DIY Aquarium Co2 System Comparison / Yeast? VS Acid?

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 29 окт 2024

Комментарии • 155

  • @natureaquariumsbyme8490
    @natureaquariumsbyme8490 3 года назад +26

    With the yeast you can use more yeast for more bubles and for longer duration mix the sugar with gelatin heat it up until gelatin. Is disovled and then poor in botle and after its set mix yeast with warm wster and pour in

  • @kennethcoutinho4439
    @kennethcoutinho4439 Год назад +2

    Awesome comparison 👏

  • @ArchDeanXD
    @ArchDeanXD 2 года назад +4

    Hi sir! Which Citric acid do you recomend to use i found there is two monohydrate and anhydrous which is suitable for making co2? Thank you in advance!! Great Video!!

  • @henrylo6773
    @henrylo6773 2 года назад +4

    Yeast seems better. You can always add more sugar if it slows down. I don't mix my sugar well so yeast can take time to break it down slowly

    • @ceyhunderindere
      @ceyhunderindere  2 года назад +4

      yes, i mostly use yeast system too

    • @alexman5203
      @alexman5203 2 года назад

      eventually the alcohol will kill the yeast though

    • @hammad3180
      @hammad3180 2 года назад +1

      @@alexman5203 you can use gelatin for that.

    • @kennethcoutinho4439
      @kennethcoutinho4439 Год назад

      @@alexman5203 can we drink 🍸

  • @alfofish2811
    @alfofish2811 4 года назад +4

    at night if we turn off the acid system that means reaction stops or the it continues. if it continues and the valve is off there is high risk of explosion. please reply

    • @ceyhunderindere
      @ceyhunderindere  4 года назад +4

      It is not enough to close the valve, pressure builds up and bursts. It is necessary to pull the hose in acid up and stop the liquid transfer.

    • @alfofish2811
      @alfofish2811 4 года назад +3

      If we put a air controller in between A and B bottle to stop the transfer of fluid. Instead of Swipeing up by magnet??

    • @ceyhunderindere
      @ceyhunderindere  4 года назад

      @@alfofish2811 Could be a stainless and fine-tuned part

  • @takagisane.g.v1377
    @takagisane.g.v1377 4 года назад +7

    It should have some part that how you mis or some kind of measurements for making those co2 thing. But still great vid. ❤

  • @BlackHawkPSU
    @BlackHawkPSU 4 года назад +7

    Instead of using a diffuser what about allowing the tank filter to suck up the Co2 and spit it out into the tank or use an airstone? I've done both with very good results. Ive used a old Ebo Jager Adjustable Air Stone or the Eheim 8599 Adjustable Air Diffuser also.

    • @ceyhunderindere
      @ceyhunderindere  4 года назад +1

      It is a method too, of course it can be done

    • @greenecospace
      @greenecospace 2 года назад

      check my DIY diffusor co2 goes over 90% efficiency , you need the right setup for a diffusor

  • @ismailsayar9395
    @ismailsayar9395 4 года назад +4

    Is it compulsory to have that valve in tank B to do this Acid System? What's it's functionality?

    • @ceyhunderindere
      @ceyhunderindere  4 года назад +1

      Evet ince ayar vanası gibi dülünebilirsiniz , hem kabarcığı hem de basıncı kontrol etmek için gerekli

    • @ismailsayar9395
      @ismailsayar9395 4 года назад

      B şişesinin içindeki bir tarafı hortumla karışımın içine gidiyor diğer tarafı boşta amacı ne anlamadım hocam.

    • @ceyhunderindere
      @ceyhunderindere  4 года назад +1

      @@ismailsayar9395 basınç farkında sıvı geçişi olmasın diye ve ilk başlatma için gerekli

    • @ismailsayar9395
      @ismailsayar9395 4 года назад

      Çok teşekkürler Ceyhun Bey peki bu ürünleri nereden temin edebilirim? Kapak, ince ayar vanası, ve o tankın içindeki sorduğum parçaları?

