As Ilan Pappe remarked that when a settler/colonial project like Zionism is in its terminal stage it is at its most violent and brutal. And Shir Hever, the Israeli Economist has said - regimes that commit genocide usually fall shortly after. Israel will never recover from this no matter the outcome.
I believe that will be the case. But how many innocents will suffer and die before the Israeli state goes away, however that happens? It's cold comfort in a sense, but still a valid point of course.
Why would IDF be shooting at people, unless there were people shooting back ? These were HOSTAGES being GUARDED by ARMED HAMAS FIGHTERS. The fact they use civilians as a shield of sorts is pathetic. Hamas wants bloodshed, they have stated that many times. It furthers their cause. There is no doubt that Hamas hides amongst civilians, if you don't believe that, then you are clearly delusional. This is not journalistic integrity, this is what you refer to as "The False Narrative". How can someone be so naive in believing this nonsense. This was a HOSTAGE RETRIEVAL operation. Yes there is bloodshed, but the Gazan's voted for Hamas, and if the recent surveys are accurate, still overwhelmingly have support for Hamas. Tell me why the leaders of Hamas are not in Gaza ? Why are they not in the "state" that they represent ? Living lavishly in a fancy hotel, away from the people they "represent". Palestinian Central Bureau of Statistics ? That sounds awfully like Hamas Statistics. You cannot trust a terrorist organization's information.
I have never felt so helpless as I have this past 250 days I feel like there's nothing I can do to help my brothers and sisters. I have never cried so much in my life. I am full of rage and sadness. Please God help us the world has to change
Same for me, I hardly ever cried before, now I'm a weeping mess multiple times a week, especially when I listen to Nora's news report at the beginning of this livestream😭
I live on flight path to Heathrow, never bothered me before. Now at night I listen to planes & imagine the absolute terror suffered by Palestinians especially those poor precious children, may God help them 🙏
“Israel” asked Palestine: “Palestine, why do the West governments love me but hate you?” Palestine responded “Because you are a beautiful lie and I am a painful truth.” =🇵🇸= CatSense =🇮🇪=
This is so painfully right. The Zionists cant whitewash this mass murder. They caused the situation. 70 years of theft, oppression & complete hatred. The world will not forget. Its only going to create more 'terrorists'. not just in Gaza. thats the truth & the problem for future Israeli generations. Thats the sad truth of it all.
@@71suns Is that all you've got? No intellectual defense against the lucid quote? I figured as much. Just a meaningless and irrelevant accusation or name calling if you will - a common tactic of those unable to produce reasoning.
Wrong messaging. It makes it seem like Izzy compares to the US. Almost goving them legitimacy. WE might have very corrupt politicians but we are still a democracy.
Thank you. This was a comprehensive and good analysis of the genocide being perpetrated against Palestinians and the efforts made by the Palestinian resistance to defend Palestine.
Amazing work from the ei team as usual! I really look forward to Wednesdays. Your guests, contributors and analysis is truly invaluable during this horrific genocide. I have the deepest gratitude for the work you all do!
Greetings from Ohio, U.S. Thank you for your excellent reporting. I'm a follower of Jesus trying to convince my friends that there is no justifying these continuous unrelenting atrocities.
It is so sad to watch and hear the news. Global leaders should act now than later. How can people live with this? How unfair is this? So many years to go through this? Unbelievable.
Thank you all for another great video show. This is one of my top shows, I recommend it wherever I can. Thanks to you and other independent journalists, high quality reporting that people can trust is available. I unsubscribed from MSM shortly after Oct. 7 because it was/is sanitized and full of spin. We can look no farther than the Iz propaganda department and the sloppy rehashing of the mass rape claims. Once again, NO EVIDENCE. I’m still surprised that this has been repeatedly presented, and with no forensic examination or autopsy results or real crime scene analysis. No rape crisis centers in Iz have reported any Iz rape victims. This is not about “believe women”, this is about credibility when making serious claims-Show Real Evidence, things admissible in a court of law, collected by trained people, using scientific standards and protocols.
