Aggressive Ashari Interrogates Muhammed Ali On Stream!
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 8 мар 2023
- Support Me and The Channel:
www.paypal.com/donate/?hosted...
/ themuslimlantern
cash.app/%C2%A3TheMuslimLantern
Follow me on Social Media:
/ chainless_slave
/ chainless_slave
/ themuslimlantern
![NoCap - Maliboo [Official Music Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/FUV7E0QyniU/mqdefault.jpg)
Just clarification on some points before they're misunderstood or "intentionally misrepresented" by some:
I'm not telling anyone not to follow a Mazhab, as i stated multiple times in my videos you can follow a Mazhab as a laymen as long as you don't blindly follow it when you find evidence against a specific issue in your Mazhab, my issue is with those who claim everyone MUST follow one of the 4
This video doesn't mean that I'm advocating for a specific sect nor I'm i a part of some group that only follow 4-5 scholars and attacks the rest
I consider myself a Muslim who follows the Qur’ān and Sunnah with the understanding of our Righteous predecessors as the Qur’ān commands us to do and i take knowledge from scholars who rely on the Qur’ān and Sunnah through the understanding of the righteous predecessors
Lastly most of you might not know who Asharis are and you don't need to as long as you're taking knowledge from the right people, however here's a couple of videos for anyone who is interested to learn further about this issue by Ustadth ABH: ruclips.net/video/u8y6GIN95Xo/видео.html ruclips.net/video/ESWNy-9uqoY/видео.html
My Allah bless you and reward you all.
قال عبد الرحمن بن أبي حاتم الحافظ - رحمه الله - : حدثنا أبي - رحمه الله - ، حدثنا الامام سليمان بن حرب - رحمه الله - (شيخ الامام البخاري - رحمه الله -) : سمعت الامام حماد بن زيد - رحمه الله - يقول :
إِنَّمَا يدورون على أَن يَقُولُوا لَيْسَ فِي السَّمَاء إِلَه يَعْنِي الْجَهْمِية // قلت مقَالَة السّلف وأئمة السّنة بل وَالصَّحَابَة وَالله وَرَسُوله والمؤمنون أَن الله عزوجل فِي السَّمَاء وَأَن الله على الْعَرْش وَأَن الله فَوق سماواته وَأَنه ينزل إِلَى السَّمَاء الدُّنْيَا وحجتهم على ذَلِك النُّصُوص والْآثَار ومقالة الْجَهْمِية أَن الله تبَارك وَتَعَالَى فِي جَمِيع الْأَمْكِنَة تَعَالَى الله عَن قَوْلهم بل هُوَ مَعنا أَيْنَمَا كُنَّا بِعِلْمِهِ ومقال متأخري الْمُتَكَلِّمين أَن الله تَعَالَى لَيْسَ فِي السَّمَاء وَلَا على الْعَرْش وَلَا على السَّمَوَات وَلَا فِي الأَرْض وَلَا دَاخل الْعَالم وَلَا خَارج الْعَالم وَلَا هُوَ بَائِن عَن خلقه وَلَا مُتَّصِل بهم وَقَالُوا جَمِيع هَذِه الْأَشْيَاء صِفَات الْأَجْسَام وَالله تَعَالَى منزه عَن الْجِسْم قَالَ لَهُم أهل السّنة والأثر نَحن لَا نَخُوض فِي ذَلِك ونقول مَا ذَكرْنَاهُ إتباعا للنصوص وَإِن زعمتم وَلَا نقُول بقولكم فَإِن هَذِه السلوب نعوت الْمَعْدُوم تَعَالَى الله جلّ جَلَاله عَن الْعَدَم بل هُوَ مَوْجُود متميز عَن خلقه مَوْصُوف بِمَا وصف بِهِ نَفسه من أَنه فَوق الْعَرْش بِلَا كَيفَ
@EverythingAndroid Ois the same way he would not invite a Shi'i or a Khariji to share their views, he should not invite an Ash'ari or Maturidi. If you are truly upon the methodology of Ahlul Sunnah, why would you bring to the people an individual who preaches against the beliefs of the Sahabah? Against what the imams of the salaf agreed upon? That is nonsensical
@@hasakicioguz9312 Why'd you delete your comment?
@@hasakicioguz9312 are u saying all muslims except salafi misguided?
@@everythingandroidois
That guy who entered the stream in rage, Brother Muhammad didn't go to him !
I am Albanian myself and this is what I often notice within my culture. We are way too proud and emotional. Even when we are presented evidence, we reject. This conversation could have been so fruitful. However, the Albanian brother went on laughing and raising his voice. I dont think there is an issue with disagreeing in general, but he even went on imitating the other brother‘s accent. This is beyond disrespectful. If you‘re reading this vlla, in sha Allah te qetëson Allahu sa ma shpejt…
I think his Arab .. not Albanian.. God knows best
May Allah bless you for standing against the arrogance and pride in culture. Surely the Makkans were thr proudest, the loudest, and most arrogant. You are following the footsteps of the Greats of Islam, that rejected their culture for evidence and Allahs Sake.
