It's ridiculous how good this is. This was several seasons ago, still one of my absolute favourite performance in the voice. Her singing and her voice is just wow. What's incredible is the genre she sings is something that so many has done especially coming to a competition like this, she really stood out. There may be many great singers and if I'm being frank she could be more seasoned, and yet I like it just the way it is. There's such a vulnerability in the way she brings the song that's just so fitting to the lyrics, and I think that's really all that matters. I think it's a 10. I can't believe that even during those season she didn't became more famous for this rendition of the song. I guess people really don't pay much attention unless something is really "different" and "unique". Whatever that means. I think it defeats the purpose if you're trying to be different for the sake of it. What I really like about her is she isn't trying hard to make it her own, the arrangement of the music is still more or less the same, she sings it the way we are familiar with how the original did it, but just singing it from her own experience , it's made it her own.
She's one of my few absolute favourite from across the seasons. It's been more than a year now and I've been coming back to watch some of her performance again and again. Personally I find her voice very soothing and I think of all the songs I've heard her sang this song fits her voice best, maybe there are better canton songs but I don't understand that dialect so I wouldn't be able to fully appreciate them. That being said, I've always felt that her singing lack something. It always feels like she has so much more potential. I appreciate singers who can sing really slow songs, and it really suits her, but to me it still sounded a little deliberate. You can almost feel her effort to sing the song well. If she was able to make the listener feel like she sang effortlessly it would've been perfect for me.
![[HD] 中国好声音 第二季第一期 2013/07/12 完整版 The Voice of China](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/xki3XnQFIVM/mqdefault.jpg)
![[HD] 中国好声音 第二季第一期 2013/07/12 完整版 The Voice of China](/img/tr.png)
2021年又再看 Gin Lee 揮手~
2021看完聲夢GIN LEE，再來這裏搜尋GIN LEE
十八
早干林良土。立土。及
2024
其實九年前她黎到香港，就已經唱得好好
可惜，就係紅唔起黎，才要再參加歌唱比賽
好興幸今晚可以聽到佢紅館上的聲音
啱吖
係香港有實力紅唔起唔係咩新鮮事, 响大陸反而有實力先係皇道
@@KennyCha87 系大陆都好多冇实力但好红的吧，比如杨超越😂
11年前香港樂壇已死，仲嚟香港做咩，選擇錯左戰場，幾叻都無人睇到。
@@hang6164 當然, 度度都係, 不過實情哩我覺得無實力紅得起唔係重點, 有好多人追星係鐘意偶像only
有實力都極難紅得起先係問題, 相對地, 係大6/ 歐美, 有實力真係點都易撈過香港
Gin Lee 根本不需參加比賽，
可以直接出道樂壇！……😀👍🎶🎵💕❤
( 2024.3.16 )
Gin Lee本身很有實力啦，在香港樂壇現在總算有點成績，最近與學友合唱的歌也很樂聽💪🏻💪🏻💪🏻💪🏻加油呀☺️
別人不懂你，不代表你不好，只是他們未知道💪🏻💪🏻💪🏻💪🏻
對
超鐘意你
她在这里明显保留了实力，她要是直接来首superwoman，估计早就4转了
其實她聲音很一般。不過香港現在沒有甚麼好歌手。那個什么JW和泳兒比她更差，不是走音就是唱不上去。
一個堅强女孩,歌唱得很好.
因為是職業歌手，整個表演很完整，百聽不膩。沒有一般素人參賽者設計好的爆點，卻令人更回味和深刻，更加耐聽。
美麗兩顆星星片片失去額客艙下俄色彩
女子凱好康ㄐ_ㄎ
空氣褲裙可衣
送你一朵花禮物李幸倪
她的唱功絕對是一流頂級，使我循環再聽，天后級Gin Lin 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏💪💪💪💪💪✌️✌️✌️✌️✌️
絕對天後級唱功，生不逢時，香港樂壇已經不如以前輝煌。
我覺得她唱的好好哦... 真的很心痛。那種心痛不是要大喊大叫要全世界的人都知道的那種，而是痛到無力的那種，在她唱的時候真的會很心痛她... :( Thumbs up!!!