This is heart breaking. Listening to these horrific and nightmare stories of innocent civilians. What is more upsetting is the children who if they survived have to live orphaned and traumatised. I have never been one to wish bad on anyone even my enemies but for these atrocities May Allah never forgive them. Allah Akbar Subhanak Ya Rabbi Allhamdullah la illaha illa Allah 🤲🏾
From Gold Coast Queensland Australia 🇦🇺 thank you guys 🙏 for your amazing weekly reports which I look forward to, they have provided me some calm 😌 at such a horrifying & devastating time for the Palestinian population 💔 😭 and for many others of us in the world that truly care. 🙏🇵🇸💔😭💔😭#humanity
I am catching up on the first hour that I missed during the livestream. Excellent reporting as usual, Team EI! MY heart breaks as Nora reads the Israeli "heroic" rescue of hostages. The video and narrative leaves me to question, "What value is it to slaughter 270 and injure another 700?"The man who describes how his sons were shot by the IOF in the next room of his home is horrendous.
It is becoming increasingly unbearable to look with our hearts at these killings and wounds especially when our Canadian government does NOTHING, we like to think of ourselves as a just nation. We are not, we remain deaf, and retired old citizens like me feel powerless and my calls to my MP remain UNRETURNED. Our comments and angry requests for a rupture of relations with Israel are not heard. What does it take?
Should you keep going back and covering the same material over and over again? Are they still lying about it? Are they still misleading people about it? Yes or no? If so, then yes, you should and we who know will be even more encouraged, because you give us the context on why speaking about the foundations of our argument against theirs is built upon the rock, a sturdy and firm foundation. Thanks to both of you, for your care and time, dedication and persistence. You would make good pastors. Peace.
Thanks so much team EI for your dedication to excellence and integrity always. Only full news publication that I read. I save the livestreams for the weekend so I can just sit down and watch it in one go on my tv. Best part of my week 🙏❤💚🔻✊🔻✊🔻🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸
Thank you EI. This is the news we don't want to hear, but need to hear. I keep hoping the 'leaders' of our complicit governments will listen to their people and stop this despicable bloodbath. My contempt for the perpetrators grows daily and will remain in my heart forever. The reporters and presenters of EI are our conscience in the face of this barbarism. Our democracies have been bought and sold when our overwhelming voices are ignored.
Please stop fawning over EI They have a job to do. Rather than commenting on how “cool “ they are - engage in their content. Ask questions - ask for answers . Engage in a dialogue - not fan club stuff. Challenge them if need be. Open up a discussion. They contribute effectively with empathy. However , ask questions . Electronic Intifada does not have a fan club - they are serious people. So ask serious questions .
@bjornjensen1309 your job is not picking on the commenters here. this space is for ANY comments. it's free for anyone who wants to comment. You are not the arbiter of what's appropriate. & arrogance is not appreciated by anyone here.
You’ve all put forth such great energy in the past year reporting on everything. Thank you. Watching this upload again 7 months since its publication, I can only begin to wonder about the toll this has taken on us all as a planet-the ‘school slaughter’ depictions are truly heart-wrenching. I cannot believe how much time has passed, and yet so little has changed. May all the suffering people of the world heal and find strength daily. Love and peace.
Nothing is too barbaric for the IDF, still reeling from the screams of those burned alive in the last attack on Rafa refugee camp. Now even more horror! How any sane person can defend this is absolutely depraved!
You've done a fantastic job of answering the repeated question: "Why did Gaza waste their efforts building tunnels instead of turning it into a new Singapore? " Not even the orchards are safe, let alone any luxurious infrastructure.
Not only that but they can't get the supplies needed to build anything. What good is all the money in the world if they can't get anything in or put of the country. The tunnels are pretty much the only way anything can get in
Wow shocking intense pinpoint accuracy the incredible Steadfast Momentum And ingenuity isJust heroic. And the commitment is totally evident. And you guys are amazing as well this is an eye-opening report.
