Smoker's body can function without its heart the same way the samurai's torso can function without its head. It's like Buggy's power, but done to other people.
I think it’s less a logical issue and more an issue of how differently the ability is presented. Smoker having his heart removed and then immediately falling unconscious kinda implies that his heart needs to be returned to restore his consciousness. As opposed to how his powers usually work where the character is usually conscious even as their body parts are rearranged, clearly showing that they are mostly unharmed by it. This and the fact that Law calls it by a specific name “Scalpel” kinda implies that this is a different move with specific rules. The later episodes do make the rules of this ability more clear, but I can’t blame people for being temporarily confused.
Bake-tanuki, or youkai raccoon dogs, that is. They disguise themselves by putting leaves on their heads and using them to transform. In that same vein, they'll use transformed leaves as fake money, and scam humans. They're one of the more well-known youkai, alongside foxes, but don't get along with said foxes at all.
I like how we've had several straight episodes of Law disconnecting people from their various body parts and surviving and Jack suddenly can't wrap his head around someone living after Law pops out their heart using his powers.
It's the same thing as people watching the live action going "Wait, where does the food go if Buggy eats without his torso?" without ever going an additional step into "wait, how does his circulatory and respiratory systems work while disconnected?" It's just a cognitive leap you don't normally have to make, so even when the principle is the same, you haven't actually thought all the way through what it means as a whole.
17:58 is one of those small but awesome One Piece moments that I love but genuinely just forgot about. Nami knows that Sanji typically smokes when he's stressed, needs to think or just plain have a distraction, so as soon as they need to all sit and process she immediately offers him his cigarettes, caring more for his state of mind than her body. And to Sanji's credit he's quick to make sure she's really ok with it. He's a perv, but he genuinely cares that it's her body that would be affected by this and future actions. Small stuff like this reflects how well the crew knows and cares about each other.
I’ve watched through One Piece twice, watching these reactions sort of counts as a third time - I never realized about Chopper’s king fu point looking like those goofy dudes from the bird island. One Piece is the greatest.
With the hearts, think of it like this: blood still flows into and out of the heart, but instead of flowing in and out directly, it flows through a portal, on one side of which is the heart and the other side is the rest of the body.
From what I can tell, the walls around what Law "cuts" are linked, so blood, nerve impulses, whatever don't spill out but instead teleport seamlessly to where they're supposed to go.
Law's devil fruit allows him to manipulate anything in his room, but at the same time- he can't cut any harm his patients, therefor the parts just stay separated, just like the heart, its still functioning but its separated. Its kind of like a portal between the blood vessels Also, the Garb Garb fruit (the disguise, clothes one) is very useful for stealth and espionage, and survivability. It will be REALLY useful in the future. Can't wait for you to see Law's backstory in the next arc and JOKER, you're now getting to the arc that starts all the hype till the current arc!
22:00 - The Wano Kingdom generally has no knowledge on the terminology for Devil Fruits so they see it as magic. The samurai's Devil Fruit may seem useless but think of the disguises you can make for espionage so it has its potential.
TO be fair Jack, I've been caught up for probably two years now. I've never made the connection with Choppers Kung-fu point either. I've never seen it mentioned before either and I watch a lot of OP YTs/streamers.
Yeah nah, I somehow don't think that's the case 🤷♂DO you even know what dull means? you sound dull by every definition.😂@@juanramonsolizvillarroel9308
I think having “useless” devil fruits kind of adds to the world building. Of course you get some sort of power to eating one, but then it becomes a dice roll as to its utility and importance in the world. Just like how Blackbeard bided his time until coming across the Dark-Dark Fruit.
The bu sound Kin's legs made while talking was the onomatopoeia for a fart or a wind escaping... in the manga it made more sense since sounds are actually usually written down...
people are mostly fine without their heart if law takes it, it still acts as if its connected but it makes them super vulnerable having their literaly heart in someones hand where the could kill them at any time. its a pretty good way to make someone a hostage
To help out, Caesar Clown is exclusively referred to as "The Master". If you hear anyone saying boss, captian or whatever, they are referring to a different character.
Kinemon's Devil Fruit is one of the weirdest powers out there. It is only useful for survival or to make the person look good or especially for camouflage. This power of his is very quickly forgotten!
I mean he uses it pretty regularly whenever it would matter, punk hazard, dressrosa, wano he uses it at some point in all 3 main arcs he's in. only one i cant remember him using it in is zou.
Even if you make it this far and don't understand Law's ability to disconnect things, it becomes crystal clear very soon when someone's heart gets squeezed and the rest of their body feels the pain.