AdeleChristine 推荐你去听她的粤语歌，尤其这首中国风的-月球下的人ruclips.net/video/W73UOP-SVfo/видео.html
她现在是香港歌坛未来天后
我有聽過，很好聽。。。還聽說這首歌一直在香港的麥當當一直狂播。。。哈哈哈
AdeleChristine
☁😘😘☁😘😘☁
😘😘😘😘😘😘😘
😘😘😘😘😘😘😘
☁😘😘😘😘😘☁
☁☁😘😘😘☁☁
☁☁☁😘☁☁☁
有經過感情的歷練
心噏
2019 依然在听的来点个赞
其中这种才叫厉害，实力派歌手
好听的歌不是靠大喊大叫，而是感动了自己也感动了大家，然后听不腻
2020+1
她後來加入周杰倫戰隊還殺到前幾強，蠻厲害的！
现在在香港大红大紫了，最近还和歌神合唱，在tvb做声梦传奇做导师，拿了五台冠军
她的嗓音太好听了，高音完全没有那种很噪音的感觉
好厲害
能唱出心痛的感覺
個人的感覺，在座的評審，我想沒有一個能唱的比她好聽，超越原唱了👍
心痛的「痛」如果真的唱上去就失了質感。就是因為她沒沖上去，突然縮了，我才真的心痛了。揪心啊
其實她真的唱得很好聽，感情到位，聲音好聽，尾音又收得好
在坐幾位也沒有達到gin的層次,純粹只是比她早出道,何來資格評論她。
連張學友都說不認為自己唱得好到可以評論他人唱歌技巧,更何況其他唱歌咬字不清,抖氣聲勁大既歌手
因為 李幸倪 我才愛上這首歌
Gin Lee現在是很強的導師了❤️❤️❤️
Gin Lee同張暘合唱既紅塵客棧，我認為係好聲音十佳之一
感情比拉高音更来得考功夫啊！ 李辛倪能唱到这样已经很好了啊！
唱的太好了，唱进心里了，而且气息很稳，情感充沛，好好听～
李幸倪是实力派的优秀歌手，唱功一流，好听到不行，根本不需要来参加这个综艺节目!
李幸倪和王菲、林憶莲、张惠妹是同一个等级的实力派的优秀歌手!
褲裙狐球啟示 我不愛你不行的 要如何去講
不管在哪裡我都需要 天真的愛情枱
你會走去哪裡觸法
持股信心不問題
很感動人心，很有感情的唱功，太棒，支持李幸倪✌️✌️✌️✌️💪💪💪💪💪💪
太好聽，聽到全身毛孔竖起來👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍
認同
好有層次感的優秀歌手。層層遞增, 做得相當好, 是
高低音turn得咁靚
唔係嗌先叫有感情囖
同意
Min Yung 贊同
最憎啲人剩係嗌，聽到勁吵耳
@@taitaitai1227 GEm
@@kinderlee1987 明明是大吵大鬧，卻叫巨肺
2021還在聽💔真的非常讓人感動😭
有一種很心動撕裂的感覺👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽
其实她有了一定的颜值~歌声是有特色~气肺量也足~自个的歌曲传唱度也不差~就只是人缘之际。。该红的年纪也过了~写作灵感不多~少了天时地利人和帮助下而不能大红 !
她的歌唱得很好，希望她能出名
整首歌处理得相当干净，感情堆叠的层次感也很明确… 我赞同周杰伦说的那一个“痛”字如果能直接飙上去，那就不会显得那段音乐落下以后的空虚感，反而更能让人感到因为心痛的一次呐喊，再来就是那种心力交瘁的落寞…但是我依然很喜欢这个版本，李幸倪的含蓄其实在这首歌反而让它增添味道了…好听！
我是很理解那个”痛“字后断开的感觉，没有澎湃，只有断肠，已经痛得没法发出声音。
真正的超越原唱！直击人心！好声音这个舞台最让人难忘的歌之一。
原唱是實力派陳潔儀，沒可能超過，叮噹馬頭吧
@@paulluk7515原唱不太好聽😅.... 我也是因為她 才喜歡這首歌
Gin lee才是百年一遇的天才。
永遠支持Gin Lee😍😍永不放棄❤️堅持精神令我欽佩💓💓💓💓
我本沒有聽過原唱唱這首歌 後來跑去聽原唱 相較之下我真的覺得這個版本最好聽也真的讓人很心痛的感覺 充滿感情 是有畫面的😢
舞台唱歌跟在錄音室可以發揮的點太多了，這哪能比較．．．
@@viviancoolya我還是喜歡這個版本啊😂 有真的心痛的感覺
我的意思是原唱陳潔儀如果上這種舞台，也可以唱出心痛的感覺．．．
@@viviancoolya 重點是我沒聽過
這就是完美得無可挑剔.