Trying, and failing, to save myself from hopeless parasocial attachment. E.I. delivers an unflinching view of our shocking reality. Thanks dudes! Er, uh, thank you for your excellent work.
Thank you for giving respect to the victims sharing their stories❤️. Once again the stories are just more horrific than you could ever imagine . Shame on the msm whitewashing this genocide !
there's some truth to this, but 95% of Indians are thought to have died from illnesses brought from Europe. Still terrible, & yes there were attacks on Indians by white people. But I don't think there was a systematic genocide of the Indians. I'm not defending American settlers, but I'm pretty sure Nazi Germany & Israel are the only ones to commit this organized, systematic genocide. Rwanda had a genocide but that was slightly different & took place over only a month or two.
As Ilan Pappe remarked that when a settler/colonial project like Zionism is in its terminal stage it is at its most violent and brutal. And Shir Hever, the Israeli Economist has said - regimes that commit genocide usually fall shortly after. Israel will never recover from this no matter the outcome.
I too watched that. It is good work and amazing he chose to make the book and bring it to the world.....
“There are decades when nothing happens and there are weeks when decades happen”
V. I. Lenin
They will certainly need light years to redeem their humanity in the eyes of the world.
I believe that will be the case. But how many innocents will suffer and die before the Israeli state goes away, however that happens? It's cold
comfort in a sense, but still a valid point of course.
Exactly....love Professor PAPPE ❤. Freedom for Palestine
Thank you very much Ali, Asa, Tamara, Nora and Jon. Thank you a thousand times.
Thank you Electronic Intifada. Independent journalists with journalistic integrity are the heroes of our time.
Why would IDF be shooting at people, unless there were people shooting back ? These were HOSTAGES being GUARDED by ARMED HAMAS FIGHTERS. The fact they use civilians as a shield of sorts is pathetic. Hamas wants bloodshed, they have stated that many times. It furthers their cause. There is no doubt that Hamas hides amongst civilians, if you don't believe that, then you are clearly delusional. This is not journalistic integrity, this is what you refer to as "The False Narrative". How can someone be so naive in believing this nonsense. This was a HOSTAGE RETRIEVAL operation. Yes there is bloodshed, but the Gazan's voted for Hamas, and if the recent surveys are accurate, still overwhelmingly have support for Hamas. Tell me why the leaders of Hamas are not in Gaza ? Why are they not in the "state" that they represent ? Living lavishly in a fancy hotel, away from the people they "represent". Palestinian Central Bureau of Statistics ? That sounds awfully like Hamas Statistics. You cannot trust a terrorist organization's information.
God save these people!😢
If there was a 24 hour Jon Elmer channel I would never sleep.
I know..me too
🔻🔻🔻So True 🔻🔻🔻
You are making a VERY special mark within even the most progressive independent journalism of the present.
#LONGLIVERESISTANCE
I have never felt so helpless as I have this past 250 days I feel like there's nothing I can do to help my brothers and sisters. I have never cried so much in my life. I am full of rage and sadness. Please God help us the world has to change
Same for me, I hardly ever cried before, now I'm a weeping mess multiple times a week, especially when I listen to Nora's news report at the beginning of this livestream😭
I live on flight path to Heathrow, never bothered me before. Now at night I listen to planes & imagine the absolute terror suffered by Palestinians especially those poor precious children, may God help them 🙏
Perfectly put. It's beyond comprehension the utter anguish and pain that all of Gaza are suffering 💔 😭
“Israel” asked Palestine: “Palestine, why do the West governments love me but hate you?” Palestine responded “Because you are a beautiful lie and I am a painful truth.”
=🇵🇸= CatSense =🇮🇪=
Cookies
Wow❤
You joined RUclips 7 months ago didn't you littleTROLL-BOT
This is so painfully right. The Zionists cant whitewash this mass murder. They caused the situation. 70 years of theft, oppression & complete hatred. The world will not forget. Its only going to create more 'terrorists'. not just in Gaza. thats the truth & the problem for future Israeli generations. Thats the sad truth of it all.
