Noob vs Pro Producers: Can you hear the difference?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 20 сен 2024
- GO HERE TO DOWNLOAD THE INFINITY VOCAL PACK FOR FREE:
cym.fm/3tqvnID
In this video we are taking 3 music producers of 3 different skill levels and making them use the exact same acapella. Let see what they can create in 30 minutes!
Big shoutout for the participants in this video:
Raffy - @raffy.beats
Tr1ll - @tri11szn
If you want to see my full 30 min unedited cook up go here!
• SIMON SERVIDA MAKES A ...
GET MY BEAT MAKING COURSE: www.prolevelbe...
Samples and kits for purchase here: www.simonservi...
FOLLOW ME ON SPOTIFY!!
open.spotify.c...
FOR COLLABORATIONS EMAIL ME AT
servidamusic@gmail.com
Follow Me On:
Instagram: @simonservidaMusic
Twitter: @ServidaMusic
Second Channel: / @servidastream8250
Soundcloud: / simonservida
Discord: / discord
www.simonservida.com
Go follow my editors @mira.wav @mdosik
#flstudio #beatmaking #musicproducer
Tags (Ignore):
Servida Music,Simon Servida,Making beat in Fl studio,making a beat,fl studio,logic pro x,ableton,acapella,fl studio acapella,music producer,music producer challenge,how to make beats,how to make beats on fl studio,fl studio vocals
GO HERE TO DOWNLOAD THE INFINITY VOCAL PACK FOR FREE:
cym.fm/3tqvnID
is it royalty free
Simon you literally put these two up against yourself to show them who's daddy this was fire tho😂🤣🤣🤣
@@k-hitz it’s 100% royalty free 👍
I tried my own with the other sample, tell me what you think please
ruclips.net/video/L7J6whIc-rM/видео.html
😍
Conclusion: the better you get, the darker the studio
😂😂
underrated comment
😂
Lol, gotta take out the sight to heighten the senses of sound 😆
Dayum :D
The most noticeable difference is in the mixing, especially with the vocals. You can hear the vocals get progressively louder from Beginner to Expert
nice point
Well you could actually see it as well. Just take a look at those waveforms
Nah, second beat felt so weird.. Almost like unmixed, vocals hidden somewhere in background and kick is clipping like crazy
Yeah, but I wouldn't downplay how valuable a professional is at bringing sounds together.
Like a painter who uses color to mix as a opposed to one who searches for the specific color, the last producer was able to give the song a "vibe"
I've made my fair share of "empty" and "soulless" beats, not that it has anything to do with a producers emotional ability as much as their ability to produce it.
The beginner actually had a pretty good melody going.
Yes you are right
Fr
Thanks bro :DD
He nice
i see eye to eye with you
This video just gave me the recipe for pro-level beats, time to cook up something amazing! I learned that pro producers usually use much better instruments and drum samples where as noobs don't focus on sound selection that much and instead try to fix stuff afterwards. I tell all of my producer friends to use platforms like Splice or Prodsounds kits so that you can have only a kick, snare and a bass and it already sounds amazing haha.
You don't need to spend money to get amazing sounds. Just learn how to use a synth through and through, record your own sounds and mangle them, or scour the internet for drum kits/presets/samples. Also I've never found presets to be satisfactory, they all are made to please a wide audience or emulate the archetypal tone of a genre and thus are almost always boring to me. Learning to make sounds yourself will allow you to never rely on anything for your mix to sound good and gives you the freedom to flesh out ANY sound in your head whenever you want.
Beginners using presets/kits almost entirely is a given but in the long game, presets can be very limiting. Sample libraries are great but don't offer anything you can't conjure yourself -- and your mix will be better for it in the long run.
