Afghanistan under the Taliban | DW Documentary
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 22 сен 2024
- Despite the Taliban’s promises of peace and stability, Afghanistan is on its knees. When the militant Islamists took Kabul a year ago, life changed dramatically, especially for women.
Our reporters travel to Afghanistan to find out what life is like under Taliban rule. In a small village in the rural province of Maidan Wardak, they meet Dr. Roshanak. She used to be a member of parliament and always worked to maintain cordial relations with the Taliban.
In the capital Kabul, our reporters spend time with Aisha, who used to work for a UN project and dreamed of a career in politics. Now she feels “like a prisoner”.
They also meet the desperate potters of Istalif, whose business crumbles under the worsening economic crisis. And they encounter members of the Taliban who blame the West for hunger and poverty.
Their return to power is the result of America’s longest war, which started barely a month after the September 11 attacks in 2001.
#documentary #dwdocumentary #afghanistan #taliban
______
DW Documentary gives you knowledge beyond the headlines. Watch top documentaries from German broadcasters and international production companies. Meet intriguing people, travel to distant lands, get a look behind the complexities of daily life and build a deeper understanding of current affairs and global events. Subscribe and explore the world around you with DW Documentary.
Subscribe to:
⮞ DW Documentary (English): / dwdocumentary
⮞ DW Documental (Spanish): / dwdocumental
⮞ DW Documentary وثائقية دي دبليو (Arabic): / dwdocarabia
⮞ DW Doku (German): / dwdoku
⮞ DW Documentary हिन्दी (Hindi): / dwdochindi
For more visit: www.dw.com/en/t...
Follow DW Documentary on Instagram: / dwdocumentary
Follow DW Documental on Facebook: / dwdocumental
We kindly ask viewers to read and stick to the DW netiquette policy on our channel: p.dw.com/p/MF1G
The Afghan Army had 330,000 personnel and billions of dollars in American weapons and equipment, yet in the face of only 80,000 Taliban almost all of them drop their weapons, surrender en masse, or ditch their uniforms and return to civilian life. Truth is, they had everything they needed to defeat the Taliban, they just didn't want to.
If they can defeat taliban then why they didn't? There were lots of Americans, neto and made in America Afghan troops but they couldn't, Actually no one can defeat taliban, they are born to die, if you think world can defeat taliban then come again to Afghanistan, you will see your failure again
It was fake army
Are you really that naive to believe as a country as racist and corrupt as U.S genuinely was interested in keeping Afghanistan peaceful and wanted nation building? 😅
The money was no more there on the table
Air support was gone
You were not here but I was, and I saw everything by my own eyes. Our people were fighting agaunst Taliban with limmited equipments till we heared no one is in givernmental offices. It was another plan of US. They handed over Afg to Taliban. Taliban didn't fight, it was a drama only.
Kabul does not equal Afghanistan. It was a bubble of western prosperity while the rest of the population was subject to constant fighting and fear. It is normal they welcomed any sort of order that would end their situation. Safety (as in not getting your family killed) is the most basic human need..
Well put. First things first for all of the people. Women will win their freedoms in Afghanistan, but the change must come from within Afghanistan, by Afghan lights, and it will take time. But in the meantime, all must eat.
Let's talk about Palestine under Israel, shall we?
How would you feel if another man broke into your home, forced your wife and daughters to turn their back on you.
Then when you and your son fight back , your son is killed you are chained up in the basement, and when your neighbours ask the new man what happened he tells them you are a te****ist planning to attack them and manipulates your defensive actions into the image of unreasonable violence
Taliban never ensured anyones safety, they literally blew themselves up in the middle of a bazaar
Two bad things can happen at the same time.
Prefect example of the saying "Sell your freedom to get security you get neither"
So true
Dont trust western media, they set traps
I've never heard this, but omg, I love it.
some important fact checks by an afghan:
first of all, the first afghan parliament was LITERALLY the most corrupted parliament ever in the short republic period; secondly, Dr roshanak was always notorious for taking money from the govt and the Americans that apparently she hates; besides that, she was a literal warlord, grabbing people's lands in wardak province and things like that
well i hope you guys enjoy your new government. Congrats you won.
@@peiershen8221 no I’m absolutely not enjoying it lol, I escaped Afghanistan 5 months ago
Her obvious love for material is apparent in the way she dresses, eats and lives in a grandiose house when compared to the surroundings, where for hundreds of miles, an impoverished people live in a marginalized region.
@@kumarj4693 I still have not seen any photos of starving Taliban.. funny that...
Afghanis need voices of reason like you.
Interviews with women who have fled Afghanistan after the Taliban take over “The Taliban are terrible, they treat us like animals, they won’t let us go to school and I had to flee because I was scared for me life. Why didn’t the Americans stay and protect us?”
Interview with women inside Afghanistan “Everything’s great! We always loved the Taliban and didn't like the Americans!”
Only those people are against taliban who want green card .... And western loss the war battle and now they are trying to start war on media but we don't care ... We don't know media we know the ground reality
both of them are saying what they have to say right ?
Because the Taliban will punish them for telling the truth. Go ask someone who lives in North Korea the same question versus a defector. You will get the same result.
So? They might have different opinions on the situation. Pretty obvious someone who have fled did it for a reason and someone who stays do it for another reason.
The women who fled Afghanistan have been telling us that they would have been killed in a bloodbath by the Taliban. Was there a bloodbath? No. That one is easy to verify.
True peace is not merely the absence of war, it is the presence of justice.
I found this quote by mother of social work profession, Jane Addams.
And?
@@Zergul_Zai and what?
@@kuromistan645 they just talk nice..
