Win or Tank: What Should the New Orleans Saints Do? | James Skrmetta Reacts

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 25 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 108

  • @SaintsFanBurnerAccount
    @SaintsFanBurnerAccount 8 часов назад +18

    Thank you for being the ONLY saints RUclipsr who isn’t pushing for “high-draft pick” agenda. Building a winning culture is the most important aspect of a successful franchise. The worst case scenario for the saints would have been the saints going 2-14 because you can’t convince a team of grown men to “buy in”when you’re that bad regardless who your QB is

    • @KryptoKai72
      @KryptoKai72 8 часов назад

      Absolutely. Preach Brother.

    • @lewistangi8004
      @lewistangi8004 7 часов назад +1

      @@SaintsFanBurnerAccount I don't believe that any team tanks at least until they are eliminated from playoffs. But I agree, the Saints need hope right now. And for that matter, they need a coach who can make do with what we have, until the next QB is determined

    • @JamesSkrmetta
      @JamesSkrmetta  7 часов назад +2

      @@SaintsFanBurnerAccount The high draft narrative is nuts. Blows my mind.

  • @timothyruss6996
    @timothyruss6996 8 часов назад +11

    It's crazy that people think losing on purpose will make them contenders later.

    • @JamesSkrmetta
      @JamesSkrmetta  7 часов назад +3

      Wild. There’s a reason teams picking in the Top 10 every year don’t get better.

  • @ReDRuMx96
    @ReDRuMx96 5 часов назад +4

    Saints fans all wanted to tank while DA was still here, but now they wanna say tanking is for losers. Ridiculous

  • @alireyistheboss
    @alireyistheboss 9 часов назад +9

    I guess we're still having this conversation. Tanking is for losers...

  • @gregorygerber9627
    @gregorygerber9627 9 часов назад +12

    Keeping Carr for another year helps our long term salary cap issues. Since the consensus was that Rattler wasn't ready maybe keeping Carr makes sense. I think we should use our draft to rebuild the offensive line next year. Keep McCoy as the line leader and extend his contract. Use what cap room we have to sign some one year contract veterans for the defense. I wouldn't bitch about using the 1st round pick on a QB or WR if a super talent falls to us. Win out baby! Geaux Saints!

    • @korylevergne8832
      @korylevergne8832 8 часов назад

      Love that it’s finally started to look like this there’s one more year carr has bought himself another shot

    • @NFL_CHECK123
      @NFL_CHECK123 7 часов назад +1

      Spencer ain’t the answer! I’m not sold. Carr is serviceable. Only thing that gives me hope is our Division is garbage and that doesn’t seem like it’s changing anytime soon. The season has been bad and we are still in playoff contention.

    • @korylevergne8832
      @korylevergne8832 7 часов назад +1

      @@NFL_CHECK123 not wrong at all an give rattler time man Rodger’s sat for years Mahomes sat until he didn’t love even tho I don’t like to bring Jordan love up sat an plays alr give it time

    • @Unlimited78
      @Unlimited78 6 часов назад

      If we can get Arch Manning in the draft after this one, then I would be al 4 drafting a QB.

    • @Unlimited78
      @Unlimited78 6 часов назад

      ​@@NFL_CHECK123 Hoping we can luck up and land Arch Manning. That would be the only QB that I would be willing to go all out for.

  • @forgive9380
    @forgive9380 8 часов назад +5

    Marshon Lattimore is on a 10 losing streak💀

  • @Twolfe_10
    @Twolfe_10 5 часов назад +1

    James drop some knowledge on the gym or diet routine because damn those arms lookin strong😂

  • @lewistangi8004
    @lewistangi8004 8 часов назад +4

    If Gayle wanted us to tank, she wouldn't have fired DA

  • @gregorygerber9627
    @gregorygerber9627 8 часов назад +4

    As far as coaching is concerned I like Vrabel. If not Vrabel then I like Rizzi. Keep Kubiak and Jonoco.

    • @JamesSkrmetta
      @JamesSkrmetta  7 часов назад

      @@gregorygerber9627 Good with either of those.

  • @Redeye_Ent
    @Redeye_Ent 2 часа назад

    This is why I watch you... Straight Facts.

  • @BillyRayValentineFCOJ
    @BillyRayValentineFCOJ 2 часа назад

    22:30 - Rewinding MANY years, when I was a kid...my step-dad was stationed at Columbus AFB in Mississippi. After being there a few years he was stationed at Elmendorf AFB in Anchorage, AK. So I moved from Mississippi to Alaska when I was a kid.
    And the weeks without daylight only happens north of the Arctic Circle. But with that, even down in Anchorage you go through extended periods without seeing the sun because you're stuck in school or work for the 1-3 hours of daylight over winter.