My sister may Allah reward you with good, can I please advise to remove your profile photo because it a means of temptation and will cause fitnah. Many men have sick hearts, many men are also single and are struggling to get married, so if they see what attracts them it harms them. BarakAllahu feek
Cover ur face sister
@@hva22 that is haqq - but what is also upon the men is to lower their gaze. the amount of uncovered women much worse than our sister is overwhelming. you can't do nothing expect lowering your own gaze. May Allah bless you for you naseeha
Love how calm and laid back Muhammed is. His a gem in giving dawah. Love this brother.
It is a **SUNNI** principle in Islam that ayat are taken on apparent meaning until there is another ayat or hadith to take it otherwise. View Quran 6 :82 Tafsir Bukhari ( Athari Aqida) & Quran 3 :7!
Athari Aqida prevents baseless tatil & tawil, not just on Allah's Siffat due to pagan foreign idolator influence awuthubillah, but the idea to do this in general to any ayat & open foreign bida over sunna (see Q 5 :48), where everyone makes up there own ideas and divides the umma as we see in the sufi Ashari history and their imams repenting and writing books like Usul Dayana.
Qadri deny Allah's siffat due to saying why doesn't Allah stop evil. Allah is Al Hakim as we see in story of Kidr things appear evil, Allah's Siffat help us understand others.
The Mutzailah say each Attribute is a separate being like the idols in Quran 53.19.
Asharis combine these 2 deviations, deny Allah's Siffat Qabr for their own pre conceived notions and see them as parts.
They rely on substance theory as their foundation and call it rationality, after that they filter the holy texts through this ''rational framework'', which in reality is Arestotelian/Greek philosphy.
people skip teaching the right Aqida is wrong, that is how the sahabas build themselves up first, in fact just ask how the last Caleef peaked & fell, in 1680 they peaked under Taymiyyan Turks teaching Tawhid and shunning shirk, but when they were exiled, Sufi grave worship took over...
Allah tied Tawhid to safety in Quran 24 :55, the sufi Uthmanis lost land, divided , even infiltrated as they made up stuff anyone fit in... and became secular until wanting to remove Arabic and Ashari Jordan rose up backed by uk,
the exiled Taymiyyan turks went south to Syria & their students taught Ibn Abdul Wahab whose later generations would form the sunni gulf nations today, like Saudi Qatar or Bahrain ... and save the Haramain from uk and jordan...
So where did the victory go... it went with the right Aqida... the correct Aqida is needed for victory in Quran 2 :137, Quran 9 : 25 shows numbers isn't the key to victory!
This is one of the many downsides of RUclips. You have people like M.A who is unqualified making false statements about the majority of Ahlus Sunnah. This man is not a scholar. Here is a video of Sheikh Hamza responding to people like this.
ruclips.net/video/Gxa63o8rs_w/видео.html
Bro. Why do you deny Allah's attribute? Allah said he forgot in the Quran, why do you deny that which Allah affirmed for himself, you're a mubtadi'!!! See how easy that was?@@falsesectslikeshiaarejudeo6543
Bro Muhammad has years of experience and probably have met the worst before.
With this much anger , ignorance and pride It’s very difficult to accept the truth
Subhanallah this is true
So emotional. Never seen a man act like this
"How am i emotional" (absolutely obliterates his microphone)
🤣🤣🤣
Some people do have a lot of energy..i think he just too passionate
nah bro he was very emotional lol if he is like that at default, he still has the responsibility to acknowledge dat and try to not be too emotional
@Assyaroni passion is an emotion lol.
@@Assyaronipassion without facts is emotions.
It's so crazy when people ask questions, but refuse to hear the answers.
it's like asking for food because you were hungry but rejecting when delicious & nutritious food comes to you.
As an Albanian I apologize for his rudeness but I also must verify for the most part we do speak really loud.
As Muslim we must show how to behave in a gentle manner.Patience is very important esp when we do dakwah to others.
The hadith is reported in Sahih Al-Muslim:
[٢٣٧١] َاثَ كَذَبَاتٍ ثِنْتَيْنِ فِي ذَاتِ اللَّهِ تَعَالَى قَوْلُهُ إِنّّ ي سَقِيمٌ وَقَوْلُهُ بَلْ فَعَلَهُ كَبِيرُهُمْ هَذَا وَوَاحِدَةً ف ِي شَأْنِ سَارَةَ
Prophet Ibrahim (ﷺ) lied only three times:
- About the fact that he was sick (and he was healthy)
- Regarding the fact that the big idol broke the small ones (and it was Ibrahim himself who broke all the idols except the big one)
- About the fact that Sarah is his sister (and she is his wife)
Firstly, the prophets (ﷺ) are sinless and do not lie.
Secondly, Prophet Muhammad (ﷺ) called it a deception because it looked like a deception in appearance, but was not a deception in reality.
1) Regarding the case when Ibrahim (ﷺ) said that he was sick, he meant that he felt unwell from their deep delusion and he seemed to be sick, and this is not a deception.