@Kurt M. that's why divine guidance came" in the form of qauran" to show us true justice, even though we are failing to implement it.
That is true, but we need it step by step. first absence of war than justice and maybe democracy. The most of time people looking to much forward and to greedy. I think with peace and with the pressure from the other contries, The women will get there rights and etc. Even in the western countries the women not always have the same right. All things need time. The problem by people in the developed countries and undeveloped is like US think it right and it is true the way they are thinking, but they never think about how long time it takes from 0 to 1 for themself. Look back in the histories and look how the original people lives now and how many left?
The lady doctor did not say a single word about women's rights, girls' education, and freedom of speech. I think she is quite happy to see that no lady doctor will be in society in the future.
Because that's the only thing to talk about in the world ?
She is happy no one will take her job and her children can study abroad to become next doctors.
She gave me the creeps.
@graveplott47 they probably want to but they have to think about what happens to their families if they get killed by the Taliban
Now you see cultures that never introduced women rights and girls education like many western cultures did.
The hardest and painful thing in this documentary is, this doctor is one of our relatives. Served in the local clinic during the Taliban government back in 1990s (the only female doctor in entire province) and then during all this period. Let us not take it to the politics here, but she spent all her life serving to the women - it is clear and obvious that we need women doctors in our society as a Woman in that culture and society cannot tell about some of their sicknesses to the male doctors (you know culture) and hopefully girls are allowed to study and work as soon as possible. Communities requires women, I don't know where them "Taliban" are getting that from not to allow girls to go to schools. Islam and Quran says it louder "Studying and learning is obligatory since you open your eyes until you die to every single human being." The countries they look up to, not what we say - they allow freely women to study, work, and have their own freedom, then why the only country on earth do not do this?
They follow the hanafi school of thought and that will be quite different than Saudi arabi, Qatar in terms of rulings(like should women drive, go without a male family member)
A good example: in hanafi fiqh women do not require permission of wali(father, brother) for marriage but in hanbali fiqh which is in saudi and neighboring countries marriage is invalid without the consent of male guardian
I dont think any non arab looks at them (arabs) for governance purposes after the fall of Baghdad
Yes they have to check and balance what is being teached in the political science in womens equality chapter
They have to look for the romance stories in english and remove them as well in short reframe the western curriculum which goes againt their beliefs
shes a feminist and she should sit at home
Culture
The Quran also contradicts itself a lot and Abraham and Ishmael would never agree with Islam
@@onewotldgovernmentonlywhen9044 - where and how the does the Quran contradict itself? Examples please!
That first lady was tripping.. If Taliban is so great then why do they need to change their view on women?
You should've asked this lady (Roshana Wardak) was it possible for her if she was in Afghanistan under TBs previous regime. How did she got her MD and became a doctor? Definitely not in Afghanistan under TB..
Women are attending medical schools in Afghanistan under the Taliban.
So? What if she didn't have that MD? Being a mother and wife is far more important.
@@hanzalaomar9915 No it's not. What is important is for the women to have the right to choose, instead of illiterate barbars that live in a 1400 year old fantasy choosing for them.
@@hanzalaomar9915 Not every woman wants to be a mother or wife. Shouldn’t that be her choice?
I was thinking the same thing. But it might be allowed for gyancology as it is immodest for a man to examine a woman that closely / intimate ly
The fact that far more Afghans fled Afghanistan when the Taliban took over than travelled to Afghanistan at the same time is evidence enough
The fact that the Taliban was Created By the West and whenever it is the time it is always used is fascinating scheme
@§pec 0ps. With USA and Western sponsorship
@@starcapture3040 the USA supported the Mujahideen. Which split after the war with the USSR.
You know who does support the taliban? Pakistan
@@invertedv12powerhouse77 Both they do and both are corrupted and bloody thieves
Mostly Saudi Arabia supported the Mujahideen
I truly wish the best upon Afghanistan!
Yea, but wishes never work, action is the only way.
#LoveTheEssenceOfTheGospel
🔥🔥🔥💝💝💝💘🏩🏩🏩🍞🍞🍸🔌😋😍🧁🍨🍥🎀🍡🚀💝💘💘🥂🧅🎂
@@spaceballs44 why they live this way of life before global super powers even existed
The women at 6:40 who speaks about feeding her children, at 6:38 she hits a child for taking bread that she clearly wanted for her children.
This is seriously bleak and depressing.
She hit her daughter because she was robbed by the child , why do your minds only look on the bad side ?
@@exvai4150 how is your description the good side?!
your filthy state made afghanistan like this
@@dafuggful And the bad side is that you distort the image of the citizens. There are those who died of hunger and do not steal, unlike the first world who steal for the sake of luxury.
That boy snatched food from the girl, and she got hit by her mom also for incompetence. Such is the grave situation of females in the country
Archaic stone age country with ak47s
That’s what you get after 20 years of war with US.
Blessed by Allah. Stop being jealous & criticising the Islamic Republic of Afghanistan and its true heroes the Taliban.
@@MaTara01 ur country is hungry
@@SumGuy554 you don't know which country I belong to. Allah provides for this world, not the corrupt, godless West, which is well on its way to doom. Inshallah.
@@MaTara01 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡
We are so proud to be Malaysian. We also the Muslim country but we manage our Countries in proper ways. Women also got their own wright.... Taliban should learn something from the Economic Muslim Country like Malaysia, Brunei & Indonesia. Taliban should change their mind to be fair to all of their Citizens. Islam teach us to be fair to everyone.....
All Muslims should be ashamed, as should all religious people. This is what faith does to a society.