    • @ceyhunderindere
      @ceyhunderindere  4 года назад +1

      @@ismailsayar9395 rica ederim, rofopet den alıyorum çoğu ürünü
      İstanbul daysanız yer fatih te veya Pazaryerinde de ilanı oluyor
      Sahibinden vs

  • @rondroider8904
    @rondroider8904 2 года назад +2

    hi thank you for this very informative video. May I ask what sealant did you use for the bottle caps?

  • @doubleg2000
    @doubleg2000 Год назад

    Hi, why did you put that paper around yeast+sugar bottle ? Does it suppose to be in dark ?

  • @antshermannstadt
    @antshermannstadt 4 года назад +1

    If I place a valve between the citric acid and the backing soda can I stop the reaction at night?

  • @vikalawa5301
    @vikalawa5301 2 года назад

    Hi my baking soda system stops after few seconds it stops they i have to put more citric acid but it stops again what should i do

  • @kaka.9x
    @kaka.9x 3 года назад +1

    Will eating citric acid do the job?

  • @bertupas2129
    @bertupas2129 3 года назад +2

    1:45 did you connect those two tubings into one inside the bootle b?

  • @Hashishtani
    @Hashishtani Год назад

    Where can I find the full description of both systems? cause I use yeast, but it seems that author adds some white powder to the yeast "reactor" at the end was that barking soda?

    • @ceyhunderindere
      @ceyhunderindere  Год назад

      yes, baking soda.
      You can also find the full explanation on the forums.

    • @Hashishtani
      @Hashishtani Год назад

      @@ceyhunderindere I got it. The water will become acid so there is need for PH buffer from soda which would also release additional CO2. I think I even tried it in past but forgot. Currently trying to setup 4L yeast CO2... but so far it does not work for me as well as 1.5L Coca Cola bottle.

    • @ceyhunderindere
      @ceyhunderindere  Год назад

      @@Hashishtani 4 L is pretty big, I've never tried it, rate and reaction may change, take it easy

  • @ianfoo1782
    @ianfoo1782 3 года назад

    can i just disconnect the tube to the diffuser at night when not using it, if I don't have a valve?

    • @ceyhunderindere
      @ceyhunderindere  3 года назад

      The pressure decreases, the next day you need to spend acid again to start

  • @itz-_-raph
    @itz-_-raph Год назад

    I m using the citric acid method ...... idk how my citric acid got finished in day one only ... Any idea what's going wrong ?

    • @ceyhunderindere
      @ceyhunderindere  Год назад +1

      If the quantities are correct, there may be an air leak somewhere.

    • @itz-_-raph
      @itz-_-raph Год назад

      @@ceyhunderindere im using 100 gram citric acid with 400 ml water and 100 baking soda with 100 ml water in 2 litre bottles ......

    • @ceyhunderindere
      @ceyhunderindere  Год назад

      @@itz-_-raph I don't remember clearly right now, but it was in my previous videos

    • @itz-_-raph
      @itz-_-raph Год назад +1

      @@ceyhunderindere u were right man there was a leak on air flow control ..

    • @itz-_-raph
      @itz-_-raph Год назад

      @@ceyhunderindere btw bro can I use medical seline kit as a flow control cuz I m a having a leak in flow control valve ... So is it okay ?

  • @anthonypope8429
    @anthonypope8429 2 года назад

    how much water do you use and how much baking soda and citric acid good video

    • @ceyhunderindere
      @ceyhunderindere  2 года назад

      thanks, actually it is written in detail in the video, you can use those measurements

  • @vikalawa5301
    @vikalawa5301 2 года назад

    I have 20 gallon tank which system should i use

  • @ssujeeth45
    @ssujeeth45 2 года назад

    Am getting 30-40 bubble counts per minute. Is it ok?

    • @ceyhunderindere
      @ceyhunderindere  2 года назад

      I did not calculate with bubble count, co2 indicator will give more accurate result

    • @debangansamanta
      @debangansamanta 2 года назад

      One bubble per sec is fine too

  • @AtomiK-XIX-Bit
    @AtomiK-XIX-Bit 3 года назад

    does this only work with coca cola bottles
    edit: i just read that and it sound like im joking but i mean desighn wise can coca cola bottles contain more pressure?

    • @ceyhunderindere
      @ceyhunderindere  3 года назад

      These bottles are resistant to pressure, a hose may come off at high pressure

  • @ashokkumar1343
    @ashokkumar1343 2 года назад

    How you are using diffuser in yeast system ?