@@calebcampbell5951 hey so where can I get that?? Like what is all of it called? Does anything cost money? Is there any personal equipment involved or is it all on the internet and computer and stuff? I have written down a lot of stuff in only a week and fine tuning lyrics off some beats I found on the internet like what’s wrong by Isaiah rashad and Kendrick but idk how to record music or even start. I just have lyrics and that’s it but I want to do more. But I know absolutely nothing.
hey so where can I get that?? Like what is all of it called? Does anything cost money? Is there any personal equipment involved or is it all on the internet and computer and stuff? I have written down a lot of stuff in only a week and fine tuning lyrics off some beats I found on the internet like what’s wrong by Isaiah rashad and Kendrick but idk how to record music or even start. I just have lyrics and that’s it but I want to do more. But I know absolutely nothing.
You don't need subscriptions for sounds and your friends aren't wrong lol. Stop having people waste money, there's thousands of sound packs and drum kits out there for free. To each their own, but I personally hate loops so I will never buy sound packs. Not to mention, you can make your own sounds and alter samples you already have.
@@thesnipingspider3852you're asking for a lot through a comment so I'm gonna assume you're young, you need a DAW. I've always used FL studios. Look up some videos. Way too much to explain for a comment
I can tell the intermediate producer wanted to do what Simon did but the way he produces 30 minutes wasn’t enough time to flesh that out 😭
SPEEEEEED
fr
@@ServidaMusic YOU ARE SPEEEED :D
@@ServidaMusicgive that man an hour🤣
Now, I can only imagine if you put 2 hours into this. That would be sick to the highest level.
This humbled me. Your intentional decision making, and sticking to a core idea and just adding enhancements was wonderful. The others also did a great job by going with their gut feeling, after all that's what music is about!
Simons Beat literally feels like it was made with the artist in a room the bounce like everything fits together perfectly this dude is insane
❤️
ye
Begginer and expert were my faves.
The first one was simple but everything in it was effective. And the last just felt so right, all of it.
❤️
the beginner is not a beginner. he has been beatmaking for 12 years
@@joshantonio4512 Haha only been producing for about a year bro 😅
@@rafaelsender367 it was good man!!
@@joshantonio4512 spreading lies on the internet is this guys hobby
Simon here just flexin
It’s my channel lemme flex
😂🤣
@@ServidaMusic 😂 your best ❤
Remember that one youtuber
❤️
I actually liked the beginner’s beat quite a lot!
the best of them
@yesyoucan7877 yep the last was the worst
@yesyoucan7877 music is subjective dont you agree ?
@yesyoucan7877 😂 i see
You can really tell where that experience went into.
Firstly Simon's mixing was much better, the mix was more balanced, the vocals more present and the drums were hitting harder without distorting.
Secondly the amount of ear candy and general scope of what he did in only 30 minutes were above the others, obviously because he doesn't have to experiment as much and knows what to do when.
That was really insightful. Thanks to all three of you!
❤️
Learning how a compressor works and what it does to sounds will literally take your beats from audiojungle quality to triple platinum
I love how this isn't a competition and shows the levels on knowledge instead. PROOF NOT TO GIVE UP YALL!!!! #DontGiveUp
Beginner and intermediate ones sounded like random beats with the accapella slapped onto it, while Simon’s actually felt like the accapella and the instrumentations played together perfectly.
Yea that's also the takeaway I had. The first two sounded like someone just slapped a youtube beat on a vocal whereas simon's just felt like the vocal was integrated into the song.
The Beginner and intermediate guys need to learn how compressor works and how to mix a little bit better. Meanwhile Simon added all the sauce. I'm sure the first 2 guys can make it sound polished but it'll just take them more time because the more beats you do you figure out how to add patterns and mix as you're building the song
I felt that the intermediate one didnt really feel a connection with the acapella since there were quite some disconnected progressions
30 mins and have that result is just insane Simon, respect man
I actually got goosebumps from your version Servida. Crazy beat. This sounds like it could be on the radio and the clubs. 10/10.
🕺🕺🕺🕺
❤️
these are actually called skin org*sms its an actual scientific term
I'm really sorry for you guys, who're getting goosebumps of this monotonous (I don't know how to call this even)
I’m so happy to say that you taught me the 90% I know about production. Your 100% the best RUclips producer and we all appreciate everything you do. Lotta love ❤
You really love percentages
@@stelkmclmaooooo😂
Raffy beats is actually crazy good, he's talented with only 1 year of experience
fr the intermediate one was worse imo, the bass went all over the place
@@sylae_music True. I think he was too focus on chopping the sampled which tbh, it doesnt really need much work he shouldve focus more on the arrangement. Hence, his work sound unfinish or rush.
