Let’s keep it 100% REAL . No shade to anyone at all . BTS did pave the way . I can explain this way …..ok let’s say there is vault with all k pop artists BTS had the combination to open the door , and instead of closing it …BTS did not shut that door they left it open so the other k pop artist can come out too . That’s just my way of describing how they pave the way .. FACT CHECK if you go on you tube and watch so many k pop artist literally saying BTS pave the way . PSY a great k pop artist he said BTS did what he wanted to do and that’s why he admire them so much . Let me say this for all the BLINKS I have nothing against black pink at all . I wish those lovely ladies nothing but continued success .i hope they get the contract they wanted 💜❤️🙂and always stay true to themselves
Imagine paving the way for others and the beneficiaries are also part of the hate train. BTS & ARMYs endured so much hate/racism breaking in to the west. The unappreciative Labels and fandoms should be praising instead of trying to bring us down.
The thing that amuses me is that after all this, BTS never "claimed" they paved the way.. not even a single member.. even when Namjoon read the message, he just said "cool".. But others have to shout on top of their lungs that they paved the way😂😂 you can never ever imagine BTS doing such cheap tricks.. They're not only kings, but are Humble Kings!
Honestly, i dont understand their hype. I've been in kpop since 2001 and have seen it become what it is, but every time someone tells me BP opened up doors and lead the way for many others, i just dont see it. First, i dont see them as singers or performers. They're not great at it. If im honest, they're more known outside of music, more in fashion, which is fine. However, to call yourself a singer or a music artist, you actually need to sing and perform, write music. Other than Rose, the other 3 are just there for the looks.
Let’s have a serious, logical, respectful discussion. If BP paved the way, what did they do to help other artists coming up after them? How did they make things easier for them? Because doing those things is what paving the way means right?
paving the way for me is literally that, making a road.. not taking someone’s hand after and leading them on that road. taking the paved way is entirely the “next one”s choice/job to do, instead of breaking their (next one) backs to pave a walkable new one. so I’m not sure what way you expect this discussion to go. cool to discuss things though.. sure. just to clarify - from my limited knowledge of k-pop and its influence around the world (discovered it after the pandemic. yeah I lived under a huge rock apparently in this regard with overwhelming amount of people in my country), those who paved the way, internationally at least, were PSY for some and BTS for the majority that I see. I personally only discovered there is BP only after discovering BTS and thinking oh I’ll check what else is there. I will not say anything negative about them cause I don’t think they deserve negativity. don’t see where they supposedly paved the way though. oh well 😊 on second thought… maybe female aspect? a version of female empowerment in Korea? somewhere in those lines would make some sense maybe. donno
Fyi , now all the other kpop group getting awards or getting nomination in western award shows, is all because of BTS... Coz of BTS , they created spreate kpop category....!! Don't talk such senseless just watching some YT videos, where they just talkin rubbish, like BTS made it difficult bla bla 😅😂
@@MikolajNieswiety what will that do? Bts are the reason why today kpop is labeled as a music industry and a part if the music industries. Coz of bts American award shows have the categories kpop like bbms, ama, vma and even grammys.
The exact same discussion can be said for BTS they did make a name for themselves and also their success is a benchmark for k-pop dies that mean their global recognition automatically extended to other groups too. nope
You’re very diplomatic. BP’s “pave the way” lyrics, stating it boldly, targets them for disagreement and shows their ego-no need to be humble or appreciative of where you came from when you’re that famous. I feel that BP has lost their creative drive. It seems they have become a money-making machine controlled by their marketing team. They appear insincere, soulless, losing their creative edge, who see themselves as “badass and beautiful” but it’s not them really talking.
I have another foul play suspicion and was wondering if anyone else has experienced this or is it just me. I’m not a blink and I don’t seek out BP content, but I keep getting their videos or videos about them suggested to me on RUclips. I’m Army and I proactively seek out BTS content to watch, but I only get a few recommended videos of BTS. Even channels that I subscribe to, sometimes I have to dig into their channel to find a video because it doesn’t even show up in the results if I search for it. I find this highly sus. Anyone else have the same experience?
@@AsianEntertainmentandCulture exactly! Hella sus!! How can videos from official accounts that I’m subscribed to not even get recommended to me? But I keep getting BP video suggestions 🤦🏻♀️
If you're not interested in a channel, hit the three dots at the bottom right of the video and select 'Don't Recommend Channel' or 'Not Interested.' This is how I stopped receiving channels that kept popping up. I always select 'Don't Recommend Channel.'
A Rapper writes their own lyrics their own story, it's part of being a Rapper along with word play, ryhming lyrics, candence and flow. To be a Rapper you need all these elements.
When I saw the lyrics of the song and who had credits I honestly just laughed. I couldn’t take the paved the way line seriously in the least because no one besides their fans has ever said that about Blackpink. 1) Clearly the lyrics were meant to poke the bear aka ARMY and in some ways it worked. Outrage marketing is still a thing. However, I won’t say that it poked the bear enough for anyone else to pick up on outside of twitter beef between the fandom because the streams were low and it didn’t move on any chart. 2) Melanie Fontana has a long-standing axe to grind with ARMYs. Don’t know if she wrote that particular lyric, but one can only wonder… 👀 3) YG is great at using the genuine things said about BTS by others and applying it to Blackpink. They’ve consistently attached themselves to BTS ever since BTS began gaining in the US, whether it be indirect or explicit comparisons. They have spent tons of money getting the public to perceive that Blackpink are the female equivalent of BTS, even if numbers and global impact say otherwise. Having the girls say they “paved the way” is just another way that YG is hitching Blackpink’s wagon to BTS’ star. 4) I’ve mostly had to move past rappers needing to write their raps because it’s an open secret that nowadays even the biggest names in hiphop have ghostwriters. *BUT* I at least have to BELIEVE that they wrote them. Believability is so important in this era of hiphop and I simply don’t believe Blackpink with this “paved the way” line. Even if Jennie wrote it… nah she doesn’t seem the type to lie to herself like that lol.
Fun Fact: do you know why BP has such high youtube numbers that don't quiet fit with the rest of their numbers? Because they put their MVs in the commercials that play with you don't buy out of that. That was btw a very real tool for charting before it was axed in 2019 (?). Taylor Swift and Co. did do it, too. It became too much when an Indian (?) singer nearly broke a record, too and the practice was stopped. There are articles about it. YG is very good at pretending to be bigger than their artists actually are and to a certain degree it also makes them actually that great (or it could if they filled it with substance). I think they may be in trouble now because from what the rumors are saying only Rose is resigning - but maybe that is only a rumor. We will have to wait for the official announcement.
@@ruthfischer7615 You ain't wrong there about BP and the RUclips commercials which is extremely low brow scraping the bottom of the barrel tactics. But then YG are nothing but low brow tacty sleezy con artists disguised as a bonafida business.
@@ruthfischer7615oh, the thing you were saying with the adds makes a lot of sense. I was seeing a lot of BP adds for a while, even though I don’t watch their videos or listen to their music. I got annoyed with them and started blocking them (the ads), but it took me several months to block them all, there were so many🤦 and even now I still get the occasional add.
Personally their Music isn't to my taste I don't rate them as artists at all. I've no hate towards them and hope they finally find what they really want to do and with a company that will help them to develop. As for the lyric's of their song it's laughable.
It's a bit sad that BP's keeps getting into scandals in relation to BTS (YG's early comments about BTS's success, dating sandal, and now this) because they have the ability to shine on their own and uplift fellow artists instead of putting them down. Unfortunately I don't think that would ever happen. YG never gives BP their own voice, they just like to cosplay feminism and girl power for profit, which is so sad to see. I don't think that the girls can look back on their career and be proud of their legacy, but hey I guess as long as they're making money they're okay with being complicit with morally dubious actions.
I have heard this reading recently - no idea how accurate it is: In BP you have a dancer, someone that actually likes making music, an actress and an influencer. Rumor says most of them are not resigning but I may have missed the newest intel.
For me, BP are more like an influencer or those tiktokers. Pretty and good at dance. (Only Rose are good singing live) They focus more on their visual than their singing. Their song are catchy and addictive. But thats all. There is nothing special about BP. Don't forget that BTS paved the way, so the others could enter easily. BP got more popular after BTS enter the global market.
