I literally said the same thing when I first heard this song, I can easily hear it being played at the ending credits to a movie, I lowkey can hear it being played in a horror movie cause the song kinda has a creepy vibe with the beat and the vocals too especially at 2:07, I can hear it being in a horror apocalypse or battle royale type of movie
I love Giselle vocals when she says welcome to my world towards the end of the song 💚 So powerful!!! Ningning vocals are god level and so clear. She's insane. Winter has sweet vocals, love her voice!!! Also, Giselle and Karina rap is so smooth... it blends well in the song. Their vocals are superb too!
Winter - 31.60s Karina - 25.53s Ningning - 49.01s (Assuming the adlibs in Karina's last part is her) Giselle - 25.49s Nævis - 28.42 (I only did the bits that were marked Nævis, so I didn't include the mechanical sounding voice that repeated after the girls in what I think is the bridge)
This song reminds me a lot of Taylor Swift's song Safe and Sound from the Hunger Games movie! There's sadness and hope at the end of every sentence they sing. aespa has been making art and bringing music that gives everyone emotion 😭 it's so beautiful. Congratulations aespa for the beautiful return!
I have been into kpop since gen2 , and this definitely got into one of my top kpop song list. So epic so rich so mysterious and yet so sic-fic feeling, almost like a background soundtrack of “west world”/“love death robot”🔥
winter's singing just makes this song so meaningful (opinion dont come after me), all the singers' voices together make this song what it has come to be
This song is such a good album opener! It could pass as a movie soundtrack easily
agree, especially the 2:28 climax part.
agree!
it's such a therapeutic and atmospheric song to listen to 😭
Fr , Marvel
I literally said the same thing when I first heard this song, I can easily hear it being played at the ending credits to a movie, I lowkey can hear it being played in a horror movie cause the song kinda has a creepy vibe with the beat and the vocals too especially at 2:07, I can hear it being in a horror apocalypse or battle royale type of movie
I’m mesmerised by this song ~ the lyrics are so beautiful, the soundtrack is mystifying, and the vocals are astonishing. What a piece of art!
The voice of Ning Ning can be like the singing of angels, or like the temptation of demons, listening is a kind of enjoyment.
her voice has something like Mariah Carey
@@vivianrebeca3819 Very high praise. She is still very young now, hope to have a good precipitation change better.
@@yusei_oll The voice has something similar but not the same it doesn't have to be like anyone else
Ning Ning has an amazing voice!
I love Giselle vocals when she says welcome to my world towards the end of the song 💚 So powerful!!!
Ningning vocals are god level and so clear. She's insane.
Winter has sweet vocals, love her voice!!!
Also, Giselle and Karina rap is so smooth... it blends well in the song. Their vocals are superb too!
Omg ningning’s voice is really awesome 🤩
Whoever made this melody needs a raise because It was a really nice listen the first time I heard it, unlike many songs these days.
Ningning's vocals are heaven ❤
Ning's voice sounds so comfortable, I love it, I want to sleep❤
Winter - 31.60s
Karina - 25.53s
Ningning - 49.01s (Assuming the adlibs in Karina's last part is her)
Giselle - 25.49s
Nævis - 28.42 (I only did the bits that were marked Nævis, so I didn't include the mechanical sounding voice that repeated after the girls in what I think is the bridge)
This is a balanced distribution ❤
Winter's vocal is angelic 😭
2:19 NINGNING'S VOCALS HERE R SO ANGELIC
Winter's vocals never fail to amaze me. Her tone is fantastic and she always adds so much emotion. What a vocalist
The uniqueness everytime she sings catches my ears
Ningning shined the brightest in this keys be real but they were all memorizing 😍
Aespa have such good songs
Winter's voice is so addicting and i don't know if i can move on from this anymore. this girl is no joke.
This song reminds me a lot of Taylor Swift's song Safe and Sound from the Hunger Games movie! There's sadness and hope at the end of every sentence they sing.
aespa has been making art and bringing music that gives everyone emotion 😭 it's so beautiful.
Congratulations aespa for the beautiful return!
ooooh i kinda feel it specially on the nature background noise ❤
AESPA'S 4TH GEN QUEENS
Winters voice is just so pleasing to the ears.
the song is sooo good when you let your main vocal sing, so proud of you ningbao
Ningning's vocal, that darara, and the bridge ❤
Winter has such a beautiful voice.
Who will support to aespa FOREVER , Raise your hand 🖐️
✋
✋ We love aespa.
🖐🖐🖐
🖐️
✋️✋️✋️✋️✋️
This sounds scary and so magical I love it veryy muchhh it sounds apocalyptic in a way too 👀
Is it just me or did the beginning sound a bit like “She loves me she loves me not” by Taemin or am I tripping
I LOVE THIS SONG SO MUCH! I LOVE HER, SHE'S SO CALM BUT AT THE SAME TIME SHE ROCKS!