再看這群評判的反應好可怕。
2021年仲係會返嚟聽呢首令我愛上Gin Lee嘅作品💗成世人聽過最好聽嘅live concert就係Gin Lee!!😈
她在香港很出名，有自己出歌，「雙雙」
@Fu-Shing Chiu只不過係你井底之蛙
@Fu-Shing Chiu 都說了很有名了看不懂字嗎？
她不少歌在RUclips 都過百萬點
沒有半首成名曲，
半輩子只活在流行K歌的世界
@@NameNo-ep2ld 她就是坚持不出k歌口水歌才至今没有一首大爆的歌好不好，你去听她出的所有专辑的歌哪个是芭乐歌?所以传唱度才不广，变相让人觉得至今没有自己的代表作
離晒譜唱得咁好竟然最後一秒才轉身
因为导演在后面一直叫他们hold住hold住，最后才叫他们action😂😂
@@nz710 我覺得也是.... 而且為何得兩人轉....
故作緊張气氛🤭
記得黃霄雲在好聲音那時也沒很紅
但我就相信她可以！！紅！
結果近年來她真的變得紅紅紅
所以我也相信幸倪就也只是差個運氣而已
希望幸倪加油，我支持你❤️
她现在就已经是职业歌手了，在香港是有地位的
上次学友也讲过这问题，说好声音都是大喊大叫的风格。看来学友不上好声音是个明智的选择。
Michael O 只是價錢出得未夠吧了👽
@@wingwinglam3124 學友邊洗仲諗錢。佢係當今華語樂壇有邊個可以比得上
@@wingwinglam3124 你認為錢不夠、是問題吗？你認為何人可做他老師。
Michael O z
Chiwing Lam 痾 人家是指請他來當導師吧 別為了護航而護航吧
好倩情的作品。不用追究出處，Gin沒有辜負長輩的培植。繼續努力！ 互勉！
對歌情的詮譯很道位，這才是實力派
我第一句就轉身了，哈哈哈
No super high notes, no super vocal, but sing your heart out of the song with your feelings. You’ve made me cry. Well done, bravo.
Gin Lee唱歌好好聽 正到爆😍
一進副歌我眼淚就流出來了....
It's ridiculous how good this is. This was several seasons ago, still one of my absolute favourite performance in the voice. Her singing and her voice is just wow. What's incredible is the genre she sings is something that so many has done especially coming to a competition like this, she really stood out. There may be many great singers and if I'm being frank she could be more seasoned, and yet I like it just the way it is. There's such a vulnerability in the way she brings the song that's just so fitting to the lyrics, and I think that's really all that matters. I think it's a 10. I can't believe that even during those season she didn't became more famous for this rendition of the song.
I guess people really don't pay much attention unless something is really "different" and "unique". Whatever that means. I think it defeats the purpose if you're trying to be different for the sake of it. What I really like about her is she isn't trying hard to make it her own, the arrangement of the music is still more or less the same, she sings it the way we are familiar with how the original did it, but just singing it from her own experience , it's made it her own.
Voice is angelic, quite rare because everyone wants outstanding
She's one of my few absolute favourite from across the seasons. It's been more than a year now and I've been coming back to watch some of her performance again and again. Personally I find her voice very soothing and I think of all the songs I've heard her sang this song fits her voice best, maybe there are better canton songs but I don't understand that dialect so I wouldn't be able to fully appreciate them.
That being said, I've always felt that her singing lack something. It always feels like she has so much more potential. I appreciate singers who can sing really slow songs, and it really suits her, but to me it still sounded a little deliberate. You can almost feel her effort to sing the song well.
If she was able to make the listener feel like she sang effortlessly it would've been perfect for me.
