of history and international law‼️
Leave or die. If we live in a world with rules based order, that’s an unacceptable way to run our world. Does she want a world where someone can come to her family and say leave or die, Just accept with it? I’m sorry but we have too much dignity to give up the land where our family members and our ancestors are buried, not theirs.
She is making me mad.
Why cause she don't like the killing?
thats the point, they're trying to drive us all mad
The ICJ clarification of July 19, 2024 states: 1 Israel must leave all illegally occupied territories (Gaza, West Bank, East Jerusalem...SYRIAN GOLAN HEIGHTS). 2 Israel and all supporters of the illegal occupation are obliged to pay reparations (USA, UK, Germany...)
First of all, it's an "advisory opinion" by the ICJ. Second, there is no mention in it about any other state's any obligation for reparation to anyone. Which means you are just a liar.
This lady is too confused with herself
How is it this woman can not understand what John is trying so hard to point out facts it's like she wants to support Israel natter what
Painful watching her, not sure how she got hired, her ignorance is beyond the pale, she must have worked FLAT OUT to get her position
The host questions if there can be apartheid if there are as many Palestinians as Jews. What she doesn't recognize is that apartheid does not depend on polulation but on power and the Jews have the power and use it to limit freedom of movement, association, and access to power.
She uses twiter as evidence of "the good life" completely confusing nice geologic or geographic reality for political reality.
She asks why other countries don't take Palestinian refugees, she shoudl be asking why Palestinians should be refugees from their own country.
She commits a classic straw man fallacy when she states, she doesn't want the Jews to not have a country. There is no issue with the Jews not having a country, there is an issue with treating Palesinians as fourth class citizens in their own country, then with ethnic cleansing, and finally with genocide.
Either that host is sorely uniformed (and considering access to information that has to be purposeful) or she is a voice for Israeli propaganda that is acting naive for propaganda purposes.
She seems completely unaware that under apartheid in S. Africa, the whites comprised only 20% of the population.
Absolute rubbish total crap Arabs in Israel vote are represented in the Knesset and in the judiciary this odious has been given voice by skilful propagandists who actually did not have to work very hard because Jew hatred is an incurable disease and no one is trying to find a cure
You want the fighting to stop, by telling the Palestinians to just let the bullies keep bullying you. And you never want to tell the bullies that they're wrong. You'd rather tell the Palestinians that they're wrong
My thoughts exactly. Only one side is unwilling to divide the land and begin to try and live in peace… and it’s not the Palestinians.
Because it's EASIER to point to the weaker group than tackle the bullies. Because doing what's easiest, while ignoring the danger of the ever-encroaching police state, is part of how we have been conditioned to behave. Like her, in fear of the state - effectively extinguishing morality and the courage to stand up and just do what's right, consequences be damned. Like Yemen.
The Palestinians to submit that wouldn’t be the solution (as the professor paitiently explained): If the Palestinians submit (as they already do I’m the westbank) there still would be an apartheidstate so :… how the professor explained that is the reason for Israel’s process of cleansing … it is as simple as that and those discussions are just wasted time … For over a year the world is discussing as if it would help because that is all we can do to stand the powerlessness
‘Strange’ is an understatement for what Israel backed by America and the western countries of the Empire that it seems never died, are doing.
She lectures him which is absolute ridiculous
Respect for him telling the truth 👍
This is not complicated at all. Open your mind. Have you ever seen a 2 year old vote.
All you have to do is ask her if the Germans would have excepted that the Jews take over Bavaria. It would have been fair after WW2.
Absolutely ‼️
Exactly.
Who is that woman. She keeps saying she understands, she completely understands. Judging by what comes out of her mount she has no understanding of the Palestine/Israel dynamic.
Is she meant to act stupid?
Maybe she just is.
Very stupid
I think it's an act. It gives her an opportunity to spread hasbara.
She is trying to act smart, but.....😅
John is a legend in cold hard truth. He has no ambiguity or bias.
