Agree. Acchan the all-time Eternal Center. Sasshi the Queen of Senbatsu in terms of numbers. After Acchan, Mayuyu was the true Center, the Face of AKB48, and the true beloved overall Queen.
Interesting video. Ranking purely by votes obviously advantages both timing (those who were in the 48 universe in the 6-10th sousenkyo get more votes by nature of the groups’ overall popularity) and longevity (more legitimate an advantage than timing, I think). It makes me wonder if there’s a way to rank based on a combination of votes, votes as a percentage of total votes cast, and ranking. For example, Acchan’s 4,630 votes in the 1st sousenkyo would have ranked her worse then 80th in the 7th. So, she ends up 25th in this ranking but, she’s an absolute legend and an all time Kami-7. Anyway, maybe I’ll spend a weekend trying to figure out a good formula to take a couple other variables into account. Fun watch and thanks for the thought problem!
@@neosicheng I quickly did the first 3 and it's pretty interesting. Acchan's 4,630 was 8.6% of all votes with Yuko's 3,345 at 6.2%. The next year, Yuko's 31,448 was 8.9% but Acchan's 30,851 was 8.7% (so, she increased her share of the vote and still finished 2nd). In the 3rd SS, Acchan's 139,892 votes jumped to 13.1% of the total with Yuko's 122, 843 representing 11.5% of the vote. Their rivalry separated them from the field. I'll do the rest over the weekend, but the participant numbers go way up so it'll take a little time.
i saw a lot of comments talking about the fact that this ranking advantages members who partecipated in the latest sousenkyo and members who partecipated the most times, and i think i've come up with a way to calculate the rankings where these two factors don't count (at least i think) you could calculate the average rank for every member, instead of the votes; for example, acchan ranked 1st twice and 2nd once, so her average rank is 1.33... ecc, while sasshii ranked 27, 19, 9, 4, 2 and four times first, so her average ranking would be 7.22...ecc (this makes sense considering that acchan always ranked high, while sasshii started as a less known member) this way, the number of participations is not important, since it's an average, and since the number of votes is not considered either, members who partecipated when the group was less famous aren't in disadvantage ^^
I love that you made this! It was a very interesting watch. I see a lot of people debating the best way to perfect the ranking and I tried my hand at it as well. I made a scale to give out "points" to girls depending on their rank (1st gets 100, 2nd gets 99, etc.) And then bonus points for every center, kami 7, and senbatsu position. It still favors longevity in the group, but I think it reduces some favoritism in timing. (Results in replies)
Undergirls Matsui Rena (Center) Yamamoto Sayaka Maeda Atsuko Itano Tomomi Takajo Aki Oba Mina Oya Masana Matsumura Kaori Okada Nana Takahashi Juri Sato Amina Ota Aika Kuramochi Asuka Muto Tomu Kasai Tomomi Umeda Ayaka
Jurina~san... At this point she gonna reign for a decade... When will there be another senbatsu... I know that the NGT scandal make a lot of the investor pull away...and the pandemic are not helping either.... But now that the dust has settled... There need to be another queen... Many of the senbatsu member of sentimental train has graduated... So it'll be interesting to see who will win...
Love that Sasshi breaks a million in total votes. So are Yui and Sakura the only members whose rank never went higher year on year (let's say minimum 4 participations)?
you would have to factor in the total number of votes per ssk, as in earlier ssks there were much less votes total cast ( Miichan getting 14th spot with just 1,414 votes ... and 32nd with 29,020)
@@saravinvong9451 as you can see i counted every votes she earned, she didn't participate for the 4th and 5th senbatsu then she graduated 😖 at the beginning there wasn't a lot of votes like at the 10th senbatsu :D
![【MV full】桜、みんなで食べた / HKT48[公式]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/4-gTfa2hO0o/mqdefault.jpg)
hi!
From members who aren’t graduated mine are yukirin, miu and emiri
And thanks for making the video even that it took long c:
@@_novvog 🤲💗
Acchan will always be my favorite
Mayuyu
Mariko and yuki 💗
This proves how unfair AKB48 has been to Yukirin
She should have been the center in Lots of singles like the top 3 girls
Akb48 prime era.
