Immolation was usually a punishment reserved for crimes related to heresy in the west, not witchcraft. Most suspected witches were hanged. The mindset was that (at least partially) the length of the punishment compared to others would allow for the condemned to repent before death.
@@user-op8fg3ny3j eh, there’s a lot of places in Europe (+ Japan) that are significantly more humane and have far fewer human rights abuses that also have lower crime rates
Fun Fact: imprisonment is a medieval punishment made by Muslims as we know it today at the Islamic golden age. it STILL EXIST Today! it's a very inefficient punishment since it just isolate you from the civilized capitalistic society and connects you to the criminal communist society, they survive by spending our tax money, like parasites. and they get out the prison to be a worse criminal, as people are the summation of the most people they spends time with, which is in this case, CRIMINALS. it also can be a blessing for some people. they don't need to work, and still have bed, toilet, food, friends, hobbies. IMPRISONMENT IS BY FAR THE MOST INAFFICIENT PUNISHMENT SINCE THERE IS NO PUNISHMENT. I Think Flogging is much better than that time wasting thing. it's superior by far, since it's fast and make the criminal regrets his actions and think twice before doing something illegal. also, the skin heals so fast also with the help of doctors.
As a Singaporean, I can tell you that canning is still used as a punishment but it is not as brutal as it is said to be and is only a sentence for crimes that involved invading someone's personal space such as molesting. For small crimes such as theft will be punished with a fine, a few months jail sentence or community service. When canning is carried out, the justice system will allow you to heal your wound for a month or two before delivering the next stroke or next few strokes, Singapore's justice system is strict not cruel
Fun Fact: imprisonment is a medieval punishment made by Muslims as we know it today at the Islamic golden age. it STILL EXIST Today! it's a very inefficient punishment since it just isolate you from the civilized capitalistic society and connects you to the criminal communist society, they survive by spending our tax money, like parasites. and they get out the prison to be a worse criminal, as people are the summation of the most people they spends time with, which is in this case, CRIMINALS. it also can be a blessing for some people. they don't need to work, and still have bed, toilet, food, friends, hobbies. IMPRISONMENT IS BY FAR THE MOST INAFFICIENT PUNISHMENT SINCE THERE IS NO PUNISHMENT. I Think Flogging is much better than that time wasting thing. it's superior by far, since it's fast and make the criminal regrets his actions and think twice before doing something illegal. also, the skin heals so fast also with the help of doctors.
At 05:13, I think that's a mistake. The condemned person is wearing attire that was usually given to him or her after he/she recanted their heretic beliefs and were spared. *Strangling* was usually an option after the condemned person had recanted but was still going to be executed. Being strangled took only a few seconds *if* the executioner was skilled.
@@Account_abandoned-q7m From Merriam-Webster: heretic noun her·e·tic ˈher-ə-ˌtik ˈhe-rə- Synonyms of heretic 1 religion : a person who differs in opinion from established religious dogma (see DOGMA sense 2) especially : a baptized member of the Roman Catholic Church who refuses to acknowledge or accept a revealed truth The church regards them as heretics. 2 : one who differs in opinion from an accepted belief or doctrine : NONCONFORMIST
Chemical castration, despite the name, doesn’t actually involve losing any body parts. Rather it means taking pills that prevents said parts from operating naturally. This variation is usually reversible. I’m surprised this video didn’t mention the use of eunuchs in the Ottoman and Chinese Empires to produce civil servants and royal courtiers who had no ability to form their own dynasties and thus theoretically would be loyal to the ruler. Of course, in practice these eunuchs still often amassed power for themselves even with nobody to pass it down to.
Alan Turning, the genius computer scientist who broke the German enigma code in WW2 was discovered to be homosexual. He was chemically castrated and died of complications. Remember his name.
4:40 I'm Paraguayan and I remembered this very clearly as a kid, It's just one example of the suffering people had to go through when protesting. It's not so common nowadays.
@@Ashraf-Hrira The “East” has far higher crime rates and corruption then the West (if we define the West as the United States and Europe plus Australia, Japan, and South Korea) What exactly would the West have to gain from such a primitive practice when their countries are incredibly safe for the most part?
Because it's not in religion There's two kinds of punishments in Islam disciplinary punishment and death punishment Torturing isn't allowed or doing anything that isn't in the rules of punishments in Islam
Saudi Arabia still practice all of this, probably the reason why crime rate in that country are so low compared to the USA. People in Saudi leave their shops, stalls and businesses when they hear call of prayer and nobody steal anything. Can you leave anything valuable on the roadside in America and expect nobody to steal it?
The crime rate in Japan, Australia & Norway is far lower than that of Saudi Arabia, without having the need to enforce any of those types of punishments. Also, in Saudi Arabia, there's simply no free media, so there's no way of knowing if such crimes are taking place. Furthermore, in medieval times, crime rates were even higher, even with those types of punishments in effect. This shows, there's absolutely no correlation between the two. Plus, countries like Sudan, Yemen, Somalia and others such, also have have those types of punishments and yet has one of the highest crime rates in the World. Why do you think, that is? It's because Sudan, Yemen, Somalia and other such countries have political instability, poverty, turmoil and other such challenges, which is why the crime rates are high. No matter, what punishment you implement, it has little to no effect on the overall crime rate in the country. It has more to do with the stability, welfare, well being and other such qualities, in a particular country. You have an answer for all of that, as well?
@@SpaceReptilioidNorway has only a population of 5 million, of which 1 million live in the urban area of Oslo. so Norway has a very very low population density. It is also one of the richest countries. Saudi‘s capital has a bigger population than the entirety of Norway. Btw, in 2011 one of the most deadliest mass shootings in global history (~4th place) happened in Norway. In Japan the laws are very very strict and they have other harsh punishments. The police is also regularly committing police brutality to get people to confess their crime. Furthermore, Japanese culture very honor based and someone would rather kill himself than kill someone else. Shunning people who are different is also commonly done which forces people to fall in line. Btw, crimes against politicians are higher in Japan than in any western country. 2nd btw, the crimes committed in Japan are unbelievably gruesome and gross, one example: the murder of Junko Furuta.
Well if you don't register any crime, then obviously crime rates will be low. How about japan, sweden and some other European countries. They have even lower crime rates than the made up crime rates of saudi Arabia. Imagine getting hanged for saying that the earth is not flat as it is written in koran.
Pellet guns are used in Kashmir as a non lethal weapon. Most times it's used on the center of the body but when fired from long range or when it missed it's supposed target then the pellets can hit all around the body including head and legs just like a bird shot from a shotgun.
My friend was martyred by the indian soldiers, they shot a whole cansister to his head. Most of the injuries led to people losing their eyesight forever, the youngest being a 3 month old child
I dont know. Having my my head quickly taken off sounds A LOT more humane of execusion than its given credit for. There are theories that you may be conscious when your head rolls, but that can very easily be rapid eye movement and nerves twitching. I'd take that over lethal injection or God forbidding, life in prison, where you're going to suffer a harsh and hopeless life so you may suffer a the hand of justice. I watched a few videos of inmates that would rather face a firing squad than continue to rot away in a jail cell.
Life in prison is just slavery but with taxpayers' money. Also, slitting the throat to just enough to where you don't sever the spinal cord is the most humane way to kill anything. oxygen stops flowing to the brain, you lose consciousness, and you lose all senses without even feeling the blade if it's sharp enough.
Lethal injection is by far the best. Are you drunk? You get an injection that makes you sleep. Then another one that stops your breathing. That vs severe trauma to your head? Remind me to never listen to anything else you ever say.
Here’s one of them, forcing you to confess to something you didn’t do, we still have this happen all the time during court hearings only difference being we don’t torture you instead just giving a longer sentence if found guilty
yep... here in Australia we got a new one... if a convicted killer does not confess where the body is, they will never be released on parole. Anyone with a tiny shred of intelligence (which no one has in Australia anymore) can see this law rewarding real killers and punishing the innocent... since obviously the innocent cannot know where the body is. It comes down to the very very arrogant assumption that a person 'IS' guilty of murder with absolute certainty if convicted of murder.... this goes well beyond convicting a person based on 'beyond reasonable doubt'
@@mystikmind2005 Very nice. It's not the first Australian law that made me raise my eyebrows, and unfortunately probably not the last. But your reasoning is excellent and it's nice to see someone with a common sense, because oh boy, is it getting rare...
@@thatayrellguy3023Nobody cares about the crime rate, because public crime rate statistics are about as useful as an IGN review. It’s still morally and psychologically backwards, and says a lot about how a country is governed and controlled. I’m sure the average Saudi citizen is fine, but the people that enforce and employ that kind of barbarism are sad, lowly people, who just want a reason to justify brutality through zealotry. Period.