@@71suns Is that all you've got? No intellectual defense against the lucid quote? I figured as much. Just a meaningless and irrelevant accusation or name calling if you will - a common tactic of those unable to produce reasoning.
Excellent reporting 🥇
Your effort is very much appreciated
Excellent work and exposure by the Electro team, jazakAllah!
From Queensland, Australia. Hello. Know we are with you.
Calling Isreal a democracy is like calling US a democracy
Wrong messaging. It makes it seem like Izzy compares to the US. Almost goving them legitimacy. WE might have very corrupt politicians but we are still a democracy.
The US is an Oligarchy and Kleptocracy. Not an exaggeration. It's textbook.
Oligopoly
I genuinely don't think democracy exists. Humanity is screwed 😢
Thank you. This was a comprehensive and good analysis of the genocide being perpetrated against Palestinians and the efforts made by the Palestinian resistance to defend Palestine.
Amazing work from the ei team as usual! I really look forward to Wednesdays. Your guests, contributors and analysis is truly invaluable during this horrific genocide. I have the deepest gratitude for the work you all do!
Greetings from Ohio, U.S. Thank you for your excellent reporting. I'm a follower of Jesus trying to convince my friends that there is no justifying these continuous unrelenting atrocities.
brave reader of news Nora ❤
AMAZING journalism ,thankyou ei team
The most valuable journalism in history ❤
Thankyou for your great work. Justice for Palestine.
Thank you EI Team, Ali, Asa, Tamara, Nora and Jon for the amazing work you do.
Thank you all very much I deeply appreciate your hard work
It is so sad to watch and hear the news. Global leaders should act now than later. How can people live with this? How unfair is this? So many years to go through this? Unbelievable.
Jon Elmer has the best reviews on this topic, very informative
It’s hard to get your head around this level of evil and depravity.
What a dignified, serious, considered, well-informed, integrous discussion. Just the opposite of what we get from mainstream news sources. 🙏🏿
You guys are AWESOME 👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
Love you all ❤ thank you very much you are amazing
thank you soo much great team.
Thank you EI. Always grateful for your information. Superior analyses.
We must not be silent while witnessing injustice. Israel is committing war crimes and US is complicit in those crimes.
Love this podcast!
It’s not a podcast
Thank you all for another great video show. This is one of my top shows, I recommend it wherever I can. Thanks to you and other independent journalists, high quality reporting that people can trust is available.
I unsubscribed from MSM shortly after Oct. 7 because it was/is sanitized and full of spin. We can look no farther than the Iz propaganda department and the sloppy rehashing of the mass rape claims. Once again, NO EVIDENCE. I’m still surprised that this has been repeatedly presented, and with no forensic examination or autopsy results or real crime scene analysis. No rape crisis centers in Iz have reported any Iz rape victims. This is not about “believe women”, this is about credibility when making serious claims-Show Real Evidence, things admissible in a court of law, collected by trained people, using scientific standards and protocols.
It’s not a “”show”. It’s not tee vee
Thank you EI❤
Thank you for your coverage e.i. I feel at home when watching you guys.
I thoroughly enjoyed Omar's analysis - thanks for hosting him on the podcast
This is heart breaking. Listening to these horrific and nightmare stories of innocent civilians. What is more upsetting is the children who if they survived have to live orphaned and traumatised. I have never been one to wish bad on anyone even my enemies but for these atrocities May Allah never forgive them. Allah Akbar Subhanak Ya Rabbi Allhamdullah la illaha illa Allah 🤲🏾
Thank you as always, Team EI. Yr tireless work is so necessary. I long for the day that we no longer need these updates. ♥️🇵🇸🔻
Many thanks for your work from Brazil!