2) Regarding the case with idols, he meant that the big idol broke all the small ones IF they are able to speak, and if not, then it was not the big idol that broke, that is, this was not an unambiguous statement, and this is not a deception.
3) Regarding the situation with Sarah, he meant that this is his sister in the religion of Islam, and this is not a hoax.
Thus, Prophet Ibrahim (ﷺ) did not actually lie, although there were three cases that outwardly appeared to be deception.
والله أعلم
He's not just loud but also really disrespectful 🙅🏻♀️
speaking loud isn’t a problem when you have good intentions, but he did tell yahmon that he is speaking directly in his ears and only increased his volume as conversation continued
He's not just loud, he's confrontational & only calling to vent his anger.
I am impressed on how good this brother is at shouting. Personally I would've just left the conversation after like 5 min or so, may Allah reward you for your patience and understanding akhi. Allahumma barik
This guy is a walking irony. “BROTHER, WHO’S ANGRY!?!? ARGHHHH!!! I AM NOT ANGRY 😡”
😂
Lol "ARHRYDFUFJJGU!!!!11"
"So you're saying xyz?"
"😯😲🥺 omg brother slow down come on take it easy brother"
I really wish that my children will grow as knowledgeable like you in our deen. Ameen ya Rabb
Ameeennn.. I alsoooo sincerely encourage you and everyone to firstly focus on teaching our kids Arabic. The Language of our Deen. That will be the single key and the driving force for our children to enter the bounties of our beautiful Deen.
Aameen Allaahumma aameen
آمين
or better
It is a **SUNNI** principle in Islam that ayat are taken on apparent meaning until there is another ayat or hadith to take it otherwise. View Quran 6 :82 Tafsir Bukhari ( Athari Aqida) & Quran 3 :7!
Athari Aqida prevents baseless tatil & tawil, not just on Allah's Siffat due to pagan foreign idolator influence awuthubillah, but the idea to do this in general to any ayat & open foreign bida over sunna (see Q 5 :48), where everyone makes up there own ideas and divides the umma as we see in the sufi Ashari history and their imams repenting and writing books like Usul Dayana.
Qadri deny Allah's siffat due to saying why doesn't Allah stop evil. Allah is Al Hakim as we see in story of Kidr things appear evil, Allah's Siffat help us understand others.
The Mutzailah say each Attribute is a separate being like the idols in Quran 53.19.
Asharis combine these 2 deviations, deny Allah's Siffat Qabr for their own pre conceived notions and see them as parts.
They rely on substance theory as their foundation and call it rationality, after that they filter the holy texts through this ''rational framework'', which in reality is Arestotelian/Greek philosphy.
Many can learn how to make Dawah from Brother Mohammad Ali. Very calm, polite, objective and evidence based.
You witnessed a PURE SABR 😄 MashaAllah i wanna do sabr in my life as Muhammad Ali do he has so much sabr may Allah increase it more inshaAllah.
@@sharulshah1979 Allah guide you and us
As an Albanian, I apologize for his rudeness lol
😊
Selam Alejkum !!
@@besmirkocia1207 alaykum assalm
😂
Why ?he's responsible for his own self. May Allah subhaan ahoe wa ta3ala guide us al.
Mohammed Ali is a gem for the dawah! His mannerisms are very gentle yet firm and very masculine. It's inspiring for the youth. May Allah grant us with more knowledge and better manners.
But why include masculine, that just sounds strange to me😂😂
@@HA-jq1mu loll some people (those that lack correct spirituality, knowledge and lean towards more of a western understanding of masculinity) think being gentle and soft are mainly feminine traits. I do not believe this because the greatest man to walk on earth was gentle and soft when appropriate. So, I emphasized his masculinity for those who do believe men being gentle is feminine.
@@aishax01 ahh I get you now
@@aishax01 being a leader is also Masculine too in general.
@@sharulshah1979 all 4 mathhabs were salfi in taking from the sahaba and the sunnah over others, they just bring the context due to experience.
Ma Sha Allah Muhammad Ali, U r so calm, patient, knowledgeable & respectful, May Allah bless you more knowledge, Baraka & perseverance 🤲
Love & respect from Bangladesh ❤️
The way Mohammed Ali says brothaaar in the lowest voice just made me crack 😂 may Allah guide this guy and bless Mohammed in his knowledge mashallah
Appreciate your patience and calm, i had a headache listening to that!
It is a **SUNNI** principle in Islam that ayat are taken on apparent meaning until there is another ayat or hadith to take it otherwise. View Quran 6 :82 Tafsir Bukhari ( Athari Aqida) & Quran 3 :7!
Athari Aqida prevents baseless tatil & tawil, not just on Allah's Siffat due to pagan foreign idolator influence awuthubillah, but the idea to do this in general to any ayat & open foreign bida over sunna (see Q 5 :48), where everyone makes up there own ideas and divides the umma as we see in the sufi Ashari history and their imams repenting and writing books like Usul Dayana.
Qadri deny Allah's siffat due to saying why doesn't Allah stop evil. Allah is Al Hakim as we see in story of Kidr things appear evil, Allah's Siffat help us understand others.