Muslim men should have to wear burka and hijab…
Muslim women standup…use ur men to fight talibans..look at Ukraine…foreigners cannot support forever
Tell ur men to show balls not corruption
@ManuLMalik
Waalaikummussallam, thanks my brotha for your traveling to our country. Very appreciate it.... hope so U will come again. Everyone are wcome at anytimes.
Wow, a country where women drink, smoke and have sexual relationship outside of marriage telling Afghanistan to learn from them..may Allah guide you.
@@ABmr.360right because there’s not a single woman in Afghanistan that hasn’t committed adultery, smoked, or committed a crime before every woman in Afghanistan is just a perfect angel every last one of them…. Like really?? Do you really believe that??? You are beyond naive if you believe that. And not all women in free countries act like that there’s bad people everywhere but that doesn’t represent that majority. But geuss what I would much rather let women have their right to choose how they conduct themselves than force them to act a certain way and kill them if they don’t abide by YOUR INTERPRETATION of sharia law. And no one was telling you to learn from the mistakes that women make in free countries they try to teach afghans how to treat women like human beings. I can tell by your comment that your blinded by bias and are an ignorant person who can’t think outside of your bubble that your mind lives in.
All the best for Afghanistan - wish peace, justice and prosperity and happiness.
"""""You yourself wanted to live in Islam and now you are living, this was your choice and no one can help you because of your own fault.""""" 🔥
@@RealNeutronStar we don't need yur useless opinions we are happy with islam because it's our religion you have no right to attack a sovereign country on their culture and values mind your own business
@@muhammadhussain5854 From here in the Pacific Northwest, wishing you and your fellow countrymen, women and children all the best.
@@muhammadhussain5854 Silly people support Taliban
1. Banning boxing
2. Banning music
3. Banning drawings
4. Banning photography
5. Banning movies
6. Banning women high-heeled shoes that produce a sound
7. Banning women showing their hair
8. Banning women wearing perfume
9. Banning women going out
10. Banning women to breathe after stoning
Wherever Islam go its bring disaster with him
Her cows look better fed than most people their these days. Can't believe she is sat to there in luxury. And I bet her clinic isn't free
The easy answer to this is because we the US are using food and other goods as a war on them just like we cry about Russia using gas as a war on the EU we are all hypocrites
the most woke liberturd comments I've ever seen...
Does human can eat cow food who literally could scraps anything on dump sites?
Does cow a pet that produces nothing?
Liberal country have it worst like literally one throwing a single meal for hundreds of dollars... Feeding pets premium food and premium meat that human could consumed... But yeah let's talk about a woman who serve the country instead of.extreme filth rich 1% in U.S who literally still have homeless and one of the worst worst crime rates in a developed country....
And she talk about Islam , how sad how sad Perfect Muhammed stays if your neighbour is hungry and you are in comfort soo you are not not a Muslim
Her clinic is free and the house is of her husband why don’t ask why America is freezing afghanistan even if they are terrorist the children have nothing to do with them
@@محمدغربي-ب3ب absolutely my dear Absolutely 😢😢😢😢😢🇦🇱🇦🇱🇦🇱🇦🇱☪️☪️☪️☪️☪️☪️
Nobody is helping Afghanistan instead they are busy to blame Taliban.
Western politicians and reporters get votes and sell ads by blaming the Taliban, fairly and unfairly. But the West, and the Islamic world, through the United Nations, are doing a lot to help in Afghanistan. It has spent hundreds of millions of dollars to feed Afghans since the Taliban retook the country last year. The authoritarian nations like Russia and China aren't blaming the Taliban, but are spending very little to help Afghans.
right i don't know after boycotting an entire country on regime level what else too expect
Taliban: "Cover yourself, cook in kitchen, make babies (only boys), and don't go outside...we give you good life"
This is ridiculous! 😂you have no idea what are you talking about? Do you?
all that stuff about the untouchables in India probaly isn't true either
@@hermanrowell3081 no, they are true! Indians are our immediate neighbors. Taliban also sucks. But, they are thousand miles away. However I just objected on the part 'make babies ( only boys )'.
@@khabibnurmagomedov9707 But they do want only boys. They do not value women... only as slaves. It's disgusting.
@@hermanrowell3081 are you dumb or what untouchables have reservations in India. The constitution of India was written by an untouchable
These people live in the stone age.
Kensington Ave , Philadelphia ... watch on youtube 🧐
Stone age with rocket launchers
@@glenncordova4027 🤣🤣🤣🤣😩😭
Superb documentary.
As an American, I don't know what to think. I hate to see women with those damn full head coverings, but 20 years of our intervention did ZERO to change it. Change must come from within.
I know you won't believe this but they choose to wear the full head covering. Taliban made it a legal requirement to wear the head scarf only.
I hated that same woman complaining about her children starving to death because nobody is giving her more than a load of bread. Surely, there is a way you could find one additional morsel of food.
Wdym zero to change it? The girl in the video literally was talking about before the Taliban took over she was free to be herself and was happy
All we did is kill people their. Made it unsafe for most afghans and now ukraine is suffering the same fate as Afghanistan.
You can't change people culture. Instead changing them, feed them when they are hungry. You guys were there because Afghanistan sits on USD3 trillions minerals.
If they want to live under the Taliban, let them, and leave them to themselves. Just don't blame the "West" for any problems.
We dont for fuck sake, she is a terrorist supporting suicide bombers, suicide attacks and tousands of others war crimes, resistance continues…
Precies sabientjree
This realisation is good. But if don't take responsibility So why you bombed Afghanistan.
Yes, Maximum problem created by West. West bombed on Iraq just for a False "news". Iraq now totally destroyed. Now who is blamed for iraq?
@@rumyhasan4145 russia
@@rumyhasan4145 For more than 10 years there is no west in Iraq anymore, but Iraqis fight against eachother. As long as they don't solve their homemade problems they won't come to rest.