In my own opinion, I feel like BP and their fans do things to engage BTS ARMY. All the views, comments, all of that still count as views, streams, so they're not losing anything, they're actually gaining. Their fan/fandom often attach themselves to BTS, videos, fake pictures, anything and everything with BTS, yet on the other hand, BTS does not do that to them or anybody else. BP, I think is not that big of a deal, look at Twice, New Jeans, their accomplishments. BP, advantage because they have a U.S. platform and U.S. people to help them in the western industry. Bora City, provided proof that BP is forcing views and streamers to view and stream because of their advertisement before viewing and streaming. The other female groups, are achieving just as much as BP, but they don't have the fandom or western industry help like BP does. It's disheartening to see the attachment to BTS all the time with BP and their fan/fandoms. I would have to disagree, I do believe 100% that they do know the meaning of that, "We Paved The Way", that's why they have that. Free publicity comes with controversy and that's what they're counting on and getting. They are really adapting to western tactics. It's hard for me to understand why they are considered the girl group, when their concerts are a hit or a miss, never consistent in all aspects, vocally, choreography, energy, why? In a video that Bora City put out, BP is in that video, stating they want to be the ones to open the door, this is after BTS had already knocked the door down. I think they're mastering the controversy tactics very well and keeping attention on themselves through this more so than by their art. I don't mind them, listen to them once in a while, but they are not the best girl group, performance wise, vocal, which is part of their art, so creating controversy is a great tactic to get people engaged. BTS is pure art, don't have to attach to anybody, don't have to use cheap tactics.
i also got free tickets. a tiktok "influencer" approached me and said if i play a game and win, I'd win two tickets. I refused and later on, when i passed her again, she gave me 5 tickets no question asked. LOL
I initially liked BP when they first started but the more I know how they use media play to create a certain narrative I just lost interest and their message in their songs are exactly the same as the very first song they had. 2NE1 really set the bar high as girl group stands
Thank you for your take on this. I personally don't like BlackPinks music. That's just me. I do respect them for their hard work. Just like I respect everyone who's in this line of business. It isn't easy. I know for a fact that the concerts weren't sold out. I've been to a concert of them with a friend because, she likes them. She likes them because, BlackPink are girls related to her personally as you have to like them because, of woman/girls empowerment. I have to admit the concert was kind a disappointing. My friend as a diehard BlackPink fan was disappointed as well. If I'm honest I don't think YG did wrong towards the members of BlackPink. Look at what they've done for them. They bought radioplay etc for them. They gave them their training. Made deals with Disney etc. They had their solo albums and promoted them. They did some acting etc. They contacted famous singers to collaborate with them. Gave them happy go lucky songs where you don't really have to think about a deeper meaning of the lyrics/messages. That you can easily sing and dance to even when you are drunk. It is understandable to me that they actually believe that they paved the way. The whole K-Pop award genre in the states isn't their due to BlackPink. It is their due to the fact that in the states you also have Latino's awards etc because, they don't want cerain musicians to over shadow the english native American musicians. YG isn't that bad because, how they put BlackPink together was/is very smart by taking girls from different countries and form a group. You know every country supports the musician from their native country. So BlackPink profited from it. Plus at the moment the Hype about woman empowerment. To me there are better Korean musicians but, not all of those musicians have a powerful company like YG behind them. I truly believe that BlackPink wouldn't be so big if they started out from a smaller and less connected and pour company. In Europe there were boybands like Take That etc so as a countermeasure there was a girlband like Spice Girls. This happened with BlackPink too. Also some of the things BlackPink is doing have been done before by others. So they are not original and are not paving the way. They are only using what is already there. YG is doing a good job for them. YG deserves a compliment because, BlackPink what they are now would never have been this big as they are now. Each member of BlackPink is doing a lot of things due to YG on the side. It doesn't matter that the members don't write their own lyrics. Not everyone is capable of writing. They can sing and dance. So that's good. Sorry, I respect every member of BlackPink but, I've seen better live concerts with female musicians far better then them. Of course to my personal taste of music and depth of lyrics etc. Sorry, for the long comment. Warm greetings from The Netherlands
That's the MOST respected criticism I've seen here today... And I Absolutely LOVE that. Much respect to you for that, although I don't agree with some of your comments but it's just me and nothing against you for saying what you've said. World would've been wonderful place if all people were like you but sadly we got mejority of opposite people 😂
what u said i respect it...but we love blackpink songs boombayah is really very bop then others too...my fav song is definitely The happiest girl...becoz that time i feel this song is really meant for their voices...its just perfect when all 4 sing it . but agree yg is great at marketing and hype...ofcourse talent too..their artists stage presence is amazing...and BP success is all becoz of yg songs ...teddy is really make hit songs....and their last seoul concert is lit...no doubt yg is great and all 4 girls was great in coachell and last seoul and los angels concert..and all 4 will definitely successful in future too...all becoz of yg ..but still the artist which original is different means. i have to say lisa will successful more becoz of dance and grow more talented in us label....rose with vocals in singing with yg...jennie with also her versatility and jisoo for acting. they 4 find their own ways. all becoz of yg ...the hype and marketing they do is most successful.
@@shantanugadakh1131Thank you for your reaction. I mean it the world of musicians (entertainment) is a difficult world. Everyone is having an opinion etc. Me included. I'm happy that everyone is different and also like different things for their own respected reason. To me it makes the world of music so diverse. Thank you again and take good care.
@@bhagwatigargThank you for your honest reaction. I respect it and I'm happy that you articulated it the reasons why you think this way. To me the music world is a very hard world as it is. The musicians all deserve respect for their hard work. Please keep on supporting BlackPink for the reasons that you have. Having different musicians and styles makes it possible that there is for everyone music etc that we personally like. Thank you again, take care and keep supporting BlackPink who you like.
I think YG as a whole and whoever wrote those lyrics knew exactly what they were saying and exactly the reaction it would get, because you hear it enough: the truth that BTS paved the way. BP hardly paved the way and I don't mind saying it. I don't see what the fuss is about when it comes to them. I don't think they're good. I don't think they perform, act or talk like they even give a shit. They most certainly didn't pave the way. As far as I'm concerned, they're still on a dirt road.
I’m sorry. BP paved the way? What social or special things did they do for their country or humanity? Nothing. Their performance in my opinion looks sleazy or a cheap club act. Twerking or wearing skimpy clothes doesn’t make an artist. There needs to be content in the lyrics.
They paved the way of showing how over marketing bare minimum subpar content and music to a new already trending market with no female competition is profitable
Like you, at first i didnt think much when i heard this because it didnt have any weight. But then i realized if new kpop fans hear this they would get the wrong information. So i am with the armys correting this wrong information. Thank you for this reaction. Would have loved it if you gave your reaction to bp concert as an army. ❤
I think you held back your true feelings about this. I understand you have to be objective in you comments. So I will say out loud that BP DID NOT pave the way and when they leave what is left is not worst. They don't write their own music or rap and no diversity in their music & genres does not give them the right to claim paving the way.
I agree completely, it’s just marketing, their lyrics are empty. There are so many artists out there, the four girls are more like products to me. But I guess it’s the case for many kpop idols and many other singers.
How can they compared themself with BTS while BTS in army, how dare BP, they can breath and claim success, because BTS is out of town for 2 years, while they have a complete full member, ask BP to join korean army, and we’ll see how they group survive, BTS thriving with solo, while the member join korean army one by one, the audacity of this girl to dish about pave the way, so ridiculous
it's just more of where this media driven world is going; words are losing their meanings. "if you know, you know." (and as you said, "pick your battle.")
Yes, BP are successful. It is primarily because YG is so good in media play but real numbers and skills prove they don't have as much commercial pull as they want people to believe.
One of my core values is TRUTH. No matter how inconvenient truth may be, that's why i borderline respect their drive to become successful but not their methods,they have no dignity as an artist but then again they aren't artist to begin with. I really dislike taking advantage on misleading people, that's absolutely one of the worst thing you could do. Especially the Law of Primacy, it's hard to unlearn first informations. That's why it's crucial for it to be fact.
No popular artist would have to do that to get bums on seats at their concerts so it goes to show how unsuccessful they really are at being Music artists. Only those starting out on their journey would give away free tickets not an musical act that's supposed to be really successful.
The only thing BlackPink is best for is MARKETING Fake it till you make it. It's amazing how I used to believe in their fake accomplishments. And how they are near to BTS, hahhahhahaa it's funny now thinking about it. In terms of Spotify streams you would need 3 blackpinks to compete with BTS streams
@@beraty.6899 yes that's also true, but let's be real, the only kpop act to have b-sides in the top 10 most streamed songs in Spotify in each year is BTS. Even if we'll remove BTS songs to match BP's songs, I'll still bet for BTS, because BP's greatest strength is their title tracks w/ videos. That's why their streams don't match their views. I've seen a lot of BP ads too. Which is very convenient for them because it only takes 3 seconds for blinks or muggles for it to be counted as view because their channel did not put it in MUSIC category but as VLOGS. Meanwhile it takes at least 30secs for BTS MV's for it to be counted as view. But that's beside my point, even if it's really just because BTS works hard and has a lot of music compared to BP, it still doesn't change the fact that BP is nowhere near them unlike what they portray them to be as equal to BTS but only girl version. Hahhahaha NO. BP is probably the biggest girl group internationally, I won't deny facts because I don't want to discredit how hard their company use mediaplay. But one thing's for sure, BP was carried by YG. While BTS carried Big Hit.
Yes they are the 'Fake it to make it' group but fake is still fake and will only get you so far before people see through the fakeness and are turned off. Their fakeness works on the uneducated and children.
@@beraty.6899but blinks have no problem flexing their views against nugus and smaller groups although they have less songs. With less songs you should have more streams as your fans only have a couple songs to pick from.
Oh come on do you really think YG will let Black explore for themselves and discover their own artists development? pigs will fly before that happens. Those girls should get out and find a company that will help to grow who will let them try things for themselves enhence what small skills they already have and discover,develop and build new skills.
The description I have of them is: a dancer, a person that is actually into creating music, an actress and an influencer - not sure how acurate that is - but it would explain some stuff I have seen. Nevermind that current rumor is that three of them will not resign with YG. Understandable when you notice how they treat their groups and now they are debuting a new girlgroup. He is also literl said that that BP are the same as 2NE1 just prettier - which is not nice.