The Mutzailah say each Attribute is a separate being like the idols in Quran 53.19.
Asharis combine these 2 deviations, deny Allah's Siffat Qabr for their own pre conceived notions and see them as parts.
They rely on substance theory as their foundation and call it rationality, after that they filter the holy texts through this ''rational framework'', which in reality is Arestotelian/Greek philosphy.
people skip teaching the right Aqida is wrong, that is how the sahabas build themselves up first, in fact just ask how the last Caleef peaked & fell, in 1680 they peaked under Taymiyyan Turks teaching Tawhid and shunning shirk, but when they were exiled, Sufi grave worship took over...
Allah tied Tawhid to safety in Quran 24 :55, the sufi Uthmanis lost land, divided , even infiltrated as they made up stuff anyone fit in... and became secular until wanting to remove Arabic and Ashari Jordan rose up backed by uk,
the exiled Taymiyyan turks went south to Syria & their students taught Ibn Abdul Wahab whose later generations would form the sunni gulf nations today, like Saudi Qatar or Bahrain ... and save the Haramain from uk and jordan...
So where did the victory go... it went with the right Aqida... the correct Aqida is needed for victory in Quran 2 :137, Quran 9 : 25 shows numbers isn't the key to victory!
This is one of the many downsides of RUclips. You have people like M.A who is unqualified making false statements about the majority of Ahlus Sunnah. This man is not a scholar. Here is a video of Sheikh Hamza responding to people like this.
ruclips.net/video/Gxa63o8rs_w/видео.html
Yes headache - too much for me.
The most impressive thing about Mohammad Ali is that he handles every situation very calmly , he doesn't get carried away with the tone or gesture of the person...and eventually he also calms down the person opposing him in most of the cases .
And what I have observed in his videos whenever he thinks he is about to lose his cool he drinks water sip by sip , Anger is like fire in your body and he cools it with water just like we are asked to cool fever with water in hadess
@IslamsBiggestOPP I hope you have the reach to the unaltered Bible which was given to Prophet Jesus (pbuh) .
@IslamsBiggestOPP You claim that Islam lies. Bring your evidence if you are truthful to prove your claim. Otherwise you will be exposed as a liar
"I follow Quran and Sunnah" Whenever I hear that it's a Red light and when you ask how then their answer is from authentic scholars as if the 4 Imams where not authentic.
I wasted 12 years of my life with this Cult, may Allah guide them that's all I can say.
@IslamsBiggestOPP What's an OPP
@@IslamsFavOPP it's funny christians say w/o lie then talks about Islam when teh bible has millions of versions and Quran is preserved...
lS = lzreal secret...
Mannn the level of patience needed for this one. May Allah bless you Bro Ali!! And may Allah guide Yahmon and us all, Ameen.
Its a good conversation.. love to hear muslims converse in the name of Islam❤️
Before I know the right way of understanding of Islam, I was like this Yahmon guy. Emotional and easily triggered.
Alhamdulillah Allah guide me to the right path. Now I know the right way to understand Islam is through how the first 3 generations understood it. Tauhid, bid’ah, asma wa sifaat etc.
This is the base of our Aqidah.
May Allah keep me and all of us on the right path.
Jazakallah khayran brother Muhammad Ali for the knowledge. May Allah increase you more. Baarakallahu fiik
Ameen.
Are you indonesian?
@@yogisopian9764 yes alhamdulillah
do you believe allah has hands?
@@jamworthy14do you believe Allah has a face that we will be able to see when we enter jannah iA? If Allah says he has hands then we believe it and we don’t ask questions. We don’t go into philosophy about it or try and compare them to something. Nothing is like Allah. We take it and we accept it. For you to take that metaphorically then you have to take Allah having a face metaphorically. You have no basis at all for these metaphors that you create either. They don’t come from the Quran or sunnah.
How beautiful is your way of explaining, as well as your smoothly accepting questions. May Allah increase your knowledge for the benefit of others.
@IslamsBiggestOPP So you convinced yourself that people can’t read and reason. So you thought by saying that people would believe? Why would you embarrass yourself like that?
@IslamsBiggestOPP tell 1 lie
@@mynmeisname4825 he can't because he is the liar, Quran 2 :111 - bring your proof if you are truthful!
Seriously how did you guys finish listening? I'm not even halfway, my ears about to burst, using an earphone here. I'm severely allergic to rude people.
He's a GREAT example for the rest of us, of how NOT to be. He said himself he was ignorant, he came to learn, he doesn't understand Arabic... and this explains why.
Because no real teacher will engage with students who have this attitude of arrogance & derision. And thus he remains both ignorant and aloof.
I pray Allah SWT help us all stay steadfast from hypocrisy, arrogance, and the Dunning-Kruger effect.
Incredible display of patience
He came asked a question and answered his own question and got upset with his own answer. It was clear his emotions were elevated
sister kindly remove the dance videos, whoever gives up something for Allah, Allah gives them better. Have some sincerity in practice because you seem intelligent already.