She blames the West for abandoning Afghanistan, meanwhile before the West ever interferd women in Afghanistan never had any rights already.
We were trying to make it better, fair society
Afghan women had their rights before 1992 when the US supported Mujahedeen and Islamists to take over the power and instill the Sharia.
There is good picture of Taliban leaders in the White House… Was G.Bush a terrorist ?
@@RostamBahadur so there was no Taliban then?
she should also blame the Afghan government and her countrymen, they were corrupt and refused to fight
Afghans are facing hunger but are not begging to world. They are truly following 'to die with hunger is not a crime but to live on begging is a shame'.
May god bless all of the peoples of Afghanistan and their nation for a future of peace, prosperity and cohesion.
Allah has gone on holiday and does not care about Afghanistan anyway...
If their god existed, don't you think the place would be a bit better of by now? One of the most % islamic country on the planet and such disaster zone.
@@cyberfunk3793 same with their mates in Pakistan, Iran, Iraq, Yemen... all crying for evil western aid, and all trying to get to evil western countries to be ruled by the white man...
Thanks you so much
@@milesinnz nobody cares about your delusions infidel
Taliban or pro-Taliban, they have the mentality of fight and war.
Afghanistan was a modern peaceful country in the 70s. Pakistan is the sole reason for the sufferings of Afghanistan.
US & Russia is. Not Pakistan
@@arhamakhyar3088pakistan created the Taliban in the first place, I would say Pakistan had a pretty big role
@@parkerl5261
Lmao,delusion
@@arhamakhyar3088 delusion? You do realize once the soviet union was kicked out, the ISI started to severely help and fund groups like the taliban. Do a little research my friend, pakistan is not the SOLE reason, but they are definitely a reason for the suffering in Afghanistan to this day.
The greatest challenge of this world is knowing enough about a subject to think you are right, but not knowing enough about the subject to know you are wrong…
that's so dumb
@@jacer5677 Agreed
i think what ur trying to describe is the dunning kruger effect.
one thing is clear, the Taliban can't rule a country.
Then what if sombody is really right and he thinks so aswell?
This is how religion can destroy whole nation
So the wars have no relation to what is happening right now?
So why did Soviet Union fell?
They were Atheist.
And why West biggest enemy is China which is ALSO atheist.
Or decades of war and destruction?????
This was the most balanced report on this issue I've seen. Bravo.
No, this wasn't! believe me. Things are much different then the perspective of these 4 guys
@@huzaifafarrukh Link to a better report?
@@huzaifafarrukhyou’re most likely a man , and we can’t believe anything you say.
@@huzaifafarrukhmullah should stop talking
@@pipipupu5104 Can you phrase down the details, please? I didn't understand
My heart aches for my Afghan brothers and sisters. I have grown up watching this beautiful nation getting destroyed. My own country Pakistan and other regional powers played a dirty role.
Afghanistan has always been destroyed. It is for good. They blame everything on Pakistan 💩
Are you sure Pakistan is a regional power? Half of pskistani people are dealing with malnutrition and the other half by the floods! Be wise please!
Pakistan saved Afghanistan, first from soviets, but pakistan shouldn’t have helped America war in Afghanistan.
It's like this for thousand years. When Islam came to Afghan it was already over
@@arman3291 You like it or not but its a fact Pakistan and India both are regional military powers. People of both countries are suffering though Pakistan is not alone.
he's says leave us alone to run our country, but at the same time wants help from the west. you can't have it both ways.
Just return their money. I think that is just.
Unfortunately many nations have taken advantage of the afghan people foreign and domestic. Not just the west.
Tell the US to return their stolen money
@@robertkerr9527 yes, America as well as the west
@@muhammadeliasqureshi1255 most of this money was given from the west to the previous government
Now the taliban Don’t have the right to it
Very sad to see beautiful kids begging... Please anyone change the situation.
6:35 Look at that Girl child tried to get a bread and a boy snatched it . then the mother slapped the girl . this is miracle of Islam they always talk . boy gender always first .
It’s not just Islam. It’s internalized misogyny and we see it everywhere
I agree, men are better!!
just like Allah and Mohammad intended it be quite woman
Men fight the wars build infrastructure, planes, cars extract oil. Of course they are better.
That was terrible to watch.. I am a Muslim myself.. and please.. don't mix Islam with the narrow thinking of some Muslims. Islam gives rights to Muslims. The wife of our prophet was a business woman! Women are given rights to study and to do jobs just like men. The thing is that some people don't understand it and mix it with their cultural behaviors and just blindly say that this is what our religion says. There is a difference in culture and religion.. I agree that Most Muslims think like that.. and we should blame them and their thinking. Not Islam. It's like if a Christian serial killer kills people then would you say that Christianity teaches people to kill eachother? No. Obviously not.. because those are the deeds of the specific person. Not what the religion teaches.
7:23 Problem of the TB is it their narrow perspective and narration. You can't blame NATO for not being able to feed your people. The women had ten children which means you need more food than you are able to harvest.
At the same during the TB hadn't power several women studied agriculture but aren't accepted as equal so their knowledge is erased. You want to keep them dumb, so stand up for your own failures as well. If this is the nation you want, this is exactly your result.
The country had been racked by war for 44 years. It hadn't been able to feed itself since shortly after the Soviet invasion. It has relied on massive US spending to keep itself going for the last 20 years. We jerked the carpet out from under Afghanistan a year ago, blocked development aid, confiscated its foreign cash reserves, put it under sanction, and ostracized it. Do you really blame the Taliban for having created that situation and for not having been able to fix it within a year?