  • @paodimal
    @paodimal 4 года назад +1

    Can i turn on the Co2 yeast thru night? 24/7?

  • @sahinsahin5275
    @sahinsahin5275 4 года назад +3

    İ always wonder which method is better😍thanks ceyhuncum valla güzel işler yapıyosun senin tercihin hangisi gardash?

    • @ceyhunderindere
      @ceyhunderindere  4 года назад +1

      I use both, it's hard to decide. Akavryum büyükse limon tuzluyu terh ediyorum genelde, dozlarla oynayıp denemeler yapmak lazım

    • @sahinsahin5275
      @sahinsahin5275 4 года назад

      Ceyhun Derindere Aquatics When i use yeats in the begining water surface becomes oily.İf its not happening with acid i will try it..Sana oldu mu bilmiyorum ama yüzey yağlı gibi oluyo limon tuzu karbonatta olmuyosa öyle deniycem yoksa nano tankta pek bi farkı yok gibi

    • @ceyhunderindere
      @ceyhunderindere  4 года назад +1

      @@sahinsahin5275 The oily look on the water is bacterial colony, not related to co2 in my opinion, su üzerinde bende arada oluyor co2 vermediğim tankta dahi, sonra kendi geçiyor, bakteri topluluğu, su üzerini biraz daldalandırabilirsin

    • @sahinsahin5275
      @sahinsahin5275 4 года назад

      Ceyhun Derindere Aquatics i think its related to the yeast.i have 4 aquariums and i use bacteriak feeder all of them.i just have problem planted with yeast co2 and the surface always agilted couse of the out pipe of filtretion

    • @ceyhunderindere
      @ceyhunderindere  4 года назад

      @@sahinsahin5275 Fermente veya asidik CO2 kullandığım tankların yüzeyinde bakteri yok, ancak tankta CO2 olmadan da olabilir

  • @flyingcat3170
    @flyingcat3170 Год назад

    How do i auto stop it at night when lights are off?

    • @ceyhunderindere
      @ceyhunderindere  Год назад

      it is very difficult to do this in these systems

  • @greg9198
    @greg9198 3 года назад

    Hi, can acetic acid (vinegar) be used? Thanks

    • @ceyhunderindere
      @ceyhunderindere  3 года назад

      Hi, I have never tried it but the acid rate may not be enough

  • @iwanshah5690
    @iwanshah5690 Год назад

    Why my diffuser no working at yeast system?

  • @jomsonjkc5863
    @jomsonjkc5863 4 года назад +1

    What r the ingredients used for co2 using yeast

    • @ceyhunderindere
      @ceyhunderindere  4 года назад +1

      On info,
      ruclips.net/video/tE4DSglqz_8/видео.html

  • @gamingmaster5727
    @gamingmaster5727 3 года назад

    Is it safe to leave the co2 yeast system 24/7?? Or do i put a valve to close ot at night , when i did that the pressure was ok overnight but in the morning when opened the valve it didn't work there was no co2 the water in the bottle had some sort of foam on it

    • @ceyhunderindere
      @ceyhunderindere  3 года назад

      yeast system works 24/7. the valve will not work in this system. I am using it for 24 hours.

    • @gamingmaster5727
      @gamingmaster5727 3 года назад +1

      @@ceyhunderindere is it safe for fish and and plants? And why it won't work?

    • @ceyhunderindere
      @ceyhunderindere  3 года назад

      @@gamingmaster5727 It works, no air leaks, right

    • @gamingmaster5727
      @gamingmaster5727 3 года назад

      @@ceyhunderindere i heared if leave the co2 24/7 it wil cause algae growth and might kill the fish??

    • @ceyhunderindere
      @ceyhunderindere  3 года назад

      @@gamingmaster5727 i dont think so

  • @hmmm2088
    @hmmm2088 2 года назад

    I am sorry to ask but i wanna try yeast system and i gonna ask is do i need to turn on co2 when light coming only (i open about 4-6 hour right now i didn’t start co2 yet if i use co2 how many light do i need to turn on please tell me;-;) and close when night time ? and how to reduce or close yeast system during night time i kinda scare my fish die or bottle explode(sorry if i ask a thing that already in video i not good at english reading ;-;)

    • @ceyhunderindere
      @ceyhunderindere  2 года назад

      Hi, I'm using 24 hours, you can try reducing the yeast rate.