@@falsesectslikeshiaarejudeo6543 Thanks! I was so confused for a second. It’s gone now
Does Keto diet actually work?
Why are you checking her out? Then you talk about the people of desire. LOL. Classic hypocrite. @@falsesectslikeshiaarejudeo6543
@@Amaleeyy Good job sister. May Allah reward you.
The Prophet ﷺ said: ❛When Allah wants good for a servant, He makes use of him.❜
He ﷺ was asked: ❛How does He make use of him?❜
He ﷺ said: ❛By helping him do a good deed right before he passes away.❜
[At-Tirmidhi 2142 | Graded Sahih]
#husnulkhatimah
This is one of the many downsides of RUclips. You have people like M.A who is unqualified making false statements about the majority of Ahlus Sunnah. This man is not a scholar. Here is a video of Sheikh Hamza responding to people like this.
ruclips.net/video/Gxa63o8rs_w/видео.html
Clearly his father didn't teach him enough to be polite
Insufferable, it pains me to see such ignorance, arrogance, and rudeness being displayed by this guy. May Allah reward brother Muhammad Ali for his patience.
This was painful to listen to, cant imagine what it was like for br Muhammad with his headset on 😂. Kudos for his alhlaq, patience in particular ❤
I'm a Muslim who follows the Quran and sunnah in a correct understanding(the understanding of the prophet and his companions)❤️
@@sharulshah1979 no
@@faysaleladdouti8394here does it say in the Quran or hadith that Allahs Speech has a sound.
@mutaabi-us-salaf does your speech have a sound?
@faysaleladdouti8394 These are two different groups. The Asharites and the Ashari aqeeda are two completely different groups and beliefs.
@@sharulshah1979ou dont study usul ya?
Love seeing you calm and keep smiling. That's a true believer at heart 😊
May Allah guide this man. Unfortunetely he is a ashari and blind.
Ameen
the patience you have is truly admirable....
This is one of the many downsides of RUclips. You have people like M.A who is unqualified making false statements about the majority of Ahlus Sunnah. This man is not a scholar. Here is a video of Sheikh Hamza responding to people like this.
ruclips.net/video/Gxa63o8rs_w/видео.html
I'm not even religious and I rly like the humble way M.A tackles every question in a very comprehensive way.
That's a good manner from you.
But be Aware, your Lord created you and gave you a law to follow. You can't just follow your desires>
I didn't like the first half of your comment but i respect the second half. May i ask. Why don't you worship God Almighty?
@@abdulmunim318 "not religious" means different things to different people. for some, it means they don't pray five times a day. for others, it means they don't believe in god. you have to ask the person individually what they mean when they say they are "not religious" because everyone has their own definition of the tern
May Allah guide you brother
Very argumentative... but you have to be patient and humble yourself. Self-control is very important. Being passionate about something is good but knowing the facts of it is better. May Allaah reward you and blessed with good brother yahmon Ameen
Wa Allahi, if I was a non-Muslim and I spoke with Yahmon from this video and he is representing Islam and his nation like this, I would never speak with another Muslim and even went to his country. Many people have bad manners. But his manner is different. Extremely difficult not saying bad words to define his action. I am proud of the host for the patience he has shown. You are one of the comforting student of islam.
Yahmon was no manner but TOO STUBBORN.
Ali in the video is wrong because he said Ibrahim aleyhisselam lied. If you accept a prophet lies it means that God lies. A lie and tawriya are totally different things.
@@mkaraerikwho are you?
@@muhammaddawood8364 A person who talks the truth
@@mkaraerik subjective “opinion”
Thank you for engaging in that rough interaction. For the sake of Allah and me! Possibly, he will take away a lil’ grace with that. As I certainly am. That’s why I LISTEN to you speak. Calm, steady and to the beat! Thanks for letting him speak and have the opportunity to listen, sincerely. May we all be blessed to listen a lot more, Inshallah🌺
Woelahi brother I love you for the sake of allah. The way you stay calm and still want to help this brother out, i love that. Love from your Moroccan brother 💪🏽❤️
Greetings to you, our Dutch Moroccan brother!
Sounds like Zerka 😂😂😂😂😂
I thought it was only me he sounds exactly like Zherka😂
Brother Muhammad is so patient with him. MashaAllah. May Allah bless you in this world and hereafter
"ooohh maaann" is disrespectful because it's a form of gaslighitng in this context. MashaAllah, i learnt alot from br Ali here. He is calm even in this situation. May Allah preserve and reward him. ameen
The way he said “who’s angry” proves that he was emotional and angry.
هو انغري
My brother you are so resourceful and broadly know what you’re talking about
May Almighty bless you more
Muhammed Ali is a great example for a young moslems should be in this generation, Masya Alloh.
This man is in my top 5 patient daee I have come to know, may Allah reward you for following the Sunnah of our Prophet Muhammad (sallallahu aleyhi wasallam). ❤❤❤
Tell me the other four, i want to learn from them aswell.
Salam.
Please brother tell us about the rest you know
Can you share the rest as well?