@@myahsoodinim8570 When the TB took over they wanted to kill everyone who worked with organizations from abroad. They impose litterally their religious believes on others. You can do so, but then don't complain that other countries won't help you.
The US first went in to get revenge for 9/11, if that was smart can be a discussion. But most other army's came in to rebuild and keep people safe so a generation would be able to grow up educated. And read more books instead of this single religious one.
We all wanted the country to be stable, some even suffered their life for it or still suffering mentally. Only they say as well some weren't willing to fight for it. And being traumatized rather chewing qat all day... As long as the women prefer boys because they are able to fight the different cultures inside this area will keep clashing all the time.
Why did NATO bomb Afghanistan? Why did they try to change afghan society?
Yes thieves like you are not blame
@@mainulvaimbbs Maybe because they searched for a guy called Osama and a group of terrorists who operated outside their borders. While Afghanistan did nothing to prosecute him. So as government, play stupid games win stupid prizes. The bombing is done to prevent deaths from people who came to help and the battle is mostly won in the air.
They tried to change it in a democracy because it is the worst system except for any other system. Lots of NATO countries were personally asked within the government to help the peacekeeping and rebuild the country. So when there is a risk the NATO brings protection with them, that were the rules of engagement Afghani's aggreed with. The idea that cultural change happens over 20 years is just imagination, it will take at least some generations.
Also I spoke some refugees and a women activist of the group protesters, who can't study anymore, and they don't feel safe because they now see trigger happy bad guys on the street, instead of some well trained military.
Imagine what you would do if everything you did gets destroyed and this person comes to beg for help... than you would let them complain but know you held up your part of the deal. Exactly what NATO is doing. So complaining and blaming doesn't gonna help, but together work hard might do...
So sad could never imagine treating a woman like that so alien to me God bless them
There is a big difference between a rogue fighter and an efficient administrator.....
Never let the feelings of some naive and unknowledgeable person represent the situation of a country, It’s called misrepresentation.
As an American I'm glad to see we stopped trying to be the worlds police at least in this country. I don't care if we agree with their rules it's not our country. 🧐
The American military was training the Afghan Army gave them equipment and weapons. When the Taliban came rolling in they laid their guns on the ground and left and didn’t fight back.
That woman doesn’t understand is they just needed to hand over osama and it would be over faster
Yes, right u said.
@@googleisbad should Iraq take revenge?
I'm glad that they are doing good
There's always security in a graveyard.
Nope! there is nothing to steal in the graveyard.
@@AIfixmath both, both are good points not gonna lie😂
@@AIfixmath you did not understand his metaphor
People can live there but I dont think anyone from west countries would decide to live there.
They dont want westerners they've seen enough of them
The Western countries have too much blood in their hand
no junk food no service station every 5 miles no driveby shootings no obesity problem no litter everywhere nor animal habit and enviornment destruction nothing like the West
west is destroyed trough spiritual trough fatness trough honor they are nothing
@@hermanrowell3081 move to afghanistan if you love it so much.
These people will never change their mentality. If they loved their children more than the religious beliefs, they will prosper.
Loving children is a major part of our belief little girl
Once again religions doing what they are meant to do: separate and tell people how to live their lives.
That was the west
i wonder who stole Afghanistan's money and practically imposes a siege warfare on them
@@hanzalaomar9915 Your a great example 👍
Just like any rule with different variations on every country, Human need guidance,
even you & me, so people can live in harmony,
some
Every situation here is just Vietnam War on replay again. The post reunification hardship was the worst. Focusing on internal reconciliation and rebuilding is the only way to move forward. I wish all the best to Afghan people.
true
We missed the assignment.. we shouldn't have raised the women out of their misery and educated their daughters we needed to convince them to change their son's from animals to humans.
I think I get it, SO SHE'S NOT BEING TRUTHFUL
Wow, well said.. incredible observation. Thank you
Yh you would have done a great job calling other people's sons animals. They would have definitely been convinced
Even an animal knows wrong from right. these evil people, don't. So they're monsters.
Before there was The Taliban, women were equal, they had rights. Some dressed like western women, That is how you know how terrible The Taliban affected Kabul :(
Don't always blame the west or American. Your mindset n governence is also responsible
Yes indeed. Their mindset
It really says something about the support base of a power when all those men need to carry weapons to keep that in check. I think most of the population hate the taliban. They have nothing to do with the origins of Afghanistan. They keep the population hostage with their own beliefs and views. Nothing new in the world but really hard to change. In some time from now there will be a new civil war, resistance and seperation. I really wish Afghan people the best, they have gone through so much.
0:01 hey that's my vest!
The fact that we see your comment
Priceless 😅
Afghanistan a mess smh poor people are deceive.
Poor afghan women...
Women enjoy all the freedoms given by allah, they dont need anything else
@@sumbajumba3037 what are those freedoms, out of curiosity?
@@sumbajumba3037 like Aisha
@@sumbajumba3037 no they don't. Thy don't get secondary education from allah apparently
@Zubair Ahmed no thanks. A benevolent God wouldn't force women to a life of subservience to husband its equal, all humans are equal and a truly great God would honor every living soul and endow it with agency and respect. Telling women they have to be mothers is not respect, its ignorant, its evil, its sin. God is neither male nor female, men and women can work, and men are also capable of doing house work. Choice should always be honored and your fake made up idea of God is nothing but a patriarchal construct from a dying era.
I am grateful President Biden kept his promise and pulled U.S. troops from that dismal hellhole. Afghans didn’t want us there. Americans didn’t want to be there, and now we are gone everyone is happier. Afghans have the Islamic system they wanted and the peace they desired. Afghanistan is now an Afghan problem and it’s up to them to create the country they want.