    • @hmmm2088
      @hmmm2088 2 года назад

      @@ceyhunderindere oh ok tysm

  • @semihtumer6382
    @semihtumer6382 3 года назад

    Merhaba , sitrik asit sistemini yapmayı iki defa denedim ancak her seferin beş dakika gaz çıkışı olduktan sonra duruyor. Hortumdaki hava geri kaçıyor. Dıy kapak sistemi mevcut değil yalnız elimde. Bu konuda tavsiyeniz varmıdır?

    • @ceyhunderindere
      @ceyhunderindere  3 года назад

      Bi kere başladıktan sonra sürekli devam etmesin lazım aslında azalsa bile
      Hava kaçağı olabilir mi kontrol edin, ilk sefer için co2 çıkışı bi tık arttırın kontrollü olarak

    • @semihtumer6382
      @semihtumer6382 3 года назад

      Teşekkür ederim yeniden kontrol sağlayacağım. Bir de şimdi farkettim sizden farklı yaptığım tek şey sitrik asitteki hortumun altına çıpa takmadım 😬

    • @semihtumer6382
      @semihtumer6382 3 года назад

      Sorunum düzeldi checkvalf takmıştım o hava kaçırıyormuş 👍 teşekkürler tekrardan

    • @ceyhunderindere
      @ceyhunderindere  3 года назад +1

      @@semihtumer6382 :) bazen hesapta olmayan şeyler çıkabiliyor

  • @gamingmaster5727
    @gamingmaster5727 3 года назад

    Why did u use 2 bottles not 1 and what are the mixture in yeast please help

    • @ceyhunderindere
      @ceyhunderindere  3 года назад

      CO2 passing through the water is for safety purposes. In addition to yeast, baking soda and milk can be added

    • @gamingmaster5727
      @gamingmaster5727 3 года назад

      @@ceyhunderindere what could happen if i didn't add milk or baking soda?

    • @ceyhunderindere
      @ceyhunderindere  3 года назад

      @@gamingmaster5727 The duration and strength of the pressure can vary

    • @mohityadav4251
      @mohityadav4251 2 года назад

      @@ceyhunderindere what safety purpose?

    • @ceyhunderindere
      @ceyhunderindere  2 года назад

      @@mohityadav4251 yeast system

  • @fizrulali6061
    @fizrulali6061 3 года назад

    it's that a baking soda for food sir?

  • @dirtydan3029
    @dirtydan3029 2 года назад +1

    Wouldnt the different water levels change how effective the comparison is? One with less water will have to produce significantly more co2 to reach the same amount of pressure as the one with more water and co2 would just be trapped in the bottle. Theres no control. You also never showed how much of each ingredient is in each bottle, nor did you show what happened between days 1 and 17

  • @ricksonyabao9542
    @ricksonyabao9542 2 года назад

    What if you will mix 4 ingredients?

  • @ccdarin520
    @ccdarin520 3 года назад +2

    I'm using co2 yeast , what happen if I turn it at night time? I saw many solenoid coil with diy co2 on aliexpress does it work well ? I'm afraid the air tube will explore .please help to explain me some ideas
    Best regards from Cambodia and sorry my English so poor

    • @ceyhunderindere
      @ceyhunderindere  3 года назад +1

      If you want, you can turn it off with the light and you can get it 1 hour before you buy it, I use it for 24 hours, so there is no ph fluctuation, the system in aliexpress works of course, but there is no big difference from dıy systems, hi from İstanbul 👋 ☺️

  • @chrischan8125
    @chrischan8125 3 года назад

    how much water did you add in your citric acid?

    • @ceyhunderindere
      @ceyhunderindere  3 года назад

      500ml, I added it as a link to the making video

  • @WRDO
    @WRDO 3 года назад

    i think if you add more yeast you will get more co2 gas , what do you think my friend , thanks

    • @ceyhunderindere
      @ceyhunderindere  3 года назад +1

      It might be nice to see it by trying it, but this may shorten the gassing time. The amount of mixed water is also important.