Why does he keep shouting? This is not the right adab for a Muslim in discussion, especially if he's discussing with another Muslim
He's not shouting, he's just very energetic. I know people like this in my area as well. They're just loud voiced and very energetic.
@@serkiznatz like: "she's not a prostitute, she's actually a commercial sex worker/he doesn't commit adultery but he's making out with his girlfriend"
Nah I think he is energetic and shouts, energetic because he is so fast with the was he speaks and he is very excited, he shouts but I think it might be normal with people around him possibly shouting for a chance to speak in convos
@@serkiznatz Yes but in Islam you need to have adab when conducting oneself without interjecting and remaining patient and letting the other person speak and finishing their point. This is basic commonsense and decency
@@serkiznatz Energetic = shouting
Aww I feel like he wasn’t outwardly trying to be rude or disruptive but maybe has ADHD or something. May Allah bless you Muhammad for your patience with him
oh god, I need to go to the beach or somewhere in nature that is quiet to unwind after listening to this lol, may Allah SWT reward br M.A. for his patience. I would have bailed a minute later :D
It's very hard to have a conversation with emotional jahil
Its very hard to convey knowledge to the jahil comment on RUclips
Beyond jahil this dude is lost in his ignorance layer after layer
Hownare you brother Yamon are you still angry? @@dr_arcade
@@dr_arcadeyahmon???
@@Dont-worry1618 r u 12? I’m a muslim Arab from Qatar.
I just wonder how people who surround Yahmon manage to survive around him, I literally had my headache watching this video, may Allah guide him and kudos to Br Ali, may Allah reward you for this❣️
I imagine that people surrounding him might have influenced him, he is quite energetic in the convos and probably surrounded by very active people
@@zeylasacli1641 there's a difference between being ENERGETIC and being RUDE AND MANNERLESS!
@@zeylasacli1641 He can have the whole energy in the world, still it doesn't change that what he did was immature.
Beta! You need to get stronger. You wouldn't survive in NYC. You sound very weak.
That is how people of innovation behave aggressively because they have no delils
Danke!
it's like talking to a toddler, asking something, you're explaining and he's asking another thing he's seeing, and then jumping to another random things.
embarrassing.
Ya Allah, grant us patience like that of brother Muhammad Ali and more.
Aameen Allaahumma aameen
I also envy his coolness..masya Allah
Setting low standards. Even he wouldn't want you to make such a dua
@@adorablecheetah2930 jealous much.
@@AbuFarouq oh hardly. From what I've watched so far the brother looks to be very intelligent and sincere. Just that setting him as an example is incorrect I feel, you should instead make the dua that Allah keeps you away from problems. Like how the prophet sallallahu alaihi wasallam instructed one sahabi to not make dua for patience, instead make dua for aafiya (riddance from any problem). That's why I said even the brother would say the same to you. Hope you have a good blday
@@adorablecheetah2930 that Hadith is dhaif. And my dua was meant for a specific context. Not to ask for calamity but rather to be patient in the face of such situations.
Sincerity is the first step towards the truth while arrogance is something which makes you far from the true path even if you are upon it😢
I love it when he said i follow qur'an and sunna❤
What a headache!
May Allah bless you brother Mohammed and increase your knowledge and patience.
May Allah reward you brother Mohammed. It is not always easy to be patient and have good manners when dealing with these kinds of people. May Allah guide Yamon, maybe he just needs time to let it sink in. When I first converted to Islam I was influenced by Sufiyah. Alhamdullilah, Allah saved me from that misguidance. May Allah guide all the Muslims to Quran and Sunnah and save us from innovation in religion, amin.
Even Christians don't behave like this in debate with Brother Ali
BarakaAllahu feek!
honestly i would have lost my temper in the first 10 minutes.
Same
I can't believe this Ash'ari brother doesn't see how he is being disrespectful throughout the chat
It could be a cultural thing. Perhaps where he is from this way of communication is typical?
@@sscr1p7 then his culture is culture of rabid dogs.
@Fred Jinkins he sounds American/Canadian in which case it is atypical to speak this way with others
I saw the stream. He's albanian. And someone mentioned this is generally how albanian act like. So perhaps it's a cultural thing
@@nitroon8476 That's true, it could be. Allahu a'lam
This man is nerve racking!
جزاكم الله خيرا
You take him to the simple definition
How consider someone who reject some صحيح Sunna a Suni !
This is the most clear definition
"How am i being disrespectful?"
"I am not shouting"
Lol.
He's passionate. Like Omar RA was.
SubhannAllah brother Mohammed Ali, your patience SubhannAllah....beautifull! Allahuma barak lik, just beautifull! Can't find the words to explain how beautifull I find your way of givind Dawah. May Allah subhannahu wa Ta3ala give you the best of this world and the best of the hereafter, Ameen! 💪🏽🤓❤️
MaShaAllah, may Allah Azzawajal continue to increase you with beneficial knowledge
Blinded by his emotions unfortunately. May Allah sw guide him.
