As an orchestral musician with limited tolerance for conductors who engage in choreography to draw attention to themselves, rather than helping the musicians play well together, i find these (unwitting) caricatures of conducting to be absolutely hilarious. I can somewhat excuse Uchida, as at least her gestures, as odd as they are, seem to be in service of the music, but some of the piano-ists look like absolute buffoons. Perhaps that is the image (Friedrich) Gulda in that hat is trying to cultivate, but the "triple axel" Rach 3, what a silly joker...
@@Kaoskadosk What's funny is while I was watching the video I was wondering if it were possible to conduct and play something as hard as Rach 3 at the same time.. That was the exact moment this clip came up, answering my question.
Some of these are absurd because you simply can't do Rachmaninov or Beethoven's Emperor without a conductor. The best is Uchida because she's a great pianist and because you don't need a seperate conductor in Mozart piano concertos, though it does help. She's a decent conductor here. Don't forget that she's communicating with the 0rchestra when conducting, NOT with the audience. It's not like Cab Calloway, who was just beating time. Also, I think Gulda (in the Emperor) played the piano part well.
My God, I laugh and get angry at the same time. Except Barenboim, no one is a real conductor. Btw, it is just me or Gavrilov is playing worst every year?
Although Gulda's gesture is pretty weird, but his music is excellent I really love the Beethoven 5th piano concerto he performed. But what happened to Mr. Gavrilov??Couldn't believe that's him......
1:35 who is that? The others i get, they're conducting Arachmaninoff or Mozart's 20th, but this guy's conducting a nursery rhyme like it's Beethoven's 10th
(2:50) "The coast is clear".....at least he looks like he's having a good time...lol...like he's not taking himself too seriously. He reminds me of Oscar on the "Odd Couple".....backwards hat and all xD
Only Barenboim has had formal education as a conductor. He is also the only one who is able to properly conduct the orchestra from the piano. And even he makes mistakes sometimes when conducting from the piano either in the piano part or in the conducting.
Woah dude what are you screaming about? You seem to have totally misread xbqchm's comment. You seem to be on a hair trigger. Go and have that beer you named yourself after (but not too many you sound like the type that might try to kill someone)
I love classical music. Everything from funny stereotypes to intense passages to insanely beautiful pieces. It really moves me.
As an orchestral musician with limited tolerance for conductors who engage in choreography to draw attention to themselves, rather than helping the musicians play well together, i find these (unwitting) caricatures of conducting to be absolutely hilarious. I can somewhat excuse Uchida, as at least her gestures, as odd as they are, seem to be in service of the music, but some of the piano-ists look like absolute buffoons. Perhaps that is the image (Friedrich) Gulda in that hat is trying to cultivate, but the "triple axel" Rach 3, what a silly joker...
OMG so hysterical. Clever. I'm a concert pianist and this nailed the styles of conducting. Mitsuko was esp funny.
Concert pianist has a particular meaning.
Do more of this, please.. I am literally rolling in laughter now
my gosh this is PURE GENIUS
Everytime I find one that I like the next one is better.
Netflix and chill! That one got me. Thanks, I needed the laugh.
I will show you, don’t worry. Lol k
@@bolanddewsnap5698 spoiler alert: he REALLY DID NOT.
Poor guy.
gotta love Mitsuko Haha
philly cream cheese OMG HAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHA WEAVE WHERE ART THOU!
"cheese nom nom"
Keith Foester or "caught me a fish"
I made it until 2:55
Literally thought that was hj freaks at first
I LOVE this video!!! One of my conducters had mastered the Sophie’s choice and headbangers ball
This is one of the funniest videos I have ever seen!
I love how half of them are from the Rachmaninoff Piano Concerto
GULDA is the man!!! 😃😃 But see what beautiful sound he gets out of the orchestra 😎
This turned out to be dimensions funnier than I expected 😂😂😂
Oh my god IM CRYINNGGG THIS IS TOO HILARIOUS
I’m a pianist and I found this the funniest video I’ve seen in a month
Rach 3 was very disrespectfully portrayed.
My thought was "If you're going to conduct as well as play the piano, why the *hell* do you pick Rach 3 to do it?"