Thank you thank you ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
From Gold Coast Queensland Australia 🇦🇺 thank you guys 🙏 for your amazing weekly reports which I look forward to, they have provided me some calm 😌 at such a horrifying & devastating time for the Palestinian population 💔 😭 and for many others of us in the world that truly care.
🙏🇵🇸💔😭💔😭#humanity
I am catching up on the first hour that I missed during the livestream. Excellent reporting as usual, Team EI!
MY heart breaks as Nora reads the Israeli "heroic" rescue of hostages. The video and narrative leaves me to question, "What value is it to slaughter 270 and injure another 700?"The man who describes how his sons were shot by the IOF in the next room of his home is horrendous.
Thank you Electronic Intifada.
Thank you Nora for update.
Thankyou all so much, as always your work is so impressive ❤
Incredible work!
Glad to catch a show live from the start
Excellent work, E I.as always
It was very nice to hear Omar
Brilliant programne. So sad but so informative, so necessary. Thank you.
Excellent report!!! Most thorough analysts I've seen thus far indeed!!!
It is becoming increasingly unbearable to look with our hearts at these killings and wounds especially when our Canadian government does NOTHING, we like to think of ourselves as a just nation. We are not, we remain deaf, and retired old citizens like me feel powerless and my calls to my MP remain UNRETURNED. Our comments and angry requests for a rupture of relations with Israel are not heard. What does it take?
It takes the so-called jewish people ending this horrid internal aspect of their culture them selves.
It takes more people like you. Your comment will motivate others to comment, ETC. Thank you.
Thank you for reporting all this... u all are amazing and doing wonderful work... long live the resistance
Electronic Intifada, you guys do an amazing job. Thank you.
Instead of arming Israel, Ukraine and Taiwan, US tax payer money should be spent on infrastructure, healthcare, education, homelessness...
It should be, I am wondering how American OK with continuous spending billions of dollars for war, to sad
Many thanks Ali.
Many many thanks to the EI TEAM FOR ALL that you do bless you all for your dedication.
Thank you Nora
Jon I will never get tired of your videos explaining the resistance videos ❣💯🙌
Should you keep going back and covering the same material over and over again? Are they still lying about it? Are they still misleading people about it? Yes or no? If so, then yes, you should and we who know will be even more encouraged, because you give us the context on why speaking about the foundations of our argument against theirs is built upon the rock, a sturdy and firm foundation. Thanks to both of you, for your care and time, dedication and persistence. You would make good pastors. Peace.
Another great livestream. Thanks, everyone at ei and thanks to all those who support them. ❤ 🔻🔻
Thanks for this reporting of facts.
Thanks so much team EI for your dedication to excellence and integrity always. Only full news publication that I read. I save the livestreams for the weekend so I can just sit down and watch it in one go on my tv. Best part of my week 🙏❤💚🔻✊🔻✊🔻🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸
Lots of Love to Nora and the Electronic Intifada!
Thank you EI. Great report as always
Thank you EI. This is the news we don't want to hear, but need to hear. I keep hoping the 'leaders' of our complicit governments will listen to their people and stop this despicable bloodbath. My contempt for the perpetrators grows daily and will remain in my heart forever. The reporters and presenters of EI are our conscience in the face of this barbarism. Our democracies have been bought and sold when our overwhelming voices are ignored.
Please stop fawning over EI
They have a job to do. Rather than commenting on how “cool “ they are - engage in their content. Ask questions - ask for answers . Engage in a dialogue - not fan club stuff. Challenge them if need be. Open up a discussion. They contribute effectively with empathy. However , ask questions .
Electronic Intifada does not have a fan club - they are serious people. So ask serious questions .
@@bjornjensen1309 thanks for the un-called for advice. Lecture someone else.
@bjornjensen1309 your job is not picking on the commenters here. this space is for ANY comments. it's free for anyone who wants to comment. You are not the arbiter of what's appropriate. & arrogance is not appreciated by anyone here.