@@K12machinima "nobody cares abput crime rate" bruh mate wtf? And even if its backward. If it work than its good. Simple as that. Dont want to receive those punishment? Dont be an idiot in the first place
@@silverhawkscape2677 why the un? The only thing simple history showed in the video that is endorsed in countries with high human rights is the chemical castration at the end of the video. The other stuff was in country where human rights don't exist because religion
"Human right dont exist because of relligion" If you really know Islam, then should know -> Mother are valued highly as they are the one who sacrifice their life and bring you to this world. -> Parents are responsible by relligion to take care of their children, as they are responsible from bringing their children to this world. -> If a muslim is the majority in the area, they must protect the non-muslim from outside threat, this include letting them to pray on their own belief. -> Peoples with wealth are endorsed to help out the poor. -> Killing others are probihited. -> Leader muct act for whats the best of the peoples. -> Stealing and corruption are greatly probihited, as it makes lots of people suffers. -> At wartime, they are not allowed to kill Children, woman, old peoples, animal (except for eating) or the people that run away, they have to treat PoW with respect and ot enforcing Islam to them, they are also not allowed to destroy buildings, including temples and Church. -> If non Muslim ask for protection and they didn't threat the Muslim, then the muslim are obliged to protect them (Like Salladin who escorted his enemy family to safety, even though the enemy can't fulfill his promise to escape the town and was ordered to defense it agains Salladin troop) If you find they are saying they are "Islam" yet they didnt do all that, chances are their knowledge of their own relligion is quote shallow, think of it like school, there are students who will always says they arevfrom that school, yet their behavior dont reflect the school policy.
Beheading is the easiest way to die than the other punishments, Imagine being tortured by black hearted people who are done with their lives putting all their misery on you
as a singaporean i can say many people mistake flogging. We flog in private out of view inside a cell. our maximum number of strokes is 24 but with a thicker cane than those used in others. in singapore we use it with small number of strokes for vandalism, and more up to 24 strokes for serious crimes like drug trafficking and other capital offences where no death penalty(hanging) is given
@@gt4969 it’s not about modern ways. It’s about whether a way works or not. Things like technology and economy yes. But laws, if old laws work in keeping a country safe then it shall stay. Modernising laws can be progressing to failure.
You forgot the most acient one: Penal labor. By putting convicts to work on physical goverment projects, such as mining, maintainance, manufacture, farming, and other forms of labor, convicts will be put to works in order to produce cheap goods for the state or a company affiliated to the prison. Depending on the state, they could get payed way below the minimun wage salary which could be claimed once they were realesed or if you got permition, send it to a familiy member or friend, but some don´t pay them at all. It is almost institucional slavery, but usually you get the choice to accept the job, and your human rights are still in place except for the rights that the state provide to you since you are temporaly or indifenetly no longer a civilian. It is a very common practice to use penal labor for a state to mine the neccesary materials to get concrete with minimal tools.
I've done time a few times. I've done it as a max custody inmate (really sucks) and I've been put on work crews and of course general population. My time flew by when they had me working and some of the work was brutal. But mc is way more difficult. GP is the easiest but the days/weeks/years go by so slow. I don't know if working is better for everyone, but I didn't get into trouble and sent to MC . And the many months just flew by. Slavery? I don't think so. But everyone has to make everything about race. And I Ain't White so don't try pulling that bs
@@eddybig2781 >Slavery is now directly associated with racism now It would be more accurate to say it is associated with xenophobia when groups come into conflict or break the rules, but seriously dude, the last part is very misleading at best. Where did I said anything about race when I was comparing being employed as forced labor to the state to being a commodity? Penal labor as a punishment is as old as farming, prostitution and mercenary work, and those are the oldest profesions on human history. Seriously, you want to stop people hearing about raceracerace all the time, start with not associating the word itself with a specific group or event when it's being used a lot by many different groups in way to many periods of time all over thousands, hundreds of years of human history, through so many civs we don't even know all of them.
Flogging in Indonesia is only legal in one province which is Aceh where Sharia law is implemented as part of it's autonomous province status, if you're in other part of Indonesia the secular civil law is used which is inherited from old Dutch colonial laws so if you're in Java for example they won't flog you
Fun Fact: imprisonment is a medieval punishment made by Muslims as we know it today at the Islamic golden age. it STILL EXIST Today! it's a very inefficient punishment since it just isolate you from the civilized capitalistic society and connects you to the criminal communist society, they survive by spending our tax money, like parasites. and they get out the prison to be a worse criminal, as people are the summation of the most people they spends time with, which is in this case, CRIMINALS. it also can be a blessing for some people. they don't need to work, and still have bed, toilet, food, friends, hobbies. IMPRISONMENT IS BY FAR THE MOST INAFFICIENT PUNISHMENT SINCE THERE IS NO PUNISHMENT. I Think Flogging is much better than that time wasting thing. it's superior by far, since it's fast and make the criminal regrets his actions and think twice before doing something illegal. also, the skin heals so fast also with the help of doctors.
0:37 SH: “A number of these medieval practices are still around today, and some are even endorsed by governments that usually champion human rights” Also SH: proceeds to mention all cases where the countries mentioned are well known for human rights violations. Sure the last one is the exception, but I think it’s an understandable exception if you know when it’s applied…
Fun Fact: imprisonment is a medieval punishment made by Muslims as we know it today at the Islamic golden age. it STILL EXIST Today! it's a very inefficient punishment since it just isolate you from the civilized capitalistic society and connects you to the criminal communist society, they survive by spending our tax money, like parasites. and they get out the prison to be a worse criminal, as people are the summation of the most people they spends time with, which is in this case, CRIMINALS. it also can be a blessing for some people. they don't need to work, and still have bed, toilet, food, friends, hobbies. IMPRISONMENT IS BY FAR THE MOST INAFFICIENT PUNISHMENT SINCE THERE IS NO PUNISHMENT. I Think Flogging is much better than that time wasting thing. it's superior by far, since it's fast and make the criminal regrets his actions and think twice before doing something illegal. also, the skin heals so fast also with the help of doctors.
Screw your liberal filthy human rights that you bomb Innocents for not believing in them and instead choosing to apply the law of Allah nice tolerance to say the least
@@52flyingbicyclesThey also have some of the worst human rights records in the modern day. They are probably in the top 5-10 of that list but all the others are places like china, afganistan, north korea and russia. And they work with all those before mentioned countries as well so i wouldnt call them ”prominent western ally”. They are just a awful dictatorship that has to suck up to western countries to not lose their power
@@user-op8fg3ny3j I don't buy that. There are countries where a woman can walk outside at night without fear of being assaulted, and yet they don't have flogging as a punishment. As with any institutionalized form of corporal punishment, it is a barbaric practice which has no place in the 21st century.
@@Aiden_Muslim Well, Japan doesn't employ those, nor South Korea, nor Iceland, nor New Zealand, and other European countries, and not only are they the safest, but they are also the happiest. You guys are safe from the people but not the government. 😩
5:30 A common misconception about immolation is that the victims died by the fire. This was not the case. In most cases, the executioner choked them shortly before the fire was lit, and only their dead body was burnt. So, in fact, it wasn't death by fire. This is not to say it never happened, but it was the exception, not the rule.
That depends on where the execution occurred as Scotland, Germany and France typically (although not always) strangled or hanged before burning but in Italy and Spain, ppl were burnt alive.
at a buffet, i personally sneak corndogs into the buffet so others can enjoy them. I hide 6 corndogs in my jacket pockets. it then, is a joy for me to see other patrons of the establishment eat my corndogs thinking they were part of the buffet.
Saudi Arabia is one of the most safest countries in the world just see the statistics of crime in Saudi Arabia and any western country you will always find Saudi Arabia to be more safe
@@Ashraf-HriraDo you think the statistics accurately reflect how „safe“ saudi arabia is? The part of the video with the brutal lashing of a blogger for „criticizing islam online“ surely should give you a hint
@@FzudemB safe as long as you follow the laws of the lands and blasphemy against any religion not only Islam is outlawed in the Sharia if I come to your country and break your laws that I don't agree with and go punished what would you say then I wonder
Fun Fact: imprisonment is a medieval punishment made by Muslims as we know it today at the Islamic golden age. it STILL EXIST Today! it's a very inefficient punishment since it just isolate you from the civilized capitalistic society and connects you to the criminal communist society, they survive by spending our tax money, like parasites. and they get out the prison to be a worse criminal, as people are the summation of the most people they spends time with, which is in this case, CRIMINALS. it also can be a blessing for some people. they don't need to work, and still have bed, toilet, food, friends, hobbies. IMPRISONMENT IS BY FAR THE MOST INAFFICIENT PUNISHMENT SINCE THERE IS NO PUNISHMENT. I Think Flogging is much better than that time wasting thing. it's superior by far, since it's fast and make the criminal regrets his actions and think twice before doing something illegal. also, the skin heals so fast also with the help of doctors.
Those "Barbaric" Punishments actually do work, Robbery is extremely rare in Saudi Arabia as a result, whilst the "merciful" lenient government still have sky rocketing crime rates Their whole purpose is to deter not to sadistically enjoy torturing people because the conditions of these punishments are usually hard to meet
This, people think it’s a religious death cult when in reality it’s meant for the people. Besides, it’s possible to forego the hudud punishments in some cases and circumstances.
Yes some harsh law that apply to everyone need thinking twice before commiting some crime Well i am Indonesia even we have some difference treat how to deals with crime even i admit Saudi Arabia have weakness in justice court system If you are "accidentally killed someone in self defense" you probably still have death sentence for you even there some Indonesian Muslim became victim of this rules
@EpicGamerAlexander It’s not oudated, it works for all time. Yeah you can cite some other countries that dont use these punishments with low crime rwtes but circumstances are different and not everyone can afford the nordic model, these laws can be applied anywhere and everywhere. It’s not black and white man.