I am a big Kpop lover for many many years now. For me, although I recognize their success, I do not like them. I think there is one dancer and one singer and two others who ride on their visuals. Perhaps I become a true fan from being able to like, respect and “idolize” the artist and I do not have enough to be a fan in that sense. After Jennie IG’d photos of herself wearing the exact outfit as she wore in photos of her and V on a date in France, I can see Jennie’s true face. She basically stated that it is true but without V’s acceptance to do the same. Hide it or come out to say they are dating, it is up to them as a couple to do but to come out by herself to do so is damaging to V. BP is now losing their lustre bcz there are new girl groups in the new generation of KPop that are shining and have early success that took BP much longer to reach their level of success. That HBO series Jennie did for her first acting job was a mess and the role she chose to do as her first acting debut again, tell me how Jennie is. Sorry but I am not a fan.
It turns out it was fake rumor but the way she's feeding the delulus and igniting the fire by what she did, makes me think it could be YG was behind it coz what was the odds that it blew up when Jennie was about to act on the Idol?
i used ti like blackPink. I noticed, it is just the same girl group just like everyone. NOTHING IS DIFFERENT, only different nationalities. Choreo, over exaggeration of how they are desired and all that.That is just how materialistic people are, specially women. I don't think anyone of them had written any songs, I saw an interview and you can tell how they are lying. I don't like that. It is never true, when you say fake it until you make. in this case it is lying. BTS' have the best, well-thought off lyrics and has a storyline. Every BTS' songs is just perfect for me. I jumped into the ARMY. Plus, the ARMYs are just incredible human beings. Lisa is a good dancer, well that is because she was initially a dancer and to be honest, sorry, same old choreography. The numbers never lie. BTS had always paved the way for everyone. Yes, the lyrics for 'girls' is a dissed track. just a ploy to create a stirs story.. thank you for being very logical. Your the best.
I guess they are confused what paving the way means. They didn't even pave the way for themselves especially coming from YG, one of the big 3. 2NE1 paved the way for BP to be popular as soon as they debuted. BP will never get the recognition if they are so concerned about who paved the way, and still attach to BTS. I tried to get into BTS and BP the same time. I fell into BTS's rabbit hole but not BP because their songs are too similar.
This song makes me feel like YG or BP wanted a song like Run BTS, since both songs (to put it very loosely) is about flexing their success. But run bts makes sense since it's a song that marks their decade long journey, talks about their immense hardwork and never stop attitude, flexes about their true success but still feels and sounds humble and most importantly it promotes the fact that hardwork will help everyone achieve their dreams because the song literally tells ARMY and others to Run towards their goals as well! Also it was written/produced by some members of BTS and in house producers. This song on the other hand doesn't make sense for a game? Like what do the lyrics have to do with the game? It's not even written by the girls, except Jennie I guess. It also flexes a lot but not about their hardwork, hardships and never give up attitude. It rather flexed about them paving the way (which makes no sense), them being topping the charts (what charts?), them destroying their rivals and if not for them there won't be anyone glorious enough left. All of the above has nothing to do with real success and real love from fans or even writing a song that will help fans in feeling motivated and good about themselves. For me BP is all about flexing about money, style, and a "I'm the greatest" personality and YG does have an uncanny obsession with BTS since they are trying to make the girls a female equivalent of BTS. All this song did for me was to make me miss Run BTS and go stream it😅
true musicianship is when a rapper actually writes their lyrics. rap is based on personal stories and thoughts. how can it be personal when you didn't write it. learning rap & hip hop is not the same as knowing and living hip hop music and its influence. for a song i can see some co-writing or someone writing your song. although i still have more respect for those that can do it all themselves or have part in the creative process. but that's neither here nor there. but a diss track you didn't write is moronic. and sincerely they have not paved the way for k pop, that road was already paved by a band of 7 brothers named BTS. now if you want to say you high up there compared to other female groups, maybe. are you much different, I don't think so. i only ever hear about 2 members, most of their songs and image sound like other songs I've heard by female k pop groups. are they pretty i guess so, to me they look like many other female idols (plastic surgery) works wonders. but i could care less for looks. the music is what should be important and its subpar to me. sorry for the rant. i love watching your videos.
I got into Kpop because of BTS. I found out about BP afterward and their music videos are really good with catchy tune. And then I saw them on a US TV show, I forgot which, maybe GMA? Anyway, I was so disappointed at their live performance. The singing was bad, lack of energy, not in sync while dancing. It was very crinchy to watch. I guess I was expecting BTS level of performance when BTS was on GMA and other US TV shows. I stop being a fan after seeing them performed on that show. I think BP are pretty, very fashionable, and their music videos are very good, but seriously, they are not BTS level and they did not pave the way. BTS paved the way. BP would not have gotten this far base on their artistry and talents if they weren't pretty with the great marketing from YG
When you are at the top, everyone else will try something to be related to you... some will copy, some will hit or scream, others will lie. We know who paved the way and we know they doesnt even care singing about it because they dont need it. I would really like seeing the BP girls developing their artistry and achieving their own goals, with all the economical support they have, they might be great artists. But I supose its not what they are chasing.
I kind of agree , if BP really paid attention to what is being said by just that one line statement, they would in the future going forward would be more careful of their lyrics. Or at this stage of their career I hope they will write there on songs right now they still on negotiating there contract . I hope the young ladies really pay attention to the small details on that contract . If it took them this long to resign I am pretty sure they had second thoughts , so hopefully something that they was not happy about changes .
Yeah. What were they smoking? BP did not pave the way . That would be BTS from many other KPop artists saying g BTS paved the way. Lol. They are delusional.
BTS is the only group that opened the door to K-pop in the world. What BTS did blackpink will never be able to do. They are popular sure but never better than BTS. I wonder what they did more than BTS. we will ever be able to compare Blackpink to BTS 💜 what has blackpink done more than BTS?
I’d trade ALL of BP catalogue for a Spring Day, UGH! or basically any song BTS has released. You spend enough money you can polish gravel to look good. If you don’t write it, it isn’t a diss track, it’s your management trying to impose their will and get a ROI. It’s not worth the effort to get upset about it. Good video! Thank you!
I don't care whether its lie , song or true. I am not blink but still there few of there songs i just listen and the girls were good too. As i am multi stan i didn't stan them but still listen few of there songs
BP definitely did their part for paving the way for new gen GGs. We all take it for granted about hardships for female idols in terms of opportunities and misogynistic system in SK. I don't think in recent times apart from BP there have been female idols who have achieved the status of global star (I'd count Tiffany, CL as 2nd gen) but lately you will see a lot of emerging names. Still a long way to go but the potential is definitely there. A lot of kpop acts before BTS and BP made short lived noise in the West so I'd say that's also paving the way. I also don't appreciate that we consider 'paving the way' defined by Western accolades. SNSD, 2NE1 , SJ, BB etc all have done a great job to stabilize and expand kpop in asian and European markets; despite not being in a stream-first era which is a lot easier now. Example: Cupid
Cupid owns that success to an English version and a buy into getting that version viral on Tiktok (paid for it). and "paved the way"? not really. Twice is at the moment more successfull in the US since at least last year. If you want to understand what really "paved the way" means - and people are not really seeing the difference between boy or girl groups in Idol music - it's all K-pop to them - I'd try vids like "how BTS paved the way" by bby gang mag (you will most likely like this one) "bts paved the way, why is it so hard to accept it?" boracity magazine and even this channel has a few vids on that theme: "Worst disrespects thrown at BTS and How they put people in their place: BTS paved the way Part 1" "How BTS paved the wax Part 2: BTS' impact on the US & Europe perception of Korean Artists" "Who will surpass BTS WHY BTS is the best pop group in the world BTS as artist #btspavedtheway" "How BTS chapter 2 affects Asians going after the US market How BTS paved the way for Asian artists" "BTS records that will never be broken The first act to archieve this #btspavedtheway" BoA and TVXQ concquered the Japanese market btw. There are girlgroups that found big success there after. DKDKTV "KPOP history in 20 miutes: from Seo Taiji to BTS" (a bit old but gets it mostly) Do you want to know why BP has so many views on their MVs (which does not fit their other numbers)? because they put their MVs in the commercials of youtube. Which btw counted till 2019 (?) also for charts - Taylor Swift also did that - it was once a legal practice to get high numbers. You can google articles for that.
Generally, I appreciate the opinions presented on this channel... but this time I'm disappointed. Nothing was said here openly and clearly, only according to the principle "the wolf is full and the sheep is whole" (this is a proverb used in my country when someone wants to please everyone)... Is today's comment an attempt to justify the actions of BLACK PINK ? I don't understand what can be justified here. Apparently, this time my English is too weak...
Oh they knew as they've said before that they are paving the way oh they knew whether they really agree with what they said or it's their company telling them what to say as it is with their company writing what they sing.
I just remembered that the Mona Lisa is da Vincis best or most famous piece of art bc he always said himself that it is. He always brought her with him and praised her. And that works as well nowadays 🙂
Once BP disbanded ,they bring nothing with them in terms of music as THEY don't hv personal attachment to each of it since they don't write their own songs. EVERYTHING belongs to YG. At least they can be influencers or brand ambassador.