以她的实力，早就到了根本不屑去拼高音的唱法，一个真正的歌手是应该用唱技去服务歌曲所传递的情感，什么歌都飙高音那是炫技。。如果Gin真的是在比赛，炫技去飙高音（很明显她可以），她可以拿四转；也不用太批判导师，在这种情况下，他们确实希望能尽量通过一首歌了解尽量多的技巧和可塑性部分。 可是对于真正好的歌手，这些和真正把歌的情绪的传达，很明显应该尊重后者。。。我觉得她真正好的部分就是高潮的时候用假音去处理，反倒让人听的揪心的疼。。
唱得很好聽，我真有1種心痛感覺，哭了
Gin Lee 好靚女🥰🥰
其实哈林一句话就总结出审美的分别，马来西亚的朋友总是比较内敛，意思其实就是让你飙高音秀技巧在这个舞台上才有惊艳，说白了没几个是真的静下心来听
唱得很棒，但在我心目中陳潔儀才是這首歌的最佳詮釋者
中國好聲音欠她一個機會，唱的很好。她現在在tvb做聲夢傳奇導師，有點大才小用。
李幸倪的歌曲很好聽
I like her voice. She sang really well in this competition!
聽著聽著竟然就流淚了....
人美歌更美，聽到我心都碎了
其实她真的不需要你们帮，只是她没你们出名而已。
minia Gao 對 ...Gin Lee 唱功不會比那英差
不是只是靠唱功。历练很重要
饺子，发声很有自己的味道，到这里来实际有点贬低她了
poolfans 不，我認為那英的唱法不符合流行趨勢
別鬧惹，李她都說欠缺伯樂
有實力者不一定成名
尤其是現在百家爭鳴更需要這些樂壇前輩幫忙
Year 2021, I still think she is the best one who covered this song. Bravo!
Gin Lee 永遠支持你❤❤
品味之選 ， 沒品味過半世紀作不出這樣的歌，唱不出這樣的情懷
In no doubt she the best singer in hong kong. She is the only female singer worth to pay to support listen live and and buy her music
好好聽，感動，支持！
2020年还在听，还是很耐听。
打動人心嘅表演 聽聽下不自覺流淚👍🏽尤其3:02-3:06呢句
看见你真的心疼......😪😢😌
就是妳制造月亮惹的祸！恨妳！还黄鼠狼给鸡拜年假慈悲？！我very very后悔不顾大众。。。去认识妳！下辈子千万千万不要再遇见了。。。
下辈子惹不起还躲不起？躲！
I not know what the words mean, but the voice of an angel to my ears. Well done angel, goodluck on your life's journey.
好好聽..
痴線好听，竟然那麼晚才有老師轉身
四個蛋散，真係唱得好好
真的是4個蛋散
Emo 想听歌，突然翻到点来听，哇～直接流泪。。真的是心痛的感觉😢😢
聽到眼眶有淚，真正實力唱將👍
天籁之音
Proud of you Gin Lee
都係雙雙好聽
我覺得唱歌唱得好要有感情，高音不代表特別會唱，再多這 就是超過100分的心痛
超级好听咯！心都痛了
妳唱别人成名的歌～我才知妳才是神级(月半小夜曲)
GIN LEE very good
超好聽，怎麼會不紅
黑幕節目 好彩樓主po 如果唔係大家就忘記gin Lee實力幾好
Wow, what a voice 👏🏽 she is a star 🌟
好聽就好了，評論什麼唱功，演唱者想怎麼唱就是自我的發揮詮釋。
这种歌曲比唱高音的歌曲难太多了吧！李佩玲的情有独钟也是属于这类型的
Gin Lee sings so well at this song.
Yes, and All Judges can't sing like her ~~
輕音不抖，氣順，淒美
❤️好喜歡你的歌聲 好美 、甜又不膩舒服的想一直一直聽～～～
在我大学时期，她，曾经唱这首歌给我听，现在会议，真的心痛
一聽就迷上了這節奏，超贊👍👏超棒💃🕺
Gin Lee唱歌真係好掂好正！人靚歌甜！耳朵懷孕！！
Gin Lee 坐落去做評判就差唔多～～～
佢而家做左聲夢導師！！
佢同幾位評判差太遠
@@kelvinchan1110k 做埋d垃圾節目評判浪費時間
冇計，佢唱片公司要佢去，佢邊有得say no?!
她聲音真的很一般，沒有特色，唱了也不知道是她
真的好聲音....👍
真的好好聽啊
終於看到了啦~之前被好聲音CUT掉,沒得看~~
mi
李幸倪很漂亮
馬來西亞的人都好會唱
為什麼她這麼好但都紅不起來⋯好可惜！
听了眼涙鼻塞完全不能控制自动流
接捧Gem的下一代粵語歌手
周杰倫說得沒錯，這的確是差了這一點點，其他方面都表現得非常好。中高音的質量都很高，A4~C5都不錯。
唱得非常好👍🏼