Sociopaths when an autoritarian goverment brutalmy kills a criminal (regards of the crime): Based 😮 Sociopaths when the goverment does those same things to protestants: 😭😭
@EpicGamerAlexander tf does "outdated" mean Did it get discontinued in the next patch or something ? Western moral standards are not a reference and it's really volatile itself 70 years ago you were okay with racial segregation and now you're promoting pro LGBT sentiments and ideas Your cultural standards are extremely dynamic and we won't modify our religion to placate it If it works why change it? Sentiments alone don't make a good argument
1:35 A little bit of clarification for Flogging in Malaysia. Yes it is recognized as a form of punishment but it is done according to islamic rites, not inspired by the european medieval form of punishment. Furthermore, all executions and punishments are done in complete privacy and if it is recorded, you are not allowed to release the footage to the public. However, judging by the inability to release footage of flogging to the public in Malaysia, i highly doubt you are able to record it in the first place. No spectators are also allowed to watch the execution in the first place. The tool used for the execution is also not a some kind of leash. The tool is actually a long object that looks like a very long ruler made of bamboo (known as "rotan" in Malay.) The wrongdoer will receive the flogging at the buttocks, not on the back and the effect of the flogging will result in painful wounds and cuts but doesn't result in bleeding.
Yup this is how you teach adult that do crimes! Not pampering them on a 5 star cell and give them food 24/7 😂😂😂 This is called get away easily! And also wasting tax payer money!
@@haziq0007 Evidence supports treating prisoners with respect, it lowers the prison population and they're less likely to reoffend, a true waste of tax payer money would be keeping someone like El Chapo in prison instead of executing him considering the amount of trouble his existence causes, same goes for the other people under the same prison
@@haziq0007Five star? They are in fear of being stabbed to death and rapped and eat horrible food. Nothing five star about that. They are also stuffed in solitary confinement where they slowly lose their minds.
In Malaysia, caning is used as a form of corporal punishment and is normally done in prisons. Caning punishment will be received if the convict is charged with rape, violence, drug trafficking, illegal immigration, bribery, illegal moneylending and criminal breach of trust. For example, a convict will be imprisoned between 8 to 30 years with whipping not less than 10 whips for sexual assault. The process is done where the convict (butt naked) is tied on a A-shape frame, the lower back and upper thighs is protected by a torso-shield and the caning punishment is then proceeded.
When someone was burned at the stake they would sometimes die of hypothermia, they would lose so much skin they couldn't keep warm, countless people have lost their lives in cold weather because a fire without clothes and/or shelter is not always enough.
Is it racist that we notice that all of these punishments are well accepted in Islam, just saying it may not be worth calling it a religion of peace if this is part of their culture.
@@yesyes3010 that's literally how laws work, you trade certain freedoms for safety e.g. gun owner "your freedom to swing your fist ends where it meets my face"
@@user-op8fg3ny3j agreed. You can't have rules without consequences and therefore neither a society without punishment. The only thing you can do is try to secure as much freedom to the people as possible. If you don't, then you are just a tyrant. You don't secure peoples freedom by cutting their hand of if they steal, instead of putting them in jail. Then you are just abusing you power as a ruler in order to conduct barbaric punishments.
I honestly think that certain forms of execution, when necessary, are more humane than the modern western standard of lethal injection. Personally, if I had to choose between a lethal injection and the guillotine (assuming it was still sharp,) I'd go with the guillotine.
@@victory9161 That’s how it works in theory, but more research suggests that it often isn’t as painless as though and the person injected can remain conscious for a while.
Me in the 1800s watching my wife get immolation after me lying to the people of my village that she committed witchcraft (she cheated on me so now she burns)
Depends on your country but in the UK at least, anti-witchcraft laws were gone by then. In fact, it was made a criminal offense to even accuse anyone of being a witch in 1735, and this law was passed overwhelmingly in parliament.
@@user-op8fg3ny3j The problem is that the "criminals" in many cases were either innocent or did things that shouldn't be illegal in the first place (like protesting, criticizing religion or the government).
@@kennet7837 that's entirely subjective. e.g. Democrats say that Jan. 6th was illegal while Republicans say they were "protesting". Republicans say that what BLM/Antifa did was illegal while Democrats say they were "protesting". Insulting religion is illegal in their countries like how insulting protected groups is illegal in ours etc.
@@user-op8fg3ny3j If only protesting was the reason. The Trump sycophants who got arrested on Jan. 6 was charged with trespassing, destruction of property, and in some cases violence (remember people even died that day as a result) and making death threats (some of them shouted "hang Mike Pence"). If they didn't storm the Capitol, it is unlikely they would have been arrested. Unfortunately, some countries don't believe in freedom of speech and wrongly conflates criticizing religion with insulting the followers of said religion.
Hi Simple history Im 18 and I’ve be writing down in blank pages of books and learning about your videos and I started from your oldest video (first) and I’m up to (attack of the dead men) I’m gonna keep going till this video and catch up your amazing at history and I enjoy your videos thanks callum 😁
Dont mean to burst your bubble but find a better source of information than youtube. This guy spreads misinformation by using half assed Wikipedia research, using most of his information out of context and spreading half truths and out right false information. His videos are interesting but worthless as a history source
oh but they won't, the USA/Europe must represent the good guys, hence why they always said "this practice last in europe until [insert times] while it is still practiced in [insert muslim countries] currently"
No no ignore the CIA crimes or the inhuman tortures of innocent people, did you forget this is all about image we want the world to know who to stand with and who to go against ❤️
And in their own homeland too. Make a video about how the January 6th protesters who legally entered the Capitol are being tortured right now in Washington, D.C.
@@amosamwig8394 prisons have to be closed? There's a reason why crime rates in those Muslim countries are low. Those stupid enough to steal sometimes lose their hands. Those that are spared don't do it again because they know what will happen. Those that think of doing it usually don't because they know what will happen. Losing your hands is a pretty effective deterrent and if you don't like it, simply don't steal.
@@ravinakuwar1407you got burned by reality 😂 but when it come to you guys you people made a exaggerated movie on kashmir and kerala with full of lies lol 😂
1:40 Not Indonesia as a whole, but only one (special) province, Aceh. Indonesia agree to let Aceh rule for themselves to cease the separatist rebellion
@@jamescourt6554 But it definitely helps Imagine this: In middle of the city, on the well, there is placed a golden grail and everybody is allowed to drink water from it. But if someone dares to steal that grail, they are gonna catch him, beat him up, torture him, and then impale you on a wooden stake while you are still alive and then puting the stake out on the open sun to fry you while you are slowly and painfully dying. Well that's what Vlad the Impaler did, and no one stole that grail.
3:21 i liked how you connected the saudi execution (the quickest death) to the jihadi john videos which he cuts his victims throats, beheading in islam is done from the back of the neck slicing the spinal cord not from the throat side like most of isis videos (the terrorist group) did. I would like to suggest to you that you search more about beheading and compare it to other “merciful” execution methods before calling it barbaric. one more thing if the process of the execution is painless whats the point then of calling it a punishment? like if a child rapist committed such crime should the rapist have a merciful death?
3:58 saudi arabia still use sord to kill the man who murder a human being!! you think that is not good but try to imagine that human is your mother or son!!!
Some punishments remain because they have preventive effects. That barbaric practice by that terrorists of so called isis has nothing to do with Islam. They harmed Muslims the most
Fun Fact: imprisonment is a medieval punishment made by Muslims as we know it today at the Islamic golden age. it STILL EXIST Today! it's a very inefficient punishment since it just isolate you from the civilized capitalistic society and connects you to the criminal communist society, they survive by spending our tax money, like parasites. and they get out the prison to be a worse criminal, as people are the summation of the most people they spends time with, which is in this case, CRIMINALS. it also can be a blessing for some people. they don't need to work, and still have bed, toilet, food, friends, hobbies. IMPRISONMENT IS BY FAR THE MOST INAFFICIENT PUNISHMENT SINCE THERE IS NO PUNISHMENT. I Think Flogging is much better than that time wasting thing. it's superior by far, since it's fast and make the criminal regrets his actions and think twice before doing something illegal. also, the skin heals so fast also with the help of doctors.
Fun Fact: imprisonment is a medieval punishment made by Muslims as we know it today at the Islamic golden age. it STILL EXIST Today! it's a very inefficient punishment since it just isolate you from the civilized capitalistic society and connects you to the criminal communist society, they survive by spending our tax money, like parasites. and they get out the prison to be a worse criminal, as people are the summation of the most people they spends time with, which is in this case, CRIMINALS. it also can be a blessing for some people. they don't need to work, and still have bed, toilet, food, friends, hobbies. IMPRISONMENT IS BY FAR THE MOST INAFFICIENT PUNISHMENT SINCE THERE IS NO PUNISHMENT. I Think Flogging is much better than that time wasting thing. it's superior by far, since it's fast and make the criminal regrets his actions and think twice before doing something illegal. also, the skin heals so fast also with the help of doctors.