Why’s the first beat so clean though?! Has a nice catchy melody vibe to it
beginner just out shined the intermediate
I mean they only have 6 months difference between them experience wise. Realistically 12-18 months I’d consider them both beginners
@@krispybowgod9656 Yeah and months is not a good measure. I feel the begginer guy put a lot more hours than the other. Intermediate's beat was all over the place, I don't think there was any theory behind it, to me it sounded like his first try at all
@@kkrup5395 yeah the bass was WHACK
Although I feel the creativity you have as a beginner can be unmatched by time and knowledge. You play around even if you don't know how to do certain things you work with what you've got.
Some of my earliest beats are still my favourites melody wise
@@krispybowgod9656 Exactly!
😂😂😂😂
The first one was my favorite. Didn't really get the middle one, but I'd obviously pay more for the last one.
The first one speaks to me, but the last one obviously topped.
At 3:35 i think the beginner said "That was horrible" ... if he did i would die of laughter that shit too funny
we need the full version , damn that made me dance dude plss we need it ❤🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
Where is the full version of the expert song? This was sick
there's stuff that's crazy clean but than there's an edge where you enter a whole different level of mixing and sound design that's the definition of true professional..so amazing...i can make pretty clean beats and i mean really clean but if you compare to soulker or simon as example that's nothing..there's so much more dynamic going on so much better sound design and even tho my mix is clean there's just like a secret unlockable stage of mixing that sounds completely different and you instantly notice...the wideness...all the perfect fitting frequencies, and only the important frequencies which makes it sound so balanced..the dynamic..i'm speechless
The difference in the quality of mixing and mastering on Simon's track. Insane
"Son of Kyle Beats" had me do an old man HA laugh out loud lmao. Always an amazing day when you upload something! Keep it up!
😂😂😂
@@ServidaMusic we gotta get you higher on sub count than him again dude. You deserve it!!! Beat Kyle at his own game (no pun intended)
This was sooo good! Love how you clearly can see who's the more/less experienced producer. This kind of vids really give me the motivation I need. Thank you!
That reggaeton is a new take I didn't expect. The beginner is by no means new, stuff is fire.
Crazy as soon as i heard the acapella i thought reggaeton haha
Nice video and really like the premise 🙂. Me personally I would just love to more explanation of the beat making process for everyone. I feel there’s no need to rush and edit that section as much. Seeing the specifics of how they made is the best part and the most inspirational and helpful for learning for me. Cheers!
I actually like the beginner version the most
Same here. Had a nice natural ring to it. But I have no idea about music so what do I know!
Same. The other two messed up the genre. This is literally Tory Lanez. Woulda been nice if they took the vocals and switched the order so the words lined up with the beat drop
Loved it
@@vacc1001 as a recording arts major ur opinion is valid
@@jordanjohnson6402 If you were a recording arts major then you would probably know that there's no such thing as "messing up the genre", especially since it was just up to them to flip the sample however they pleased and to their best capability. So uh, for a recording arts major, you sound pretty uneducated so far.
Don't mind me though, just some dumb high school band kid pursuing music, what would I know, right?
I think the beginner has the best track. Interesting they all went for a similar sound. They could all pass for remixes of each other.
When the world needed him most,he came back.btw,did u see that kyle passed u by subs😅
Hence my intro 😭😭😭
5:17
I got goosebumps listening to Simon's beat and then the little "unh" at the end made me burst with laughter 😂
SIMON I JUST STARTED YOUR MUSIC PROGRAM AND ITS SOO GOOD ❤️ keep up the good work plz
💛
LEVEL UP
@@ServidaMusic will do Simon, will do 🫡
Big difference you can see is that waveform. Very dynamic clean and nit over compressed.