@@Kaoskadosk What's funny is while I was watching the video I was wondering if it were possible to conduct and play something as hard as Rach 3 at the same time.. That was the exact moment this clip came up, answering my question.
@@tidnid1869 Have you heard Rachmaninoff's recording?
Absolutely
Chopin 1 has the flexibility, not rach 3
Some of these are absurd because you simply can't do Rachmaninov or Beethoven's Emperor without a conductor. The best is Uchida because she's a great pianist and because you don't need a seperate conductor in Mozart piano concertos, though it does help. She's a decent conductor here. Don't forget that she's communicating with the 0rchestra when conducting, NOT with the audience. It's not like Cab Calloway, who was just beating time. Also, I think Gulda (in the Emperor) played the piano part well.
heres a little known fact: i put "pixie hands" in my conductors notes. about time someone followed my cues.
I will NOT
Oh dear what is it with these guys butchering Rachmaninoff so badly 😂
the first one, here: 0:12, GOD, those last notes were a mess.
I wanna cry 😂😂😂
And guess what. He is the winner of 1974 Tchaikovsky competition!!! LMFAO
I'm picturing Sergei making these gestures and expressions and my brain is exploding.
Daniel Lu Sergei was actually apparently very restrained both with the piano and conducting.
My God, I laugh and get angry at the same time. Except Barenboim, no one is a real conductor. Btw, it is just me or Gavrilov is playing worst every year?
He's going the way of the Pogorelich
"how the mighty have fallen" indeed
You must thank to God that Pogorelich doesn't conduct.....
Well, he does force conductors to chase after his random tempi.
And Barenboim uses nothing but his eyebrows.
Mitsuko loves the music a what she does.
we want more please. We need more!!!
The music goes well with the gestures as well.
Yeah but Mitusko Uchida gets a great performance as does Barenboim
I LOST IT IN STRANGER THINGS HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHA
6:00 My favourite one
"The coast is clear"
Gulda is by far the most hilarious
Everyone overboard
@@sebastianzaczek My personal favourite is "Philly cheese nom nom". The last part just killed me.
And "Netflix and chill" is just MOOD :-)
YES
NO
MAYBE SO
truly hysterical!
Friedrich Gulda was truly a goddamn legend...
1:09 let's take a moment of laugh❤❤
Anyone know where that shoulder bounce comparison video is from at 4:27?
Thanks for making me laugh so much!!!!
Uchida rocks! Love that woman!
Philly Cream Cheese nomnomnomnom
Thank you so much for this!
4:34 i love Mozart ❤️
This is so awesome, I love that everyone has a different style! Also, I think 1:54 was a young Daniel Barenboim, so that was cool to see
Please put the name of these pieces up pls pls
Lol Mitsuko san make my day!! hahahahahahahahaha!
Stranger Things?
I did NOT know she was a fan lol.
@@glenngouldschair390 she was trying to call mozart from his grave
Absolutely brilliant
What piece is Barenboim playing from 2:36?
ruclips.net/video/Aqxr0gwq3tY/видео.html
Art Song Transpositions Thank you very much
Daniel Barenboim's spot on
who's the "4th down with 3 seconds to go" pianist at 1:12 ? would like to listen to the full recording ^^
Although Gulda's gesture is pretty weird, but his music is excellent
I really love the Beethoven 5th piano concerto he performed.
But what happened to Mr. Gavrilov??Couldn't believe that's him......
Richter advise he have a problem of egomania and narcissism to be a good musician
Someone :You are the conductor
That dancing man : No I'm the condancetor
Someone : The ... who?
1:26
1:35 who is that?
The others i get, they're conducting Arachmaninoff or Mozart's 20th, but this guy's conducting a nursery rhyme like it's Beethoven's 10th
Naoumoff. He's brilliant but he does seem crazy as a shithouse rat.
It's a Mozart concerto where's the respect ?
What's the concerto young Daniel Barenboim is playing? (the first one) It's beautiful!
Mozart 26 & 13
What concerto is Van Cliburn playing from 00:57?