8:00 the irony of the Taliban saying "we want autonomy. let us live and make our own choices" but not letting half of his country (women) do the same
What a ridiculous oaf
So we should let them roam showing their body to other men not obeying their husbands? This is the autonomy you people want? Shame on you.
4:03 the female doctor describes a jungle where wilde animals live and prosper depending on their ability to fight. This women only supports tiliban because they're from her own tribe and she's not discriminated against. She's not mistreated like the nonpashtuns.
Please be rational during passing comments.
May ALLAH SWT bless all of us.
May be she dont want to die from a suicidal attacks
Yes,she would think differently if she was trying to study to be a doctor,an the carpet got ripped out from under her. She has a good job,think of all the younger generation that aren't to work,or walk around alone for that matter.
Yeah the women are going to be screwed when all the ones who were allowed to be educated die off.
I get it - Afghans are angry with the US for "abandoning them" and leaving them defenseless against Taliban rule. But it was our blood that bought your freedom. It is not our responsibility to die for your freedoms as a woman. That is only something you can do - as a citizen and woman of Afghanistan. You must fight now, for those freedoms you wanted us to fight for you.
It is no longer our fight.
Your country destroyed Afghanistan
@@quantumballs1488 the taliban destroyed Afghanistan
@@quantumballs1488 there was nothing to destroy in the first place. they were doing that part all on their own with decades of tribal and civil war. they never stopped long enough to even build a country. their entire economy relied on US taxpayer money because able bodied men didn’t want to work and women who were eager to work weren’t allowed to.
@@norman6694Do a research and then talk buddy.
@obiazmi ask the women and little boys of Afghanistan to do research
Thank you for also interviewing Afghan men. They always get excluded from the conversation.
Afghans are resilient and tough. 🇦🇫❤
Afghans are suffering and dying.
@Farhad Ahmadi the west has done nothing to you. Nobody owes the Taliban a damn thing. If you choose to function like an archaic regime, don’t come crying about the west.
@Farhad Ahmadi My Afghan friend, along with his family, fled to Canada with his family following the Taliban's violent resurgence last year
He says the Taliban are to blame for the national poverty and starvation by, among other things, banning secondary education for Afghan women and silencing the country's ethnic and religious minorities
@Farhad Ahmadi lol enjoy your Afghanistan. As far as you don’t harbor terrorists that threaten the west, I promise, you have absolutely nothing we want.
@Farhad Ahmadi 🤣 'Cradle of science and knowledge'?? Mate, it's called the 'graveyard of empires' for a reason; this is also a sign of the fate of Taliban's presence in the country
Now while it's true that the ancient Silk Road passed through Afghanistan, that doesn't mean the region's gonna flourish anytime soon
DW is 1000% better channel for true news and ground reporting...
Blaming others for their food troubles. Now its their responsibility.
You have 10 children, do you have a cow ??
😃😃😉
moooooouuuuu
how about do you have contraceptive
@@hermanrowell3081 they probably don't
@@pattynellis7347 your probably right plus contraceptives i think probably would be frowned upon and the woman probaly receives great social significance for having many children i wouldn't doubt the husband using contraception devices if they did have them for fire wood the culture always knows best
Make the detiotions that you want for your country BUT why do you expect the money from abroad ???
Nobody is asking for handouts, just need sanctions removed for the afghan people to eat (including women which the West cares very deeply about)
Exactly
@@keyboardmouse7699 Yes hey are, why do they specct having the good life ruling while the rest feed their people. Maybe is the way women have to live there, Why do we have to tell them HOW ??
Because Americ froze 9 billion of Afghani peoples money.
This is what you get when you’re unwilling to fight for your own freedom.
This is the beauty of Islam..
MF US & USSR ruined Afghanistan for their own benefits.
at the beginning the story was US was going to Afghanistan only to root out terrorist cells that could threaten the US and i think find Osama bin Laden
@@shahnawaz_58 the Us didnt force islamic sharia on them. This is all because of religion.
Not exactly. Of all their achievements, afghanistan under taliban is a poor and powerless country. It is more of pashtun tribal ideology with islamic flavor.
The religion doesn't ask to abandon worldy values. In classical islamic lands power, trade, prosperity, literature and culture were enriched. It is just pashtun traditionalists not wanting to change their way of life. Whether it be communism or capitalism or consumerism or liberalism, they simply don't want them.
Now I don't see imposing a war on them as a legitimate method to help them change their way of life.
@@saimbhat6243 the religion dosent ask to abandon worldly values ????, all religions do, the word worldly is seen as evil and sinful and when one says it's not religion it's the pashtun traditionalist culture, then one must ask how much influence has religion already played in forming the pashtun traditionalist culture. i would never think a culture has ever been formed without religion playing a dominate or at least a major role in its formation. asking the pashtun traditionalist to change is asking them to abandon their religion=the religious view of their religion=you can't up and change a culture from its religious view just like that it dosent work religion is a form of control. religious traditionalist people all over the world are steadfast, they don't see themselves that way, they see themselves as following the laws of god.
Wow balanced documentory, may be for the safety of the reporters. 👍
Thank you! We're glad you liked the documentary. Subscribe to our channel for the latest uploads.
3:15 "because you have 10 kids , is there a Cow?" lol that went straight to her face
I thought it was a caption mistake soni went back again. So funny
FreeAfghanistan 🇮🇳❤️🇦🇫 from 🇮🇳
😢😢😢 This is so unbelievable tragic for women and girls
Keep crying
Wrong un @@Account2129
I can smell them through the screen. Please stay there.
They want you to stay where u are not the contrary
Ey yo spare them by not returning 🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼 please bro tell your govt
Cruel taunt.