Maeda the Ace of akb48
Mayuyu the future True center of akb48
Sasshi The Queen of Senbatsu..
Agree. Acchan the all-time Eternal Center. Sasshi the Queen of Senbatsu in terms of numbers. After Acchan, Mayuyu was the true Center, the Face of AKB48, and the true beloved overall Queen.
Cuma sekali menang 1🤣@@jsprite123
Mayuyu is my favorite member of AKB. She deserves the best.
Thumbnail is very nice.
Interesting video. Ranking purely by votes obviously advantages both timing (those who were in the 48 universe in the 6-10th sousenkyo get more votes by nature of the groups’ overall popularity) and longevity (more legitimate an advantage than timing, I think). It makes me wonder if there’s a way to rank based on a combination of votes, votes as a percentage of total votes cast, and ranking. For example, Acchan’s 4,630 votes in the 1st sousenkyo would have ranked her worse then 80th in the 7th. So, she ends up 25th in this ranking but, she’s an absolute legend and an all time Kami-7. Anyway, maybe I’ll spend a weekend trying to figure out a good formula to take a couple other variables into account. Fun watch and thanks for the thought problem!
thank you so much! some followers told me that i can make a variable of all votes of each member, i can try but i'm not really good at maths haha..
Do you have all the votes in an excel sheet? If so, you could email it to me and I can do it pretty quickly.
@@grechan no i don't but everything is on stage48 website, i only have the totals for everyone :(
@@neosicheng I quickly did the first 3 and it's pretty interesting. Acchan's 4,630 was 8.6% of all votes with Yuko's 3,345 at 6.2%. The next year, Yuko's 31,448 was 8.9% but Acchan's 30,851 was 8.7% (so, she increased her share of the vote and still finished 2nd). In the 3rd SS, Acchan's 139,892 votes jumped to 13.1% of the total with Yuko's 122, 843 representing 11.5% of the vote. Their rivalry separated them from the field. I'll do the rest over the weekend, but the participant numbers go way up so it'll take a little time.
@@grechan wow you're really good :O
i saw a lot of comments talking about the fact that this ranking advantages members who partecipated in the latest sousenkyo and members who partecipated the most times, and i think i've come up with a way to calculate the rankings where these two factors don't count (at least i think)
you could calculate the average rank for every member, instead of the votes; for example, acchan ranked 1st twice and 2nd once, so her average rank is 1.33... ecc, while sasshii ranked 27, 19, 9, 4, 2 and four times first, so her average ranking would be 7.22...ecc (this makes sense considering that acchan always ranked high, while sasshii started as a less known member)
this way, the number of participations is not important, since it's an average, and since the number of votes is not considered either, members who partecipated when the group was less famous aren't in disadvantage ^^
your way is a good way, i didn't think of it >
I love that you made this! It was a very interesting watch. I see a lot of people debating the best way to perfect the ranking and I tried my hand at it as well. I made a scale to give out "points" to girls depending on their rank (1st gets 100, 2nd gets 99, etc.) And then bonus points for every center, kami 7, and senbatsu position. It still favors longevity in the group, but I think it reduces some favoritism in timing. (Results in replies)
Senbatsu
Sashihara Rino (Center)
Watanabe Mayu
Matsui Jurina
Kashiwagi Yuki
Yokoyama Yui
Takahashi Minami
Kitahara Rie
Minegishi Minami
Kojima Haruna
Oshima Yuko
Suda Akari
Miyawaki Sakura
Miyazawa Sae
Takayanagi Akane
Shinoda Mariko
Shimazaki Haruka
Undergirls
Matsui Rena (Center)
Yamamoto Sayaka
Maeda Atsuko
Itano Tomomi
Takajo Aki
Oba Mina
Oya Masana
Matsumura Kaori
Okada Nana