Sati (also called suttee) is the practice among some Hindu communities by which a recently widowed woman by use of force or coercion commits suicide as a result of her husband's death. The best known form of sati is when a woman burns to death on her husband's funeral pyre.
@@ozzyk558 "Algorithms" were not invented, nor improvized, by Mohammadans. The mathematics and cryptography were already known by ancient Greeks, Indians and even Egyptians. Moreover, Khwarizmi (the guy who is credited with the "creation" of algorithma) was a Persian Zoroastrian (al-Majusi). lmao'ing at you
@@MustacheCashStash125 I don't know if you're from the US, but if you aren't, we have a whole registry for them. I don't care about public urinaters, I mean the predators
Video is misleading. For instance, when you mention the lashing, it's nothing in the Middle-East like it was in Europe. What we lash them with isn't painful and it's meant to be more of an embarrassing punishment. Even the other things like the chocolate at 2:00 don't ever happen, and bringing up an odd case without emphasizing only serves misinformation.
Immolation was usually a punishment reserved for crimes related to heresy in the west, not witchcraft. Most suspected witches were hanged. The mindset was that (at least partially) the length of the punishment compared to others would allow for the condemned to repent before death.
Also adds to the mindset that if you die while you're not touching the ground it acts as a curse
I always thought burnings were to purify the soul before death and as such act as a mercy to the afflicted, however cruel it was beforehand.
@@zacky1010fear Allah unseen
@@AdmiralHalimeshdon't die as a disbeliever
Fear Allah unseen
“This enraged everyone, who punished them severely.”
"This enraged everyone, who punished them severely."
"This enraged everyone, who punished them severely."
“This punished everyone, who enraged them severely.”
Ah, a man of quality
This comment enraged his dad but he was too old to do anything about it
Bruh Saudi Arabia continuing to practice nearly all of these
And their crime rate thanks for it
@@user-op8fg3ny3j eh, there’s a lot of places in Europe (+ Japan) that are significantly more humane and have far fewer human rights abuses that also have lower crime rates
Fun Fact: imprisonment is a medieval punishment made by Muslims as we know it today at the Islamic golden age. it STILL EXIST Today! it's a very inefficient punishment since it just isolate you from the civilized capitalistic society and connects you to the criminal communist society, they survive by spending our tax money, like parasites. and they get out the prison to be a worse criminal, as people are the summation of the most people they spends time with, which is in this case, CRIMINALS.
it also can be a blessing for some people. they don't need to work, and still have bed, toilet, food, friends, hobbies. IMPRISONMENT IS BY FAR THE MOST INAFFICIENT PUNISHMENT SINCE THERE IS NO PUNISHMENT.
I Think Flogging is much better than that time wasting thing. it's superior by far, since it's fast and make the criminal regrets his actions and think twice before doing something illegal. also, the skin heals so fast also with the help of doctors.
@@user-op8fg3ny3jit's not all that low my guy.
@@wake6000 it is though?
The history of Japanese capital punishment spans from the time of Rome to present day. Japan still uses death by hanging.
So that's who death punishment has to give lol
Good!
Good. If you kill someone, you should die yourself.
"What about the Electric,⚡chair soaked with water,💦 from a wet sponge is more quicker and painless than medieval punishments."
"Electrocution from the water,💦 soaked sponge electric,⚡chair?"
the animation has gone a long way on this channel, awesome job
3:00 common izlam L
@@LavaCreeperPeopleIt's not Islam. İt's the culture of Saudi Arabia.
Far enough to make Jesus black 🤣
I was thinking the same 😂.
@@LavaCreeperPeopletell me your stupid without telling me your stupid.
As a Singaporean, I can tell you that canning is still used as a punishment but it is not as brutal as it is said to be and is only a sentence for crimes that involved invading someone's personal space such as molesting. For small crimes such as theft will be punished with a fine, a few months jail sentence or community service. When canning is carried out, the justice system will allow you to heal your wound for a month or two before delivering the next stroke or next few strokes, Singapore's justice system is strict not cruel
We need this for molesters
Some of the crown territories had judicial corporal punishment until the 1970’s
@@OscarOSullivan I catch no ball, pls explain or elaborate
There have been cases where people were caned for overstaying in a foreign country
arent people immediately killed off for doing drugs instead of therapy and jail to help off the addiction??
Everyone : Thank God these punishments don’t happen anymore
Saudi Arabia : You were saying?
Different god
@@_Storch_same god. Different government
Victims of rampant crime in our countries would wish otherwise
@@_Storch_same one god
Fun Fact: imprisonment is a medieval punishment made by Muslims as we know it today at the Islamic golden age. it STILL EXIST Today! it's a very inefficient punishment since it just isolate you from the civilized capitalistic society and connects you to the criminal communist society, they survive by spending our tax money, like parasites. and they get out the prison to be a worse criminal, as people are the summation of the most people they spends time with, which is in this case, CRIMINALS.
it also can be a blessing for some people. they don't need to work, and still have bed, toilet, food, friends, hobbies. IMPRISONMENT IS BY FAR THE MOST INAFFICIENT PUNISHMENT SINCE THERE IS NO PUNISHMENT.
I Think Flogging is much better than that time wasting thing. it's superior by far, since it's fast and make the criminal regrets his actions and think twice before doing something illegal. also, the skin heals so fast also with the help of doctors.
At 05:13, I think that's a mistake. The condemned person is wearing attire that was usually given to him or her after he/she recanted their heretic beliefs and were spared.
*Strangling* was usually an option after the condemned person had recanted but was still going to be executed.
Being strangled took only a few seconds *if* the executioner was skilled.
"Ouch!"
What does heretic mean
"Heretic means a blasphemous person?"
@@Account_abandoned-q7m From Merriam-Webster:
heretic
noun
her·e·tic ˈher-ə-ˌtik ˈhe-rə-
Synonyms of heretic
1
religion : a person who differs in opinion from established religious dogma (see DOGMA sense 2)
especially : a baptized member of the Roman Catholic Church who refuses to acknowledge or accept a revealed truth
The church regards them as heretics.
2
: one who differs in opinion from an accepted belief or doctrine : NONCONFORMIST
Also her name is Giovanna D'arco, not jonavark or whatever tf he said :DDD
Chemical castration, despite the name, doesn’t actually involve losing any body parts. Rather it means taking pills that prevents said parts from operating naturally. This variation is usually reversible.
I’m surprised this video didn’t mention the use of eunuchs in the Ottoman and Chinese Empires to produce civil servants and royal courtiers who had no ability to form their own dynasties and thus theoretically would be loyal to the ruler. Of course, in practice these eunuchs still often amassed power for themselves even with nobody to pass it down to.
Also eunuchs were prominent in the Late Roman and Byzantine Empire
More modern studies have shown that it is way more permanent than once believed.
Alan Turning, the genius computer scientist who broke the German enigma code in WW2 was discovered to be homosexual. He was chemically castrated and died of complications. Remember his name.
It's not as casual and safe as you make it sound. In many cases the effects can be permanent and lead to other complications.
I volunter you to undergo it
It's reversible, as you said, so no harm in trying it out, right?
One thing the English and French have in common is beheading their King
4:40
I'm Paraguayan and I remembered this very clearly as a kid, It's just one example of the suffering people had to go through when protesting.
It's not so common nowadays.
10 lashes in public square would set many people straight
true that law what the west need right now
@@Ashraf-Hrira No
@@kingmarre9130 Chicago had a higher death rate than Iraq at one point
@@Ashraf-Hrira The “East” has far higher crime rates and corruption then the West (if we define the West as the United States and Europe plus Australia, Japan, and South Korea)
What exactly would the West have to gain from such a primitive practice when their countries are incredibly safe for the most part?
It wouldn’t.
Heck, as a kid, I preferred paddling over time-out.
It's kinda weird that Saudi Arabia doesn't have castration as a punishment, despite having almost everything else on this list.
Because it's not in religion
There's two kinds of punishments in Islam
disciplinary punishment and death punishment
Torturing isn't allowed or doing anything that isn't in the rules of punishments in Islam
@@esamsenpaiak74ss won't make any of the things that are allowed any better
@@diprogamer3294 because you don't know how much are thay useful
@@diprogamer3294the ones allowed contribute to the fact that saudi arabia is among the safest countries on the planet.
@@albaraqahtani tell that to the random tourist who got whipped by the Saudi state.
Saudi Arabia still practice all of this, probably the reason why crime rate in that country are so low compared to the USA. People in Saudi leave their shops, stalls and businesses when they hear call of prayer and nobody steal anything.
Can you leave anything valuable on the roadside in America and expect nobody to steal it?
The crime rate in Japan, Australia & Norway is far lower than that of Saudi Arabia, without having the need to enforce any of those types of punishments. Also, in Saudi Arabia, there's simply no free media, so there's no way of knowing if such crimes are taking place. Furthermore, in medieval times, crime rates were even higher, even with those types of punishments in effect. This shows, there's absolutely no correlation between the two. Plus, countries like Sudan, Yemen, Somalia and others such, also have have those types of punishments and yet has one of the highest crime rates in the World. Why do you think, that is? It's because Sudan, Yemen, Somalia and other such countries have political instability, poverty, turmoil and other such challenges, which is why the crime rates are high. No matter, what punishment you implement, it has little to no effect on the overall crime rate in the country. It has more to do with the stability, welfare, well being and other such qualities, in a particular country. You have an answer for all of that, as well?