I was NEVER impressed with GG -BP, i guess they were just lucky to be popular and successful . They can dance maybe but not credible performers or artists to claim it even in their song. Sad that there are more GG who are far more better than them…. Really just got lucky but too much to say that they paved the way… even in their song…really apologies for the fandom but this is my take 🙏 I would say the people behind their song/s or who ever does the beats in their music are good as they know what the public likes but not them, they are not consistent, stable and constant in their performances and so i think anyone with a pretty face who can sing and dance can be a BP singer/ artist-and hopefully their song writers would learn how to write sensible lyrics… 🙏🙏🙏 the only one and time I appreciated was Rose with Gone and On the Ground… but not as a group to be paving the way or opening doors for Asian girl group artists…. where exactly did they pave the way, anyway?😊
Can’t believe people are so mad over lyrics. Thank god my fav rappers dont get called out like that when they rap about being the best rapper. Its always those cringe kpop stans
But you can blame a company for marketing things with lies and exaggeration. Numbers not working out is a pretty good indicator of a company go further than what they should. Also, to say a group that debuted the year another from a small company surprisingly won their first deasang is rather silly.... I'm sure I'm not the first to say that ' It's just the first time I'm even paying attention...
They don't even have a daesang how could they surpass BTS with over 70 daesangs and many accolades under their belt? With the rumors of BP not resigning, I guess that will remain a wishful thinking.🤷
With all due respect, I personally totally disagree with you. 1st thing 1st, I didn't understand your point of Born Pink concert and it being "not sold out" but YG still showing it as a "sold out" thing, I'd be great if someone can explain me that Now, I know as usual people (including you) likes to come to the fact that "they don't write their music" but does that make "Paved the way" line a lie? I don't think so cos as much as people hate to admit this but BLACKPINK and BTS are the groups who paved the way for k-pop to be as popular as it is now in the world so them saying this line is not at all lie when it comes to K-POP girl groups. Now, "The Girls" being a "diss" track... Specially as you said 'now I'm waiting for TWICE to respond' so you believe it's a diss towards TWICE. Well, I must be tripping here cos I don't understand how and Why would Blackpink "diss" a group with whom they share a really lovely and close bond (to the point where both groups attend and enjoy each others concerts). Personally I don't think this song was targeted towards any group but instead it was for the people who are doing nothing but criticizing them (while attending their concerts and streaming their music lol). It's also for the people who are saying that boy band are better than GGs.. song's name is "The Girls" not "The Blackpink" right? They are talking on behalf of the "Girls" not dissing any group as you said. Now about your analogy (which is quite interesting to say the least) of taking eminem's words And performing it brilliantly with some changes but it won't be "original"or have ANY weight to it but that just BS to me.... I'm from INDIA and here in Bollywood music songs have always been written by the "lyricist" and sung by "singers" but people cry their heart out on emotional Bollywood songs and dance their @ss off on up-beat Bollywood songs, and that's just impossible if the songs or "lyrics" don't have the weight to them so it can be said to Blackpink too, right? I've seen many many reaction channels where they didn't even knew who blackpink is but still cried when they heard "happiest girl'' and it wasn't written by any of the blackpink member so does the song wich have lyrics of "no weight" can make basically stranger cry? I don't think so. I Totally Respect Your Opinions but I can't disagree more with anyone right now. You totally missed it by thinking this song was a 'diss' track towards any other groups.
I can confirm that their concerts were not sold out but advertised that they were. When they came to my city, they had 2 small arena shows and it was not sold out. Prior to the tickets going on sale, there was a lot of hype that the shows will sell out instantly, etc etc. so first I was surprised they were doing the shows at a small venue in our city versus larger venues (I’m from a large city). Then all my friends that wanted to see them, had absolutely no issues getting tickets. I also had soooo many friends try to resell their tickets with no bite at all even till the day of the concert. Then I keep seeing that their concerts were sold out so I did look on Ticketmaster for tickets in other cities and there were a lot of available tickets even a week before the concert, and they weren’t even resell tickets (resell tickets would say that they’re resell tickets). They were original tickets. This whole ordeal made me realize, a lot of their popularity might just be a marketing effort. Don’t get me wrong, they are super popular. But their popularity is somewhat inflated is all I’m saying
Rap is traditionally perform by the writers of the words because they are essentially poetry performed. Singing is traditional performed by singers. Not by lyricists who are more like poets. She was talking rap. Rhythm And Poetry.
YG media play. Even with BP's concert tour attendance data. YG claiming attendees of a festival in the data, just to make BP the biggest/most attended tour, when it was not, is just laughable. You can NOT claim festival numbers in the data, as festivals have multiple artists performing. YG, father of mediaplay.
When you said that there's lyricist behind the singer's songs in India, yet it's still able to move the audience. That actually just means the singer's are great "performers", they're not considered artist at all. Cause "art" is expressing one self. Same goes with Black Pink, they can rap that's for sure, but they're not real rappers or MC unless they actually write their own lyrics. Black Pink is basically a typical normal idol group that only has great marketing strategy. As a group they're not known for their rapping, dancing nor singing. I guess they're more known for their advertisement and controversy.
Also "Paved the way" doesn't apply to Black Pink. Cause if you say it's for "girl group", then that's not true at all cause they aren't helping, Twice, New Jeans, Red Velvet, Mamamo, and other Kpop girl groups get known in the US or globally. BTS paving the way however is fact, cause without BTS, Kpop wouldn't be as big or recognized globally as it now. Thanks to BTS, Black Pink can gets famous too, cause media just loves to say Black Pink is the Queen of Kpop and they are equivalent to BTS. Even though that's completely FALSE. BP is indeed the biggest Kpop girl group but if really compared to BTS, looking at the real stats like the streams, sales, sold out tickets and not just the RUclips views, and Instagram following cause that's the only thing Blinks care about, BTS is way bigger, at least 3x bigger than Black Pink
i thought of the 4, she would be the one that's most concerned about releasing more music, group or solo. and maybe she included it in her negotiations (if the rumors are true) but given YG's track record and the return of Yang Hyun Suk, there is more possibility that they would keep the same cadence in how they release music. But there's lots we don't know. It's her music I like the most so I hope she gets to release music as often as she wants. It's a real wasted opportunity if someone who has the skill isn't given an opportunity to cover as much ground as she can.
Ohhhhhh so what I'm getting from this is that madam Rose has potential to flourish but YG is holding her back, thus you thought she'd be the one to leave, right? But wouldn't you say Lisa too has potential as she is a very good performer? And them releasing & performing once in a blue moon, I could imagine, must be tiring for her.@@AsianEntertainmentandCulture
oh yeah. I think that Lisa is the one that can conquer the stage. I think she has the potential to be a young Madonna (transported and evolved with modern day trends and artistry of course). If it is true that she is being pursued by international labels, it makes the most sense. I think the Crazy Horse would serve as an "international showcase". But I also think that she is the most consistent with YG's branding. That's why I thought she would opt to stay. i also think YG failed to maximize her potential. She should have been pushed more and packaged better. I think... they didn't take her personality in consideration properly when she promoted her solo album. I think they pushed her to fit an image they wanted for her rather than starting with what she has and letting that grow and show. She has done great but she could have done greater. As for Rose, I definitely think she has potential artistically and yes, I think YG held her back. Had I been YG, I would have let Rose release her music regularly. Maybe not each release is supported as much as the others, but I would let her just release her music until she finds her identity.
I am not into BP so I have no reaction to their songs, but to claim that they paved the way for Kpop, huh? Girls, pls. wake up from your do do da da.
Let’s keep it 100% REAL . No shade to anyone at all . BTS did pave the way . I can explain this way …..ok let’s say there is vault with all k pop artists BTS had the combination to open the door , and instead of closing it …BTS did not shut that door they left it open so the other k pop artist can come out too . That’s just my way of describing how they pave the way .. FACT CHECK if you go on you tube and watch so many k pop artist literally saying BTS pave the way . PSY a great k pop artist he said BTS did what he wanted to do and that’s why he admire them so much . Let me say this for all the BLINKS I have nothing against black pink at all . I wish those lovely ladies nothing but continued success .i hope they get the contract they wanted 💜❤️🙂and always stay true to themselves
💜💜💜
Imagine paving the way for others and the beneficiaries are also part of the hate train. BTS & ARMYs endured so much hate/racism breaking in to the west. The unappreciative Labels and fandoms should be praising instead of trying to bring us down.
The thing that amuses me is that after all this, BTS never "claimed" they paved the way.. not even a single member.. even when Namjoon read the message, he just said "cool".. But others have to shout on top of their lungs that they paved the way😂😂 you can never ever imagine BTS doing such cheap tricks.. They're not only kings, but are Humble Kings!
given up on BP a long time ago..You hear 1 song, you've already heard them all 😂
True😅
This was brutal.💀
Honestly, i dont understand their hype. I've been in kpop since 2001 and have seen it become what it is, but every time someone tells me BP opened up doors and lead the way for many others, i just dont see it. First, i dont see them as singers or performers. They're not great at it. If im honest, they're more known outside of music, more in fashion, which is fine. However, to call yourself a singer or a music artist, you actually need to sing and perform, write music. Other than Rose, the other 3 are just there for the looks.
Let’s have a serious, logical, respectful discussion. If BP paved the way, what did they do to help other artists coming up after them? How did they make things easier for them? Because doing those things is what paving the way means right?
paving the way for me is literally that, making a road.. not taking someone’s hand after and leading them on that road. taking the paved way is entirely the “next one”s choice/job to do, instead of breaking their (next one) backs to pave a walkable new one. so I’m not sure what way you expect this discussion to go. cool to discuss things though.. sure.
just to clarify - from my limited knowledge of k-pop and its influence around the world (discovered it after the pandemic. yeah I lived under a huge rock apparently in this regard with overwhelming amount of people in my country), those who paved the way, internationally at least, were PSY for some and BTS for the majority that I see. I personally only discovered there is BP only after discovering BTS and thinking oh I’ll check what else is there. I will not say anything negative about them cause I don’t think they deserve negativity. don’t see where they supposedly paved the way though. oh well 😊
on second thought… maybe female aspect? a version of female empowerment in Korea? somewhere in those lines would make some sense maybe. donno
Fyi , now all the other kpop group getting awards or getting nomination in western award shows, is all because of BTS...