Takahashi Juri
Sato Amina
Ota Aika
Kuramochi Asuka
Muto Tomu
Kasai Tomomi
Umeda Ayaka
Next Girls
Fujie Reina (Center)
Furuhata Nao
Akimoto Sayaka
Shiroma Miru
Miyazaki Miho
Tomonaga Mio
Watanabe Miyuki
Kojima Mako
Tashima Meru
Kizaki Yuria
Mukaichi Mion
Yoshida Akari
Kato Rena
Soda Sarina
Kodama Haruka
Masuda Yuka
Future Girls
Sato Sumire (Center)
Ogino Yuka
Sasaki Yukari
Shibata Aya
Ichikawa Miori
Kimoto Kanon
Hirajima Natsumi
Fuchigami Mai
Moriyasu Madoka
Yabuki Nako
Katayama Haruka
Ishida Haruka
Yagura Fuuko
Yamauchi Suzuran
Tanaka Miku
Nakagawa Haruka
(Which may be the cutesiest selection ever 🤣)
Upcoming Girls
Iriyama Anna (Center)
Tano Yuka
Matsuoka Natsumi
Ono Erena
Homma Hinata
Iwatate Saho
Kawamoto Saya
Furukawa Airi
Motomura Aoi
Ota Yuuri
Yamada Nana
Sakaguchi Riko
Yabushita Shu
Ego Yuna
Maeda Ami
Nagao Mariya
エイケイビ可愛い応援する大好き❤
Jurina~san... At this point she gonna reign for a decade... When will there be another senbatsu... I know that the NGT scandal make a lot of the investor pull away...and the pandemic are not helping either.... But now that the dust has settled... There need to be another queen... Many of the senbatsu member of sentimental train has graduated... So it'll be interesting to see who will win...
Ayyy naachan top 20!!
Le fait que mayuyu soit arrivée qu'une seule fois première me surprendra toujours 😂
même moi genre mayuyu 1ère place ? elle mérite 😳
Love that Sasshi breaks a million in total votes.
So are Yui and Sakura the only members whose rank never went higher year on year (let's say minimum 4 participations)?
Sakura rank always move up (47, 26, 11, 7, 6, 4, 3)
わかめスープ飲む！
cool
Omg top 3 still super strong?!!?!?!!!???
Should I be shocked that even in an Ult sousenkyo Sasshi is once again The Queen of AKB48!🤣😛
Well she participate to all sousenkyo (except the Last)😂
Most of nmb girls didn't participate expect for the aces cause they lowkey hate ssk
Takayanagi akane is real ultimate undergirls 😂
Sashi Legend
What about you get the average votes? For example, some of them joined the SSK three times so the votes are definitely low.
it's a good idea but i'm not good at math haha.. but i really understand, i can try maybe :D
@@neosicheng You just add all votes and divide the number of times they join SSK. The result is fair haha
@@MyKoreanNotebook thanks i'll try :D
you would have to factor in the total number of votes per ssk, as in earlier ssks there were much less votes total cast ( Miichan getting 14th spot with just 1,414 votes ... and 32nd with 29,020)
@@remko2 thanks💖
エイケイビ可愛い大好き応援する😂
is this #sukinanda senbatsu right?
it's all the senbatsu combined together
wkwk the top 3 is same with love trip and #sukinanda senbatsu
0:24 song title?
it's ngt48 "hakkiri itte hoshii", every songs are in the description if you need more titles
Takajo aki is 5th generation😄
she is 6th gen >
No meada atsuko?
she's at 10:16 :D
Why is she got only 175,373?
@@saravinvong9451 as you can see i counted every votes she earned, she didn't participate for the 4th and 5th senbatsu then she graduated 😖
at the beginning there wasn't a lot of votes like at the 10th senbatsu :D
これでシングル出して欲しい
しかし 渡辺麻友が引退してるから難しいかな？
it would be really cool haha
i miss mayuyu :(
26, Ogino Yuka 164,400? Right?. No
i just redid the math and it's an error... it's actually 179,056 votes! i'm sorry for the mistake :(
song at 10:54 on juris pic?
and muto tomo’s? pls
@@aaeongi hi, i don't remember the exact titles but all the titles are in the description of the video if you need
@@neosicheng ohh tyy ^^
朝長美桜第5回の総選挙29位じゃなくない？
i just verified and it says 59th place for the 5th election! sorry for my mistake :(
I❤ Mayu sugoi super Kawaii girl
❤Mayu Kawaii so cute girl
@7:21 that’s kizaki yuria, not sasaki yukari! :)
you're right, sorry for the error omg..
so basically, Sashihara takes on of the rest on.