    • @dizzyguy7423
      @dizzyguy7423 3 года назад +1

      more yeast will make the mix run out quicker, the extra yeast will eat up the sugar faster. but it will increase the amount of co2

    • @WRDO
      @WRDO 3 года назад

      @@dizzyguy7423 thanks , how much yeast and sugar to use , and how much water

    • @dizzyguy7423
      @dizzyguy7423 3 года назад

      @@WRDO hm im not sure but there are other youtube videos teaching how to make some

    • @herbertangielopacana6610
      @herbertangielopacana6610 3 года назад

      Try cooking your sugar and add gelatin to it.

  • @herbertangielopacana7107
    @herbertangielopacana7107 3 года назад

    I thought it would explode if you close the valve for the citric acid and baking soda? Does co2 dont build up inside the bottle when you close it?

    • @ceyhunderindere
      @ceyhunderindere  3 года назад

      It is necessary to pull the hose through the acid, or it may burst.

    • @JR537
      @JR537 3 года назад

      @@ceyhunderindere if you pull out the tube from acid bottle, you keep it open until next day ? Would that lessen the amount and duration of the Co2 from 17 days to less which you need to change more often.

    • @ceyhunderindere
      @ceyhunderindere  3 года назад +1

      it will explode only if the valve is closed, it is necessary to cut off the fluid flow

    • @herbertangielopacana7107
      @herbertangielopacana7107 3 года назад

      @@ceyhunderindere what are the ways to cut the fluid flow? Like using the magnet to place the tip of the hose above the water surface?

    • @herbertangielopacana7107
      @herbertangielopacana7107 3 года назад

      @@ceyhunderindere hoq to lifting the hose above the water surface with a magnet on the citric acid bottle. Then closing the valve. Would it still build up a co2? Or will it stop?

  • @juliusandre405
    @juliusandre405 3 года назад

    What is white thing placed in the yeast system bottle? I just started mine and it only lasted 2 days

  • @Comedyboy9909
    @Comedyboy9909 3 года назад +1

    how do you automate a diy co2 system?

    • @ceyhunderindere
      @ceyhunderindere  3 года назад

      automatic flow continues after pressure builds up inside

  • @blankfido7229
    @blankfido7229 3 года назад

    Can you give co2 equipment link as in from where to buy it

    • @ceyhunderindere
      @ceyhunderindere  3 года назад +1

      It was taken from many different places. Some from local markets

  • @f27gaming63
    @f27gaming63 3 года назад

    Citric acid will blast??

  • @JhunDumsTVXj
    @JhunDumsTVXj 3 года назад +1

    Wow

  • @LearningIsTheBest
    @LearningIsTheBest 3 года назад

    Is it ok to use this in shrimp tank?

    • @ceyhunderindere
      @ceyhunderindere  3 года назад

      I did not see a negative effect, but I do not use any additives in other shrimp breeding tanks.

    • @LearningIsTheBest
      @LearningIsTheBest 3 года назад

      @@ceyhunderindere ohh thanks sir

    • @AVIKO607
      @AVIKO607 3 года назад

      @@LearningIsTheBest for extra clarification I had blue bolt shrimp that didn’t mind the co2 at all and even Chris lukhaup said that shrimp don’t mind co2

    • @LearningIsTheBest
      @LearningIsTheBest 3 года назад

      @@AVIKO607 thank you so much 😁

    • @udaydas6291
      @udaydas6291 3 года назад +1

      Co2 not safe for shrimps.Shrimps are sensitive scavengers.Most hobbiyests use low light plants in theirs shrimp tank.Use moss,guppy grass,anubias they don't need Co2.

  • @akshaw8798
    @akshaw8798 3 года назад

    Please make a video on how to make co2 with East and suger

  • @sebatiaydin7653
    @sebatiaydin7653 4 года назад +1

    Harika

  • @mr1enrollment
    @mr1enrollment 3 года назад

    annoying music

  • @ghos282
    @ghos282 3 года назад

    Over Blaring Audio Track. NO Verbal Explanation Track of the precise steps and measures of the processes being compared. - A USELESS waste of time - CLICK BAIT!!!