How are you surprised that smoker can live without his heart that was taken by law, and then don't been surprised with samuria guy been cut in 3 by law, is like the same.
Smokers body can function without its heart the same way the samurai’s torso can func ion without ists head. It’s like Buggy’s power, but done to other people
Japanese lore lessons... Tanukis(racoons), as magical beings not just the regular animal, are able to disguise themeselves by putting a leaf. twig or rock on their head and using their magic... so that is what Kin'emon can do with his fruit...
it's not about her being without heart,the heart could function while separated thats Law's ability similar with the samurai is parts could walk and fight without his head similar scenario
Franky inside of Chopper's body is some what unsettling. I'm so used to the sweet voice of Chopper and lets not forget that Nami is inside of Franky's body now. She must really be freaking out now. No wonder the Kids are some what confused as well.
Not aways, only when it's called full name, i guess. otherwise people would call Luffy by "Monkey" the whole anime. I guess that's why Jack pointed that out
Ok 3 things: 1. Jack we know you're not quitting One Piece (though i'm surprised everyone is NOT commenting about this, when he said he was sick of Sanji the comment section was filled, and at that point we all were, but it comes back around/that feeling doesn't last... fully, we know it, just be patient). 2. Saying Kinne'mon's devil fruit is useless is a bit of a stretch, yes it has no battle capabilities, but not every fruit needs one, honestly (and i know i might draw the ire of some) Spring-Spring is much worse, if you had to eat a devil fruit, this one is not so bad. 3. Jack: "Franky just kinda fits with Chopper"... He's gonna regret that (i know Jack doesn't read these so i don't mind putting a spoiler here... Plus i talked so much the comment will probably be folded anyway), not only does Robin disagree, but the disrespect... Only as a last resort means you CAN'T handle it, seriously you were there back in Enies Lobby, darn ya Franky.
Besides him being upset about losing his penis, I honestly don't think Sanji would be too different. He'd just be a lesbian. A lesbian that really likes her own breasts...
Kinemon's fruit is actually good case he is a strong swordsmans he doesn't need an op fruit, it's good for situations, bon clay is like useless in fighting but useful in other ways and bon clay is good at fighting. Depends on how the user use it
I always thought it was because he was in his most muscular form. Like boas lets say round sister is 100% muscle. So chopper being a smol round boy is similar.
"Law vs. Smoker was straight GAS" I see what you did there. Don't discount the Garb-Garb fruit! Sure, its very useful in direct combat, but could you imagine the versitility of being able to summon whatever clothes you wanted at any time for FREE irl? And its perfect if you're a spy of some kind, almost as powerful as Door-Door.
Hmmmm I had never made that connection with chopper's kung fu point. What if his human fruit lets him turn into any type of human? Could he turn into a fishman? A long arm? Or any of the future races we will see?
The op op fruit consumes your stamina fast with the bigger the room and the more you do in it will cause it to drain faster that’s the downside of laws fruit
Why is the Op-Op Fruit the only Devil Fruit that runs on stamina? I mean, technically Luffy's Gears, but even then that's more of an issue with his rubber body.
@@Nightlingbolt mainly because he would literally be undefeatable in battle, nothing would work against him because the Op op fruit is like 7 fruits in one.
Smoker's body can function without its heart the same way the samurai's torso can function without its head. It's like Buggy's power, but done to other people.
Basically parts function as if they are still attached pretty sure Law explains that a bit later into punk hazard
seriously...i dont know what's so hard to understand.
I think it’s less a logical issue and more an issue of how differently the ability is presented.
Smoker having his heart removed and then immediately falling unconscious kinda implies that his heart needs to be returned to restore his consciousness.
As opposed to how his powers usually work where the character is usually conscious even as their body parts are rearranged, clearly showing that they are mostly unharmed by it.
This and the fact that Law calls it by a specific name “Scalpel” kinda implies that this is a different move with specific rules.
The later episodes do make the rules of this ability more clear, but I can’t blame people for being temporarily confused.
The rock/leaf is a reference to the myth that Racoons can disguise by putting leaves on their heads.
That’s cool, ngl
Specifically it's "raccoon dogs", or tanuki, critters native to Japan that Chopper is constantly mistaken for.
Is that why Mario can get the stone tanuki suit😭
Bake-tanuki, or youkai raccoon dogs, that is.
They disguise themselves by putting leaves on their heads and using them to transform. In that same vein, they'll use transformed leaves as fake money, and scam humans. They're one of the more well-known youkai, alongside foxes, but don't get along with said foxes at all.