@@SpaceReptilioidNorway has only a population of 5 million, of which 1 million live in the urban area of Oslo. so Norway has a very very low population density. It is also one of the richest countries. Saudi‘s capital has a bigger population than the entirety of Norway.
Btw, in 2011 one of the most deadliest mass shootings in global history (~4th place) happened in Norway.
In Japan the laws are very very strict and they have other harsh punishments. The police is also regularly committing police brutality to get people to confess their crime.
Furthermore, Japanese culture very honor based and someone would rather kill himself than kill someone else. Shunning people who are different is also commonly done which forces people to fall in line.
Btw, crimes against politicians are higher in Japan than in any western country. 2nd btw, the crimes committed in Japan are unbelievably gruesome and gross, one example: the murder of Junko Furuta.
@@SpaceReptilioidSudan, Somalia and Yemen are in a civil war.
No, pretty sure that’s just the religion.
Well if you don't register any crime, then obviously crime rates will be low. How about japan, sweden and some other European countries. They have even lower crime rates than the made up crime rates of saudi Arabia. Imagine getting hanged for saying that the earth is not flat as it is written in koran.
NK has executed high officials with a 37mm autocannon. Eat your hearts out, medieval kings!
Pellet guns are used in Kashmir as a non lethal weapon. Most times it's used on the center of the body but when fired from long range or when it missed it's supposed target then the pellets can hit all around the body including head and legs just like a bird shot from a shotgun.
My friend was martyred by the indian soldiers, they shot a whole cansister to his head. Most of the injuries led to people losing their eyesight forever, the youngest being a 3 month old child
@@Kashmirimuslimakhi What was the 3 month old doing at the stone pelting event?
@@crazyhorse141 she wasnt there, she was in her home on her veranda!
Why not ask about my friend too ehh?
Thousands of Kashmir Pandits were killed by Muslims...
I dont know. Having my my head quickly taken off sounds A LOT more humane of execusion than its given credit for.
There are theories that you may be conscious when your head rolls, but that can very easily be rapid eye movement and nerves twitching.
I'd take that over lethal injection or God forbidding, life in prison, where you're going to suffer a harsh and hopeless life so you may suffer a the hand of justice. I watched a few videos of inmates that would rather face a firing squad than continue to rot away in a jail cell.
Life in prison is just slavery but with taxpayers' money. Also, slitting the throat to just enough to where you don't sever the spinal cord is the most humane way to kill anything. oxygen stops flowing to the brain, you lose consciousness, and you lose all senses without even feeling the blade if it's sharp enough.
There are fates worse than de@th.
- Raiden
Lethal injection is by far the best.
Are you drunk?
You get an injection that makes you sleep.
Then another one that stops your breathing.
That vs severe trauma to your head? Remind me to never listen to anything else you ever say.
I even heard of some inmate spending the rest of his life in prison who requested the death penalty, but it was rejected. I’m sure he’s miserable.
4:20 I'm detecting a pattern in the locations where these punishments are still allowed.
Does anyone else see it?
Yes, countries that have not been reduced to degeneracy, minus Iran of course.
Muslim countries??
Yes, Islam seems to have a certain disregard for humanity, or civilisation. Nice ideology. And we're importing it
@@daveanderson3805 What's cruel in eye for eye punishment ? Most countries where such punishments are allowed have lower crime rates
@@daveanderson3805 Remind me which countries have lower crime statistics? Cope harder. The system works in reducing crime than any other.
Here’s one of them, forcing you to confess to something you didn’t do, we still have this happen all the time during court hearings only difference being we don’t torture you instead just giving a longer sentence if found guilty
yep... here in Australia we got a new one... if a convicted killer does not confess where the body is, they will never be released on parole.
Anyone with a tiny shred of intelligence (which no one has in Australia anymore) can see this law rewarding real killers and punishing the innocent... since obviously the innocent cannot know where the body is.
It comes down to the very very arrogant assumption that a person 'IS' guilty of murder with absolute certainty if convicted of murder.... this goes well beyond convicting a person based on 'beyond reasonable doubt'
@@mystikmind2005 Western civil law is rigged, sometimes it even favors criminals rather than the victims very heart breaking to see them crying!
@@mystikmind2005 Very nice. It's not the first Australian law that made me raise my eyebrows, and unfortunately probably not the last. But your reasoning is excellent and it's nice to see someone with a common sense, because oh boy, is it getting rare...
@@AKuTepionfear Allah unseen
@@REBECCA12341 I don't understand the context.
The history of Guerrilla Warfare tactics would be a great video topic
We invented it, spanish guerrilleros, catalán migueletes and somatén etc🇪🇦😉
Guerrilla Warfare was the default war strategy until the formation of large organized militaries.
"Today we're looking at countries that still use these methods today..."
"Half of this list seems to be Saudi Arabia"
And thats why the crime rate there is low. It kept the people's discipline
@@thatayrellguy3023Nobody cares about the crime rate, because public crime rate statistics are about as useful as an IGN review.
It’s still morally and psychologically backwards, and says a lot about how a country is governed and controlled. I’m sure the average Saudi citizen is fine, but the people that enforce and employ that kind of barbarism are sad, lowly people, who just want a reason to justify brutality through zealotry. Period.
@@K12machinima "nobody cares abput crime rate" bruh mate wtf? And even if its backward. If it work than its good. Simple as that. Dont want to receive those punishment? Dont be an idiot in the first place
how can you say morally backwards when you don't have a morality in the first place@@K12machinima
That’s because that whole part of the world is about 1000 years behind
"Some are even endorsed by governments that usually champion human rights"
Saudi Arabia
Don't you mean India who blinded those children and civilians?
@@user-op8fg3ny3j also kenya, iran, etc
Blame the UN for that Joke. 😂
@@silverhawkscape2677 why the un? The only thing simple history showed in the video that is endorsed in countries with high human rights is the chemical castration at the end of the video. The other stuff was in country where human rights don't exist because religion
"Human right dont exist because of relligion"
If you really know Islam, then should know
-> Mother are valued highly as they are the one who sacrifice their life and bring you to this world.
-> Parents are responsible by relligion to take care of their children, as they are responsible from bringing their children to this world.
-> If a muslim is the majority in the area, they must protect the non-muslim from outside threat, this include letting them to pray on their own belief.
-> Peoples with wealth are endorsed to help out the poor.
-> Killing others are probihited.
-> Leader muct act for whats the best of the peoples.
-> Stealing and corruption are greatly probihited, as it makes lots of people suffers.
-> At wartime, they are not allowed to kill Children, woman, old peoples, animal (except for eating) or the people that run away, they have to treat PoW with respect and ot enforcing Islam to them, they are also not allowed to destroy buildings, including temples and Church.
-> If non Muslim ask for protection and they didn't threat the Muslim, then the muslim are obliged to protect them (Like Salladin who escorted his enemy family to safety, even though the enemy can't fulfill his promise to escape the town and was ordered to defense it agains Salladin troop)
If you find they are saying they are "Islam" yet they didnt do all that, chances are their knowledge of their own relligion is quote shallow, think of it like school, there are students who will always says they arevfrom that school, yet their behavior dont reflect the school policy.
Surely the best history channel on youtube...you're animations are top notch
Fun fact: Japanese crucifixion did not include nails, they only tied them by using ropes and then speared
is that any better???
@@AseemAhmad-k2p a little yeah
@@AseemAhmad-k2pat least your hands won t hurt that much
The animations on this channel are top notch great work
Beheading is the easiest way to die than the other punishments, Imagine being tortured by black hearted people who are done with their lives putting all their misery on you
as a singaporean i can say many people mistake flogging. We flog in private out of view inside a cell. our maximum number of strokes is 24 but with a thicker cane than those used in others. in singapore we use it with small number of strokes for vandalism, and more up to 24 strokes for serious crimes like drug trafficking and other capital offences where no death penalty(hanging) is given
Imagine if I could eat a metal pipe
Somewhat outdated practice
@@gt4969 it’s not about modern ways. It’s about whether a way works or not. Things like technology and economy yes. But laws, if old laws work in keeping a country safe then it shall stay. Modernising laws can be progressing to failure.
@@verycursedplane6557yes true
Idk seems harsh to cane someone for vandalism
"It seems the medieval world is still alive and well"
Yes we still eat bread and get drunk like in the Middle Ages
B r e d
BRÖD
R O T I
You forgot the most acient one:
Penal labor. By putting convicts to work on physical goverment projects, such as mining, maintainance, manufacture, farming, and other forms of labor, convicts will be put to works in order to produce cheap goods for the state or a company affiliated to the prison. Depending on the state, they could get payed way below the minimun wage salary which could be claimed once they were realesed or if you got permition, send it to a familiy member or friend, but some don´t pay them at all. It is almost institucional slavery, but usually you get the choice to accept the job, and your human rights are still in place except for the rights that the state provide to you since you are temporaly or indifenetly no longer a civilian.
It is a very common practice to use penal labor for a state to mine the neccesary materials to get concrete with minimal tools.