GO HERE TO DOWNLOAD THE INFINITY VOCAL PACK FOR FREE:
cym.fm/3tqvnID
If you want to see my full 30 min unedited cook up go here!
ruclips.net/video/B2SUUGGXJz0/видео.html
Would love to vibe to the 30 min vid, but the link doesn't work yet simon
link is not working dude
Just bought your music course about an hour ago and I LOVE IT ❤️ keep it up
Nice
Link is working again, thanks :)
Why did you turn down the volume of the first two then turn yours up to make yours sound better? You should've done then all at the same volume to make it fair.
its probably that his 'loudness' was higher (ie his was better mixed, more compressed and limited) rather than he turned the actual volume up. I'd hope so at least
30 minutes?? I couldn’t get something that clean in 24 hours 😩
You’ll get there with enough reps 💪💪
And always depends on your workflow mood and the idea you got..sometimes i can make a beat base in 10-20 min then quick mix and arrangement which usually takes a little longer but they didn't do full tracks so 30 min would be fine...the key is inspiration and motivation if you're hyped for the idea you've got you just build the beat in no time because you know exactly what you're doing next in your beat other than when you just start a project and have to think about how to cook it up and what to add you know? The hype the mood the motovation and a great idea are just a workflow on a different level
Music aside, what did it for me was the fact that the camera and background clearly showed who was at what level.
Great vid tho!
That's insane, the beginner and intermediate producers have been producing later than me and they did great
Wow it would be really unfortunate if Simon were to accidentally leave the download file to these vocals so that we could also try this challenge
The beginner was the best one lmao
You remain to be my biggest inspiration Simon. Props to the two producers as well.
the 1st one goes hard
Here’s how it goes. Start creating RUclips videos where you’re always the “pro” and then after awhile everyone will believe it.
ayo Simon I love your vids, keep doing ur thing! just a little suggestion, do u remember the videos about ur first beats? how about turning them into a fire beat again ?
But I hate those
@@ServidaMusic but we love those 😂
@@ServidaMusic no they are fire , and also doing beats in different genres
Besides, it was your first beat and we actually see no faults in it. Could you pls grant that request just for the sake of love???
Thanks for the oppurtunity Simon!!
I think the first one had a lot more going on with it. The second one is probably what i would more listen too and chill too but i thought there was something missing from it like it needed more but i do like the dance/RnB vibe it had. The third one was more put together. Overall they were all good and I could bounce to them all.
I liked the beginner a lot, I wonder what the intermediate would have done with more time. And obviously you did great.
Hey Simon, I have been watching you for years now and I learned a lot from your videos! A little suggestion tho: would it be possible to up the quality of the videos a bit? Since you are already putting a lot of work into them, it would make it more pleasant to watch. Maybe you could do 1440p, 1080p @60fps, or better bitrate overall. Much love!
I’ll look into that!
I like how when they listen to the songs, all of them just nod their head
He just wanted to show how much better he is then all of us TOT
the expert track sounds way more alive, how he even do that?
now i know the importance of good mixing
Yeah bro. I don't believe he did that in raw 30 minutes. Next time the acapella should be randomly picked on the spot.
Its also using compression more effective
Hey Simón your killing it man your feel is crazy talented, I just had a question, did you go to school for music production?
I went to school for music theory, production was more from RUclips and experience
The beginner is by far the best. Just give it to a pro to mix. His ideas were way better than the other two.
Been here since day 1, raffy day 1 supporter, i know all his earlier beats like Latino beat and tropington
Sometimes simple is always best then I really dig the person who play the first track because that was a beginner and a beginner made it fire not to say I don't understand the other stuff but I really like the Beginner producer
Is there even a doubt here? both of them did their best thou. The drop was absolute fire 🔥
As a songwriter who can’t make beats, I look for beats that change throughout the song instead of having just one melodic instrumental sound aside from the intro- even the second verse and the second round of chorus should be different whether it’s more instruments being added or a shift in the beat, it helps with creating the perfect vocal melodies that will keep people listening and replaying the song! I think each level of producer did great but you can tell that the pro understood the importance of beat structure and development, great demonstration! Love love love!