  • @terrorsix6
    @terrorsix6 9 часов назад +4

    See the jags had a lot of bust players picking up in the draft and had a bad gm giving players away for chips and pickles and players leaving off rookie contracts etc Leonard Fornette ,Jaylon Ramsey……

  • @michaelangelos5117
    @michaelangelos5117 9 часов назад +5

    Planning to lose is a LOSER ATTITUDE.
    Karma's going to come back and bite you in the AAAAASSSSSSSSS when you start to play that game.
    (Shout out to Jim Rome)

    • @JamesSkrmetta
      @JamesSkrmetta  7 часов назад +1

      @@michaelangelos5117 Big shout to Rome

  • @KryptoKai72
    @KryptoKai72 9 часов назад +3

    We take one game at a time and win the remaining games that we can. Tanking and purposely losing doesn't solve and fix anything especially the culture because tanking only makes a losing culture.

    • @KryptoKai72
      @KryptoKai72 8 часов назад +2

      Plus to add, I'd rather win out so we stick with Rizzi. Yes, he's won only two games and for him to be our official HC he has to win more games and prove he can beat good teams like the Rams, Commanders, Packers, and Buccaneers. For the mentality, passion, energy, and changes he's brought and made to the team, I might be all in for him to be the Saints next and official HC.

    • @JamesSkrmetta
      @JamesSkrmetta  7 часов назад +1

      Preach

  • @JayVeil
    @JayVeil 9 часов назад +4

    Brother…please drop your workout routine/meal plan. Sheesh

  • @ianhambly
    @ianhambly 8 часов назад +1

    Saints need a 3, 4 5 year plan to build their culture. Draft the best players of any position, and build a core of talent. Carr is good enough to stablise whilst finding the franchise QB future. Manage the cap down. Roster gaps can be filled with free agency. Obviously the first item if to settle on the new coach; Rizzi has a decent shout if he ends with 500+ record. We must keep Kubiak at least until 2026.

  • @Georgedaniel70
    @Georgedaniel70 8 часов назад +2

    Funny how Rattler is not the guy anymore, from all the anti Carr comments.

    • @BillyRayValentineFCOJ
      @BillyRayValentineFCOJ 2 часа назад

      Rattler was NEVER the guy. He was drafted to be a backup for a year or two and that's what he is going to be.

  • @terrorsix6
    @terrorsix6 8 часов назад +2

    They really need to go get that Rizzi shovel and get Hunter Renfro and bring him from the dead like they did MVS and let Taysum the Tow Truck drag Car raggedy a## to another win WHODAt⚜️⚜️⚜️

  • @AbbeyCelestine
    @AbbeyCelestine 8 часов назад +3

    I can’t stand Matt Moscona’s takes. I’m truly convinced that he wants the Saints to suck, so he can get more views.

  • @OfficialKarnivalKahos
    @OfficialKarnivalKahos 4 часа назад

    Hey, never say never; we have had some wild things happen in the NFL.

  • @calebchristman3427
    @calebchristman3427 8 часов назад

    You can tell James been listening to our boy Ross Jackson! I heard this exact almost word for word explanation at Locked On Saints. But good review

    • @JamesSkrmetta
      @JamesSkrmetta  7 часов назад

      @@calebchristman3427 Ross on team high draft pick or team win?

  • @NFL_CHECK123
    @NFL_CHECK123 7 часов назад +1

    I’m calling it..an 8-8 record will rep the NFC south in the playoffs. Fitting for a division where every team is middle of the road.

    • @JamesSkrmetta
      @JamesSkrmetta  7 часов назад +1

      Missing a game.

    • @NFL_CHECK123
      @NFL_CHECK123 7 часов назад

      @ forgot we added one. Shows my age

    • @NFL_CHECK123
      @NFL_CHECK123 7 часов назад

      @ with that said our division, 8-9 will rep us!

    • @BillyRayValentineFCOJ
      @BillyRayValentineFCOJ 2 часа назад

      If 8-9 wins the division it will be the Falcons and no one in the division will get a wild card

    • @NFL_CHECK123
      @NFL_CHECK123 2 часа назад

      @ You are right. Now looking at Tampas remaining schedule, they have a cake walk for the home stretch. They are definitely winning the division.