I have been into kpop since gen2 , and this definitely got into one of my top kpop song list. So epic so rich so mysterious and yet so sic-fic feeling, almost like a background soundtrack of “west world”/“love death robot”🔥
It's so magical. I want Disney to take their move I'm not kidding
Ningning vocals shine the best in this song. ❤❤❤
this song sounds like its from an epic movie soundtrack
10000000% the most underrated gen 4 group. Blows my mind how these vocal skills get overlooked.
What? Aespa underrated? Are u sure lol hahaha just search about aespa achievement hahaha
not underrated at all, pls study more ❤️
*NingNing's untouchable trend has left the chat*
not underrated, but underappreciated. along with overhated
underrated 4th gen group??
ok brb im CRYING
bro WHAT
aespa are literally leading among 4th gen ggs
they are very successful in sk
This has to be one of the best b sides I’ve heard in while I cannot LIEEEE 😩
Theyre soooo underappreciated for their discography when they have sooo many bops
This city's so pretty with your lights on 🥸
Winter has the sweetest and the calmest voice I’ve ever heard in my life.Definitely the vocal queen and of the best in 4th gen
Winter's voice is always calming and fits this song perfectly.
LUV NING NING’S VOCAL
winter's singing just makes this song so meaningful (opinion dont come after me), all the singers' voices together make this song what it has come to be
nævis's voice is so similar with Ningning's voice
It sound like a mix of Ning2 and Winter
The lyrics are so poetic
Giselle VOCALS 👑
Line Distribution
1. Ningning
2. Winter
3. Giselle
4. Karina
4.Nævis
Hhhhh that's also their vocal ranking hhhhhh
@@rodricamichael5510 naevis is 2
funny enough, naevis is actually number 2
1. NingNing
2. Nævis
3. Winter
4. Giselle
5. Karina
닝닝목소리 미쳤네;
Giselle voice is so addictive 😫❤
This song is so majestic I don’t even know how to explain
Nah but no one be talking 'bout naevis's vocals tho like- bae slayed
MY NAEVIS WE LOVE YAUR 😍😍😍😍😍
Vocals and instrument are so magical, love it!
this haunting magical out of this world melody is what gets me!
처음에는 밋밋했는데 자꾸 들으니 명곡이네 이거
I LOVE NAEVIS SHES SO HYPNOTIZING
Ningning's first line is legendary... i feel there is door opening in the sky.
Beautiful song amd vocals
the perfect intro for the new era 🤍🤍
늘 실망시키지 않는 에스파
엄청빨라요 어떻게 이걸 다외우시는지👍 에스파 이번컴백 대박나자🙂
iM SOBBING YALL ITS SO BEAUTIFUL
2:04 it's Giselle's voice
This is such a pretty song!
Omgg i love how they look in this CB
Vocals from heaven 😍
I could listen to these girls all day. Every one of their songs suck me right in. Especially Karina's parts, she is my bias.
I really like this concept it’s so emotional
I love winter voice so muchhh❤
WINTER'S VOCALS 😢🤕🫶🏾
THE WAY THAT AESPA ONLY DO PERFECT MUSIC--
the grey lyrics from 2:07 to 2:24 are naevis' lines!
I'm so excited to listen to this album
their vocals are just too good
AESPA'S SLOW SONGS RANKING
Til we meet again
welcome to my world
Forever
Lucid Dream
Once again
Life's too short
Icu
Karina's voice is unique, I could immediately differentiate her from the other members
this song is sooo beautiful and calming!
NINGNING OUTSINGS EVERYONE IN 4TH GEN 🫶🏾🤕
No one beats taeil stfu
lets be humble don't say that, praise ningning without mention any other, everyone had their own skills and everything 🤗
@@hannnnn123 agree
ouhh but she didn’t
Stop fighting like little kids and grow up
I just want to praise Ningning
Ningning voice is amazing
They slayyyyyyedd this so hard❤❤
Special appreciation to NAEVIS' voice ❤
ngl I wanted miss naevis to have more lines but overall one of my fave song openers fr
Damn, was Ning Ning's voice always this good
Giselle voice so stunning❤
Winter amazing 😍😍😍
"I Cried To Listen This Song". 😢
nævis ❤
NINGNING'S "This city's so pretty when your lights on" IS LITERALLY SO ANGELIC LIKE
ningning voice is so pretty, my heart ❤🥺
Perfect😩💥
Nævis is pretty 😻😻😻😻😍😍😍😍🎉🎉🎉
queen winter 😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍
Naevis slayed
It's Ningning voice tho.
oh my god ningning’s voice is just so beautiful ❤
Giselle queen 💝👑
This song is so underrated
Love this omg ahhh 😱
I LOVE THIS SONG
NING SINGGG FOR MEEE❤
Heavenly
i've been addicted to this lately!
this song actually fit disney vibe
0:37 여기 나만 좋나 멜로디 묵직하게 울리는거 개좋음
Can’t get enough of Ning’s voice …she owned this song tho ❤🦋🦋🦋
1:53 GOOSEBUMPS 😌😌😌😌
Winter ❤
Everyday I'm believing more that naevis will be the new aespa's member