Coz of BTS , they created spreate kpop category....!!
Don't talk such senseless just watching some YT videos, where they just talkin rubbish, like BTS made it difficult bla bla 😅😂
Now change "BP" to "BTS".
@@MikolajNieswiety what will that do? Bts are the reason why today kpop is labeled as a music industry and a part if the music industries. Coz of bts American award shows have the categories kpop like bbms, ama, vma and even grammys.
The exact same discussion can be said for BTS they did make a name for themselves and also their success is a benchmark for k-pop dies that mean their global recognition automatically extended to other groups too. nope
You’re very diplomatic. BP’s “pave the way” lyrics, stating it boldly, targets them for disagreement and shows their ego-no need to be humble or appreciative of where you came from when you’re that famous.
I feel that BP has lost their creative drive. It seems they have become a money-making machine controlled by their marketing team. They appear insincere, soulless, losing their creative edge, who see themselves as “badass and beautiful” but it’s not them really talking.
I have another foul play suspicion and was wondering if anyone else has experienced this or is it just me. I’m not a blink and I don’t seek out BP content, but I keep getting their videos or videos about them suggested to me on RUclips. I’m Army and I proactively seek out BTS content to watch, but I only get a few recommended videos of BTS. Even channels that I subscribe to, sometimes I have to dig into their channel to find a video because it doesn’t even show up in the results if I search for it. I find this highly sus. Anyone else have the same experience?
me. to this day, I don't get any official BTS content recommendation. Even though I watch at least maybe 5 of their videos everyday.
@@AsianEntertainmentandCulture exactly! Hella sus!! How can videos from official accounts that I’m subscribed to not even get recommended to me? But I keep getting BP video suggestions 🤦🏻♀️
@@menohero_menovillianthat's the PR
If you're not interested in a channel, hit the three dots at the bottom right of the video and select 'Don't Recommend Channel' or 'Not Interested.' This is how I stopped receiving channels that kept popping up. I always select 'Don't Recommend Channel.'
@@menohero_menovillian The reason is that BTS is shadowbanned on yt 😕and bighit isn't doing anything
A Rapper writes their own lyrics their own story, it's part of being a Rapper along with word play, ryhming lyrics, candence and flow. To be a Rapper you need all these elements.
100% agree. "We paved the way"??? gimme a break....
@@davidbryant5840no haha
In conclusion. No they didn't . They just sing a diss song for attention
Their marketing tactics, lying about numbers, inflating their impact, etc, are common in the US. i was in their LA encore concert, not sold out.
Overly polite response.....BP is lucky they look good enough to have people apologise for them....
When I saw the lyrics of the song and who had credits I honestly just laughed. I couldn’t take the paved the way line seriously in the least because no one besides their fans has ever said that about Blackpink.
1) Clearly the lyrics were meant to poke the bear aka ARMY and in some ways it worked. Outrage marketing is still a thing. However, I won’t say that it poked the bear enough for anyone else to pick up on outside of twitter beef between the fandom because the streams were low and it didn’t move on any chart.
2) Melanie Fontana has a long-standing axe to grind with ARMYs. Don’t know if she wrote that particular lyric, but one can only wonder… 👀
3) YG is great at using the genuine things said about BTS by others and applying it to Blackpink. They’ve consistently attached themselves to BTS ever since BTS began gaining in the US, whether it be indirect or explicit comparisons. They have spent tons of money getting the public to perceive that Blackpink are the female equivalent of BTS, even if numbers and global impact say otherwise. Having the girls say they “paved the way” is just another way that YG is hitching Blackpink’s wagon to BTS’ star.
4) I’ve mostly had to move past rappers needing to write their raps because it’s an open secret that nowadays even the biggest names in hiphop have ghostwriters. *BUT* I at least have to BELIEVE that they wrote them. Believability is so important in this era of hiphop and I simply don’t believe Blackpink with this “paved the way” line. Even if Jennie wrote it… nah she doesn’t seem the type to lie to herself like that lol.
Fun Fact: do you know why BP has such high youtube numbers that don't quiet fit with the rest of their numbers?
Because they put their MVs in the commercials that play with you don't buy out of that. That was btw a very real tool for charting before it was axed in 2019 (?). Taylor Swift and Co. did do it, too. It became too much when an Indian (?) singer nearly broke a record, too and the practice was stopped. There are articles about it.
YG is very good at pretending to be bigger than their artists actually are and to a certain degree it also makes them actually that great (or it could if they filled it with substance).
I think they may be in trouble now because from what the rumors are saying only Rose is resigning - but maybe that is only a rumor. We will have to wait for the official announcement.
@@ruthfischer7615 You ain't wrong there about BP and the RUclips commercials which is extremely low brow scraping the bottom of the barrel tactics. But then YG are nothing but low brow tacty sleezy con artists disguised as a bonafida business.
@@ruthfischer7615oh, the thing you were saying with the adds makes a lot of sense. I was seeing a lot of BP adds for a while, even though I don’t watch their videos or listen to their music. I got annoyed with them and started blocking them (the ads), but it took me several months to block them all, there were so many🤦 and even now I still get the occasional add.
Personally their Music isn't to my taste I don't rate them as artists at all. I've no hate towards them and hope they finally find what they really want to do and with a company that will help them to develop. As for the lyric's of their song it's laughable.
It's a bit sad that BP's keeps getting into scandals in relation to BTS (YG's early comments about BTS's success, dating sandal, and now this) because they have the ability to shine on their own and uplift fellow artists instead of putting them down. Unfortunately I don't think that would ever happen. YG never gives BP their own voice, they just like to cosplay feminism and girl power for profit, which is so sad to see. I don't think that the girls can look back on their career and be proud of their legacy, but hey I guess as long as they're making money they're okay with being complicit with morally dubious actions.
I have heard this reading recently - no idea how accurate it is:
In BP you have a dancer, someone that actually likes making music, an actress and an influencer.
Rumor says most of them are not resigning but I may have missed the newest intel.
For me, BP are more like an influencer or those tiktokers. Pretty and good at dance. (Only Rose are good singing live) They focus more on their visual than their singing. Their song are catchy and addictive. But thats all. There is nothing special about BP.
Don't forget that BTS paved the way, so the others could enter easily. BP got more popular after BTS enter the global market.
Love how PROOF is sitting right behind you as you speak
🤣 yes the clock is from from a BTS merch box.💜 💜 💜
You were very diplomatic in your analysis…but the bottom line is …. they didn’t pave the way!
Let them embarass themselves we know they paved nothing but stood on the shoulders of giants
What “way” did they pave?
No way
5:55 this I don't agree with, I'm pretty sure they knew cause armys trend this all the time. It's pretty closely connected to bts
In my own opinion, I feel like BP and their fans do things to engage BTS ARMY. All the views, comments, all of that still count as views, streams, so they're not losing anything, they're actually gaining. Their fan/fandom often attach themselves to BTS, videos, fake pictures, anything and everything with BTS, yet on the other hand, BTS does not do that to them or anybody else. BP, I think is not that big of a deal, look at Twice, New Jeans, their accomplishments. BP, advantage because they have a U.S. platform and U.S. people to help them in the western industry. Bora City, provided proof that BP is forcing views and streamers to view and stream because of their advertisement before viewing and streaming. The other female groups, are achieving just as much as BP, but they don't have the fandom or western industry help like BP does. It's disheartening to see the attachment to BTS all the time with BP and their fan/fandoms. I would have to disagree, I do believe 100% that they do know the meaning of that, "We Paved The Way", that's why they have that. Free publicity comes with controversy and that's what they're counting on and getting. They are really adapting to western tactics. It's hard for me to understand why they are considered the girl group, when their concerts are a hit or a miss, never consistent in all aspects, vocally, choreography, energy, why? In a video that Bora City put out, BP is in that video, stating they want to be the ones to open the door, this is after BTS had already knocked the door down. I think they're mastering the controversy tactics very well and keeping attention on themselves through this more so than by their art. I don't mind them, listen to them once in a while, but they are not the best girl group, performance wise, vocal, which is part of their art, so creating controversy is a great tactic to get people engaged. BTS is pure art, don't have to attach to anybody, don't have to use cheap tactics.
❣️BOOYAH! Well stated. 🙌 💜
i also got free tickets. a tiktok "influencer" approached me and said if i play a game and win, I'd win two tickets. I refused and later on, when i passed her again, she gave me 5 tickets no question asked. LOL
I initially liked BP when they first started but the more I know how they use media play to create a certain narrative I just lost interest and their message in their songs are exactly the same as the very first song they had. 2NE1 really set the bar high as girl group stands
Thank you for your take on this.
I personally don't like BlackPinks music.
That's just me.
I do respect them for their hard work.
Just like I respect everyone who's in this line of business.
It isn't easy.
I know for a fact that the concerts weren't sold out.
I've been to a concert of them with a friend because, she likes them.
She likes them because, BlackPink are girls related to her personally as you have to like them because, of woman/girls empowerment.
I have to admit the concert was kind a disappointing.
My friend as a diehard BlackPink fan was disappointed as well.