I've done time a few times. I've done it as a max custody inmate (really sucks) and I've been put on work crews and of course general population. My time flew by when they had me working and some of the work was brutal. But mc is way more difficult. GP is the easiest but the days/weeks/years go by so slow. I don't know if working is better for everyone, but I didn't get into trouble and sent to MC . And the many months just flew by. Slavery? I don't think so. But everyone has to make everything about race. And I Ain't White so don't try pulling that bs
@@eddybig2781 >Slavery is now directly associated with racism now
It would be more accurate to say it is associated with xenophobia when groups come into conflict or break the rules, but seriously dude, the last part is very misleading at best.
Where did I said anything about race when I was comparing being employed as forced labor to the state to being a commodity?
Penal labor as a punishment is as old as farming, prostitution and mercenary work, and those are the oldest profesions on human history.
Seriously, you want to stop people hearing about raceracerace all the time, start with not associating the word itself with a specific group or event when it's being used a lot by many different groups in way to many periods of time all over thousands, hundreds of years of human history, through so many civs we don't even know all of them.
I love the modern-day prison complex (slavery)
@@Crownpandagotta love loopholes in the most fundamental amendment for the largest minority in the country and the for profit prison system.
This is a great idea!
Punishment + productivity
Feudal Japan: You like the guy on the cross? Let's make it official.
Flogging in Indonesia is only legal in one province which is Aceh where Sharia law is implemented as part of it's autonomous province status, if you're in other part of Indonesia the secular civil law is used which is inherited from old Dutch colonial laws so if you're in Java for example they won't flog you
Fun Fact: imprisonment is a medieval punishment made by Muslims as we know it today at the Islamic golden age. it STILL EXIST Today! it's a very inefficient punishment since it just isolate you from the civilized capitalistic society and connects you to the criminal communist society, they survive by spending our tax money, like parasites. and they get out the prison to be a worse criminal, as people are the summation of the most people they spends time with, which is in this case, CRIMINALS.
it also can be a blessing for some people. they don't need to work, and still have bed, toilet, food, friends, hobbies. IMPRISONMENT IS BY FAR THE MOST INAFFICIENT PUNISHMENT SINCE THERE IS NO PUNISHMENT.
I Think Flogging is much better than that time wasting thing. it's superior by far, since it's fast and make the criminal regrets his actions and think twice before doing something illegal. also, the skin heals so fast also with the help of doctors.
Good to hear 👍
0:37 SH: “A number of these medieval practices are still around today, and some are even endorsed by governments that usually champion human rights”
Also SH: proceeds to mention all cases where the countries mentioned are well known for human rights violations. Sure the last one is the exception, but I think it’s an understandable exception if you know when it’s applied…
Hence the word, "some"
Fun Fact: imprisonment is a medieval punishment made by Muslims as we know it today at the Islamic golden age. it STILL EXIST Today! it's a very inefficient punishment since it just isolate you from the civilized capitalistic society and connects you to the criminal communist society, they survive by spending our tax money, like parasites. and they get out the prison to be a worse criminal, as people are the summation of the most people they spends time with, which is in this case, CRIMINALS.
it also can be a blessing for some people. they don't need to work, and still have bed, toilet, food, friends, hobbies. IMPRISONMENT IS BY FAR THE MOST INAFFICIENT PUNISHMENT SINCE THERE IS NO PUNISHMENT.
I Think Flogging is much better than that time wasting thing. it's superior by far, since it's fast and make the criminal regrets his actions and think twice before doing something illegal. also, the skin heals so fast also with the help of doctors.
Screw your liberal filthy human rights that you bomb Innocents for not believing in them and instead choosing to apply the law of Allah nice tolerance to say the least
Saudi Arabia is a prominent western ally.
@@52flyingbicyclesThey also have some of the worst human rights records in the modern day. They are probably in the top 5-10 of that list but all the others are places like china, afganistan, north korea and russia. And they work with all those before mentioned countries as well so i wouldnt call them ”prominent western ally”. They are just a awful dictatorship that has to suck up to western countries to not lose their power
“No matter how struggle and strive, I’ll never get out of this world alive.” Hank Williams Sr
Fun fact : France continued using the guillotine until 1977
Feel kinda fitting that all but one of these are only used in countries that are stuck in the medieval ages
Indeed
Singapore stuck in the middle ages? Lmao, you wish 🤣
@@user-op8fg3ny3j if your country still does flogging, yes
@@richardsamuelgustavo you know why their commuters don't have to worry about criminals threatening to murder them?
@@user-op8fg3ny3j I don't buy that. There are countries where a woman can walk outside at night without fear of being assaulted, and yet they don't have flogging as a punishment.
As with any institutionalized form of corporal punishment, it is a barbaric practice which has no place in the 21st century.
Can't help but notice a similarity in the cultures that still employ medieval punishments
@@CrackCatWantsPatCould be Saudi Arabia but idk
Can't help but notice the crime rates in the cultures that employ them VS the ones that don't.
Yeah, wahhabist sunni islamist (radicals) states in particular
@@m1n10ns8do you even know what wahhabism means?
@@Aiden_Muslim Well, Japan doesn't employ those, nor South Korea, nor Iceland, nor New Zealand, and other European countries, and not only are they the safest, but they are also the happiest.
You guys are safe from the people but not the government. 😩
5:30 A common misconception about immolation is that the victims died by the fire. This was not the case. In most cases, the executioner choked them shortly before the fire was lit, and only their dead body was burnt. So, in fact, it wasn't death by fire. This is not to say it never happened, but it was the exception, not the rule.
That depends on where the execution occurred as Scotland, Germany and France typically (although not always) strangled or hanged before burning but in Italy and Spain, ppl were burnt alive.
at a buffet, i personally sneak corndogs into the buffet so others can enjoy them. I hide 6 corndogs in my jacket pockets. it then, is a joy for me to see other patrons of the establishment eat my corndogs thinking they were part of the buffet.
interesting
Thats a health code violation
You must be flogged 🤣👌
@@noahboat580 its not. i have a food handlers liscenmce plus the hard exoskeelton of the corndog keeps bacteria at baY
@@luigidisanpietro3720 ya corndogs
Controversial opinion: if some of these are still used today, we would not have half of the bs we have today.
It would make the offenders rally together and collapse the government and country so no
Saudi Arabia is one of the most safest countries in the world just see the statistics of crime in Saudi Arabia and any western country you will always find Saudi Arabia to be more safe
@@Ashraf-HriraDo you think the statistics accurately reflect how „safe“ saudi arabia is?
The part of the video with the brutal lashing of a blogger for „criticizing islam online“ surely should give you a hint
@@FzudemB safe as long as you follow the laws of the lands and blasphemy against any religion not only Islam is outlawed in the Sharia if I come to your country and break your laws that I don't agree with and go punished what would you say then I wonder
@@SLD-bz9so bruh those statistics are made by your own western countries
Note to self: Don't commit crimes in Saudi Arabia
Better life advice, don't break the law in the country you're at
Fun Fact: imprisonment is a medieval punishment made by Muslims as we know it today at the Islamic golden age. it STILL EXIST Today! it's a very inefficient punishment since it just isolate you from the civilized capitalistic society and connects you to the criminal communist society, they survive by spending our tax money, like parasites. and they get out the prison to be a worse criminal, as people are the summation of the most people they spends time with, which is in this case, CRIMINALS.
it also can be a blessing for some people. they don't need to work, and still have bed, toilet, food, friends, hobbies. IMPRISONMENT IS BY FAR THE MOST INAFFICIENT PUNISHMENT SINCE THERE IS NO PUNISHMENT.
I Think Flogging is much better than that time wasting thing. it's superior by far, since it's fast and make the criminal regrets his actions and think twice before doing something illegal. also, the skin heals so fast also with the help of doctors.
Just dont break the law in general
Here's one better don't go there
@@CallmeLJ700why tho?
Those "Barbaric" Punishments actually do work, Robbery is extremely rare in Saudi Arabia as a result, whilst the "merciful" lenient government still have sky rocketing crime rates
Their whole purpose is to deter not to sadistically enjoy torturing people because the conditions of these punishments are usually hard to meet
This, people think it’s a religious death cult when in reality it’s meant for the people. Besides, it’s possible to forego the hudud punishments in some cases and circumstances.
Yes some harsh law that apply to everyone need thinking twice before commiting some crime
Well i am Indonesia even we have some difference treat how to deals with crime even i admit Saudi Arabia have weakness in justice court system
If you are "accidentally killed someone in self defense" you probably still have death sentence for you even there some Indonesian Muslim became victim of this rules
@EpicGamerAlexander It’s not oudated, it works for all time. Yeah you can cite some other countries that dont use these punishments with low crime rwtes but circumstances are different and not everyone can afford the nordic model, these laws can be applied anywhere and everywhere.
It’s not black and white man.
Sociopaths when an autoritarian goverment brutalmy kills a criminal (regards of the crime): Based 😮
Sociopaths when the goverment does those same things to protestants: 😭😭
@EpicGamerAlexander tf does "outdated" mean
Did it get discontinued in the next patch or something ?
Western moral standards are not a reference and it's really volatile itself
70 years ago you were okay with racial segregation and now you're promoting pro LGBT sentiments and ideas
Your cultural standards are extremely dynamic and we won't modify our religion to placate it
If it works why change it?