And HE never gives up trying to inform with facts and evidence to doubters and denialists …that has to be work!
He is a legend in your mind not mine
@@JacobRothmanNo doubt you disagree with something he has said. As I don’t know your credentials I will favour him.
At least she admits she hasnt a clue about the conflict but she should at least keep quiet for a little bit and let the expert speak for a while.
She's using the word "agnostic" wrong. She means to say "ignorant"
Ha .....she should have said " I'm just a moron on the situation in Gaza "
Why don’t the Palestinians leave their land, give it to Israel and go live in other Arab countries? I can’t believe the reporter is so naive.
This woman is CLUELESS (and that's putting it nicely).
She's blaming the Palestinians for not giving up. She regards the Palestinians as a nuisance. No blame at all for the Israelis. Go figure.
I guess the Israelis are at fault foe reacting to the murder and rape of its citizens I must assume that other countries would be passive in these circumstances Why did the USA invade Iraq genius the ignorance of people is incredible
Prof. John M. is simply brilliant! Thank you for educating us.
He omits mentioning the 97 odd Israeli hostages.still held in the Hamas dungeons.
No funds
No weapons
No wars
She's basically saying "the allies did it to the germans, they can now do it to the arabs"
Wow, who is she? Why is she running a political show?
Why is JM giving her the time of day. JM is exhibiting extreme patience.
TY Prof JM. Clearly the voice of sanity.
This interviewer is not brain dead, she is heart dead. She is ignorant, rude and not being sure "of facts" yet she interrupts the Professor repeatedly. Good God.
"Agnosticism" is not "ignorance".
If you pose yourself as an interviewer stop interrupting with stupid dogma.
She does not want to know and does not want to acknowledge what the Israelis have done and continue to do.
Call it what it is or you are complicit in this genocidal land theft.
Genocide and land theft you Jew haters are really something special truly stupid
She says the Jews deserve their own country, but expects the Palestinians to abandon their homes and roots and move to Jordan and Egypt. Even the most rabid right wing demagogues in Europe would not make such a profoundly unjust argument
You are very confused In 1947 the Arabs refused partition an unfortunate tragedy a horrible blunder No one is asking the Arabs to move The only thing they have to do is stop killing Jews digging tunnels in order to commit murder etc
She seems selectively ignorant about this situation
Why is she even on the air.? She is the most ignorant host I have seen to date. She knows no history. She knows no current events. Wow. Ignorance at this level is stunning. Sad. Poor Professor. He deserves better.
The moderator is 100 times smarter than the professor
“Hardly surprising” She is done !
She understands. She totally understands. And she's agnostic.
She’s an airhead getting educated 😂
She is uneducable
Is this debate or Interview?? Why such arrogant and ignorant lady sitting with the Professor John??
“These things happen all the time, JOHN”???? WTF is her problem?
Now I have heard it all!!!! What a stupid woman .
I wish she had born in Gaza then I would like to hear what she has to say about Israel !?
Why would you be on RUclips commenting on geopolitics if you know so little about an ongoing G-cide - the most documented and obvious G-cide in world history - that you can't even take a confident stance against it?
JM, my hero, speaking truth to power....
Prof john hopefully could change german opinion. To be complicit in a genocide is a shame.
This woman's ignorance is nauseating.
Not compelled by her argument
I don’t recall when I’ve ever seen a less informed or less qualified interviewer. Is this common in the German press?
76 years of Israeli occupation she asking why it's still like that Democracy means Palestinians will be voted to power Israel can't have that this lady playing dumb 🤣🤣🤣
Her body language speaks volumes about her true attitude, which she admits is based on a lack of knowledge.
how ignorant is this interviwwer, is this typical of German understaning of the issue?
What a low low level interviewer. Tks Professor for your patience.
Pure facts from the professor, the host is struggling to accept said facts.
try 'unwilling' she has OCD with her own fantasies.
Israel will not come to its senses, without it being forced to.
1) US has for decades supported Israel unequivocally, will it always support Israel?