When arrogance take over you and you do not listen or learn. It’s sad honestly, anyone can fall in that, if they let their ignorance take over, or pride. It’s important to have beautiful character and humbleness. A need to learn and correct oneself. The truth can hurt, because it tells you to let go of a thing that you might hold on to, that is not good for you. Even though you want it to be good. and truly the truth sets you free and the believer they correct themselves and not stay in wrong. And don’t let your love for someone or something take you away from the command of Allah and the sunnah. Alhamdulillah for our deen islam
This brother needs to calm down and relax. Subhana Allah. Why this energy?
Little hard to watch because of this guest, but seeing the love of Muhammed for a fellow believer makes me so happy. Two muslims talking about our religion (even tho with a lil disagreement) gives me a good feeling. May Allah guide both of them and everyone who is watching!
Mohammad Ali brother Allah bless you for your patience.
What i heard is he shouting and my mind is gonna explode
I’m with you Muhammad Ali. May Allah swt always protect and preserve our iman dan hidayah…aamiin
This is a total misunderstanding of Fakhr ud Deen ar Razi's statement.
The statement means that the intellect is necessary to understand revelation.
It certainly does not mean that revelation can be denied, for that is kufr.
I’m not even halfway through and I don’t feel like continuing because of his attitude and how noisy he’s being.
May Allah grant you sabr for dealing with such individuals
Yahmon! At least you need to have patience and decency to listen to others!
I see non-Muslims being more POLITE than this Muslim in this channel.
بارك الله فيك أخي محمد كل ماقلته فهو المنهج الصحيح بإذن الله تعالى وفقنا الله وإياك لما فيه الخير . وأحمد الله وأشكره على فضله ومنه ونسأله الثبات بالفول الثابت في الحياة الدنيا والآخرة .
Quick question….. 😢😂 Barakallahu fik ya akhi for your patience. I started to pull my hair out. 😂
Brother Muhammad, may Allah multiply your patience ten fold. You handle that beautifully.
I am generally a patient guy but he was getting on my nerves from the get go. I would have ended the call within the 1st minute. Brother Yahmon was just abnoxious and sounded like he came on with preconceived notion and wanted to prove himself right, not to really ask questions and learn something or have a dialogue. He may have been trying to troll you. He reminded me of Amy, the christian lady that never wins any debate but is uber confident in her misinformation.
Everyone can see how rude, misguided, arrogant and emotional he is
Maa Shah Allah this brother is very knowledgeable like Utman very calm and convincing may Allah increase his knowledge
May ALLAH increase brother Mohommads patience and bless him and may ALLAH bless all of us with patience like him . Every single time , sunhanAllah , his patience amazes me .
He’s acting like he’s got a gun aimed at his head if he doesn’t get his answer within 0.25 seconds 😭
Love for your Patience ❤
I feel sorry for his wife if he has one 😅 that guy was too much to handle 😂
The wives are always the ones to suffer unless she is like him, then they are on an equal playing field 😂😂🎉
I saw that live on the stream.
He came aggressive and disrespectful
Sometimes the way someone talks show you a lot of his values and religion
The Truth is always clear and obvious
You can see who's on the straight path
Omar RA was also like that. Couldn't be passion? Fear Allah mr know it all.
@@j.r.r.tolkien8724are you saying umar was disrespectful? No he wasnt, he was passionate but not disrespectful like the guy who joined the stream. Stop defending his behaviour
He was by today's standards rude. Don't be ignorant.@@AliHassan-cg6hg
Allah guides from the Quran those who are pious in the sight of Allah according to the first 5 verses of Sura Baqarah,
Brother MA is patient, knowledgeable and and an inspiration to be like him. Bless u brother MA
Amin!
sufi asharis are like half shia mutazili, one deny sahaba who compile Quran, other deny Aqida of 4 Mathhab & 6 Hadith imams who compile fiqh & hadith, yet claim Islam or sunna & enjoin ext. taqlid of Quran 9 :31, not Quran 21 :7 to learn dalil like Quran 12 :108 & divide umma & persons from revelation. See quotes of the 4 mathhab imams, a good compilation was made by Sh. Albani.
Keep in mind the quotes of the preistly sufis who say be like a corpse and not asking questions... maybe that is why deviant Yasir Qadhi though yajuj and majuj were zombies... they hought they were sufis or from the book of mathew. Asharis error on Sifat mixed with sufi error on hadith of dreams in a preistly bida manner compiled over time to their seularism. the kitabis of the umma, or recal the hadith some will follow the greeks and majewsis!
---
They have no dalil to differ one Siffat of Allah for another or aka Siffat Qabr, they interpret like pagans interpret Allah's Siffat as parts or physical idols.
Quran 53 : 19. Have you then considered Al-Lat, and Al-'Uzza
, Tafsir ibn Kathir - Ibn Jarir said: They derive name for their idol Al-`Uzza from Allah's name Al-`Aziz.
Ashari errors on Tawhid Siffat are of old pagans. Quran 2 :143 - we are the middle nation, in running from idolatry, asharis fell in. Allah not speaking is of idolators of Ibrahim (Quran 21 :65), to say Allah isn't over His Arsh is of Firaun/atheism (Quran 40 :37), to say Allah doesn't change denies hadith of intercession, Allah is angriest on Qiyama (Sahih Muslim, Kitab Iman). The Salafis when they say Ashari imply Tashbih to deny the Siffat is clear from their pattern of error matching the pagans of old who affirmed it in a way they do.