If I'm honest I don't think YG did wrong towards the members of BlackPink.
Look at what they've done for them.
They bought radioplay etc for them.
They gave them their training.
Made deals with Disney etc.
They had their solo albums and promoted them.
They did some acting etc.
They contacted famous singers to collaborate with them.
Gave them happy go lucky songs where you don't really have to think about a deeper meaning of the lyrics/messages.
That you can easily sing and dance to even when you are drunk.
It is understandable to me that they actually believe that they paved the way.
The whole K-Pop award genre in the states isn't their due to BlackPink.
It is their due to the fact that in the states you also have Latino's awards etc because, they don't want cerain musicians to over shadow the english native American musicians.
YG isn't that bad because, how they put BlackPink together was/is very smart by taking girls from different countries and form a group. You know every country supports the musician from their native country.
So BlackPink profited from it.
Plus at the moment the Hype about woman empowerment.
To me there are better Korean musicians but, not all of those musicians have a powerful company like YG behind them.
I truly believe that BlackPink wouldn't be so big if they started out from a smaller and less connected and pour company.
In Europe there were boybands like Take That etc so as a countermeasure there was a girlband like Spice Girls.
This happened with BlackPink too.
Also some of the things BlackPink is doing have been done before by others.
So they are not original and are not paving the way.
They are only using what is already there.
YG is doing a good job for them.
YG deserves a compliment because, BlackPink what they are now would never have been this big as they are now.
Each member of BlackPink is doing a lot of things due to YG on the side.
It doesn't matter that the members don't write their own lyrics.
Not everyone is capable of writing.
They can sing and dance.
So that's good.
Sorry, I respect every member of BlackPink but, I've seen better live concerts with female musicians far better then them.
Of course to my personal taste of music and depth of lyrics etc.
Sorry, for the long comment.
Warm greetings from The Netherlands
That's the MOST respected criticism I've seen here today... And I Absolutely LOVE that. Much respect to you for that, although I don't agree with some of your comments but it's just me and nothing against you for saying what you've said. World would've been wonderful place if all people were like you but sadly we got mejority of opposite people 😂
what u said i respect it...but we love blackpink songs boombayah is really very bop then others too...my fav song is definitely The happiest girl...becoz that time i feel this song is really meant for their voices...its just perfect when all 4 sing it .
but agree yg is great at marketing and hype...ofcourse talent too..their artists stage presence is amazing...and BP success is all becoz of yg songs ...teddy is really make hit songs....and their last seoul concert is lit...no doubt yg is great and all 4 girls was great in coachell and last seoul and los angels concert..and all 4 will definitely successful in future too...all becoz of yg ..but still the artist which original is different means.
i have to say lisa will successful more becoz of dance and grow more talented in us label....rose with vocals in singing with yg...jennie with also her versatility and jisoo for acting. they 4 find their own ways.
all becoz of yg ...the hype and marketing they do is most successful.
@@shantanugadakh1131Thank you for your reaction.
I mean it the world of musicians (entertainment) is a difficult world.
Everyone is having an opinion etc.
Me included.
I'm happy that everyone is different and also like different things for their own respected reason.
To me it makes the world of music so diverse.
Thank you again and take good care.
@@bhagwatigargThank you for your honest reaction.
I respect it and I'm happy that you articulated it the reasons why you think this way.
To me the music world is a very hard world as it is.
The musicians all deserve respect for their hard work.
Please keep on supporting BlackPink for the reasons that you have.
Having different musicians and styles makes it possible that there is for everyone music etc that we personally like.
Thank you again, take care and keep supporting BlackPink who you like.
They are huge and successful.
Paved the way? No!
I think YG as a whole and whoever wrote those lyrics knew exactly what they were saying and exactly the reaction it would get, because you hear it enough: the truth that BTS paved the way. BP hardly paved the way and I don't mind saying it. I don't see what the fuss is about when it comes to them. I don't think they're good. I don't think they perform, act or talk like they even give a shit. They most certainly didn't pave the way. As far as I'm concerned, they're still on a dirt road.
I’m sorry. BP paved the way? What social or special things did they do for their country or humanity? Nothing. Their performance in my opinion looks sleazy or a cheap club act. Twerking or wearing skimpy clothes doesn’t make an artist. There needs to be content in the lyrics.
They paved the way of showing how over marketing bare minimum subpar content and music to a new already trending market with no female competition is profitable
Like you, at first i didnt think much when i heard this because it didnt have any weight. But then i realized if new kpop fans hear this they would get the wrong information. So i am with the armys correting this wrong information. Thank you for this reaction. Would have loved it if you gave your reaction to bp concert as an army. ❤
I think you held back your true feelings about this. I understand you have to be objective in you comments. So I will say out loud that BP DID NOT pave the way and when they leave what is left is not worst. They don't write their own music or rap and no diversity in their music & genres does not give them the right to claim paving the way.
I agree completely, it’s just marketing, their lyrics are empty. There are so many artists out there, the four girls are more like products to me. But I guess it’s the case for many kpop idols and many other singers.
How can they compared themself with BTS while BTS in army, how dare BP, they can breath and claim success, because BTS is out of town for 2 years, while they have a complete full member, ask BP to join korean army, and we’ll see how they group survive, BTS thriving with solo, while the member join korean army one by one, the audacity of this girl to dish about pave the way, so ridiculous
They were only known in US after their collab with Selena Gomez, until then, none of their songs were charting in the US.
it's just more of where this media driven world is going; words are losing their meanings. "if you know, you know." (and as you said, "pick your battle.")
I agree with you YG uses clouds so well. But sometimes, we would like to see hard work and true humanity prevail. Thxs for your contents.😊
Yes, BP are successful. It is primarily because YG is so good in media play but real numbers and skills prove they don't have as much commercial pull as they want people to believe.
If they left,they won't be missed! Could never understand what all the fuss about them was 🤔. Paved the way? nah🤣
I didn't know they were in delulu as well like their fans😂lol how can you even say that line😆
Having someone else write your diss track is like having your mom go Karen at people for you.
This, like at least BTS wrote their Cyphers
One of my core values is TRUTH.
No matter how inconvenient truth may be, that's why i borderline respect their drive to become successful but not their methods,they have no dignity as an artist but then again they aren't artist to begin with.
I really dislike taking advantage on misleading people, that's absolutely one of the worst thing you could do.
Especially the Law of Primacy, it's hard to unlearn first informations. That's why it's crucial for it to be fact.
No popular artist would have to do that to get bums on seats at their concerts so it goes to show how unsuccessful they really are at being Music artists. Only those starting out on their journey would give away free tickets not an musical act that's supposed to be really successful.
The only thing BlackPink is best for is MARKETING
Fake it till you make it.
It's amazing how I used to believe in their fake accomplishments.
And how they are near to BTS, hahhahhahaa it's funny now thinking about it.
In terms of Spotify streams you would need 3 blackpinks to compete with BTS streams
maybe cuz bts have 7x times more songs than blackpink? 😭😭
@@beraty.6899 because BTS has more substance and actually writes their stuff.
@@beraty.6899 yes that's also true, but let's be real, the only kpop act to have b-sides in the top 10 most streamed songs in Spotify in each year is BTS.
Even if we'll remove BTS songs to match BP's songs, I'll still bet for BTS, because BP's greatest strength is their title tracks w/ videos. That's why their streams don't match their views.
I've seen a lot of BP ads too. Which is very convenient for them because it only takes 3 seconds for blinks or muggles for it to be counted as view because their channel did not put it in MUSIC category but as VLOGS. Meanwhile it takes at least 30secs for BTS MV's for it to be counted as view.
But that's beside my point, even if it's really just because BTS works hard and has a lot of music compared to BP, it still doesn't change the fact that BP is nowhere near them unlike what they portray them to be as equal to BTS but only girl version. Hahhahaha NO.
BP is probably the biggest girl group internationally, I won't deny facts because I don't want to discredit how hard their company use mediaplay.
But one thing's for sure, BP was carried by YG.
While BTS carried Big Hit.
Yes they are the 'Fake it to make it' group but fake is still fake and will only get you so far before people see through the fakeness and are turned off. Their fakeness works on the uneducated and children.
@@beraty.6899but blinks have no problem flexing their views against nugus and smaller groups although they have less songs. With less songs you should have more streams as your fans only have a couple songs to pick from.
What kind of lyrics is that 😂 who's the writer of that song 😮
Bp themselves…
Clearly someone who can't write lyric's
@eileencritchley4630 you made me laugh 🤣🤣🤣
@@eileencritchley4630burra
@@DilucImpact23from what i knew, bp members only wrote the singing part, it was other producer who wrote the rap part
Oh come on do you really think YG will let Black explore for themselves and discover their own artists development? pigs will fly before that happens. Those girls should get out and find a company that will help to grow who will let them try things for themselves enhence what small skills they already have and discover,develop and build new skills.
The description I have of them is:
a dancer, a person that is actually into creating music, an actress and an influencer - not sure how acurate that is - but it would explain some stuff I have seen.
Nevermind that current rumor is that three of them will not resign with YG.
Understandable when you notice how they treat their groups and now they are debuting a new girlgroup.
He is also literl said that that BP are the same as 2NE1 just prettier - which is not nice.