2) The Arab street has not forgotten the Palestinian cause even if some of the Arab leaders have, will Arab people on the street always support the Palestinian cause?
So which will happen, the Arab street stops its support or the USA stops its support?
In my opinion, the US will be the one which changes, as the USA has often been fickle, we can already see US public support is changing, as it has in Europe. When US policy changes, Israel will no longer be able to continue as it has, it is very difficult though then to predict what will happen, it would be in Israel’s interest to realise this sooner than later, so that it can remain a state.
This woman is an example of intentional specious ignorance.
She needs to research the definition of "Agnostic". She gives the impression of being bought.
Military Take over - How about Moral Philosophy and decency toward others.
More people died than hamas fighters
There has never been an independent Palestinian State,FACT
"I don't know enough about it."
Read "The Iron Wall" by Jabotinsky or "They Must Go" by Meyer Kahane. You'll be clear about it.
She says things and then says thats not what I am saying. "Listen John "she says rudely not listening to him and talking over him. I Imagine hé must be thinking " Thé germans just dont think normally with a serious almost pathological lack of empathy. Thé problem is thé Germans as a nation just can't tune into othe peoples perspectives and are thé worst politiciens in Europe and this woman amply displays this. Germains are great engineers, musiciens, but thé worst when it comes to politics.
”You can choose unfair peace, or you can fight for fairness”
Wow. Im starting to give up on people.
WWII germany were the aggressors and had to pay the price with having their borders changed. The Palestinians are the victims here since 1947. The ukrainians will have to accept territorial losses, despite western support, they are also victims of aggression. In the middle east the so called virtuous west is supporting the aggressive invaders (Israel) but really should be forcing them to stop - which it could (ie. look at Serbia and the Balkans conflict)
The Palestinians are the victims? Read a little bit of history who refused partition genius
OMW....is this woman for real 😮😮😮...
How utterly ridiculous. So this lady doesn’t research literally anything about the situation in preparation for an interview on the topic with a subject matter expert? Then - life is unfair so deal with it? How about giving Bavaria to the Jews?
The displaced Germans in WW2 can go back to Germany after WW2. But Israel will not allow the displace Palestinians to go back to theirs lands like the previous Nakbas ( 1948, 1967 etc ).🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸
not truly interested in truth or justice. this is why there are 'moral quandaries'..
“ im agnostic towards the conflict”, continues arguing using the Israeli Propaganda ☕️
She is comfortable for Israelis to have a State, but not the Palestinians
Love Prof. John Mearsheimer. Religion is neither a race nor a national identity
If you dont know anything, why are you doing an interview?
What a stupid set of talking point questions by this bubble head
Arab israelíes are 20% with full rights
She should say why isr not accept and should accept Palestinian wants a state.
This interviewer doesn’t have a basic understanding of the facts. She said that there are 7 million Palestinians within Israel that are equal citizens 😂
Prof. John Mearsheimer is very kind not kicking this woman!
She is so naive. Does she live in Disneyland?
She lives with Bugs Bunny, Daffy Duck and other Looney Tunes characters? Sooooo stewpid.. agnostic? Try ignorant 🙄
The professor twists the facts
His books are well sourced, and are of academic quality. The reports he mention are from dependable sources. I think what’s more probable is that you have a dog in this crooked fight, and aren’t an honest broker. It’s incredibly dark to observe just how far people have deluded themselves when they have been indoctrinated into a cult.
AI confirmation.
1. Complexity as an excuse
• The core of the conflict is clear: It is essentially about land, rights, and self-determination. Palestinians are fighting for their own state and against the occupation of the West Bank and the blockade of Gaza, While Israel claims to defend its security but also increasingly annexes and colonizes more land. These basic issues are not “complex,” but quite clear.
Even ChatGPT get’s it!
If I could debate you I would destroy you argument with ease You are either I’ll informed or a Jew hater probably both if you think otherwise read the history instead of blabbering rubbish