Sentiments alone don't make a good argument
1:35
A little bit of clarification for Flogging in Malaysia. Yes it is recognized as a form of punishment but it is done according to islamic rites, not inspired by the european medieval form of punishment. Furthermore, all executions and punishments are done in complete privacy and if it is recorded, you are not allowed to release the footage to the public. However, judging by the inability to release footage of flogging to the public in Malaysia, i highly doubt you are able to record it in the first place. No spectators are also allowed to watch the execution in the first place.
The tool used for the execution is also not a some kind of leash. The tool is actually a long object that looks like a very long ruler made of bamboo (known as "rotan" in Malay.)
The wrongdoer will receive the flogging at the buttocks, not on the back and the effect of the flogging will result in painful wounds and cuts but doesn't result in bleeding.
Yup this is how you teach adult that do crimes! Not pampering them on a 5 star cell and give them food 24/7 😂😂😂 This is called get away easily! And also wasting tax payer money!
@@haziq0007 Evidence supports treating prisoners with respect, it lowers the prison population and they're less likely to reoffend, a true waste of tax payer money would be keeping someone like El Chapo in prison instead of executing him considering the amount of trouble his existence causes, same goes for the other people under the same prison
@@haziq0007Five star? They are in fear of being stabbed to death and rapped and eat horrible food. Nothing five star about that. They are also stuffed in solitary confinement where they slowly lose their minds.
@@Jambuc829Don't do the crime if you can't do the time. It's as simple as that.
@@ashleysalomon4349
Is that why people that leave prison even if they were innocent return to prison no longer innocent
"That's inhumane?" "Electric,⚡chairs soaked in water,💦 from a wet sponge is more quicker and painless than medieval punishments."
I think simple history should have tried that first :)))
"You darn right!"👉
"Electric,⚡chairs soaked in water,💦 from a wet sponge is more quicker and painless and humane, than barbarous methods of torture?" "I'd say?" 🕵
1:35 As a Bruneian, I saw this demonstration by the Police Force when I was in Secondary School.
So we can say that medieval punishments still lives in the countries who remain stuck in middle age.
better to stay in the sanity of the middle ages than to be in the insanity of the western modern age
Some non-state actors are stuck there too, just to top it off.
Correct
Singapore stuck in the middle age, lmao you wish 😂
and it shows the evils of Muslims and why islam is in decline in africa and the middle east
Modern problems require Medieval solutions!
In Malaysia, caning is used as a form of corporal punishment and is normally done in prisons. Caning punishment will be received if the convict is charged with rape, violence, drug trafficking, illegal immigration, bribery, illegal moneylending and criminal breach of trust. For example, a convict will be imprisoned between 8 to 30 years with whipping not less than 10 whips for sexual assault. The process is done where the convict (butt naked) is tied on a A-shape frame, the lower back and upper thighs is protected by a torso-shield and the caning punishment is then proceeded.
Chemical castration is also used on children who are convinced by teachers that they are the incorrect gender.
Wow. It must be horrible being so mentally messed up as you are
Jesus that's barbaric
Good lord which 3rd world barbaric country is this?
Canada and the west coastal states of USA are the champions of it, because it is done in hte name of promoting Divershitty!
Here in America we give criminals extra rights and privileges 😅 thanks Joe
You just couldn't wait to name drop someone who has absolutely nothing to do with this 😂
@@MoSherriCharlaSmith dude u are free to steal 900$ worth of products lol 😂🤣🤣
@@MoSherriCharlaSmith so-called public school teachers do it, why can’t I?
Way before Joe actually.
Who’s joe?
When someone was burned at the stake they would sometimes die of hypothermia, they would lose so much skin they couldn't keep warm, countless people have lost their lives in cold weather because a fire without clothes and/or shelter is not always enough.
Is it racist that we notice that all of these punishments are well accepted in Islam, just saying it may not be worth calling it a religion of peace if this is part of their culture.
Well, to be fair, if everyone is too scared to really do anything, then there is peace. Peace, but not freedom.
@@yesyes3010 that's literally how laws work, you trade certain freedoms for safety e.g. gun owner
"your freedom to swing your fist ends where it meets my face"
Muslims never used to call it that until our Bush used that term to pacify the populace in their wars
@@user-op8fg3ny3j agreed. You can't have rules without consequences and therefore neither a society without punishment. The only thing you can do is try to secure as much freedom to the people as possible. If you don't, then you are just a tyrant. You don't secure peoples freedom by cutting their hand of if they steal, instead of putting them in jail. Then you are just abusing you power as a ruler in order to conduct barbaric punishments.
@@yesyes3010 yes, every culture agrees with that. they only differ in what is an acceptable punishment
I love how Czechia became a sea in 1:36
No, that means you can flogg only women and kids
The closest thing Slovakia will get to having a sea
Why do I have water in living room
Absolutely fascinating. beautifully made video thank you !
Yeah, the "castration" is happening to a lot of kids nowadays
It's sickening.
And it is somehow "promoted" by "rights activists."
Finally, someone said it! 👌
WTF are you talking about?
LGBT @@Nicky_Savage
I honestly think that certain forms of execution, when necessary, are more humane than the modern western standard of lethal injection.
Personally, if I had to choose between a lethal injection and the guillotine (assuming it was still sharp,) I'd go with the guillotine.
Aren't you during lethal injection unconcious so you won't feel what's happening
@@victory9161 That’s how it works in theory, but more research suggests that it often isn’t as painless as though and the person injected can remain conscious for a while.
@@capncake8837 wow
@@capncake8837 oof
Nothing on this list can compare to the following... "I'd like to talk to you about your cars extended warranty." 💀
Me in the 1800s watching my wife get immolation after me lying to the people of my village that she committed witchcraft (she cheated on me so now she burns)
Depends on your country but in the UK at least, anti-witchcraft laws were gone by then. In fact, it was made a criminal offense to even accuse anyone of being a witch in 1735, and this law was passed overwhelmingly in parliament.
Medieval punishments were brutal
Edit: there’s a slight war in the comments 💀
And they still do them in the middle east and africa
@@johnrussell6222 better than cuddling criminals
@@user-op8fg3ny3j The problem is that the "criminals" in many cases were either innocent or did things that shouldn't be illegal in the first place (like protesting, criticizing religion or the government).
@@kennet7837 that's entirely subjective.
e.g. Democrats say that Jan. 6th was illegal while Republicans say they were "protesting".
Republicans say that what BLM/Antifa did was illegal while Democrats say they were "protesting".
Insulting religion is illegal in their countries like how insulting protected groups is illegal in ours etc.
@@user-op8fg3ny3j If only protesting was the reason. The Trump sycophants who got arrested on Jan. 6 was charged with trespassing, destruction of property, and in some cases violence (remember people even died that day as a result) and making death threats (some of them shouted "hang Mike Pence"). If they didn't storm the Capitol, it is unlikely they would have been arrested.
Unfortunately, some countries don't believe in freedom of speech and wrongly conflates criticizing religion with insulting the followers of said religion.
Know what’s great of the bloodiest and goriest being gone? When they’re brought back, they’re twice as effective.
imagine the electric chair was so old and forgotten and we somehow came up with the same idea
2:52 bring the guillotine, wouldn't want to be executed by this inaccurate axeman
"these practices have been abandoned"
Saudi Arabia, China, Parts of Africa:: HOLD MY BEER
Hi Simple history Im 18 and I’ve be writing down in blank pages of books and learning about your videos and I started from your oldest video (first) and I’m up to (attack of the dead men) I’m gonna keep going till this video and catch up your amazing at history and I enjoy your videos thanks callum 😁
good work, keep it up!
Thanks mate
Dont mean to burst your bubble but find a better source of information than youtube. This guy spreads misinformation by using half assed Wikipedia research, using most of his information out of context and spreading half truths and out right false information. His videos are interesting but worthless as a history source
Should also mention the tortures US practices in their overseas prison. What law did they use for those are still unknown.
That would ruin their good guy image
oh but they won't, the USA/Europe must represent the good guys, hence why they always said "this practice last in europe until [insert times] while it is still practiced in [insert muslim countries] currently"
No no ignore the CIA crimes or the inhuman tortures of innocent people, did you forget this is all about image we want the world to know who to stand with and who to go against ❤️
they would never do such a thing :D
And in their own homeland too. Make a video about how the January 6th protesters who legally entered the Capitol are being tortured right now in Washington, D.C.
3:14 and don’t forget, the Russian Military practiced decapitations on Ukrainian civilians
And azov's "alleged" Crucifixion
I can't believe they still use crucifixion as punishment. Here in Philippines, we use crucifixion as a tradition during holy weeks
Alhamdulilah that Saudi Arabia still practises Sharia law, it is one of the main reasons for peacefulnes and low criminality in the country.
Until they give non muslims tourists sharia law
@@ThatOneManWhoLaughsInBritishWhoever breaks the laws of God will get it.
Has anyone noticed the pattern to what continents all this medieval tortures still continue and then wonder why they aren't considered as civilised
So you’re saying you weren’t civilized before and if you actually look at it, you see that you guys have a higher crime rates than that region
I love how he describes each execution method and then hes like "In these Muslim countries today..." Really says a lot about Islam doesn't it.