I am a big Kpop lover for many many years now. For me, although I recognize their success, I do not like them. I think there is one dancer and one singer and two others who ride on their visuals. Perhaps I become a true fan from being able to like, respect and “idolize” the artist and I do not have enough to be a fan in that sense. After Jennie IG’d photos of herself wearing the exact outfit as she wore in photos of her and V on a date in France, I can see Jennie’s true face. She basically stated that it is true but without V’s acceptance to do the same. Hide it or come out to say they are dating, it is up to them as a couple to do but to come out by herself to do so is damaging to V.
BP is now losing their lustre bcz there are new girl groups in the new generation of KPop that are shining and have early success that took BP much longer to reach their level of success. That HBO series Jennie did for her first acting job was a mess and the role she chose to do as her first acting debut again, tell me how Jennie is. Sorry but I am not a fan.
It turns out it was fake rumor but the way she's feeding the delulus and igniting the fire by what she did, makes me think it could be YG was behind it coz what was the odds that it blew up when Jennie was about to act on the Idol?
That's why they're always in 2nd position 😂
BTS PAVED THE WAY, YOU HAVE TO ADMIT - Bangchen (SKZ)
i used ti like blackPink. I noticed, it is just the same girl group just like everyone. NOTHING IS DIFFERENT, only different nationalities. Choreo, over exaggeration of how they are desired and all that.That is just how materialistic people are, specially women. I don't think anyone of them had written any songs, I saw an interview and you can tell how they are lying. I don't like that. It is never true, when you say fake it until you make. in this case it is lying. BTS' have the best, well-thought off lyrics and has a storyline. Every BTS' songs is just perfect for me. I jumped into the ARMY. Plus, the ARMYs are just incredible human beings. Lisa is a good dancer, well that is because she was initially a dancer and to be honest, sorry, same old choreography. The numbers never lie. BTS had always paved the way for everyone. Yes, the lyrics for 'girls' is a dissed track. just a ploy to create a stirs story.. thank you for being very logical. Your the best.
I guess they are confused what paving the way means. They didn't even pave the way for themselves especially coming from YG, one of the big 3. 2NE1 paved the way for BP to be popular as soon as they debuted. BP will never get the recognition if they are so concerned about who paved the way, and still attach to BTS. I tried to get into BTS and BP the same time. I fell into BTS's rabbit hole but not BP because their songs are too similar.
Their writers and producers wrote their lyrics so I don’t take those seriously.
Lisa is an amazing performer.
I love your analysis and commentaries. Great job! Please continue on what you are great doing. I love you!❤️
This song makes me feel like YG or BP wanted a song like Run BTS, since both songs (to put it very loosely) is about flexing their success.
But run bts makes sense since it's a song that marks their decade long journey, talks about their immense hardwork and never stop attitude, flexes about their true success but still feels and sounds humble and most importantly it promotes the fact that hardwork will help everyone achieve their dreams because the song literally tells ARMY and others to Run towards their goals as well! Also it was written/produced by some members of BTS and in house producers.
This song on the other hand doesn't make sense for a game? Like what do the lyrics have to do with the game? It's not even written by the girls, except Jennie I guess. It also flexes a lot but not about their hardwork, hardships and never give up attitude. It rather flexed about them paving the way (which makes no sense), them being topping the charts (what charts?), them destroying their rivals and if not for them there won't be anyone glorious enough left. All of the above has nothing to do with real success and real love from fans or even writing a song that will help fans in feeling motivated and good about themselves.
For me BP is all about flexing about money, style, and a "I'm the greatest" personality and YG does have an uncanny obsession with BTS since they are trying to make the girls a female equivalent of BTS.
All this song did for me was to make me miss Run BTS and go stream it😅
No BLACKPINK but BTS PAVED THE WAY OF KPOP!
true musicianship is when a rapper actually writes their lyrics. rap is based on personal stories and thoughts. how can it be personal when you didn't write it. learning rap & hip hop is not the same as knowing and living hip hop music and its influence. for a song i can see some co-writing or someone writing your song. although i still have more respect for those that can do it all themselves or have part in the creative process. but that's neither here nor there. but a diss track you didn't write is moronic. and sincerely they have not paved the way for k pop, that road was already paved by a band of 7 brothers named BTS. now if you want to say you high up there compared to other female groups, maybe. are you much different, I don't think so. i only ever hear about 2 members, most of their songs and image sound like other songs I've heard by female k pop groups. are they pretty i guess so, to me they look like many other female idols (plastic surgery) works wonders. but i could care less for looks. the music is what should be important and its subpar to me. sorry for the rant. i love watching your videos.
Either way I like the song❤️
Its so shame , they cant write their raps being rappers, n they given fake credit to Jennie written n gave it to lisa.....😅😂😂
I dont for a single second believe that any of these girls write any of their lyrics lol.
Jennie and rosé are credited for it...
I can't get into girl groups. I have tried. So I hope all girl groups much success. 💜💜💜🤟🇺🇸💜💜💜💜
I got into Kpop because of BTS. I found out about BP afterward and their music videos are really good with catchy tune. And then I saw them on a US TV show, I forgot which, maybe GMA? Anyway, I was so disappointed at their live performance. The singing was bad, lack of energy, not in sync while dancing. It was very crinchy to watch. I guess I was expecting BTS level of performance when BTS was on GMA and other US TV shows. I stop being a fan after seeing them performed on that show. I think BP are pretty, very fashionable, and their music videos are very good, but seriously, they are not BTS level and they did not pave the way. BTS paved the way. BP would not have gotten this far base on their artistry and talents if they weren't pretty with the great marketing from YG
BTS paved the way 🛐👑🗣️
BP would be more significant if their product was music instead of brand.
When you are at the top, everyone else will try something to be related to you... some will copy, some will hit or scream, others will lie. We know who paved the way and we know they doesnt even care singing about it because they dont need it. I would really like seeing the BP girls developing their artistry and achieving their own goals, with all the economical support they have, they might be great artists. But I supose its not what they are chasing.
I kind of agree , if BP really paid attention to what is being said by just that one line statement, they would in the future going forward would be more careful of their lyrics. Or at this stage of their career I hope they will write there on songs right now they still on negotiating there contract . I hope the young ladies really pay attention to the small details on that contract . If it took them this long to resign I am pretty sure they had second thoughts , so hopefully something that they was not happy about changes .
Yeah. What were they smoking? BP did not pave the way . That would be BTS from many other KPop artists saying g BTS paved the way. Lol. They are delusional.
BTS is the only group that opened the door to K-pop in the world. What BTS did blackpink will never be able to do. They are popular sure but never better than BTS. I wonder what they did more than BTS. we will ever be able to compare Blackpink to BTS 💜 what has blackpink done more than BTS?
Well I'm an ARMYBLINK but thats so true
I've never heard the track.
Based on the lyrics that you explained, it has no weight on them.
I’d trade ALL of BP catalogue for a Spring Day, UGH! or basically any song BTS has released. You spend enough money you can polish gravel to look good. If you don’t write it, it isn’t a diss track, it’s your management trying to impose their will and get a ROI. It’s not worth the effort to get upset about it. Good video! Thank you!
And for free ticket, thats is why YG doesn’t get much money than the other agency
I don't care whether its lie , song or true. I am not blink but still there few of there songs i just listen and the girls were good too. As i am multi stan i didn't stan them but still listen few of there songs
3:01 that's actually so smart i never thought of it like that
BP definitely did their part for paving the way for new gen GGs. We all take it for granted about hardships for female idols in terms of opportunities and misogynistic system in SK. I don't think in recent times apart from BP there have been female idols who have achieved the status of global star (I'd count Tiffany, CL as 2nd gen) but lately you will see a lot of emerging names. Still a long way to go but the potential is definitely there. A lot of kpop acts before BTS and BP made short lived noise in the West so I'd say that's also paving the way. I also don't appreciate that we consider 'paving the way' defined by Western accolades. SNSD, 2NE1 , SJ, BB etc all have done a great job to stabilize and expand kpop in asian and European markets; despite not being in a stream-first era which is a lot easier now. Example: Cupid
Cupid owns that success to an English version and a buy into getting that version viral on Tiktok (paid for it).
and "paved the way"?
not really. Twice is at the moment more successfull in the US since at least last year.
If you want to understand what really "paved the way" means - and people are not really seeing the difference between boy or girl groups in Idol music - it's all K-pop to them - I'd try vids like
"how BTS paved the way" by bby gang mag (you will most likely like this one)
"bts paved the way, why is it so hard to accept it?" boracity magazine
and even this channel has a few vids on that theme:
"Worst disrespects thrown at BTS and How they put people in their place: BTS paved the way Part 1"
"How BTS paved the wax Part 2: BTS' impact on the US & Europe perception of Korean Artists"
"Who will surpass BTS WHY BTS is the best pop group in the world BTS as artist #btspavedtheway"
"How BTS chapter 2 affects Asians going after the US market How BTS paved the way for Asian artists"
"BTS records that will never be broken The first act to archieve this #btspavedtheway"
BoA and TVXQ concquered the Japanese market btw. There are girlgroups that found big success there after.
DKDKTV "KPOP history in 20 miutes: from Seo Taiji to BTS" (a bit old but gets it mostly)
Do you want to know why BP has so many views on their MVs (which does not fit their other numbers)?
because they put their MVs in the commercials of youtube. Which btw counted till 2019 (?) also for charts - Taylor Swift also did that - it was once a legal practice to get high numbers. You can google articles for that.