  • @Archerforthelord
    @Archerforthelord 8 часов назад

    I love the boost that the coaching change has done for the Saints. That doesn't mean no coach search in the off-season. That's like getting a car wash and then deciding to Pay Benny $16/month

    • @JamesSkrmetta
      @JamesSkrmetta  7 часов назад

      @@Archerforthelord Yeah we definitely need to still do a full search

  • @unforgivenkd
    @unforgivenkd 6 часов назад

    0:03 “Beat the rams and we can talk”

  • @mobbinkorrectly
    @mobbinkorrectly 6 часов назад

    Keep winning!! keep the winning culture alive in the Nola don’t believe in tanking. We can get good picks through out the draft does have to be the top pick. scouts just really have to do there job. Keep winning that’s my take ⚜️⚜️

    • @JamesSkrmetta
      @JamesSkrmetta  4 часа назад

      @@mobbinkorrectly We just gotta hit with all our picks

  • @saulsilver1930
    @saulsilver1930 8 часов назад +1

    All I have to say is, don't draft another QB, we are good.

  • @KermitTFYT
    @KermitTFYT 9 часов назад +1

    22:20 it’s expensive and luxurious or we would.

  • @wordcoffee101
    @wordcoffee101 7 часов назад

    Video suggestion: Bryce Young's comeback.

  • @geoffhoutman1557
    @geoffhoutman1557 8 часов назад +1

    After watching. Great video as usual, couple of points, and both based on your Steelers comments.
    The Jags have cycled through a lot of coaches and GMs, has Shad always owned the team? Ownership may be the problem there.
    Have the Rooney’s or the O Maras always owned the Steelers? (Great, now I’m thinking of Rooney Omara, yuk) Could it be the Steeler family’s ownership is the key to ongoing success- only three HCs in the last 40 years or whatever?
    Also on the Steelers- that one time they got to pick first, they picked a QB, he coulda been a bust, more than half first round QBs are,- but he wasn’t, won them two pairs of back to back SBs. Would they ave won those 4 without him? Maybe, maybe not, but you don’t know til you try.
    The Saints haven’t drafted a first round QB for 53 years. Might be time to give it a try?

    • @JamesSkrmetta
      @JamesSkrmetta  7 часов назад +1

      Khan is the 2nd owner. He bought the team in 2012

    • @dl9232
      @dl9232 3 часа назад

      When the Steelers drafted Big Ben, they were stacked offensively. They had Hines Ward, Jerome Burress, Plaxico Burress, Duece Staley, and a solid offensive line. They also had a really good coach and the #1 defense that year. Do we have anything comparable for a rookie quarterback to step in and have similar success? We need to focus on so many other positions right now.🤷🏿‍♂️

  • @NFL_CHECK123
    @NFL_CHECK123 8 часов назад

    Only reason I’m not for tanking is our division is so pathetic, that we could still make the playoffs. Other than that, draft capital has become too important in the NFL. It’s not necessarily about the player you could draft but how you leverage the draft capital via trade and such. If you had 2 first round picks a season ago, Lamar Jackson could literally have been your starting QB. Teams that had two first rounders look like morons not jumping on that opportunity. Hell this season for a 3rd or 4th round pick, top Wide receivers were being moved. Draft capital matters!

  • @Unlimited78
    @Unlimited78 6 часов назад

    There arent any QBs worth tanking for in this draft anyway. We need to sure up WR, and defense. When Arch Manning comes out, I would be all for it because that would be a perfect situation.

  • @BillyRayValentineFCOJ
    @BillyRayValentineFCOJ 2 часа назад

    It's insane that anyone is even discussing tanking for a QB draft class that is legendarily weak. The only guys that are possibly 1st round caliber QBs are Quinn Ewers and Shedeur Sanders and the Saints fans screaming to dump DC4 would absolutely RIOT if the Saints drafted Quinn Ewers. Ewers is closer to Kenny Pickett than he is to Dan Marino. Sanders is closer to J.T. Barrett than to Donovan McNabb. Jalen Milroe is a 4th round talent that SOMEONE is going to reach on in the 1st round, and it's going to be HILARIOUS.

  • @KermitTFYT
    @KermitTFYT 9 часов назад +2

    I need to whip out my notebook of doom.

    • @JamesSkrmetta
      @JamesSkrmetta  7 часов назад

      The notebook of doom is when things get real.

  • @Cjac1027
    @Cjac1027 3 часа назад

    lol don’t nobody get picked on more by James than Conor mcgovern, mason tipton and the jags 😂😂

  • @wolfbisbing486
    @wolfbisbing486 5 часов назад

    You have to pick the right players and that’s on the GM. That’s in the draft and in free agency. Yes it doesn’t really matter where you pick but you have to pick the right players and Mickey Loomis can’t pick the right players.