As-Salaam-Alaikum. Anyone else wonder how the Lady physician who reportedly supports the Taliban regime ever had the opportunity to attend a medical school and become her province's only female physician? Maybe when she said that she is happy to live under the Taliban government she is pleased that there will be no other female doctors to compete against her business..., maybe yes maybe no. She certainly looks very relaxed and well fed.
Universities were open for woman under the 90s rule. They have problems with 6-12 class education of woman.
Don't know why, lol
The Afghans wanted the US out now they have this.
They must talk to their neighbours Iran, Pakistan and China if they need anything.
It's not our problem any more
People lost their home lose their dreams. After Taliban come to power. The worse things is that people die from starvation
I you don’t fight for your freedom when Americans are helping you, then you got what you deserve. Live free or die.
We know thats a fucking lie
freedom with americans 😂😂😂😂?
U call by Americans attacking Afghanistan and destroy the country an the killing of thousands of innocent people that u call help remember this is a Muslim country our value an American is not the same
They want to us to stay out of their business it at the same time expect us to send them aid.
Then stay out of their business
@@imrankh68 and don't send aid.
@@captrockh2055 Right, just give their money back. Keep the aid.
Thank you so much for your wonderful job I hope some day we get longer each other. I’m so glad for the freedom we have here in USA 🇺🇸 I hope everyone have that opportunity. Please take care your self 💙💙💙
An American is talking about peace 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
America is the main culprit for the situation of Afghanistan because Afghanistan once was more civilised but USA destroyed all this things in an excuse of security.... 😡
@@shahabrahimi1495 a Muslim talking about peace before exploding in to thin air.
@@ernststavrosblofeld366 What about Hiroshima Japan? Have shame
@@emlive2290 Mauritania (Islamic country) still practice sex slavery to this day
I don't understand at all why they don't ask Allah for help?
Lòl
Coz Allah doesn't exists
Actually, Allah states that life on Earth is temporary & useless and all Muslims should follow Islam according to Sharia law and then Allah will reward them with material pleasures eternal heaven (only for the men though). And he also says that they should not complain and lose their faith, while suffering.
It's not enough. Prayers won't answer if money doesn't involve. Give their wealth to mosques and Islamic organisation then Arab Allah will help them
@@arolemaprarath6615 you need to read the Quran and its prophecies, which clearly state that suffering will become unendurable for the pious people who follow Allah, but if they get through with it, they will go to Heaven for Eternity.
“ Give me liberty or give me death” Patrick Henry
It's isn't it really "Give them death till they're given liberty."? We have Afghanistan under sanctions on trade, finance, travel, commerce and development aid. We've made human rights a condition of lifting those sanctions. That is strangling the economy and reducing the country's ability to feed its citizens - just after a war, and during a drought. That conditionality has already started to kill a few men, women and children. The Taliban are largely to blame, but we're are nevertheless saying "Give them death till they're given liberty."
We have got our bodies to serve and protect us, our faces to express our emotions and see them in other people. How come men there are allowed to have that luxury of life and women are not?
How would we know? It's the way these backwards people live.
it's instinctive to dominate men have always sought to dominate females seen in patriarchal societies so men create male dominate societies and make sure the prophets of their religion and god also believe in male domination or at least is interpreted as such. men are also highly threatened by the females sexuality and leads to oppressive and exzazzarated culture control patterns take a look at the animal kingdom of the dominate male
sorry to be blatant many males feel women are inferior when it comes to competency the diversity of sex sets up a male verses female situation testosterone vrs estrogen it's the law of the land to be solved by culture
@@hermanrowell3081 Stop it, get some help...
@@bonnie7898 what ever is said i think we know whoes brains it is that are over heating. to me this isn't about what people call (feminism) it's about the correct treatment of people and being fair. my sister's have had their own autos sense the early 70's go as they please taking care of family affairs visite who they want and they are very capable i never worry about them because i know there is no need to yes their married now have grand children and capable of making their own choices plus their very decent and moral women
what an amazing documentary
you are a very brave crew for going there and recording this footage
Foreign reporters have been going in and out of Afghanistan all year and have faced no problems from the Taliban.
@@myahsoodinim8570 "no problems" is an understatement. They don't get murdered and kidnapped as often anymore. And yes, the Taliban used to do that, actually. Not sure how you can celebrate them for doing this just a little less.
@@Andreas-gh6is I'd say it's fair game for killing Afghan women and children.
DW is best at making documentaries and is more interested to find the solution to the problem rather than pushing their bias.
Bravo to the team 👏
Prayers for Afghanistan ❤
Thanks a lot for watching and for your positive feedback. We appreciate you taking the time to comment and are glad you like our content!
Excellent reporting, DW. Thanks.
"""""You yourself wanted to live in Islam and now you are living, this was your choice and no one can help you because of your own fault.""""" 🔥
You mean propaganda
@@siratal-mustaqim2614 no that's Islam
Does the good doctor honestly believe that the last 20 years before the final betrayal were not a testament to the great freedom that Americans brought to Afghanistan. As long as the American forces were there Afghan women were free to study and live but as soon as they were pulled out everything went to back to 1999. I do not understand the lack of gratitude to the brave heroes of the American Armed Forces.
Afghanistan is and always has been a male dominated society. Women in Afghanistan face greater restrictions under the Taliban than under the prior government, but they were hardly "free to study and live" under the last government either. After 20 years under the old government, female literacy only got to 30% (according to UNESCO). Now, at least, they live in a country at peace.
lol.Was she supposed to show her gratitude for Bombing her village
@@zakiyasarkar2029 bombing her village that had terr0rist who wanted to oppress the women.