Bp ARE misogynist
Generally, I appreciate the opinions presented on this channel... but this time I'm disappointed. Nothing was said here openly and clearly, only according to the principle "the wolf is full and the sheep is whole" (this is a proverb used in my country when someone wants to please everyone)... Is today's comment an attempt to justify the actions of BLACK PINK ? I don't understand what can be justified here. Apparently, this time my English is too weak...
It is called being subtle. This lady is an adult. Most grown up understand exactly what she is saying and let me tell you the sheep is NOT whole.
I think you didn’t understand what she is saying. She was calm and well spoken but definitely not “pleasing everyone” 😂
Because their "Actions" are just words and if you do not believe it to be true to some it shouldn't bother you and retaliate.
Oh they knew as they've said before that they are paving the way oh they knew whether they really agree with what they said or it's their company telling them what to say as it is with their company writing what they sing.
I just remembered that the Mona Lisa is da Vincis best or most famous piece of art bc he always said himself that it is. He always brought her with him and praised her. And that works as well nowadays 🙂
Not a fan and time will show that they can not rewrite history to make them look better than they are
help what is this ? 😭
Dont like BP at all
Once BP disbanded ,they bring nothing with them in terms of music as THEY don't hv personal attachment to each of it since they don't write their own songs. EVERYTHING belongs to YG. At least they can be influencers or brand ambassador.
Goodness! Aren't Blackpink a joke?
TVXQ
Delusions of grandeur
I was NEVER impressed with GG -BP, i guess they were just lucky to be popular and successful . They can dance maybe but not credible performers or artists to claim it even in their song. Sad that there are more GG who are far more better than them…. Really just got lucky but too much to say that they paved the way… even in their song…really apologies for the fandom but this is my take 🙏 I would say the people behind their song/s or who ever does the beats in their music are good as they know what the public likes but not them, they are not consistent, stable and constant in their performances and so i think anyone with a pretty face who can sing and dance can be a BP singer/ artist-and hopefully their song writers would learn how to write sensible lyrics… 🙏🙏🙏 the only one and time I appreciated was Rose with Gone and On the Ground… but not as a group to be paving the way or opening doors for Asian girl group artists…. where exactly did they pave the way, anyway?😊
BTS paved the way 🛐👑🗣️🗣️
3:26 4:28 7:35. 9:27 shde
Can’t believe people are so mad over lyrics. Thank god my fav rappers dont get called out like that when they rap about being the best rapper. Its always those cringe kpop stans
That's because they are REAL Rappers and have something Real To Say.
@@eileencritchley4630wdym Real rapper?
@@butnobodycame2242the one's who can hold a pen for once and don't always copy other's flow and cadence.
But you can blame a company for marketing things with lies and exaggeration. Numbers not working out is a pretty good indicator of a company go further than what they should.
Also, to say a group that debuted the year another from a small company surprisingly won their first deasang is rather silly.... I'm sure I'm not the first to say that ' It's just the first time I'm even paying attention...
YG wants BP to surpass BTS
They'll can keep trying as much as they want but they'll never manage that feat.
They don't even have a daesang how could they surpass BTS with over 70 daesangs and many accolades under their belt? With the rumors of BP not resigning, I guess that will remain a wishful thinking.🤷
Lol💀💀😭
With all due respect, I personally totally disagree with you.
1st thing 1st, I didn't understand your point of Born Pink concert and it being "not sold out" but YG still showing it as a "sold out" thing, I'd be great if someone can explain me that
Now, I know as usual people (including you) likes to come to the fact that "they don't write their music" but does that make "Paved the way" line a lie? I don't think so cos as much as people hate to admit this but BLACKPINK and BTS are the groups who paved the way for k-pop to be as popular as it is now in the world so them saying this line is not at all lie when it comes to K-POP girl groups.
Now, "The Girls" being a "diss" track... Specially as you said 'now I'm waiting for TWICE to respond' so you believe it's a diss towards TWICE. Well, I must be tripping here cos I don't understand how and Why would Blackpink "diss" a group with whom they share a really lovely and close bond (to the point where both groups attend and enjoy each others concerts). Personally I don't think this song was targeted towards any group but instead it was for the people who are doing nothing but criticizing them (while attending their concerts and streaming their music lol). It's also for the people who are saying that boy band are better than GGs.. song's name is "The Girls" not "The Blackpink" right? They are talking on behalf of the "Girls" not dissing any group as you said.
Now about your analogy (which is quite interesting to say the least) of taking eminem's words And performing it brilliantly with some changes but it won't be "original"or have ANY weight to it but that just BS to me.... I'm from INDIA and here in Bollywood music songs have always been written by the "lyricist" and sung by "singers" but people cry their heart out on emotional Bollywood songs and dance their @ss off on up-beat Bollywood songs, and that's just impossible if the songs or "lyrics" don't have the weight to them so it can be said to Blackpink too, right? I've seen many many reaction channels where they didn't even knew who blackpink is but still cried when they heard "happiest girl'' and it wasn't written by any of the blackpink member so does the song wich have lyrics of "no weight" can make basically stranger cry? I don't think so.
I Totally Respect Your Opinions but I can't disagree more with anyone right now. You totally missed it by thinking this song was a 'diss' track towards any other groups.
I can confirm that their concerts were not sold out but advertised that they were. When they came to my city, they had 2 small arena shows and it was not sold out. Prior to the tickets going on sale, there was a lot of hype that the shows will sell out instantly, etc etc. so first I was surprised they were doing the shows at a small venue in our city versus larger venues (I’m from a large city). Then all my friends that wanted to see them, had absolutely no issues getting tickets. I also had soooo many friends try to resell their tickets with no bite at all even till the day of the concert. Then I keep seeing that their concerts were sold out so I did look on Ticketmaster for tickets in other cities and there were a lot of available tickets even a week before the concert, and they weren’t even resell tickets (resell tickets would say that they’re resell tickets). They were original tickets. This whole ordeal made me realize, a lot of their popularity might just be a marketing effort. Don’t get me wrong, they are super popular. But their popularity is somewhat inflated is all I’m saying
Rap is traditionally perform by the writers of the words because they are essentially poetry performed. Singing is traditional performed by singers. Not by lyricists who are more like poets. She was talking rap. Rhythm And Poetry.
YG media play. Even with BP's concert tour attendance data. YG claiming attendees of a festival in the data, just to make BP the biggest/most attended tour, when it was not, is just laughable. You can NOT claim festival numbers in the data, as festivals have multiple artists performing. YG, father of mediaplay.
When you said that there's lyricist behind the singer's songs in India, yet it's still able to move the audience.
That actually just means the singer's are great "performers", they're not considered artist at all. Cause "art" is expressing one self.
Same goes with Black Pink, they can rap that's for sure, but they're not real rappers or MC unless they actually write their own lyrics.
Black Pink is basically a typical normal idol group that only has great marketing strategy.
As a group they're not known for their rapping, dancing nor singing. I guess they're more known for their advertisement and controversy.
Also "Paved the way" doesn't apply to Black Pink. Cause if you say it's for "girl group", then that's not true at all cause they aren't helping, Twice, New Jeans, Red Velvet, Mamamo, and other Kpop girl groups get known in the US or globally.
BTS paving the way however is fact, cause without BTS, Kpop wouldn't be as big or recognized globally as it now. Thanks to BTS, Black Pink can gets famous too, cause media just loves to say Black Pink is the Queen of Kpop and they are equivalent to BTS.
Even though that's completely FALSE.
BP is indeed the biggest Kpop girl group but if really compared to BTS, looking at the real stats like the streams, sales, sold out tickets and not just the RUclips views, and Instagram following cause that's the only thing Blinks care about, BTS is way bigger, at least 3x bigger than Black Pink
See, this is why Lisa is leaving.
i have to say that surprised me. i thought if there was anyone who was going to pack first, it would be Rose. But then, i dunno, maybe it's PR.
may i ask why you suspected that Rose would be the one leaving?@@AsianEntertainmentandCulture
i thought of the 4, she would be the one that's most concerned about releasing more music, group or solo. and maybe she included it in her negotiations (if the rumors are true) but given YG's track record and the return of Yang Hyun Suk, there is more possibility that they would keep the same cadence in how they release music.
But there's lots we don't know. It's her music I like the most so I hope she gets to release music as often as she wants. It's a real wasted opportunity if someone who has the skill isn't given an opportunity to cover as much ground as she can.
Ohhhhhh so what I'm getting from this is that madam Rose has potential to flourish but YG is holding her back, thus you thought she'd be the one to leave, right?
But wouldn't you say Lisa too has potential as she is a very good performer? And them releasing & performing once in a blue moon, I could imagine, must be tiring for her.@@AsianEntertainmentandCulture
oh yeah. I think that Lisa is the one that can conquer the stage. I think she has the potential to be a young Madonna (transported and evolved with modern day trends and artistry of course). If it is true that she is being pursued by international labels, it makes the most sense. I think the Crazy Horse would serve as an "international showcase".
But I also think that she is the most consistent with YG's branding. That's why I thought she would opt to stay. i also think YG failed to maximize her potential. She should have been pushed more and packaged better. I think... they didn't take her personality in consideration properly when she promoted her solo album. I think they pushed her to fit an image they wanted for her rather than starting with what she has and letting that grow and show. She has done great but she could have done greater.
As for Rose, I definitely think she has potential artistically and yes, I think YG held her back. Had I been YG, I would have let Rose release her music regularly. Maybe not each release is supported as much as the others, but I would let her just release her music until she finds her identity.
🤢🤮🤮🤮🤮
Yes bp is 🤢🤢