  • @geoffhoutman1557
    @geoffhoutman1557 9 часов назад

    Before watching the video- chances of us making the playoffs are a long shot. We would have to win out and Bucs and Failcons collapse for it to happen.
    Bucs only have one hard game left, we have three. Possible but very very very unlikely.
    Tanking is not real, but if we were to play no so we’ll once mathematically eliminated, we’ll that would be lovely. But-
    Until we have a new GM it doesn’t matter. Mickey can screw up a top ten pick as easy as a #32.
    Let us all pray Gayle and her group have a plan in motion already🤞🏽

  • @DoubleKAllday
    @DoubleKAllday 3 часа назад

    I wished they could’ve traded Lattimore too Chiefs or sum. I feel badd☹️

  • @wolfbisbing486
    @wolfbisbing486 5 часов назад

    I think the offense is better but the defense isn’t so good. Too many old players on defense.

  • @KermitTFYT
    @KermitTFYT 9 часов назад +2

    Saints do need a top pick for a qb though. We need our Jayden or Stroud. So they can become a Jackson or Allen. I guarantee nobody on earth is Drafting a qb saying I want him to play like Carr.

    • @KryptoKai72
      @KryptoKai72 8 часов назад

      @@KermitTFYT I rather in 2026, we go QB in the draft.

  • @freedom_at_the_cross
    @freedom_at_the_cross 8 часов назад

    Win and lose all the way

  • @franciscopomar2942
    @franciscopomar2942 8 часов назад

    It's kind of stupid to think the Saints are going to tank. They don't, never do, and won't Tank. I can tell you what's going to happen though. They going to hire Rizzi ...they like to hire from within ....but I don't even know if Rizzi is the right guy or if I even want to wait another 3 years to find out, the other viable option is Aaron Glen I think one of those 2 will be our head coach

    • @JamesSkrmetta
      @JamesSkrmetta  7 часов назад

      Is Rizzi loses 2 games or less down the stretch, I think he’s the front runner.

  • @KermitTFYT
    @KermitTFYT 9 часов назад +4

    I wish people would understand that I think Carr sucks as much as the current position of the saints. We SHOULD lightweight rebuild. WE SHOULD get a young qb for the future thinking Carr is the answer is insane. WE SHOULD start getting younger at all positions, LB S OL RB. WE SHOULD get deep at Oline. We should be collecting picks and be looking for a serious head coaching candidate whether it’s Rizzi or someone else. I don’t want to possibly but highly unlikely win a playoff game this year then screw our chances of getting a talented young qb and etc. Carr can’t be our qb for the next 5-10 years. Thats absurd to even think or say. WE NEED to do what we should have done forever ago was go get a damn qb. Sean Peyton left and went to get a qb. Guaranteed Bo Nix gets a Super Bowl in his career and Carr doesn’t. Peyton has exactly what he wants now. They are doing so much better than us. And you fans are just like Mickey. Don’t wanna change.

    • @KryptoKai72
      @KryptoKai72 9 часов назад +4

      I say stick with Carr for 2025 then go get a QB in 2026. For the 2025 draft, in the first round we go DT like Mason Graham because the d-line is still lacking, second round, go WR or TE then third round, CB and S.

    • @geoffhoutman1557
      @geoffhoutman1557 9 часов назад +2

      Unless we win SB he is gone some time next season.
      We SHOULD get a proper GM, nothing else matters as much

    • @vinsanitize
      @vinsanitize 8 часов назад +1

      @@geoffhoutman1557Joe Douglas is an option, not sure thought honestly.

    • @geoffhoutman1557
      @geoffhoutman1557 7 часов назад

      @@vinsanitize For real, last two drafts have been killer I think, but Zach Wilson was his pick too...

  • @BillyRayValentineFCOJ
    @BillyRayValentineFCOJ 2 часа назад

    No one on this team is going to tank. There are absolutely ZERO QBs in this draft that are better or will be better than DC4. There are ZERO other QBs on the Saints roster that are or will ever be better than DC4. There are absolutely ZERO QBs that will be available in FA in the off season who are better or will ever be better than DC4, the best of them will be Sam Darnold.
    But we're talking about a fan base that would actually be HAPPY if the Saints went into 2025 with a QB room of Spencer Rattler, Trey Lance, and Cam Ward. And confused why the team finishes 1-16.

