Robert Whitaker Answers Reader Questions on Mad in America, the Biopsychosocial Model, and...

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 8 сен 2024

Комментарии • 10

  • @haileysmom2358
    @haileysmom2358 9 месяцев назад +11

    I have learned so much from MIA I’ve been tapering for 1.5 years & the quality of life has improved significantly. My doctor has not supported my tapering & continuously tells me that I MUST continue the drugs or I will fail miserably & he won’t be able to SAVE me. He is more committed to the drug lords than towards the patient.

  • @juliaschlegel7175
    @juliaschlegel7175 8 месяцев назад +1

    I'm poor and really careful who I subscribe to, but what you do is CRITICALLY IMPORTANT and i would happily pay a subscription to keep it running. So grateful .

  • @claireh.7605
    @claireh.7605 8 месяцев назад +2

    If I knew I had to taper for months I would have never bothered starting the med! Discontinuation was never discussed when it was prescribed

  • @stevekaylor5606
    @stevekaylor5606 8 месяцев назад

    Mental Health is the development of a mental + emotional dedication - a cathexis!

  • @juliaschlegel7175
    @juliaschlegel7175 8 месяцев назад +3

    I find it interesting that India, a spiritual culture handles alternative states better than anyone else. Maybe we should stop fearing what we don't understand and start listening to those who you call mad.

  • @replaceablehead
    @replaceablehead 4 месяца назад +1

    I think Nassir and Healy are closer to the mark on the disease issue.The issue is scientifically invalid diagnosis, therapeutic bandwagons, and ignoring patients.
    If treatment, any treatment, proceeds from a scientifically invalid diagnosis and a overhyped treatment is used, it will lead to a poor outcome. It's not that the disease model is always wrong, it's that our disease categories and treatments suck. We're using a pop quiz for diagnosis and a blue dye for treatment and we're confused that it's not working and that healthy people are receiving treatment. Think about all the healthy people that endured blood letting and leeching. That wasn't because diseases don't exist, that was because we didn't have the ability to diagnose them and treat them with any real degree of accuracy..
    Case in point, my wife received DBT during a manic episode. This talk therapy and the context in which it happened was almost as distressing as many of the medications. Had treatment proceeded from a more objectively accurate view of the situation, I think it would have been more successful.

  • @ancabostinariu6550
    @ancabostinariu6550 7 месяцев назад

    A big part ofvtreatment in psychiatry is psychotherspy however in the last years is less anc less used.
    There are programms of training psychiatrists which do not emphasise it.
    I think it should be reintroduced and developed

  • @wildhumans8116
    @wildhumans8116 25 дней назад

    I experienced brief and fleeting voices during deep meditation. I think I've been misdiagnosed with schizophrenia versus hypnagogia as an explanation. They put me on an antipsychotic and the doctor wants to put me on a second antipsychotic to treat one side effect of the first (prolactin). I didn't like that idea, I take laxatives for Constipation and pain killers sometimes for headaches. I think my doctor also wants to put me on a Parkinson's medication to treat muscle Cramps and twitches. Antidepressants to treat avolition and something to treat the cognitive decline I've experienced. Good lord, where does it stop, this shrink wants to have a cocktail party with me...

    • @Waves353
      @Waves353 23 дня назад

      @@wildhumans8116 please avoid further meds