Was she supposed to show gratitude to the U.S for funding the Taliban and bringing them to power?
@@ricksanchez8584 The US never funded the Taliban. You are thinking of the Mujahideen of the 1980's whom we supported against the Soviets. The Taliban only emerged in 1994, after we ended our involvement. Most of the Mujahideen leaders fought the Taliban and formed the core of the government that the US set up after its invasion. Only a fraction of the Mujahideen joined the Taliban.
2:39 why they came to our country? Because of your system, and when your on parliament. corruption killing poor people getting poor, education, health, infrastructure, & basically teaching you rich people don't ever drain poor people tax and hardly earn salary.
They like pure Islam. Let em enjoy
I feel for the women and girls of Afghanistan whose own fathers and brothers treat them so terribly. The reality is that men don't want women to have even the most basic rights because they fear that women will not need them anymore. Look at most modern societies and you'll see that women are opting out of marriage (something created by men) and choosing to pursue their education and career-- and that men are not willing to do the same but expect women to lower their standards. It doesn't matter if one woman claims she's happy with the Taliban ruling. It matters that all women have access to education and freedom to make decisions. Not only will it benefit the women, but their children as well. They live in a society where men rule and it's become the survival of the strongest. Women and children are ignored.
The same thing was happening when taliban wasnt in rule, I dont see any comment or any person saying those same words when that was the case. 2ndly taking a small sample out of an immense population is what the media always does. People are literally dying over there for basic needs, men and women. The UN is the one that hoards resources now that they lost the fight in Afghanistan and somehow the taliban are to blame?. All the criteria for the acceptance of Afghanistan has been filled by the taliban. They follow Islam there. Men dont have a say just as much as women if you've ever read anything about that religion. The reason why women are moving away from marriages are because of feminist movement. Not because of "men". Neither was marriage created for the benefit of men it was for women. Naturally men are built to do jobs that require physical powers. Even in this technological age where mental fortitude is considered more important, men still do jobs that women simply cant. Hence the wage and salary gap. A consequence of women "pursuing careers" is your west. I dont even need to say anything anymore. Look at your familial system. Its non-existant. The only gender that benefitted from women going out are actually men. Single mothers. One night stands. No responsibility of children. Easy to complete your sexual desires.
" It matters that all women have access to education and freedom to make decisions" What matters more than this is the ability to have enough resources to live. You never mention those. People are dying over there and the only thing you're concerned about is "education". What did that education do for you westerners?. The highest positions your men and women hold arent because of educations whatsoever, its because they were entrepreneurs. You are lost and narrow minded I hope you find an actual path to believe and go on.
men want control of women and when men create religion they put in place control mechanisms in writings to control women and of course the claim is, they were put there by their god=male domination
"and choosing to pursue their education and career"
Yes, better work a soulless job in the office than have children. I agree, all hail progressive values! Look the depression rates among women in the US. It might surprise you.
It is sad that a woman says having girls makes the family weak, and with boys It is strong... Without girls no grown woman, no wife to their sons and also no new babies or sons...
More or less like North Korea
North Korea is much better. No Islam
Nope, not close at all. North Korea treats their population like actual cattle its horrendous.
North Korea is much better. North Korea is technically very advanced.
she became a doctor but still talking silly i feel sorry for this nation
I say let them be it's not our place to interfere I say pray for them it's their culture we were over there long enough
They are deserved it, just let them live on its own way.
I think it's safe to say, Afghanistan had better coffee when the US was around.
Islam curse for Muslim after seeing Afghanistan
Why everyone is shouting Taliban, Taliban. This mentality is of all Afghan men about women. Even those who call themselves women rights activists which is just a project for those men nothing else. As nowadays political leaders talking about women rights and are setting in Europe countries, having luxury lives from the food of these hungry people that they loot in last 20 years.
So why men hate women and why women accept it to be oppressed
Of course they love their new life and Taliban regime would they be game to say otherwise?
I feel for the oppressed women
Afghan men really failed this country.
Afghan was once part of Hindustan ( india) thousands years ago. King Subala ruled the city, the father of gandhara now called as 'kandhar'. Later during Mahabharata it was cursed as this land will never progress and always be war torn.
So it is today since half century, you will never find peace within yourself or with Western rulers or anyone.
Well, where is the great Nobel laureate Malala n team? Happy in London politics instead of speaking actual women rights ?
India's untouchable explained , TRT world ... watch on youtube , the truth about Hinduism 🧐
Welcome to the rat 🐀 temple ... watch on youtube 😂 🐱
Which omen rights? like in india gang rapes of women on a daily basis?
@@ttt3258 bulla can't understand wat is Hinduism.... chudlim
@@ttt3258 Trt is run by Turkey. So, nothing new can be expected from them and their pest Erdogan. Also, what he said is right it is a cursed land. You cant change fact.
Nice reporting DW news 👍👍
The Prophet Muhammad (s.a.w) said: "Acquiring knowledge is obligatory on every Muslim; man and woman."
I now rest my case.
Well said
Makes you wonder how badly they were threatened
"Life is good under the taliban"... yeah, unless you're non-muslim, a business owner, highly educated (or want to be), a female or homosexual. Then you risk prison, torture, extortion and public execution
Where did that doctor get the Dr degree from? Now she is supporting the Taliban, then how does she expect other young women can get a degree like her....it is so contradict to what she is thinking
😃😃😉
She is a Pashtun, that's why she supports Taliban. All Pashtuns support Taliban and even those Pashtuns who are living in the West supports Taliban. Ghani was a Pashtun, he secretly supported Taliban, that's why Afghanistan fell to Taliban so quickly.
I'll tell you what is so contradictoring is "having to self sensor yourself instead of telling the truth"