Quran 16 : 60. For those who believe not in the Hereafter is an evil description, and for Allah is the highest description. And He is the All-Mighty, the All-Wise.
- Ties Allah's Siffat's high description, clearly above tashbih to the hereafter, like Seeing Allah in Quran 75 :23, refutes Jahmiya who error on Allah's Siffat who Asharis follow, who maybe deprived of seeing Allah as a penalty!
---
Other errors, we don't need greek kalam baggage but Islamic qiyas for logic. True Aql conforms with the Naql as Ibn Taymiyyah teaches.
We don't need Batini sufi preist baggage zhud (Quran 58) but Sunni Zhud for dicipline!
Ahad hadith are taken in creed as Sh. Albani wrote in his book with that name, even Ibn Hajr and Nawawi were salafi in hadith science in this affair!
Many of their imams, Imam Ashari himself repented as did Juwaini i think and ghazali but didn't know what to repent to due to the post salaf mihnah situation of the day.
Sunni scholarship is Athari.
Muhammad Ali is so amazing! So much knowledge and humbleness. Honestly, him and other brothers I hear talking about Islam and giving Dawah, their Islam is so beautiful and far beyond what I know or can discuss. May Allah give him jannah and reward him for his effort. And it is a huge effort to discuss and talk about so many topics with this brother and others and non Muslims..
The videos are all well edited maşaAllah, with all the quotes and sources etc. I really appriciate your work, may Allah جل جلاله reward you for your work and time you spent for this.
I just want to ask if you think about adding subtitels in other languages so even more people can profit from these videos?
Barakallah to you Muhammad amd your crew..wallah the name Muhammad befits you due to your patience and your surname Allie as for your knowledge.May Allah bless you even more and your entire team...Ameeen
Blessed you Ali. Your very patient and calm. Listening to other guy irritates me, je started laughing and raising his voice but I want to listen Ali's answer. Thank you Ali.
"WHY YOU GETTING EMOTIONAL BRO!!!????🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬"**Demolishes my ears**
Anxiety is mental issue May Allah heal us
You are getting better every time you facing these guys
Brother Mohummad is too knowledgeable for any aggression!!
Allahuma Barik
Too patronizing.
8:04 the way he said “Alhumdulillah”😂😂
This guy was the definition of uncontrolled emotion
Alhamdulillah for the Quran and Sunnah with the understanding of the Sahaba/Salaf!
It is a **SUNNI** principle in Islam that ayat are taken on apparent meaning until there is another ayat or hadith to take it otherwise. View Quran 6 :82 Tafsir Bukhari ( Athari Aqida) & Quran 3 :7!
Athari Aqida prevents baseless tatil & tawil, not just on Allah's Siffat due to pagan foreign idolator influence awuthubillah, but the idea to do this in general to any ayat & open foreign bida over sunna (see Q 5 :48), where everyone makes up there own ideas and divides the umma as we see in the sufi Ashari history and their imams repenting and writing books like Usul Dayana.
Qadri deny Allah's siffat due to saying why doesn't Allah stop evil. Allah is Al Hakim as we see in story of Kidr things appear evil, Allah's Siffat help us understand others.
The Mutzailah say each Attribute is a separate being like the idols in Quran 53.19.
Asharis combine these 2 deviations, deny Allah's Siffat Qabr for their own pre conceived notions and see them as parts.
They rely on substance theory as their foundation and call it rationality, after that they filter the holy texts through this ''rational framework'', which in reality is Arestotelian/Greek philosphy.
people skip teaching the right Aqida is wrong, that is how the sahabas build themselves up first, in fact just ask how the last Caleef peaked & fell, in 1680 they peaked under Taymiyyan Turks teaching Tawhid and shunning shirk, but when they were exiled, Sufi grave worship took over...
Allah tied Tawhid to safety in Quran 24 :55, the sufi Uthmanis lost land, divided , even infiltrated as they made up stuff anyone fit in... and became secular until wanting to remove Arabic and Ashari Jordan rose up backed by uk,
the exiled Taymiyyan turks went south to Syria & their students taught Ibn Abdul Wahab whose later generations would form the sunni gulf nations today, like Saudi Qatar or Bahrain ... and save the Haramain from uk and jordan...
So where did the victory go... it went with the right Aqida... the correct Aqida is needed for victory in Quran 2 :137, Quran 9 : 25 shows numbers isn't the key to victory!
This is one of the many downsides of RUclips. You have people like M.A who is unqualified making false statements about the majority of Ahlus Sunnah. This man is not a scholar. Here is a video of Sheikh Hamza responding to people like this.
ruclips.net/video/Gxa63o8rs_w/видео.html
Alhamdoulilah
The Salaf(second and third generation) a majoirity used Ra'y for sharia in those times.
It only shows that nowdays muslims no nothing about early islamic history