It's just so amazing what Servida can accomplish in 30 minutes 👏🏾 🙌🏾 🔥🔥🤙🏾🤙🏾🤙🏾
The beginner had a more gangsta vibe to it. It was my favorite and would bump this on repeat in my car.
The intermediate was a dope chill dance vibe could be sped up for some techno vibes.
The expert one was what you would actually hear on the radio. Not my favorite type of beat but the way he flipped the sample is nothing less than masterful 👌 very creative. The spanish guitar was a nice lil flex too.
Great video.
The beginner better than me，meanwhile I've been producing for almost 2 years.
Simon , please on your next vid show how you master or what you got going on on your master.
Tr5 clipper that’s it!
I absolutely LOVE these! I've just started learning FL Studio myself, so I can't express how inspiring this kind of content is. Thank you, Simon! 🤩
Stupid Question.. how can they tell what key the vocals are in to make the beat and melodies? Is it just ear training to know right away?
In my opinion the beginner managed to make the most catchy one. Of course Simon did most accurate chord progression and stuff, but I think the vibe of the first one is just better
The Begginer did really good!
But the Kyle Beats son..😂
Kyle beats son is crazy
Simons beat is basically telling the other guys to just quit lol
You should do a vocal mixing challenge, that would be dope! And we can learn too.
the beginner was almost better than the intermediate but the experts track was mixed wayyyy better and the mix came out so much louder
More of this man!
If you need one for the “beginner” part sign me up!
I do! Everyone kept saying they were intermediate!
@@ServidaMusic if you need female vocals! I would love to send mine!
@@ServidaMusic also where is the discord?
Me too!
Beginner used Ableton Live, while everybody else used FL. Teared me up.
ngl i like the beginner beat the most. but shoutouts to all of yall tho yall did great :)
Damn bro, means a lot 🙏🙏
i really love this type of video- please keep making them ! ;)
year for all of us, for so- it's still ongoing. i respect you for being honest as that's what's been keeping a bit sane recently, just being
Raffy beat lowkey hard asf🤪🤪
The difference is inspiration and time 👌🏻
Damn Raffy goes hard
Boy I could say “scooby-dooby-doo” on Servida drop where the beat turns up and that thing would go platinum no joke!
This is getting crazy man ...
Keep it up
the fact that he a beginner and using ableton just inspired me, that thing is not user/beginner friendly at all! props
simons drop and the "hook" was so haredhitting. I got taken aback!! FIREEEEEE!!!
🙏🙏
This gives me so much more confidence as a beginner producer myself
The back and forth between Simon & Kyle is too good 😅
😂😂😂
No one gives a fuck if they are a noob at it or even a mid or pro we all like their beats and remix’s LOVE THEM MAN❤❤
I know I'll be the one to be Simon someday 😂😂
I'm actually beat blocked right now and just started browsing and watching vids on youtube. This was a good motivation honestly I needed this.
IMO ... first track was decent ... second track was off key to my ears .. and third was the fucking bomb... soon as I heard the vocals I thought of Carribean vibes too !!!
2nd one was definitely off key
Simon is on GOD level no joke, drop it on streaming platforms please!!
Simon has to be the best producer in the industry right now 😤💥💥
WOOOOOW
@@ServidaMusic not taking it back😤🖤
I like the begginer one better than the intermediate. 🙌🏻 - great video!
the expert one has way to much going on. WAY WAY WAY to much.
Beginner was definitely my favourite, intermediate was kinda like something you hear in some random tiktok edit, and the lady one just sounds like any other song ever made.
Calling yourself a pro producer is like me starting a skatebpard company so I can call myself a pro skater lmao
I like the first one, and the mixing is more balanced
I thought the beginner was BY FAR the best out of the three
The newbie just needs to learn mixing and mastering. His beats and ear for melody are spot on.
when he busted out them lofi jazz guitar riffs I knew I was in for some ear candy
the beginner was the best, lol.
The baseline and melody for the first one was insane
If I had to close my eyes and listen to all three, I’d choose the beginner 👍🏼