Look up Doha 💀 i think you’re just sad you can’t flash your 2 incher to kids in Muslim countries 💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀
Because treating murderers and thieves with respect has worked so well for the West. Have fun with the rampant crime.
@@swiss8988 look in scandinavia, prisons have to be closed, but they dont cutt people hands of or behead them.
@@amosamwig8394 prisons have to be closed? There's a reason why crime rates in those Muslim countries are low. Those stupid enough to steal sometimes lose their hands. Those that are spared don't do it again because they know what will happen. Those that think of doing it usually don't because they know what will happen. Losing your hands is a pretty effective deterrent and if you don't like it, simply don't steal.
How funny that not all Muslim countries do it. I love people who blame the religion instead of the people
BEHEADING IS BETTER THAN THE ELECTRIC CHAIR
Video idea: The battle of Berlin ww2
7:43 when did this happen I never heard about this either from news channel or politician from Kashmir I don't think you for your research properly
It's based on an Exaggerated article written by a Kashmiri novelist MIRZA WAHEED in The Guardian. Which is full of lies & Exaggerations.
@@ravinakuwar1407 hmm you're right
@@ravinakuwar1407you got burned by reality 😂 but when it come to you guys you people made a exaggerated movie on kashmir and kerala with full of lies lol 😂
@@shed_worrior4022 come here and see for yourself
@@gauravkanwasi7084 i am from kashmir and @shed_worrior4022 is right
1:40 Not Indonesia as a whole, but only one (special) province, Aceh. Indonesia agree to let Aceh rule for themselves to cease the separatist rebellion
The more gruesome is the punishment , the more people are afraid of committing offenses or crimes .
yet it doesnt solve it in the end
If that was true, why were banditry and criminality still rampant problems even when these brutal punishments were in their heyday?
@@jamescourt6554 It definitely helps
@@scientistmilorad9735 it doesnt solve it thats the problem more crime is still happening
@@jamescourt6554 But it definitely helps
Imagine this: In middle of the city, on the well, there is placed a golden grail and everybody is allowed to drink water from it.
But if someone dares to steal that grail, they are gonna catch him, beat him up, torture him, and then impale you on a wooden stake while you are still alive and then puting the stake out on the open sun to fry you while you are slowly and painfully dying.
Well that's what Vlad the Impaler did, and no one stole that grail.
Why not bring this punishment back; it looks like does works well enough.
Are you a muslim?
I’m confused what the NYPD on the title card has to do with any of these when not a single one of these even occur within the state of NY.
Clickbait for " anti racists " monkeys
Flogging still occurs in Ecuador, Dominican Republic(not formally), Cuba(not formally) and Brazil(not formally).
America needs some of these. Canning should be used in America.
No.
As a native speaker of English myself, you’re pretty good at speaking it accent is amazing
huh?
@@iamjohnfarlow lol
*4:47** are you serious? :(*
3:21 i liked how you connected the saudi execution (the quickest death) to the jihadi john videos which he cuts his victims throats, beheading in islam is done from the back of the neck slicing the spinal cord not from the throat side like most of isis videos (the terrorist group) did. I would like to suggest to you that you search more about beheading and compare it to other “merciful” execution methods before calling it barbaric. one more thing if the process of the execution is painless whats the point then of calling it a punishment? like if a child rapist committed such crime should the rapist have a merciful death?
That's absolutely right
It's barbaric. Like your pislam religion.
3:58 saudi arabia still use sord to kill the man who murder a human being!! you think that is not good but try to imagine that human is your mother or son!!!
Some punishments remain because they have preventive effects. That barbaric practice by that terrorists of so called isis has nothing to do with Islam. They harmed Muslims the most
Today this barbaric punishment is still allowed in (insert islamic country here). This video in a nutshell
Most would argue that letting criminals run rampant in your country raping, stealing, and murdering your populace is more barbaric
@@user-op8fg3ny3j Ye dude. I mean chocolate candy with alcohol? Disgusting human being got what he deserved.
In Islamic states, the victims of rape are punished for reason of being attractive.
Fun Fact: imprisonment is a medieval punishment made by Muslims as we know it today at the Islamic golden age. it STILL EXIST Today! it's a very inefficient punishment since it just isolate you from the civilized capitalistic society and connects you to the criminal communist society, they survive by spending our tax money, like parasites. and they get out the prison to be a worse criminal, as people are the summation of the most people they spends time with, which is in this case, CRIMINALS.
it also can be a blessing for some people. they don't need to work, and still have bed, toilet, food, friends, hobbies. IMPRISONMENT IS BY FAR THE MOST INAFFICIENT PUNISHMENT SINCE THERE IS NO PUNISHMENT.
I Think Flogging is much better than that time wasting thing. it's superior by far, since it's fast and make the criminal regrets his actions and think twice before doing something illegal. also, the skin heals so fast also with the help of doctors.
@@user-op8fg3ny3jdamn, at this point you're trying super hard to defend atrocities. Might as well start defending War crimes while you're at it.
Insane to see some of these still exist
Only in the muslim world
@@johnrussell6222 which don't have to worry about rampant criminals that our governments let off the hook multiple times
@@johnrussell6222 says a lot really
Fun Fact: imprisonment is a medieval punishment made by Muslims as we know it today at the Islamic golden age. it STILL EXIST Today! it's a very inefficient punishment since it just isolate you from the civilized capitalistic society and connects you to the criminal communist society, they survive by spending our tax money, like parasites. and they get out the prison to be a worse criminal, as people are the summation of the most people they spends time with, which is in this case, CRIMINALS.
it also can be a blessing for some people. they don't need to work, and still have bed, toilet, food, friends, hobbies. IMPRISONMENT IS BY FAR THE MOST INAFFICIENT PUNISHMENT SINCE THERE IS NO PUNISHMENT.
I Think Flogging is much better than that time wasting thing. it's superior by far, since it's fast and make the criminal regrets his actions and think twice before doing something illegal. also, the skin heals so fast also with the help of doctors.
@@Beowolf5388 especially when you compare the crime rates and safety. People in America wouldn't dare leave their car unlocked.
That's how almost zero crime in KSA.. 🥰
@ricardo-2022chub be loveday. Char chivini ghode pe gaumata mere love day pe
9:14 As an argentinian, i dont know where did you got that information but the only castration my country accepts its the domestic pet one.
Chemical castration seems like about the nicest punishment that you could give to a rapist or kiddy diddler. A heck of a lot nicer than I would be.
It just means they can't get anybody pregnant.
It bolsters their actions in many cases.
Sati (also called suttee) is the practice among some Hindu communities by which a recently widowed woman by use of force or coercion commits suicide as a result of her husband's death. The best known form of sati is when a woman burns to death on her husband's funeral pyre.
Don’t forget about flaying or skinning. Because it’s an ancient method of execution of threatening enemies or criminals for punishment.
nobody does that today unless you talk about cartels ,,,
@@ahmadnaser8172 I’ve seen cartels in Mexico do that to their rivals though
@@virtuesoflocusts9658 as a punishment ofc… a punishment to there rivals..
@@ahmadnaser8172 Have you watched funkytown gore
@@virtuesoflocusts9658 yes and it is aimed toward there own rivals or traitors.. you join the drug game at your own risk ..
Anyone notice the common thread of the countries still using these practices? Btw you didn't mention stoning to death.
I did, and i noticed that as well.
Yeah, they don't have violent crime because unlike us, they don't let repeat criminals of the hook multiple times
Islam and its fonsequences has been disastrous for mankind
@@amacsizbirkisiislam is the reason you're using algorithms to see this video and comment on it
Genuis.
@@ozzyk558 "Algorithms" were not invented, nor improvized, by Mohammadans. The mathematics and cryptography were already known by ancient Greeks, Indians and even Egyptians.
Moreover, Khwarizmi (the guy who is credited with the "creation" of algorithma) was a Persian Zoroastrian (al-Majusi).
lmao'ing at you
Fun fact : France continued using the guillotine until 1977
Muslim countries is the safest places in earth cause once those criminals knows theirs a strong law to stop them they gonna be afraid!
At least I know what countries not to visit, even though I follow the law I'm not taking chances
0:21 the Vikings tv series reference is nice
Europeans thinking of the most painful and utterly horific way to kill a person
YEAH! at least the Islamic world stays with traditional ways.
Lets be real here. There are certain people, most of whom have some control over a nation, that shouldn't have jail time by flogging time
They forgot to mention burning a basket full of black cats, during a burn at the stake.
Fun fact : France continued using the guillotine until 1977
Good
They should probably bring it back
@@spicytrashpanda There’s definitely some horrible people in this world who deserve it
@@MustacheCashStash125 I don't know if you're from the US, but if you aren't, we have a whole registry for them. I don't care about public urinaters, I mean the predators
@@spicytrashpanda Yes. People I think deserve it are people like serial killers, terrorists, child molesters, and warlords
Video is misleading. For instance, when you mention the lashing, it's nothing in the Middle-East like it was in Europe. What we lash them with isn't painful and it's meant to be more of an embarrassing punishment. Even the other things like the chocolate at 2:00 don't ever happen, and bringing up an odd case without emphasizing only serves misinformation.