  • @titodalporto1527
    @titodalporto1527 2 часа назад

    The Saints are tired of loosing.
    “You have to suffer pain to get rid of pain”
    That’s what’s happening with our country with Trump as the leader. And now Rizzy is bringing back that pride of winning with a team of veterans.

  • @wolfbisbing486
    @wolfbisbing486 5 часов назад

    I wouldn’t count on Olave. It seems like his family is trying to get him either out of New Orleans or just out of the league. If I were Chris I’d retire and save what I have left of my brain. Besides I personally don’t think Olave is a true WR1. I think regardless if Olave comes back we need a true WR1.

  • @KermitTFYT
    @KermitTFYT 9 часов назад +2

    I’m not saying tank. But we need a high pick so we can go get our guy. Carr is not the answer financially or for the future.

    • @KryptoKai72
      @KryptoKai72 8 часов назад +2

      @@KermitTFYT how high of a draft pick like top 5 or top 3. In my opinion, a top 10 is good enough but generally wherever the pick is, it shouldn't matter as long you pick the impact player that is needed in the team.

    • @willfotwenty7469
      @willfotwenty7469 8 часов назад +1

      I love Carr he’s the answer and needs to be paid more 🎉🎉🎉

    • @KermitTFYT
      @KermitTFYT 8 часов назад

      @@KryptoKai72 needs to be within 10. Trade for the pick. Carr isn’t the answer. He’s not as good as baker. I’m a baker hater and I hate the Bucs. But baker is good now.

    • @KermitTFYT
      @KermitTFYT 8 часов назад

      @@willfotwenty7469 you realize he’s already fleeced the saints for 100 mill. 🧌

    • @KryptoKai72
      @KryptoKai72 8 часов назад +2

      @@KermitTFYT I don't consider Carr as the answer and the Franchise QB but I don't think he sucks. Yes he isn't elite but he's not garbage, he is a flawed middle of the road and average or above QB. Also I'm not for trading up especially for this QB draft class which I don't think sucks but it's a huge gamble and at the same time a fugazi. In 2026, we should pick for a QB.

  • @platypuspracticus2
    @platypuspracticus2 7 часов назад +1

    tanking is loser shit.

  • @matthenagan8189
    @matthenagan8189 6 часов назад

    I'm tired of talking about this topic to be frank. Aren't we beyond the point of tanking? Won 2, lose 7, win 2 and now we are at the point of losing all the games from here on out. Makes no sense to me. People need to read the damn room at this point. If we beat the Rams next game we are legitimate sleepers for contending. I'm not even watching the video, only commenting. Don't want to hear about this mess. ✌️ Who dat.

  • @HumbledAnimeEnthusiast
    @HumbledAnimeEnthusiast 9 часов назад

    To tank or not to tank? That is the question. 🎭
    Saints better trade up for Sheduer or Cam Ward if they ain’t gonna tank and go on a run, that’s all I know. If the Saints nail it with a head coach(obviously easier said than done) we are right back in the win column.

  • @KermitTFYT
    @KermitTFYT 9 часов назад +1

    We Need a top pick to get our guy. I guess people will let Carr play below average for 8 years straight before we finally go get our guy who isn’t an 11 year bum.

    • @KermitTFYT
      @KermitTFYT 8 часов назад

      @ thanks for checking out my page I don’t play qb for a living. I get to criticize what I want and you have to deal with it and Dragin Ball is more popular than Derek Carr will ever be try again little girl

    • @KermitTFYT
      @KermitTFYT 8 часов назад

      @@nathanjump9920 I’m 24 your sad you watched my videos to try to come at me but dragon ball is more popular than you will ever be and your god carr will ever be. Dragon ball has made more money than your god and you will in your entire life and career. You’re salty because your favorite man to watch throw a ball sucks.

    • @KermitTFYT
      @KermitTFYT 8 часов назад

      @@nathanjump9920 cause he sucks at his job and I don’t suck at my job. My job doesn’t pay 38 mill for me to suck at it. Not to mention he scammed our favorite team cuz all you did was ride his nuts while he missed the playoffs consistently his entire contract

    • @nathanjump9920
      @nathanjump9920 8 часов назад

      He was 24 and in the NFL you’re 24 and playing cartoons. Starving for attention I’m just trying to help you. There’s only one god the lord and savior ✝️

  • @mobbinkorrectly
    @mobbinkorrectly 6 часов назад

    Keep winning!! keep the winning culture alive in the Nola don’t believe in tanking. We can get good picks through out the draft does have to be the top pick. scouts just really have to do there job. Keep winning that’s my take ⚜️⚜️