All of Van Cliburn's clips are Prokofiev's third concerto
(2:50) "The coast is clear".....at least he looks like he's having a good time...lol...like he's not taking himself too seriously. He reminds me of Oscar on the "Odd Couple".....backwards hat and all xD
does anyone know where I can find the clip of the Prokofiev sonata concerto in c major? 0:58
just search "van cliburn prokofiev 3" and it should be one of the first results
What’s the piece at 1:11 (4th Down with 3 Second to Go)?
Finale of Rach 3
Micha Weinst thank you so much!
Who the heck is the pianist at 1:15!
0:59 Clean
LMAO... Most appropriate move descriptions ever :D
17 pianists have downvoted this video.
You genius, thank you!!!
4:02 Look at the lady's resigned expression. Hahahaha...
Same expression at 1:28
haha oh man that's so gold. he may as well be spitting on her and her morale is just gone
Please make more of these!!
A new Olympic event. Like synchronized swimming only faster. The triple axel was brilliant, that would get a 9.5 (his recovery needs some practice).
This is sooooo good
I know what you did last summer 😂 best one
Can anybody tell me what the piece was during the Fond Farewell/Robin Williams at 2:26?
+yeah oh right rach 3 2nd movement
Lovely! But the clips are sooo short :)
what piece is played at 1:07 ? Please help :(
Prokofiev 3rd concerto, 1rst mov
thank you sir!
I bring to you all the conducting styles of Carter Simmons. You're so amazingly welcome!
What's the piece at 6:03?
1:50 and 2:36 is the same pianist BTW.
3:16 is that Yefim Bronfman??
No that's Gavrilov
My god this is too good I'm dying
I kind of like Uchida. As a cellist, I have issues with Daniel Barenboim, even though he's an outstanding pianist and conductor.
Poor Jacqueline 😥
I thought this a serious demonstration. It's entertaining.
When the classic beat drops
Love it
what music piece is this? 3:36
Rachmaninoff piano concerto no3
Thank you
Anyone know what the piano concerto is at 4:18-4:28?
Rach 3
I can’t stop laughing at the “Stranger Things” moment.
Expertly observed.
BRAVO!!!
クライヴァーンとグルダのかっこよさは異常
jetzt kapiert hoffentlich jeder, was der Unterschied von einemPianisten und einem richtigen Dirigenten ausmacht.
Danke schön (Trans: "Now, hopefully, everyone will understand the difference between a pianist and a real conductor")
hoffentlich...
Ja, ein Pianist kann Klavier spielen 😜
What's the one at 5:48
Gavrilov/Rach 2
this is genius
LOVED IT...🤣🤣🤣
What is "the hypnotist" piece?
The Fuggedaboutit is my favourite. Notice the guy in the audience who just starts laughing when it's over.
I am crying of laughter!
love cliburns
who wrote 1:30 ? i love this ! thanks
I need to who is that pianist in the old black and white footage
Van Cliburn
@@artsongtranspositions thank you very much :D
Its more amazing that you found all the matching moves lol
hahaha! This is the best. :D
The last one really is something.
Awesome I laughed so hard
2:40 what is barenboim playing?
ruclips.net/video/Aqxr0gwq3tY/видео.html
this is so hilarious and true at the same time rip
Surprised there is no Glenn Gould
SOMIT2003 his video recordings are very rare due to his shyness and preference for audio recordings
Glenn Gould wasn't a pianist + conductor. He was a pianist + choir.
@@lollycopter when he plays, he become a pianist+conductor+choir.
this is actually amazing hahahaha
whats the piece at 3:38?
Rach 3, just before the first movement cadenza
There are no conductors in the shown examples ?
yes there are: the pianists. :)
Only Barenboim has had formal education as a conductor. He is also the only one who is able to properly conduct the orchestra from the piano. And even he makes mistakes sometimes when conducting from the piano either in the piano part or in the conducting.
Woah dude what are you screaming about? You seem to have totally misread xbqchm's comment. You seem to be on a hair trigger. Go and have that beer you named yourself after (but not too many you sound like the type that might try to kill someone)
Stop it you're turning me on
Cold German Beer *grabs popcorn*
Song list please