I like how we've had several straight episodes of Law disconnecting people from their various body parts and surviving and Jack suddenly can't wrap his head around someone living after Law pops out their heart using his powers.
It's the same thing as people watching the live action going "Wait, where does the food go if Buggy eats without his torso?" without ever going an additional step into "wait, how does his circulatory and respiratory systems work while disconnected?" It's just a cognitive leap you don't normally have to make, so even when the principle is the same, you haven't actually thought all the way through what it means as a whole.
@@JoshTheValiantdamn you are very articulate in the way you explain. Very true though. ^
17:58 is one of those small but awesome One Piece moments that I love but genuinely just forgot about.
Nami knows that Sanji typically smokes when he's stressed, needs to think or just plain have a distraction, so as soon as they need to all sit and process she immediately offers him his cigarettes, caring more for his state of mind than her body. And to Sanji's credit he's quick to make sure she's really ok with it. He's a perv, but he genuinely cares that it's her body that would be affected by this and future actions. Small stuff like this reflects how well the crew knows and cares about each other.
Fr I really liked this moment it
I’ve watched through One Piece twice, watching these reactions sort of counts as a third time - I never realized about Chopper’s king fu point looking like those goofy dudes from the bird island. One Piece is the greatest.
With the hearts, think of it like this: blood still flows into and out of the heart, but instead of flowing in and out directly, it flows through a portal, on one side of which is the heart and the other side is the rest of the body.
Man. Been watching one piece since 2014 and didn't put that chopper thing ether till u said that crazy
Man it crazy. One piece epic love. Keep it up it counted somehow
Law is such a great character. Can’t wait till you see his backstory
I am the 14th comment. I came here after 4 minutes
Hello
I think he’s almost there on patreon
He's my favorite character
😭😭😭
I totally forgot Kinemon has that devil fruit to spawn clothes lol
Yup, the Fuku Fuku no Mi, or Garb Garb Fruit.
What I've realized after all this time, is that Kin'emon's special power was actually just talking out his ass.
@@TrueZero2 is it actually called garb garb fruit? 😹
@@keflalssj Yep. First got named in the 'Vivre Card' One Piece Visual Dictionary.
@@TrueZero2 lol it’s kinda fitting bc his devil fruit is garbage compared most
From what I can tell, the walls around what Law "cuts" are linked, so blood, nerve impulses, whatever don't spill out but instead teleport seamlessly to where they're supposed to go.
Jack, Kin'emon has the power to make clothes basically out of nowhere. That is VERY useful for stealth
He would be perfect in a combo with Bon Clay.
which we literally see in the future
Fascinating, surely that will never be relevant in the future.....
Who ever called Smoker heartless... Well he is now 😂
I want Jack to catch up so he can do a Laugh tier list
Shirorororororo
Yohohohohoho
Behehehehehehehe
Zehahahahaha
Law's devil fruit allows him to manipulate anything in his room, but at the same time- he can't cut any harm his patients, therefor the parts just stay separated, just like the heart, its still functioning but its separated. Its kind of like a portal between the blood vessels
Also, the Garb Garb fruit (the disguise, clothes one) is very useful for stealth and espionage, and survivability. It will be REALLY useful in the future.
Can't wait for you to see Law's backstory in the next arc and JOKER, you're now getting to the arc that starts all the hype till the current arc!
It was only recently I realized the “Punk” in Punk Hazard comes from Vegapunk. Seems sort of obvious in retrospect but I needed other info to notice
i thought i would hate Caesar's laugh as they say but it's one of my favorites. it's both funny and evil at the same time.
22:00 - The Wano Kingdom generally has no knowledge on the terminology for Devil Fruits so they see it as magic. The samurai's Devil Fruit may seem useless but think of the disguises you can make for espionage so it has its potential.
5:39 just wait till he meets me goat Bruce D Wayne
Sanji in Nami's body is one of the most iconic funniest moments in the One Piece history.
Just so you know “joker” gets the nickname from the card
TO be fair Jack, I've been caught up for probably two years now. I've never made the connection with Choppers Kung-fu point either. I've never seen it mentioned before either and I watch a lot of OP YTs/streamers.
you both are just dull .
Yeah nah, I somehow don't think that's the case 🤷♂DO you even know what dull means? you sound dull by every definition.😂@@juanramonsolizvillarroel9308
It's so weird seeing Smoker with a polite facial expression without a cigar.
I think having “useless” devil fruits kind of adds to the world building. Of course you get some sort of power to eating one, but then it becomes a dice roll as to its utility and importance in the world. Just like how Blackbeard bided his time until coming across the Dark-Dark Fruit.