Omar Karmi is brilliant! Thank you
You’ve all put forth such great energy in the past year reporting on everything. Thank you. Watching this upload again 7 months since its publication, I can only begin to wonder about the toll this has taken on us all as a planet-the ‘school slaughter’ depictions are truly heart-wrenching. I cannot believe how much time has passed, and yet so little has changed. May all the suffering people of the world heal and find strength daily.
Love and peace.
They won't stop until they're STOPPED. AND THEY HAVE TO BE STOPPED.
What the hell are fellow Arab and Muslim countries doing?! Seems like nothing.
Arrest the psychopath Netanyahu immediately. This is how this can be stopped in an instant . Enough is enough.
You guyes are doing a great historic job for our common humanity. Love.
Amazing journalism salutations from England
Thank you for the detailed coverage EI. Outstanding as usual.
Thank you EI team for this amazing work!
Great discussion with Omar.
Well done, as others have said. We need to hear this, thank you.
الا ان نصر الله قريب 🇵🇸
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤ Love Electronic Intafada when you want the truth of the matter reported accurately
Long live the RESISTENCE !!!
can we please give Jon Elmer his own 2 hour segment.. or maybe daily segments. yalllah
Nothing is too barbaric for the IDF, still reeling from the screams of those burned alive in the last attack on Rafa refugee camp. Now even more horror! How any sane person can defend this is absolutely depraved!
I'm thrilled to learn y'all are streaming on other platforms now.✊🏽🍉
This is incredible reporting. Much appreciated to the most professional presentation of the most highly disturbing event in my life 😢
You've done a fantastic job of answering the repeated question: "Why did Gaza waste their efforts building tunnels instead of turning it into a new Singapore? " Not even the orchards are safe, let alone any luxurious infrastructure.
Not only that but they can't get the supplies needed to build anything. What good is all the money in the world if they can't get anything in or put of the country. The tunnels are pretty much the only way anything can get in
The tunnels were CONSTRUCTED by the Zionist government of Israel during the early 80's when they militarily occupied Gaza and the West Bank.
I'm re-listening to this episode. So horrific what the Palestinians have endured. 😢
Have a good day my Friend ... Love from Malaysia
Resilience, joy, determination - and to free a bird - such a beautiful symbol despite the gravity and loss of words.
Thank you
I cant imagine what its like try to humanise yourself while you suffering in front of the eyes of the world
Sorry for not visiting sooner. Thank you very much
Wow shocking intense pinpoint accuracy the incredible Steadfast Momentum And ingenuity isJust heroic. And the commitment is totally evident. And you guys are amazing as well this is an eye-opening report.
You are my heroes! Thanks so much for the incredible reporting, glad to be a subscriber. Mainstream media is dead!!!
They aren’t your heroes
Surviving Palestinians are
@@bjornjensen1309 - indeed EI are my media heroes and many of their staff are indeed Palestinians
many thanks Jon. very grateful for your analysis. I find it encouraging. Go Resistance!
the scene of people in Gaza saving a bird caught in wires was so moving and poignant. More words aren't necessary
Love Jon Elmer's segments
❤ thank u all ❤
subscribed, liked and shared
Trying, and failing, to save myself from hopeless parasocial attachment. E.I. delivers an unflinching view of our shocking reality. Thanks dudes! Er, uh, thank you for your excellent work.
Thank you for giving respect to the victims sharing their stories❤️. Once again the stories are just more horrific than you could ever imagine . Shame on the msm whitewashing this genocide !
I’m so sorry people of Gaza 😢
It's 'curtains' for the idf
The same thing Americans did to the Indians said they were a bunch of rappers and scalpers
there's some truth to this, but 95% of Indians are thought to have died from illnesses brought from Europe. Still terrible, & yes there were attacks on Indians by white people. But I don't think there was a systematic genocide of the Indians. I'm not defending American settlers, but I'm pretty sure Nazi Germany & Israel are the only ones to commit this organized, systematic genocide. Rwanda had a genocide but that was slightly different & took place over only a month or two.