Jack catching the information discrepancy with wano is very intuitive
Law is my 3 most favourite character and he's backstory (Cora also 🗿)
Whoever was caesar clown again? I only know gangster gastino 😎
Hahhahaha this. 😂
Caesar Clown is a reference to Caesar Romero, the first actor for the Joker, so that other person being called that is another piece.
Can't wait for law/chopper combo
Someone asked in SBS wether Tashigi always goes with no bra and Oda answered that Smoker took them off after they swapped.
Fun fact: the real reason choppers kung-fu boost look like that cause of a little funny notice to kung-fu panda
Smoker's body can move without his heart just like how the samurai can move without his torso. It's just how Law's DF works.
0:04 I am caught up to the manga and still I didnt know that lol
The bu sound Kin's legs made while talking was the onomatopoeia for a fart or a wind escaping... in the manga it made more sense since sounds are actually usually written down...
Where's the guy who kept asking for Jack's Moria cosplay? We need Jack to do 'Master' or Crocodile cosplay next.
6:33
Oh come on what are you guys, Babies?🗿
0.001 seconds later.
Oops 💀
"He just spawned clothes.. out of Rocks! Explain this devil fruit!" 😂💯
14:55 Expect the Unexpected GODA knows 🤭
people are mostly fine without their heart if law takes it, it still acts as if its connected but it makes them super vulnerable having their literaly heart in someones hand where the could kill them at any time. its a pretty good way to make someone a hostage
To help out, Caesar Clown is exclusively referred to as "The Master". If you hear anyone saying boss, captian or whatever, they are referring to a different character.
Kinemon's Devil Fruit is one of the weirdest powers out there. It is only useful for survival or to make the person look good or especially for camouflage. This power of his is very quickly forgotten!
I mean he uses it pretty regularly whenever it would matter, punk hazard, dressrosa, wano he uses it at some point in all 3 main arcs he's in. only one i cant remember him using it in is zou.
Even if you make it this far and don't understand Law's ability to disconnect things, it becomes crystal clear very soon when someone's heart gets squeezed and the rest of their body feels the pain.
Bro is dogging on the Garb-Garb fruit. 😂
6:25 that was ruthless jack what xD
"Come on what are you guys babies......wait"
@@ajorozco671 xD
You could say that Law stole Smoker's heart
Using leaves and rocks to make clothes is like tanuki magic.
Basically think of Kin'emon's power as like Piccolo's Clothes Beam.
"We got Batman in here?"
Meanwhile in Wano: 🦇
How are you surprised that smoker can live without his heart that was taken by law, and then don't been surprised with samuria guy been cut in 3 by law, is like the same.
Smoker is simply cool, One of my favorito marines, he’s strong, he’s ready to fight devil fruits users, he deserves much more 😢
I always liked this fight!
Smokers body can function without its heart the same way the samurai’s torso can func ion without ists head. It’s like Buggy’s power, but done to other people
Japanese lore lessons... Tanukis(racoons), as magical beings not just the regular animal, are able to disguise themeselves by putting a leaf. twig or rock on their head and using their magic... so that is what Kin'emon can do with his fruit...
Actually Brook can feel everything just like a normal human. Thats why he can eat and pass gas etc. Just imagine he has an invisible outer body
it's not about her being without heart,the heart could function while separated thats Law's ability similar with the samurai is parts could walk and fight without his head similar scenario
19:35 😂
I feel sorry for tsuru😂😂 15:50
Law is basically Batman
The short version is that Wano is a very isolated kingdom. Due in large part to its own policies as well as just being terribly difficult to get to.
No heard makes so sense. Samurai has been taking when his head was a jigsaw puzzle
Franky inside of Chopper's body is some what unsettling. I'm so used to the sweet voice of Chopper and lets not forget that Nami is inside of Franky's body now. She must really be freaking out now. No wonder the Kids are some what confused as well.
1:09 last names always come first in Japanese
Not aways, only when it's called full name, i guess. otherwise people would call Luffy by "Monkey" the whole anime. I guess that's why Jack pointed that out
Ok 3 things:
1. Jack we know you're not quitting One Piece (though i'm surprised everyone is NOT commenting about this, when he said he was sick of Sanji the comment section was filled, and at that point we all were, but it comes back around/that feeling doesn't last... fully, we know it, just be patient).
2. Saying Kinne'mon's devil fruit is useless is a bit of a stretch, yes it has no battle capabilities, but not every fruit needs one, honestly (and i know i might draw the ire of some) Spring-Spring is much worse, if you had to eat a devil fruit, this one is not so bad.
3. Jack: "Franky just kinda fits with Chopper"... He's gonna regret that (i know Jack doesn't read these so i don't mind putting a spoiler here... Plus i talked so much the comment will probably be folded anyway), not only does Robin disagree, but the disrespect... Only as a last resort means you CAN'T handle it, seriously you were there back in Enies Lobby, darn ya Franky.
Cesar's powers are insane. Like really. Talk about overpowered. We'll discuss at a later date. 😆
I wonder if Chopper can transform into different body types of humans like long arm, long leg etc.
“I think I have to drop One Piece” is like a universal Punk Hazard moment lol
Agreed
You know, maybe Sanji would be happier as a woman
Like… Ivankov could probably do it if he asked
I feel like Sanji would be fucking thrilled honestly
Besides him being upset about losing his penis, I honestly don't think Sanji would be too different. He'd just be a lesbian. A lesbian that really likes her own breasts...
U have to remember everything 😂
Remember that sentence Lax told to Tashigi
They really stretch the concept of Law performing “miracle surgeries” lol
2:15 I thought it was po from kung fu panda
How can you dare to roast that disguise devil fruit XD
but it is so damn Funny that law also switched tahsigis and smokers heart XD
funfact: frieeza, cheesar and mayuri from bleach has same VA
yo the first 49 seconds uploaded!!!!!!!!!!
Shororororo, shororororo, best laugh!!
Things about go nuts bro! Do 3eps (Recommended from now on 😂😂)
When he reaches Roof Piece, he gets brain damage from it
You're not ready for it yet🤣
I think Tashigi is often too emotional to be a good marine. From the grudge she holds against Zoro to just attacking Law without thinking.
Some could say, Smoker didnt have the heart to end the fight
Chopper Kung Fu point is obviously inspired by Kung Fu Panda
Kinemon's fruit is actually good case he is a strong swordsmans he doesn't need an op fruit, it's good for situations, bon clay is like useless in fighting but useful in other ways and bon clay is good at fighting. Depends on how the user use it
mostly likely in the next arcs
It'll all make sense in about 300-400 episodes. dont worry.
I always thought it was because he was in his most muscular form. Like boas lets say round sister is 100% muscle. So chopper being a smol round boy is similar.
Kinemon df is OP for infiltrating the Death Star
I believe that Chambres in French means room temperature.
Dude is so hung up on Smoker not having a heart when this whole time we have a chopped off head... Wtf bro
Oh joker name drop. Finally this shit is getting exciting. Gonna love this saga.
"Law vs. Smoker was straight GAS" I see what you did there.
Don't discount the Garb-Garb fruit! Sure, its very useful in direct combat, but could you imagine the versitility of being able to summon whatever clothes you wanted at any time for FREE irl? And its perfect if you're a spy of some kind, almost as powerful as Door-Door.
Imagine the money you can save on new clothes. You don't even need to wash them!
Hmmmm I had never made that connection with chopper's kung fu point. What if his human fruit lets him turn into any type of human? Could he turn into a fishman? A long arm? Or any of the future races we will see?
Funny enough, there is a character named Batman in OP lol
Wait until you met gangsta gastino :)
Woww so much happen in here 😂
The op op fruit consumes your stamina fast with the bigger the room and the more you do in it will cause it to drain faster that’s the downside of laws fruit
Why is the Op-Op Fruit the only Devil Fruit that runs on stamina? I mean, technically Luffy's Gears, but even then that's more of an issue with his rubber body.
@@Nightlingbolt they all do it’s just different devil fruits drain more or less and most characters have insane levels of stamina
@@Nightlingbolt mainly because he would literally be undefeatable in battle, nothing would work against him because the Op op fruit is like 7 fruits in one.
@@Nightlingboltbecause Oda had to nerf Law or else it would be top easy
He said PH, i thought the hub instead of punk hazard💀💀💀💀.
law switched their souls. so he doesn't need his heart. his heart is still beating at least.
Jack acting as if he would be ANY different in Sanji's situation, shut the front door bro we know you just as degen as Sanji.
why did i think Jack already knew Caesar?
So a samurai can be cut into pieces and still be alive but smoker/tashigi can't be alive without his heart? interesting
he's really caught up on smoker not having a heart. All the people who have had their heads cut off by law is perfectly fine though
damn i never knew that about kung fu point wow
Ceasar clown is a new character
Kinemon can move without his entire torso. Why shouldn't Smokers body be able to move without the heart?